\section{Objections and scope} \label{sec:objections} This section takes the objections in turn: that X-ray bounds do not apply to coloured noise, that the theory under test may not be completely positive, that regulators, running couplings or a mass could remove the strip, and that the atomic and statistical inputs are idealised. Each subsection states what the objection changes and what it leaves in place. Statements about the tensor strip refer to the estimated margin of Section~\ref{sec:tensor}. \subsection{Do X-ray bounds constrain white noise only?} Curceanu \emph{et al.}\ stress that X-ray bounds constrain Markovian, effectively white noise, and that suppressing the spectrum at high frequency can weaken them~\cite{CurceanuMusing2026}; Vinante and Ulbricht make the same point for heating~\cite{VinanteUlbricht2021}. The caveat concerns spectra suppressed at high frequency. The near-cone spectrum is fixed by the theory: at frequency $\omega$ the force-noise density is $\int d^3q\,q^2S\propto\omega^3\int s\,du$, which is blue, and Lorentz invariance places its support at keV. The emission rate~\eqref{eq:rate} uses the spectral density at $\omega=E/\hbar$, which is what Section~\ref{sec:xray} computes. In Oppenheim and Sajjad's analysis the matter decoherence obtained after integrating out $\psi$ is non-Markovian~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. That does not enter: $s(u)$ is the field noise of $\psi$ with its own propagator, and the golden-rule rate needs only its spectral density. \subsection{Is the published theory completely positive?} \label{sec:cp} The floors assume complete positivity, and the authors of the theory leave open whether it holds once matter is coupled. The result does not need the question settled, because it takes the form of a dilemma. The gravitational action is a positive weight on the scalar and tensor modes~\cite{OppenheimWellerDavies2023,Grudka2024,OppenheimSajjad2026}, but its vector weight $-\tfrac{\alpha}4p^2k^2|V|^2$, with $V$ the vector part of the metric perturbation, is negative on spacelike $p$, the strip itself. With matter added, Oppenheim and Sajjad find that the vector sector favours recoherence of the momentum density, so that ``even if the gravitational vector sector is somehow fixed, the evolution would no longer be positive'', and that ``it is not fully clear to us how the vectorial sector is to be handled''~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. They name remedies: (i) restricting the path integral to exclude tachyonic $V$, at the price of a non-Markovian noise kernel; (ii) a preferred frame, worked out as a unit timelike vector $n^\mu$ in the diffusion matrix, either in the vector and scalar sectors (their case A) or in the vector sector only (case C); (iii) an additional field; and (iv) restricting the kernel to timelike $p$~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. The dilemma can be stated without choosing among them. Define ``the scalar sector stays Lorentz invariant'' operationally: on the physical record space $\Dtwo^{-1}=a_2(p^2)P^{(2)}+a_0(p^2)P^{(0s)}+\Delta$ with $\Delta\succeq0$ vanishing, to $O(u/k^2)$, on every $B=0$ source~\eqref{eq:source} (all $A$ and $\Sigma_{ab}$), and likewise for $\Dz$. Then: \begin{itemize} \item \emph{either} the matter-coupled theory is CP on the record space, which its authors leave open; its scalar sector is positive~\cite{Grudka2024,OppenheimSajjad2026}, the strip noise is defined, and the theory is excluded as it stands, by $\geq1.1\times10^{8}$ and by about $2.5\times10^{3}$ in its constant-coupling window; \item \emph{or} it needs a CP completion, and every completion whose scalar sector stays Lorentz invariant is excluded by the same margins. \end{itemize} The remedies fall on one side or the other. Remedy (i) and case C act on the vector sector only. With a positive vector sector the sectors are orthogonal, $\langle\Phi V\rangle=0$, so the scalar floor on the $B=0$ source is untouched and the scalar noise is a lower bound on the force noise; case C adds a non-negative