Erdős's 1974 distance-product volume problem resolved: the ball is always the unique maximizer in d ≥ 2

A mix of human-written and AI-generated textHuman understanding: some partsmath.CA — Classical Analysis and ODEsmath.AP — Analysis of PDEs

Contributed by Dave Goel ↗

Version 1 / Nov 20, 2026 / CC BY-SA 4.0

Abstract

We consider the set of all points of ℝ^d whose distances to n given points have product at most one. Erdős (1974) asks how large its volume can be. We show that in every dimension d ≥ 3, and for every integer n ≥ 1, this volume is at most that of the unit ball. Equality holds only and exactly when all n given points coincide. This completely answers Erdős's question; in the plane, the same statement is Pólya's theorem of 1928. In fact we settle a more general problem, with weighted points. Our theorem also shows that the two-point counterexample in dimension three, reported by Erdős in 1976 and repeated in 2018 and 2026, cannot exist. Our second theorem is a stability estimate in dimension three: if such a set falls short of the maximal volume by a small fraction D, it still contains a ball of radius at least 1 − D − o(D) as D tends to zero, uniformly in the number, weights and positions of the points. The coefficient one is sharp. These results are verified in Lean.

Author comments: The expanded version is available on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24378911

Provenance statement

This work was done overwhelmingly by AI models, steered by the author in a continuous critical dialogue, alternating between Anthropic's Claude and OpenAI's ChatGPT. The author takes full responsibility for the paper.

References

  1. C. Clark and R. S. Laugesen, Balls minimize moments of logarithmic and Newtonian equilibrium measures , Potential Anal. 63 (2025), 389--412 (https://doi.org/10.1007/s11118-024-10175-z), published online in 2024.DOI
  2. G. De Philippis, M. Marini and E. Mukoseeva, The sharp quantitative isocapacitary inequality , Rev. Mat. Iberoam. 37 (2021), 2191--2228 (https://doi.org/10.4171/RMI/1259).DOI
  3. P. Erdős, Extremal problems on polynomials (https://users.renyi.hu/~p_erdos/1976-12.pdf), in Approximation Theory II , Academic Press (1976), 347--355.link
  4. A. Ferudun, On a question of Erdős on lemniscates in Rm\R^m: connected lemniscates lie in a ball of radius 2 , preprint (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23422190DOI
  5. D. Goel, Erdős's 1974 distance-product volume problem resolved: the ball as unique maximizer, sharp inradius stability, and other miscellanea , preprint (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24378911DOI
  6. W. K. Hayman and E. F. Lingham, Research Problems in Function Theory (New Edition) , arXiv:1809.07200 (https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.07200) (2018), Problem 4.23 and Tables 1--2.arXiv
  7. P. Jasion and K. Magnucki, Elastic buckling of Cassini ovaloidal shells under external pressure -- theoretical study (https://am.ippt.gov.pl/index.php/am/article/view/v67p179), Arch. Mech. 67 (2015), 179--192.link
  8. P. Erdős, F. Herzog and G. Piranian, Metric properties of polynomials (https://www.renyi.hu/~p_erdos/1958-05.pdf), J. Analyse Math. 6 (1958), 125--148.link
  9. G. Pólya, Beitrag zur Verallgemeinerung des Verzerrungssatzes auf mehrfach zusammenhängende Gebiete (Zweite Mitteilung) (https://archive.org/details/sitzungsbericht1928preu), Sitzungsber. Preuss. Akad. Wiss., Phys.-Math. Kl. (1928), 280--282.link
  10. G. Talenti, Elliptic equations and rearrangements (https://www.numdam.org/item/ASNSP_1976_4_3_4_697_0/), Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 3 (1976), 697--718.link
Show all 12 referencesShow fewer references
  1. H. Tang and Y. Wang, Sharp constants for weak estimates of the Riesz potentials , arXiv:2608.31043v2 (https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.31043v2) (2026).arXiv
  2. D. Goel, What to read in the distance-product proof , version (2026).

Version history

  1. v1 · 17 pagesSubmitted by Dave GoelThe expanded version is available on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24378911CurrentNov 20, 2026