\section{One quartic anchor for all exponents at least four}\label{sq:section} Let $a=\alpha\ge4$, $b=\pi/n$, $F(y)=-\log\sin(\pi y)$, $h(u)=u\log u-u+1$, $b_0=u-1-\log u$, $H=\E_Uh(u)$. For $n\ge5$ the original current bounds (Theorem~\ref{thm:high-source-floor}, Lemma~\ref{new:count}) give $u_i=nw_i\ge1/5$ and $w_i\le1/4$. The purpose of this section is to contradict the two physical comparisons for every nonuniform mass word on this support. We first calibrate the trial configuration at exponent four. We then bound its change with $a-4$ by a single affine function. Two scalar inequalities, one for the intercept and one for the slope, will pay this bound for the whole ray $a\ge4$. \subsection{The quartic anchor} Prescribe consecutive cells of widths $w_i$ with midpoints $\phi_i$; $d_{ij}$ is their forward fractional separation, $k^\phi_{ij}=Q_R\sin(\pi d_{ij})^{-a}$. For $v_i>0$ put $Z=\sum_{i\ne j}k^\phi_{ij}v_iv_j$, $P_{ij}=k^\phi_{ij}v_iv_j/Z$ and $U=(Z/M)\exp[2\E_w\log(m_i/v_i)]$. By the radial rows the directed $\pi_{ij}=m_im_j|z_i-z_j|^{-a}/(MC)$ has both marginals $w$. For the physical and trial forward angles $t,s$ write $r=\sin(s/2)/\sin(t/2)$, $B=(s-t)\cot(t/2)/2$. The unordered torque derivative is $-aMC\E_\pi B/2=0$. Indeed, the displacement from the physical angles to the trial angles is a permitted angular variation, and every physical angular derivative vanishes. The two marginals of $\pi$ then give the entropy identity \[ D(\pi\Vert P)=2\E_w\log(m_i/v_i)+\log[Z/(MC)] +a\E_\pi\log r =\log(U/C)+a\E_\pi\log r. \] Since $\E_\pi B=0$, this proves $\log(U/C)=D(\pi\Vert P)+a\E_\pi(B-\log r)\ge0$ by the log-sum inequality and the tangent inequality for log-sine. Proposition~\ref{prop:lower} gives the other bound $B_{\rm root}\le C$. Use \eqref{eq:cell-square} only at four; its real diagonal is \[ S_4(N)=(N^2-1)(N^2+11)/45\qquad(N>1). \] To verify this at noninteger $N$, let $K$ be the ratio in \eqref{eq:analytic-row}, $z=|\xi|$. The Gamma recurrence and reflection give $\dd\mu_2=2z\dd\xi/\sinh(\pi z)$ and $\dd\mu_4=2(1+z^2)\dd\mu_2/3$. Expanding $\coth(\pi z/N)-\coth(\pi z)$ in exponentials gives $\int K\dd\mu_2=(N^2-1)/3$ and $\int z^2K\dd\mu_2=(N^4-1)/30$ by the ordinary even sums $\zeta(2)=\pi^2/6$, $\zeta(4)=\pi^4/90$. This gives the displayed polynomial. Choose the gauge \begin{align*} r_4(y)&=(1-y^2)(1+11y^2)[\sin(\pi y)/y]^4/45,\quad c(y)=r_4(y)^{-1/2},\\ v_i&=\sqrt{w_i}\,c(w_i)\sin(\pi w_i)^{a/2}, \quad \rho_{ij}=\frac{\sqrt{\sin(\pi w_i)\sin(\pi w_j)}}{\sin(\pi d_{ij})},\\ Z_s&=\sum_{i\ne j}\sqrt{w_iw_j}\,c(w_i)c(w_j)\rho_{ij}^{s},\\ p(s)&=\frac{R_n(s)}{R_n(4)},\quad R_n(s)=\sum_{r=1}^{n-1}\left(\frac{\sin b}{\sin(rb)}\right)^s . \end{align*} Both arcs contain the half endpoint cells, hence $0<\rho_{ij}\le1$ by monotonicity on the first half and log-sine concavity. At $a=4$ the gauge satisfies $v_i^2 S_4(1/w_i)=w_i$. The diagonal in the cell square therefore sums to one and the off-diagonal sum is $Z_4$, giving $\Delta_4=1-Z_4\ge0$. At uniform masses $Z_s=p(s)$. Dropping the positive power mean in \eqref{eq:root-value} to the geometric mean at this very $a$, cancellation of $Q_R,M,v$ yields \begin{align} \log(B_{\rm root}/U)&\ge L_4+(a-4)D+\log p(a)-\log Z_a,\label{sq:base}\\ L_4&=\log S_4(n)+\E_U\log u-\E_w\log[uS_4(1/w)],\qquad D=F(1/n)-\E_w F(w).