\section{A counterexample for truncated shifted algebras}\label{tr:section} In this section the Cartan matrix and symmetrizing integers are \begin{equation}\label{tr:cartan} C=\begin{pmatrix}2&-1\\-3&2\end{pmatrix},\qquad (d_1,d_2)=(3,1), \qquad q_i=q^{d_i}. \end{equation} Thus vertex 1 is long. A rational $\ell$-weight is a pair of nonzero rational functions regular and nonzero at zero. Its normalization divides each component by its value at zero. For $b\in\C^*$, let $z_{i,b}$ have component $1-bx$ at $i$ and component 1 at the other vertex. We abbreviate $z_{i,q^k}$ to $z_{i,k}$. All products of these symbols below have finite support. Define the normalized truncation roots by \begin{equation}\label{tr:roots} a_{1,k}=\frac{z_{1,k}z_{1,k+6}}{z_{2,k+3}},\qquad a_{2,k}=\frac{z_{2,k}z_{2,k+2}} {z_{1,k-1}z_{1,k+1}z_{1,k+3}}. \end{equation} The same formulas with $q^k$ replaced by $b$ define $a_{i,b}$ on every $q^{\Z}$-orbit. We write $\Psi\preceq P$ when $P/\Psi$ is a product of nonnegative integral powers of the $a_{i,b}$. \subsection{Polynomial truncations and the finite-chain assertion} Let $P=(P_i(x))$ have polynomial components with constant term 1, put $\lambda_i=\deg P_i$, and let \begin{equation}\label{tr:shift} \mu_i=\lambda_i-\sum_j a_jc_{ji},\qquad a_j\in\N. \end{equation} In the adjoint shifted algebra, the invertible generators $\phi_i^\pm$ and the auxiliary series $A_i^\pm$ satisfy \begin{equation}\label{tr:adjoint-constant} A_{i,0}^+=(\phi_i^+)^{-1},\qquad A_{i,0}^-=z_i'(\phi_i^-)^{-1},\qquad \prod_j(z_j')^{c_{ji}}=\operatorname{lc}(P_i). \end{equation} Here $\operatorname{lc}(P_i)$ is the leading coefficient, and the two Cartan leading terms are $\prod_j(\phi_j^+)^{c_{ji}}$ and $\prod_j(\phi_j^-)^{c_{ji}}$, respectively. The positive Cartan recursion is \begin{equation}\label{tr:cartan-recursion} \psi_i^+(x)=P_i(x) \frac{\displaystyle\prod_{j\ne i}\prod_{p=1}^{-c_{ji}} A_j^+(q_j^{c_{ji}+2p}x)}{A_i^+(x)A_i^+(q_i^2x)}. \end{equation} An empty product is 1. Hernandez's polynomial truncation imposes \begin{equation}\label{tr:truncation-relations} \begin{gathered} A_i^+(x)\in U[x],\quad \deg A_i^+=a_i,\qquad A_i^-(x)\in U[x^{-1}],\quad \deg_{x^{-1}}A_i^-=a_i,\\ A_{i,0}^+A_{i,0}^-=(-q_i)^{a_i},\qquad A_i^+(x)=(xq_i^{-1})^{a_i}A_i^-(x). \end{gathered} \end{equation} We use the original algebra of \cite[Definition 10.3]{H23}. In \eqref{tr:truncation-relations}, $U$ denotes that quotient, and the degree conditions include invertible extreme coefficients. Let $Q(P)$ be the set of normalized highest $\ell$-weights of its simple objects in shifted category $\cO$, allowing every $\mu$ in \eqref{tr:shift}. On a highest vector the commuting coefficients of $A_i^+$ have a common polynomial eigenvalue with nonzero constant term. Factoring these polynomials in \eqref{tr:cartan-recursion} gives \begin{equation}\label{tr:necessary-order} \Psi\in Q(P)\quad\Longrightarrow\quad P/\Psi=\prod_{i,b}a_{i,b}^{n_{i,b}},\qquad n_{i,b}\in\N. \end{equation} The root of an $A_i^+$ eigenpolynomial is counted with its algebraic multiplicity. This is also the order statement of \cite[Theorem 11.9]{H23}. Let $\chi(P)$ denote the mixed character of \cite[Section 11]{HICM26}. It is multiplicative in the linear factors of $P$. Write $P\longrightarrow\Psi$ if its support contains the normalized weight $\Psi$. These labels suppress the constant parts, as in \cite[Remark 10.3]{HICM26}; the full constants are fixed by \eqref{tr:adjoint-constant} and \eqref{tr:truncation-relations}. Conjecture 11.4 asserts \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)] \item $P\longrightarrow\Psi$ implies $\Psi\in Q(P)$; \item if $\Psi\in Q(P)$, there are polynomial parameters $P=P_0,P_1,\ldots,P_N$ with $P_j\longrightarrow P_{j+1}$ and $P_N\longrightarrow\Psi$. \end{enumerate} The argument below applies to