\documentclass[11pt,reqno]{amsart} \usepackage{jaswal} \makeatletter \def\@settitle{\begin{center}\baselineskip18\p@\relax\normalfont\Large\bfseries\boldmath\@title\end{center}} \def\@setauthors{\begin{center}\normalfont\normalsize\authors\\[3pt]\small Toronto, Canada\quad\texttt{manvirjaswal@icloud.com}\quad\url{https://manvirjaswal.github.io}\\[3pt]\@date\end{center}} \def\@adminfootnotes{} \def\@secnumfont{\bfseries} \def\section{\@startsection{section}{1}\z@{.7\linespacing\@plus\linespacing}{.5\linespacing}{\normalfont\bfseries\boldmath}} \makeatother \pagestyle{plain} \newcommand{\T}{\mathbb T^3} \newcommand{\R}{\mathbb R} \newcommand{\Id}{\operatorname{Id}} \newcommand{\curl}{\operatorname{curl}} \newcommand{\divg}{\operatorname{div}} \newcommand{\tr}{\operatorname{tr}} \newcommand{\PP}{\mathbb P} \newcommand{\D}{\mathsf D} \newcommand{\eps}{\varepsilon} \newcommand{\ba}{\mathbf a} \newcommand{\bd}{\mathbf d} \newcommand{\Tr}{\mathsf T} \newcommand{\Hc}{\mathsf H} \begin{document} \title[Density of blow-up data and regularity at the blow-up time]{Density of blow-up data and regularity at the blow-up time for the three-dimensional Euler equations} \author{Manvir Jaswal} \date{November 20, 2026} \hypersetup{pdftitle={Density of blow-up data and regularity at the blow-up time for the three-dimensional Euler equations},pdfauthor={Manvir Jaswal}} \begin{abstract} Alpöge, Buckmaster and Coiculescu have constructed smooth odd initial data on $\mathbb T^3$ whose solutions of the incompressible Euler equations blow up in finite time. Running their construction without oddness, with the singularity carried by a fluid particle, we show that data whose solutions blow up in arbitrarily short time are dense among smooth divergence-free fields in $L^\infty$, $H^1$ and $C^\alpha$, $0<\alpha<5/6$. The same holds inside classes of fields invariant under a finite group of isometries of $\mathbb T^3$, such as the Taylor--Green and Kida classes, with blow-up at the same time along a whole orbit. The Euler equations are not well posed in these topologies, and the result says nothing about instability in $C^{1,\alpha}$ or in $H^s$, $s>5/2$. For both our solutions and those of Alpöge, Buckmaster and Coiculescu, the velocity stays continuous up to the blow-up time $T$ in $H^1$ and in $C^\alpha$ for every $0<\alpha<5/6$, so the enstrophy converges, while $u(T)\notin C^{5/6}$, $\operatorname{curl}u(T)$ lies in no $L^p$ with $p>2$, and the vorticity on the particle grows faster than $(T-t)^{-2}$. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} We consider the incompressible Euler equations on $\T=\R^3/\mathbb Z^3$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:euler} \partial_tu+(u\cdot\nabla)u+\nabla p=0,\qquad \divg u=0. \end{equation} Smooth divergence-free data have a unique maximal smooth solution~\cite{EM}. Alpöge, Buckmaster and Coiculescu have recently shown that it can become singular in finite time. Smooth compactly supported data on $\mathbb R^3$ whose solutions blow up were constructed earlier in~\cite{OpenAIEuler}. \begin{theorem}[Alpöge, Buckmaster and Coiculescu {\cite[Theorem~1.1]{ABC}}]\label{thm:abc} There is an odd divergence-free $u_0\in C^\infty(\T;\R^3)$ whose maximal classical solution $u$ of \eqref{eq:euler} is smooth and odd on $\T\times[0,T_*)$ for a finite $T_*>0$, and satisfies \begin{equation}\label{eq:integrals} \int_0^{T_*}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{L^\infty}\,dt=\infty,\qquad \int_0^{T_*}\|\curl u(t)\|_{L^\infty}\,dt=\infty. \end{equation} Moreover, \begin{equation}\label{eq:center} \sup_{0\le t0$. There is a divergence-free $u_0\in C^\infty(\T;\R^3)$ that blows up along the particle from $z$ at a time $T_*<\eps$, with endpoint $y_*$ at distance less than $\eps$ from $z$, and \[ \|u_0-v\|_{L^\infty}+\|u_0-v\|_{H^1}+\|u_0-v\|_{C^\alpha}<\eps. \] \end{theorem} Here $\|w\|_{C^\alpha}=\|w\|_{L^\infty}+[w]_\alpha$, where $[w]_\alpha$ is the supremum of $|w(x)-w(y)|/|x-y|^\alpha$ in the periodic distance. As the periodic distance is less than~$1$, $[w]_\alpha$ increases with~$\alpha$, and a diagonal choice of $\alpha\uparrow5/6$ and $\eps\downarrow0$ in \cref{thm:main} gives a single sequence of such data converging to $v$ in $L^\infty$, in $H^1$ and in every $C^\alpha$, $0<\alpha<5/6$, with blow-up times tending to zero and endpoints tending to $z$. