\section{Introduction} \label{sec:intro} \subsection*{The question} Is gravity quantized? Entanglement witnesses aim to answer through the entanglement a gravitational interaction can create~\cite{Bose2017,Marletto2017}. Classical--quantum (CQ) gravity answers the other way: it keeps the metric classical and couples it to quantum matter by a linear, completely positive (CP) dynamics~\cite{Oppenheim2023PRX}. The price is fixed by positivity. A classical field that responds to quantum matter must diffuse, and the matter must decohere, with the product of the two bounded below: the decoherence--diffusion trade-off~\cite{Oppenheim2023}. In the Newtonian limit the least decoherence allowed is the Di\'{o}si--Penrose rate~\cite{TilloyDiosi2016,TilloyDiosi2017,Layton2023}, whose spontaneous X-ray emission is bounded by underground detectors~\cite{Donadi2021,Arnquist2022,XENONnT2026}. A covariant version exists. Its diffusion kernel is quadratic in curvature, of DeWitt form $\alpha R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}-\beta R^2$~\cite{OppenheimWellerDavies2023}; it is power-counting renormalisable with a positive scalar sector~\cite{Grudka2024}, and its scalar--vector--tensor decomposition shows a dynamical, stochastic conformal mode beside the spin-2 mode~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. Its authors find it viable against matter-wave coherence, LISA Pathfinder and gravitational-wave data~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. They find that with scale-independent couplings the integrated energy density of the stochastic gravitational waves would rule the theory out, and that asymptotic freedom~\cite{Grudka2024} makes the coupling run~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. The question of this paper is whether the covariant theory also survives the search for spontaneous X-rays. \subsection*{Why it was open} Oppenheim and Panella expected anomalous heating bounds to be the most stringent~\cite{OppenheimPanella2025}, but did not compute them. They also noted that the tensor trade-off decoheres the strain components of the stress tensor, for example through $T_{ij}T^{ij}$, so that it is unclear whether heating constrains the tensor coupling~\cite{OppenheimPanella2025}. Di\'{o}si showed that the heating of Lorentz-invariant Markovian decoherence and diffusion diverges~\cite{Diosi2022GKLS,Diosi2024hybrid}. The published X-ray bounds are for the Newtonian, frame-fixed model. An X-ray of energy $E$ is emitted from noise at the frequency $E/\hbar$. The assessment of the covariant theory rests on its static and low-frequency scalar sector and on its tensor sector at gravitational-wave frequencies~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}; the matter noise at keV frequencies was not evaluated. \subsection*{The answer} This paper computes the keV matter noise of covariant CQ gravity and confronts it with the XENONnT spectrum~\cite{XENONnT2026}. The idea fits in one line. Lorentz invariance maps the laboratory band on which Newton's law is tested, invariant lengths from 1~mm to 1~m, onto a thin strip next to the light cone at every X-ray energy; the trade-off forces noise on that strip; slow matter feels it through its rest mass and radiates it as keV photons. The number is \begin{equation} \frac{\int s\,du}{\text{limit}}\;\geq\;\frac{\tfrac23\ln10^{6}}{7.7\times10^{-8}} \;=\;1.2\times10^{8}, \label{eq:headline} \end{equation} with $s$ the matter noise in units of the Di\'{o}si--Penrose kernel and $u=p^2$ the invariant momentum squared (Section~\ref{sec:setting}). The limit is not a published number: it comes from our likelihood fit to the published spectrum (Section~\ref{sec:xray}). After a bound-electron envelope we quote the exclusion as $\geq1.1\times10^{8}$ for the observed spectrum; the median expected margin is $6.6\times10^{7}$. The exclusion holds for every DeWitt coupling, every regulator and every running coupling that depends on $p^2$ alone, and it needs Lorentz invariance of the scalar sector only up to boosts of about $10^{7}$ (the margin is one at $\gamma=1.1\times10^{7}$; this threshold is set by the 1--2.2~keV bins alone, and moves by about $10\%$ between observed and median-expected data and between two evaluations of the atomic factor). The scalar exclusion has a precise escape: a frame acting on the scalar sector. One of the authors' completions, which puts a unit timelike vector into the scalar weight~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}, survives it; so does a preferred foliation of the Ho\v{r}ava type~\cite{Horava2009,BlasPujolasSibiryakov2011}. Section~\ref{sec:tensor} answers that escape with a second argument, which rests on a further assumption and on an estimated margin. General relativity's response to a conserved near-null source has a light-cone pole, and the pole is purely tensor. The response-squared form of the trade-off holds for every positive diffusion weight, so no frame in the weight removes it. It assumes general relativity's tensor propagator at