{ "paper": "Uniform intervals for irrational even beta values", "assembled_manuscript_date": "2026-11-18", "independently_reviewed_proof_records_date": "2026-11-17", "mathematical_review": [ "The manuscript was compared with the four proof records of 17 November\nfor the bounded gaps, derivative estimates, explicit thresholds and\nfinite cover. The following points were checked in the assembled proof.", "1. Both fixed families satisfy d < 3A. The same zeros remove the\n initial analytic terms and allow the complementary sum at each\n negative integer evaluation. The extra odd-prime denominator\n factor is H_n^(d-2A). Its rate is 2j in the (9j,20j) family,\n within the margin from nine copies of the original estimate.\n2. The centered pole and derivative scales give P^(1356A+d). At a\n selected address the harmonic denominator can consume i+d powers.\n Other addresses retain at least 30A. The fixed rational constant\n includes the factorial d!, which is restored before excluding the\n finitely many exceptional dilation primes.\n3. The change of summation order gives y_l-u_a = 2h+1 and the sign\n (-1)^l. Both families have positive zero order at y_l and at\n infinity. The root residues are bounded there. Algebraicity and\n nonpolynomiality give a fixed recurrence and prevent arbitrarily\n long runs of zeros. Only the normalized seeds enter the Frobenius\n congruence. The exponent prime and dilation prime are chosen at\n different stages of the argument.\n4. The exceptional-prime bound, Dusart's stated hypothesis, both\n prime bands, the parity rounding and both overlaps were checked.\n The finite tables cover all of the initial range. The explicit\n endpoint 15m and the endpoint (299/20)m+C have different\n effectiveness statements in the abstract and the body.\n5. All five certificate outputs reproduced using the bundled programs\n and matched the reference JSON. The companion Laurent routines used\n here agree with the original routines. The 89 seeds split 45 and 44\n between the two families. The 135 bridge residues are nonzero, and\n the intervals join. The second calculation uses 100003 for the\n initial seeds and redoes the bridge one prime at a time.", "Scope of independent review\n---------------------------\nSeparate AI reviewers examined the 17 November mathematical records.\nOne reviewed bounded gaps, the derivative estimate and the complete\nfinite coverage, including program replays. Another checked the\nexplicit thresholds, the local height bound, the quoted Dusart\ntheorem and the exposition of that threshold argument. The assembled\nmanuscript received the author's separate mathematical and exposition\nchecks. The inherited order-31 phase and prime-density bounds and\nDusart's prime-distribution estimate are cited inputs." ], "exposition_review": [ "The intended reader knows partial fractions, elementary valuations,\nresidues and basic facts about algebraic functions. The introduction\nstarts with a prescribed lower index. It gives the exact theorem,\nthen compares the asymptotic endpoint with the earlier published\nbound in the same odd variable m. The ninth power at q=10 illustrates\nwhy a successful exponent serves a requested interval.", "The fixed-power argument separates the number of derivatives from the\nkernel power. It explains the origin of the extra denominator cost\nbefore comparing it with decay. The algebraic-function argument first\nintroduces a fixed residue integrand, then shows why the behavior at\ninfinity matters for the gaps. The prime argument explains why one\nneeds a bound on the total size of the exceptional primes. The final\ntwo ranges and their endpoints can be checked directly against the\ninfinite range on a single line.", "The abstract states the results and their significance. Code references\nin the body identify the source directory. A short verification\nparagraph identifies the version and scope of independent review.\nThe public bibliography links to primary versions and the project\nrepository. The paper distinguishes irrationality somewhere in an\ninterval from nonvanishing of an individual original seed.", "The attribution review traced the intermediate beta papers to the\noriginal arguments for reflection, alternating half-integer sums,\ndifferentiation, and the arithmetic use of integer zeros. The revised\nproof distinguishes Lai and Sprang's auxiliary-prime criterion from\nthe later dilation for this kernel. It also cites Stanley at the\npassage from an algebraic generating function to a coefficient\nrecurrence. The precise sources and sections are in anc/sources/inputs.json." ] }