Smooth isometric bending of a closed sphere

Contributed by Boyang Hu ↗

Version 1 / Nov 16, 2026 / CC BY 4.0

Abstract

We construct a smooth embedded sphere Σ⊂R3\Sigma\subset\mathbb R^3 together with a smooth one-parameter family of isometric embeddings of Σ\Sigma whose images are not all congruent. The family is periodic; an inner disk and a complementary cap stay fixed pointwise; and the area, the enclosed volume and the total mean curvature do not change. This gives a flexible closed surface in the smooth category. The mechanism is elementary. A disk whose metric is rotationally symmetric, but whose embedding is not, can be turned inside a fixed shell provided it is exactly planar near its rim. The whole difficulty is to produce such a disk. This reduces to a scalar equation of Monge–Ampère type on an annulus, the Darboux equation, for a height function which must be nonradial and yet constant to infinite order at both boundary circles. We solve this equation by a Nash–Moser argument around an infinitesimal bending of a radial profile. The profile is forced to change the sign of its curvature infinitely often near each boundary circle, so the linearized equation changes type on infinitely many circles accumulating at both ends. We build the profile from explicitly solvable one-dimensional models, describe its accumulating ends by an exact three-term recurrence, and invert the linearized operator on the whole annulus. Two modifications of the linearization, each proportional to an unsolved equation, keep the type-change circles and the characteristic return maps fixed during the iteration, so that all linearized operators act on one domain.

Author comments: 119 pages. The main theorem (Theorem A) has been formalized in Lean 4 with Mathlib: https://github.com/Rogerhu12/continuous-flexibility. The folder anc/ contains four Python scripts which check explicit identities of the text, and the script which draws Figure 2.

Provenance statement

The mathematical arguments were developed with GPT-6 Astra Pro. The paper was then organized and rewritten with Claude Fable 5.2, and in the course of this several arguments were replaced or expanded. Theorem A has been formalized in Lean 4 with Mathlib; the formal proof follows the lemma structure of the paper but does not certify the text line by line. Boyang Hu organized the work and is responsible for the manuscript.

