math.NT — Number Theory
Contributed by Zeng Chunping
Independent audit and coefficient verification of C. Soulé's preprint
"On the abc conjecture" (arXiv:2611.05217, 2026). This work neither
proves nor disproves the abc conjecture; all No-Go statements are
internal to the audited construction, and every statement that uses
Soulé's Theorem A is explicitly tagged as conditional on it.
We axiomatise the DIC framework and prove three stratified groups of
results on Kodaira–Parshin arithmetic surface fibrations.
(i) Unconditional geometric theorems: the adjunction identity
Z⋅ωX/B=−Z2, the Riemann–Hurwitz
intersection numbers, the invariants of the general (g0,r,b)
construction, and a Deligne–Riemann–Roch decomposition
c=122b2+2b−1+(D0−T)/ω2 of the arithmetic
coefficient.
(ii) A meta-theorem: integrality of torsion lengths forces the
coefficient of Theorem A onto the discrete set t=12/N,
N≡1(mod3) (at the literature point (q,λ)=(5,3); for
varying q this is an arithmetic coincidence, not a structural
barrier). A local hyperelliptic model gives T=8k, t=12 as the
unique transverse output; second-order torsion gives n1=n2, hence
Θ=T/k∈2Z, leaving (Θ,q)=(12,27) as the sole
lattice candidate. The unified criterion E=12(q−1)/(qNγ) has
the unique solution (N,Θ,q,γ)=(13,12,27,8/9); the height
is the canonical-bundle height of a fixed genus-2 curve
(γ=2/5, confirmed by 12/γ=30 in Section 7.3.2 of the
source), so (12,27) requires genus 13 and lies outside the
theorem's hypotheses: the last cell is empty.
(iii) Controlled weak abc: all unconditional bounds known for abc are
of exponential type (logc≪N1/3(logN)3; Stewart–Yu);
the exponent below is of polynomial type, and its existence is what
Theorem A supplies. We derive η(q)=(q−1)/q, unify the exponent
as E=tη/γ, and obtain
Emax=12qq−1⌈ℓ2q−2⌉. A
discriminant stratification sharpens this to
c≤Aε(N/M5)24+ε; bootstrapping to
exponent 1 is impossible (infθ=0); the
discriminant-to-degree ratio is tower-monotone; 4/5 is an Artin
conductor identity; and the isometry step (32) of the source
contributes only O(d′), derived unconditionally from a finite
Čech complex, leaving 23=m⋅c, 36, 12, 24 and
E(c)=12/(5−18c) unchanged.
A verbatim check of the source confirms twelve items, including the
statement and scope of Theorem A; the constant 12 decomposes as
31⋅ρ−mcm, and Route 1 is closed. Appendices
N–Z complete the audit: changing the type of external inequality
yields a trichotomy; enlarging the prime set restores the bridge
unconditionally but the resulting bound is vacuous, and a fixed
finite S is logically impossible by S-unit finiteness; the five
degrees of freedom are exhaustive, with the δp/Λ-ring
loophole closed at the bridging layer; a complete self-contained
proof of density-one abc is given; the Szpiro-side verbatim check
(Theorem 3, Moret-Bailly 6.4, Robin constants, and the
Section 7.2/Section 7.3 partition) repairs the zero-degree-class
applications of Corollary 1; and the remaining geometric gap is
resolved: ψ1 is a Prym map, k=2j, the 2-torsion ambiguity
is completely classified, and translation invariance forces all
Harder–Narasimhan slopes to coincide. Consequently Θ=12 is
excluded unconditionally, with C≥36/7>3 and uf=3 inside the
construction; on the Szpiro side E, CBMY and
CSzp are three scalings of the same discrete lattice,
and the only remaining room is a single discrete factor 7 at
Θ=10. There are twelve independent No-Go reasons; after
Appendices G–Z only two conditional items remain: Theorem A∗
(unremovable) and the strict isometry in (32) (no coefficient
consequences).
No Diophantine conjecture enters the derivations. We neither prove
nor disprove the abc conjecture; all conclusions are internal to the
construction under its listed hypotheses.
A mix of human-written and AI-generated textHuman understanding: all partsArakelov geometryKodaira-Parshin fibrationabc conjecturediscrete obstructiontorsion sheaves and determinant cohomologyweak abc inequality