\section{The tensor strip: a second exclusion} \label{sec:tensor} The scalar floor needs a diffusion weight that is diagonal in the Lorentz-invariant projectors, and it needs Lorentz invariance to carry Newton's tested band to the light cone. A frame in the scalar weight removes it (Section~\ref{sec:shield}). This section shows that the tensor sector gives a noise floor that uses neither step, and estimates the exclusion that follows from it. The floor is analytic under three stated assumptions. The margin is an estimate, for the reasons collected in Remark~\ref{rem:tt-estimate}, and is labelled so wherever it is quoted. \subsection{The response is a tensor} The scalar response has no pole on the light cone. The full response of general relativity has one, and conservation decides which part of the source carries it. Normalised so that a static density gives Newton's response, $\chi=\rho^2/k^2$, the response of general relativity to a conserved source $J$ with trace $T$ is \begin{equation} \chi(J)=\frac{2\,(J{:}J-\tfrac12T^2)}{u}. \label{eq:gr-response} \end{equation} On the near-null source~\eqref{eq:source}, the split~\eqref{eq:split} at $b=\tfrac12$ gives \begin{equation} J{:}J-\tfrac12T^2=\Sigma^{\TT}{:}\Sigma^{\TT}-2B^2\frac{u}{k^2}+\frac12A^2\frac{u^2}{k^4}+A\operatorname{tr}\Sigma\,\frac{u}{k^2}, \qquad \chi(J)=\frac{2\,\Sigma^{\TT}{:}\Sigma^{\TT}}{u}+O\big(k^{-2}\big). \label{eq:tt-response} \end{equation} The light-cone pole that the scalar response lacks~\eqref{eq:shield} is entirely in the transverse-traceless block. It is the propagator of the theory's own mean field: in the covariant theory the classical Einstein equation; in a theory with a preferred foliation, $1/(c_T^2k^2-\omega^2)$ with a tensor speed $c_T$ that obeys $|c_T-1|\lesssim10^{-15}$~\cite{GumrukcuogluSaravaniSotiriou2018}. For $c_T\neq1$ the strip is taken on the spacelike side of the tensor cone, where the response is real; the near-null relations~\eqref{eq:source} then change at relative order $|c_T-1|$, which we neglect. \subsection{The floor holds for every weight} Because the tensor response has a pole, the response form~\eqref{eq:response-form} of the trade-off applies to it directly. The theorem shows that the noise on each transverse-traceless polarisation is then at least $2/u$, and that the form of the diffusion weight does not enter. \begin{theorem}[Tensor floor] \label{thm:tensor} Assume \begin{enumerate} \item[(T1)] Gaussian CQ dynamics, translation invariant and CP on every past region; \item[(T2)] a drift whose response on conserved sources at the near-null momentum $p$ is the tensor response~\eqref{eq:tt-response}; \item[(T3)] matter coupled through $\tfrac12h_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}$ to the total conserved $T^{\mu\nu}$, the atom's Coulomb field included. \end{enumerate} Then for every positive diffusion kernel $\Dtwo$, Lorentz invariant or carrying any frame, the matter noise on every unit transverse-traceless polarisation $e$ obeys, in units~\eqref{eq:s}, \begin{equation} s_e(u)\;\geq\;\frac{2}{u}. \label{eq:tt-floor} \end{equation} \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Lemma~\ref{lem:P} uses only (T1) and gives~\eqref{eq:tradeoff-p} at $p$. The response form~\eqref{eq:response-form} follows from it by Cauchy--Schwarz in the $\Dtwo$ inner product and needs only $\Dtwo\succ0$. For $J=e$, $e{:}e=1$, it gives $s_e\geq|\chi(e)|=2/u$ by~\eqref{eq:tt-response}. \end{proof} The theorem means that a classical tensor field which carries general relativity's response next to the cone exposes every transverse-traceless stress to noise of at least that response. The bound rests neither on static tests nor on the form of the weight; it rests on the tensor response itself, assumption (T2). \begin{remark} \label{rem:tensor} Theorem~\ref{thm:floor} and Theorem~\ref{thm:tensor} differ in what they square. The scalar floor is