keV momenta, but it needs no transfer of static tests through Lorentz boosts. The atom's Coulomb field gives the tensor source an order-one share. Its margin, $1.7\times10^{9}$ (median expected $9.8\times10^{8}$), is an estimate, because the tensor conversion uses the elastic structure factor of an isolated atom. The two exclusions share several steps, which Section~\ref{sec:independence} lists; they are independent in the sense that different escapes defeat each. Section~\ref{sec:idea} gives both arguments in words and one picture, before any formalism. The statements below are of three kinds, and the text says which is which. The two noise floors (Theorems~\ref{thm:floor} and~\ref{thm:tensor}) and the per-momentum trade-off they rest on (Lemma~\ref{lem:P}) are shown analytically from stated assumptions. The limit on the integrated noise and every margin are numerical: they come from a likelihood fit to the published spectrum with a model atom. The tensor margin, and the margin for a coupling that omits the Coulomb field, are estimates. Only the numbers that carry the result are in the body; Appendix~\ref{app:numbers} collects the rest. \subsection*{What is not shown} We do not show that gravity is quantized. The scalar exclusion is conditional on a scalar sector that is Lorentz invariant up to boosts of about $10^{7}$; with a frame in the scalar weight, or a non-perturbative scalar mass above $(0.34~\mu\mathrm{m})^{-1}$, it no longer applies. The tensor floor is shown for a tensor sector that is general relativity's at keV momenta, where it has not been tested, and for matter coupled through its total stress, the Coulomb field included; its margin is an estimate, made with the elastic structure factor of an isolated atom, and no tensor conversion for liquid xenon with a relativistic atom is given. For a coupling that omits the Coulomb stress we have only a rough, gauge-dependent estimate. Whether the published theory is completely positive once matter is coupled is left open by its authors, and we do not settle it: the result is a dilemma between the theory as it stands and its completions (Section~\ref{sec:cp}). The theorems are for Gaussian dynamics at linear order. For a Poisson record of jumps the floors and the mean photon yield are unchanged under stated conditions (Section~\ref{sec:class}), but a theory whose non-Gaussian noise delivers its keV emission in multi-photon bursts is not excluded, and jump dynamics outside those conditions are not treated. Nor do we exclude a theory with a non-linear effect that changes the scalar propagator next to the light cone and leaves the static sector alone. Frame-fixed Newtonian models are outside the result and remain subject to the published bounds~\cite{Donadi2021,XENONnT2026}. Sections~\ref{sec:objections} and~\ref{sec:discussion} give the full scope. \subsection*{What is not new} The dynamical scalar is Oppenheim and Sajjad's; its positivity is from~\cite{Grudka2024}. So is the static scalar floor, a factor $25/9$ above the tensor channel's in their product of diffusion and decoherence; Remark~\ref{rem:floor}(iii) gives its square root, $5/3$, in our units~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. That the tensor channel decoheres the transverse-traceless anisotropic stress is stated in~\cite{OppenheimPanella2025} and~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. The trade-off, and the remark that heating bounds on decoherence bound diffusion through it, are from~\cite{Oppenheim2023}. The divergence of Lorentz-invariant Markovian heating is Di\'{o}si's~\cite{Diosi2022GKLS,Diosi2024hybrid}. The X-ray route was named in~\cite{OppenheimPanella2025}, and X-ray bounds on Newtonian CQ gravity follow from Tilloy and Di\'{o}si's identification of its least-decoherence limit with the Di\'{o}si--Penrose model~\cite{TilloyDiosi2017}. Gravitational-wave strain noise~\cite{HirotaniMatsumura2026} and classical--quantum scattering~\cite{CarneyMatsumura2024} have been used against covariant CQ models by other routes. The conversion of noise into photons is Manti \emph{et al.}'s~\cite{Manti2026}. What we add is the near-cone face of the conformal mode, the $\alpha$-independent floor that survives every $p^2$-only regulator, the tensor floor that survives every positive weight, the observation that an atom's Coulomb field makes the tensor channel of order one at keV, the quantitative XENONnT bound on the scalar sector, and an estimate of the corresponding tensor margin. We found no earlier X-ray bound on covariant CQ gravity. \subsection*{Plan} Section~\ref{sec:idea} states the idea. Section~\ref{sec:setting} sets up the Gaussian CQ dynamics and derives the trade-off at fixed momentum. Section~\ref{sec:scalar} gives the scalar floor, Section~\ref{sec:xray} its conversion into photons and the XENONnT exclusion, Section~\ref{sec:tensor} the tensor exclusion, Section~\ref{sec:objections} the objections and the scope, and Section~\ref{sec:discussion} what remains. Appendix~\ref{app:numbers} lists the numerical values.