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:sym} Let $v\in C^\infty(\T;\R^3)$ be divergence free, $0<\alpha<5/6$ and $\eps>0$. \begin{enumerate} \item\label{sym:odd} If $v$ is odd, there is an odd divergence-free $u_0\in C^\infty(\T;\R^3)$ that blows up as in \cref{thm:abc} at a time $T_*<\eps$, with $\|u_0-v\|_{L^\infty}+\|u_0-v\|_{H^1}+\|u_0-v\|_{C^\alpha}<\eps$. \item\label{sym:group} Let $G$ be a finite group of isometries $gx=Q_gx+d_g$ of $\T$, acting on fields by $(g_*w)(x)=Q_gw(g^{-1}x)$, and suppose that $g_*v=v$ for $g\in G$. Let $z\in\T$ satisfy $\nabla v(z)\ne0$ and $gz\ne z$ for $g\ne\mathrm{id}$. Then there is a $G$-invariant divergence-free $u_0\in C^\infty(\T;\R^3)$ that blows up along the particles from all the points $gz$, $g\in G$, at one time $T_*<\eps$, with $\|u_0-v\|_{L^\infty}+\|u_0-v\|_{H^1}+\|u_0-v\|_{C^\alpha}<\eps$. The particle from $gz$ ends at $gy_*$, where $y_*$ is at distance less than $\eps$ from $z$, and these $|G|$ endpoints are distinct. \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} If $v$ is $G$-invariant and not constant, a point $z$ as in \labelcref{sym:group} exists. An isometry other than the identity fixes no open set, so the points with trivial stabilizer form a dense open set, which meets the nonempty open set where $\nabla v\ne0$. If $v$ is constant, take a point $z$ with trivial stabilizer, a ball $B$ about it whose images $gB$ are disjoint, and a small smooth divergence-free $w$ supported in $B$ with $\nabla w(z)\ne0$; then $v+\sum_{g\in G}g_*w$ is $G$-invariant and divergence free, with gradient $\nabla w(z)$ at $z$. Blow-up data are therefore dense in every class of $G$-invariant fields. The Taylor--Green class~\cite{TG} and Kida's class~\cite{Kida} consist of the fields invariant under groups of $64$ and $192$ isometries that preserve the two flows (\cref{sec:sym}). \begin{theorem}\label{thm:terminal} Let $u$ be the solution constructed in \cite[Sections~6--8]{ABC}, with $z=0$, or the solution from the data constructed in the proof of \cref{thm:main} or of \cref{thm:sym}, with $z=0$ in \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:odd}. In each case, let $N$, the large parameter of the construction (\cref{sec:recall}), be sufficiently large. Let $T$ be the blow-up time of $u$, $y$ the particle from $z$, and $u(T)$ the uniform limit of $u(t)$ as $t\uparrow T$, which exists by \cite[Section~8]{ABC} and \cref{sec:nosym}. Then: \begin{enumerate} \item\label{t:cont} $u\in C([0,T];C^\alpha)$ for every $0<\alpha<5/6$ and $u\in C([0,T];H^1)$; in particular $\curl u(T)\in L^2$ and the enstrophy converges, $\|\curl u(t)\|_{L^2}\to\|\curl u(T)\|_{L^2}$ as $t\uparrow T$; \item\label{t:neg} $u(T)\notin C^{5/6}$, and $\curl u(T)\notin L^p$ for every $p>2$; \item\label{t:rate} $(T-t)^2|\curl u(t,y(t))|\to\infty$ as $t\uparrow T$. \end{enumerate} In particular, the data in \cref{thm:main,thm:sym} can be chosen so that their solutions have these properties. \end{theorem} Theorems~\labelcref{thm:main}--\labelcref{thm:terminal} rest on the proof of \cite[Theorem~1.1]{ABC}, which runs the induction of its Theorem~7.1, built from the step of its Sections~3--5, and passes to the limit in its Section~8. For \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:odd} we change only the field over which the induction starts (\cref{prop:base} and \cref{sec:proof}). Sections~3 and~5 of~\cite{ABC} are stated for an odd parent field, and \cref{thm:main} and \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:group} use them for a parent that is not odd. Their proofs justify this, since oddness there only keeps the origin fixed and propagates parity (\cref{lem:step}). Without a fixed point, each wave is centered at the label $z$ of its own parent's flow, and two successive waves see the velocity gradient along two different particle paths. \Cref{lem:particle} compares them, using two bounds from the proofs of \cite[Lemmas~5.9 and~5.10]{ABC}, which we state as \cref{lem:inside}. For a group, the waves run at all points of an orbit at once, with one phase-independent correction for all of them (\cref{sec:sym}). In~\cite{ABC} the induction starts from the stationary shear $\sin(2\pi x_2)(e_1+\eps_1e_3)$. Its first wave, of frequency $\lambda_1=N^{640b}$ with $N$ large and $b$ a fixed integer, is set up in the frame $(e_1,e_2,e_3)$, in which the two couplings of the shear's gradient are $2\pi$ and $2\pi\eps_1$ \cite[(6.1)--(6.4)]{ABC}. Their ratio $\eps_1$ is what the second wave needs. It tends to zero as $N\to\infty$, and by \cite[(7.4)]{ABC} and the counts of \cref{lem:data} the data of~\cite{ABC} then converge to $\sin(2\pi x_2)e_1$ in the norms of \cref{thm:main}, with blow-up times tending to zero; so for this shear at $z=0$, and hence, by scaling, translation and a Galilean change of frame, for constant fields, \cref{thm:main} already follows from their construction. Here the base is the Euler solution from $\theta v$, for a small $\theta>0$, cut off in frequency at $N^5$ at each time. Its residual is smaller than any power of $N$, as the induction requires, whereas the residual of the stationary cutoff of $\theta v$ does not tend to zero unless $v$ is a steady state. The frame of the first wave is built from the gradient of the base at $z$, which is trace free and, once a small shear is added to $v$ if necessary, nonzero. At time zero the ratio of the couplings is then again exactly $\eps_1$, while the first coupling, no longer $2\pi$, stays within a factor two of its initial value. At time zero the data differ from