\documentclass[11pt]{amsart} \usepackage[a4paper,margin=2.6cm]{geometry} \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,enumitem} \usepackage[colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue,citecolor=blue,urlcolor=blue]{hyperref} \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark} \newtheorem{hypothesis}[theorem]{Standing data} \newcommand{\st}{\operatorname{st}} \newcommand{\en}{\operatorname{en}} \newcommand{\Res}{\operatorname{Res}} \newcommand{\ord}{\operatorname{ord}} \begin{document} \title[A residue obstruction for the family $F_2$]{A residue obstruction for the whole family $F_2$\\ in the plane Jacobian problem} \author{David Niedbala Giraudin} \address{Independent researcher, France} \thanks{ORCID: 0009-0009-1526-1178} \date{19 November 2026} \begin{abstract} In the classification of Guccione, Guccione, Horruitiner and Valqui of the possible shapes of a counterexample to the plane Jacobian conjecture, the family $F_2$ consists of the standard $(m,n)$-pairs with $n=2m-1$, $m\ge2$, starting corner $(5,20)$ and final corner $(7/5,2)$; its degrees are $(25m,25(2m-1))$, that is $(50,75)$, $(75,125)$, $(100,175)$, \dots\ We show that no such pair exists, for every $m\ge2$. (Other shapes with the same degrees, which occur for $(50,75)$ and $(125,225)$, are not covered.) This extends to the whole family the argument given for $(m,n)=(3,5)$ in \cite{N1}: on a generic fibre of $P$ the form $y^2Q\,dQ$ has no residue along the left side of the Newton polygon, while its residues along the right side add up to $-\frac{2m}{2m-1}\sum G^2$, which cannot vanish. All statements are proved relative to the cited results of Guccione--Guccione--Valqui; the exact computations are reproduced by an ancillary script. The argument has not yet been examined by specialists. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Statement} Throughout, $K$ is an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, $L=K[x,y]$, $[P,Q]=P_xQ_y-P_yQ_x$, and $m\ge2$, $n:=2m-1$. We use the notation of \cite{GGV1} (Guccione--Guccione--Valqui): for a weight $(\rho,\sigma)$, $v_{\rho,\sigma}$ is the weighted degree, $\ell_{\rho,\sigma}$ the leading form, and $\st_{\rho,\sigma}$, $\en_{\rho,\sigma}$ its end points. \emph{Standard $(m,n)$-pairs} and their \emph{starting triple} are defined in \cite[Definitions 4.3, 6.2]{GGV1}. \begin{hypothesis}\label{data} $(P,Q)$ is a standard $(m,n)$-pair in $L$ with $[P,Q]=J\in K^\times$, $\deg P=25m$, $\deg Q=25n$, starting triple $\bigl((5,20),(1,0),(5,-1)\bigr)$, and $(-1,1)<\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)<(-1,0)$ as in \cite[Corollary 5.21(4)]{GGV1}. Moreover the polynomial $h$ of \textup{(D1)} below has a root of multiplicity exactly two. \end{hypothesis} The last condition says that the pair belongs to the family $F_2$ of \cite[Section 5]{GGV4}: a root of multiplicity $k$ generates the corner $(1,0)+k(1/5,1)$ \cite[Proposition 5.18]{GGV1}, and $F_2$ is the family with final corner $(7/5,2)$. For $(m,n)=(3,5)$ every