# The window checks: exact checks of the masks of sep_p5/p5rig.py, on the shipped program and on a copy with the masks as first run # Exact rational checks of two lines of the separately written program sep_p5/p5rig.py (section "The window masks of sep_p5/p5rig.py" of README.md): not certificates, and not part of Theorem A's record. # Each section below is one output file. unpack.py writes it back out and checks its SHA-256: the original one where the # shipped text is the file as written by its run, and the shipped one where declared substitutions were made. ==== file: p5_window_runs.txt | original SHA-256 c5cbe34d98b354ad174c978399453e00a791f892c73665125b52c6558a6b4091 | shipped SHA-256 c5cbe34d98b354ad174c978399453e00a791f892c73665125b52c6558a6b4091 | trailing newline: yes | as written by the run c5522ae5b1d4cfc5cacb2b0b8102b2ca29977dd70a8f35728ad33e61706bdb07 sep_p5/p5rig.py 675de15350248a9724f2fddd25e9f40ced6543feaad029976c3beb787d05c744 p5rig_oldmasks.py 424c424 < sure = (c0 >= ih - l) & (c1 < ih - 1) --- > sure = (c0 >= ih - l) & (c1 <= ih - 1) 426c426 < maybe = (c1 >= ih - l - 2) & (c0 <= ih - 1) --- > maybe = (c1 >= ih - l - 1) & (c0 <= ih - 1) sep_p5/p5rig.py sure = (c0 >= ih - l) & (c1 < ih - 1) maybe = (c1 >= ih - l - 2) & (c0 <= ih - 1) M = 40: 16400 (l, c0, c1) checked; false 'sure' 0 (caller-form candidates 0); missed 'maybe' 0 (caller-form candidates 0) -> CONTRACT HOLDS M = 40: actual calls (caller form AND M/20 <= l < M/5 AND c1 + l < M, the PhiD loop; the far strata use a subset): false 'sure' 0, missed 'maybe' 0; mesh admissible to the certificate (M % 60 == 0): False M = 120: 435600 (l, c0, c1) checked; false 'sure' 0 (caller-form candidates 0); missed 'maybe' 0 (caller-form candidates 0) -> CONTRACT HOLDS M = 120: actual calls (caller form AND M/20 <= l < M/5 AND c1 + l < M, the PhiD loop; the far strata use a subset): false 'sure' 0, missed 'maybe' 0; mesh admissible to the certificate (M % 60 == 0): True p5rig_oldmasks.py sure = (c0 >= ih - l) & (c1 <= ih - 1) maybe = (c1 >= ih - l - 1) & (c0 <= ih - 1) M = 40: 16400 (l, c0, c1) checked; false 'sure' 190 (caller-form candidates 18); missed 'maybe' 190 (caller-form candidates 0) -> VIOLATIONS M = 40: actual calls (caller form AND M/20 <= l < M/5 AND c1 + l < M, the PhiD loop; the far strata use a subset): false 'sure' 6, missed 'maybe' 0; mesh admissible to the certificate (M % 60 == 0): False M = 120: 435600 (l, c0, c1) checked; false 'sure' 1770 (caller-form candidates 58); missed 'maybe' 1770 (caller-form candidates 0) -> VIOLATIONS M = 120: actual calls (caller form AND M/20 <= l < M/5 AND c1 + l < M, the PhiD loop; the far strata use a subset): false 'sure' 18, missed 'maybe' 0; mesh admissible to the certificate (M % 60 == 0): True { "M": 120, "source": "sep_p5/p5rig.py", "groups": { "exact_step_P": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "exact_step_P", "where": { "key": [ 1, 1 ], "l": 6, "n": 58 }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_P11": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_P11", "where": { "l": 6, "n": 58, "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_Z_closed": { "count": 288, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": 1e-323, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 1e-323, "slack_exact": "1/101201126653655309176247673359458653524778324882071059178450679013715169783997673445980191850718562247593538932158405955694904368692896738433506699970369254960758712138283180682233453871046608170619883839236372534281003741712346349309051677824579778170405028256179384776166707307615251266093163754323003131653853870546747392", "ok": true } }, "paper_Z_interior": { "count": 432, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_interior", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 66, "c0": 59, "c1": 60, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.033898305084747, "upper": 1e-323, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 1e-323, "slack_exact": "1/101201126653655309176247673359458653524778324882071059178450679013715169783997673445980191850718562247593538932158405955694904368692896738433506699970369254960758712138283180682233453871046608170619883839236372534281003741712346349309051677824579778170405028256179384776166707307615251266093163754323003131653853870546747392", "ok": true } } }, "total": 936, "passed": 936 } exact_windows.py on sep_p5/p5rig.py: exit status 0 { "M": 120, "source": "p5rig_oldmasks.py", "groups": { "exact_step_P": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "exact_step_P", "where": { "key": [ 1, 1 ], "l": 6, "n": 58 }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_P11": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_P11", "where": { "l": 6, "n": 58, "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_Z_closed": { "count": 288, "failures": 24, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false } }, "paper_Z_interior": { "count": 432, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_interior", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 66, "c0": 59, "c1": 60, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.033898305084747, "upper": 1e-323, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 1e-323, "slack_exact": "1/101201126653655309176247673359458653524778324882071059178450679013715169783997673445980191850718562247593538932158405955694904368692896738433506699970369254960758712138283180682233453871046608170619883839236372534281003741712346349309051677824579778170405028256179384776166707307615251266093163754323003131653853870546747392", "ok": true } } }, "total": 936, "passed": 912 } exact_windows.py on p5rig_oldmasks.py: exit status 1 ==== end: p5_window_runs.txt ==== file: exact_shipped.json | original SHA-256 223ed745845730c3b475875f8c631bd4461e8282d4b58739727890c0401162f0 | shipped SHA-256 223ed745845730c3b475875f8c631bd4461e8282d4b58739727890c0401162f0 | trailing newline: yes | as written by the run { "M": 120, "source": "sep_p5/p5rig.py", "groups": { "exact_step_P": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "exact_step_P", "where": { "key": [ 1, 1 ], "l": 6, "n": 58 }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_P11": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_P11", "where": { "l": 6, "n": 58, "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_Z_closed": { "count": 288, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": 1e-323, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 