the base by the first leading wave $V(x)=\mbox{$\chi(|x-z|/\ell_*)$}F_h(\lambda_1E_1\cdot(x-z))\ba_*$, $h=\lambda_1^{-1/2}$, up to terms that are small in $C^1$; for a group, by one such wave at each point of the orbit. Here $F_h$ is the profile of \cite[Lemma~3.1]{ABC}, $E_1$ is a unit vector, $\ba_*\perp E_1$ has length between $\lambda_1^{-3/4}/2$ and $\lambda_1^{-3/4}$, and the envelope radius $\ell_*$ tends to zero. The size $\lambda_1^{-5/4}$ of $V$ and the size $\lambda_1^{1/4}$ of its gradient give the bound in $C^\alpha$ for $0<\alpha<5/6$ (\cref{lem:data,rem:exact}). In $H^1$, the one-sided bound $F_h'\ge-Ch$ makes the mean of $|F_h'|^2$ at most of order $h$, which offsets the slope $\lambda_1|\ba_*|\le\lambda_1^{1/4}$ and gives $\|\nabla V\|_{L^2}=O(\ell_*^{3/2})$ (\cref{lem:data}). The same two counts, applied to each wave uniformly for $0\le t\le T$, give \cref{thm:terminal}\labelcref{t:cont}; the statements in \labelcref{t:neg} use the strength and wave vector of the waves at their crossings \cite[Proposition~2.8]{ABC}. For the solution of~\cite{ABC}, the approximate solutions converge uniformly on $[0,T]\times\T$ \cite[Section~8]{ABC}, so that $u\in C([0,T];C^0)$, and their auxiliary note shows that, for a suitable choice of the function $\mathcal B$, their velocity extends to a smooth field on a space-time neighborhood of $\{T\}\times(\T\setminus\{0\})$ \cite[Theorem~1.1]{ABCaux}, so that the singular set is $\{(T,0)\}$. For the other solutions the uniform convergence is proved in the same way. The lower bound on the particle uses $D^2p\le\Id$, the limit of the pressure bound (T3) of \cite[Theorem~7.1]{ABC} and of its version (T3$'$) in \cref{sec:recall}, which gives $|\omega|''\ge-|\omega|$ for the vorticity $\omega$ on the particle (\cref{sec:terminal}), and the strength of the waves at their crossings, as in the proof of \cite[(8.2)]{ABC}. \Cref{thm:main,thm:sym} are about topologies in which the Euler equations are not well posed. Bardos and Titi give shear flows that lie in $C^{0,\alpha}$ at $t=0$ and in no $C^{0,\beta}$, $\beta>\alpha^2$, at any $t\neq0$ \cite[Theorem~2.2(iii)]{BT}, and conclude that the equations are not well posed in $C^\beta$, $0<\beta<1$ \cite[Section~5]{BT}; with shear flows of the same form, DiPerna and Lions showed that a $W^{1,p}$ norm can grow from one to any size in any given time, as recalled in \cite[Theorem~2.1]{BT}; and bounded weak solutions are not unique \cite[Theorem~1.1]{DLS}. Smooth data, on the other hand, have unique local solutions in $C^{1,\alpha}$ \cite{Lichtenstein,Gunther}, and the equations are well posed in $H^s$ for every integer $s>5/2$ \cite[Section~15.2]{EM}; \cref{thm:main,thm:sym} say nothing about instability in $C^{1,\alpha}$ or in $H^s$, $s>5/2$. \looseness=-1 Near the Biot--Savart velocity of every smooth compactly supported vorticity on $\R^3$, Bourgain and Li find smooth perturbations, arbitrarily small in $H^{5/2}$, whose solutions have unbounded $H^{5/2}$ norm on every interval $(0,t_0)$ \cite[Theorem~1.8]{BL}. Near any smooth solution on $\T$, Enciso, Peñafiel-Tomás and Peralta-Salas construct weak solutions that are uniformly close to it at time zero and singular in a prescribed region \cite[Theorem~1.5]{EPP}. \Cref{thm:main} is a statement of the same kind for blow-up in finite time from smooth data, in topologies weaker than $C^1$. \section{The construction over a general base}\label{sec:recall} The construction of~\cite{ABC}, which follows the multiscale approach of Córdoba and Martínez-Zoroa~\cite{CMZEuler,CMZIPM}, adds to a parent field, at frequencies $\lambda_1<\lambda_2<\cdots$, Craik--Criminale waves~\cite{CraikCriminale} localized at the origin. Each wave grows in the shear of its predecessor, and an endpoint problem for the phase-independent correction chooses the initial velocity of each step so that the limit solves the unforced equations \cite[Sections~1 and~4]{ABC}. We recall what the proof uses, in the notation of~\cite{ABC}: $(\nabla U)_{ij}=\partial_jU_i$, $a\otimes b=ab^\Tr$, $\PP$ is the Leray projection and pressures have zero mean \cite[Section~1, Conventions]{ABC}. Matrix norms are operator norms, and matrices are compared as quadratic forms. As in~\cite{ABC}, this section and the next work at the origin with odd fields; \cref{sec:nosym} moves the center to a label $z$. \emph{Other inputs.} Besides Sections~3 and~5 of~\cite{ABC}, \cref{thm:main} and \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:group} use from~\cite{ABC}, as stated, \cite[(1.14), (1.15), Section~2, Theorem~4.2, Lemmas~1.3, 3.1, B.1 and D.1--D.3, and Appendices~A and~C]{ABC} and the continuation criterion cited in~\cite[Corollary~8.3]{ABC}. Their proofs run the arguments of \cite[Sections~6--8]{ABC} again with the moving center and do not use \cite[Theorems~7.1 and~1.1]{ABC}.