math-ph — Mathematical Physics
Axiomatic Foundations of Astrophysical Systems: Model-Independent Obstructions Between Equations of State, Observables, and Field Equations
Continuing the axiomatic program for astrophysics initiated in previous works, we introduce a gravity-model-independent and scale-independent definition of an \emph{astrophysical system} and of \emph{clusters of astrophysical systems} over arbitrary piecewise smooth spatial manifolds. A cluster is modeled as a subspace of piecewise differentiable sections of matter and gravitational bundles (modulo coincidence on dense open sets), endowed with macroscopic observable functionals and coupled through a parametric field operator encompassing Newtonian gravity, General Relativity, and modified gravity theories (, Rastall, scalar-tensor, and MOND-type models). Restricting local equations of state to bounded extended-norm balls (which form affine Banach spaces on fixed partitions) and applying Implicit Function Theorems in locally convex spaces, we prove four universal obstruction theorems: (i) a direct multi-observable obstruction theorem; (ii) a gravity-coupled structural obstruction theorem via locally density-solvable field equations and reference evaluation operators; (iii) a causal lifting theorem for general acoustic cones; and (iv) an \emph{inverse obstruction theorem}, showing that combining causality-constrained equations of state with empirical observable relations induces \emph{a priori} bounds on the parameter space of the gravitational theory. We also prove that finite-dimensional gravity-coupled clusters are closed and nowhere dense in any Hausdorff locally convex topology, and apply our results to compact stars in Rastall and perturbative gravity, Bowers--Liang anisotropic stars, and galaxies obeying the Baryonic Tully--Fisher Relation.