\nonumber \end{align} For example $Z=Q_R Z_a$ and $2\log v_i=\log w_i-\log r_4(w_i)+a\log\sin(\pi w_i)$, which verifies the normalization directly. \subsection{Two mass tangents} Put $P(y)=\log[(1-y^2)(1+11y^2)]$ and $J=2yP'+y^2P''$. For $01200$ by completing the quadratic square, its tangent at $2/11$ gives $K\ge685/1331-(420/121)^2/2400=14923/29282>0$. The second derivative of $uP(u/n)$ is $J(u/n)/u<6.2/n$. Subtract its unit tangent in $L_4$; the affine term cancels in the uniform mean. The remaining terms of $L_4$ equal $3h-b_0$ modulo affine functions. Hence $L_4\ge\E_U[3h-b_0-3.1(u-1)^2/n]$. For the principal sine, $-y(yF)''=C_0=2z\cot z-z^2\csc^2z$, $z=\pi y$. The cot partial fractions give nonnegative even powers in $1-z\cot z$; as $1-C_0=(1-z\cot z)+z(1-z\cot z)'$, $(1-C_0)/z^2$ increases. The endpoint $\pi/4$ gives $C_0\ge1-43y^2/4$ since $64(1-\pi/2+\pi^2/8)<43$. Integrate the negative perspective from its unit tangent: $D\ge\E_U[h-43(u-1)^2(u+2)/(24n^2)]$. \subsection{The two intervening arcs} At a nonneighbor half-rank $2\le r\le\lfloor n/2\rfloor$, $j=i+r$, put $T=(u_i+u_j)/2$. Let $I,I'$ be the sums of the two strictly intervening sets of labels, of sizes $k=r-1,k'=n-r-1$, both positive. Then $2T+I+I'=n$. Write $g=-\log\rho_{ij}$ and $g_r=\log[\sin(rb)/\sin b]$. Endpoint log-sine concavity and two integrations give \[ 2g\ge2\log\frac{\sin b(T+I)}{\sin bT} =\int_0^I\int_0^{I'}b^2\csc^2[b(T+s+s')]\dd s'\dd s>0. \] The middle sines in the mixed difference agree, as do the outer two. Scale the integration to $[0,1]^2$ and take log Jensen with the fixed probability of density $kk'b^2\csc^2[b(1+kz+k'z')]/(2g_r)$ there, applied to the ratio of the two squared cosecants. The resulting lower for $\log(g/g_r)$ is $\log(I/k)+\log(I'/k')$ minus twice the integral of the change in $\log\sin$ from $b(1+kz+k'z')$ to $b(T+Iz+I'z')$. Over all cyclic translates of the pair, $\E_U T=1$, $\E_U I=k$ and $\E_U I'=k'$ because each label occurs once in each translated slot. Hence the mean of $T+Iz+I'z'$ is $1+kz+k'z'$ for each $z,z'$. Concavity of log-sine makes the negative integral nonnegative in this mean. By log concavity each intervening average has mean logarithm at least $\E_U\log u$ (use all cyclic translates). Thus $\E_U\log(g/g_r)\ge2\E_U\log u$. \subsection{One supporting line for the entire ray} Write $x=1/n$, $t=a-4$, $R=\E_U b_0$, $V=\E_U(u-1)^2$ and \[ A=7R+11.5x^2V,\quad B=R+2x^2V,\quad q_r=e^{-g_r},\quad p_\infty=2/R_n(4). \] For $G(y)=\log[\sin(\pi y)/y]$, the even partial fractions of $-G''$ increase from $\pi^2/3$ to $2\pi^2-16<4$ on the cap. Thus $(\log r_4)''\le-2+22-4\pi^2/3<7$. The mean logarithm of the actual prefactor $\sqrt{u_i u_j}c(w_i)c(w_j)$ relative to $c(x)^2$ is at least $-R-3.5x^2V$ by its unit tangent. The numerator log-sine in $g$ has nonpositive mean displacement by concavity; its endpoint log-sine equals $\log u+G(xu)$ up to constants. Hence $\E_U(g-g_r)\le R+2x^2V$. To see how these three estimates enter the derivative, fix a nonneighbor rank and let the average below run over its $n$ cyclic translates. Put \[ a_i=\frac{\sqrt{u_i u_{i+r}}c(w_i)c(w_{i+r})}{c(x)^2}, \qquad s=4+t. \] The estimates just proved give \begin{align*} \E_U\log a_i&\ge-R-3.5x^2V,\\ \E_U\log(g_i/g_r)&\ge-2R,\\ \E_U(g_i-g_r)&\le R+2x^2V. \end{align*} Consequently their sum, with the last line multiplied by $-s$, is at least $-A-Bt$. Exponential Jensen now gives the explicit bound \[ \E_U[a_i g_i e^{-s g_i}] \ge g_r e^{-s g_r}e^{-A-Bt}. \] For each directed rank, $c(x)^2=1/R_n(4)$ and $w_i=xu_i$. Thus the contributions to $(Z_s)'$ and $p'(s)$ are, respectively, \[ -\frac{\E_U[a_i g_i e^{-s g_i}]}{R_n(4)} \qquad\text{and}\qquad -\frac{g_r e^{-s g_r}}{R_n(4)}. \] Their difference is at most $g_r e^{-s g_r}(1-e^{-A-Bt})/R_n(4)$. Since $A,B\ge0$, $1-e^{-A-Bt}\le A+Bt$. The nearest regular rank has $g_r=0$; its actual derivative is nonpositive and can be discarded in this upper bound. Swapping the pair endpoints gives equal contributions at ranks $r$ and $n-r$. Pairing these ranks, with half weight at an even antipode, yields \[ (Z-p)'(4+t)\le p_\infty\sum{}^*q_r^4 g_r e^{-g_rt}(A+Bt) \] where the star means half weight at the even antipodal rank and unit weight at other nonneighbor half-ranks. This does not substitute a surrogate inside $g e^{-sg}$. For $g=g_r$, $q=e^{-g}$ let $K(t)=\int_0^t g e^{-gs}(A+Bs)\,\dd s$. As $g\ge\log(2\cos(\pi/5))>1/4$ and $B\le4A/23$, $K''=-g e^{-gt}[g(A+Bt)-B]\le0$. Its tangent at one bounds the whole ray. The slope is at most $(A+B)/e$. On $[0,1]$ the weighted mean of $s$ against the decreasing $e^{-gs}$ is at most $1/2$ by reflection. The intercept is thus at most $(A+B/2)(1-q-qg)\le (A+B/2)(1-q)^2/(1+q)$, using $g\ge2(1-q)/(1+q)$. The ordinary sine moments, the second by cotangent multiplication and the fourth as above, give for $y=x^2$, $c_0=\pi^2$, \[ 2+2\sum{}^*q_r^2=c_0(1-y)\operatorname{sinc}^2 b/3, \quad 2+2\sum{}^*q_r^4=c_0^2(1-y)(1+11y)\operatorname{sinc}^4 b/45. \] Here $\operatorname{sinc}b=\sin(b)/b\le e^{-b^2/6}$. For an elementary verification, $\sin b-b\cos b\ge0$ follows by differentiation from zero. The derivative of $(1-b^2/3)\sin b-b\cos b$ is $b(\sin b-b\cos b)/3\ge0$. Hence $e^{b^2/6}\operatorname{sinc}b$ is nonincreasing from its value one at zero, proving the bound. The first sum is $<.65$. For the second the logarithmic factor $(1+10y-11y^2)e^{-2c_0y/3}$ increases to $y=1/25$: the derivative sign factor $10-22y-(2c_0/3)(1+10y-11y^2)$ decreases but exceeds $.024$ there. The resulting upper for $2+2\sum{}^*q_r^4$ is $<2.29998$, using $3.14159<\pi<3.14160$ and the first six exponential terms at $2(3.14159)^2/75$. Hence $\sum{}^*q_r^4<.15$. Since $q^2(1-q)^2/(1+q)\le1/20$ (for $q\le1/4$ the numerator is at most $(3/16)^2$; otherwise use $1/16$), the integrated bound is \[ Z_a-p(a)\le-\Delta_4+p_\infty\{\rho(A+B/2)+t\lambda(A+B)\}, \qquad \rho=.0325,\quad\lambda=.0552>.15/e . \] \subsection{Bounding the error using the mass distribution} We can now state the comparison delivered by these estimates. \begin{proposition}\label{sq:separation} For a nonuniform positive mass word with $n\ge5$, $u_i=nw_i\ge1/5$ and $w_i\le1/4$, the preceding trial gauge satisfies, for every $a\ge4$, \[ \log(B_{\rm root}/U)>H/50+\Delta_4/p(a)>0. \] At the uniform word $B_{\rm root}=U$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Use $\log(Z_a/p(a))\le(Z_a-p(a))/p(a)$ in \eqref{sq:base}, with $p_\infty/p(a)\le1$ only on the nonnegative error term. By the two mass tangents above it suffices to prove $W=W_0+tW_1>0$ off $u=1$, where $k=43/24$ and \begin{align*} W_0&=2.98h-(1+7.5\rho)b_0-(3.1x+12.5\rho x^2)(u-1)^2,\\ W_1&=h-8\lambda b_0-[13.5\lambda+k(u+2)]x^2(u-1)^2. \end{align*} This pays the literal intercept and the sine slope simultaneously without a separate uniform dropout maximum. The function $u^2W''$ is concave: its respective parts are $2.98u-(1+7.5\rho)-2(3.1x+12.5\rho x^2)u^2$ and $u-8\lambda-x^2u^2(27\lambda+6ku)$. Apply this observation separately to $W_0$ and $W_1$. For each, the strict superlevel set $\{u:u^2W_i''(u)>0\}$ is an interval containing one, because $u^2W_i''$ is concave and positive at one. On that interval, $W_i(1)=W_i'(1)=0$ and strict convexity give $W_i(u)>0$ for $u\ne1$. On either remaining portion of the support $[1/5,1/(4x)]$, $W_i''\le0$, so $W_i$ is bounded below by the chord between its endpoint values. The value adjoining the central interval is positive by the preceding argument. It therefore remains only to check the two original support endpoints. This also covers the case where one or both outer portions are empty. At $u=1/5$ both costs are worst at $x=1/5$. On the other end write $s=1/(4x)\ge5/4$; each $W_i(s)$ is $E(s)=P h(s)-Q b_0(s)-(l s+m)(1-1/s)^2$, with rows \[ (P,Q,l,m)= (2.98,1+7.5\rho,3.1/4,12.5\rho/16),\quad (1,8\lambda,k/16,(2k+13.5\lambda)/16). \] Put $J=s^4E''=P s^3-Qs^2-2(l-2m)s-6m$. Direct substitution gives the following strict lower bounds, the first two at $x=1/5$ and the last five at $s=5/4$: \[ \begin{array}{c|rrrrrrr} &W_i''(1)&W_i(1/5)&J&J'&J''&E&E'\\ \hline 0&.46&.0107&1.91&9.41&19.86&.0130&.1307\\ 1&.068&.00064&.712&4.44&6.61&.00064&.0252 \end{array} \] Here $\log5<1.6095$, $\log(5/4)>.22314$ follow from the positive $2\operatorname{arctanh}z$ series at $z=2/3,1/9$, with 24 and four terms and tail at most $2z^{2j+1}/[(2j+1)(1-z^2)]$. Machin's alternating formula gives the stated $\pi$ bounds. Since $J'''=6P>0$, both cap endpoint functions are positive on their whole ray. The left endpoint and unit curvature therefore complete the claim for every label. Since $h''(u)=1/u>0$ and $h(1)=h'(1)=0$, a nonuniform word has $H>0$. Averaging $W_0+(a-4)W_1$ thus gives \[ \log(B_{\rm root}/U)>H/50+\Delta_4/p(a)>0 . \] At the uniform word $B_{\rm root}=U$. \end{proof}