\documentclass[11pt]{amsart} \usepackage[a4paper,margin=2.6cm]{geometry} \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,enumitem} \usepackage[colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue,citecolor=blue,urlcolor=blue]{hyperref} \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark} \newtheorem{hypothesis}[theorem]{Standing data} \newcommand{\st}{\operatorname{st}} \newcommand{\en}{\operatorname{en}} \begin{document} \title[The degree pair $(88,132)$ in the plane Jacobian problem]{The degree pair $(88,132)$ in the plane Jacobian problem:\\ exclusion of the shape with starting corner $(11,33)$ and final corner $(19/4,8)$} \author{David Niedbala Giraudin} \address{Independent researcher, France} \thanks{ORCID: 0009-0009-1526-1178} \date{20 November 2026} \begin{abstract} In the list of Guccione, Guccione, Horruitiner and Valqui of the possible shapes of a counterexample to the plane Jacobian conjecture with degrees at most $150$, exactly one shape has maximal degree $132$, up to the exchange of the two polynomials: the standard $(2,3)$-pairs of degrees $(88,132)$ with starting corner $(11,33)$ and final corner $(19/4,8)$. We show that no such pair exists, when it is normalised as in Corollary 5.21 of Guccione--Guccione--Valqui. The two sides of the Newton polygon are described by the results of Guccione--Guccione--Valqui. In suitable polynomial coordinates the pair is confined to an explicit finite system of polynomial equations. Its leading part has exactly two solutions, defined over $\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-3})$ and exchanged by its non-trivial automorphism; for each of them the system is solved order by order by linear algebra over that field, and the compatibility conditions of the first twelve orders, six polynomials in three unknowns, generate the unit ideal. The computation is exact and is reproduced by an ancillary script (SymPy, and Singular for three Gr\"obner bases). All statements are proved relative to the cited results. Nothing in this note has been checked by a third party. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Statement} Throughout, $K$ is an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, $L=K[x,y]$, $[P,Q]=P_xQ_y-P_yQ_x$ and $(m,n)=(2,3)$. We use the notation of \cite{GGV1}: for a weight $(\rho,\sigma)$, $v_{\rho,\sigma}$ is the weighted degree, $\ell_{\rho,\sigma}$ the leading form, $\st_{\rho,\sigma}$ and $\en_{\rho,\sigma}$ its end points; $L^{(l)}=K[x^{\pm1/l},y]$. \emph{Standard $(m,n)$-pairs}, their \emph{starting triple} and their \emph{regular corners} are defined in \cite[Definitions 4.3, 6.2, 5.5]{GGV1}. Put $t:=xy^4$. \begin{hypothesis}\label{data} $(P,Q)$ is a standard $(2,3)$-pair in $L$ with $[P,Q]=J\in K^\times$, $\deg P=88$, $\deg Q=132$, starting triple $\bigl((11,33),(3,1),(4,-1)\bigr)$, and $(-1,1)<\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)<(-1,0)$ as in \cite[Corollary 5.21(4)]{GGV1}. Thus: \begin{enumerate}[label=(D\arabic*),leftmargin=3em] \item the