term to the explicit channel. A non-Markovian kernel keeps the hypotheses of Lemma~\ref{lem:P}, which needs translation invariance and positivity on every past region, not Markovianity. Remedy (iv) sets the kernel to zero at spacelike $p$. If that is the decoherence kernel, Lemma~\ref{lem:P} forces $\Done=0$ there, that is, no static Newtonian force. If it is the weight $\Dtwo^{-1}$, the diffusion is infinite at spacelike $p$, as the authors note for $V$, and static Newton is lost in noise. If it is the noise kernel itself, the natural reading of a restriction on correlations, then $\Dtwo=0$ at spacelike $p$ and~\eqref{eq:tradeoff-p} forces $\Dz=\infty$ wherever $\Done\neq0$, which is also excluded. Static Newton, a drift with bounded noise at spacelike $p$, therefore excludes (iv) on the full kernel. Case A puts $n^\mu$ into the scalar weight and survives the scalar strip; it does not survive the tensor strip (Section~\ref{sec:tensor}). Remedy (iii) is not specified; one realisation, a relational clock field~\cite{VaidhyanathanMilburn2025}, is open (Table~\ref{tab:shield}). \subsection{Regulators, running couplings and the mean field} Running couplings are the authors' proposed answer to the bound from the energy density of stochastic gravitational waves~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}, so the question is whether they also answer this one. They do not, because every Lorentz-invariant regulator and every running of the couplings acts on $u$, and Theorem~\ref{thm:floor} holds for arbitrary $a_2(p^2)$, $a_0(p^2)$; the invariant $\varepsilon$ and modulus-squared prescriptions of~\cite{Grudka2024} are covered by rows 1 and 3 of Table~\ref{tab:margins}. A cut-off on $\Dz$ alone violates the trade-off unless the Newton coupling is cut as well; the floor holds wherever $|f|$ is tested, which is why the band is 1~mm--1~m. An invariant modification of the mean-field operator, $(1+\ell^2\Box)G_{\mu\nu}=8\pi GT_{\mu\nu}$, multiplies the product~\eqref{eq:product} by $(1-\ell^2u)^2$, which is close to one on the band for $\ell$ well below a millimetre. \subsection{A mass for the scalar} A mass is a Lorentz-invariant structure that lowers the floor, since it moves the pole away from $u=0$. A mass $m$ acts on $u$, and the scalar floor becomes $\tfrac23\int_1^{10^6}du/(u+m^2)$. The margin is large, so the mass must be large: the margin reaches one at $m^2=8.6\times10^{12}~\mathrm{m^{-2}}$, a Compton length of $0.34~\mu$m. Masses induced by matter are smaller by many orders of magnitude (Appendix~\ref{app:numbers}). The DeWitt family has no gauge-invariant quadratic mass term at linear order. A non-perturbative scalar mass above $(0.34~\mu\mathrm{m})^{-1}$ is the one Lorentz-invariant escape from the scalar strip that we find within the Gaussian class at linear order. It does not touch the tensor floor. \subsection{What shields each strip} \label{sec:shield} \begin{table}[t] \centering \caption{Structures that a classical theory may contain, and whether each removes the noise floor on the scalar strip and on the tensor strip (``no'': the floor stays; ``removed'': it does not apply; ``open'': not settled; a dash: the structure does not concern that strip). ``Frame in the law'' means a frame written into the dynamics; the other carriers are the classical record, the matter, and the state of an extra field. The tensor column assumes a tensor sector that is that of general relativity at keV momenta and assumptions (T1)--(T3), and its exclusion rests on an estimated margin.