math.NT — Number Theory
Contributed by Zeng Chunping
Let a,b,c be coprime positive integers with a+b=c, and let E:y2=x(x−a)(x+b) be the associated Frey curve. We determine the structure of minimal discriminants across the Q-isogeny class C(E) by closed formulas in (a,b,c). The three 2-torsion points of E are rational, so E is always the centre of its class; the first-level quotients via Velu's formula have monomial model discriminants {16(abc)2, 256a4bc, 256ab4c, 256abc4}, an exact collapse forced by the identity u=4f(r) in Velu's algorithm. We prove the Crater--Peak Law: among the first-level vertices the minimal and maximal discriminants are min{16(abc)2,256min(a,b)4max(a,b)c} and 256abc4, the exponent 4 landing on the smallest entry (crater) and the largest (peak); for star classes these are the class extrema, while on square or quartic triggers the extrema are the minimum and maximum over ten explicit candidates. The class size ∣V∣∈{4,6,8} is decided by the square and quartic character of ac and bc (107 samples, zero failures), matching the isogeny-torsion graph classification via the lcm of the isogeny matrix. When ac or bc is a square the class extends to depth 2 with model discriminants 210ACu8v2 and −210ACu2v8, and to depth 3 on quartic triggers with discriminants 211pqu16v4e and 211pqu4v16e. On the multiplicative bad-prime set π we prove the Volcano Law: each vertex carries an integer height vector k(V)∈Zπ with vp(ΔVmin)=2kp(V)vp(Δcratermin), and along every 2-edge k↦k+σ with σ∈{±1}π independently per prime (578 edge-prime samples, zero exceptions), via the Tate parameterization. For odd primes p∣min(a,b) we have vp(j)=−2vp(min), so the entire law is read off the j-invariant. The peak curve is explicit (y2=x3−2(b−a)x2+c2x), and the j-denominator exponent is a theorem: logden(j)/lognum(j)=(α+2)/3+O(1/logc), with the exact discrepancy identity verified to machine precision on 2185 samples --- the Pasten meeting point in its precise form; we also show the Pasten mechanism is information-free on the Frey family. As an application, for Ax+By=Cz we give an explicit two-branch formula for the crater ratio ρc; and with α=logmin(a,b)/logc we prove σmax→(5+α)q, so Szpiro is equivalent on the Frey family to the mass bound q≤6/(5+α), sharp at α=1 where Szpiro and abc coincide, while the residual gap lives at α=0, the Pillai/S-unit corner. A Sage-verified table of 17 classes (Kraus minimization agreeing with Sage minimal_model() throughout) gives σmax>6 in 14 of 17 rows (non-refutations: Szpiro allows O(1)/logN slack). All absolute σ values are certified against Sage; structural statements are proved or machine-verified symbolically. We prove no conjecture: abc, Szpiro, Beal and the height conjecture remain open.
Primarily human-written textHuman understanding: all partsDiophantine equationsFaltings heightFrey curveSzpiro conjectureabc conjectureelliptic curve isogeny classisogeny volcanoj-invariantminimal discriminant