Tools used

OpenAI
ChatGPTVersion GPT-6 Pro
Anthropic
Claude FableVersion Claude Fable 5.2

References

  1. A. D. Alexandrov. On the works of S. E. Cohn-Vossen . Uspekhi Matematicheskikh Nauk , 2(3(19)):107--141, 1947. In Russian; English translation by A. Iacob, 2012, https://math.uni-koeln.de/sites/math_career/studium/Weitere_Dokumente/Stefan_Cohn_Vossen/Alexandrov_Iacob.pdf.link
  2. F. J. Almgren, Jr. and I. Rivin. The mean curvature integral is invariant under bending. In The Epstein Birthday Schrift , volume 1 of Geometry & Topology Monographs , pages 1--21. 1998.
  3. W. Cao. The semi-global isometric embedding of surfaces with curvature changing signs stably. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society , 147(10):4343--4353, 2019.
  4. R. Connelly. A counterexample to the rigidity conjecture for polyhedra. Publications Mathématiques de l'IHÉS , 47:333--338, 1977.
  5. J. M. Combes and L. Thomas. Asymptotic behaviour of eigenfunctions for multiparticle Schrödinger operators. Communications in Mathematical Physics , 34:251--270, 1973.
  6. S. Cohn-Vossen. Zwei S ä tze ü ber die S tarrheit der E ifl ä chen. Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu G ö ttingen, Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse , pages 125--134, 1927.
  7. S. Cohn-Vossen. Unstarre geschlossene fl ä chen. Mathematische Annalen , 102:10--29, 1930.
  8. G.-C. Dong. The semi-global isometric imbedding in R3\mathbb{R}^3 of two-dimensional Riemannian manifolds with Gaussian curvature changing sign cleanly. Journal of Partial Differential Equations , 6(1):62--79, 1993.
  9. N. V. Efimov. Qualitative problems of the theory of deformation of surfaces. Uspekhi Matematicheskikh Nauk , 3(2(24)):47--158, 1948. In Russian.
  10. N. V. Efimov. Research on the deformation of surfaces containing points with zero gaussian curvature. Matematicheskii Sbornik (N.S.) , 23(65)(1):89--125, 1948. In Russian.
Show all 55 referencesShow fewer references
  1. M. Ghomi. Open problems in geometry of curves and surfaces, 2019.
  2. M. Ghomi, H. Qiu, M. Raffaelli, and Y. Zhang. Nonrigidity of smooth tight surfaces, 2026. Preprint, arXiv:2611.17269v1, 12 November 2026.arXiv
  3. M. Ghomi and J. Spruck. Rigidity of nonnegatively curved surfaces relative to a curve. International Mathematics Research Notices , 2020(17):5387--5400, 2020.
  4. R. S. Hamilton. The inverse function theorem of Nash and Moser . Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society (New Series) , 7(1):65--222, 1982.
  5. Q. Han. On the isometric embedding of surfaces with Gauss curvature changing sign cleanly. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics , 58(2):285--295, 2005.
  6. G. Herglotz. Ü ber die S tarrheit der E ifl ä chen. Abhandlungen aus dem Mathematischen Seminar der Hansischen Universit ä t , 15:127--129, 1943.
  7. Q. Han and J.-X. Hong. Isometric Embedding of Riemannian Manifolds in Euclidean Spaces , volume 130 of Mathematical Surveys and Monographs . American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2006.
  8. Q. Han, J.-X. Hong, and C.-S. Lin. Local isometric embedding of surfaces with nonpositive Gaussian curvature. Journal of Differential Geometry , 63(3):475--520, 2003.
  9. Q. Han and M. A. Khuri. On the local isometric embedding in R3\mathbb{R}^3 of surfaces with Gaussian curvature of mixed sign. Communications in Analysis and Geometry , 18(4):649--704, 2010.
  10. Q. Han and M. A. Khuri. Smooth solutions to a class of mixed type Monge--Ampère equations. Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations , 47:825--867, 2013.
  11. W. Hamouche, C. Maurini, S. Vidoli, and A. Vincenti. Multi-parameter actuation of a neutrally stable shell: a flexible gear-less motor. Proceedings of the Royal Society A , 473(2204):20170364, 2017. arXiv:1707.09013.arXiv
  12. L. H ö rmander. The boundary problems of physical geodesy. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis , 62:1--52, 1976.
  13. L. H ö rmander. On the Nash--Moser implicit function theorem. Annales Academiae Scientiarum Fennicae, Series A I Mathematica , 10:255--259, 1985.
  14. L. Infeld and T. E. Hull. The factorization method. Reviews of Modern Physics , 23:21--68, 1951.
  15. I. Ivanova-Karatopraklieva and I. K. Sabitov. Deformation of surfaces. I . Itogi Nauki i Tekhniki. Seriya Problemy Geometrii , 23:131--184, 1991. In Russian; English translation in Journal of Mathematical Sciences 70 (1994), no. 2, 1685--1716.
  16. M. A. Khuri. The local isometric embedding in R3\mathbb{R}^3 of two-dimensional Riemannian manifolds with Gaussian curvature changing sign to finite order on a curve. Journal of Differential Geometry , 76(2):249--291, 2007.
  17. I. S. Kac and M. G. Krein. On the spectral functions of the string. American Mathematical Society Translations, Series 2 , 103:19--102, 1974.
