\documentclass[11pt]{amsart} \usepackage[a4paper,margin=2.6cm]{geometry} \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,enumitem} \usepackage[colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue,citecolor=blue,urlcolor=blue]{hyperref} \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark} \newtheorem{hypothesis}[theorem]{Standing data} \newcommand{\st}{\operatorname{st}} \newcommand{\en}{\operatorname{en}} \begin{document} \title[The degree pair $(56,140)$ in the plane Jacobian problem]{The degree pair $(56,140)$ in the plane Jacobian problem:\\ exclusion of the shape with starting corner $(7,21)$ and final corner $(13/7,3)$} \author{David Niedbala Giraudin} \address{Independent researcher, France} \thanks{ORCID: 0009-0009-1526-1178} \date{20 November 2026} \begin{abstract} In the list of Guccione, Guccione, Horruitiner and Valqui of the possible shapes of a counterexample to the plane Jacobian conjecture with degrees at most $150$, the family $F_{11}$ contributes one shape: the standard $(2,5)$-pairs of degrees $(56,140)$ with starting corner $(7,21)$ and final corner $(13/7,3)$. We show that no such pair exists, when it is normalised as in Corollary 5.21 of Guccione--Guccione--Valqui. The two sides of the Newton polygon are described by the results of Guccione--Guccione--Valqui; the left side is reduced as in the treatment of the corner $(7,21)$ by the four authors for the degrees $(56,84)$. In suitable polynomial coordinates the pair is then confined to an explicit finite system of polynomial equations, which has no solution: a chain of linear eliminations with rational coefficients leads to $840=0$. The eliminations are reproduced by an ancillary script, which also confirms the result by a Gr\"obner basis computation. All statements are proved relative to the cited results. Nothing in this note has been checked by a third party. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Statement} Throughout, $K$ is an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, $L=K[x,y]$, $[P,Q]=P_xQ_y-P_yQ_x$ and $(m,n)=(2,5)$. We use the notation of \cite{GGV1}: for a weight $(\rho,\sigma)$, $v_{\rho,\sigma}$ is the weighted degree, $\ell_{\rho,\sigma}$ the leading form, $\st_{\rho,\sigma}$ and $\en_{\rho,\sigma}$ its end points; $L^{(l)}=K[x^{\pm1/l},y]$. \emph{Standard $(m,n)$-pairs}, their \emph{starting triple} and their \emph{regular corners} are defined in \cite[Definitions 4.3, 6.2, 5.5]{GGV1}. Put $t:=x^2y^7$. \begin{hypothesis}\label{data} $(P,Q)$ is a standard $(2,5)$-pair in $L$ with $[P,Q]=J\in K^\times$, $\deg P=56$, $\deg Q=140$, starting triple $\bigl((7,21),(1,0),(7,-2)\bigr)$, and $(-1,1)<\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)<(-1,0)$ as in \cite[Corollary 5.21(4)]{GGV1}. Thus: \begin{enumerate}[label=(D\arabic*),leftmargin=3em] \item the support of $P$ lies in $\{(i,j):7i-2j\le 14\}$, that of $Q$ in $\{7i-2j\le 35\}$, and \[ \ell_{7,-2}(P)=\lambda_P\bigl(x\,h(t)\bigr)^2,\qquad \ell_{7,-2}(Q)=\lambda_Q\bigl(x\,h(t)\bigr)^5, \qquad \lambda_P,\lambda_Q\in K^\times, \] with $h\in K[t]$ monic of degree $3$, $h(0)\ne0$ \cite[Proposition 6.1, Theorem 7.6(2)]{GGV1}. \end{enumerate} \end{hypothesis} \begin{theorem}\label{main} There is no pair $(P,Q)$ as in Standing data~\ref{data}. \end{theorem} This is the shape of the family $F_{11}$ of \cite[Section 5]{GGV4} for $j=0$, the only member of that family with degrees at most $150$ \cite[Section 6]{GGV4}. The first arXiv version of \cite{GGHV3} listed this family among those discarded, assuming that two expressions for the intersection number of a Jacobian pair coincide; the revised version (arXiv v2) establishes only an inequality between them and no longer contains that list. To our knowledge the shape has not been excluded elsewhere. \section{The roots of $h$} \begin{lemma}\label{roots} In Standing data~\ref{data}, $h=(t-c)^3$ with $c\in K^\times$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By \cite[Definition 6.2]{GGV1}, $((7,21),(7,-2))$ is a regular corner of the $(2,5)$-pair $(P,Q)$ in $L^{(1)}$, with $\frac12\st_{7,-2}(P)=(1,0)$. In $\tilde z:=x^{2/7}y$ one has $\ell_{7,-2}(P)=x^2p(\tilde z)$ with $p(\tilde z)=\lambda_Ph(\tilde z^7)^2$; the bracket of $\ell_{7,-2}(P)$ and $\ell_{7,-2}(Q)$ vanishes, both being powers of $x\,h(t)$ up to constants, $p$ has at least seven distinct roots and $v_{1,-1}(\st_{7,-2}(P))=v_{1,-1}(2,0)>0$. By \cite[Proposition 5.16]{GGV1} some root $\lambda\ne0$ of $p$ has multiplicity at least $\frac ml\cdot\frac{a\rho+bl\sigma}{\rho+\sigma}=2\cdot\frac{49-42}{5}=\frac{14}5$ (the root can be taken different from $0$ because $p(0)\ne0$). A root of $h$ of multiplicity $k$ gives roots of $p$ of multiplicity $2k$; so some root $c$ of $h$ has multiplicity $k\ge2$, and by \cite[Proposition 5.18]{GGV1} some $(2,5)$-pair in $L^{(7)}$ has a regular corner at $(1,0)+k(\frac27,1)$. For $k=2$ this point is $(11/7,2)$. By \cite[Proposition 5.19]{GGV1} it would be the first entry of a regular corner of Case I or of Case II (in the sense of \cite[Section 5, before Remark 5.9]{GGV1}). Case II requires $\gcd(11,2)>1$ \cite[Proposition 5.14(4)]{GGV1}. In Case I, with direction $(\rho,\sigma)$, \cite[Proposition 1.13, Corollary 5.7(2)]{GGV1} give $2(\frac{11}7\rho+2\sigma)=\frac27(\rho+\sigma)$, that is $(\rho,\sigma)=(13,-10)$, $v(P)=\frac67$, $v(Q)=\frac{15}7$; by \cite[Proposition 5.13]{GGV1} one of $\frac{13}7\cdot2a'=\frac67$, $\frac{13}7k'=\frac{15}7$, $\frac{13}7k'=\frac67$ would have a solution in positive integers, which is not the case. Hence $k=3$. \end{proof} \section{The left side} \begin{lemma}\label{left} There is $\gamma\in K$ such that \[ \hat P(z,v):=P\bigl(zv^3+\gamma v^2,\,v^{-1}\bigr),\qquad \hat Q(z,v):=Q\bigl(zv^3+\gamma v^2,\,v^{-1}\bigr) \] are polynomials in $z,v$. Give $z$ the weight $1$ and $v$ the weight $2$. Then $\hat P$ has weighted degree $14$ with top form $\lambda_P z^2(z^2-cv)^{6}$, $\hat Q$ has weighted degree $35$ with top form $\lambda_Q z^5(z^2-cv)^{15}$, and \[ \hat P_z\hat Q_v-\hat P_v\hat Q_z=-J\,v . \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} This is the reduction of \cite[Section 4, Case $(7,21)$]{GGHV22}, stated