Highly Connected Counterexamples to the Multiplicative Merino–Welsh Inequality
Version 1 / Oct 21, 2026 / CC BY 4.0
Abstract
For every integer , we construct -connected matroids representable over every infinite field, with girth , arbitrarily large cogirth, and Merino–Welsh quotient
\[
\Phi(M)=\frac{T_M(1,1)^2}{T_M(2,0)T_M(0,2)}
\]
tending to infinity.
In particular, this disproves **Conjecture 7.2 of Csikvári (2026)**, which asserts the multiplicative Merino–Welsh inequality for simple and cosimple matroids, and therefore also the stronger **Conjecture 7.3** therein, as observed by its author.
Our examples are rank truncations of direct sums of -element circuits. We give a 3-connected counterexample on 1011 elements of rank 433, certified by exact integer arithmetic, and a 6048-element counterexample admitting a proof without computation.
Taking the direct sum of a counterexample with its dual also gives a negative answer to **Problem 4.3 of Beke, Csáji, Csikvári, and Pituk (2024)**: the original maximum and additive Merino–Welsh inequalities can fail for simple and cosimple matroids.
The same construction disproves **Conjecture 2 of Knauer, Martínez-Sandoval, and Merino (2026)**: for every fixed , is unbounded even among matroids having both girth and cogirth exactly .
The dual direct-sum examples need not be connected; these constructions do not disprove the graphical or binary versions.
Provenance statement
Tools used
- OpenAI
- ChatGPTVersion 6 Pro
References
- C. Beke, G. K. Csáji, P. Csikvári, and S. Pituk, The Merino--Welsh conjecture is false for matroids , Advances in Mathematics 446 (2024), 109674. doi:10.1016/j.aim.2024.109674 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2024.109674). The published version contains Problem 4.3.DOI
- P. Csikvári, Around the Merino--Welsh conjecture: improving Jackson's inequality , European Journal of Combinatorics 137 (2026), 104402. doi:10.1016/j.ejc.2026.104402 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejc.2026.104402). Conjecture 7.2 is stated in arXiv:2502.19196v2 (https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.19196).arXivDOI
- K. Knauer, L. Martínez-Sandoval, and C. Merino, Merino--Welsh inequalities for matroids with controlled lattices of cyclic flats , arXiv:2609.38047 (https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.38047), version 1, 29 September 2026. Conjecture 2.arXiv
Version history
- v1 · 7 pagesSubmitted by Jungang ChenInitial depositCurrentOct 21, 2026