\section{Discussion} \label{sec:discussion} \subsection{Where this disagrees with the authors} The disagreement with the theory's authors is about one channel that their assessment does not contain. Oppenheim and Sajjad conclude that covariant CQ gravity is viable given current bounds, with care needed over non-linearities, non-Markovianity and scale invariance~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. Their assessment rests on the static and low-frequency scalar sector (matter-wave coherence, LISA Pathfinder) and on the tensor sector at gravitational-wave frequencies. They already find that constant couplings would be ruled out by the integrated energy of the stochastic gravitational waves; they point to the running of the couplings under asymptotic freedom, together with matter coupling, non-linear and cosmological effects that ``may further suppress'' that energy, and note that ``a definitive assessment requires a full treatment on an expanding background''~\cite{OppenheimSajjad2026}. Their assessment does not evaluate the matter noise at keV. That channel excludes the constant-coupling window again, by about $2.5\times10^{3}$ from the field noise alone. The sharper disagreement is with the proposed answer: running couplings act on $u$, and the floor (row~1 of Table~\ref{tab:margins}) holds for every running in $p^2$. The disagreement is one channel, and it is testable. \subsection{What it means for ``is gravity classical?''} The result is narrower than the question. It does not show that gravity is quantized. It excludes Gaussian, translation-invariant CQ dynamics, treated at linear order, in which matter couples through $\tfrac12h_{\mu\nu}T^{\mu\nu}$, Newton's force is carried by the classical field and either the scalar sector is Lorentz invariant up to boosts of about $10^{7}$, with no scalar mass above $(0.34~\mu\mathrm{m})^{-1}$, or the tensor sector is that of general relativity at keV momenta and the coupling includes the stress of the Coulomb field; the second alternative rests on an estimated margin. Within that class the argument is short: positivity ties decoherence to diffusion; Lorentz invariance, or the tensor propagator itself, puts the diffusion next to the light cone at every X-ray energy; slow matter feels it through its rest mass or through the Maxwell stress of its own Coulomb field; xenon converts it to keV photons with an order-one atomic factor; XENONnT sees no excess. At linear order, a classical theory of gravity that survives both exclusions needs, at once, \begin{enumerate} \item a frame or a mass in the scalar sector near the light cone (Table~\ref{tab:shield}), and \item a tensor sector that leaves general relativity below about 10~eV (for a $z=3$ Lifshitz dispersion), or a matter coupling that does not see the atom's stress, \end{enumerate} or a single structure that does both, such as a frame carried by the matter coupling (Table~\ref{tab:shield}); or its noise must lie outside the Gaussian class, and for a Poisson record of jumps it must then bunch the keV emission into multi-photon bursts (Section~\ref{sec:class}). Frame-fixed Newtonian CQ models, whose least decoherence is the Di\'{o}si--Penrose rate~\cite{TilloyDiosi2017}, remain subject to the published Di\'{o}si--Penrose X-ray bounds~\cite{Donadi2021,XENONnT2026} and are not excluded by this analysis. \subsection{Open problems} Each item would either decide an escape or turn an estimate into a bound. \begin{itemize} \item A tensor conversion for liquid xenon with a relativistic atom, which would turn the tensor margin from an estimate into a bound. \item A gauge-invariant treatment of matter couplings that omit the Coulomb field's stress. \item A non-perturbative scalar mass, outside the DeWitt family at linear order. \item The resolution of a relational clock field~\cite{VaidhyanathanMilburn2025}. \item Non-linear effects on the strip that leave the static sector alone. \end{itemize}