\section{Angular convexity and elementary cases}\label{sec:geometry} Write $z_i=R(\cos\theta_i,\sin\theta_i)$ and $d_{ij}=|z_i-z_j|$. We label the points in their cyclic order. Taking the scalar product of \eqref{eq:force} with $z_i$ and using \[ z_i\mathbin{\cdot}(z_j-z_i)=-\tfrac12d_{ij}^{2} \] gives the common radial value \begin{equation}\label{eq:radial} C_i:=\sum_{j\ne i}m_jd_{ij}^{-\alpha}=2\lambda R^2=:C>0. \end{equation} The tangential projection says that the angular potential is stationary. For $\alpha>0$ we also use the unscaled energy \[ U_\alpha(m,\theta)=\sum_{i0$, and $\alpha\ge0$. Up to a common rotation, there is at most one angular critical configuration with that order. If one exists, it is the unique minimum of the angular energy on the ordered chamber. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Fix $\theta_1=0$ and work on the convex chamber $0<\theta_2<\cdots<\theta_n<2\pi$. For $00,\\ -\log[2R\sin(t/2)],&\alpha=0. \end{cases} \] Differentiation gives, in both cases, \[ v_\alpha''(t)=\tfrac14[2R\sin(t/2)]^{-\alpha} \{1+(\alpha+1)\cot^2(t/2)\}>0. \] The second variation of $\sum_{i0$ for every $\alpha\ge0$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} In a regular polygon, the terms at forward and backward cyclic rank have opposite tangential components. An antipodal term, when present, has zero tangential component. Thus the regular polygon is angular critical. Lemma~\ref{lem:angular} proves uniqueness for equal masses. Its center of mass is the circle center, since the sum of the $n$th roots of unity is zero. The radial rows are identical and positive by cyclic symmetry, so their common value gives $\lambda=C/(2R^2)>0$. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:log} Theorem~\ref{thm:main} holds at $\alpha=0$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Equation~\eqref{eq:radial} becomes $M-m_i=C$. Hence the masses are equal, and Corollary~\ref{cor:equal} applies. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:small} Theorem~\ref{thm:main} holds for $2\le n\le4$ and every $\alpha\ge0$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} For two bodies, $m_1z_1=-m_2z_2$ and equal positive radii imply equal masses at antipodal points. For three bodies, the center-of-mass condition gives \[ \sum_{j\ne i}m_j(z_j-z_i)=-Mz_i. \] Subtracting $\lambda/M$ times this identity from the force equation gives \[ \sum_{j\ne i}m_j\bigl(d_{ij}^{-\alpha-2}-\lambda/M\bigr)(z_j-z_i)=0. \] Three distinct points on a circle are not collinear, so the two chord vectors in this sum are independent. Every coefficient is zero. Since $\alpha+2>0$, the three distances are equal. The only linear dependence between the three radius vectors of an equilateral triangle is their sum, so the center-of-mass equation forces equal masses. It remains to consider four bodies with $\alpha>0$. In their cyclic order, each opposite transposition $P=(1\;3)$ or $(2\;4)$ reverses that order. Reflection of the original critical configuration, followed by this relabeling and a rotation, gives an angular critical configuration for the mass word $Pm$, with the same energy as the original one. By Lemma~\ref{lem:angular}, this is the minimum for $Pm$. In particular, at the original angles, \[ U_\alpha(Pm,\theta)\ge U_\alpha(m,\theta). \] For a transposition of $i$ and $j$, put $\delta=(m_j-m_i)(e_i-e_j)$. The energy is quadratic in the masses. Its linear change is $C\sum_k\delta_k=0$, and its quadratic change is $\delta_i\delta_jd_{ij}^{-\alpha}$. Consequently \[ U_\alpha(Pm,\theta)-U_\alpha(m,\theta) =-(m_i-m_j)^2d_{ij}^{-\alpha}. \] Both opposite masses must agree; write the cyclic word as $(A,B,A,B)$. A square is angular critical for this word, by cancellation of the two adjacent terms at each vertex. Angular uniqueness identifies the positions with that square. Comparing an $A$ row and a $B$ row now gives \[ (A-B)\{(2R)^{-\alpha}-2(\sqrt2R)^{-\alpha}\}=0. \] The bracket is strictly negative. Thus $A=B$, completing the proof. \end{proof}