\documentclass[11pt,a4paper]{article} \usepackage[T1]{fontenc} \usepackage{lmodern,amsmath,amssymb,amsthm} \usepackage[a4paper,margin=28mm]{geometry} \usepackage{microtype,xcolor} \usepackage[unicode,colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue!55!black,citecolor=blue!55!black,urlcolor=blue!55!black]{hyperref} \hypersetup{pdftitle={Failure of the Li--Liu spectral hypothesis R under Dirichlet GRH},pdfauthor={Yilin Liu},pdfkeywords={Goldbach representations, primes in short intervals, Buchstab function, Dirichlet GRH}} \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newcommand{\sg}{\mathfrak S} \newcommand{\grh}{\mathrm{GRH}} \newcommand{\ind}{\mathbf1} \newcommand{\dd}{\,\mathrm d} \setlength{\emergencystretch}{1em} \clubpenalty=10000 \widowpenalty=10000 \displaywidowpenalty=10000 \allowdisplaybreaks[1] \title{Failure of the Li--Liu spectral hypothesis R\\under Dirichlet GRH} \author{Yilin Liu} \date{21 November 2026} \begin{document} \makeatletter \begin{center} {\LARGE\bfseries\parbox{.99\linewidth}{\centering\@title}\par} \vspace{.8em} {\large\@author\par} \vspace{.4em} {\small\@date\par} \end{center} \makeatother \begin{abstract} Under Dirichlet GRH, the Li--Liu spectral hypothesis R fails. For every fixed \(D>0\) and \(0<\varepsilon<1\), each sufficiently large interval \([X,2X]\) contains at least \(X\exp(-(\log X)^\varepsilon)\) even integers \(N\) for which \(\sqrt N\,\|T_N\|>(\log N)^D\). We construct these integers unconditionally and use GRH only at the modulus \(N\) to obtain the norm bound. Each has at least \((\log N)^D\) representations as a sum of two distinct primes. The proof isolates a matrix entry in which the continuous model cancels and the two arithmetic terms have different Buchstab densities. \end{abstract} \section{Introduction} Li and Liu~\cite{LL} attach a compact self-adjoint operator \(T_N\) to each even \(N>e^{10}\) satisfying \(\grh(N)\), the Riemann hypothesis for the primitive Dirichlet \(L\)-functions of conductor dividing \(N\), including the Riemann zeta function. Their hypothesis R places every zero of an auxiliary spectral product on the line \(\Re s=1/2\) for every sufficiently large such \(N\). By their Theorem~6.1, this is equivalent at \(N\) to \begin{equation}\label{eq:R} \sqrt N\,\|T_N\|\le (\log N)^{3/2}\sqrt{\sg(N)},\qquad \sg(N)=2\prod_{p>2}\left(1-\frac{1}{(p-1)^2}\right) \prod_{\substack{p\mid N\\p>2}}\frac{p-1}{p-2}. \end{equation} \begin{theorem}\label{th:main} Fix \(D>0\) and \(0<\varepsilon<1\). There exists \(C=C(D,\varepsilon)\) such that, for every sufficiently large \(X\), at least \(X\exp(-(\log X)^\varepsilon)\) even integers \(N\in[X,2X]\) have both of the following properties. \begin{enumerate} \item \(N\) has at least \((\log N)^D\) distinct representations \(N=p+q\) by primes \(p(\log N)^D\). \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} Since \(\sg(N)\ll N/\varphi(N)\ll\log\log N\), taking \(D=2\) contradicts \eqref{eq:R} under global Dirichlet GRH. The first conclusion holds unconditionally on the same set of moduli. Maier's matrix method detects fluctuations of primes in short intervals~\cite{Maier}. Granville and Soundararajan developed the connection between intervals and progressions for general arithmetic sequences~\cite{GS}, and Pandey and Woo obtained related results for systems of prime linear forms~\cite{PW}. Here the shifts \(N-m\) and \(N+m\) occur in the same matrix entry. Their continuous contributions agree, while their progression averages sample Buchstab's