\documentclass[11pt]{amsart} % \usepackage[T1]{fontenc} % \usepackage[utf8]{inputenc} \usepackage{ben} % \usepackage{microtype} % \hypersetup{ % pdftitle={On finite-time blow-up of the 2D inviscid Boussinesq equations}, % pdfauthor={Xi Chen, Hedong Hou, Haoling Xiang}, % pdfkeywords={Boussinesq equations, finite-time blow-up, smooth periodic data, Kelvin waves, inclined shear, pressure Hessian, two-point boundary value problem, Gevrey regularity} % } % \setlist[itemize]{topsep=4pt,itemsep=3pt,leftmargin=1.8em} % \setlength{\emergencystretch}{2em} % \allowdisplaybreaks[2] \title[2D Boussinesq finite-time blow-up]{On finite-time blow-up of the 2D inviscid Boussinesq equations} \author{Xi Chen} \address{Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, University of Basel, Spiegelgasse 1, CH-4051 Basel, Switzerland} \email{xi01.chen@unibas.ch} \author{Hedong Hou} \address{Department of Mathematics, ETH Z\"urich, R\"amistrasse 101, 8092 Z\"urich, Switzerland} \email{hedong.hou@math.ethz.ch} \author{Haoling Xiang} \address{Department of Mathematics, Huxley Building, South Kensington Campus, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom} \email{h.xiang23@imperial.ac.uk} \date{November 20, 2026} \subjclass[2020]{35Q35, 76B03, 35B44, 76B70} \keywords{Boussinesq equations, finite-time blow-up, Kelvin waves, inclined shear} \begin{document} \begin{abstract} We construct smooth odd periodic data for the 2D inviscid Boussinesq equations whose temperature gradient becomes unbounded at the origin in finite time. On an accelerating shear with inclination $\delta$, a wave amplifies its temperature gradient by a factor of at least $\exp(c/\sqrt\delta)$. At the first return of its vorticity to zero, the gradient points downwards with inclination asymptotic to $\delta/2$. We use the successive zeros of the leading wave vorticity to select return times on successively shorter intervals. An upper bound on the pressure Hessian permits correction of each periodic wave with both particle endpoints prescribed. A transverse Green function bounds the contribution of late forcing to the initial velocity by the inverse of the preceding amplification, yielding smooth initial data for the limiting solution. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Introduction} Consider the inviscid Boussinesq equations \begin{equation}\label{eq:mainpde} \tag{B} \begin{cases} \partial_t u + u \cdot \nabla u + \nabla p = \theta \bfe_2 \\ \partial_t\theta+u\cdot\nabla\theta=0 \\ \Div u=0 \\ u(0) = u_0, \quad \Div u_0 = 0, \quad \theta(0) = \theta_0 \end{cases} \end{equation} on the 2-dimensional torus $\bT^2=(\bR/2\pi\bZ)^2$. Here $u$ denotes the velocity, $\theta$ denotes the temperature, and $p$ denotes the pressure. Write $\bfe_1:=(1,0)$ and $\bfe_2:=(0,1)$. The temperature is constant on each particle path. Its gradient, however, can grow as the flow brings distinct temperature layers together. The odd symmetry is defined by central inversion, so $u(t,-x)=-u(t,x)$ and $\theta(t,-x)=-\theta(t,x)$. The equations preserve this symmetry, with the mean-zero pressure even. In particular, $u(t,0)=0$, and the particle at the origin remains there. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:main} There are odd, mean-zero $C^\infty$ initial data $(u_0,\theta_0)$ on $\bT^2$, with $\Div u_0=0$, whose unique smooth solution of \eqref{eq:mainpde} has maximal lifespan $[0,T_*)$, $00$, smooth away from the origin. Multiscale constructions for forced fluids include~\cite{CMZEuler,CMZIPM}. For Boussinesq, C\'ordoba, La\'in-Sanclemente and Mart\'inez-Zoroa~\cite{CLMZ} constructed a forced cascade, and Alp\"oge and Buckmaster~\cite{AlBu} proved blow-up with smooth forcing in both equations. Their Lemma~3.1 gives the affine Boussinesq wave equations used below, and their controlled rotation returns the wave vorticity to zero. Here the accelerating inclined shear produces the return without a control term. The wave calculation uses the shear-wave cancellation of Craik and Criminale~\cite{CC} and the short-wave equations of Lifschitz and Hameiri~\cite{LH}. The endpoint formulation draws on the geometry of incompressible flow~\cite{Arnold,EbinMarsden} and Brenier's least-action principle~\cite{Brenier}. The Euler construction in~\cite{OpenAIEuler}, also presented in~\cite{ZhengEuler}, uses an upper pressure-Hessian bound to control a two-endpoint problem. For incompressible porous media, Dai~\cite{Dai} uses such an upper bound to control the preparation of a new layer. Zheng~\cite{Zheng} combines inclined layers, one-sided profiles, terminal displacement conditions for phase means, and correction of a finite expansion. In the present endpoint problem the second-order transverse Green function estimates how late forcing contributes to the initial velocity. \subsection{Acknowledgments} This project began during Xi Chen and Haoling Xiang's visit to Zurich from 27 September to 2 October 2026. They thank ETH Zurich for its hospitality. Hedong Hou was supported by Simons Initiative of Geometry of Flows. \subsection{AI statement} The authors proposed the underlying mechanism and used ChatGPT (6.1 Sol) to assist with the detailed computations. \section{The mechanism and the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:main}}\label{sec:mechanism} At the stationary particle $x=0$ we follow the temperature gradient $\nabla\theta$ and the velocity gradient $\nabla u$. Consider a layer released from rest with $\nabla\theta=-G\nu$, where $G>0$ is the magnitude of the gradient and $\nu$ is the upward unit normal to the temperature level lines. Its horizontal component $\delta:=\nu\cdot\bfe_1$ is small and positive. Thus $\nu=(\delta,\sqrt{1-\delta^2})$ and $\delta$ is the sine of its angle from the vertical. The temperature decreases upwards, so cold fluid lies above warm fluid. Pressure balances the component of buoyancy normal to the layers. The tangential component makes neighboring layers slide past one another, creating a shear. A weak wave enters this shear with a horizontal wave vector. Where the wave carries warm fluid upwards, it reinforces the temperature perturbation that drives the upward motion. At the same time the shear turns the wave vector downwards. When its horizontal component changes sign, the horizontal temperature gradient of the wave changes sign with it, reversing the production of wave vorticity. The vorticity then decreases to zero. At this \emph{return}, the wave's velocity gradient vanishes and its temperature gradient points downwards. The shear has subtracted about $2\nu/\delta$ from the initial unit wave vector. The spacing of the wave fronts has therefore shrunk to about $\delta/2$ of its initial value, and their new upward normal has horizontal component about $\delta/2$. To first order in time this wave acts as a top-heavy layer released from rest, with a larger temperature gradient and a smaller tilt. Its shear turns the next wave. The velocity gradient left by the older layers is small on the time scale of this new layer. At fixed $G$, a smaller tilt weakens the shear and gives the wave more time in the initial regime where its growth rate is comparable to $\sqrt G$, the growth rate for horizontal layers. The temperature amplitude grows by a factor of at least $e^{c/\sqrt\delta}$, so a small incident wave can leave a gradient much larger than $G$. The return time is asymptotic to $2/(\delta\sqrt G)$. In the iteration $G$ grows fast enough that the successive return intervals have finite sum. The incident wavelength in the normalized affine model is $2\pi/N$. On the torus the background varies across a wavelength. A derivative falling on an older phase in place of the new one brings a factor of order $R/N$, where $R$ is the frequency scale of the preceding waves. All waves are already present at time zero. We choose $N$ so that the incident amplitude absorbs every fixed power of the frequency in the initial temperature. For the initial velocity the corresponding smallness follows from an estimate for the equation with prescribed particle endpoints. \subsection{A wave on an inclined shear} The unit tangent to the layers is $\nu^\perp:=(-\nu_2,\nu_1)$. The affine shear has velocity gradient $-tG\delta\,\nu^\perp\otimes\nu$. Superimpose a wave with an odd periodic