\looseness=-1 \emph{Parameters} \cite[Section~1.5]{ABC}. An integer $b\ge1$, a constant $\Gamma_P\ge1$ \cite[Section~5.6]{ABC} and a nondecreasing function $\mathcal B$ bounding the fixed-order constants are fixed once, before $N$, large enough for~\cite{ABC}, for \cref{lem:inside,lem:particle} and, for a group $G$, for the constants of \cref{lem:orbit}, which depend on $G$; \cite[(1.14), (5.43), (7.8)]{ABC} hold for every such choice. Then $K(s)=320b(s+1)$ and $N\ge\mathcal B(1)$. With orders $q_j$ as in \cite[(1.14)]{ABC}, $q_1=1$, put $\lambda_0=N$, $\lambda_j=\lambda_{j-1}^{K(q_j)}$, $\Lambda_j=\lambda_j^5$, $L_j=4\log\lambda_{j+1}$ and $\eps_{j-1}=L_j^{-2}$ for $j\ge2$. Thus $\lambda_1=N^{640b}$, and $L_{j+1}\le(\log\lambda_{j-1})^2$ by \cite[(1.15)]{ABC}. The times of \cite[Section~7]{ABC} are $t_1=t_2=0$, $\tau_j=\lambda_{j-1}^{-1/8}L_{j+1}^3$, $S_0=1$ and $S_j=t_j+2\tau_j$.\looseness=-1 \emph{The profile} \cite[Lemma~3.1]{ABC}. For $00$, \[ \int_{|x|\le R}|F_h'(\lambda E\cdot x)|^2\,dx\le4\pi Ch\,R^2(R+\lambda^{-1}). \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By \eqref{eq:profile} and $Ch\le1$, $|F_h'|\le1$. Being the derivative of a periodic function, $F_h'$ has mean zero, so $\int_0^1|F_h'|=2\int_0^1(F_h')_-\le2Ch$ and $\int_0^1|F_h'|^2\le\sup|F_h'|\int_0^1|F_h'|\le2Ch$. Write $x=sE+y$ with $y\perp E$, $|y|\le R$. The slice $\{s:|sE+y|\le R\}$ is an interval $I_y$ of length at most $2R$, and $\lambda I_y$ meets at most $\lambda|I_y|+2$ intervals $[k,k+1]$, $k\in\mathbb Z$. By periodicity, \[ \int_{I_y}|F_h'(\lambda s)|^2\,ds=\lambda^{-1}\int_{\lambda I_y}|F_h'|^2\le(2R+2\lambda^{-1})\,2Ch. \] Integrating over the disc $|y|\le R$, of area $\pi R^2$, gives the bound. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:data} In the setting of \cref{prop:base}, write $\lambda=\lambda_1$, $\ell=\ell_*$, $E=E_1$, and put \[ V(x)=g(x)F_h(\lambda E\cdot(x-z))\,\ba_*,\qquad V^{\mathrm c}(x)=\lambda^{-1}P_h(\lambda E\cdot(x-z))\,\nabla g(x)\times(\ba_*\times E). \] For large $N$, $u_0-U_0(0)=V+V^{\mathrm c}+H$ with $\|V^{\mathrm c}\|_{C^1}\le2\lambda^{1/16-3/4}$, and, with $C$ depending only on $\chi$ and the profiles, \begin{gather} \|V\|_{L^\infty}\le C\lambda^{-5/4},\qquad \tfrac12\lambda^{1/4}\le\|\nabla V\|_{L^\infty}\le C\lambda^{1/4},\qquad [V]_\alpha\le C\lambda^{3\alpha/2-5/4}\quad(0<\alpha\le1),\label{eq:sup}\\ \|\nabla V\|_{L^2}^2\le C\bigl(\lambda^{-5/2}\ell+\ell^3+\lambda^{-1}\ell^2\bigr).\label{eq:H1} \end{gather} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since $E\times(\ba_*\times E)=\ba_*$, the curl in \eqref{eq:data} is $\lambda^{-1}\nabla(gP_h(\lambda E\cdot(x-z)))\times(\ba_*\times E)=V^{\mathrm c}+V$. By \eqref{eq:potential} and \eqref{eq:Q0}, $V^{\mathrm c}=C[A_1]^\natural(0)$ for the first wave. The bounds \cite[(5.36)]{ABC} at $p=1$ and \cite[(5.44)]{ABC} at orders $0$ and $1$ and $t=0$, where $\gamma\le1$ (for a parent that is not odd, by \cref{lem:step}), bound $\|V^{\mathrm c}\|_\infty$ and $\|\nabla V^{\mathrm c}\|_\infty$ by $\lambda^{-9/4}$ and $\lambda^{3/2-9/4}$ times products of two fixed-order constants and powers $\D^C$ with $C\le b$. By \cite[(7.8)]{ABC} at $j=1$, $\mathcal B(q_2)\D^b\le\lambda^{1/32}$, which gives the bound for $V^{\mathrm c}$. For large $N$, $Ch\le1$, so $|F_h'|\le1$. The bound for $V$ is $|\ba_*|\|F_h\|_\infty\le C\lambda^{-3/4}h$. Next, \[ \nabla V=\ba_*\otimes\bigl(F_h(\lambda E\cdot(x-z))\nabla g+\lambda gF_h'(\lambda E\cdot(x-z))E\bigr). \] The second term is at most $\lambda|\ba_*|\le\lambda^{1/4}$, and at $z$, where $\nabla g=0$, it is $\lambda\ba_*\otimes E$, of norm at least $\lambda^{1/4}/2$. On the support of $\nabla g$, $|x-z|\le2\ell$, so $F_h(0)=0$ gives $|F_h(\lambda E\cdot(x-z))|\le2\lambda\ell$, while $|\nabla g|\le\|\chi'\|_\infty\ell^{-1}$; the first term is therefore at most $2\|\chi'\|_\infty\lambda|\ba_*|$. The H\"older bound follows from $|V(x)-V(y)|\le(2\|V\|_\infty)^{1-\alpha}(\|\nabla V\|_\infty|x-y|)^\alpha$. For \eqref{eq:H1}, $V$ is supported in $|x-z|\le2\ell$, and $\|\nabla g\|_{L^2}^2\le C\ell$, so \begin{align*} \|\nabla V\|_{L^2}^2&\le2|\ba_*|^2\Bigl(\|F_h\|_\infty^2\|\nabla g\|_{L^2}^2+\lambda^2\int_{|x|\le2\ell}|F_h'(\lambda E\cdot x)|^2\,dx\Bigr)\\ &\le C\lambda^{-3/2}\bigl(h^2\ell+\lambda^2h(\ell^3+\lambda^{-1}\ell^2)\bigr) \end{align*} by \cref{lem:slice}, and $\lambda^{1/2}h=1$. \end{proof} The one-sided bound in \eqref{eq:profile} is what makes \eqref{eq:H1} small. A sine profile with the same slope at zero has $\int_0^1|F'|^2=1/2$, and for it the count in the proof of \cref{lem:data} gives $\|\nabla V\|_{L^2}$ of order $\lambda_1^{1/4}\ell_*^{3/2}$, which grows, since $\ell_*\ge\lambda_1^{-1/32}$ by \eqref{eq:ell}. \begin{remark}\label{rem:exact} With $\delta=1/(2C_2)$ and $y=z+\delta\lambda^{-3/2}E$, \eqref{eq:ell} and \eqref{eq:profile} give $g(y)=1$ and $|V(y)|\ge\frac\delta4\lambda^{-5/4}=\frac14\delta^{1/6}|y-z|^{5/6}$, so $[V]_{5/6}\ge\frac14\delta^{1/6}$. Near $z$ the other terms of $u_0-v$ in the proofs below have gradient bounded uniformly in $N$, and each changes the $C^{5/6}$ quotient at $(y,z)$ by $O(|y-z|^{1/6})$; so for these data the $C^{5/6}$ distance to $v$ stays bounded below. \end{remark} \begin{proof}[Proof of \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:odd}] \emph{Scaling.