function at two consecutive arguments. \section{Two opposite shifts} Write \(\Lambda\) for the von Mangoldt function. For a smooth real weight \(b\) supported in \((0,N/10)\), set \[ B_N(b)=\sum_{\substack{1\le m0\), \begin{equation}\label{eq:ap} \sum_{\substack{n\le y\\n\equiv r\bmod Q}}\Lambda(n) =\frac{y}{\varphi(Q)}+O(Xe^{-c\sqrt L}) \qquad(X/2\le y\le3X,\ (r,Q)=1). \end{equation} Second, for fixed \(v>4\), \(c_0>0\), and \(W\in C_c^\infty(0,\infty)\), \begin{equation}\label{eq:rough} \sum_{\substack{n\ge1\\(n,Q)=1}} W\!\left(\frac{n}{c_0z^v}\right) =\frac{c_0z^v}{\log z}\left(\omega(v)\int_0^\infty W(t)\dd t+o(1)\right), \qquad \frac{Q}{\varphi(Q)}\asymp\log z , \end{equation} where \(\omega\) is Buchstab's function. To choose \(Q\), use the exceptional prime of Ford, Green, Konyagin, Maynard and Tao~\cite[Cor.~6 and (7.2)]{FGKMT}. It is a number \(\ell\) equal to one or a prime \(\gg\log\log X\). Take \(Q=P/(P,\ell)\). Since \(\log Q\ll z=o(\sqrt L)\), their estimate (7.2) applies to each conductor \(r>1\) dividing \(Q\). Summing its primitive character bounds over \(r\mid Q\) costs at most \(Q/\varphi(Q)\ll\log z\), by \(\sum_{r\mid Q}\varphi(r)=Q\). Orthogonality and the ordinary prime number theorem give \eqref{eq:ap}, absorbing this factor in the exponential error. Passing from a primitive character to its induced character removes only prime powers above primes dividing \(Q\), of total weight \(O(\log Q\log X)\). Mertens' theorem gives the product estimate in \eqref{eq:rough}. For \(Q=P\), the weighted estimate is partial summation from Buchstab's asymptotic~\cite[(1.3)]{Fan}. If a prime \(\ell\) is removed, write \(\Phi(Y,z)=\#\{1\le n\le Y:(n,P)=1\}\). For \(Y\asymp z^v\), the extra integers up to \(Y\) number at most \[ \sum_{j\ge1}\Phi(Y/\ell^j,z) \ll \frac{Y}{\ell\log z}+\sqrt Y=o(Y/\log z). \] For \(\ell^j\le\sqrt Y\) use Buchstab's bound \(\Phi(t,z)\ll t/\log z\) for \(t\ge z^2\), and sum the remaining geometric tail trivially. This proves \eqref{eq:rough}. \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{th:main}] Choose a fixed \(u>4\) so large that \begin{equation}\label{eq:choice} \omega(u)>\omega(u+1),\qquad d(u/2-1)>D+2 . \end{equation} Such \(u\) occur arbitrarily far out. If \(\omega(t)\le\omega(t+1)\) eventually, the equation \(t\omega'(t)=\omega(t-1)-\omega(t)\) makes \(\omega\) nonincreasing on a tail. It must then be constant there. The same equation propagates a constant tail backwards to \((1,2)\), where \(\omega(t)=1/t\). Set \(H=z^u\) and \(M=zH\). Fix nonnegative \(w,v\in C_c^\infty(1,2)\) of integral one. For each integer \(a\) put \[ b_a(m)=w(m/M)v((m-a)/H),\qquad S_a=\sum_{m\ {\rm odd}}\Lambda(m)b_a(m) \{\ind_{(a-m,Q)=1}-\ind_{(a+m,Q)=1}\}. \] Summing the first term over \(a\) separates the \(m\)-sum from the sum over \(h=m-a\). The prime number theorem and \eqref{eq:rough} at \(H\) give \((MH/\log z)(\omega(u)+o(1))\). For the second term put \(t=a+m\). Uniformly on its support \(2M-2H\le t\le4M\), \[ \sum_{m\ {\rm odd}}\Lambda(m)w(m/M)v((2m-t)/H) =\frac H2w(t/(2M))+o(H). \] Indeed \(H=M^{u/(u+1)}>M^{4/5}\). Huxley's prime number theorem in short intervals~\cite{Huxley} gives \(\psi(y+s)-\psi(y)=s+o(H)\) uniformly for \(y\asymp M\), \(0\le s\le2H\): use his asymptotic for \(s\ge M^{2/3}\) and the trivial bound below \(M^{2/3}\). Partial summation against the smooth weight gives the formula, since \(H/M\to0\) and the powers of two cost \(O(\log M)\). There are \(O(M/\log z)\) admissible \(t\) by \eqref{eq:rough}. Summing