\section{The lower diagonal of the joint comparison}\label{app:middlediagonal} This appendix treats $u=1-\delta$, $m=1-2\delta$, $d=0$, with $0\leq\delta\leq1/8$. All derivatives in this appendix are with respect to $\delta$, unless an exponent derivative is specified. The positive normalization is $\mathcal N=p(p+1)m^{-p-2}$. \begin{lemma}[Diagonal curvature]\label{mid:diagonalcurvature} For $1\leq p\leq9/5$ and the fixed coefficients \eqref{mid:valuemultipliers}, \[ \Phi'''(\delta)/\mathcal N>.08. \] In particular $\Phi(\delta)/\delta$ is strictly convex, with its continuous value at zero given by $g_*(p,1,0)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} We split the derivative as \[ \Phi'''=S'''+(\lambda_*-\mu_*)q''' +\mu_*(H'''+q'''). \] We will prove \begin{align} q'''/\mathcal N&>8.03+5(p-1),\label{md:qthird}\\ H'''+q'''&>0,\label{md:Hqthird}\\ S'''/\mathcal N&> .811153846-1.587692308t+.28t^2-1.89+1.52t-.1, \quad t=p-1.\label{md:Sthird} \end{align} For the adjacent row write \[ q=q_{\rm known}+q_{\rm right},\quad q_{\rm known}=T_{B_u}(0,1)+(\delta-pm)u^{-p}, \quad q_{\rm right}=m^{1-p}F(U), \] where $U=u/m$, $\ell=2U-1=1/m$ and $F(U)=\sum_{j\geq1}A_U(j)$. In the known part, $B_u(j)=upj^{-p-1}-j^{-p}+(j+u)^{-p}$. Its only contribution after three derivatives is the positive sum $(p)_3\sum_{j\ge1}(j+u)^{-p-3}$. For the finite term, write $(\delta-pm)u^{-p}=(p+1)u^{-p}-(2p+1)u^{1-p}$. Thus, with $A=(p+1)(p+2)$ and $B=(2p+1)(p-1)$, \[ q_{\rm known}'''/\mathcal N> (m/u)^{p+2}(A-Bu)/u. \] The logarithmic $\delta$ derivative of this lower bound is $-(p+2-m)/(mu)+B/(A-Bu)<0$, since $A>2B$ on $[1,9/5]$. At $\delta=1/8$ use $(6/7)^{p+2}\ge(6/7)^4(9-p)/7$, from $e^s\ge1+s$ and $\log(7/6)>1/7$. This gives \[ q_{\rm known}'''/\mathcal N >\frac{10368(9-p)}{117649} (-3p^2/4+31p/8+23/8)>4.23. \] The polynomial on the right increases on $[1,9/5]$: its derivative decreases and is positive at $9/5$. The normalized right derivative is the pole-free expression \[ \widehat R=8(p-1)F+12\ell F'+6\ell^2F''/p +\ell^3F'''/[p(p+1)], \] where these primes denote $U$ derivatives. This increases with $U$. To verify the whole-series sign, in each summand put $z=\ell/(j+U)\leq8/13$ and $k=\ell/U\geq1$. After positive factors are removed, the derivative is affine in $k$ with positive coefficient. At $k=1$ its numerator is \[ N(p,z)=4(p+1)(2p+3)-12(p+2)^2z +3(p+3)(2p+5)z^2-(p+3)(p+4)z^3. \] It decreases with $z$ and increases with $p$ at $z=8/13$. In particular $N(1,8/13)=1512/2197>0$ and $N_p(1,8/13)=14580/2197>0$; the second derivatives preserve these signs on the indicated rectangle. At $U=1$ the complete expression is \begin{align*} 8(p-1)(p+1-Z)&+6(2p+1)(p+1)[\zeta(p+2)-1]\\ &-(6p+8)(p+2)[\zeta(p+3)-1] +(p+2)(p+3)[\zeta(p+4)-1]. \end{align*} Here $p+1-Z\geq.31534+.3t$. If $b=9/5-p$, complete monotonicity of zeta and its endpoint moments give \[ \zeta(p+2)-1> .09751+.0835b+.0405b^2+(.094/6)b^3+(.126/24)b^4. \] For these five coefficients, sum $n^{-19/5}(\log n)^j$ from $n=2$ through $128$, with $j=0,1,2,3,4$, and divide by $j!