not the square of a response, because the scalar response is shielded; it is the product of two channels whose weights must be diagonal in the invariant projectors. The tensor floor is the square of a response, and Cauchy--Schwarz holds in any positive inner product. A frame in the weight changes which inner product is used, not the bound. \end{remark} \subsection{Conversion of tensor noise into photons} A floor on tensor noise excludes nothing unless an atom at rest presents a transverse-traceless stress. Its particles hardly do; its Coulomb field does. This subsection computes the photon rate of tensor noise relative to that of trace noise, the conversion ratio $\XTT$. The tensor noise is a random metric field on the transverse block, $h_{ab}=\sum_e\xi_ee_{ab}$, with orthonormal polarisations $e$ and variances $N_e$. Through the amplitude~\eqref{eq:amplitude}, a tensor mode acts on an atom at rest through the Maxwell stress of its Coulomb field; the particles' kinetic stress gives only order $v^2/c^2$. Per unit variance on orthonormal components the angular weights of $|\hat k\times\mathbf J|^2$ are $\sin^2\theta/8$ for the trace and, for the two tensor polarisations summed and averaged over azimuth, $\sin^2\theta\,(1-\tfrac12\sin^2\theta)/\big(4(1-\cos\theta)^2\big)$; after the azimuthal average there are no trace--tensor cross terms. With the elastic structure factor the ratio of tensor to trace emission is \begin{equation} \XTT(E)=\frac{2\big\langle\sin^2\theta\,(1-\tfrac12\sin^2\theta)\,S_{\rm el}(Q)/(1-\cos\theta)^2\big\rangle} {\big\langle\sin^2\theta\,S_{\rm el}(Q)\big\rangle},\qquad Q=2k\sin\tfrac\theta2 , \label{eq:xtt} \end{equation} which rises from $1.62$ at 5~keV to $9.60$ at 140~keV (Table~\ref{tab:atom}): the tensor channel is of order one, not of order $v^2/c^2$. $S_{\rm el}=|Z-F|^2$ is the exact ground-to-ground factor of the atom, so the elastic conversion needs no closure; the inelastic channels only add to it, so the elastic value is the lower side. The conversion is forward peaked. In liquid xenon inter-atomic interference acts at $Q<2$~\AA$^{-1}$, which holds a share of the numerator of~\eqref{eq:xtt} that falls with energy (Table~\ref{tab:atom}); it is below two percent from 30~keV up. The interference itself is not computed. The proposition fixes the normalisation: it shows that the floor of Theorem~\ref{thm:tensor}, a bound on each tensor polarisation, gives a photon rate at least that of a definite trace noise, so that the template and likelihood of Section~\ref{sec:xray} apply to it. \begin{proposition}[Tensor emission floor] \label{prop:tt-emission} Under Theorem~\ref{thm:tensor} the photon rate from tensor noise is at least the rate of trace noise with \begin{equation} s_{\rm eq}(u)=\frac{\XTT(E)}{u}=\frac32\,\XTT(E)\times\frac{2/3}{u}. \label{eq:s-eq} \end{equation} \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Let $N_{ee'}$ be the noise covariance on orthonormal polarisations, of any form. The coupling $\tfrac12h{:}J$ gives the decoherence $\lambda\sum_{ee'}N_{ee'}J_eJ_{e'}$ with $J_e=e{:}J$ and $\lambda=\tfrac14$. The trace polarisation is $e_{\rm tr}=\delta_{ab}/\sqrt2$, so $J_{\rm tr}=\operatorname{tr}\Sigma/\sqrt2=-\rhom/\sqrt2$ and $s=\lambda N_{\rm tr}/2$: trace noise of strength $s$ has variance $2s/\lambda$. In the emission, the azimuthal integral over photon directions removes every cross conversion identically, whatever the azimuthal structure of $N$: the trace--tensor term is $\propto\cos\theta\sin\theta\cos2\phi$ and the $+\times$ term $\propto\sin^2\theta\cos2\phi\sin2\phi$, as the helicities $0$ and $\pm2$ about $\hat q$ require. Only the diagonal $N_{ee}$ enter, and by~\eqref{eq:tt-floor} $\lambda N_{ee}\geq2/u$ for each tensor polarisation. The tensor emission is therefore at least $(2/\lambda u)$ times the summed tensor conversion, which is $\XTT$ times the trace conversion per unit variance. That