profile of slope one at zero. Let $k(t)$ be its wave vector normalized by $k(0)=\bfe_1$. At the origin write $A(t)$ for its vorticity and $B(t)k(t)$ for its temperature gradient. Set $\beta:=G(\nu\cdot\bfe_2)$ and introduce the dimensionless time $\gamma(t):=\delta\sqrt\beta\,t$, where $t$ is the time since release. The shear gives $k(t)=\bfe_1-\gamma(t)^2\nu/(2\delta)$, and the amplitudes satisfy \[ \frac{\rmd A}{\rmd t}=k_1B,\qquad \frac{\rmd B}{\rmd t}=\frac{\beta A}{|k|^2},\qquad A(0)=0,\quad B(0)=\epsilon>0 . \] \begin{prop}[One-wave gain and return]\label{prop:onewave} For sufficiently small $\delta>0$, the first positive zero $t_\delta$ of $A$ is simple. At this return $B$ attains its unique maximum on $0\le \gamma\le3$, and, for absolute constants $c,C>0$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:mechanism-return} \gamma(t_\delta)=2+o(1),\qquad e^{c/\sqrt\delta}\le\frac{B(t_\delta)}{\epsilon}\le e^{C/\sqrt\delta}, \qquad |k(t_\delta)|=\frac{2+o(1)}{\delta}. \end{equation} The new upward normal $\nu_+:=-k(t_\delta)/|k(t_\delta)|$ has inclination $\delta_+:=\nu_+\cdot\bfe_1=(\tfrac12+o(1))\delta$ as $\delta\downarrow0$. For any $G_+>0$, some $0<\epsilon\le C\delta G_+e^{-c/\sqrt\delta}$ gives the wave increments at $(t_\delta,0)$ \[ \nabla\tiltheta=-G_+\nu_+,\qquad \nabla\tilu=0,\qquad \partial_t\nabla\tilu=-G_+\delta_+\,\nu_+^\perp\otimes\nu_+ . \] The wave's contribution to the pressure Hessian at the origin is negative semidefinite up to and including the return. \end{prop} In these variables the torque $k_1B$ reverses at $\gamma=\sqrt2$, and $A$ returns to zero at $\gamma=2+o(1)$. In the iteration $G>1$ and we choose $G_+:=G^{11/10}$, so the old gradient is smaller by a factor $G^{-1/10}$. \subsection{The periodic induction step} Set $t_0:=0$. For a large integer $m$, take $\delta_0:=(1+m^2)^{-1/2}$ and $\nu_0:=(\delta_0,\sqrt{1-\delta_0^2})$. Define the gradient magnitudes by \begin{equation}\label{eq:gradients} G_0:=\exp\bigl((\log(1/\delta_0))^2\bigr),\qquad G_{j+1}:=G_j^{11/10}. \end{equation} For $j\ge1$, let $t_j$ denote the return of the leading amplitude of wave $j$ on its parent. Write $-G_j\nu_j$ for its leading temperature-gradient increment there and set $\delta_j:=\nu_j\cdot\bfe_1$. The corresponding gradient of the exact periodic solution satisfies \eqref{eq:periodic-gradients}. The stage runs until the $j$th level stopping time \[ T_j:=t_j+\frac{3}{\delta_j\sqrt{G_j(\nu_j\cdot\bfe_2)}} . \] The next wave returns at $t_{j+1}0$. Its phase gives $|k(t_j)-\bfe_1|\le\delta_j^{10}$, with $k(0)=\bfe_1$ for the first wave. \begin{prop}[Periodic induction step]\label{prop:step} For sufficiently small $\delta_0$, the construction starts on $[0,T_0]$ from a smooth odd periodic shear at rest at $t=0$ with central temperature gradient $-G_0\nu_0$. Given a stage $j$ constructed on $[0,T_j]$, one can add a localized wave and obtain a smooth odd periodic solution $(u_{j+1},\theta_{j+1})$ of \eqref{eq:mainpde} on that interval. Its return satisfies $t_j1$ interpolate the two factors with Hölder exponents $2(l-1)/(k-1)$ and $2(l-1)/(l-k)$, taking $\infty$ at a zero denominator. For $l=1$ use Hölder directly. Gronwall gives the uniform bound on $[0,t_j]$ \cite[Lemma~3.2]{ChengXu} (see also~\cite{KatoPonce}). The projected equations bound one time derivative in $H^{s-1}$. Compact Sobolev embedding and Arzelà--Ascoli give a diagonal subsequence converging in $C([0,t_j];H^{s-1})$ for every $j,s$. Its limit solves \eqref{eq:mainpde} smoothly on $[0,T_*)$ with the limiting data. Testing the difference equations in $L^2$ gives the same differential inequality for the squared difference norm with the gradients of the second solution. Gronwall then gives uniqueness. Oddness gives mean-zero data. All flows fix the origin, and the subsequence converges in $C^1$ at each $t_j$. The sum of the errors at label zero and the lower bound from \eqref{eq:periodic-gradients} therefore give \[ |\nabla\theta(t_j,0)|\ge G_j-CG_{j-1}-2^{-j} \longrightarrow\infty . \] Since the return times approach $T_*$, the maximal smooth lifespan ends at $T_*$. \end{proof} \section{A wave on an inclined shear} We prove Proposition~\ref{prop:onewave} and quantify the change in the return time and gain when earlier waves perturb the shear. For any vector $k=(k_1,k_2)$ write $k^\perp:=(-k_2,k_1)$ and, for $k\ne0$, $\widehat k:=k/|k|$. We use $(\nabla u)_{ij}=\partial_j u_i$. The flow map $X(t,a)$ starts at $a$ and $F=\nabla_aX$ has determinant one. Along a trajectory a prime denotes time differentiation. For symmetric matrices, $P\preceq Q$ means that $Q-P$ is positive semidefinite, and $\lambda_{\max}^+(P)=\max(0,\lambda_{\max}(P))$. The constants in $\lesssim$ and $\sim$ are uniform in the stage and the frequencies. They may depend on fixed regularity indices. A polynomial bound in nonnegative $x_1,\ldots,x_m$ has the form $C(1+\sum_i x_i)^C$. Torus averages are normalized and $\Delta^{-1}$ annihilates constants. \subsection{The exact wave} Let $\nu=(\delta,\sqrt{1-\delta^2})$. For any smooth odd profile with $f'(0)=-G$, the fields \begin{equation}\label{eq:shear} \theta=f(\nu\cdot x),\qquad u=t\delta\theta\nu^\perp,\qquad p=(\nu\cdot\bfe_2)\int_0^{\nu\cdot x}f(r)\,\rmd r \end{equation} solve \eqref{eq:mainpde} on $\bR^2$. Indeed $u$ is tangent to the temperature layers, and the projection of $\theta\bfe_2$ onto $\nu$ is $\nabla p$. At the origin \begin{equation}\label{eq:shear-origin} \nabla\theta=-G\nu,\qquad \nabla u=-tG\delta\,\nu^\perp\otimes\nu, \qquad \nabla^2p=-G(\nu\cdot\bfe_2)\,\nu\otimes\nu . \end{equation} We call $\delta=(1+m^2)^{-1/2}$, $m\in\bN$, admissible. In this case $\nu/\delta=(1,m)$, so any $2\pi\delta$-periodic odd profile gives a solution on $\bT^2$. More generally, let $u_b=M(t)x$, $\theta_b=g(t)\cdot x$, $p_b=x\cdot\Pi_b(t)x/2$. These fields solve \eqref{eq:mainpde} on $\bR^2$ when $\tr M=0$, $g'=-M^Tg$, and $\Pi_b=\bfe_2\otimes g-M'-M^2$ is symmetric. Let $k'=-M^Tk$, $k(0)\ne0$. Then $(k^\perp)'=Mk^\perp$ and $\beta=-g\cdot k^\perp$ is constant. The amplitudes of vorticity and temperature solve \begin{equation}\label{eq:amp} A'=k_1B,\qquad B'=\frac{\beta A}{|k|^2}. \end{equation} \begin{lemma}[Exact wave]\label{lem:exactwave} Let $\psi$ be smooth, odd and $2\pi$-periodic with $\psi'(0)=1$, and let $\Psi$ be its mean-zero primitive. For $N>0$ and $z=Nk\cdot x$, the affine solution admits the exact increment \begin{equation}\label{eq:wave} \begin{aligned} \tilu&=\frac{A k^\perp}{N|k|^2}\psi(z),& \tiltheta&=\frac{B}{N}\psi(z),\\ \tilp&=\frac{q}{N^2|k|^2}\Psi(z),& q&=Bk_2-\frac{2A}{|k|^2}\,k\cdot Mk^\perp . \end{aligned} \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The background transports $z$, and $\tilu\cdot\nabla z=0$. With $b=Ak^\perp/|k|^2$, substitution leaves $B'=-b\cdot g$ and $b'+Mb+qk/|k|^2=B\bfe_2$. The first identity is \eqref{eq:amp}. Taking the scalar product of the second with $k^\perp$ gives $A'=Bk_1$, since $b$ is parallel to $k^\perp$ and $(k^\perp)'=Mk^\perp$. The scalar product with $k$ gives $q=Bk_2-2k\cdot Mb$, since $(k\cdot b)'=0$. \end{proof} At the origin the increments are \begin{equation}\label{eq:wave-origin} \nabla\tiltheta=Bk,\qquad \nabla\tilu=A\,\widehat{k}^\perp\otimes\widehat{k},\qquad \nabla^2\tilp=q\,\widehat{k}\otimes\widehat{k} . \end{equation} For a general smooth flow use $M=\nabla u$, $g=\nabla\theta$ along each trajectory and $k=F^{-T}n$, where $n$ is the initial covector. The leading increments for the material phase $Nn\cdot a$ are \begin{equation}\label{eq:updates} \begin{aligned} F&\mapsto F\bigl(I+\psi' c\,n^\perp\otimes n\bigr), &c(t)&=\int_0^t\frac{A}{|k|^2}\,\rmd s,\\ \nabla\theta&\mapsto\nabla\theta+\psi' Bk, &\nabla u&\mapsto\nabla u+\psi'A\,\widehat{k}^\perp\otimes\widehat{k},\\ \nabla^2p&\mapsto\nabla^2p+\psi'q\,\widehat{k}\otimes\widehat{k} . \end{aligned} \end{equation} Here $\psi'=\psi'(Nn\cdot a)$ and $\beta c=B(t)-B(0)$. These are the terms of order one in the gradient and deformation of a periodic wave (Section~\ref{sec:step}). Indeed $Fn^\perp=k^\perp$, so in material coordinates the velocity gradient increment is a multiple of the fixed square-zero matrix $n^\perp\otimes n$. This gives the first line by integration. The other three increments are the derivatives in \eqref{eq:wave}. \subsection{The return} For the shear \eqref{eq:shear-origin}, take $k(0)=\bfe_1$, $A(0)=0$ and $B(0)=\epsilon>0$. Now $\beta=G(\nu\cdot\bfe_2)$ and $k\cdot\nu^\perp=-\nu\cdot\bfe_2$ is constant. With $\gamma:=\delta\sqrt\beta\,t$ one obtains \begin{equation}\label{eq:vclock} k=\bfe_1-\frac{\gamma^2}{2\delta}\nu,\qquad P_\delta(\gamma)=\delta^2|k|^2=\frac{\gamma^4}{4}-\delta^2\gamma^2+\delta^2 . \end{equation} In rescaled time, with $B_\gamma=\rmd B/\rmd \gamma$, \eqref{eq:amp} becomes \begin{equation}\label{eq:ampv} (P_\delta B_\gamma)_\gamma=(1-\gamma^2/2)B,\qquad P_\delta B_\gamma=\delta\sqrt\beta\,A,\qquad B_\gamma(0)=0 . \end{equation} \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:onewave}] Normalize $B(0)=1$. The flux $P_\delta B_\gamma$ is positive up to $\gamma=\sqrt2$ by \eqref{eq:ampv}, so $B$ increases there. On $0\le \gamma\le\sqrt\delta$ one has $P_\delta\le5\delta^2/4$ and $1-\gamma^2/2\ge1/2$. Integrating twice and iterating the positive integral inequality gives $B(\gamma)\ge\cosh(\sqrt{2/5}\,\gamma/\delta)$. At $\gamma=\sqrt\delta$ this is at least $e^{c/\sqrt\delta}$, and $B$ keeps increasing until the return. For the upper bound use $\rmd\tau=\rmd \gamma/\sqrt{P_\delta}$. The system for $(B,\sqrt{P_\delta}B_\gamma)$ has bounded coefficients on $[0,3]$, since $P_\delta\sim\delta^2+\gamma^4$ and $|P_\delta'|/\sqrt{P_\delta}\le C$. This interval has $\tau$-length at most $C\int_0^3(\delta+\gamma^2)^{-1}\rmd \gamma\le C/\sqrt\delta$. Gronwall's inequality gives the upper bound. To locate the zero, normalize instead by $B(1)$. The ratio lies in $(0,1]$ on $(0,1]$, and its derivative is bounded at some point of $[1/3,1/2]$ by the mean value theorem. On compact subintervals of $(0,3]$ the normalized solution and its flux therefore converge along subsequences to $g$ and $\gamma^4g'/4$. Here $g'=\rmd g/\rmd\gamma$ and \[ (\gamma^4g'/4)'=(1-\gamma^2/2)g,\qquad g(1)=1 . \] The two solutions $\gamma^{-1}e^{\pm2/\gamma}$ form a basis. Boundedness at zero selects $g(\gamma)=\gamma^{-1}e^{2-2/\gamma}$, so the whole family converges on compact subintervals of $(0,3]$. Its limiting flux is $\gamma^2(2-\gamma)g/4$, as plotted in Figure~\ref{fig:return}. On $[\sqrt2,3]$ the original amplitude is positive and its flux is strictly decreasing. Thus the flux vanishes exactly once there, at $\gamma=2+o(1)$. Since $A'=k_1B<0$ at the zero, it is simple. Formula \eqref{eq:vclock} gives $k_1\to-1$ and $\delta k_2\to-2$ at return. Rescale the unit solution so that $B(t_\delta)|k(t_\delta)|=G_+$. The three gradient identities follow from \eqref{eq:wave-origin} and $A'(t_\delta)=B(t_\delta)k_1(t_\delta)=-G_+\delta_+$. Finally $k\cdot Mk^\perp=tG\delta(k\cdot\nu^\perp)^2\ge0$ and $k_2\le0$. Since $A\ge0$ and $B>0$ before return, \eqref{eq:wave} gives the pressure sign. \end{proof} \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \begin{tikzpicture}[x=1.83cm,y=0.78cm,font=\small] \begin{scope} \draw[->] (0,-2.05)--(0,1.36); \draw[->] (0,0)--(2.65,0) node[right] {$\gamma$}; \draw[gray,dotted] (2,0)--(2,-1); \draw[thick,domain=0:2.43,samples=50] plot (\x,{1-\x*\x/2}); \draw (-.04,1)--(.04,1) node[left,xshift=-3pt] {$1$}; \node[below left] at (0,0) {$0$}; \node[below left] at (1.4142,0) {$\sqrt2$}; \node[above] at (2,0) {$2$}; \node[right] at (.12,1.34) {Horizontal wave number}; \end{scope} \begin{scope}[xshift=5.9cm,y=2.12cm] \draw[->] (0,-.82)--(0,.53); \draw[->] (0,0)--(2.65,0) node[right] {$\gamma$}; \draw[gray,dotted] (1.4142,0)--(1.4142,.370); \draw[thick,domain=.03:2.43,samples=120] plot (\x,{\x*(2-\x)*exp(2-2/\x)/4}); \node[below left] at (0,0) {$0$}; \node[below] at (1.4142,0) {$\sqrt2$}; \node[above right] at (2,0) {$2$}; \node[right] at (.12,.51) {Wave vorticity}; \end{scope} \end{tikzpicture} \caption{The horizontal wave number vanishes at $\gamma=\sqrt2$ (left). The vorticity is then maximal and returns to zero at $\gamma=2+o(1)$. The right panel shows its limit in the normalization $\delta\sqrt\beta\,A/B(1)$, with $B(1)$ evaluated at $\gamma=1$.}\label{fig:return} \end{figure} \subsection{Comparison along a trajectory} Let $M=\nabla u$, $g=\nabla\theta$ and $\Pi=\nabla^2p$ along a trajectory of a smooth solution. Differentiating the momentum equation gives \begin{equation}\label{eq:hessian-trajectory} M'+M^2+\Pi=\bfe_2\otimes g . \end{equation} \begin{lemma}[Transverse equation]\label{lem:transverse} For a wave \eqref{eq:amp} with $k'=-M^Tk$, its gradient amplitude $d=|k|B$ solves \begin{equation}\label{eq:transverse} d''=\bigl(|\widehat{k}'|^2-\widehat{k}^\perp\cdot\Pi\widehat{k}^\perp\bigr)d . \end{equation} Replacing $(M,g)$ by $(M+A\widehat{k}^\perp\otimes\widehat{k},g+Bk)$ in \eqref{eq:hessian-trajectory} replaces $\Pi$ by $\Pi+q\widehat{k}\otimes\widehat{k}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Writing $w=k^\perp$, one has $w'=Mw$ and $w''=-\Pi w-\beta\bfe_2$. The identity $|w|''=\widehat{w}\cdot w''+|w|\,|\widehat{w}'|^2$ gives \[ |k|''=|k|\bigl(|\widehat{k}'|^2-\widehat{k}^\perp\cdot\Pi\widehat{k}^\perp\bigr) -\beta k_1/|k|. \] Using $(|k|^2 B')'=\beta k_1B$ in $(|k|B)''$ cancels the last term. For the second assertion put $b=Ak^\perp/|k|^2$. Since $(b\otimes k)^2=0$ and $k'=-M^Tk$, the pressure increment equals $(B\bfe_2-b'-Mb)\otimes k=q\,\widehat{k}\otimes\widehat{k}$ by the two projections in Lemma~\ref{lem:exactwave}. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[Comparison]\label{lem:compare} Let $A(0)=0$, $B(0)>0$, $\lambda(t)=\lambda^+_{\max}(\Pi(t))$. If \begin{equation}\label{eq:budget-traj} T|M(0)|+\int_0^T(T-s)\lambda(s)\,\rmd s\le\tfrac12 , \end{equation} then for $0\le s\le t\le T$, \[ 00$ and $B(a)k(a)=-G\nu$. Suppose its parent gradients $M_o,g_o$ satisfy $|M_o|\le\eta\sqrt G$ and $|g_o|\le\eta G$ on $[a,T]$, with $\eta\le\delta^3/C$ for an absolute constant $C$. Then the updated gradients $M=M_o+A\widehat{k}^\perp\otimes\widehat{k}$, $g=g_o+Bk$ satisfy \[ \begin{aligned} |M/\sqrt G+s\delta\,\nu^\perp\otimes\nu|&\le C\eta/\delta^2, & |g/G+\nu|&\le C\eta/\delta,\\ |A|&\le C\sqrt G, & |Bk|&\le4G . \end{aligned} \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The interval has length $O((\delta\sqrt G)^{-1})$. Integrating $k'=-M_o^Tk$ gives $k/|k(a)|=-\nu+O(\eta/\delta)$, so $|k_1|\le2\delta |k(a)|$. As long as $|B|\le2B(a)$, the equation $A'=k_1 B$ and $B(a)|k(a)|=G$ give $|A|\le C\sqrt G$. Then $B'=-(g_o\cdot k^\perp)A/|k|^2$ gives $|B/B(a)-1|\le C\eta/\delta$, closing the bound by continuity. In particular $A'/G=-\delta+O(\eta/\delta)$. Integrating once more yields $A/\sqrt G=-s\delta+O(\eta/\delta^2)$. Substitution in $M$ and $g$ proves the assertions. \end{proof} \begin{prop}[Return under perturbations]\label{prop:return} For sufficiently small $\delta$, suppose the gradients $M,g$ of a smooth solution on a stationary trajectory satisfy \begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\alph*)}] \item $|M/\sqrt G+s\delta\,\nu^\perp\otimes\nu|+|g/G+\nu| \le\delta^{10}$ on $[a,T]$, \item \eqref{eq:budget-traj} on $[0,T]$ and $|M(0)|+\int_0^T\lambda^+_{\max}(\Pi)\,\rmd t\le\delta\sqrt G$. \end{enumerate} Let $A(0)=0$, $B(0)>0$, $|k(a)-\bfe_1|\le\delta^{10}$. Then $A$ has a first zero $a_+$ after $a+G^{-1/2}$, with $a_+0$ and $\sigma=G^{-1/2}B'(a)/B(a)\ge-3\delta$, since $|\partial_t\log|k||\le|M|$ and $|M(a)|\le\delta^{10}\sqrt G$. For $0\le s\le1$ the equation $(|k|^2 B_s)_s=(\beta/G)k_1B$ converges, in first-order form, to $B_{ss}=B$. Its normalized solutions with data $(1,0)$ and $(0,1)$ converge in $C^1$ to $\cosh s$ and $\sinh s$. Their combination with coefficients $1,\sigma$ therefore has positive value and derivative at $s=1$, uniformly for $\sigma\ge-3\delta$. For $1\le s\le c/\sqrt\delta$, one has $|k|^2\le2$ and $(\beta/G)k_1\ge1/4$. Two integrations give $B(s)\ge B|_{s=1}\cosh((s-1)/\sqrt8)$. Normalize $B$ by $B|_{\gamma=1}$. On each compact subinterval of $(0,3]$ the coefficients in \eqref{eq:ampv-pert} converge to those of \eqref{eq:ampv} at $\delta=0$. Starting at $s=1$ the normalized amplitude is positive and increasing through $\gamma=1$. Its flux is bounded at some point of $[1/3,1/2]$ by the mean value theorem and the bound on $\delta^2|k|^2$. The compactness and uniqueness argument of Proposition~\ref{prop:onewave} gives the same limit $(g,\gamma^2(2-\gamma)g/4)$, $g=e^{2-2/\gamma}/\gamma$. The flux is positive from $s=1$ to $\gamma=3/2$ by monotonicity away from $\sqrt2$ and convergence near $\sqrt2$. Thereafter it is strictly decreasing since $B>0$ and $k_1<0$. Its unique zero has $\gamma=2+o(1)$ and $A'=k_1B<0$. The covector estimate gives the outgoing inclination. The lower gain follows from monotonicity up to return and $\sup_{t\le a+G^{-1/2}}d(t)\le2d(a+G^{-1/2})$. On $[a_+,T]$ we have $B(t)\sim B(a_+)$ and $|k|\sim\delta^{-1}$. Before return, $d(t)\le2d(a_+)$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:compare}. Finally, $k\cdot Mk^\perp/\sqrt G=s\delta(k\cdot\nu^\perp)^2 +O(\delta^8)$ with $k\cdot\nu^\perp=-\nu\cdot\bfe_2+O(\delta^7)$. For $s\ge1$ this is positive, and $k_2<0$ by \eqref{eq:vclock} and the covector estimate. Thus $q<0$ until return. Thereafter $Bk_2\le-cB(a_+)/\delta$, whereas the other term of $q$ has magnitude at most $CB(a_+)\delta$, since $|A|\le CB(a_+)/(\delta\sqrt G)$, $|k|\sim\delta^{-1}$ and $|k\cdot Mk^\perp|\le C\sqrt G$. \end{proof} \section{Pressure and the endpoint problem}\label{sec:pressure} \subsection{Coercivity and the initial velocity} Prescribing the two endpoints of a particle path leads to an energy estimate for its displacement. The positive part of the pressure Hessian controls this energy through a one-dimensional inequality in time. In the following statements $\Pi$ may be any smooth symmetric matrix field evaluated along a smooth area-preserving path $X(t,a)$ with $X(0,a)=a$. Integrals in $a$ are over $\bT^2$. \begin{lemma}[Endpoint coercivity]\label{lem:coercive} If \[ \kappa=1-\sup_a\int_0^T \frac{t(T-t)}{T}\, \lambda^+_{\max}(\Pi(t,a))\,\rmd t>0 , \] then for every $Y\in H^1_0((0,T);L^2)$, \[ \int_0^T\!\!\int (|Y_t|^2-Y\cdot\Pi Y)\,\rmd a\,\rmd t \ge\kappa\int_0^T\!\!\int |Y_t|^2\,\rmd a\,\rmd t . \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} At each label, $Y(t)=\int_0^T(\I_{[0,t]}(s)-t/T)Y_s(s)\,\rmd s$. The squared $L^2$ norm of the kernel is $t(T-t)/T$. Apply Cauchy--Schwarz and integrate the resulting bound against $\lambda^+_{\max}(\Pi)$. \end{proof} For stage $j$, let $T_j\le T_0$ be the endpoint in \eqref{eq:window}. The bound \begin{equation}\label{eq:budget} b_j=T_0^2\sup\lambda^+_{\max}(\nabla^2p_j) +T_0\sup|\nabla u_j(0)|\le\tfrac18 \end{equation} implies both \eqref{eq:budget-traj} and $\kappa\ge 1-b_j/6$ on each trajectory. The suprema range over all positions and, for the pressure, all times in $[0,T_j]$. Let $F=\nabla_a X$ and set $Y=Fw$. By change of variables, $Y\circ X^{-1}$ is divergence free in space precisely when $w$ is divergence free in the labels. The linear endpoint problem is \begin{equation}\label{eq:jacobi} Y_{tt}+\Pi Y+F^{-T}\nabla_a\pi=f,\qquad \nabla_a\cdot w=0,\qquad w(0)=w(T)=0 . \end{equation} Testing against $Fz$ for divergence-free $z\in H^1_0((0,T);L^2)$ gives \begin{equation}\label{eq:jacobi-weak} \cB(w,z)=\int_0^T\!\!\int \bigl[(Fw)_t\cdot(Fz)_t-\Pi Fw\cdot Fz\bigr]\,\rmd a\,\rmd t =-\int_0^T\!\!\int f\cdot Fz\,\rmd a\,\rmd t . \end{equation} \begin{lemma}[Linear endpoint problem]\label{lem:linear} For $\kappa>0$ and $f\in L^2$, \eqref{eq:jacobi-weak} has a unique solenoidal solution $w\in H^1_0((0,T);L^2)$, and \[ \|w\|_{H^1_t L^2}\le \frac{T}{\kappa}\|F^{-1}\|_\infty \bigl(1+T+T\|F_t\|_\infty\|F^{-1}\|_\infty\bigr)\|f\|_{L^2}. \] If $\bP$ is the Leray projection in the labels, the flux $\Phi=\bP(F^TY_t)$ satisfies \begin{equation}\label{eq:flux-eq} \Phi_t=\bP(F^Tf+F_t^TY_t-F^T\Pi Y). \end{equation} Both $Y_t$ and $w_t$ are continuous in time with values in $L^2$, and $Y_t(0)=w_t(0)=\Phi(0)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since $w=F^{-1}Y$ and $w_t=F^{-1}(Y_t-F_tw)$, the inequality $\|Y\|_{L^2}\le T\|Y_t\|_{L^2}$ controls $\|w\|_{H^1_tL^2}$ by $\|Y_t\|_{L^2}$ with the displayed deformation factor. Lemma~\ref{lem:coercive} gives coercivity in $w$, so Lax--Milgram gives a unique solution. Testing with $w$ gives $\kappa\|Y_t\|_{L^2}^2\le\|f\|_{L^2}\|Y\|_{L^2}$ and hence the bound. Expanding $(Fz)_t$ gives \eqref{eq:flux-eq} distributionally. Its right side belongs to $L^2$, hence $\Phi$ is continuous. On solenoidal fields the operator $\bP F^TF$ is bounded below by $\|F^{-1}\|_\infty^{-2}$ as a quadratic form. Thus $w_t=(\bP F^TF)^{-1}(\Phi-\bP F^TF_tw)$ is continuous, as is $Y_t=Fw_t+F_tw$. At time zero $F=I$ and $w=0$. \end{proof} To recover the Eulerian perturbation of an exact background $(U,\Theta)$, write $D_t=\partial_t+U\cdot\nabla$. Its linearized equations are \begin{equation}\label{eq:linearized} D_t v+v\cdot\nabla U+\nabla p'=h\bfe_2+f_u,\qquad D_t h+v\cdot\nabla\Theta=f_\theta,\qquad \nabla\cdot v=0 . \end{equation} The displacement satisfies $Y_t=v\circ X+(\nabla U\circ X)Y$. Since $(h\circ X+(\nabla\Theta\circ X)\cdot Y)_t=f_\theta\circ X$, differentiation of the displacement equation and \eqref{eq:hessian-trajectory} give \eqref{eq:jacobi} with \begin{equation}\label{eq:recover} \begin{gathered} H=h(0)+\int_0^t f_\theta\circ X\,\rmd s,\qquad f=f_u\circ X+H\bfe_2,\\ v\circ X=Fw_t,\qquad h\circ X=H-\nabla_a\Theta(0)\cdot w . \end{gathered} \end{equation} These identities also recover a solution of \eqref{eq:linearized} from the endpoint solution. The condition $Y(T)=0$ determines $v(0)=\Phi(0)$. \subsection{Periodic profiles and the initial shear} An amplifying wave lowers the pressure Hessian at its centre. We choose its periodic profile so that at other phases the opposite increment is small. \begin{lemma}[One-sided profiles]\label{lem:onesided} For each integer $m\ge2$ there is an odd trigonometric polynomial $\psi_m$ of degree $m-1$ with $\psi'_m(0)=1$ and $-1/(m-1)\le\psi'_m\le1$. Its derivative has nonnegative Fourier coefficients summing to one. For every symmetric matrix $\Pi$, unit vector $e$ and real $q$, \[ \lambda_{\max}(\Pi+\psi'_m q\,e\otimes e) \le \max\{\lambda_{\max}(\Pi),\lambda_{\max}(\Pi+q\,e\otimes e)\} + |q|/(m-1). \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Use the Fej\'er kernel $K_m(z):=m^{-1}|\sum_{l=0}^{m-1}e^{ilz}|^2$. Define $\psi_m$ by $\psi_m(0)=0$ and $\psi'_m=(K_m-1)/(m-1)$. The kernel is even, has mean one, attains its maximum $m$ at zero and has nonnegative Fourier coefficients. The matrix inequality follows by convexity of $\lambda_{\max}$ when $0\le\psi'_m\le1$ and by the operator norm bound $|q|/(m-1)$ otherwise. \end{proof} In particular $|\partial_z^r\psi_m'|\le(m-1)^r$ and its norm \eqref{eq:gevrey} is at most $2$ at radius $1/(2m)$. \begin{lemma}[Gevrey cutoffs]\label{lem:cutoff} Fix a Gevrey order $\sigma>1$. There are $a_\sigma>0$ and an even function $0\le\varphi\le1$, equal to one on $[-1/2,1/2]$ and supported in $[-7/8,7/8]$, with $|\varphi^{(r)}|\le a_\sigma^{-r}(r!)^\sigma$. A product $\prod_i\varphi(y_i/\ell)$ obeys the same bound for every multi-index of order $r$, with $a_\sigma\ell$ in place of $a_\sigma$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Convolve $\I_{[-3/4,3/4]}$ successively with the uniform probability measures on $[-a_\sigma j^{-\sigma},a_\sigma j^{-\sigma}]$, choosing $\sum_j a_\sigma j^{-\sigma}<1/8$~\cite[Lemma~3.3]{Rainer}. The $r$th derivative of the limit is bounded by differentiating the first $r$ measures once each, at total variation cost $a_\sigma^{-r}(r!)^\sigma$. For products use $\prod_i\alpha_i!\le |\alpha|!