there for $(m,n)=(2,3)$; we give the argument in detail. Apply the flip $\psi_1$ of \cite[Section 8]{GGV1}, so that the weight $(7,-2)$ becomes $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)=(-2,7)$, with $\st_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(42,14)$ and $\en_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(0,2)$ for the flipped $P$, and $\frac1m\st=\frac1n\st=(21,7)$. Let $F$ be the element of \cite[Theorem 2.6]{GGV1} for $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)$; then $v_{-2,7}(F)=5$. If $\st(F)=(1,1)$ then $\en(F)\ne(1,1)$, since $F$ is not a monomial \cite[Remark 2.5]{GGV1}, so $\en(F)\sim\en(P)\sim(0,1)$ and $\en(F)=(0,5/7)$, which is impossible; hence $\st(F)\sim(21,7)$, so $\st(F)=(15,5)=\frac57(21,7)$ and $q=7$ in \cite[Corollary 7.4]{GGV1}. That corollary applies to the flipped pair (its hypotheses hold with $(a/l,b)=(21,7)$, and $\rho_0+\sigma_0>0$): for every weight between $(1,-3)$ and $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)$ at which the pair has an edge, the edge form of $P$ is a power $R^{14}$. In the original variables: for a weight $(-s,1)$ with $s<3$ carrying an edge with starting point $(14,42)$, the form is $(xy^3-\gamma y^{3-s})^{14}$ up to a constant, so $s\in\mathbb Z$, and $s\ge2$ by the condition on $\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)$; thus $s=2$. Here $(14,42)=\en_{7,-2}(P)$ is the starting point of the edge at $\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)$, because $\deg P=56=v_{1,1}(14,42)$. The translation $x\mapsto x+\gamma y^{-2}$ removes this edge \cite[Proposition 3.9]{GGV1} (take $\gamma=0$ if there is no such edge). By \cite[Proposition 3.9]{GGV1} the leading forms of the translated pair at the weights between $(7,-2)$ and $(-2,1)$ are unchanged, and its $(-2,1)$-form is the monomial $x^{14}y^{42}$; so an edge with starting point $(14,42)$ and $s<3$ could only occur for $21$; this holds at every step below, since it depends only on the point $A_1$. In Case III, \cite[Proposition 5.17]{GGV1} gives $\rho'\mid7$, hence $\rho'=7$ (no direction $(1,\sigma')$ is smaller than $(7,-2)$ in the interval of directions) and $\sigma'/\rho'=-j/7$ with $3\le j\le6$, and the translation $y\mapsto y+\lambda'x^{-j/7}$ produces a $(2,5)$-pair in $L^{(7)}$ with a regular corner at the same point $A_1$ and a smaller direction. After finitely many steps Case I occurs, for a pair $(P_1,Q_1)$ and a direction $(\rho,\sigma)$. There $v_{\rho,\sigma}(P_1)+v_{\rho,\sigma}(Q_1)=\rho+\sigma$ \cite[Proposition 1.13]{GGV1}, while $\en(P_1)=2A_1=\frac25\en(Q_1)$ \cite[Corollary 5.7(2)]{GGV1}. Hence $2(\tfrac{13}{7}\rho+3\sigma)=\tfrac27(\rho+\sigma)$, that is $(\rho,\sigma)=(5,-3)$, $v(P_1)=\frac47$, $v(Q_1)=\frac{10}7$. By \cite[Proposition 5.13]{GGV1} either $\frac12\st(P_1)=(a'/7,0)$ with $a'\in\mathbb N$, which would give $\frac{10}7a'=\frac47$; or $\{\st(P_1),\st(Q_1)\}=\{(k'/7,0),(1-k'/7,1)\}$ with $k'\in\mathbb N$. If $\st(P_1)=(k'/7,0)$ then $5k'=4$; so $\st(Q_1)=(k'/7,0)$ with $5k'=10$, that is $\st(Q_1)=(2/7,0)$ and $\st(P_1)=(5/7,1)$. The