Points from Processes: Vakarelov’s Dynamic Mereotopology and Whitehead’s Point-Free Program

A mix of human-written and AI-generated textHuman understanding: all partsmath.LO — Logic

Contributed by John Hessler ↗

Version 1 / Nov 15, 2026 / CC BY 4.0

Abstract

Whitehead held that neither points of space nor instants of time should be primitive: both ought to be definable from relations between material things. Region-based theories of space have largely carried out the spatial half of this program, but the temporal half has remained informal. This paper offers an expository and philosophical account of Dimiter Vakarelov’s dynamic mereotopology, developed in five papers between 2010 and 2016, which aims at a theory of space and time that is point-free in this double sense. We argue that the program is best read as a staged realization of Whitehead’s demand. Each stage enriches the primitive spatio-temporal relations between changing regions just enough to recover a further layer of temporal structure: first moments without order, then an ordered time, and finally nameable, spatially non-trivial epochs. The staging culminates in a structural result Whitehead anticipated but never formalized: points of space and points of time turn out to be different aggregations of one and the same stock of abstract atoms. We also argue that the representation theorems on which the program rests deliver a reconstruction, rather than a reduction, of points, and that reconstruction is what Whitehead’s program requires.

References

  1. Allen, J. F. (1983). Maintaining knowledge about temporal intervals. Communications of the ACM 26: 832--843.
  2. Balbiani, P., Tinchev, T. and Vakarelov, D. (2007). Modal logics for region-based theories of space. Fundamenta Informaticae 81: 29--82.
  3. Bennett, B. and Düntsch, I. (2007). Axioms, algebras and topology. In M. Aiello, I. Pratt-Hartmann and J. van Benthem (eds.), Handbook of Spatial Logics , pp. 99--160. Springer.
  4. Bezhanishvili, G., Morandi, P. J. and Olberding, B. (2013). Bounded Archimedean ℓ\ell-algebras and Gelfand--Neumark--Stone duality. Theory and Applications of Categories 28: 435--475.
  5. Buchholz, D., Dreyer, O., Florig, M. and Summers, S. J. (2000). Geometric modular action and spacetime symmetry groups. Reviews in Mathematical Physics 12: 475--560.
  6. Connes, A. (1994). Noncommutative Geometry . San Diego: Academic Press.
  7. de Laguna, T. (1922). Point, line and surface as sets of solids. Journal of Philosophy 19: 449--461.
  8. de Vries, H. (1962). Compact Spaces and Compactifications: An Algebraic Approach . Assen: Van Gorcum.
  9. Dimov, G. and Vakarelov, D. (2006). Contact algebras and region-based theory of space: A proximity approach, I and II. Fundamenta Informaticae 74: 209--249, 251--282.
  10. Dixmier, J. (1977). C*-Algebras . Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Show all 50 referencesShow fewer references
  1. Düntsch, I. and Vakarelov, D. (2007). Region-based theory of discrete spaces: A proximity approach. Annals of Mathematics and Artificial Intelligence 49: 5--14.
  2. Düntsch, I. and Winter, M. (2008). Moving spaces. In S. Demri and C. S. Jensen (eds.), Proceedings of TIME 2008 , pp. 59--63. IEEE Computer Society.
  3. Düntsch, I. and Winter, M. (2009). Timed contact algebras. In C. Lutz and J.-F. Raskin (eds.), Proceedings of TIME 2009 , pp. 133--138. IEEE Computer Society.
  4. Egenhofer, M. and Franzosa, R. (1991). Point-set topological spatial relations. International Journal of Geographical Information Systems 5: 161--174.
  5. Galton, A. (1999). The mereotopology of discrete spaces. In C. Freksa and D. M. Mark (eds.), Spatial Information Theory , LNCS 1661, pp. 251--266. Springer.
  6. Gelfand, I. and Naimark, M. (1943). On the imbedding of normed rings into the ring of operators in Hilbert space. Matematicheskii Sbornik 12(54): 197--217.
  7. Goldblatt, R. (1980). Diodorean modality in Minkowski spacetime. Studia Logica 39: 219--236.
  8. Haag, R. (1996). Local Quantum Physics: Fields, Particles, Algebras . 2nd ed. Berlin: Springer.
  9. Haag, R. and Kastler, D. (1964). An algebraic approach to quantum field theory. Journal of Mathematical Physics 5: 848--861.
  10. Kamp, H. (1979). Events, instants and temporal reference. In R. Bäuerle, U. Egli and A. von Stechow (eds.), Semantics from Different Points of View , pp. 376--417. Berlin: Springer.
  11. Kontchakov, R., Kurucz, A., Wolter, F. and Zakharyaschev, M. (2007). Spatial logic + temporal logic = ? In M. Aiello, I. Pratt-Hartmann and J. van Benthem (eds.), Handbook of Spatial Logics , pp. 497--564. Springer.