$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[Base shear]\label{lem:base} Let $\delta_0$ be admissible and sufficiently small, $\nu_0=(\delta_0,\sqrt{1-\delta_0^2})$, and $T_0=3/(\delta_0\sqrt{G_0\,\nu_0\cdot\bfe_2})$. There is an odd shear \eqref{eq:shear} released from rest, with $\nabla\theta(0,0)=-G_0\nu_0$, such that on $[0,T_0]$ \[ \begin{aligned} |\nabla\theta|+|\nabla^2p|&\le4G_0,& |\nabla u|&\le C\sqrt{G_0},\\ \lambda^+_{\max}(\nabla^2p)&\le CG_0\delta_0^4,& |F|+|F^{-1}|&\le C/\delta_0 . \end{aligned} \] In particular $b_0\le C\delta_0^2$. For $G_0$ as in \eqref{eq:gradients}, the norms \eqref{eq:gevrey} of these fields $F^{\pm1},\nabla u,\nabla\theta,\nabla^2p$ are at most $G_0^2$ at radius $\rho_0=a_\sigma\delta_0^5/2\ge G_0^{-1}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $\chi$ be the $2\pi$-periodization of $\varphi(\cdot/\delta_0^4)$, with mean $\bar\chi\le\delta_0^4$. Choose $f(0)=0$ and \[ f'(s)=-G_0\,\frac{\chi(s/\delta_0)-\bar\chi}{1-\bar\chi}. \] The derivative is even and has zero mean on a period, so $f$ is odd and $2\pi\delta_0$-periodic. Its derivative has magnitude at most $2G_0$ and positive part at most $2G_0\delta_0^4$. In \eqref{eq:shear}, $\nabla^2p$ is this derivative times $(\nu_0\cdot\bfe_2)\nu_0\otimes\nu_0$. The remaining bounds follow from \[ F^{\pm1}=I\pm\tfrac12 t^2\delta_0\,\nu_0^\perp\otimes\nabla\theta(0),\qquad \nabla u=t\delta_0\nu_0^\perp\otimes\nabla\theta . \] One label derivative of $\chi(\nu_0\cdot a/\delta_0)$ costs at most $(a_\sigma\delta_0^5)^{-1}$ in addition to the Gevrey factorial. At half this radius the norm is bounded by the geometric sum $2$. \end{proof} \section{The nonlinear endpoint problem} We correct the particle equation while preserving the endpoint maps. The estimates distinguish derivatives of amplitudes from derivatives of phases. \subsection{Derivatives on translated phases} For $M_i\in\bZ^2$ write $z_i=M_i\cdot a+\zeta_i$. Each $\zeta\in\bT^j$ defines a translated torus (a \emph{fiber}), with $\zeta=0$ giving the physical phases. For a function of $y=(a,z_1,\ldots,z_j)$, denote its restriction to this torus by $f_\zeta$. Then $(Df)_\zeta=\nabla_a f_\zeta$, where $D=\nabla_a+\sum_iM_i\partial_{z_i}$. For the Gevrey order $\sigma$ fixed above, set \begin{equation}\label{eq:gevrey} \|f\|_r=\sum_{m\ge0}\frac{r^m}{(m!)^\sigma} \max_{|\alpha|=m}\|\partial_y^\alpha f\|_\infty . \end{equation} The supremum includes time. Write $\|f\|_{r;E}$ if each derivative is measured in the fiber norm $E$ before taking the supremum over $\zeta$. Brackets $[f]_{r;E}$ omit the zeroth order. \begin{lemma}[Gevrey estimates]\label{lem:gevrey} For $00$ and $[g]_r\le g_*/2$, then $\|g^{-1}\|_r\le2/g_*$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} In Leibniz's rule the terms of orders $i,m-i$ carry total coefficient $\binom mi$, and $\binom mi(i!)^\sigma((m-i)!)^\sigma\le(m!)^\sigma$. The same estimate applied to $g g^{-1}=1$, first up to a finite order, gives $g_*[g^{-1}]_r\le[g]_r\|g^{-1}\|_r$. The two radius estimates follow from $(s/r)^m\le s/r$ for $m\ge1$ and $\sup_m(m+1)^\sigma(s/r)^m\lesssim_\sigma(1-s/r)^{-\sigma}$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[Fiber estimates]\label{lem:fibers} Let $R=1+\sum_i|M_i|$ and $d=j+2$. Write $\Delta_D=D\cdot D$ and take $\Delta_D^{-1}$ to vanish on constants on each physical fiber. \begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\alph*)}] \item The fiberwise Leray projection $\bP_D$, the fiber mean and $D\Delta_D^{-1}$ commute with all independent derivatives. Their operator norms on a fiber are those on $\bT^2$. \item $\|Df\|_{s;E}\le C_\sigma Rr^{-1} (1-s/r)^{-\sigma}\|f\|_{r;E}$. \item\label{item:fib-embed} For $h=r-s$, $\|f\|_s\le(C_\sigma d/h)^{C_\sigma d}\|f\|_{r;L^2(\bT^d)}$, where the last norm takes all $d$ variables in $L^2$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} On the Fourier mode $(m,\ell)$ the physical frequency is $m+\sum_i\ell_i M_i$. This proves the multiplier statement, including its action at zero frequency. The derivative estimate follows from Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey}. For the last inequality use Fourier Cauchy--Schwarz with $d+2$ derivatives and apply the derivative estimate on $d+2$ equal subdivisions of the radius loss $h$. \end{proof} \subsection{The inverse of the Jacobi operator} For divergence-free label fields, the coefficients in \eqref{eq:jacobi-weak} are the blocks of the matrix in \begin{equation}\label{eq:form-coeff} \cB(w,z)=\int_0^T\!\!\int \binom{w_t}{w}\cdot \begin{pmatrix} F^TF & F^TF_t\\ F_t^TF & F_t^TF_t-F^T\Pi F \end{pmatrix} \binom{z_t}{z}\,\rmd a\,\rmd t . \end{equation} \begin{lemma}[Gevrey regularity of the endpoint inverse]\label{lem:gevrey-inverse} Suppose on every fiber that $\cB(w,w)\ge L^{-1}\|w\|_{H^1_tL^2}^2$ and $F^TF\ge L^{-1}I$. Suppose each block in \eqref{eq:form-coeff} has positive-order norm at radius $r$ at most $c/L$ for a sufficiently small absolute $c$. Then \[ \|w\|_{r;H^1_tL^2}+\|w_t\|_{r;C_tL^2} \le C\|F^Tf\|_{r;L^2_tL^2}, \] where $C$ is polynomial in $L$, $T+T^{-1}$ and one plus the norms of the blocks at radius $r$. For continuous forces, $\|w_{tt}\|_{r;C_tL^2}\le C'\|F^Tf\|_{r;C_tL^2}$, with the same polynomial dependence for $C'$ and additional polynomial dependence on the time derivatives of the two upper blocks. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Independent translations carry fibers isometrically to fibers and commute with $D$. Take their difference quotients in the weak equation. Coercivity gives the differentiated equation at every finite order by weak compactness and preserves the solenoidal constraint. Apply coercivity to the differentiated form \eqref{eq:form-coeff} and sum over the orders. By the product estimate of Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey}, the terms in which a derivative hits a coefficient contribute at most $4c\|w\|_{r;H^1_tL^2}$ after multiplication by $L$. Absorption gives the $H^1_tL^2$ estimate. For $Y=Fw$ the flux $\Phi=\bP_D(F^TY_t)$ obeys \[ \Phi_t=\bP_D\bigl(F^Tf+F_t^TFw_t+(F_t^TF_t-F^T\Pi F)w\bigr). \] The same blocks thus bound $\Phi$ in $H^1_tL^2$, hence in $C_tL^2$. Solve \[ \bP_D(F^TFw_t)=\Phi-\bP_D(F^TF_tw) \] on solenoidal fields, using the lower bound on $F^TF$ and the same commutator estimate. This gives the asserted bound for $w_t$, including its initial trace. Differentiating this identity in time and using \eqref{eq:flux-eq} gives the stated bound for $w_{tt}$. \end{proof} \subsection{Correction of an approximate flow} With prescribed initial temperature $\theta_0$ and terminal map $X^0(T)$, the material equations are \begin{equation}\label{eq:endpoint} \begin{gathered} X_{tt}+(DX)^{-T}Dp=\theta_0\bfe_2,\qquad \det DX=1,\\ X(0,a)=a,\qquad X(T,a)=X^0(T,a). \end{gathered} \end{equation} Write $|f|_{r,m}=\|f\|_{r;C_tH^m(\bT^2)}$. Products satisfy the algebra estimate for $m\ge2$. Passing from a fiber $L^2$ estimate to $H^m$ on radius $r-h$ costs at most $C_{m,\sigma}(R/h^\sigma)^m$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:fibers}. Set \[ F=DX,\qquad g=F^{-T}Dp,\qquad \Pi=(Dg)F^{-1},\qquad \mathcal R(X,p)=X_{tt}+g-\theta_0\bfe_2 . \] Here $p$ is the material pressure, so $\Pi$ is its Eulerian Hessian pulled back by $X$. In $DX$ the derivative of the identity lift is $I$. \begin{prop}[Correction with prescribed endpoints]\label{prop:newton} Fix $m\ge5$ and $\sigma>1$. Let $X^0(0)=a$, let $X^0-a$ be periodic, and assume $\det DX^0=1$ on each fiber. Fix the terminal map $X^0(T)$ and the material temperature $\theta_0$. Suppose the coefficients at $(X^0,p^0)$ satisfy Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey-inverse} at radius $r\le1$, with a sufficiently small $c$. Let $P\ge2$ bound $L,T+T^{-1},r^{-1},R$, the norms $|X^0-a|_{r,m}$ including its first two time derivatives, and $|p^0|_{r,m},|\theta_0|_{r,m}$. Take pressures of fiber mean zero. If $|\mathcal R(X^0,p^0)|_{r,m}\le c_mP^{-C_m}$, there is an exact solution of \eqref{eq:endpoint} with \[ |X-X^0|_{r/2,m}+|p-p^0|_{r/2,m} \le C_m P^{C_m}|\mathcal R(X^0,p^0)|_{r,m}, \] including the first two time derivatives of $X-X^0$. Here $C_m,c_m$ may depend on $\sigma$. On the untranslated fiber, if $X^0$ and $\theta_0$ are odd in the label and $p^0$ is even, the corrected $X$ is odd and $p$ is even. \end{prop} \begin{proof} A tangent displacement $Y=Fw$ has $D\cdot w=0$. For a material pressure variation $\delta p$ put $\pi=\delta p-g\cdot Y$. Differentiating $g$ gives $\delta g=\Pi Y+F^{-T}D\pi$. The Newton equation is thus \eqref{eq:jacobi} with $f=-\mathcal R(X,p)$ and zero endpoint values. Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey-inverse} bounds $Y,Y_t,Y_{tt}$, while $D\pi=F^T(f-Y_{tt}-\Pi Y)$ determines the pressure up to its mean. After shrinking the radius by $h$ we obtain \begin{equation}\label{eq:newton-linear} |Y|_{s-h,m}+|\delta p|_{s-h,m} \le C_m(P/h)^{C_m}|\mathcal R(X,p)|_{s,m}, \end{equation} including $Y_t$ and $Y_{tt}$. To keep the inverse uniform at the current radius $s$, measure the distance to the starting pair by \[ \sum_{q=0}^2 |\partial_t^q(X-X^0)|_{s,m}+|p-p^0|_{s,m}. \] On area-preserving maps, $F^{-T}=\operatorname{cof}F$ is linear in $F$. The product estimates and the fiber embedding $H^m\hookrightarrow W^{2,\infty}$ therefore control the changes of the form blocks and of $F^TF$ by $C_mP^{C_m}$ times this distance, for distance at most one. Choosing the initial positive-order block bound with a factor of two to spare, and keeping the distance below $c_mP^{-C_m}$, preserves the coercivity and absorption bounds with a fixed change of constants. To restore the determinant, put $Z=Y+FDb$. The Piola identity and the two-dimensional determinant formula give $\det(F+DZ)=1+\Delta_D b+\det DZ$. Thus $Db=-D\Delta_D^{-1}\det D(Y+FDb)$, whose source has zero fiber mean by integration by parts. On radius $s-2h$ one additional derivative bounds $F,F_t,F_{tt}$ in the fiber $H^m$ norm by $C_m(P/h)^{C_m}$. The multiplier $D\Delta_D^{-1}$ maps $H^{m-1}$ to $H^m$. Thus the quadratic determinant map for $Db$ has Lipschitz constant at most $C_m(P/h)^{C_m}(|Y|_{s-h,m}+|Db|_{s-2h,m})$ on its ball about zero. It gives $Z-Y$ quadratic in $Y$ for a sufficiently small Newton step. Differentiating this fixed-point equation once or twice in time gives the same invertible linear part and quadratic sources. At both endpoints $Z=0$. The new map is locally invertible and has degree one. On area-preserving maps $F^{-T}=\operatorname{cof}F$ is linear in $F$. After the update $(Z,\delta p)$ the surviving residual is therefore \[ (Z-Y)_{tt}+\operatorname{cof}(D(Z-Y))Dp+ \operatorname{cof}(DZ)D\delta p . \] It is bounded on radius $s-3h$ by $C_m(P/h)^{C_m}$ times the squared old residual. Taking $s_k=r(1/2+2^{-k-1})$ and $3h_k=s_k-s_{k+1}$, the errors $e_k=|\mathcal R(X_k,p_k)|_{s_k,m}$ satisfy $e_{k+1}\le C_mP^{C_m}2^{C_m k} e_k^2$. After increasing $C_m$, the rescaled errors $C_mP^{C_m}2^{C_m(k+1)}e_k$ are bounded at each step by the square of the preceding one. For sufficiently small $P^{C_m}e_0$ the corrections therefore sum to the claimed bound by \eqref{eq:newton-linear}. Every step preserves odd symmetry. \end{proof} \section{Realization of a periodic wave}\label{sec:step} We construct an exact periodic wave with the four prescribed increments in \eqref{eq:updates}. Fix its parent flow $X$ on $[0,T]$. Its fields below are pulled back by $X$. The new angle $z$ has carrier $Nn\in\bZ^2$. Write $D_+=D+Nn\partial_z$, $k=F^{-T}n$, and $\mu=R/N$, where $R$ is the sum of the old frequencies plus one. \subsection{Recovering spatial gradients} \begin{lemma}[Material div--curl estimate]\label{lem:divcurl} Suppose $X$ is an area-preserving diffeomorphism on each fiber, $F=DX$, and $\|F\|_r+\|F^{-1}\|_r\le M$ for $00$ before taking its supremum on $\operatorname{supp}\chi$. The restriction is used only for functions supported there. \begin{lemma}[Weighted propagation]\label{lem:weighted} Under \eqref{eq:budget-traj}, let $C_*$ be the bound in Lemma~\ref{lem:compare}. If $[\beta/|k|^2]_s+[k_1]_s\le(4C_*T)^{-1}$, the solution with zero data of $(\vartheta,Y)_t=(\beta Y/|k|^2,k_1\vartheta)+S$ satisfies $\|(\vartheta,Y)\|_{s;W}\le2C_*T\|S\|_{s;W}$. The solution with initial data $(1,0)$ satisfies $\|(B_1,A_1)\|_{s;B_1}\le2C_*$ and $|\partial_i\log B_1|\le2C_*/s$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The propagator from $s_0$ to $t$ has norm at most $C_*B_1(t)/B_1(s_0)$, so Duhamel's formula gives the pointwise bound. Apply it to the independent derivatives and absorb the positive-order coefficient terms by Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey}. The derivative-free initial value contributes at most $C_*$ to the estimate for unit data. \end{proof} In every oscillatory source at least one factor is oscillatory. It retains the weight $W$, and all other factors can be estimated in the ordinary norm whenever $W$ is bounded. Thus the repeated use of Duhamel's formula costs only the single growth factor already present in the wave. \begin{lemma}[Change of labels]\label{lem:deformation}\label{lem:flows} Use a common radius $s\le1$ and suppose $K\ge1$ bounds $T,s^{-1},|n|,\|F\|_s$ and the norms of \[ V,\qquad \widetilde V/R,\qquad \mu^{-1}\bigl(V-n^\perp\epsilon\chi A_1\psi/|k|^2\bigr). \] If $\mu K^4\le c_\sigma$, the change of labels has size $O(TK/N)$, and on a fixed fraction of the radius \[ D_+X_+=F\bigl(I+c\psi'(z)n^\perp\otimes n\bigr)+O(\mu K^C), \qquad c=\epsilon\chi\int_0^t A_1/|k|^2\,\rmd s . \] All leading quantities are evaluated at the original labels. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Write $X_+=X(t,a+\Delta a)$, with the translated phases implicit. The relative label solves $\Delta a(0)=0$ and \[ \partial_t\Delta a=N^{-1}V\bigl(t,a+\Delta a, (z_i+M_i\cdot\Delta a)_{i\le j},z+Nn\cdot\Delta a\bigr). \] The velocities in independent variables are therefore $V/N$, $M_i\cdot V/N$ and $n\cdot\widetilde V/N$. The sum of their sizes divided by $s$, integrated up to $T$, is at most $T\mu K(1+|n|)/s\le2\mu K^4$. For a real periodic shift $h$ of the independent variables, the chain rule gives \[ \|g\circ(I+h)\|_u\le\|g\|_s \quad\text{if}\quad u+\sum_k[h_k]_u\le s . \] Indeed for a partition of $m$ derivatives into $q$ blocks of sizes $m_1,\ldots,m_q$, $q!\prod m_k!\le m!$. After division by $(m!)^\sigma$ each term is bounded by the corresponding coefficient in ordinary power-series composition. An identity derivative costs $u$ and picks one coordinate. The shift derivatives cost $\sum_k[h_k]_u$. The zeroth-order bound holds for every real shift. On $u=s/4$, integration along the segment between shifts of norm at most $s/8$ therefore gives a Lipschitz bound $C_\sigma s^{-1}\|g\|_s\sum_k\|h_k-\tilde h_k\|_u$, using Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey} for $\nabla g$ on half the radius. The integrated independent velocity has sum of norms at most $2s\mu K^4$. Hence its integral equation is a contraction on the ball of shifts of norm $s/8$ for sufficiently small $\mu K^4$. Each component has at most its own integrated velocity norm there. This proves the composition bound uniformly in the number of phases and in the terminal time, also for the backward flow. Finally $D_+\Delta a=D\Delta a+N\partial_z\Delta a\otimes n$. The old derivative costs $O(R/N)$ times the radius factors. Differentiating $N\Delta a=\int V$ and replacing the moving variables by the initial ones gives $N\partial_z\Delta a=c\psi' n^\perp+O(\mu K^C)$. The chain rule gives the claimed deformation. By \eqref{eq:amp}, $c=(B(t)-B(0))/\beta$ when $\beta\ne0$. \end{proof} \subsection{The uniform estimate for one wave} \begin{prop}[One periodic wave]\label{prop:realize} Fix $m\ge5$ and $\sigma>1$. For $T\le T_0$, assume the following on every parent fiber for some $M\ge 2+T_0+T^{-1}$ and $028(C_1+3)$ gives \[ N^{C_1}\mu^{J/4}\le N^{-3-(j+1)/28}. \] The four approximation errors are therefore at most $\mu U_1^C\le N^{-1/6+o(1)}\le N^{-1/8}$. Since $A(0)=0$, the leading velocity gradient at time zero equals the parent's. The exact budget thus increases by at most $2T_0^2\sigma_j+(T_0^2+T_0)N^{-1/8}\le2^{-j-6}$. This pressure bound holds throughout the construction interval $[0,T_j]$ for stage $j+1$, including the part beyond $T_{j+1}$. From \eqref{eq:updates} and \eqref{eq:amplitudes}, \[ K_{j+1}\le (1+CG_jG_{j+1})K_j+1,\qquad W_{j+1}\le C(1+G_{j+1})(1+K_j)W_j+1 , \] and $\sup|\nabla\theta_{j+1}|\le\sup|\nabla\theta_j|+CG_{j+1}+1$. Taking logarithms in the first recurrence and using $\sum_{i=0}^j\log G_i\le 11\log G_j$ gives $\log K_j\lesssim\log G_j$. Substitution in the second recurrence and the same summation give $\log W_j\lesssim\log G_j$. In particular the pressure Hessian is polynomially bounded in $G_j$ at each stage. To obtain the same kind of bound for the full Gevrey norms, reduce the positive-order part to at most one by shrinking the radius below $r/H^C$ and $\ell/4$, using Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey}\ref{item:gev-positive}. Take $\rho_{j+1}$ to be the smaller of $\ell/4$ and $c\rho_j H^{-2C}$, increasing the fixed $C$ if necessary. The positive-order norms are then at most one. Thus the norms used in choosing $M$ at the next step depend polynomially on the real bounds just proved, with an exponent independent of the radius. Write $L_j=\log(1/\rho_j)$ and $g_j=\log G_j$. Since $\rho_j/\ell\le[2^jG_{j+1}(1+T_0^2)]^C$ and $\log\log(2+NR)=O(1+j+\log\log G_0)$, the stated choice gives \[ L_{j+1}\le L_j+C\bigl(g_{j+1}+j+1+\log(1+L_j)\bigr) \le \tfrac{21}{20} L_j+C' g_{j+1}. \] Here $C\log(1+x)\le x/20+C''$ for $x\ge0$. Since $g_{j+1}=11g_j/10$, division by $g_{j+1}$ gives $L_{j+1}/g_{j+1}\le (21/22)L_j/g_j+C'$. Fix the exponents for $K_j$ and $W_j$ from their real recurrences first. With those exponents fixed, a bound for $L_j/g_j$ larger than both $L_0/g_0$ and $22C'$ is preserved at every step. This gives a uniform exponent for the reciprocal radius. On $I_{j+1}\subset I_j$, Lemma~\ref{lem:retire} bounds the preceding wave contributions by $C_0\sqrt{G_j}$ and $4G_j$. The old contributions are smaller by factors $(G_{j-1}/G_j)^{1/2}$ and $G_{j-1}/G_j$, respectively, so the constants in \ref{hyp:origin} can be fixed once. At $t_{j+1}$ the returning wave on the parent has temperature gradient $-G_{j+1}\nu_{j+1}$ and zero velocity gradient. Adding the parent gradients and the error in \ref{hyp:accuracy} gives \eqref{eq:periodic-gradients} for the exact solution. The even cutoff and odd profile preserve oddness on the zero translation. This closes the induction and proves Proposition~\ref{prop:step}\ref{item:stage-return}. \subsection{Effect on the preceding interval} \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:step}\ref{item:stage-earlier}] On $[0,t_j]$, \eqref{eq:cutoff-gain} and \eqref{eq:amplitudes} bound the two leading gradient increments in \eqref{eq:updates} by $G_{j+1}^C e^{-c/\sqrt{\delta_j}}$ on the support of the new wave. They vanish off this support. The right-hand side is at most $N_{j+1}^{-1/8}$ by \eqref{eq:cascade-scales}. Comparison at equal particle labels adds at most another $N_{j+1}^{-1/8}$ by \ref{hyp:accuracy}. Formula~\eqref{eq:frequencies} gives $2N_{j+1}^{-1/8}\le2^{-j-1}$ for every $j$ once $\delta_0$ is sufficiently small. This is \eqref{eq:periodic-early}. \end{proof} \section{Smoothness of the initial data} We prove Proposition~\ref{prop:step}\ref{item:stage-data} using the initial velocity selected by the correction with prescribed temperature and endpoints. Estimate~\eqref{eq:tree} bounds its first angular mean increment by $N_{j+1}^{-2} R_j N_{j+1}^{o(1)}$. Estimating its $C^r$ norm directly introduces a further factor $R_j^rN_{j+1}^{o(1)}$. We estimate its dependence on a fixed number of recent angles before taking derivatives on the physical torus. \subsection{The transverse Green function} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:green} Assume \eqref{eq:budget-traj}. Use the solution with $(B_1,A_1)(0)=(1,0)$ and put $d:=|k|B_1$ and $I(t):=\int_0^t d(s)^{-2}\,\rmd s$. For $(|k|^2 y')'-\beta k_1 y=f$ with $y(0)=y(T)=0$, the Green function is \[ G(t,s)=-B_1(t)B_1(s)\frac{I(\min(s,t))[I(T)-I(\max(s,t))]}{I(T)} . \] In particular \[ |k(0)|^2 y'(0)=-\int_0^TB_1(s)\frac{I(T)-I(s)}{I(T)}f(s)\,\rmd s . \] The kernel also satisfies \[ |G(t,s)|+|\partial_tG(t,s)| \le C\,\frac{d(\min\{s,t\})}{d(\max\{s,t\})} . \] On the diagonal take either one-sided derivative. The constant is polynomial in $1+T+T^{-1}$, $\sup(|k|+|k|^{-1})$, $\sup|d'/d|$ and $\sup|B_1'/B_1|$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Putting $y=B_1u$ gives $(d^2u')'=B_1f$. Two integrations with the endpoint conditions give the formulas. Lemma~\ref{lem:compare} yields $I(T)-I(s)\le4T/d(s)^2$. Integrating near zero gives $I(T)^{-1}\lesssim d(0)^2(T^{-1}+\sup|d'/d|)$. Together with $I(t)/I(T)\le1$ these imply the bound for $G$. When $ts$, differentiating the tail gives at most $B_1(s)B_1(t)d(t)^{-2}$. All other terms are bounded by $|B'_1(t)/B_1(t)|\,|G(t,s)|$. \end{proof} Let $d_h(t,\xi)$ be the unit-data amplitude for wave $h$ at the older labels $\xi$. On $\supp\chi_h$ use the time weight \[ w_h(t)=e^{-c/\sqrt{\delta_{h-1}}} +\min\{1,d_h(t,0)/d_h(t_h,0)\}. \] The early estimate gives $w_h(0)\le 2e^{-c/\sqrt{\delta_{h-1}}}$ for a common $c>0$. Comparison and localization yield \[ w_h(s)\lesssim w_h(t)\quad(s\le t),\qquad \frac{d_h(t,\xi)}{d_h(s,\xi)}w_h(s)\lesssim w_h(t)\quad(t\le s). \] For $k>h$ we also have $w_k\lesssim w_h$ on the common window. Use the early bound for wave $k$ up to $t_h$ and $d_h(t,0)\ge d_h(t_h,0)/2$ thereafter. For a forcing bounded by $w_h$, split the integral at $s=t$. Use the first weight inequality for $s\le t$ and the second for $s\ge t$. Lemma~\ref{lem:green} gives $|y|+|y'|\lesssim w_h$ on the same support. The equation gives the bound for $y''$ with an additional factor polynomial in the coefficients $|k|^{-2}$, $(|k|^2)'$ and $\beta k_1$. For the label derivatives write $p_0=|k|^2$, $b_0=\beta k_1$, and $L=p_0\partial_t^2+p_0'\partial_t-b_0$. Each $\partial^\alpha y$ has zero endpoint values and solves \[ L\partial^\alpha y=\partial^\alpha f- \sum_{0<\eta\le\alpha}\binom{\alpha}{\eta} \bigl((\partial^\eta p_0)\partial^{\alpha-\eta}y'' +(\partial^\eta p_0')\partial^{\alpha-\eta}y' -(\partial^\eta b_0)\partial^{\alpha-\eta}y\bigr). \] Use the scalar inverse bound for the triple $(y,y',y'')$ with the time weight $w_h$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:gevrey}\ref{item:gev-positive}, the radius can be reduced so the sum of the three positive-order coefficient norms is smaller than half the reciprocal of this bound. Summing with the Gevrey weights and absorbing the commutators gives the same time weight for all three fields. \subsection{One angular average} Write $z=z_i$, $n=n_i$, $l=n^\perp$, and let $D$ and $F,\Pi$ refer to the parent. With $D_+=D+N_i n\partial_z$, the leading matrices are \[ F_*=F(I+c\psi' l\otimes n),\qquad \Pi_*=\Pi+q\psi'\widehat{k}\otimes\widehat{k}. \] A leading solenoidal displacement has the form $V=V_0+l w$, with $D\cdot V_0=0$, $V_0$ independent of $z$, and $\langle w\rangle=0$, where brackets denote the $z$-average. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:anglesplit} Set $W=w+c\psi'(n\cdot V_0)$. The averaged Dirichlet form \eqref{eq:jacobi-weak} is the parent form on $V_0$ plus the transverse form \[ \int_0^T\big\langle |k|^2 W_t^2+\beta k_1 W^2\big\rangle\,\rmd t \] along each trajectory. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since $Fl=k^\perp$, we have $F_*V=FV_0+k^\perp W$ with $\langle W\rangle=0$. All cross terms average to zero, as does the pressure increment because $\widehat{k}\cdot F_*V=(n\cdot V_0)/|k|$ is independent of $z$. Integrate by parts using $W(0)=W(T)=0$ and $(k^\perp)_{tt}+\Pi k^\perp=-\beta\bfe_2$. \end{proof} For a material force $E=F_i^Tf$, substitution of $w=W-c\psi'(n\cdot V_0)$ gives the forces in the two forms: \[ \langle E\rangle-cn\langle\psi'(l\cdot E)\rangle,\qquad l\cdot E-\langle l\cdot E\rangle. \] \subsection{A finite number of recent angles} Fix a depth $m$ and consider stages $j-m0$ and all sufficiently large $j$, on some radius $\rho\ge C_j^{-1}$ it decomposes as $E=f+e$ with \begin{equation}\label{eq:component-bounds} \begin{gathered} \|e\|_\rho\le N^{-b},\qquad \|f_<\|_\rho\le C_j,\\ \supp f_h\subset\supp\chi_h,\qquad \|f_h\|_{\rho;w_h}\le C_j \quad (j-mp}\mu^l U^{l+2}\le 2C_j\mu^{p+1}U^{p+3}$. For fixed $p$, $U^{p+3}\le C_j$ by Section~\ref{sec:orders}. Thus $H$ has the component bounds to arbitrary accuracy. Let $S_tg$ be the value of a field $g$ at the relative particle labels at time $t$. The velocity of these labels in the independent variables is $\mu b(t)$, where \[ b=\bigl(V/R,(M_h\cdot V/R)_{h0$. Choose $p\eta_m>b+2$ and $a>b+2$, both independent of $j$. The unweighted inverse at level $i$ costs $C_j=N^{o(1)}$ on a common smaller radius. It supplies the remaining displacement and its first two time derivatives with norms at most $N^{-b}$. The finite sum has the component bounds on the same interval, which closes the induction. \end{proof} \subsection{Summation of the initial data} \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:step}\ref{item:stage-data}] Fix an integer $r\ge0$. The temperature increment \eqref{eq:incident} has $C^r$ norm at most $\epsilon_{j+1}N_{j+1}^{r+o(1)}$. Since $|n_{j+1}|\gtrsim1$, the early bound in \eqref{eq:cutoff-gain} at time zero and \eqref{eq:cascade-scales} bound these norms by $N_{j+1}^{-1}$ for all sufficiently large $j$. For the velocity write $N:=N_{j+1}$ and choose $m$ with $r(5/6)^{m+1}<7/6$. On the untranslated fiber the initial increment is the sum of the means $N^{-2-l}v_l(0)$ and the Newton correction. The correction has $C^r$ norm at most $N^{r-3-(j+1)/28+o(1)}$ by Section~\ref{sec:orders}, hence at most $N^{-1}$ for large $j$. Apply the mean-profile argument in the proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:resolved} once more, to wave $j+1$ with parent $j$ and endpoints $0,T_j$. The endpoint inverse needed here is the one already proved at level $j$. Thus each retained angular component of $v_l(0)/R_j^{l+1}$ has norm at most $C_je^{-c/\sqrt{\delta_{h-1}}}+N^{-b}$ for every fixed $b$ and each fixed $l$. For $j-mr+3$ bounds these components by $O(N^{-1})$ after $r$ physical derivatives for all sufficiently large $j$. Only frequencies from stages through $j-m$ enter the remaining component, so each physical derivative costs $R_{j-m}N^{o(1)}$. For fixed $l$ its contribution to the increment is at most \[ N^{-2}R_j(R_j/N)^l R_{j-m}^{\,r}N^{o(1)} =N^{-7/6-l/6+r(5/6)^{m+1}+o(1)} . \] The exponent at $l=0$ is negative by the choice of $m$. For the tail, the bound in \eqref{eq:tree} before angular decomposition is \[ N^{-2-l+(5/6)(l+1+r)+o(l+r+1)}\le N^{-l/12} \] for fixed $r$ and all sufficiently large $j,l$ up to the truncation order. Summing this geometric tail and the finitely many lower orders bounds the full $C^r$ increment by $O_r(N_{j+1}^{-c_r})$ for some $c_r>0$. By \eqref{eq:frequencies} this is at most $2^{-j}$ for all sufficiently large $j$. Absorbing the finitely many earlier increments in $C_r$ proves the asserted estimate on initial data. \end{proof} \subsection*{Data availability} No datasets were generated or analysed in this work. \begin{thebibliography}{99} \bibitem{AlBu} L. Alp\"{o}ge and T. Buckmaster, \href{https://cims.nyu.edu/~tristanb/boussinesq.pdf}{Blowup for the Boussinesq equations with smooth forcing}, preprint (2026). \bibitem{ApplebaumBanuelos} D. Applebaum and R. Ba\~{n}uelos, \href{https://doi.org/10.1512/iumj.2014.63.5317}{Martingale transform and L\'{e}vy processes on Lie groups}, \emph{Indiana Univ. Math. J.} \textbf{63} (2014), 1109--1138. See also \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/1206.1560}{arXiv:1206.1560}, Corollary~4.1. \bibitem{Arnold} V. Arnold, \href{https://doi.org/10.5802/aif.233}{Sur la g\'{e}om\'{e}trie diff\'{e}rentielle des groupes de Lie de dimension infinie et ses applications \`{a} l'hydrodynamique des fluides parfaits}, \emph{Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble)} \textbf{16} (1966), 319--361. \bibitem{Brenier} Y. Brenier, \href{https://doi.org/10.1090/s0894-0347-1989-0969419-8}{The least action principle and the related concept of generalized flows for incompressible perfect fluids}, \emph{J. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{2} (1989), 225--255. \bibitem{ChaeNam} D. Chae and H.-S. Nam, \href{https://doi.org/10.1017/s0308210500026810}{Local existence and blow-up criterion for the Boussinesq equations}, \emph{Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A} \textbf{127} (1997), 935--946. \bibitem{CH1} J. Chen and T. Y. Hou, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.07191v4}{Stable nearly self-similar blowup of the 2D Boussinesq and 3D Euler equations with smooth data I: analysis}, arXiv:2210.07191 (2022), revised 2026. \bibitem{CH2} J. Chen and T. Y. Hou, \href{https://doi.org/10.1137/23m1580395}{Stable nearly self-similar blowup of the 2D Boussinesq and 3D Euler equations with smooth data II: rigorous numerics}, \emph{Multiscale Model. Simul.} \textbf{23} (2025), 25--130. Revised version: \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.05660v3}{arXiv:2305.05660v3}. \bibitem{ChengXu} F. Cheng and C.-J. Xu, \href{https://doi.org/10.4208/jpde.v33.n3.4}{On the radius of spatial analyticity for the inviscid Boussinesq equations}, \emph{J. Partial Differential Equations} \textbf{33} (2020), 235--248. Preprint version: \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.09901v1}{arXiv:1911.09901v1}. \bibitem{CordFef} D. C\'{o}rdoba and C. Fefferman, \href{https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.061038998}{Behavior of several two-dimensional fluid equations in singular scenarios}, \emph{Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA} \textbf{98} (2001), 4311--4312. \bibitem{CLMZ} D. C\'{o}rdoba, A. La\'{i}n-Sanclemente, and L. Mart\'{i}nez-Zoroa, \href{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2025.110480}{Finite-time singularity via multi-layer degenerate pendula for the 2D Boussinesq equation with uniform $C^{1,\sqrt{4/3}-1-\varepsilon}\cap L^2$ force}, \emph{Adv. Math.} \textbf{480} (2025), Art.~110480. Corrected version: \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.20988v3}{arXiv:2505.20988v3}. \bibitem{CMZEuler} D. C\'{o}rdoba and L. Mart\'{i}nez-Zoroa, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08495}{Blow-up for the incompressible 3D-Euler equations with uniform $C^{1,\frac12-\varepsilon}\cap L^2$ force}, arXiv:2309.08495 (2023). \bibitem{CMZIPM} D. C\'{o}rdoba and L. Mart\'{i}nez-Zoroa, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.22920}{Finite time singularities of smooth solutions for the 2D incompressible porous media (IPM) equation with a smooth source}, arXiv:2410.22920 (2024). \bibitem{CC} A. D. D. Craik and W. O. Criminale, \href{https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1986.0061}{Evolution of wavelike disturbances in shear flows: a class of exact solutions of the Navier--Stokes equations}, \emph{Proc. Roy. Soc. London Ser. A} \textbf{406} (1986), 13--26. \bibitem{Dai} M. Dai, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.06712}{Finite-time blowup for 2D unforced IPM}, arXiv:2610.06712 (2026). \bibitem{ES} W. E and C.-W. Shu, \href{https://doi.org/10.1063/1.868044}{Small-scale structures in Boussinesq convection}, \emph{Phys. Fluids} \textbf{6} (1994), 49--58. \bibitem{EbinMarsden} D. G. Ebin and J. E. Marsden, \href{https://doi.org/10.2307/1970699}{Groups of diffeomorphisms and the motion of an incompressible fluid}, \emph{Ann. of Math. (2)} \textbf{92} (1970), 102--163. \bibitem{EJ} T. M. Elgindi and I.-J. Jeong, \href{https://doi.org/10.1007/s40818-020-00080-0}{Finite-time singularity formation for strong solutions to the Boussinesq system}, \emph{Ann. PDE} \textbf{6} (2020), Art.~5. \bibitem{EP} T. M. Elgindi and F. Pasqualotto, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.19780}{From instability to singularity formation in incompressible fluids}, arXiv:2310.19780 (2023). \bibitem{EPlin} T. M. Elgindi and F. Pasqualotto, \href{https://doi.org/10.1007/s00220-025-05367-6}{Invertibility of a linearized Boussinesq flow: a symbolic approach}, \emph{Comm. Math. Phys.} \textbf{406} (2025), Art.~261. \bibitem{KatoPonce} T. Kato and G. Ponce, \href{https://doi.org/10.1002/cpa.3160410704}{Commutator estimates and the Euler and Navier--Stokes equations}, \emph{Comm. Pure Appl. Math.} \textbf{41} (1988), 891--907. \bibitem{KPY} A. Kiselev, J. Park, and Y. Yao, \href{https://doi.org/10.2140/apde.2025.18.171}{Small scale formation for the 2-dimensional Boussinesq equation}, \emph{Anal. PDE} \textbf{18} (2025), 171--198. \bibitem{LH} A. Lifschitz and E. Hameiri, \href{https://doi.org/10.1063/1.858153}{Local stability conditions in fluid dynamics}, \emph{Phys. Fluids A} \textbf{3} (1991), 2644--2651. \bibitem{OpenAIEuler} OpenAI, \href{https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/315b36cd-ec98-4023-8342-93345194ece1/euler.pdf}{Finite time blowup for the Euler equation}, preprint (2026). \bibitem{PS} A. Pumir and E. D. Siggia, \href{https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.68.1511}{Finite-time singularities in the axisymmetric three-dimension Euler equations}, \emph{Phys. Rev. Lett.} \textbf{68} (1992), 1511--1514. \bibitem{Rainer} A. Rainer, \href{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.exmath.2021.12.001}{Ultradifferentiable extension theorems: a survey}, \emph{Expo. Math.} \textbf{40} (2022), 679--757. \bibitem{ZhengEuler} F. Zheng, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.02509}{Finite-time blowup of the Euler equation without forcing}, arXiv:2610.02509 (2026). \bibitem{Zheng} F. Zheng, \href{https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.06544v1}{Finite-time blowup of the IPM equation from smooth initial data without forcing}, arXiv:2610.06544 (2026). \end{thebibliography} \end{document}