any character assignment multiplicative in the linear factors and satisfying these two assertions. Set \begin{equation}\label{tr:data} P_L=z_{2,-3},\qquad P_R=z_{2,1},\qquad P=P_LP_R,\qquad t=\frac{z_{1,-6}z_{1,-4}z_{1,0}z_{1,2}z_{2,-3}} {z_{2,-7}z_{2,-1}}. \end{equation} Multiplying the three expressions in \eqref{tr:roots} gives \begin{equation}\label{tr:three-roots} \frac{P}{t}=a_{1,-8}a_{2,-7}a_{2,-1}. \end{equation} We will prove \begin{equation}\label{tr:three-properties} t\in Q(P),\qquad t\notin Q(P_L)Q(P_R),\qquad P'\preceq P\text{ and }P'\text{ polynomial}\ \Longrightarrow\ P'=P. \end{equation} \subsection{Root independence and polynomial isolation} \begin{lemma}\label{tr:independence} The truncation roots $a_{i,b}$ are multiplicatively independent among finite products. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Different $q^{\Z}$-orbits of $b$ do not share a linear factor, since $q$ is not a root of unity. Fix one orbit and encode a finite exponent sequence by a Laurent polynomial in $s$, with multiplication by $s$ shifting an index by one. The map from root exponents to linear-factor exponents is \[ M(s)=\begin{pmatrix} 1+s^6&-(s^{-1}+s+s^3)\\-s^3&1+s^2 \end{pmatrix}. \] Its determinant is \[ (1+s^6)(1+s^2)-s^3(s^{-1}+s+s^3)=1-s^4+s^8. \] This is nonzero in the integral domain $\Z[s,s^{-1}]$. Multiplication by the adjugate shows that $M(s)f=0$ implies $f=0$. Apply this to each of the finitely many orbits present in a relation. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{tr:isolation} The only polynomial parameter $P'$ with $P'\preceq P$ is $P$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} On the component containing the even long indices and odd short indices, assign the following nonnegative weights to the linear factors, periodically with period 24: \begin{center} \small \begin{tabular}{c|rrrrrrrrrrrr} $k$&0&2&4&6&8&10&12&14&16&18&20&22\\ \hline $w(z_{1,k})$&0&2&1&5&4&6&6&4&5&1&2&0\\ $w(z_{2,k+1})$&0&4&5&6&10&7&10&6&5&4&0&3 \end{tabular} \end{center} For all even $k$ the table gives \[ w(z_{1,k})+w(z_{1,k+6})-w(z_{2,k+3})=1, \] and, for all odd $k$, it gives \[ w(z_{2,k})+w(z_{2,k+2})- w(z_{1,k-1})-w(z_{1,k+1})-w(z_{1,k+3})=1. \] Each identity follows for the twelve residue classes by reading the table; periodicity covers every integer. On the opposite parity component, and on every other $q^{\Z}$-orbit, assign the constant weights 3 at the long vertex and 5 at the short vertex. The two root weights there are $2\cdot3-5=1$ and $2\cdot5-3\cdot3=1$. Thus $w(a_{i,b})=1$ for every truncation root, while $w(P)=w(z_{2,21})+w(z_{2,1})=0$. If $P/P'=\prod a_{i,b}^{n_{i,b}}$, put $N=\sum n_{i,b}$. Every linear factor of the polynomial tuple $P'$ has nonnegative multiplicity and nonnegative weight. Consequently \[ 0\le w(P')=w(P)-N=-N. \] It follows that every $n_{i,b}$ is zero and $P'=P$. \end{proof} \subsection{A geometric simple module} We first construct a simple over the geometric algebra and compute its entire support. The fixed-point and completed-localization constructions used here are those of \cite[Sections 2--4]{VV25}. In the $D_4$ unfolding of \eqref{tr:cartan}, retain the short center $c$ and the long leaf $a$ of residue $4$ modulo $6$. Put \[ V_c=\C^2,\qquad V_a=\C,\qquad W_c=\C^2,\qquad W_a=0. \] The nonzero arrow is $c\to a$. Hence the representation space is \[ N=\Hom(W_c,V_c)\oplus\Hom(V_c,V_a)\simeq\mathbb A^6. \] Write its coordinates as $A=(A_L,A_R)$ and $B$, where $A_L,A_R\in\C^2$ and $B\in(\C^2)^*$. The original flavor and gauge cocharacters are \begin{equation}\label{tr:cocharacters} \rho_2=(-5/2,-1/2),\qquad \gamma_1=-4/3,\qquad \gamma_2=(-7/2,-1/2). \end{equation} The flavor index is $2d_i+2d_i\rho_{i,s}$, so the two framing factors are $z_{2,-3}$ and $z_{2,1}$. The gauge index is $2d_i\gamma_{i,s}$, giving $-8$ at the