} For $c>0$, $u_c(t,x)=cu(ct,x)$ is the maximal solution from $cu_0$; it blows up along the particle path $y(ct)$, with the same endpoint, at time $T_*/c$. \emph{A nonzero gradient.} If $\nabla v(0)=0$, then $v+s\sin(2\pi x_2)e_1$ is smooth, odd and divergence free, has gradient $2\pi s\,e_1\otimes e_2\neq0$ at the origin for $s\neq0$, and tends to $v$ in $C^\infty$ as $s\to0$. So we may assume $\nabla v(0)\neq0$. \emph{The base.} Let $u_v$ be the smooth solution from $v$ on $[0,T_0]$, $T_0>0$, with pressure $p_v$; it is odd, since $-u_v(t,-x)$ solves \eqref{eq:euler} with the same data. Let $\theta=\min\{1,T_0,(2\sup|D^2p_v|)^{-1/2}\}$, omitting the last term if $D^2p_v\equiv0$. Then $f(t,x)=\theta u_v(\theta t,x)$ solves \eqref{eq:euler} on $[0,1]$ with pressure $p_f(t,x)=\theta^2p_v(\theta t,x)$, $D^2p_f\le\frac12\Id$ and $f(0)=\theta v$. The matrix $\nabla f(0,0)=\theta\nabla v(0)$ is nonzero and trace free, and a trace-free matrix for which every vector is an eigenvector vanishes. We fix once and for all a unit vector $e$ with $d=|(\Id-e\otimes e)\nabla f(0,0)e|>0$. With $S_\Lambda$ the frequency cutoff of \cite[Appendix~B]{ABC}, put $U_0=S_{N^5}f$ and $\delta_N=U_0-f$. Let $01920b$. The tail estimate \cite[(B.2)]{ABC} at $s=1$, the product estimate \cite[(5.59)]{ABC} and the boundedness of $\PP$ on $C^{0,1/2}$ give $\|R_0\|_{C_tL^\infty}\le C_{f,J}N^{5(1-J)}\le N^{-1920b}=\lambda_1^{-3}$ for large $N$, which is hypothesis \labelcref{h:res}. Next, $\Delta(\pi_0-p_f)=-\tr(\nabla\delta_N\nabla U_0+\nabla f\nabla\delta_N)$ and $D^2\Delta^{-1}$ is bounded on $C^{0,1/2}$, so $\|D^2(\pi_0-p_f)\|_\infty\le C_{f,J}N^{5(1-J)}\le\frac14$ for large $N$, which gives hypothesis \labelcref{h:hess}. Finally $\nabla U_0(0,0)\to\nabla f(0,0)$ by \cite[(B.2)]{ABC}, so hypothesis \labelcref{h:dir} holds for large $N$, as $m\le d/2$. \emph{Conclusion.} For large $N$, \cref{prop:base,lem:data} give an odd divergence-free $u_0^N\in C^\infty(\T;\R^3)$ that blows up as in \cref{thm:abc} at a time at most $\frac43\lambda_1^{-1/8}(\log\lambda_1)^6$, with $u_0^N-\theta v=V+(V^{\mathrm c}+H+S_{N^5}(\theta v)-\theta v)$. By \cref{lem:data}, \eqref{eq:data} and \cite[(B.2)]{ABC}, the bracket tends to zero in $C^1$ as $N\to\infty$, and on $\T$ the norms of $H^1$ and $C^\alpha$ are bounded by that of $C^1$. By \eqref{eq:sup}, \eqref{eq:H1} and \eqref{eq:ell}, $V$ tends to zero in $L^\infty$, in $H^1$ and in $C^\alpha$ for $\alpha<5/6$. By the scaling step with $c=\theta^{-1}$, $u_0=\theta^{-1}u_0^N$ blows up as in \cref{thm:abc} at a time at most $\frac43\theta\lambda_1^{-1/8}(\log\lambda_1)^6$, and $u_0-v=\theta^{-1}(u_0^N-\theta v)$. Taking $N$ large proves \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:odd}. \end{proof} \section{Without symmetry}\label{sec:nosym} This section proves \cref{prop:base} without oddness, and with it \cref{thm:main}. \Cref{sec:step} adapts the step of \cite[Section~5]{ABC} to a wave centered at a moving particle, and \cref{sec:induction} runs the induction along it. \subsection{One step over a parent that is not odd}\label{sec:step} We use the notation of \cite[Sections~5.5--5.6]{ABC}: $W=W_{\mathrm{osc}}+\bar W$ is the profile of the velocity increment of a step, with oscillatory part $W_{\mathrm{osc}}$ and phase-independent part $\bar W$, $V_1=\widetilde\chi A_1$ is its leading term (at the first step $\widetilde\chi\equiv1$, as in \cite[(6.3)]{ABC}, so this is $V_1=A_1$ of \cref{sec:recall}), and $U+W^\natural$ is the approximate solution of \cite[Lemma~5.8]{ABC}. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:step} Let $U$, $X$, $\D$ and $\lambda$ be as in the step of \cref{sec:recall}, except that $U$ need not be odd, and let $z\in\T$. Center the wave at the label $z$: its phase is $k_*\cdot(a-z)$, and its oscillatory profiles are defined on the lift of the cell $z+[-1/2,1/2]^3$, where they vanish near the faces, and extended periodically; its envelope is $g(a)=\chi(|a-z|/\ell_*)$; $\lambda=|\kappa(t_0,z)|$; the seed is normalized by $\max_{[t_0,T]}|\ba(t,z)|=\lambda^{-3/4}$ and extended to the other labels by \cite[(5.4)]{ABC} with $z$ in place of $0$; and $\gamma$, $\nu$ and \eqref{eq:central} are taken at $z$. Then the statements of \cite[Sections~3 and~5]{ABC} hold for this wave, with the label $z$ in place of $0$, the point $X(t,z)$ in place of $x=0$ in \cite[(5.50)]{ABC}, and without the assertions of parity. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Oddness enters \cite[Sections~3 and~5]{ABC} in three ways, none of them an estimate. It makes the origin a fixed particle and $D_aX$, $M$, $\kappa$, the seed and the envelope even in $a$ \cite[end of Section~3.1, and Section~5.1]{ABC}. It makes the construction symmetric under $(a,s)\mapsto(-a,-s)$, by the paragraph before \cite[Proposition~5.4]{ABC}, which is used only for the parity assertions of \cite[Lemma~5.8 and Proposition~5.11]{ABC}. And in the proof of \cite[(5.50)]{ABC} the flow fixes the origin, so the gradient is evaluated at $a=0$, $s=0$. Here we evaluate at $a=z$, $s=0$, $x=X(t,z)$. As $g(z)=F_h'(0)=1$ and $F_h(0)=0$, the chain rule \cite[(3.1)]{ABC} gives $D_xV_1^\natural(t,X(t,z))=\widetilde\chi(t)\ba(t,z)\otimes\kappa(t,z)$, and the bound for $E_c$ is proved as in~\cite{ABC}. The rest does not use parity. \cite[Theorem~4.2]{ABC} is stated for every smooth divergence-free parent with $D^2p_U-\nabla R_U\le\Id$; \cite[Propositions~5.1 and~5.2]{ABC} bound coefficients and the mean inverse at all labels; the proof of \cite[Lemma~5.3]{ABC} compares the equation at a label $a$ with the one at the center, now $z$, with $|a-z|$ in place of $|a|$; \cite[Proposition~5.4, Lemma~5.5 and Theorem~5.6]{ABC} use cancellations at fixed labels and the global estimate of \cite[Proposition~5.2]{ABC} for the mean; \cite[Lemma~5.7]{ABC} is the chain rule, with profiles extended periodically as in \cite[Section~3.1]{ABC}; and the proof of \cite[Lemma~5.10]{ABC} uses the volume preservation of $X$ and a phase primitive. Finally, odd fields have zero mean and $U$ need not. The estimates of \cite[Sections~3--7]{ABC} do not use the mean, since $\PP$ is the identity on constants, the inverse of \cite[Theorem~4.2]{ABC} includes the zero Fourier mode (proof of \cite[Lemma~A.2]{ABC}), and $S_\Lambda$ preserves it. \end{proof} Below, $\Hc$ denotes a quantity $C_{2,P}\D^C$ with $C$ absolute, which may change from line to line; $b$ and $\Gamma_P$ were taken at least as large as these exponents and constants (\cref{sec:recall}), so \cite[(5.43)]{ABC} gives $\Hc\le\lambda^{1/12}$. \begin{lemma}[from the proofs of {\cite[Lemmas~5.9 and~5.10]{ABC}}]\label{lem:inside} In the setting of \cref{lem:step}, let $v_\Lambda$ be a smooth divergence-free field on $[0,T]\times\T$ with $\|v_\Lambda\|_{C_tC^2}\le\lambda^{-5/2}$, and $U^+=U+W^\natural+v_\Lambda$. Write \[ U^+-U=(\widetilde\chi g\ba F_h)^\natural+r,\qquad c=(D_aX)^{-1}(W+v_\Lambda\circ X)=c_{\mathrm{osc}}+\bar c, \] with $\bar c$ the phase-independent part of $c$. Then, on $[0,T]\times\T$, \begin{gather} |r|\le\Hc\lambda^{-23/12},\qquad |\nabla r|\le\Hc\lambda^{-5/12},\label{eq:r}\\ \|c_{\mathrm{osc}}\|_{[2]}\le\Hc\lambda^{-5/4},\qquad \|\bar c\|_{[2]}\le\Hc\lambda^{-5/2},\qquad \|k_*\cdot c\|_{[1]}\le\Hc\lambda^{-5/4}.\label{eq:c} \end{gather} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Here $r=(W_{\mathrm{osc}}-V_1)^\natural+\bar W^\natural+v_\Lambda$. The proof of \cite[(5.50)]{ABC} bounds $\|W_{\mathrm{osc}}-V_1\|_{[1],\gamma}$ by $\Hc\lambda^{-23/12}$, using \cite[(5.34), (5.36)]{ABC}, and $\|\bar W\|_{[1]}$ by $\Hc\lambda^{-5/2}$, using \cite[(5.37)]{ABC}. The bound \cite[(5.44)]{ABC} is a supremum over all $x$; at orders $0$ and $1$, with $\gamma\le1$, it gives $|(W_{\mathrm{osc}}-V_1)^\natural|\le\Hc\lambda^{-23/12}$ and $|\nabla(W_{\mathrm{osc}}-V_1)^\natural|\le\Hc\lambda^{3/2-23/12}$, and its version for phase-independent fields gives $\Hc\lambda^{-5/2}$ for $\bar W^\natural$ and its gradient. With $\|v_\Lambda\|_{C^1}\le\lambda^{-5/2}$ this proves \eqref{eq:r}; before $t_0$ the oscillations vanish. The bounds \eqref{eq:c} are displayed in the proof of \cite[Lemma~5.10]{ABC}, from $\widetilde\bd\cdot(W+v_\Lambda\circ X)=0$, the Piola identity and the zero-mean phase primitive; they do not involve the center. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:particle} In the setting of \cref{lem:inside}, let $Y$ be the flow of $U^+$, and $y(t)=X(t,z)$, $y^+(t)=Y(t,z)$. Then $|y^+-y|\le\lambda^{-1}$ on $[0,T]$, and on $[t_0,T]$ \[ \nabla U^+(t,y^+(t))=\nabla U(t,y(t))+\widetilde\chi(t)\,\ba(t,z)\otimes\kappa(t,z)+E(t),\qquad |E(t)|\le\lambda^{-1/3}. \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $A(t)$ be the label with $X(t,A(t))=y^+(t)$, lifted continuously with $A(0)=z$, and $s(t)=k_*\cdot(A(t)-z)$, its phase. Differentiating $X(t,A)=Y(t,z)$ and subtracting $U(t,y^+)$ gives $(D_aX)A'=(U^+-U)(t,X(t,A))$, that is, the system \cite[(5.54)]{ABC} along one trajectory, $A'=c(t,A,s)$, $s'=k_*\cdot c(t,A,s)$. By \eqref{eq:c} and $T\le1$, $|A-z|$ and $|s|$ are at most $\Hc\lambda^{-5/4}$; in particular $|A-z|\le\ell_*$, since $\ell_*^{-1}\le C\D^b\le\lambda^{1/12}$ by \cref{sec:recall} and \cite[(5.43)]{ABC}. At the label $A$ the leading term of $U^+-U$ is $\widetilde\chi g(A)\ba(t,A)F_h(s)$, with $|F_h(s)|\le|s|$, as $F_h(0)=0$ and $|F_h'|\le1$, and $|\ba(t,A)|\le2\lambda^{-3/4}$ by \cite[(5.19)]{ABC}; so it is at most $\Hc\lambda^{-2}$, and $|r|\le\Hc\lambda^{-23/12}$ by \eqref{eq:r}. Hence $|A'|\le\D\Hc\lambda^{-23/12}$, and \[ |A-z|\le\Hc\lambda^{-23/12},\qquad |y^+-y|=|X(t,A)-X(t,z)|\le\D|A-z|\le\Hc\lambda^{-23/12}\le\lambda^{-1}. \] For $t\ge t_0$, put $p=g\ba$. By \cite[(3.1)]{ABC}, \[ \nabla U^+(t,y^+)=\nabla