{ "title": "Audit and manuscript verification, 18 November 2026", "sections": [ "Independent mathematical audit", "An independent AI auditor read the seven-page working proof with its both-parities supplement. The audit found no mathematical error or unresolved gap. It checked the general and unit-supported constants, the refined support calculation, integrality of the scaled moment matrix, the signed-measure hypotheses, and the order of limits needed for uniformity. In the nonvanishing proof it treated an integer witness and a zero residue on either tail. The audit also derived the stronger matching-parity statement over the algebraic numbers by applying transcendence of pi to the Bernoulli evaluations. The auditor made separate recommendations on exposition.", "Transfer to the article", "Theorem 1.1 incorporates both parities and both support constants at the outset. It retains the uniform cutoff when the coefficient function varies. Section 2 displays the scaled integer entries before taking their determinant, including the two triangular change-of-basis factors. The residue comparison in Section 3 uses the first discrepancy between the two reflected profiles and allows a zero tail. Section 5 takes the determinant limit with the profile fixed at the chosen cutoff. Section 6 gives the finite-polynomial argument for linear independence and the Mellin argument for at most D-1 zeros. It states the separate distinct- value bounds for unmatched profiles. The independent audit applied to the underlying working proof. This article was subsequently checked for faithful transfer and for readability.", "Independent exposition review and revision", "A separate reviewer read the ten-page manuscript of 18 November 2026, including the assigned Hexagon citation, for a number theorist new to the signed Hankel determinant. That review concerned exposition. The ensuing revision distinguishes counting exponents from counting distinct values in the abstract and states the integer contradiction before defining the grid fractions. The uniform theorem and the displayed integer matrix keep their original statements and numbering.", "Section 3 first compares the two normalized residues in the same class modulo one. For the imaginary quartic character modulo five, the weights 4 and -1 cancel the coefficient at exponent two but give W(1/5) = -1 and W(-1/5) = 1. The general first-discrepancy identity precedes the signed recurrence. The period-three example illustrates the separate possibility of a zero residue on one tail. Both examples make clear which grid contributes.", "Other revisions distinguish test-polynomial degree from pole order, illustrate the finite-tail replacement at the prime 7, and explain both the degree cost of the analytic basis and the choice of matrix size. The period-eight example motivates the squared cutoff in the support formula. The source-bundle commands sit beside their respective calculations. The illustrative arithmetic was checked directly, and the statement of the main theorem, the determinant scales and the nonvanishing size conditions were compared against the reviewed text.", "Independent programs", "The three programs and their expected text outputs in anc/checks/ come from the independent audit. All three were rerun for this write-up and their outputs agreed byte for byte with the supplied results. The grid and kernel checks use exact arithmetic. The profile check includes high-precision Fourier comparisons alongside its exact residue checks and rational bounds on finite examples. These are finite tests of the identities, supplementary to the proofs.", "Final manuscript review, 18 November 2026", "The authoring session reviewed the eleven-page article after the introduction was revised. The mathematical check traced the entries of the cleared determinant through (2.4) and (2.5), and compared the degree, moment and recurrence hypotheses of Proposition 3.1 with the signed-measure criterion in Proposition 5.4 of Fischler, Lai, Sprang and Zudilin. The discrepancy (3.2) also works when the detecting fraction is an integer or one tail has zero mass. In Section 5 the limit in the auxiliary even integer is taken at fixed cutoff and fixed profile. This removes the profile-dependent factor before the two leading constants are obtained. Section 6 proves linear independence over the algebraic numbers for nonzero values at distinct exponents in matching parity. It distinguishes the uniform and fixed-profile counts of distinct values. The review found no mathematical correction to make.", "For the separate exposition pass, the introduction was read with the abstract omitted. It defines the periodic weights and series before giving examples. Page 5 shows why the largest active grid detects the discrepancy before introducing the recurrence. All three check programs reproduced their recorded outputs. A clean three-pass build reproduced the text, the twelve external links and the rendering of all eleven pages at 112 dpi. Reference 11 uses the version URL assigned by Hexagon.", "Packaging for the repository and source archive", "The three checker footnotes now name the script directory in each distribution. It is checks/ in the repository and anc/checks/ in the Hexagon archive. These footnotes are the only edits to the reviewed LaTeX source. Both distributions contain the same manuscript and the same three independent check programs." ] }