support of $P$ lies in $\{(i,j):4i-j\le 22\}$, that of $Q$ in $\{4i-j\le 33\}$, and \[ \ell_{4,-1}(P)=\lambda_P\bigl(x^3y\,h(t)\bigr)^2,\qquad \ell_{4,-1}(Q)=\lambda_Q\bigl(x^3y\,h(t)\bigr)^3, \qquad \lambda_P,\lambda_Q\in K^\times, \] with $h\in K[t]$ monic of degree $8$, $h(0)\ne0$ \cite[Proposition 6.1, Theorem 7.6(2)]{GGV1}. \end{enumerate} \end{hypothesis} \begin{theorem}\label{main} There is no pair $(P,Q)$ as in Standing data~\ref{data}. \end{theorem} This is the shape with corners $(11,33)$, $(19/4,8)$ and $(m,n)=(2,3)$ of \cite[Section 6]{GGV4}: by \cite[Theorem 2.20, items (5), (8), (13)]{GGV4} the second corner lies on the line through $(11,33)$ of direction $(1/4,1)$ given by the direction of the starting triple, which is therefore $(4,-1)$, and Lemma~\ref{roots} below shows that the middle entry of the triple is then necessarily $(3,1)$. We found no exclusion of this shape in the literature we searched; its novelty is not otherwise verified. The four authors treat in \cite{GGHV22} the shapes of degree below $125$ and obtain the bound $108$. \section{The roots of $h$} \begin{lemma}\label{roots} Let $(P,Q)$ be a standard $(2,3)$-pair in $L$ with a regular corner $((11,33),(4,-1))$. Then $\frac12\st_{4,-1}(P)=(3,1)$. In Standing data~\ref{data}, $h=(t-c)^8$ with $c\in K^\times$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The point $A':=\frac12\st_{4,-1}(P)$ lies in $\mathbb Z\times\mathbb N_0$, on the line through $(11,33)$ of direction $(1/4,1)$ and below $(11,33)$ \cite[Proposition 5.14 and its proof]{GGV1}: $A'=(11-e,33-4e)$ with $1\le e\le8$. The corner is of Case II in the sense of \cite[Section 5, before Remark 5.9]{GGV1}: Case I would require $l-a/b=1-\frac13>1$ \cite[Proposition 5.13]{GGV1}, and Case III would require that $\rho=4$ divides $l=1$ \cite[Proposition 5.17]{GGV1}. If $e\le7$ then $v_{1,-1}(A')<0$, and $A'$ is the first entry of a regular corner of $(P,Q)$ \cite[Remark 5.11]{GGV1}, which requires $\gcd(11-e,33-4e)>1$ \cite[Proposition 5.19]{GGV1} (the other alternative of that proposition, $l-a/b>1$, is impossible for $l=1$); but $\gcd(11-e,33-4e)=\gcd(11-e,11)=1$. Hence $e=8$ and $A'=(3,1)$. In $\tilde z:=x^{1/4}y$ one has $\ell_{4,-1}(P)=x^{11/2}p(\tilde z)$ with $p(\tilde z)=\lambda_P\tilde z^2h(\tilde z^4)^2$; the bracket of $\ell_{4,-1}(P)$ and $\ell_{4,-1}(Q)$ vanishes, both being powers of $x^3y\,h(t)$ up to constants, $p$ has at least five distinct roots and $v_{1,-1}(\st_{4,-1}(P))=v_{1,-1}(6,2)>0$. By \cite[Proposition 5.16]{GGV1} some root $\lambda\ne0$ of $p$ has multiplicity at least $\frac ml\cdot\frac{a\rho+bl\sigma}{\rho+\sigma}=2\cdot\frac{44-33}{3}=\frac{22}3$ (the root can be taken different from $0$, the multiplicity $2$ of the root $0$ being smaller than this bound). A root of $h$ of multiplicity $k$ gives roots of $p$ of multiplicity $2k$; so some root $c$ of $h$ has multiplicity $k\ge4$, and by \cite[Proposition 5.18]{GGV1} some $(2,3)$-pair in $L^{(4)}$ has a regular corner at $(\frac{11}4,0)+k(\frac14,1)=(\frac{11+k}4,k)$. By \cite[Proposition 5.19]{GGV1} this point would be the first entry of a regular corner of Case I or of Case II. Case II requires $\gcd(11+k,k)>1$ \cite[Proposition 5.14(4)]{GGV1}, which fails for $4\le k\le8$. In Case I, with direction $(\rho,\sigma)$, \cite[Proposition 1.13, Corollary 5.7(2)]{GGV1} give $2(\frac{11+k}4\rho+k\sigma)=\frac25(\rho+\sigma)$, which determines $(\rho,\sigma)$, and \cite[Proposition 5.13]{GGV1} requires a positive integer $a'$ with $\frac\rho4\cdot2a'=v(P)$ or a positive integer $k'$ with $\frac\rho4k'\in\{v(P),v(Q)\}$, where $v(P)=\frac25(\rho+\sigma)$ and $v(Q)=\frac35(\rho+\sigma)$. For $k=4,5,6,7$ the directions are $(76,-71)$, $(24,-19)$, $(116,-81)$, $(68,-43)$ and no such integer exists (ancillary script). Hence $k=8$. \end{proof} \section{The left side} \begin{lemma}\label{left} There is $\gamma\in K$ such that \[ \hat P(z,v):=P\bigl(zv^3+\gamma v^2,\,v^{-1}\bigr),\qquad \hat Q(z,v):=Q\bigl(zv^3+\gamma v^2,\,v^{-1}\bigr) \] are polynomials in $z,v$. Then $\hat P$ has total degree $22$ with top form $\lambda_P z^6(z-cv)^{16}$, $\hat Q$ has total degree $33$ with top form $\lambda_Q z^9(z-cv)^{24}$, and \[ \hat P_z\hat Q_v-\hat P_v\hat Q_z=-J\,v . \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The argument is the one of \cite[Section 4, Case $(7,21)$]{GGHV22}; we give it in detail. Apply the flip $\psi_1$ of \cite[Section 8]{GGV1}, so that the weight $(4,-1)$ becomes $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)=(-1,4)$, with $\st_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(66,22)$ and $\en_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(2,6)$ for the flipped $P$, and $\frac1m\st=\frac1n\st=(33,11)$. Let $F$ be the element of \cite[Theorem 2.6]{GGV1} for $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)$; then $v_{-1,4}(F)=3$. If $\st(F)=(1,1)$ then $\en(F)\ne(1,1)$, since $F$ is not a monomial \cite[Remark 2.5]{GGV1}, so $\en(F)\sim\en(P)\sim(1,3)$ and $\en(F)=\frac3{11}(1,3)$, which is impossible; hence $\st(F)\sim(33,11)$, so $\st(F)=(9,3)=\frac3{11}(33,11)$ and $q=11$ in \cite[Corollary 7.4]{GGV1}. That corollary applies to the flipped pair (its hypotheses hold with $(a/l,b)=(33,11)$, and $\rho_0+\sigma_0>0$): for every weight between $(1,-3)$ and $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)$ at which the pair has an edge, the edge form of $P$ is a power $R^{22}$. In the original variables: for a weight $(-s,1)$ with $s<3$ carrying an edge with starting point $(22,66)$, the form is $(xy^3-\gamma y^{3-s})^{22}$ up to a constant, so $s\in\mathbb Z$, and $s\ge2$ by the condition on $\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)$; thus $s=2$. Here $(22,66)=\en_{4,-1}(P)$ is the starting point of the edge at $\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)$: an edge of $P$ with a direction strictly between $(4,-1)$ and $(1,1)$ starting at $(22,66)$ would end at a point with $v_{1,1}>88=\deg P$ \cite[Remark 1.8]{GGV1}, and by the condition on $\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)$ there is no direction of $P$ between $(1,1)$ and $(-1,1)$; then \cite[Proposition 3.7]{GGV1} applies. The weights $(-s,1)$ with $s<3$ are in the range of the corollary, because $v_{-s,1}(22,66)=22(3-s)>0$. The translation $x\mapsto x+\gamma y^{-2}$ removes this edge \cite[Proposition 3.9]{GGV1} (take $\gamma=0$ if there is no such edge). By \cite[Proposition 3.9]{GGV1} the leading forms of the translated pair at the weights between $(4,-1)$ and $(-2,1)$ are unchanged, and its $(-2,1)$-form is the monomial $x^{22}y^{66}$; so an edge with starting point $(22,66)$ and $s<3$ could only occur for $21$; this holds at every step below, since it depends only on the point $A_1$. In Case III, \cite[Proposition 5.17]{GGV1} gives $\rho'\mid4$, and the translation $y\mapsto y+\lambda'x^{\sigma'/\rho'}$ produces a $(2,3)$-pair in $L^{(4)}$ with a regular corner at the same point $A_1$ and a smaller direction. After finitely many steps Case I occurs, for a pair $(P_1,Q_1)$ and a direction $(\rho,\sigma)$. There $v_{\rho,\sigma}(P_1)+v_{\rho,\sigma}(Q_1)=\rho+\sigma$ \cite[Proposition 1.13]{GGV1}, while $\en(P_1)=2A_1=\frac23\en(Q_1)$ \cite[Corollary 5.7(2)]{GGV1}. Hence $2(\tfrac{19}{4}\rho+8\sigma)=\tfrac25(\rho+\sigma)$, that is $(\rho,\sigma)=(12,-7)$, $v(P_1)=2$, $v(Q_1)=3$. By \cite[Proposition 5.13]{GGV1} either $\frac12\st(P_1)=(a'/4,0)$ with $a'\in\mathbb N$, which would give $6a'=2$; or $\{\st(P_1),\st(Q_1)\}=\{(k'/4,0),(1-k'/4,1)\}$ with $k'\in\mathbb N$. If $\st(P_1)=(k'/4,0)$ then $3k'=2$; so $\st(Q_1)=(k'/4,0)$ with $3k'=3$, that is $\st(Q_1)=(1/4,0)$ and $\st(P_1)=(3/4,1)$. The directions of the Case III steps decrease strictly from $(4,-1)$ and stay larger than the direction $(12,-7)$ of the final Case I corner, which is determined by the point $A_1$; they have $\rho'\in\{1,2,4\}$. The only such direction is $(2,-1)$ (the direction $(4,-3)$ is smaller than $(12,-7)$), so there is at most one such step, a translation $y\mapsto y+\lambda_2x^{-1/2}$. Finally $v_{12,-7}(x^{i/4}y^j)=3i-7j$, $\en(P_1)=(38/4,16)$ and $\en(Q_1)=(57/4,24)$. \end{proof} \section{Common coordinates} Let $\mathcal A$ be the set of formal sums $\sum c_{ij}X^i\eta^j$ ($i\in\mathbb Z$, $j\ge0$) such that, for every $r$, only finitely many terms have $W=3i-7j\ge r$. It is a ring containing $K[X^{\pm1},\eta]$; for $f\ne0$ let $W(f)$ be the largest weight of its terms and $\ell(f)$ the sum of the terms of that weight. Then $\ell(fg)=\ell(f)\ell(g)$ and $W(fg)=W(f)+W(g)$, and $1+\varepsilon$ is invertible in $\mathcal A$ when $W(\varepsilon)<0$. \begin{lemma}\label{coord} Let $\gamma$, $\lambda,\lambda_2$ be as in Lemmas~\ref{left} and~\ref{corner}, and put \[ \zeta:=z-c\,v-\kappa,\qquad \kappa:=4\lambda^2\lambda_2 . \] Write $\hat P=\sum p_{ab}\zeta^av^b$ and $\hat Q=\sum q_{ab}\zeta^av^b$ in $K[z,v]=K[\zeta,v]$. Then $p_{ab}\ne0$ implies $3b-a\le2$ and $a+b\le22$; $q_{ab}\ne0$ implies $3b-a\le3$ and $a+b\le33$. Moreover $p_{1,1}$, $p_{16,6}$, $q_{0,1}$, $q_{24,9}$ are