equals the emission of trace noise with $s=\XTT/u$. \end{proof} The proposition means that the tensor floor yields at least as many photons as trace noise $\tfrac32\XTT$ times as strong as the scalar floor at $|f|=1$, with both conversions taken with the elastic structure factor. It holds whatever the correlations between polarisations. \subsection{The tensor margin, an estimate} The margin is obtained as in Section~\ref{sec:xray}, with the tensor conversion in place of the scalar one. It is an estimate, not a bound (Remark~\ref{rem:tt-estimate}). The template is the one of Section~\ref{sec:xray} with $\Acone$ restricted to its elastic part and multiplied by $\XTT(E)$, refitted to the same likelihood. The product $\Acone^{\rm el}\XTT=3\langle\sin^2\theta(1-\tfrac12\sin^2\theta)S_{\rm el}/(1-\cos\theta)^2\rangle/(Z^2+Z)$ cancels the trace conversion, so the tensor template uses no conformal-mode input. Two bands: \begin{enumerate} \item \emph{Newton's band}, $u\in[1,10^6]~\mathrm{m^{-2}}$, the band of the scalar floor. The estimated margin is $1.7\times10^{9}$ for the observed spectrum and $9.8\times10^{8}$ median expected (Table~\ref{tab:tensor-values} gives the template-weighted $\XTT$ that the refit implies). \item \emph{The tensor's own band.} The tensor response is the theory's propagator, not a static test carried to the cone, so the band need not stop at $10^6~\mathrm{m^{-2}}$. On $u\in[1~\mathrm{m^{-2}},10^{-2}k^2]$, where the near-null relations hold to 1\%, the estimated margin is $6.0\times10^{9}$, larger because the logarithm of the band is larger. We keep the lower end at $1~\mathrm{m^{-2}}$, a conservative choice: there the null extent $k/u$ of the wave packets of Lemma~\ref{lem:P} is $7.1\times10^{11}$~m at 140~keV, and it reaches the Hubble length only near the cosmological friction scale $u_\eta=2kH_0/c=1.0\times10^{-14}~\mathrm{m^{-2}}$, with $H_0$ the Hubble rate (Table~\ref{tab:kin}). \end{enumerate} Both bands use the spacelike side of the pole only. On the timelike side $|\chi|=2/|u|$ as well, so including it would double every tensor margin; we leave that factor out to keep the same one-sided band as the scalar strip. A sensitivity test of the normalisation and of the energy dependence of $\XTT$ is in Appendix~\ref{app:numbers}; it does not address the real uncertainties, which are the atom model and (T3). \begin{remark}[What is an estimate] \label{rem:tt-estimate} Theorem~\ref{thm:tensor} is analytic under (T1)--(T3): for $J=e$ the terms of~\eqref{eq:tt-response} beyond the pole vanish, so the floor $2/u$ carries no remainder for the response of general relativity. The normalisation of Proposition~\ref{prop:tt-emission} follows from the coupling. The margin is an estimate for two reasons. (i) $\XTT$ uses the elastic structure factor of an isolated local-density atom and the near-cone kinematics. The elastic factor is exact for that atom and needs no closure, and the inelastic part only adds, so including it would raise the margin. The interference between neighbouring atoms of the liquid and the relativistic corrections to the atom are not included, and their sign is not established. (ii) Assumption (T3) is about how classical gravity couples to field energy. The equivalence principle fixes the coupling to the Coulomb field's energy, which is part of every atom's mass. Spatial diffeomorphisms, which a preferred foliation keeps, give only $\partial_0T^{0j}+\partial_iT^{ij}=0$; for a static atom $T^{0j}=0$, so the total stress it couples must be divergence-free. Kinetic and Coulomb stress separately have divergence $\mp$ the Lorentz force density, so keeping one without the other breaks the symmetry a foliation keeps. A model could still drop the Coulomb stress. The tensor mode then reaches the atom only through the particles' kinetic stress. In the gauge where the noise is $h_{ab}$ alone, it changes an electron's velocity by $\delta\mathbf v=-h\cdot\mathbf v$, an incoherent current whose elastic part vanishes. With closure over final states and isotropic orbitals, the two polarisations give $|\hat k\times\mathbf J|^2=\tfrac23\sum\langle v^2/c^2\rangle(1-\tfrac12\sin^2\theta)$ per unit variance, the sum being over the electrons of the local-density xenon atom. The tensor template becomes the constant $\tfrac{16}3\sum\langle v^2/c^2\rangle/(Z^2+Z)$ in place of $\Acone^{\rm el}\XTT$ (values in Table~\ref{tab:tensor-values}), and the Newton-band margin is $2.6\times10^{5}$. The estimate keeps the floor $\lambda N_{ee}\geq2/u$, which was derived for conserved sources. This is a rough estimate: without (T3) the source is not conserved and the result depends on the gauge in which the coupling is written. On this estimate, dropping the Coulomb field alone does not escape; a coupling blind to the atom's stress altogether would. \end{remark} \subsection{What the two exclusions share} \label{sec:independence} Two arguments support each other only as far as they can fail separately. The two exclusions share Lemma~\ref{lem:P}, the emission rate~\eqref{eq:rate}, the local-density xenon atom, the coupling $\tfrac12h_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}$, linearisation, the Gaussian class, translation invariance, and the XENONnT likelihood. Each also assumes that the mean field of its own sector is that of general relativity. The tensor exclusion does not use the projector-diagonal weight of Theorem~\ref{thm:floor}, the Lorentz transfer of Newton's band (no boost $\gamma$ appears), or the conformal-mode conversion. In exchange it assumes that general relativity's tensor propagator holds at keV momenta. Gravitational-wave observations test that propagator only at frequencies up to about a kilohertz, many orders of magnitude below those of keV photons, so this is an assumption, not a measured fact. The exclusions are independent in this sense: different escapes defeat each (Table~\ref{tab:escapes}). \begin{table}[t] \centering \caption{What each escape does to each exclusion. ``Removed'' means that the exclusion no longer applies to a theory with that feature; ``survives'' means that it still does. The last row lists the steps that both exclusions use. The tensor column refers to the estimated tensor margin.} \label{tab:escapes} \begin{tabular}{lcc} \hline Escape & Scalar exclusion & Tensor exclusion\\ \hline A frame in the scalar weight & removed & survives\\ A non-perturbative scalar mass & removed & survives\\ A tensor sector off the light cone at keV & survives & removed\\ A coupling blind to the atom's stress & survives & removed\\ Lemma~\ref{lem:P}, the atom model or the Gaussian class & removed & removed\\ \hline \end{tabular} \end{table} \subsection{What it excludes, and what escapes} Under (T1)--(T3) and a tensor sector that is that of general relativity at keV momenta, the tensor floor, with the estimated margin, excludes the published covariant theory, both completions proposed by its authors (a unit timelike vector in the scalar and vector weights, and in the vector weight only~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}), and classical CQ gravity with a dynamical preferred foliation. In the last case the foliation removes the scalar strip of Section~\ref{sec:scalar}: the Lorentz transfer of Newton's band fails, and the Bardeen potential's response in the preferred frame has no light-cone pole. The tensor propagator keeps its pole with $c_T=1$ to $10^{-15}$. A scalar mode of the foliation with its own sound cone is not treated here. The tensor floor is escaped only by leaving one of (T1)--(T3). The ways we know are: \begin{itemize} \item a tensor dispersion that leaves the light cone below the X-ray scale. Take a Lifshitz-type dispersion $\omega_T^2(q)=q^2+q^4/k_*^2+q^6/k_*^4$ with $M_T=\hbar ck_*$. At photon frequency $\omega$ the pole moves to $q_T