On sequential ideal measurements in the exceptional Jordan algebra

Contributed by Robert R. MacGregor ↗

Version 1 / Nov 19, 2026 / CC BY 4.0

Abstract

Real, complex and quaternionic quantum theory have one exceptional relative, the Albert algebra H3(O)H_3(\mathbb O), which single-system reconstructions leave standing. Sequences of measurements on a single system can still tell it apart, provided the measurements are ideal. A yes–no test is ideal if it disturbs the state no more than its answer requires, as under the projection postulate. Ideal tests of finitely many pure states of H3(O)H_3(\mathbb O) are then matched by ideal measurements on a real, complex or quaternionic Hilbert space of any dimension exactly when those states fail to generate the algebra. When they generate it, an ideal Hilbert-space model matching every sequence from even one starting state would yield a faithful representation of the algebra and its Jordan product by operators, which Albert ruled out in 1934. Three states never generate it; whether four do is decided by one number, proportional to a squared octonion associator. Even when four do, the difference is slow to show: from the maximally mixed state, a random choice between two quaternionic qutrits matches every sequence of up to six outcomes, and only at seven is every Hilbert-space model excluded. If the tests need not be ideal, then for any finite set of tests a finite-dimensional quantum device with sharp answers matches every sequence, of any length.

Author comments: 132 pages. The LaTeX source of the companion paper, Finite certificates for sequential measurements in the exceptional Jordan algebra (56 pages), is in the source archive at companion/macgregor-finite-certificates.tex.

Tools used

Anthropic
Claude FableVersion 5.2
Anthropic
Claude OpusVersion 5.5
OpenAI
GPT AstraVersion 6.2
OpenAI
GPT SolVersion 6.2
Google
GeminiVersion Carbon
Google
GeminiVersion Hydrogen
Lean FRO
Lean 4Version v4.36.0
Mathlib community
MathlibVersion v4.36.0

References

No bibliography entries.

Version history

  1. v1 · 132 pagesSubmitted by Robert R. MacGregor132 pages. The LaTeX source of the companion paper, Finite certificates for sequential measurements in the exceptional Jordan algebra (56 pages), is in the source archive at companion/macgregor-finite-certificates.tex.CurrentNov 18, 2026