pair with this starting triple is of this kind \cite{N1}. In \cite{GGV4} the shapes are listed up to exchanging $P$ and $Q$; here $\deg P<\deg Q$, which is the orientation of $F_2$. \begin{theorem}\label{main} For every $m\ge2$ there is no pair $(P,Q)$ as in Standing data~\ref{data}. \end{theorem} \subsection*{Consequence of the standing data used below} Put $t:=xy^5$. Rescaling $x$, $P$, $Q$ we may assume: \begin{enumerate}[label=(D\arabic*),leftmargin=3em] \item The support of $P$ lies in $\{(i,j):5i-j\le 5m\}$, that of $Q$ in $\{5i-j\le 5n\}$, and \[ \ell_{5,-1}(P)=\bigl(x\,h(t)\bigr)^m,\qquad \ell_{5,-1}(Q)=\mu\bigl(x\,h(t)\bigr)^n,\qquad \mu\in K^\times, \] with $h\in K[t]$ monic of degree $4$, $h(0)\neq0$; thus $\st_{5,-1}(P)=(m,0)$ and $\en_{5,-1}(P)=(5m,20m)$ \cite[Proposition 6.1, Theorem 7.6(2)]{GGV1}. We write $u(t):=t\,h(t)$. \end{enumerate} By the standing data, $h$ is either $(t-c)^2(t-r_1)(t-r_2)$ with $c,r_1,r_2$ distinct, or $(t-c_1)^2(t-c_2)^2$ with $c_1\ne c_2$. \section{Homogeneous brackets} Let $N\ge1$ be an integer and $R_\omega:=K[\tau][\omega,\omega^{-1}]$, with the bracket $\{f,g\}_N:=\omega^{N}(f_\tau g_\omega-f_\omega g_\tau)$. For $s\in\mathbb Q_{>0}$ put $\nu_s(\tau^a\omega^{-d}):=d-sa$, let $\nu_s(f)$ be the maximum over the monomials of $f$ and $\ell_s(f)$ the sum of the terms realising it. An element with a single $\nu_s$-value $a$ has the form $\omega^{-a}F(\sigma)$ with $\sigma:=\tau\omega^{-s}$ and $F\in K[\sigma]$. \begin{lemma}\label{bracket} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)] \item $\{\omega^{-a}F(\sigma),\omega^{-b}G(\sigma)\}_N=\omega^{N-a-b-s-1}\bigl(aFG'-bF'G\bigr)(\sigma)$. \item $\nu_s(\{f,g\}_N)\le \nu_s(f)+\nu_s(g)+s+1-N$, with equality if and only if $\{\ell_s f,\ell_s g\}_N\ne0$. \item If $\{f,g\}_N=c\in K^\times$, then $\Sigma_s:=\nu_s(f)+\nu_s(g)+s+1-N\ge0$ for every $s$; if $\Sigma_s>0$ then $aFG'=bF'G$ for the leading forms, and if $\Sigma_s=0$ then $aFG'-bF'G=c$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) is a direct computation; (b) and (c) follow from (a) by comparing $\nu_s$-values. \end{proof} The plane enters through $(\tau,W):=(t-\theta,\,y)$ for $\theta\in K$: since $dx\wedge dy=y^{-5}\,dt\wedge dy$, one has $[f,g]=\{f,g\}_5$ with $\omega=W$, and $P=\sum_{d\le5m}f_d(t)\,W^{-d}$ with $f_{5m}=u^m$, $Q=\sum_{d\le 5n}g_d(t)W^{-d}$ with $g_{5n}=\mu u^n$. \section{The left side} \begin{lemma}\label{left} There is $g\in vK[v]$ with $\deg g\le 3$ and $v^2\mid g$ such that \[ \hat P(z,v):=P\bigl(zv^4+g(v),\,v^{-1}\bigr),\qquad \hat Q(z,v):=Q\bigl(zv^4+g(v),\,v^{-1}\bigr) \] are polynomials in $z,v$. Moreover $\hat P$ has total degree $5m$, top form $H^m$ with $H(z,v):=v^5u(z/v)$, $\hat P(z,0)$ has degree $5m$ in $z$, and \[ \hat P_z\hat Q_v-\hat P_v\hat Q_z=-J\,v^2 . \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Apply the flip $\psi_1$ of \cite[Section 8]{GGV1}, so that the weight $(5,-1)$ becomes $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)=(-1,5)$, with $\st_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(20m,5m)$ and $\en_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(0,m)$ for the flipped $P$. Let $F$ be the element of \cite[Theorem 2.6]{GGV1} for $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)$. As in the proof of \cite[Proposition 8.1]{GGV1}: if $\st(F)=(1,1)$ then $\en(F)\ne(1,1)$, since $F$ is not a monomial \cite[Remark 2.5]{GGV1}, so $\en(F)\sim\en(P)\sim(0,1)$ and $v_{-1,5}(F)=4$ would give $\en(F)=(0,4/5)$, which is impossible; hence $\st(F)\sim(20,5)$, so $\st(F)=(16,4)=\frac45\cdot\frac1m\st(P)$ and $q=5$ in \cite[Corollary 7.4]{GGV1}. That corollary applies to the flipped pair and to every pair obtained from it by a translation of the second variable by a Laurent monomial in the first (the form $\ell_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}$, the degrees $v_{1,1}$, $v_{0,1}$ and $F$ are unchanged). It yields: for every weight between $(1,-4)$ and $(\rho_0,\sigma_0)$ at which the pair has an edge, the edge form of $P$ is a power $R^{5m}$. In the original variables: for a weight $(-s,1)$ with $s<4$ carrying an edge with end point $(5m,20m)$, the form is $(xy^4-\gamma y^{4-s})^{5m}$, so $s\in\mathbb Z$, and $s\ge2$ by the condition on $\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0)$. The translation $x\mapsto x+\gamma y^{-s}$ removes this edge and leaves the forms of smaller $s$ unchanged \cite[Proposition 3.9]{GGV1}. After at most two such translations ($s=2,3$) no edge of weight $(-s,1)$, $s<4$, has end point $(5m,20m)$. Since the weight $(-4,1)$ lies within a half-turn of $(5,-1)$, the point $(5m,20m)$ is then still leading for $(-4,1)$ \cite[Remark 2.10, Proposition 3.7]{GGV1}; hence every monomial $x^iy^j$ of the translated $P$ satisfies $j\le 4i$, that is, $x^iy^j=z^iv^{4i-j}$ is a monomial in $z=xy^4$, $v=y^{-1}$. The same holds for $Q$: at a weight where $P$ has an edge, \cite[Proposition 7.3]{GGV1} with $T_0=Q$ gives $[\ell(Q),\ell(P)]=0$ and proportional values, so $\ell(Q)\sim R^{5n}$ and the same translation applies; at the remaining weights $(-s,1)$, $s<4$, the values of $P$ and $Q$ are positive, so the leading forms commute \cite[Proposition 1.13]{GGV1} and $\ell(Q)$ is the monomial at $(5n,20n)$; hence $j\le4i$ on the support of $Q$ by continuity. The degree statements follow from $5i-j\le5m$ in (D1), and the Jacobian from $dx\wedge dy=-v^2\,dz\wedge dv$. \end{proof} \section{Places at infinity of a fibre} Fix a generic $p\in K$ and let $\Gamma_p:=\{\hat P=p\}\subset\mathbb A^2_{z,v}$, with $\bar\Gamma_p$ the normalisation of its projective closure. Since $H(1,0)=1$, every place $\pi$ of $\bar\Gamma_p$ at infinity satisfies $v\to\infty$ and $z/v\to\theta$ with $u(\theta)=0$; then $y=v^{-1}\to0$ and $t=xy^5\to\theta$. So $\pi$ is a branch, at $(\tau,W)=(0,0)$, of $P-p$ regarded in $K[\tau][W,W^{-1}]$, $\tau=t-\theta$. \begin{lemma}\label{simple} Let $P,Q\in R_\omega$ with $\{P,Q\}_N=c\in K^\times$, let $(N,\delta)$ be one of $(5,5)$, $(5,4)$, $(5,3)$, $(9,9)$, $(9,7)$, put $D:=\delta m$, and let $0\le s_*<\delta$. Assume that for all $s$ in some interval $(s_*,s_*+\varepsilon)$ one has $\ell_s(P)=A'\tau^m\omega^{-D}$ and $\ell_s(Q)=B'\tau^n\omega^{-\delta n}$ with $A'B'\ne0$. Then $\delta=N$ (so the hypotheses cannot hold for the other three pairs), and there is $\kappa\in K[\omega]$ with $\ord_\omega\kappa>s_*$ such that, for $\tau=\kappa(\omega)+\sigma\omega^{\delta}$, both $P$ and $Q$ are polynomials in $\sigma,\omega$. Every branch $\tau(\omega)$ of $P=p$ with $\ord_\omega\tau>s_*$ has $\sigma$ bounded; in particular $Q$ is regular along it. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $s_0$ be the supremum of the $s>s_*$ with $\ell_s(P)=A'\tau^m\omega^{-D}$. It is finite, since otherwise $\tau^m\mid P$ and $\{P,Q\}_N$ would vanish at $\tau=0$. Suppose $s_0<\delta$ and write $\ell_{s_0}(P)=\omega^{-a}F_P$, $\ell_{s_0}(Q)=\omega^{-b}F_Q$; then $a=m(\delta-s_0)>0$, $\deg F_P=m$, $F_P$ has at least two terms, $b\ge n(\delta-s_0)=\frac nma$ and $\deg F_Q\le n$ (a monomial of $P$ of $\tau$-degree $>m$, or of $Q$ of $\tau$-degree $>n$, is not leading for any $s>s_*$). By Lemma~\ref{bracket}(c), either $F_P^{\,b}$ is proportional to $F_Q^{\,a}$, or $\Sigma_{s_0}=0$ and $aF_PF_Q'-bF_P'F_Q=c$. In the first case degrees give $b=\frac nma$ and $F_P^n\sim F_Q^m$; as $\gcd(m,n)=1$, every root of $F_P$ has multiplicity divisible by $m$, so $F_P=A'(\sigma-\kappa_0)^m$ with $\kappa_0\ne0$ and $s_0\in\mathbb Z$; the translation $\tau\mapsto\tau+\kappa_0\omega^{s_0}$ preserves the bracket and the hypotheses, with $s_*$ replaced by $s_0$. The second case is impossible. Put $\eta:=\delta-s_0>0$. From $\Sigma_{s_0}=0$ and $b\ge\frac nma$ we get $N-1-s_0=a+b\ge(m+n)\eta=(3m-1)\eta$, that is $(3m-2)\eta\le N-1-\delta$. For $(N,\delta)=(5,5),(5,4),(9,9)$ the right side is $\le0$, a contradiction. For $(5,3)$ and $(9,7)$ it equals $1$, so $0<\eta\le\frac1{3m-2}$. The equation $aF_PF_Q'-bF_P'F_Q=c$ has a nonzero constant term, which requires a monomial $\tau\omega^{-(a+s_0)}$ in $P$ or a monomial $\omega^{-a}$ in $P$; hence $a+s_0=\delta+(m-1)\eta\in\mathbb Z$ or $a=m\eta\in\mathbb Z$. Both are impossible, because $0<(m-1)\eta0$, Lemma~\ref{bracket}(c) gives $F_P'F_Q=0$ or $-bF_P'F_Q=c$, both impossible; so $b=0$ and $Q\in K[\sigma,\omega]$. Now $dP\wedge dQ=c\,\omega^{-N}d\tau\wedge d\omega=c\,\omega^{\delta-N}d\sigma\wedge d\omega$ is regular, so $\delta\ge N$; among the five pairs this leaves only $\delta=N$. Finally, for every $s$ with $s_*s_*$ has order $\ge \delta$ in the final coordinate, that is, $\sigma$ is bounded. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}\label{simpleroots} At every place of $\bar\Gamma_p$ at infinity lying over a simple root $\theta$ of $u$ (including $\theta=0$), the function $\hat Q$ is regular. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} For small $s$, $\ell_s(P)=u'(\theta)^m\tau^mW^{-5m}$ and $\ell_s(Q)=\mu u'(\theta)^n\tau^nW^{-5n}$; apply Lemma~\ref{simple} with $(N,\delta)=(5,5)$, $s_*=0$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{double} Let $\theta=c$ be a double root of $h$ and $u(c+\tau)=U\tau^2+O(\tau^3)$, $U\ne0$. Put $s^*:=\frac{5m-3}{2m-1}$. Then exactly one of the following holds. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)] \item $\hat Q$ is regular at every place of $\bar\Gamma_p$ over $c$. \item After a translation $\tau\mapsto\tau+\kappa_1W+\kappa_2W^2$, with $\sigma=\tau W^{-s^*}$, \begin{align*} \ell_{s^*}(P)&=W^{-m/n}\bigl(B\sigma+U^m\sigma^{2m}\bigr),\\ \ell_{s^*}(Q)&=W^{-1}\,G\Bigl(1+\tfrac{2m}{m-1}\varsigma+\tfrac{2m^2}{(m-1)(2m-1)}\varsigma^2\Bigr),\qquad \varsigma:=\tfrac{U^m}{B}\sigma^{n}, \end{align*} with $BG=-J$ and $G=\mu(m-1)nB^2/(2m^2U)$. There are exactly two places of $\bar\Gamma_p$ over $c$: a place $\beta_1$ with $\ord_{\beta_1}(y)=n$, at which $\hat Q$ has a pole of order $n$ and $y\hat Q\to -G/n$; and a place $\beta_2$ with $\ord_{\beta_2}(y)=1$, at which $\hat Q$ has a simple pole and $y\hat Q\to G$. \end{enumerate} In case \textup{(ii)}, $G^3=(m-1)n\mu J^2/(2m^2U)$, and $\kappa_1,\kappa_2,B,G$ do not depend on $p$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Work with $f:=P-p$ and $Q$ in $K[\tau][W,W^{-1}]$, $N=5$. For small $s$, $\ell_s(f)=U^m\tau^{2m}W^{-5m}$, $\ell_s(Q)=\mu U^n\tau^{2n}W^{-5n}$. Let $s_0$ be the first $s$ at which $\ell_s(f)$ is not a monomial; for generic $p$ the constant term of $f$ is nonzero, also after the translations below (which do not depend on $p$), so $s_0\le 5/2$. Put $a=\nu_{s_0}(f)=m(5-2s_0)$ and $b=\nu_{s_0}(Q)\ge\frac nma$, so that $\Sigma_{s_0}\ge (3m-1)(5-2s_0)+s_0-4=(6m-3)(s^*-s_0)$. Note $20$, so $F_P^{\,b}\sim F_Q^{\,a}$, whence $b=\frac nma$, $F_P^n\sim F_Q^m$, and $F_P=U^m\mathcal G^m$, $F_Q=\mu U^n\mathcal G^n$ with $\mathcal G$ monic quadratic, $\mathcal G\ne\sigma^2$. If $\mathcal G=(\sigma-\kappa)^2$, then $s_0\in\{1,2\}$ and we translate by $\kappa W^{s_0}$ and start again. If $\mathcal G$ has two distinct roots and $s_0\in\{1,2\}$, translating to either root gives the situation of Lemma~\ref{simple} with $N=5$, $\delta=5-s_0\in\{4,3\}$, $s_*=s_0$, which is contradictory. Otherwise $\mathcal G=\sigma^2-\kappa$ with $2s_0\in\{1,3\}$; with $W=\omega^2$ one has $\{\cdot,\cdot\}_{5}=\frac12\{\cdot,\cdot\}_{9}$, and translating to $\tau=\sqrt\kappa\,\omega^{2s_0}$ gives the situation of Lemma~\ref{simple} with $N=9$, $\delta=10-2s_0\in\{9,7\}$, $s_*=2s_0$. For $\delta=7$ this is contradictory; for $\delta=9$ it gives (i), the $2m$ roots of $f$ with $\tau\to0$ being those near $\pm\sqrt\kappa\,\omega$, exchanged by $\omega\mapsto-\omega$. \emph{$s_0=s^*$.