non-zero, the part of $\hat P$ of degree $22$ is $\lambda_P\zeta^{16}(\zeta+cv)^6$, and $\hat P_\zeta\hat Q_v-\hat P_v\hat Q_\zeta=-J\,v$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The substitution $z=\zeta+cv+\kappa$ does not increase the total degree and turns the top form of Lemma~\ref{left} into $\lambda_P\zeta^{16}(\zeta+cv)^6$; it preserves the bracket. In $\mathcal A$ the element $Y$ of Lemma~\ref{corner} is $\lambda X^{-1}(1+\varepsilon)$ with $W(\varepsilon)<0$; it is invertible. The assignment $v\mapsto Y^{-1}$, $z\mapsto X^4Y^3-\gamma Y$ defines a ring morphism $K[z,v]\to\mathcal A$ which sends $\hat P$ to $P_1$ and $\hat Q$ to $Q_1$, because $P(x,y)=\hat P\bigl((x-\gamma y^{-2})y^3,y^{-1}\bigr)$ in $K[x,y^{\pm1}]$. Expanding (ancillary script), the image of $v$ has $W=3$ and leading term $X/\lambda$, and the image of $\zeta$ has $W=-1$ and leading term $4\lambda^2\eta X^2$: the terms of weights $3$ and $0$ cancel by the choice of $c=\lambda^4$ and $\kappa$. Hence the image of $\zeta^av^b$ has leading term a non-zero multiple of $\eta^aX^{2a+b}$, of weight $3b-a$, and these monomials are distinct for distinct $(a,b)$. Therefore, for a non-zero polynomial, the value of $W$ on the image of $\sum c_{ab}\zeta^av^b$ is $\max\{3b-a:c_{ab}\ne0\}$, and the leading part is the image of the corresponding terms. Lemma~\ref{corner} gives the values $2$ and $3$ for the images of $\hat P$ and $\hat Q$; the monomials $X^3\eta$, $X^{38}\eta^{16}$, $X$, $X^{57}\eta^{24}$ correspond to $\zeta v$, $\zeta^{16}v^6$, $v$, $\zeta^{24}v^9$. \end{proof} \section{The finite system} By Lemmas~\ref{roots}--\ref{coord}, a pair as in the standing data yields a solution of the following system. \begin{enumerate}[label=(S\arabic*),leftmargin=3em] \item $\hat P=\sum p_{ab}\zeta^av^b$ with $a,b\ge0$, $a+b\le22$, $3b-a\le2$; $\hat Q=\sum q_{ab}\zeta^av^b$ with $a,b\ge0$, $a+b\le33$, $3b-a\le3$; and $p_{1,1}\,p_{16,6}\,q_{0,1}\ne0$. \item $\hat P_\zeta\hat Q_v-\hat P_v\hat Q_\zeta=-J\,v$ with $J\in K^\times$. \item The part of $\hat P$ on the line $a+b=22$ is $\lambda_P\,\zeta^{16}(\zeta+c\,v)^6$, with $\lambda_P,c\in K^\times$. \end{enumerate} In (S1), $\hat P$ has $89$ possible monomials and $\hat Q$ has $187$. Call the terms with $3b-a=2-k$ the \emph{layer $k$} of $\hat P$ and those with $3b-a=3-k$ the layer $k$ of $\hat Q$, and write $\hat P=\sum_{k\ge0}P_k$, $\hat Q=\sum_{k\ge0}Q_k$. The bracket of a term of layer $i$ of $\hat P$ with a term of layer $j$ of $\hat Q$ is a monomial $\zeta^av^b$ with $3b-a=3-(i+j)$, and $v$ has $3b-a=3$. So (S2) is equivalent to the \emph{equations of order $k$}: \begin{equation}\label{order} \sum_{i+j=k}\{P_i,Q_j\}=\begin{cases}-J\,v,&k=0,\\ 0,&k\ge1,\end{cases} \qquad \{f,g\}:=f_\zeta g_v-f_vg_\zeta . \end{equation} With $s:=\zeta^3v$, the layers of order $0$ are \[ P_0=p_{1,1}\,\zeta v\,(1+a_1s+\dots+a_5s^5),\qquad Q_0=q_{0,1}\,v\,(1+h_1s+\dots+h_8s^8), \] with $a_5\ne0$ by (S1). \begin{lemma}\label{normal} If \textup{(S1)--(S3)} has a solution, it