math.GR — Group Theory
Counterexamples to the Mathieu Property: From Explicit Quotient Constructions to a General Classification
In 1997, Olivier Mathieu conjectured that if every positive power of a function on a compact connected Lie group has average zero, then multiplying those powers by any fixed function should eventually preserve this property. Christopher D. Long disproved this conjecture in 2026 and classified the compact connected groups for which the property holds. This paper extends that classification to a much broader family of algebraic spaces, including nonspherical homogeneous spaces and disconnected groups. We prove a necessary and sufficient condition determining exactly when the Mathieu–Zhao property holds. The proof constructs new explicit counterexamples using the binary octahedral and icosahedral groups, covering cases not addressed by earlier classifications. These counterexamples remain valid under polynomial transformations and give rise to transcendental generating functions. The main result completes the classification of the Mathieu–Zhao property for complex homogeneous spaces whose acting groups and stabilizers have reductive identity components, extending the known results from compact groups and spherical spaces to this general setting.