} A lattice point $\tau^{a'}W^{-d}$ on the edge has $(2m-a')\frac{5m-3}{2m-1}\in\mathbb Z$; as $\gcd(5m-3,2m-1)=1$, this forces $a'=1$, $d=3$. So $F_P=B\sigma+U^m\sigma^{2m}$ and $a=m/n$. If $b>1$, proportionality $F_P^{\,b}\sim F_Q^{\,a}$ is impossible by degrees; so $b=1$, $\Sigma_{s_0}=0$ and $\frac mnF_PF_Q'-F_P'F_Q=J$, where $F_Q=G+E\sigma^n+D\sigma^{2n}$ (the exponents of $\sigma$ in $F_Q$ are multiples of $n$). Its unique solution is \[ BG=-J,\qquad E=\frac{2m\,U^mG}{(m-1)B},\qquad D=\frac{2m^2\,U^{2m}G}{(m-1)n\,B^2}. \] Comparing $D$ with the coefficient $\mu U^n$ of $\tau^{2n}W^{-5n}$ gives $G=\mu(m-1)nB^2/(2m^2U)$, hence $B^3=-2m^2JU/((m-1)n\mu)$ and the value of $G^3$. For $s>s^*$ the leading terms are $B\tau W^{-3}$ and $GW^{-1}$, with $\Sigma_s=0$; since $\nu_{s^*}(f)=m/n<1$, $f$ has no monomial $W^{-d}$ with $d\ge1$, so the next edge of $f$ can only end at the constant term, at $s=3$, where Lemma~\ref{bracket}(c) forces $\ell_3(Q)=GW^{-1}$. Thus the roots $\tau(W)$ of $f$ with $\tau\to0$ are $n$ conjugate roots of order $s^*$, forming one place $\beta_1$ on which $\varsigma\to-1$ and $WQ\to G\bigl(1-\frac{2m}{m-1}+\frac{2m^2}{(m-1)(2m-1)}\bigr)=-G/n$, and one root of order $3$, the place $\beta_2$, on which $WQ\to G$. \emph{$s^*\frac nma$; then proportionality is impossible by degrees, so $\Sigma_{s_0}=0$ and the bracket equation has a nonzero constant term, which requires $a\in\mathbb Z$ or $a+s_0\in\mathbb Z$. But $00$ at a root of $u$ of multiplicity $k$, the left side has the nonzero leading term $-(5e+4k)Uc\,\tau^{k-e-1}$, of order below that of $u$; at the other points the equation is regular. It has degree at most $4$: if $\psi\sim c\,t^{d}$ at infinity with $d>4$, the left side has the nonzero leading term $(5d-20)c\,t^{d+4}$. So $\psi$ is a polynomial of degree $\le4$, and eliminating its coefficients gives $c_1^2-3c_1c_2+c_2^2=0$ (ancillary script). If moreover $c_1^2=-c_2^2$, then $c_1c_2=0$, a contradiction. \end{proof} \section{Proof of Theorem~\ref{main}} On $\bar\Gamma_p$ consider the meromorphic forms \[ \omega_1:=v^{-1}\,d\hat Q,\qquad \omega_2:=v^{-2}\,\hat Q\,d\hat Q . \] \emph{Finite points.} They are regular where $v\ne0$. The points of $\Gamma_p$ with $v=0$ are the $(z_0,0)$ with $\hat P(z_0,0)=p$; for generic $p$, $\hat P_z(z_0,0)\ne0$, so $v$ is a local parameter and, by Lemma~\ref{left}, $d\hat Q=-J\,v^2\hat P_z^{-1}\,dv$ on $\Gamma_p$. Hence $\omega_1,\omega_2$ are regular at these points. \emph{Places at infinity.} There $y=v^{-1}$ vanishes, so $\omega_j=y^j\hat Q^{j-1}d\hat Q$ is regular wherever $\hat Q$ is regular. By Corollary~\ref{simpleroots} and Lemma~\ref{double}, $\hat Q$ has poles only at the places $\beta_1,\beta_2$ over the double roots $c$ of $h$ that are in case \textup{(ii)}; there, writing $\omega_2=(y\hat Q)^2\,d\hat Q/\hat Q$, \begin{align*} \Res_{\beta_1}\omega_2+\Res_{\beta_2}\omega_2&=-n\Bigl(\frac{G}{n}\Bigr)^2-G^2=-\frac{2m}{2m-1}\,G^2,\\ \Res_{\beta_1}\omega_1+\Res_{\beta_2}\omega_1&=-n\Bigl(-\frac Gn\Bigr)-G=0 . \end{align*} \emph{Conclusion.