has one with $p_{1,1}=q_{0,1}=a_1=c=1$ and $p_{0,0}=q_{0,0}=q_{16,6}=0$. For such a solution $J=-1$, $\lambda_P=a_5$, and $(a_2,\dots,a_5,h_1,\dots,h_8)$ is one of exactly two tuples, which have their entries in $\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-3})$ and are exchanged by its non-trivial automorphism; in both, $T:=1/a_5$ is a root of \[ 150994944\,T^2-314828451840\,T+1291756832812537=0, \] whose discriminant is $-3\cdot476472471552^2$, and \begin{gather*} a_2=\tfrac{33207559840-1179648T}{87282533261},\quad a_3=\tfrac{9142619992576-948436992T}{111808925107341},\quad a_4=\tfrac{35168631085056-8204058624T}{4222117981434353},\\ h_1=4,\quad h_2=\tfrac{132959026424-1179648T}{37406799969},\quad h_3=\tfrac{17130979691392-721944576T}{10164447737031},\\ h_4=\tfrac{23190255008542720-2265018531840T}{47742411020834607},\quad h_5=\tfrac{65536T+154611184}{1175013\,T},\quad h_6=\tfrac{6291456T+42564276664}{1839678687\,T},\\ h_7=\tfrac{132830239360-4718592T}{69469771371\,T},\quad h_8=\tfrac{25761882159104-5173673984T}{484505342131811\,T}. \end{gather*} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The equation of order $0$ in \eqref{order} reads, for the coefficient of $v$, $p_{1,1}q_{0,1}=-J$, and for the coefficient of $vs^k$, $1\le k\le12$, \begin{equation}\label{zero} \sum_{i}(5i-2k+1)\,a_i\,h_{k-i}=0\qquad(a_0=h_0=1,\ 0\le i\le5,\ 0\le k-i\le8), \end{equation} because $\{\zeta^{3i+1}v^{i+1},\zeta^{3j}v^{j+1}\}=(3i-2j+1)\,\zeta^{3(i+j)}v^{i+j+1}$. The system \eqref{zero} has no solution with $a_1=0$ and $a_5\ne0$ (Gr\"obner basis, ancillary script). The system (S1)--(S3) is preserved by $(\hat P,\hat Q)\mapsto(\gamma'\hat P(\alpha\zeta,\beta v),\delta\hat Q(\alpha\zeta,\beta v))$, which multiplies $p_{1,1}$ by $\gamma'\alpha\beta$, $q_{0,1}$ by $\delta\beta$, each $a_i$ by $(\alpha^3\beta)^i$ and $c$ by $\beta/\alpha$. Since $a_1\ne0$ we may assume $p_{1,1}=q_{0,1}=a_1=c=1$; then $J=-1$, and comparing the coefficients of $\zeta^{16}v^6$ in $P_0$ and in (S3) gives $\lambda_P=a_5$. Adding constants to $\hat P$ and $\hat Q$, and replacing $\hat Q$ by $\hat Q-(q_{16,6}/a_5)\hat P$, preserves (S1)--(S3) and the layers of order $0$, since $\hat P$ has no term in layer $0$ of $\hat Q$. Finally, with $a_1=1$ and $a_5\ne0$ the system \eqref{zero} has exactly two solutions, in which $T=1/a_5$ satisfies the quadratic equation stated (Gr\"obner basis, ancillary script), and the displayed expressions satisfy \eqref{zero} for each root $T$ (ancillary script). \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{nosol} The system \textup{(S1)--(S3)}, normalised as in Lemma~\ref{normal}, has no solution. \end{proposition} \begin{proof}[Proof (exact computation)] Fix one of the two tuples of Lemma~\ref{normal}; its entries lie in $E:=\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-3})$, and (S3) fixes the coefficients of $\hat P$ on the line $a+b=22$: $p_{16+j,6-j}=a_5\binom6j$. For $k\ge1$ the equation of order $k$ in \eqref{order} is $\{P_k,Q_0\}+\{P_0,Q_k\}=-\sum_{0