$. Each sum is a lower bound because the omitted terms are positive. Enclose the power by fifth-root bisection to width $10^{-18}$ as in Appendix~\ref{app:middleendpoint}. For the logarithm write $n=2^\ell v$, $1\le v<2$, and keep the first 12 terms of $2\sum_{k\ge0}[(v-1)/(v+1)]^{2k+1}/(2k+1)$ and the same series at $v=2$ for $\log2$. These rational lower sums give the five displayed bounds. Also $\zeta(p+3)-1<.0824-.049t$ and $\zeta(p+4)-1\geq2^{-p-4}\geq.03125-.0216875t$. Substitution gives the lower polynomial \[ L_r=4.1286624+3.5105408t+1.3516743t^2+.9608485t^3 +.00452t^4-.1691t^5+.063t^6>3.8+5t. \] For the last inequality discard the positive fourth and sixth terms, use $-.1691t^5\geq-.108224t^3$, and put $v=t-.4$. The difference is at least $.003714576+.00114v+2.0337739v^2>0$. This proves \eqref{md:qthird}. For \eqref{md:Hqthird}, the finite terms of $H_{\rm left}+q_{\rm known}$ cancel to $-mu^{-p}+u(3u-1)^{-p}$. The first term has third derivative $p(p+1)u^{-p-3}[p+2-2(p-1)u]>0$. For the second, write it as $[(3u-1)^{1-p}+(3u-1)^{-p}]/3$; both third derivatives are nonnegative. The paired left tail has third derivative $(p)_3$ times \[ \sum_{j\geq1}x^{-p-3}[(p+3)r-6+27(1+r)^{-p-3}], \qquad x=u+j,\quad r=m/x\leq1/2. \] The bracket decreases with $r$, and at $r=1/2$ decreases with $p+3\in[4,24/5]$. It is positive at $24/5$, since $(3/2)^{24/5}<15/2$. The remaining right comparison is $\widehat R>8(p-1)(Z-1)$. The right side is at most $5.16t+6t^2$, while $L_r-5.16t-6t^2$ decreases and is greater than $.28$ at $t=.8$. This establishes the sign, including $p=1$ without division by $p-1$. We next estimate the third derivative of $S$, retaining its first two sites separately. For every site $x$, the convergent central expansion is \begin{align*} G_u(x)={}&\sum_{n\geq0} \frac{[2n/(2n+1)-\delta](p)_{2n+1}}{2^{2n}(2n)!} (x+1/2)^{-p-2n-1}\\ &+b\sum_{n\geq0}\frac{(p)_{2n+2}}{2^{2n+1}(2n+1)!} (x+1/2)^{-p-2n-2}, \quad b=.52-\delta+.48\delta^2. \end{align*} For $j\geq2$, put $y_j=u+jm+1/2$ and $X=1/y_j\leq8/23$. The derivatives of $my_j^{-q}$ are \begin{align*} D_1&=2y_j^{-q}[q-1-qX],\\ D_2&=(4q/m)y_j^{-q}(1-X)[q-1-(q+1)X],\\ D_3&=(8q(q+1)/m^2)y_j^{-q}(1-X)^2[q-1-(q+2)X]. \end{align*} The ratio $D_3/D_2$ increases with $q$ and decreases with $X$. For every odd correction $n\geq1$, its minimum is $450/77>5.84$, whereas its coefficient is at least $13/24$; therefore the derivative of that complete correction is positive. For the first even correction the ratio is at least $15/2$ and $b\geq161/400$, giving the same sign; all higher corrections are stronger. It suffices to retain \[ G_{\rm base}(y)=-p\delta y^{-p-1}+[bp(p+1)/2]y^{-p-2}. \] To record the complete tail calculation, put $h=\delta/m$, $\ell=1+2h$, $Y=7/2+2h$, $B=.52+1.08h+.56h^2$, $e=1+1.04h$. The normalized third derivative of each base site is $\sum_{k=0}^4C_k(j+3/2+2h)^{-p-1-k}$, where \begin{align*} C_0={}&-8hp(p+2)-12p,\\ C_1={}&[24h(p+2)(p+1)+24(p+1)]\ell +(p+1)[4B(p+2)(p+3)-6e(p+2)+2.88],\\ C_2={}&-[24h(p+2)^2+12(p+2)]\ell^2 +[-12B(p+2)^2(p+3)+12e(p+2)^2-2.88(p+2)]\ell,\\ C_3={}&8h(p+2)(p+3)\ell^3 +[12B(p+2)(p+3)^2-6e(p+2)(p+3)]\ell^2,\\ C_4={}&-4B(p+2)(p+3)(p+4)\ell^3. \end{align*} The signs alternate. Apply the Euler upper through $B_2$ to the negative coefficients and the lower through $B_4$ to the positive ones. After dividing by $Y^{-p}$, the lower is \[ L=\sum_{k=0}^4 C_k\left[ \frac{1}{(p+k)Y^k}+\frac{1}{2Y^{k+1}}+ \frac{p+1+k}{12Y^{k+2}}\right] -\sum_{k=1,3}\frac{C_k(p+k+1)_3}{720Y^{k+4}}. \] To verify $L>-(6.898-.303p)$, expand $Y^7(p)_5(L+6.898-.303p)$ as $\sum q_{ij}v^iw^j$ with $p=1+4v/5$, $h=w/6$. Its bidegree is $(11,7)$. The minimum of the Bernstein coefficients \[ \sum_{i=0}^{r}\sum_{j=0}^{s}q_{ij} \frac{\binom ri\binom sj}{\binom{11}i\binom7j}, \qquad 0\le r\le11,\quad 0\le s\le7, \] is $415341507/640>0$. The complete $j\geq2$ tail therefore exceeds \[ -(6.898-.303p)(7/2)^{-p}>-[1.89-1.52t]. \] The final comparison is the convex chord of the positive expression, whose endpoint uppers are $1.89$ and $.674$. For $j=0$, put $\alpha_0=.48p(p-1)(2-p)/(p+1)<.075$. The unshifted part, divided by $p(p+1)$, is \[ u^{-p-3}[-\alpha_0u^2+(p-1)(4p/5-2)u +(p+2)(1-13p/25)]. \] The known term and the shifted part together are positive. After multiplication by $v^{p+4}$, $v=u+1\geq15/8$, their numerator is \[ \frac{1.44}{p+1}v^{p+4}+\alpha_0v^3 +(p-1)(2+66p/25)v^2-(p+2)(3+108p/25)v +(54/25)(p+2)(p+3). \] It increases with $v$. At $15/8$ it is greater than $1.43-4.4625t+4.34125t^2>0$. The remaining unshifted bracket is bounded using $B_0=.28p^2-2.84p+4-\alpha_0$, $[B_0]_+\leq1.8(P-p)$, and $1\geq m^{p+2}u^{-p-3}>8/13$. This gives the lower $.811153846-1.587692308t+.28t^2$. For $j=1$, put $x=3u-1$, $y=3u$. Its derivative divided by $p(p+1)$ is \[ x^{-p-4}[-\alpha_0x^3+A x^2+B_1x-C_1] +y^{-p-3}[\alpha_0y^2+D_1y-E_1], \] with \[ \begin{gathered}A=(p-1)(96p/25-18),\quad B_1=(p+2)(39p/25+9),\\ C_1=(9/5)(p+2)(p+3).\end{gathered} \] \[ D_1=(18/5)(p-1)(p+5),\qquad E_1=27(p+2)(1+4p/25). \] The first numerator divided by $x$ is concave in $x$ and its minimum exceeds ten. Use $(y/x)^{p+3}\geq(3/2)^{p+3}>(2479/1000)(p+1)$. The remaining numerator is bounded below by \begin{align*} T_j={}&k(p+1)[(87/13)p^2-(37581/1300)p+10557/260]\\ &-k(2028/1600)p(p-1)(2-p)+(513/100)p^2+(54/25)p-405/4, \qquad k=2479/1000. \end{align*} Its positive normalization is at most $(8/7)3^{-p-3}$. To prove a lower $-.1$, set $W=T_j+(189/80)3^p$. Differentiation gives $W''>8$ on $[1,6/5]$, $W'(6/5)<-10$, $W(6/5)>1.5$. On $[6/5,P]$, $W''>30$, $W(7/5)>.57$ and $|W'(7/5)|<.8$, whose quadratic lower is positive. These tests use $4.65<3^{7/5}<4.656$ and $1.098<\log3<1.099$. Hence $W>0$, proving the claimed $-.1$. This finishes \eqref{md:Sthird}. Finally $\lambda_*-\mu_*>.1573$ and \eqref{md:qthird}--\eqref{md:Sthird} give \[ \Phi'''/\mathcal N>.08427+.7188t+.28t^2>.08. \] Since $\Phi(0)=0$, write $\Phi(\delta)/\delta=\int_0^1\Phi'(t\delta)\dd t$. Its second derivative is the positive integral $\int_0^1t^2\Phi'''(t\delta)\dd t$. This proves the last assertion. \end{proof}