1e-323, "slack_exact": "1/101201126653655309176247673359458653524778324882071059178450679013715169783997673445980191850718562247593538932158405955694904368692896738433506699970369254960758712138283180682233453871046608170619883839236372534281003741712346349309051677824579778170405028256179384776166707307615251266093163754323003131653853870546747392", "ok": true } }, "paper_Z_interior": { "count": 432, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_interior", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 66, "c0": 59, "c1": 60, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.033898305084747, "upper": 1e-323, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 1e-323, "slack_exact": "1/101201126653655309176247673359458653524778324882071059178450679013715169783997673445980191850718562247593538932158405955694904368692896738433506699970369254960758712138283180682233453871046608170619883839236372534281003741712346349309051677824579778170405028256179384776166707307615251266093163754323003131653853870546747392", "ok": true } } }, "failures": [], "total": 936, "passed": 936 } ==== end: exact_shipped.json ==== file: exact_oldmasks.json | original SHA-256 779600f87719308103d8685609fb51302f57a9fc5231a80a936883ef745930bd | shipped SHA-256 779600f87719308103d8685609fb51302f57a9fc5231a80a936883ef745930bd | trailing newline: yes | as written by the run { "M": 120, "source": "p5rig_oldmasks.py", "groups": { "exact_step_P": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "exact_step_P", "where": { "key": [ 1, 1 ], "l": 6, "n": 58 }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_P11": { "count": 108, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_P11", "where": { "l": 6, "n": 58, "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -5e-324, "upper": 5e-324, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 5e-324, "slack_exact": "1/202402253307310618352495346718917307049556649764142118356901358027430339567995346891960383701437124495187077864316811911389808737385793476867013399940738509921517424276566361364466907742093216341239767678472745068562007483424692698618103355649159556340810056512358769552333414615230502532186327508646006263307707741093494784", "ok": true } }, "paper_Z_closed": { "count": 288, "failures": 24, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false } }, "paper_Z_interior": { "count": 432, "failures": 0, "smallest_slack": { "label": "paper_Z_interior", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 66, "c0": 59, "c1": 60, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.033898305084747, "upper": 1e-323, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": 1e-323, "slack_exact": "1/101201126653655309176247673359458653524778324882071059178450679013715169783997673445980191850718562247593538932158405955694904368692896738433506699970369254960758712138283180682233453871046608170619883839236372534281003741712346349309051677824579778170405028256179384776166707307615251266093163754323003131653853870546747392", "ok": true } } }, "failures": [ { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "13/240" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 1, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "7/120" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 2, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/20" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 2, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "13/240" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 6, "k": 2, "aidx": 65, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "7/120" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 12, "k": 1, "aidx": 71, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/10" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 12, "k": 1, "aidx": 71, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "5/48" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 12, "k": 1, "aidx": 71, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "13/120" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 12, "k": 2, "aidx": 71, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/10" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 12, "k": 2, "aidx": 71, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "5/48" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 12, "k": 2, "aidx": 71, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "13/120" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 18, "k": 1, "aidx": 77, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "3/20" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 18, "k": 1, "aidx": 77, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "37/240" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 18, "k": 1, "aidx": 77, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "19/120" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 18, "k": 2, "aidx": 77, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "3/20" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 18, "k": 2, "aidx": 77, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "37/240" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 18, "k": 2, "aidx": 77, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "19/120" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 23, "k": 1, "aidx": 82, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "23/120" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 23, "k": 1, "aidx": 82, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "47/240" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 23, "k": 1, "aidx": 82, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/5" }, "lower": -2.068965517241381, "upper": -1.9999999999999993, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -1.9999999999999993, "slack_exact": "-9007199254740989/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 23, "k": 2, "aidx": 82, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "23/120" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 23, "k": 2, "aidx": 82, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "47/240" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false }, { "label": "paper_Z_closed", "where": { "l": 23, "k": 2, "aidx": 82, "c0": 58, "c1": 59, "x": "1/2", "sigma": "1/5" }, "lower": -0.838962524603434, "upper": -0.6961053817462888, "reference_lower": 0.0, "reference_upper": 0.0, "slack": -0.6961053817462888, "slack_exact": "-3134979937843183/4503599627370496", "ok": false } ], "total": 936, "passed": 912 } ==== end: exact_oldmasks.json