cs.CC — Computational Complexity
A Three-Polynomial Counterexample to the Generalized Effective Hypercube Nullstellensatz
We give a counterexample to the proposed extension of the effective Hypercube Nullstellensatz from two polynomials to an arbitrary fixed number of polynomials. For every , we construct three real polynomials in variables, of degrees , respectively. Each is nonzero as a function on the Boolean cube, their product vanishes on the cube, and they have no common Boolean zero. Nevertheless, every polynomial certificate on the cube satisfies , where the bar denotes multilinearization. The construction applies a fresh selector variable to the hard pair of Kothari, Kovacs-Deak, Wang, and Yang. Thus its new ingredient is a short transfer of their existing degree obstruction to the product-zero setting. The full unbounded-degree counterexample has been formalized and checked in Lean 4. HAL deposit: hal-05800244v1.