math.LO — Logic
Under Measurables, HOD_{Ord^{\omega}} is locally arbitrary
For the inner model $\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}$, we derive an analogue for Roguski's classical result that without nontrivial assumptions on , $\HOD$ is an arbitrary model of $\ZFC$. For any sentence , letting $\CM$ denote ``class of measurables,'' the following theories are equiconsistent: \begin{enumerate} \item $\ZFC+\CM+ [\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}\models (\exists\kappa\,V_{\kappa}\models\sigma)]$; \item $\ZFC+\GCH+\CM+ [\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}\models (\SVC\wedge\CM\wedge\exists\kappa\,V_{\kappa}\models\sigma)]$; \item $\ZF+\DC+\CM+ \exists\kappa\,V_{\kappa}\models\sigma$. \end{enumerate} Thus, under measurables the only local constraint on $\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}$ is the requisite choice principle. We also derive an analogue for Woodins. Letting $\CW$ denote ``class of Woodins,'' the following are equiconsistent: \begin{enumerate} \item $\ZFC+\CW+ [\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}\models (\exists\kappa\,V_{\kappa}\models\sigma)]$; \item $\ZFC+\GCH+\CW+ [\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}\models (\exists\kappa\,V_{\kappa}\models\sigma)]+$ $\HOD_{\Ord^{\omega}}$ is a ground of ; \item $\ZFC+\CW+$ some symmetric extension $V(G) \models \DC+\exists\kappa\,V_{\kappa}\models\sigma$. \end{enumerate}