} By the residue theorem, $\sum_c G_c^2=0$, the sum being over the double roots in case (ii). If there is no such root, $\hat Q$ has no pole on $\bar\Gamma_p$ and is constant on each component, whereas $dQ$ has no zero on the affine curve $\{P=p\}$ because $[P,Q]=J\ne0$. If there is exactly one, $G_c=-J/B\ne0$, a contradiction. The only remaining possibility is $h=(t-c_1)^2(t-c_2)^2$ with both roots in case (ii) and $G_{c_1}^2=-G_{c_2}^2$. Then $G_{c_1}^6=-G_{c_2}^6$, and Lemma~\ref{double} gives $U_1^2=-U_2^2$, where $U_k=c_k(c_1-c_2)^2$; thus $c_1^2+c_2^2=0$, contradicting Lemma~\ref{carrier}. \qed \section{Scope} \begin{itemize}[leftmargin=2em] \item \textbf{Proved here, relative to the cited results:} Theorem~\ref{main}, for every $m\ge2$. The inputs are (D1) and \cite[Theorem 2.6, Corollary 7.4, Propositions 1.13, 3.7, 3.9, 7.3]{GGV1}, as indicated. For $m=3$ this is the statement of \cite{N1}; for $m=2$ it concerns the part of the case $(50,75)$ with a double root, a case already discarded in \cite{GGV2}, where the reduction step is stated without proof. \item \textbf{Verified by exact computation:} the bracket formula; for $2\le m\le12$, the solution of the terminal bracket equation, the value $-1/n$ and the two residue sums; the closed formulas for general $m$; the arithmetic facts used in Lemmas~\ref{simple} and~\ref{double}, by exhaustive search for small $m$; and the elimination in Lemma~\ref{carrier} (ancillary file \texttt{verify\_family.py} in the folder \texttt{anc}; SymPy). \item \textbf{Not claimed:} a statement on the plane Jacobian conjecture itself, on the pairs with the same starting triple whose polynomial $h$ has no root of multiplicity exactly two, or on the other families of \cite{GGV4}. In particular the degree pairs $(50,75)$ and $(125,225)$ also carry a shape of another family ($F_3$ with a triple root, respectively $F_5$ with a quadruple root, up to exchanging $P$ and $Q$), which is not covered; and the two shapes of maximal degree $126$ are not covered. \item \cite[Proposition 7.3 and Corollary 7.4]{GGV1}, on which Lemma~\ref{left} rests, are stated in \cite{GGV1} with the indication that their proofs mimic those of Proposition 7.1 and Corollary 7.2; they are applied here to Laurent translates, as in \cite[Section 8]{GGV1}. \item The argument has been checked only by the author with AI assistance (Claude, Anthropic); it has not been validated by professionals. \end{itemize} \begin{thebibliography}{9} \bibitem{GGV1} C.~Valqui, J.~A.~Guccione, J.~J.~Guccione, \emph{On the shape of possible counterexamples to the Jacobian Conjecture}, J. Algebra \textbf{471} (2017), 13--74, \href{https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jalgebra.2016.08.039}{doi:10.1016/j.jalgebra.2016.08.039}; arXiv:1401.1784v3. Statement numbers refer to the arXiv version v3. \bibitem{GGV2} J.~A.~Guccione, J.~J.~Guccione, C.~Valqui, \emph{A system of polynomial equations related to the Jacobian Conjecture}, arXiv:1406.0886v3. \bibitem{GGV4} J.~A.~Guccione, J.~J.~Guccione, R.~Horruitiner, C.~Valqui, \emph{Some algorithms related to the Jacobian Conjecture}, arXiv:1708.07936v1. \bibitem{N1} D.~Niedbala Giraudin, \emph{A residue obstruction for the family $F_2$ with $(m,n)=(3,5)$: the degree pair $(75,125)$ in the plane Jacobian problem}, Hexagon \texttt{hexagon:2611.00675} (2026). \end{thebibliography} \end{document}