directions of the Case III steps lie strictly between $(5,-3)$ and $(7,-2)$, so $j\in\{3,4\}$, each at most once. Finally $7\,v_{5,-3}(x^{i/7}y^j)=5i-21j$, $\en(P_1)=(26/7,6)$ and $\en(Q_1)=(65/7,15)$. \end{proof} \section{Common coordinates} Let $\mathcal A$ be the set of formal sums $\sum c_{ij}X^i\eta^j$ ($i\in\mathbb Z$, $j\ge0$) such that, for every $r$, only finitely many terms have $W=5i-21j\ge r$. It is a ring containing $K[X^{\pm1},\eta]$; for $f\ne0$ let $W(f)$ be the largest weight of its terms and $\ell(f)$ the sum of the terms of that weight. Then $\ell(fg)=\ell(f)\ell(g)$ and $W(fg)=W(f)+W(g)$, and $1+\varepsilon$ is invertible in $\mathcal A$ when $W(\varepsilon)<0$. \begin{lemma}\label{coord} Let $\gamma$, $\lambda,\lambda_3,\lambda_4$ be as in Lemmas~\ref{left} and~\ref{corner}, and put \[ \zeta:=z^2-c\,v-\kappa_1z-\kappa_2,\qquad \kappa_1:=7\lambda^2\lambda_3,\quad \kappa_2:=7\lambda^4(\lambda\lambda_4-\lambda_3^2). \] Then $K[z,v]=K[z,\zeta]$. Write $\hat P=\sum p_{ab}z^a\zeta^b$ and $\hat Q=\sum q_{ab}z^a\zeta^b$. Then $p_{ab}\ne0$ implies $5a-b\le4$ and $a+2b\le14$; $q_{ab}\ne0$ implies $5a-b\le10$ and $a+2b\le35$. Moreover $p_{1,1}$, $p_{2,6}$, $q_{2,0}$, $q_{5,15}$ are non-zero, and \[ \hat P_z\hat Q_\zeta-\hat P_\zeta\hat Q_z=\frac{J}{c^2}\,\bigl(z^2-\kappa_1z-\kappa_2-\zeta\bigr). \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since $c\ne0$, $v=(z^2-\kappa_1z-\kappa_2-\zeta)/c$, so $K[z,v]=K[z,\zeta]$; giving $\zeta$ the weight $2$, this substitution does not increase the weighted degree of Lemma~\ref{left}, which gives $a+2b\le14$ and $a+2b\le35$, and the top form of $\hat P$ becomes $\lambda_Pz^2\zeta^6$, that of $\hat Q$ becomes $\lambda_Qz^5\zeta^{15}$. In $\mathcal A$ the element $Y$ of Lemma~\ref{corner} is $\lambda X^{-2}(1+\varepsilon)$ with $W(\varepsilon)<0$; it is invertible. The assignment $v\mapsto Y^{-1}$, $z\mapsto X^7Y^3-\gamma Y$ defines a ring morphism $K[z,v]\to\mathcal A$ which sends $\hat P$ to $P_1$ and $\hat Q$ to $Q_1$, because $P(x,y)=\hat P\bigl((x-\gamma y^{-2})y^3,y^{-1}\bigr)$ in $K[x,y^{\pm1}]$. Expanding (ancillary script), the image of $z$ has $W=5$ and leading term $\lambda^3X$, and the image of $\zeta$ has $W=-1$ and leading term $7\lambda^5\eta X^4$: the terms of weights $10$, $5$, $0$ cancel by the choice of $c=\lambda^7$, $\kappa_1$, $\kappa_2$. Hence the image of $z^a\zeta^b$ has leading term a non-zero multiple of $\eta^bX^{a+4b}$, of weight $5a-b$, and these monomials are distinct for distinct $(a,b)$. Therefore, for a non-zero polynomial, $W\bigl(\sum c_{ab}z^a\zeta^b\bigr)=\max\{5a-b:c_{ab}\ne0\}$, and its leading part is the image of the corresponding terms. Lemma~\ref{corner} gives the values $4$ and $10$ for the images of $\hat P$ and $\hat Q$; the monomials $X^5\eta$, $X^{26}\eta^6$, $X^2$, $X^{65}\eta^{15}$ correspond to $z\zeta$, $z^2\zeta^6$, $z^2$, $z^5\zeta^{15}$. Finally $dz\wedge d\zeta=-c\,dz\wedge dv$, so the bracket in $(z,\zeta)$ is $-\frac1c$ times the bracket in $(z,v)$, which is $-Jv$ by Lemma~\ref{left}. \end{proof} \section{The finite