\section{The scalar strip: a floor from the conformal mode} \label{sec:scalar} The covariant diffusion makes the conformal part of the metric a random field with large variance next to the light cone. This section shows that slow matter feels that field through its rest mass, that the mean field gives no bound there, and that the two noise channels of the theory together give a floor that does not depend on the couplings. \subsection{The covariant diffusion and the conformal mode} Linearised about Minkowski space, covariant CQ gravity gives the metric perturbation $h$ the weight~\cite{OppenheimWellerDavies2023,Grudka2024,OppenheimSajjad2026} \begin{equation} \exp\Big\{-\tfrac12\!\int\!\big(\alpha R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}-\beta R^2\big)\Big\},\qquad b\equiv\beta/\alpha<\tfrac13 , \label{eq:dewitt} \end{equation} a diffusion with DeWitt form $\Dtwo^{-1}=\alpha I-\beta\eta\eta$, where $R_{\mu\nu}$ and $R$ are the linearised Ricci tensor and scalar of $h$, $\eta$ is the Minkowski metric, and $\alpha$, $\beta$ are the two couplings of the theory. The explicit decoherence term is $\tfrac18\Delta T\,\Dz\,\Delta T$ with $\Dz\succeq64\pi^2G^2\Dtwo^{-1}$, saturated by the authors. Matter couples through $\tfrac12h_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}$. In the scalar--vector--tensor split the conformal scalar $\psi$ and the transverse-traceless part $h^{\TT}$ are dynamical, and the Bardeen potential $\Phi$, which is the potential that accelerates slow matter, and the vector $V_i$ are constraints~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. The scalar correlator is~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026} \begin{equation} \langle\Phi\Phi\rangle=\frac{3}{2\alpha k^4} +\frac{1}{\alpha p^4}\Big[\frac{\omega^2}{k^2}+\frac{-3\alpha+10\beta}{4(\alpha-3\beta)}\Big]. \label{eq:phiphi} \end{equation} We rederived~\eqref{eq:phiphi} from the quadratic form of~\eqref{eq:dewitt}, with the four gauge modes removed and the Bardeen functionals $\Phi=\tfrac12h_{00}+\tfrac{\omega}{k}\hat k\cdot h_0+\tfrac{3\omega^2}{4k^2}(\hat k\hat k-\tfrac13\delta){:}h$, $\psi=\tfrac14(\delta-\hat k\hat k){:}h$. The proposition evaluates this correlator next to the cone. It shows that the variance of $\Phi$ has a double pole in $u$ there, and that the fluctuation is conformal: $\Phi+\psi$, which measures the departure from a conformal metric, stays small. \begin{proposition}[Near-cone conformal mode] \label{prop:cone} On the strip $u\ll k^2$, \begin{equation} \langle\Phi\Phi\rangle=\frac{c_d(b)}{\alpha u^2}-\frac{1}{\alpha k^2u}+O(1),\qquad c_d(b)=\frac{1-2b}{4(1-3b)}, \label{eq:cd} \end{equation} with $c_d\in[\tfrac16,\tfrac12]$ for $b\leq\tfrac14$. At every $p$, $\langle(\Phi+\psi)^2\rangle=3/(2\alpha k^4)$, so that \begin{equation} \frac{\langle(\Phi+\psi)^2\rangle}{\langle\Phi^2\rangle}=\frac{3}{2c_d}\Big(\frac{u}{k^2}\Big)^2\big[1+O(u/k^2)\big] \leq9\Big(\frac{u}{k^2}\Big)^2\big[1+O(u/k^2)\big]. \label{eq:conformal} \end{equation} Near the cone $h_{\mu\nu}\approx2\psi\eta_{\mu\nu}$: a conformal mode. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} At $p^4=u^2$ and $\omega^2/k^2=1-u/k^2$ the bracket of~\eqref{eq:phiphi} is $1+\frac{-3+10b}{4(1-3b)}-\frac{u}{k^2}=\frac{1-2b}{4(1-3b)}-\frac{u}{k^2}$, which gives~\eqref{eq:cd}. For $\Phi+\psi$: on $h=2\sigma\eta$ the functionals give $\Phi=-\sigma$, $\psi=\sigma$, so $\Phi+\psi$ is gauge and Weyl invariant. At quadratic order $R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}=\tfrac12C_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}C^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}+\tfrac13R^2$ up to a total derivative, with $C_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}$ the linearised Weyl tensor and $C^2$ its square, so the weight is $\tfrac\alpha2C^2+\alpha(\tfrac13-b)R^2$ with both coefficients positive for $b<\tfrac13$. On the scalar sector, where $\Phi+\psi$ lives and the weight is positive, the variance of a linear functional $L$ is $\sup_h(Lh)^2/(\text{weight})$; over all $h$ the supremum would be infinite, since the vector weight is negative at spacelike $p$ (Section~\ref{sec:cp}). Since $R(2\sigma\eta)\propto p^2\sigma\neq0$ off the cone, every $h$ can be shifted along the conformal direction to $R=0$ without changing $L=\Phi+\psi$ or $C_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}$; the supremum is therefore attained at $R=0$, and it does not depend on $b$. Evaluating the quadratic form gives $3/(2\alpha k^4)$; the value was also checked numerically across the range of $b$ and $\omega/k$ (Appendix~\ref{app:numbers}). Dividing by~\eqref{eq:cd} and using $c_d\geq\tfrac16$ for every $b<\tfrac13$ gives~\eqref{eq:conformal}. \end{proof} The proposition means that on the strip the potential that accelerates slow matter fluctuates with a variance $c_d/(\alpha u^2)$, larger the weaker the diffusion weight $\alpha$, and that this fluctuation is a rescaling of the metric. Only the lower bound $c_d\geq\tfrac16$ is used below, and it holds for every $b<\tfrac13$; the upper bound $\tfrac12$ holds for $b\leq\tfrac14$, where the DeWitt form $\alpha I-\beta\eta\eta$ is non-negative on every component of $h$ and not only on the physical modes. The next subsection shows why such a rescaling shakes charges without shaking their fields. \subsection{Coupling: rest mass, not Maxwell} On a conserved near-null source (Section~\ref{sec:source}) \begin{equation} \tfrac12h_{\mu\nu}J^{\mu\nu}=(\Phi+\psi)\rho-\psi\rhom\;\approx\;\Phi\,\rhom , \label{eq:coupling} \end{equation} so the mode couples to the rest-mass density $\rhom=-T^\mu{}_\mu$; the traceless electromagnetic binding fields drop out. A slow particle has geodesic acceleration $\mathbf a=+\nabla\Phi$ (with $\Phi=\tfrac12h_{00}+\dots$ a static mass $M$ at distance $r$ has $\Phi=+GM/r$). Maxwell's equations are conformally invariant in four dimensions, so the photon field does not see the mode: in conformal variables Maxwell is flat and the rest mass varies, a slow charge has coordinate acceleration $+\nabla\Phi$ and radiates by Larmor, with no Coulomb-scattering term to cancel it. The non-conformal remainder is $O(u/k^2)$, which is negligible on the band at X-ray energies (Appendix~\ref{app:numbers}). Near the cone the scalar sector of covariant CQ gravity acts on slow matter as a stochastic Nordstr\"om field. \subsection{The mean field is shielded; the noise is not} The response form~\eqref{eq:response-form} bounds noise by the response of the mean field, so the first question is what that response is next to the cone. General relativity's retarded response of $\Phi$ to any conserved source, with energy density $\rho$, stress $\tau_{ij}$ and transverse stress trace $\operatorname{tr}_\perp\tau\equiv(\delta_{ij}-\hat k_i\hat k_j)\tau_{ij}$ (the $\operatorname{tr}\Sigma$ of Eq.