} \label{tab:shield} \begin{tabular}{p{8.8cm}cc} \hline Structure & Scalar strip & Tensor strip\\ \hline Conservation $k_\mu T^{\mu\nu}=0$ & response floor only & no\\ Constraint as a weight (covariant DeWitt) & no & no\\ Constraint as a frame law~\cite{Layton2023} & removed & no\\ Unit timelike vector in the scalar and vector weights (case A) & removed & no\\ Unit timelike vector in the vector weight only (case C) & no & no\\ Excluding tachyonic $V$, non-Markovian kernel & no & no\\ Kernel restricted to timelike $p$ & \multicolumn{2}{c}{excluded by static Newton}\\ Preferred foliation with a light-cone tensor & removed & no\\ Any $p^2$-only regulator or running & no & no\\ Finite age, cosmological friction & no & no\\ Perturbative or matter-induced scalar mass & no & no\\ Frame cut-off on $k$ or $\omega$ below 1~keV in the full drift & removed & removed\\ Form factor in the matter four-velocity & removed & removed\\ Tensor dispersion off the cone below $\sim10$~eV ($z=3$) & --- & removed\\ Matter coupling blind to the atom's stress & no & removed\\ Relational clock field~\cite{VaidhyanathanMilburn2025} & open & open\\ \hline \end{tabular} \end{table} Table~\ref{tab:shield} lists what removes each strip. The pattern is simple. Every structure in the table that removes the scalar strip is a frame on the scalar sector near the light cone: in the law, carried by the record, or carried by the matter's own four-momentum. A frame carried by the state of an extra field is the open case, and the scalar mass of the preceding subsection is the one exception. A matter-frame form factor $\exp(-[p^2+2(p\cdot U)^2]R_0^2/2)$, with $U$ the four-velocity of the matter and $R_0$ a smearing length, depends on $U$ only through the change of invariant mass at a vertex, so it acts only on inelastic vertices; the floor becomes $\tfrac23|F_U|^2/u$, with $F_U$ the form factor, and falls below the limit for $R_0\geq1.68$~\AA. A relational clock field~\cite{VaidhyanathanMilburn2025} regulates the vacuum heating of a covariant master equation through $n_\mu\propto\partial_\mu\Theta$, the gradient of the clock field $\Theta$, a frame carried by the state; whether the X-ray data bound its resolution is open. \subsection{Linearisation, cosmology, the atom and the Gaussian class} \label{sec:class} The remaining inputs are approximations or restrictions of class. None of them is known to change the result; the last marks its edge. \begin{itemize} \item \emph{Linearisation.} The strip has invariant lengths of at least 1~mm, deep infrared in a Lorentz-invariant theory. A non-linear effect that changes the scalar propagator on the strip without touching the static sector would shield; none is known. \item \emph{Cosmological friction} acts only at $u\lesssim u_\eta$, far below the band (Table~\ref{tab:kin}). \item \emph{The atom.} An isolated local-density xenon atom with closure. For near-cone noise the force is not uniform on the atom ($qa_{\rm at}\gg1$, with $a_{\rm at}$ the atomic radius), so $\Acone$ rests on closure, which is least accurate below the xenon K edge; the $E^2$ template is dominated by 50--140~keV. Manti \emph{et al.}'s isotropic form of the rate moves every margin by about one percent (Appendix~\ref{app:numbers}). \item \emph{The class.} The theorems are stated for Gaussian, continuous CQ dynamics. For jump-class dynamics~\cite{OppenheimTwoClasses2022,PiccioneBassi2025} the trade-off is a statement about second moments and holds as it stands~\cite{OppenheimTwoClasses2022}. The floors extend under conditions. Let the record be a marked Poisson process in spacetime, translation invariant (Lorentz invariant for the scalar strip), with jump events that occur whether or not matter is present and with no cross-correlation between the record and the explicit noise. Then the floors of Theorems~\ref{thm:floor} and~\ref{thm:tensor} hold for the second cumulant of the noise. The charges that radiate in Eq.~(\ref{eq:rate}) respond linearly to the force as long as the kick of a single jump is weak on the atomic scale, and the mean photon yield is then the two-point value for any noise statistics; the statistics change only how the photons are bunched. A theory of this kind therefore escapes only if all but a fraction of order the inverse margin of the floor's photons arrive in multi-photon bursts that the XENONnT event selection would reject, at unchanged mean radiated power. We do not exclude such a theory here. Jump dynamics outside these conditions, with rates that depend on the matter state or with a record that is not a Poisson process, are not treated. \end{itemize}