U(t,y^+)+\widetilde\chi\bigl[F_h(s)\,\bd p+F_h'(s)\,p\otimes\kappa\bigr](t,A)+\nabla r(t,y^+). \] On the envelope, \cite[(5.20)]{ABC} for the seed, as in the proof of \cite[(5.22)]{ABC}, gives $|\nabla_ap|\le\Hc\lambda^{-3/4}$, so $|\bd p|\le\Hc\lambda^{-3/4}$; \cite[Proposition~5.1 and (5.3)]{ABC} give $|\nabla_a\kappa|\le\Hc\lambda$ and $|\kappa|\le\D^2\lambda$; and $|p|\le2\lambda^{-3/4}$. So $p\otimes\kappa$ has label derivative at most $\Hc\lambda^{1/4}$, and $p(z)=\ba(t,z)$. By \eqref{eq:profile}, $|F_h'(s)-1|\le C_2|s|/h$, and $\|\nabla^2U\|_\infty\le C\D^2$ by \cite[(B.1)]{ABC}. Hence \[ |E|\le\Hc\bigl(\lambda^{-3/4}|s|+\lambda^{1/4}|A-z|+\lambda^{1/4}|s|/h+|y^+-y|+\lambda^{-5/12}\bigr), \] and the bounds above give the exponents $-2$, $-5/3$, $-1/2$, $-23/12$ and $-5/12$. Thus $|E|\le\Hc\lambda^{-5/12}\le\lambda^{-1/3}$. \end{proof} \subsection{The induction along the particle}\label{sec:induction} Let $U_0$, $z$ and $m$ be as in \cref{prop:base}, without oddness. We run the proof of \cref{sec:recall}, with wave $j$ centered as in \cref{lem:step} at the label $z$ of the flow $X_{j-1}$ of $U_{j-1}$. Write $y_i(t)=X_i(t,z)$ and $M_i(t)=\nabla U_i(t,y_i(t))$, and let $(\ba_j,\kappa_j)$ be the seed and wave vector of wave $j$ at the label $z$, with couplings \cite[(7.1)]{ABC} taken for $M_{j-1}$. For $j\ge1$ and $\mu=\lambda_{j-1}$, the iteration gives fields $U_j$ on $[0,S_j]\times\T$ with the following properties, proved in \cref{sec:recall} for odd $U_0$ and $z=0$, where $y_j\equiv0$ and (T4) gives (T4$'$). \begin{enumerate}[label=(I\arabic*),ref=(I\arabic*)] \item\label{i:T} (T1), (T2) and (T3$'$), without the oddness in (T1) (\cref{sec:recall}, index zero and the other items); \item\label{i:nu} \cite[(7.3)]{ABC} at $t_{j+1}$, with $\nu_*/2\le\nu_j\le2\nu_*$ (\cref{sec:recall}, items (2) and (3)); \item\label{i:par} \cite[(7.4), (7.6)--(7.8)]{ABC}, and $0j}\lambda_k^{-1}\le2\lambda_{j+1}^{-1}$ for $i>j$, so the $y_j$ converge uniformly on $[0,T_\infty]$ to a path $y$. Passing to the limit in $y_j(t)=z+\int_0^tU_j(s,y_j(s))\,ds$, using the uniform convergence of $U_j$ and the uniform continuity of $w$, gives $y(t)=z+\int_0^tw(s,y(s))\,ds$. Before $T_\infty$, $y$ is the particle of $u$ from $z$, and $y_*=y(T_\infty)$ is its limit, with $|y_*-z|\le(m^{-1}+1)T_\infty$. \emph{The vorticity on the particle.} On $[t_j,t_{j+1}]$, (T4$'$) at steps $j-1$ and $j$ gives $M_j=M_{j-2}+\ba_{j-1}\otimes\kappa_{j-1}+\widetilde\chi_j\ba_j\otimes\kappa_j+E_{j-1}+E_j$. This is the splitting at the origin in the proof of \cite[Proposition~8.2]{ABC}, along the particle. The preceding pair solves \cite[(2.1)]{ABC} over $M_{j-2}$, so \cite[(2.2)]{ABC} gives $|\partial_t\log\sigma_{j-1}|\le|M_{j-2}|$, and that proof gives $|\curl U_j(t,y_j(t))|\ge c(m)\lambda_{j-1}^{1/8}-C\lambda_{j-2}^9-C$ on $[t_j,t_{j+1}]$, with $C\lambda_{j-2}^9$ replaced by $Cm^{-1}$ for $j=2$. By \cite[(B.1)]{ABC}, $\|\nabla^2U_j\|_\infty\le C\Lambda_j^2\lambda_j=C\lambda_j^{11}$, so moving the evaluation from $y_j(t)$ to $y(t)$ costs at most $C\lambda_j^{11}\lambda_{j+1}^{-1}$. For $l>j$ the oscillation $O_l$ vanishes on $[t_j,t_{j+1}]$, so the remaining increments change the curl by at most $C\sum_{l>j}\lambda_l^{-1}$, as in the proof of \cite[Proposition~8.2]{ABC}. Hence $|\curl u(t,y(t))|\to\infty$ as $t\uparrow T_\infty$. As in \cite[Corollary~8.3]{ABC}, this gives $T_*=T_\infty$, and \eqref{eq:integrals} by the periodic Beale--Kato--Majda criterion~\cite{BKM} in the formulation of \cite[Theorem~1]{GGPP} used there; for data with nonzero mean the criterion is applied to $u(t,x+\bar ut)-\bar u$, with $\bar u$ the mean of $u_0$. \emph{Away from the endpoint.} Let $K\subset\T\setminus\{y_*\}$ be compact, at distance $\delta>0$ from $y_*$. When $O_j$ is active, $t\ge t_j$, and its support lies within $\lambda_{j-1}^{-1}+2\lambda_j^{-1}+(m^{-1}+1)(T_\infty-t_j)$ of $y_*$, which is less than $\delta/2$ for large $j$. So for large $j$, $O_j$ vanishes on the $\delta/2$-neighborhood of $K$ throughout $[0,T_\infty]$, and the proof of \cite[Proposition~8.4]{ABC}, with a cutoff equal to one near $K$ and zero near $y_*$, gives the convergence of $u(t)$ and $\partial_tu(t)$ in $C^n(K)$. \emph{The data.} The paragraph on the data in \cref{sec:recall} applies, with the phase $\lambda_1E_1\cdot(x-z)$ in \eqref{eq:Q0}, and gives \eqref{eq:data}. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of \cref{thm:main}] We follow the proof of \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:odd} without oddness, at the point $z$. If $\nabla v(z)=0$, replace $v$ by $v+s\sin(2\pi(x_2-z_2))e_1$, whose gradient at $z$ is $2\pi s\,e_1\otimes e_2$. The base $U_0=S_{N^5}f$ and the bounds of hypotheses \labelcref{h:freq}--\labelcref{h:hess} are as there, the vector $e$ is chosen from $\nabla f(0,z)=\theta\nabla v(z)$, and \labelcref{h:dir} holds at $(0,z)$ for large $N$. \Cref{prop:base,lem:data} give $u_0^N$ blowing up along the particle from $z$ at a time $T_*^N\le\frac43\lambda_1^{-1/8}(\log\lambda_1)^6$ with endpoint at distance at most $(m^{-1}+1)T_*^N$ from $z$, and the bounds on $u_0^N-\theta v$ are those of the proof of \cref{thm:sym}\labelcref{sym:odd}. The scaling step gives $u_0=\theta^{-1}u_0^N$, with the same endpoint and blow-up time $\theta T_*^N$. Taking $N$ large, and $s$ small first if $\nabla v(z)=0$, proves \cref{thm:main}. \end{proof} \section{Symmetry classes}\label{sec:sym} Let $G$ be a finite group of isometries $gx=Q_gx+d_g$ of $\T$. Each $Q_g$ is orthogonal and preserves $\mathbb Z^3$, so it is a signed permutation matrix; put $e_g=\det Q_g$. If $u$ solves \eqref{eq:euler}, then so does $g_*u$, with the pressure composed with $g^{-1}$, so by uniqueness the solution from $G$-invariant data is $G$-invariant. For a $G$-invariant field $U$ with flow $X$, uniqueness of trajectories gives $X(t,ga)=gX(t,a)$, so that \[ D_aX(t,ga)=Q_gD_aX(t,a)Q_g^\Tr,\qquad M(t,ga)=Q_gM(t,a)Q_g^\Tr, \] and $\curl U(t,gx)=e_gQ_g\curl U(t,x)$. The cutoff $S_\Lambda$ commutes with $g_*$, since $Q_g$ preserves $|\xi|$ and $d_g$ multiplies each Fourier mode by a phase. Let $z$ have trivial stabilizer, and fix $02$.} Let $Q$ be a cube of side $\rho/8$, with a face perpendicular to $k_*$, inside the shell $\rho/4\le|a-z|\le\rho/2$, and $\mathcal S=\{a\in Q:\operatorname{dist}(k_*\cdot(a-z),\mathbb Z)\le c_1h\}$. As $|k_*|\rho\ge\D^{-1}\lambda\rho\to\infty$, $|\mathcal S|\ge c\rho^3h$. Its image $\mathcal E=X(T,\mathcal S)$ has $|\mathcal E|=|\mathcal S|$ and lies at distance at least $\rho/(4\D)>4\lambda^{-1}$ from $x^0$ and within $\D\rho$ of it. At time $T$, for each $i>j$, the packet of $O_i$ at $z$ is supported within $\lambda_{i-1}^{-1}$ of $y_{i-1}(T)$, hence within $3\lambda^{-1}$ of $x^0$ by (F2); in the group case the other packets lie near the points $gy_{i-1}(T)$, far from $\mathcal E$. So the later oscillations vanish near $\mathcal E$, and $u(T)$ is $C^1$ there, with later increments bounded by $\sum_{i>j}\lambda_i^{-1}$ in $C^1$. On $\mathcal E$ the curl of $V_1^\natural$ is $F_h'\,\kappa\times\ba+F_h\,\bd\times(g\ba)$, with $g=1$, $F_h'\ge\frac12$ and $|\kappa\times\ba|\ge\frac9{16}\sigma_T$ by (F3) and (F4). Everything else contributes at most $2\mu^9+3$, so $|\curl u(T)|\ge\sigma_T/4\ge c\lambda^{1/4}$ on $\mathcal E$, and \[ \int_{\T}|\curl u(T)|^p\ge c^p\lambda^{p/4}|\mathcal E|\ge c_p\lambda^{p/4-1/2}\rho^3=c_p\lambda^{p/4-1/2-o(1)}\to\infty. \] \emph{The lower bound on the particle.} Let $\omega(t)=\curl u(t,y(t))$ and $\Omega(t)=|\omega(t)|$ for $t0$ on $[0,T]$, and $\Phi=\Omega'\cos t+\Omega\sin t$ satisfies $\Phi'=(\Omega''+\Omega)\cos t\ge0$ and $(\Omega/\cos t)'=\Phi/\cos^2t$. If $\Phi\le0$ throughout, $\Omega$ is bounded, which the lower bound at $t_j$ excludes; so $\Phi>0$ on some $[t^*,T)$, and $\Omega(t)\ge\cos(1)\,\Omega(s)$ for $t^*\le s\le t1$, $\tau_c=r_jd_j$, so $\widetilde\chi_j=1$. By \cite[(2.10), (2.18)]{ABC}, $\sigma_j$ lies between absolute multiples of $b_j\lambda a_{\mathrm{ref}}/\cos\varphi$, where $b_j>0$ is the scale of the seed \cite[Section~6.2]{ABC}, and by \cite[(2.14)]{ABC}, with $a_{\mathrm{ref}}$ the reference amplitude there, \[ \frac{(a_{\mathrm{ref}}/\cos\varphi)(\tau_c/2)}{(a_{\mathrm{ref}}/\cos\varphi)(\tau_c)}=\Bigl(\frac{\cos\varphi(\tau_c)}{\cos\varphi(\tau_c/2)}\Bigr)^{1/2}\exp\Bigl(-\int_{\tau_c/2}^{\tau_c}(1+e)\cos\varphi\,d\tau\Bigr). \] Since $\tan\varphi(\tau_c/2)=\tan\varphi(\tau_c)/4$, the first factor is at least $1/2$, and, as $0\le e\le\eps_{j-1}/8$ \cite[(2.13)]{ABC} and $\cos\varphi\le1/\tan\varphi$, the integral is at most $\frac98\int_{\tau_c/2}^{\tau_c}2/(\eps_{j-1}\tau^2)\,d\tau=\frac94/(\eps_{j-1}\tau_c)\le1$, since $\eps_{j-1}\tau_c\ge L_{j+1}/(\sqrt2L_j)\ge4$ by \cite[(7.9)]{ABC}. So $\sigma_j(s_j)\ge c\,\sigma_j(t_{j+1})$. The preceding wave contributes at most $2\sigma_{j-1}(t_j)\le C\mu^{1/4}L_j^2$, as in the proof of \cite[Proposition~8.2]{ABC}, and $\sigma_j(t_{j+1})\ge c\lambda_j^{1/4}$, so $\Omega(s_j)\ge c\,\sigma_j(t_{j+1})\ge c\,r_{j+1}^2$. For large $j$, $t_j\ge t^*$. On $[t_j,s_j]$, $T-t\ge d_j/2$ and $\Omega\ge\cos(1)\Omega(t_j)$, so $(T-t)^2\Omega(t)\ge c\,d_j^2r_j^2\ge c(L_jL_{j+1})^2$. On $[s_j,t_{j+1}]$, $T-t\ge t_{j+2}-t_{j+1}=d_{j+1}$ and $\Omega\ge\cos(1)\Omega(s_j)$, so $(T-t)^2\Omega(t)\ge c\,d_{j+1}^2r_{j+1}^2\ge c(L_{j+1}L_{j+2})^2$. Both tend to infinity. \end{proof} \subsection*{Use of AI} This paper and its results were produced by an AI research system that the author designed, built and directs, running on Anthropic's Claude Opus~5.5 in Claude Code and OpenAI's GPT-6.2 Astra in Codex. The author chooses the problems and prioritizes the work. Separate AI agents checked each result. The system also searched the literature and checked the citations against reliable sources. The author read the paper and takes full responsibility for all of the paper's contents. \bibliographystyle{amsplain} \bibliography{refs} \end{document}