~\eqref{eq:source} below), is \begin{equation} \frac{\Phi_{\rm resp}}{16\pi G}=\frac{1}{k^2}\Big[-\frac{\rho-\operatorname{tr}_\perp\tau}{4}+\frac{\rho u}{2k^2}\Big], \label{eq:shield} \end{equation} with no pole at $u=0$: the instantaneous Poisson constraint at every $\omega$. The $1/u$ response sits in the tensor channel (Section~\ref{sec:tensor}). The response form~\eqref{eq:response-form} therefore gives slow matter no near-cone floor. The floor comes from the diffusion structure~\eqref{eq:dewitt}, through both channels at once. \subsection{The conserved near-null source} \label{sec:source} The floor is a statement about the noise on the source that an emitting atom presents. Conservation fixes the form of that source next to the cone and shows which of its parts can carry a floor. At near-null $p$ every conserved source has the form \begin{equation} J=A\,ll+B\,(le+el)+\Sigma_{ab}\,e_ae_b,\qquad l=\big(1,\tfrac{\omega}{k}\hat k\big),\quad l\cdot l=-\frac{u}{k^2},\quad e_a\perp\hat k , \label{eq:source} \end{equation} and conservation forces $T^{0z}\approx T^{00}$. For a slow atom the relevant source is the transition element $\langle f\gamma|T^{\mu\nu}(p)|0\rangle$ of the full emission process. It includes the photon and the Maxwell stress of the atom's Coulomb field and is conserved because the total $T^{\mu\nu}$ is, so~\eqref{eq:source} is a property of the amplitude, not of the kinetic stress of the atom. The trace $T$ of the source sits in the transverse block, $\operatorname{tr}\Sigma=T+Au/k^2\approx-\rhom$. Write $\kappa\equiv\Sigma{:}\Sigma/\rhom^2\geq\tfrac12$, with equality when the traceless part $\Sigma^{\TT}$ vanishes. The saturated explicit kernel per $\alpha$ splits as \begin{equation} \frac{N}{\alpha}=J{:}J-bT^2=\big(\tfrac12-b\big)(\operatorname{tr}\Sigma)^2+\Sigma^{\TT}{:}\Sigma^{\TT} -2B^2\frac{u}{k^2}+(1-b)A^2\frac{u^2}{k^4}+2bA\operatorname{tr}\Sigma\,\frac{u}{k^2}. \label{eq:split} \end{equation} The $ll$ part, which carries $T^{00}$, $T^{0z}$ and $T^{zz}$ together, has weight $(1-b)u^2/k^4$, which is negligible on the band at every energy above 1~keV (Appendix~\ref{app:numbers}): the energy density carries none of the floor. The trace enters with weight $\tfrac12-b>0$, the anisotropic stress with weight one, and the $B$ term, the non-positive direction of the DeWitt form, at $O(u/k^2)$. \subsection{The scalar floor} Matter on the source~\eqref{eq:source} receives noise through two channels. The explicit channel is the decoherence that positivity ties to the diffusion weight; it is proportional to $\alpha$. The dynamical channel is the fluctuating potential of Proposition~\ref{prop:cone}; it is proportional to $1/\alpha$. The theorem shows that their sum has a lower bound in which $\alpha$ does not appear, and that the bound holds for every positive weight built from the two Lorentz-invariant projectors that act on conserved sources, the spin-2 projector $P^{(2)}$ and the spin-0 projector $P^{(0s)}$, with coefficients that are any positive functions of $p^2$. \begin{theorem}[Scalar floor] \label{thm:floor} Let the CQ dynamics be Gaussian, translation invariant and CP on every past region, with matter coupled through $\tfrac12h_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}$ and Newton's force carried by the classical field. Let the diffusion weight on physical modes be $\Dtwo^{-1}=a_2(p^2)P^{(2)}+a_0(p^2)P^{(0s)}$ with $a_2,a_0>0$, the DeWitt form~\eqref{eq:dewitt} included. Then on the conserved near-null source~\eqref{eq:source} \begin{equation} s(u)\;\geq\;\frac23\,\frac{|f(u)|}{u}\,\big[1+O(u/k^2)\big] \label{eq:floor} \end{equation} for every $\alpha$, every $b<\tfrac13$ and every $p^2$-dependent regulator or running of $a_2,a_0$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} For the DeWitt weight the two channels on the same source are \begin{equation} s_{\rm exp}=4\pi\lP^2\,\alpha(\kappa-b)\,|f|^2,\qquad s_{\rm dyn}=\frac{\kappa-\frac{1-4b}{4(1-3b)}}{4\pi\lP^2\,\alpha\,u^2}, \label{eq:channels} \end{equation} the first from~\eqref{eq:split} with $\Dz$ saturating~\eqref{eq:tradeoff-p} (Lemma~\ref{lem:P}), the second from~\eqref{eq:cd} on the source. Both increase with $\kappa$, so their product is least at $\kappa=\tfrac12$: \begin{equation} s_{\rm exp}\,s_{\rm dyn}\geq\big(\tfrac12-b\big)c_d\,\frac{|f|^2}{u^2} =\frac{\tilde g^2|f|^2}{4u^2},\qquad \tilde g^2=\frac{(1-2b)^2}{2(1-3b)}\geq\frac49 , \label{eq:product} \end{equation} with the minimum at $b=\tfrac16$. The product does not contain $\alpha$, and $s\geq2\sqrt{s_{\rm exp}s_{\rm dyn}}=\tilde g|f|/u\geq\tfrac23|f|/u$. For general positive $(a_2,a_0)$ the invariant form on conserved sources is $\tfrac14J\langle hh\rangle J=(x_2/a_2+x_0/4a_0)/p^4$ with $x_2=J\cdot P^{(2)}\cdot J$ and $x_0=T^2/3$, and Cauchy--Schwarz gives \begin{equation} (a_2x_2+a_0x_0)\Big(\frac{x_2}{a_2}+\frac{x_0}{4a_0}\Big)\geq\big(x_2+\tfrac12x_0\big)^2\geq\frac{\rhom^4}{9}, \label{eq:cs} \end{equation} since at $\kappa\geq\tfrac12$, $x_0=\rhom^2/3$ and $x_2\geq\rhom^2/6$. The DeWitt weight at $b=\tfrac16$ attains the bound. \end{proof} The theorem means that no choice of the couplings, and no regulator or running that is a function of $p^2$, lowers the noise on the strip below two thirds of the value $|f|/u$ that a field coupled to the trace alone would have: weakening one channel strengthens the other. The floor is analytic. Its assumptions are those of the statement; the one that a classical theory can give up at least cost is the form of the weight. \begin{remark} \label{rem:floor} (i) The floor~\eqref{eq:floor} is not the square of a response: the scalar response is shielded~\eqref{eq:shield}. It needs a weight diagonal in the Lorentz-invariant projectors. A frame in the scalar weight breaks this structure; Section~\ref{sec:shield} lists what that costs. (ii) At $b\to\tfrac13^-$ the factor $\tilde g^2$ rises monotonically from its minimum and diverges; at $b=\tfrac13$ the scalar is Weyl-degenerate and unweighted, and $b>\tfrac13$ is not positive. Nothing opens at the edge. Hirotani and Matsumura report that a strain-noise term vanishes at $\beta=\tfrac13$~\cite{HirotaniMatsumura2026}; that factor comes from a non-conserved stochastic source in harmonic gauge, and on the conserved source~\eqref{eq:source} the physical scalar weight is $a_0=\alpha-3\beta$. (iii) At $\omega=0$ conservation gives $\kappa=1$ and the floor is $\sqrt{(1-b)(3-8b)/(1-3b)}/k^2\geq\tfrac53/k^2$, above the static mediator value $1/k^2$. This static floor is Oppenheim and Sajjad's~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. With $x=1-3b$, $(1-b)(3-8b)/(1-3b)=(1+8x)(2+x)/(9x)$ is their ratio of the scalar channel's product of diffusion and decoherence to the tensor channel's, whose minimum $25/9$ at $b=\tfrac16$ they give. The noise floor is its square root, because the least noise is twice the geometric mean of the two channels. \end{remark} \subsection{The integrated floor} The emission of an atom depends on the floor through its integral over the strip (Section~\ref{sec:xray}), and static tests fix the integrand. Newton's law is tested with $|f|=1$ from 1~mm to 1~m, that is $u\in[1,10^6]~\mathrm{m^{-2}}$. By Lorentz invariance of the scalar weights this band is a near-cone strip at every photon energy, and \begin{equation} \int s\,du\;\geq\;\frac23\ln10^{6}=9.21 . \label{eq:int-floor} \end{equation} For a theory whose classical field couples to the trace alone (Nordstr\"om-type CQ gravity~\cite{OppenheimNordstrom2024}) the response form~\eqref{eq:response-form} applies directly, $s\geq|f|/u$, and $\int s\,du\geq\ln10^6=13.8$. Both integrals depend on the tested band only through the logarithm of its width, and neither depends on the photon energy.