system} Writing again $z$ for $z-\kappa_1/2$ (this replaces $\kappa_1$ by $0$, changes $\kappa_2$, and preserves all the statements of Lemma~\ref{coord}, the leading terms of the images and the weighted degrees being unchanged), a pair as in the standing data yields a solution of the following system, in which $s$ stands for $\zeta$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(S\arabic*),leftmargin=3em] \item $\hat P=\sum p_{ab}z^as^b$ with $a,b\ge0$, $a+2b\le14$, $5a-b\le4$; $\hat Q=\sum q_{ab}z^as^b$ with $a,b\ge0$, $a+2b\le35$, $5a-b\le10$; and $p_{1,1}\,p_{2,6}\,q_{5,15}\ne0$. \item $\hat P_z\hat Q_s-\hat P_s\hat Q_z=J'\,(z^2-\kappa-s)$ with $J'\in K^\times$, $\kappa\in K$. \end{enumerate} In (S1), $\hat P$ has $15$ possible monomials and $\hat Q$ has $72$. The system is deliberately weaker than what is known: the top forms of Lemma~\ref{left} and the fact that $P$ and $Q$ are polynomials in $y$ give further restrictions, which are not needed. \begin{lemma}\label{normal} If \textup{(S1)--(S2)} has a solution, it has one with $p_{1,1}=p_{2,6}=q_{5,15}=1$ and $p_{0,0}=q_{0,0}=q_{4,12}=q_{2,6}=0$. For such a solution $q_{2,0}=\frac5{16}$, $q_{3,5}=\frac{15}8$, $q_{4,10}=\frac52$ and $J'=-\frac58$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The system is preserved by $(\hat P,\hat Q)\mapsto(\alpha\hat P(\mu z,\mu^2s),\beta\hat Q(\mu z,\mu^2s))$, with $\kappa$ replaced by $\kappa/\mu^2$ and $J'$ by $\alpha\beta\mu^5J'$; it multiplies $p_{1,1}$ by $\alpha\mu^3$, $p_{2,6}$ by $\alpha\mu^{14}$ and $q_{5,15}$ by $\beta\mu^{35}$, so we may assume that these three coefficients are $1$. The system is also preserved by adding constants to $\hat P$ and $\hat Q$, and by $\hat Q\mapsto\hat Q+\alpha'\hat P^2+\beta'\hat P$, since the monomials of $\hat P^2$ satisfy $a+2b\le28$ and $5a-b\le8$; the coefficient of $z^4s^{12}$ in $\hat P^2$ is $p_{2,6}^2=1$ and $\hat P$ has no such monomial, and the coefficient of $z^2s^6$ in $\hat P$ is $1$; so $\alpha'$ and then $\beta'$ can be chosen to obtain $q_{4,12}=q_{2,6}=0$. These operations do not change the terms with $5a-b=10$ of $\hat Q$. The terms of (S2) with $5a-b=10$ read $\{z s+z^2s^6,\ q_{2,0}z^2+q_{3,5}z^3s^5+q_{4,10}z^4s^{10}+z^5s^{15}\}=J'z^2$, where $\{f,g\}=f_zg_s-f_sg_z$, because the bracket of $z^as^b$ and $z^{a'}s^{b'}$ is a multiple of $z^{a+a'-1}s^{b+b'-1}$, on which $5a-b$ takes the value of the sum minus $4$. This equation has the unique solution stated (ancillary script). \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{nosol} The system \textup{(S1)--(S2)}, normalised as in Lemma~\ref{normal}, has no solution. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Call the terms with $5a-b=4-k$ the \emph{layer $k$} of $\hat P$ and those with $5a-b=10-k$ the layer $k$ of $\hat Q$; put $J'$ in layer $0$ and $\kappa$ in layer $10$. The bracket of a term of layer $i$ of $\hat P$ with a term of layer $j$ of $\hat Q$ is a monomial $z^as^b$ with $5a-b=10-(i+j)$, and $z^2$, $1$, $s$ have $5a-b=10,0,-1$. So the coefficients of the monomials with $5a-b=10-k$ in (S2) form, once the layers $