  18. N. H. Kuiper. On C 1^1-isometric imbeddings. I . Proceedings of the Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen, Series A , 58:545--556, 1955.
  19. R. E. Langer. The asymptotic solutions of ordinary linear differential equations of the second order, with special reference to a turning point. Transactions of the American Mathematical Society , 67:461--490, 1949.
  20. C.-H. Li. The semi-global isometric embedding of surfaces with Gaussian curvature changing sign cleanly. Science China Mathematics , 55(12):2507--2515, 2012.
  21. C.-S. Lin. The local isometric embedding in R3\mathbb{R}^3 of two-dimensional Riemannian manifolds with Gaussian curvature changing sign cleanly. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics , 39(6):867--887, 1986.
  22. A. D. Milka. On points of relative non-rigidity of a convex surface of revolution. Ukrainskii Geometricheskii Sbornik , 1:65--74, 1965. In Russian.
  23. P. M. Morse. Diatomic molecules according to the wave mechanics. II . vibrational levels. Physical Review , 34:57--64, 1929.
  24. J. Moser. A rapidly convergent iteration method and non-linear partial differential equations. I . Annali della Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa, Classe di Scienze (3) , 20(2):265--315, 1966.
  25. T. Minagawa and T. Rad ó . On the infinitesimal rigidity of surfaces of revolution. Mathematische Zeitschrift , 59:151--163, 1953.
  26. B. Muckenhoupt. Hardy's inequality with weights. Studia Mathematica , 44(1):31--38, 1972.
  27. J. Nash. C 1^1 isometric imbeddings. Annals of Mathematics , 60(3):383--396, 1954.
  28. J. Nash. The imbedding problem for Riemannian manifolds. Annals of Mathematics , 63(1):20--63, 1956.
  29. National Institute of Standards and Technology . Digital Library of Mathematical Functions : Chapter 9, Airy and related functions. https://dlmf.nist.gov/9.link
  30. F. W. J. Olver. Asymptotics and Special Functions . Academic Press, New York, 1974.
  31. A. V. Pogorelov. Extrinsic Geometry of Convex Surfaces , volume 35 of Translations of Mathematical Monographs . American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1973.
  32. Y. G. Reshetnyak. On non-rigid surfaces of revolution. Sibirskii Matematicheskii Zhurnal , 3(4):591--604, 1962. In Russian.
  33. I. K. Sabitov. Possible generalizations of the Minagawa--Rado lemma on the rigidity of a surface of revolution with a fixed parallel. Mathematical Notes , 19(1):74--79, 1976. Russian original: Mat. Zametki 19:1 (1976), 123--132.
  34. I. K. Sabitov. Quasiconformal mappings of a surface generated by its isometric transformations, and bendings of the surface onto itself. Fundamentalnaya i Prikladnaya Matematika , 1(1):281--288, 1995. In Russian.
  35. I. K. Sabitov. The volume of polyhedron as a function of its metric. Fundamentalnaya i Prikladnaya Matematika , 2(4):1235--1246, 1996. In Russian.
  36. I. K. Sabitov. Infinitesimal and global rigidity and inflexibility of surfaces of revolution with flattening at the poles. Sbornik: Mathematics , 204(10):1516--1547, 2013.
  37. I. K. Sabitov. Second-order infinitesimal bendings of surfaces of revolution with flattening at the poles. Sbornik: Mathematics , 205(12):1787--1814, 2014.
  38. I. K. Sabitov. Bendable surfaces without visible deformations of their shape. Mathematical Notes , 110(1):126--134, 2021.
  39. I. K. Sabitov. Infinitesimal sliding bendings of compact surfaces and Euler's conjecture. Siberian Mathematical Journal , 64(5):1213--1228, 2023.
  40. R. T. Seeley. Extension of C∞C^\infty functions defined in a half space. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society , 15:625--626, 1964.
  41. R. Sa Earp and E. Toubiana. Discrete and nondiscrete isometric deformations of surfaces in R3\mathbb{R}^3 . Siberian Mathematical Journal , 43(4):714--718, 2002.
  42. J. Sj ö strand and M. Zworski. Elementary linear algebra for advanced spectral problems. Annales de l'Institut Fourier , 57(7):2095--2141, 2007.
  43. G. Teschl. Mathematical Methods in Quantum Mechanics: With Applications to Schrödinger Operators , volume 99 of Graduate Studies in Mathematics . American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2009.
  44. F. Tricomi. Sulle equazioni lineari alle derivate parziali di secondo ordine, di tipo misto. Atti della Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Serie 5 , 14:134--247, 1923.
  45. D. A. Trotsenko. Nonrigid analytic surfaces of revolution. Siberian Mathematical Journal , 21(5):718--724, 1980. Russian original: Sibirsk. Mat. Zh. 21:5 (1980), 100--108.

Version history

  1. v1 · 119 pagesSubmitted by Boyang Hu119 pages. The main theorem (Theorem A) has been formalized in Lean 4 with Mathlib: https://github.com/Rogerhu12/continuous-flexibility. The folder anc/ contains four Python scripts which check explicit identities of the text, and the script which draws Figure 2.CurrentNov 16, 2026