math.NT — Number Theory
Making the coprimality convention explicit in a mean value theorem of Halupczok for the ternary Goldbach problem
Theorem 1.2 of Halupczok (2013) is a Bombieri-Vinogradov type mean value theorem for the ternary Goldbach problem with one prime in an arithmetic progression and two primes in short intervals. Her proof works with residue classes coprime to the modulus, as stated on p. 344 of her paper, and this convention needs to be written explicitly into the statement because the printed product and the prime sum differ at , where the prime sum is for while the printed product is at least for odd . We give two closely related explicit formulations, Formulation A and Formulation B, show that Formulation A implies Formulation B, and prove both assuming two cited inputs, Hypothesis H1 and Hypothesis H2, or alternatively Theorems 2.1 and 2.3 of her paper, which follow from these two inputs. Here Hypothesis H1 is a uniform reading of a printed remark of Perelli, Pintz and Salerno, supported by a reading of the proof, and Hypothesis H2 is assembled from displays of Perelli and Pintz and is not a numbered statement. The supplement of Theorem 1.2 with a maximum over is not covered. The later results of Halupczok's paper use only coprime residue classes and are unaffected. The main results of this note have been checked by computer.