over \((t,Q)=1\) and applying \eqref{eq:rough} at \(2M\) gives the second term \((MH/\log z)(\omega(u+1)+o(1))\). Thus \[ \sum_a S_a=\frac{MH}{\log z} \{\omega(u)-\omega(u+1)+o(1)\}. \] Only \(O(M)\) values of \(a\) occur, and odd \(a\) contribute zero because \(2\mid Q\). Fix an even \(a\) with \(S_a\gg H/\log z\). Let \(\mathcal A=\{N\in[X,2X]:N\equiv a\bmod Q\}\), so \(K=|\mathcal A|=X/Q+O(1)\). For odd \(m=p^j\) in the support of \(b_a\), \eqref{eq:ap} gives \[ \sum_{\substack{N\in\mathcal A\\(m,N)=1}}\Lambda(N\pm m) =\frac{X}{\varphi(Q)}\ind_{(a\pm m,Q)=1}+O(Xe^{-c\sqrt L}). \] In a nonunit class every nonzero term is a power of a single prime dividing \((a\pm m,Q)\). Terms removed by \(p\mid N\) are powers of \(p\). Each costs \(O(\log X)\) in total. Since \(\sum_m\Lambda(m)b_a(m)\ll H\) by the short-interval estimate, we obtain \[ \frac1K\sum_{N\in\mathcal A} B_N(b_a) =\frac{X}{K\varphi(Q)} S_a+o(H)\gg H . \] Here \(Qe^{-c\sqrt L}=o(1)\). Pointwise \(|B_N(b_a)|\ll H\log X\), so \(B_N(b_a)\gg H\) for \(\gg X/(Q\log X)\) members of \(\mathcal A\), with a fixed positive lower-bound constant. Discard any such \(N\) within \(2M\) of a proper prime power in \([X/2,3X]\). This removes \(O(M\sqrt X\log X)\) integers. Since \(\log Q\ll L^d\) and \(d<\varepsilon\), at least \(X\exp(-L^\varepsilon)\) moduli remain. For each of them the sum with \(\Lambda(N-m)\) alone has weight \(\gg H\) and every positive term has \(N-m\) prime. Proper prime powers \(m\le2M\) contribute \(O(\sqrt M\log^2(2M)\log X)=o(H)\) by \eqref{eq:choice}. Each remaining pair contributes \(O(\log(2M)\log X)\), so there are at least \((\log N)^D\) distinct prime pairs with smaller prime at most \(2M\le(\log N)^{d(u+1)+1}\). Finally \(\|b_a\|_\infty+H\|b_a'\|_\infty\ll1\) uniformly in \(a,X\). At each of these moduli satisfying \(\grh(N)\), Lemma~\ref{lem:entry} and \eqref{eq:choice} give \[ \sqrt N\,\|T_N\|\gg \frac{H^{3/2}}{M} =(\log X)^{d(u/2-1)}>(\log N)^D . \] \end{proof} \par\medskip\noindent\textbf{Acknowledgment.}\enspace The author used OpenAI's GPT-6.2 Astra to formulate the results, develop and review the proofs, and draft the manuscript. \begin{thebibliography}{9} \bibitem{Fan} K. Fan, \href{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnt.2024.01.008}{Numerically explicit estimates for the distribution of rough numbers}, \emph{J. Number Theory} 260 (2024), 120--150. \bibitem{FGKMT} K. Ford, B. Green, S. Konyagin, J. Maynard and T. Tao, \href{https://doi.org/10.1090/jams/876}{Long gaps between primes}, \emph{J. Amer. Math. Soc.} 31 (2018), 65--105. \bibitem{GS} A. Granville and K. Soundararajan, \href{https://doi.org/10.4007/annals.2007.165.593}{An uncertainty principle for arithmetic sequences}, \emph{Ann. of Math.} (2) 165 (2007), 593--635. \bibitem{Huxley} M. N. Huxley, \href{https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01418933}{On the difference between consecutive primes}, \emph{Invent. Math.} 15 (1972), 164--170. \bibitem{LL} J. Li and J. Liu, \href{https://mrc.sdu.edu.cn/english/info/1018/1514.htm}{A conditional proof of the Goldbach conjecture}, preprint, 2026. \bibitem{Maier} H. Maier, \href{https://doi.org/10.1307/mmj/1029003189}{Primes in short intervals}, \emph{Michigan Math. J.} 32 (1985), 221--225. \bibitem{PW} M. Pandey and K. Woo, \href{https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms.13001}{Small-scale distribution of linear patterns of primes}, \emph{J. Lond. Math. Soc.} (2) 110 (2024), e13001. \end{thebibliography} \end{document}