math.DS — Dynamical Systems
Contributed by Joshua Boorstein
Let Δ be a triangle with angles πai/N, gcd(a0,a1,a2)=1, and N odd. The directions perpendicular to the sides of Δ form one orbit under the reflection group, and a companion note showed that this direction class is completely periodic whenever it has no swapped pair: two vertex-to-vertex billiard paths, each the reverse of the other, that meet no side at a right angle. Let p be the number of swapped pairs. We prove that when N is prime there are no swapped pairs, so the class is completely periodic and every regular orbit in it meets a side at a right angle. This answers the note's conjecture at prime N and proves Boshernitzan's Conjecture 2.2(b) for every rational triangle with prime denominator placed with a side horizontal. The proof has two halves: a residue modulo 1−ζN rules out paths between distinct vertices (at an odd prime power ℓk it forces ℓ to divide the third angle's numerator), and at prime N, where the first homology is one-dimensional over Q(ζN), a closed path is homologous to its mirror image, which an orientation-reversing involution forbids unless they coincide.
At composite odd N swapped pairs exist, but if no signed sum of their lengths vanishes, every regular orbit of the class still meets a side at a right angle; so p≤1 never breaks complete periodicity at odd N, unlike at even N. This criterion applies with p unbounded: the triangles (3,6m+2,12m+4) and (3,6m+1,12m+5) have exactly p=m, with independent lengths for all practical m (computer-assisted). And it is sharp: on four explicit intervals of triangles a pair of mirror-image cylinders meets no side at a right angle (computer-assisted).
Primarily AI-generated textHuman understanding: some partsBoshernitzan conjecturecomplete periodicitycyclotomic fieldsperpendicular orbitsprime denominatorrational billiardsrational trianglessaddle connectionstranslation surfaces