  12. Nenchev, V. (2011). Logics for stable and unstable mereological relations. Central European Journal of Mathematics 9: 1354--1379.
  13. Nenchev, V. (2013). Dynamic relational mereotopology: Logics for stable and unstable relations. Logic and Logical Philosophy 22: 295--325.
  14. Pratt-Hartmann, I. (2007). First-order region-based theories of space. In M. Aiello, I. Pratt-Hartmann and J. van Benthem (eds.), Handbook of Spatial Logics , pp. 13--97. Springer.
  15. Randell, D. A., Cui, Z. and Cohn, A. G. (1992). A spatial logic based on regions and connection. In B. Nebel, C. Rich and W. Swartout (eds.), Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Knowledge Representation and Reasoning , pp. 165--176. San Mateo, CA: Morgan Kaufmann.
  16. Robb, A. A. (1914). A Theory of Time and Space . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  17. Russell, B. (1914). Our Knowledge of the External World as a Field for Scientific Method in Philosophy . Chicago and London: Open Court.
  18. Russell, B. (1936). On order in time. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 32: 216--228.
  19. Shapirovsky, I. and Shehtman, V. (2003). Chronological modality in Minkowski spacetime. In P. Balbiani et al.\ (eds.), Advances in Modal Logic 4, pp. 437--459. London: King's College Publications.
  20. Shapirovsky, I. and Shehtman, V. (2005). Modal logics of regions and Minkowski spacetime. Journal of Logic and Computation 15: 559--574.
  21. Shehtman, V. (1983). Modal logics of domains on the real plane. Studia Logica 42: 63--80.
  22. Simons, P. (1987). Parts: A Study in Ontology . Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  23. Tarski, A. (1956). Foundations of the geometry of solids. In Logic, Semantics, Metamathematics , pp. 24--29. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  24. van Benthem, J. (1983). The Logic of Time . Dordrecht: Reidel.
  25. Vakarelov, D. (2007). Region-based theory of space: Algebras of regions, representation theory, and logics. In D. M. Gabbay et al.\ (eds.), Mathematical Problems from Applied Logic II , pp. 267--348. Springer.
  26. Vakarelov, D. (2008). A modal approach to dynamic ontology: Modal mereotopology. Logic and Logical Philosophy 17: 163--183.
  27. Vakarelov, D. (2010). Dynamic mereotopology: A point-free theory of changing regions. I. Stable and unstable mereotopological relations. Fundamenta Informaticae 100: 159--180. [ ]
  28. Vakarelov, D. (2012). Dynamic mereotopology II: Axiomatizing some Whiteheadean type space-time logics. In T. Bolander et al.\ (eds.), Advances in Modal Logic 9, pp. 538--558. London: College Publications. [ ]
  29. Vakarelov, D. (2014). Dynamic mereotopology. III. Whiteheadean type of integrated point-free theories of space and time. I. Algebra and Logic 53(3): 191--205. [ ]
  30. Vakarelov, D. (2016a). Dynamic mereotopology. III. Whiteheadian type of integrated point-free theories of space and time. II. Algebra and Logic 55(1): 9--23. [ ]
  31. Vakarelov, D. (2016b). Dynamic mereotopology. III. Whiteheadian type of integrated point-free theories of space and time. III. Algebra and Logic 55(3): 181--197. [ ]
  32. Vakarelov, D. (2020). Point-free theories of space and time. arXiv:2004.14755.arXiv
  33. Walker, A. G. (1947). Durées et instants. Revue Scientifique 85: 131--134.
  34. Whitehead, A. N. (1917). The Organization of Thought: Educational and Scientific . London: Williams and Norgate.
  35. Whitehead, A. N. (1919). An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Natural Knowledge . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  36. Whitehead, A. N. (1920). The Concept of Nature . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  37. Whitehead, A. N. (1925). Science and the Modern World . New York: Macmillan.
  38. Whitehead, A. N. (1929/1978). Process and Reality: An Essay in Cosmology . Corrected edition, ed.\ D. R. Griffin and D. W. Sherburne. New York: Free Press, 1978. First published New York: Macmillan, 1929. Page references are to the corrected edition unless marked ``1929 ed.''
  39. Wiener, N. (1914). A contribution to the theory of relative position. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 17: 441--449.
  40. Wolter, F. and Zakharyaschev, M. (2000). Spatial representation and reasoning in RCC-8 with Boolean region terms. In W. Horn (ed.), Proceedings of ECAI 2000 , pp. 244--248. Amsterdam: IOS Press.

Version history

  1. v1 · 35 pagesSubmitted by John HesslerInitial depositCurrentNov 14, 2026