long vertex and $-7,-1$ at the short vertex. The short-vertex regrading following \cite[(3.1.72)]{VV25} subtracts 2 from its geometric degrees. Thus the red degrees are $-7,-3$, and the target black degrees are \begin{equation}\label{tr:target-loading} c(-9),\quad a(-8),\quad c(-3). \end{equation} The original torus characters remain those of \eqref{tr:cocharacters}. The flag conditions in these degrees are \begin{equation}\label{tr:flag-conditions} A(W^{\le k})\subseteq F^{\le k},\qquad B(F^{\le k})\subseteq F^{2\dim\mathbb P^1$. Consequently \begin{equation}\label{tr:small-ic} \pi_*\C_X[5]=\IC_Z. \end{equation} The local system on the smooth locus of $Z$ has rank one and is constant. For each loading $\nu$, let $K_\nu=(\pi_\nu)_*\C_{X_\nu}[\dim X_\nu]$. The convolution algebra is the locally unital sum of the equivariant groups $\Ext_G^\bullet(K_\nu,K_{\nu'})$, with $G=\GL(V_c)\times\GL(V_a)$. The decomposition theorem expresses each $K_\nu$ as a finite sum of shifted simple perverse sheaves. After these decompositions, a morphism has a well-defined perverse Ext degree; negative degrees vanish and degrees add under composition. Quotienting by positive perverse Ext degrees leaves matrix algebras on the multiplicity spaces of the simple perverse summands. The block belonging to $\IC_Z$ therefore defines a simple module $S_Z$ and \begin{equation}\label{tr:support-ic} e_\nu S_Z\ne0\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \IC_Z\text{ occurs, up to shift, in }K_\nu. \end{equation} Indeed, the degree-zero maps between its copies supply every matrix unit, so any nonzero vector generates the multiplicity module. This also proves the assertion for the locally unital direct sum over all loadings. Each individual multiplicity space is finite dimensional. The construction is the convolution--Ext description of \cite[Proposition 5.1 and Theorem 5.2]{Ginzburg98}. Positive-degree equivariant parameters act by positive perverse Ext and annihilate $S_Z$. In particular this is a nilpotent module for the completed-localization correspondence. The module descends through the full cyclotomic ideal. To see this, set \[ U=\{(A,B):\det A\ne0, B\ne0\}\subset N. \] The set $U\cap Z$ is dense and nonempty; it contains $A=1$, $B=(0,1)$. At every point of $U$, the framing generates $V_c\oplus V_a$. A loading with a black degree greater than the maximum red degree $-3$ would give a proper subspace $F^{\le-3}$ containing $A(W_c)$ and stable under $B$. But $A(W_c)=V_c$ and $B(V_c)=V_a$, so this is impossible. Hence $X_\nu|_U$ is empty for every violating loading. Since $\IC_Z|_U\ne0$, \eqref{tr:support-ic} shows that every such $e_\nu$, and its generated two-sided ideal, annihilates $S_Z$. The target loading is integral and its weight space is nonzero by \eqref{tr:small-ic}; restriction to the integral idempotent corner is thus a nonzero simple module. This last assertion follows directly: if $eM\ne0$ and $M$ is simple, then any nonzero $eAe$-submodule $L\subseteq eM$ satisfies $AL=M$ and $eAL=eAeL=L$, so $L=eM$. \begin{lemma}\label{tr:all-loadings} The supported integral loadings have short degrees $x\le y$ and long degree $\ell$ precisely as follows: \begin{equation}\label{tr:loading-inequalities} x\le-70}x_{i,r}^-x^r,\qquad C_i(x)=(q_i-q_i^{-1})x_i^{-,+}(x)A_i^+(x) =\sum_{r>0}C_{i,r}x^r. \] The Cartan--current relation \cite[(11.24)]{H23} is \[ (w-x)[A_i^+(x),C_i(w)]_{q_i} =(q_i-q_i^{-1}) \bigl(xC_i(w)A_i^+(x)-wC_i(x)A_i^+(w)\bigr). \] Its coefficient of $w$ gives \[ -x[A_i^+(x),C_{i,1}]_{q_i^{-1}} =-(q_i-q_i^{-1})C_i(x)A_{i,0}^+. \] Since $A_i^+$ is polynomial and $A_{i,0}^+$ is invertible, $C_i(x)$ is polynomial as an operator. Now $A_i^+(x)v=a_i(x)v$ and $x_{i,0}^+v=0$. The positive--negative current commutator yields \[ x_{i,0}^+C_i(x)v =-a_i(x)\left( \Psi_i(x)-\Psi_{i,0}^+ -\sum_{0