stat.TH — Statistics Theory
Reconstructing the Simulmatics 1960 Simulation: Mathematics, Methods and a Partial Replication
In August 1960 the Simulmatics Corporation ran a computer simulation for the Democratic National Committee. It ranked 32 non-Southern states by Kennedy’s likely strength if religion dominated the campaign. Pool and Abelson (1961) reported that this ranking correlated .82 with the November result, using no political data later than October 1958. This paper reconstructs the mathematics behind that result from the published record: the 1961 Public Opinion Quarterly article and the list of 480 voter types later printed in the appendix of Burdick’s The 480 (1964). We make four contributions. First, we write the model as a complete system: a 480-type typology, a pooled issue-cluster estimator, a synthetic-state aggregator and nine cross-pressure equation sets. Second, we show that the model’s one non-trivial step, estimating how many 1958 Democrats were anti-Catholic, is an odds-ratio constrained 2 × 2 table with a unique feasible solution for every odds ratio, and we derive its comparative statics. Third, we prove that the authors’ “lucky guess” benchmark (add 34 per cent of the Catholic share to the 1956 Democratic vote) is the in-sample ratio of two least-squares coefficients, so its correlation is a two-parameter multiple correlation fitted with hindsight. Fourth, we recompute the published benchmarks from public returns. The authors’ printed ranking has a Spearman correlation of 0.755 with Kennedy’s 1960 share across the 32 states (p < 10−6). The model’s own list of failures, the Mountain states, reappears in our data. Six animations, collected in an online story map, accompany the paper..