{ "status": "Internally reviewed manuscript; independent replay, external mathematical review and publication pending.", "date": "2026-11-17", "source": "main.tex", "pdf": "paper.pdf", "source_sha256": "721194083ee204cc295b5bb81248f0888775948607a53f8c92fdfb6493d86ec4", "pdf_sha256": "f8e737eeea83bad95bb4c60c9d23adc74add740aaba411c6036df32bdcdce9f8", "checker": "verify.py", "checker_sha256": "0461daf0cb0ab3ff158d8eb44c4427b23a201f2418c3274fddd3d76fede1c16e", "source_audit": "source_audit.json", "source_audit_sha256": "92790b10cd7a6b182b3d8a0b5fdc477bc49a56e4533c12dd8e1bcc7ab11e2de8", "pages": 18, "internal_proof_review": { "result": "No unresolved proof gap identified; this is internal AI-assisted review.", "scope": { "exceptional_witnesses": "Sections 2-4 and Appendices A-C: polynomial regularity, subgroup invariance, purity, row degrees, factorial denominators, Wilson congruence, Klein identities, Cartier pullback and nonzero binary coefficients.", "radial_witness": "Section 5: independently derived all-order binomial cancellation of pure moments, positive double-integral formula and triangle evaluation for marked moments, normalizer invariance and explicit radius scaling. The new printed formulas were reread against that derivation.", "connected_classification": "Section 6: compact forms including disconnected stabilizers, line/doublet construction, regular dual matrix coefficients, branching rules, proper SL2 stabilizer images and subdirect products.", "disconnected_classification_and_nullcone": "Section 7: number-field specialization, completely splitting primes, exponent separation, Newton identities, component averaging and the character-lattice criterion. Finite spaces, inversion and factor-permutation examples were also checked.", "recompositions": "Section 8: CRT choice of a fixed marker, valuation extension with unit coefficients, unique negative valuation, descent of algebraicity, finite-generation Eisenstein argument and prime-quotient reduction for coefficient algebras.", "primary_source_dependencies": "All 15 current bibliography entries have inspected supporting passages and recorded scope, including the two missing Long references.", "proof_clarifications": "The exact fixed subspace, representation-coordinate invariant, Cartier scalar cancellation and separable field inclusion were reread after revision; theorem scope is unchanged." }, "executor": "Internal Codex/ChatGPT source audits and mathematical clarification checks; PDF-only reading is recorded separately. No external acceptance claimed." }, "replay": { "command_from_repository_root": ".venv/bin/python unpublished/mathieu-reductive-homogeneous-spaces/verify.py", "executor": "Internal Codex replay after the clarification edits; finite scope only.", "python": "3.12.3", "sympy": "1.14.0", "dependency_pin": "../../research/requirements.txt", "result": "PASS", "exact_checks": { "Jacobian_and_Klein_identities": { "8": "PASS", "12": "PASS" }, "generator_invariance": "PASS: diagonal and non-diagonal generators for each exceptional form; normalizer Weyl element", "exceptional_direct_haar_moments": { "8": { "1": { "pure": "0", "marked": "6628352/26558675" }, "2": { "pure": "0", "marked": "-865594153113747456/298435517190385025", "prime": 53, "valuation": -1, "scaled_moment_mod_prime": 5 } }, "12": { "1": { "pure": "0", "marked": "774322255859375/51180384593195769156336", "prime": 61, "valuation": -1, "scaled_moment_mod_prime": 14 }, "2": { "pure": "0", "marked": "41958690403313837610721588134765625/1532800285927159272199695730537217233992065276406", "prime": 127, "valuation": -1, "scaled_moment_mod_prime": 3 } } }, "binary_coefficient_prime_checks": { "8": [ 13, 17, 29, 37, 41, 53, 61, 73, 89, 97, 109, 137, 193 ], "12": [ 7, 13, 19, 31, 37, 43, 61, 67, 73, 79, 97, 127, 193, 457, 523 ] }, "radial_checks": { "polynomial_and_rational_identities": "PASS", "symbolic_factorial_simplification": "PASS", "independent_phase_beta_moments": "PASS: pure and marked, m=1,...,8", "beta_double_integral_evaluation": "PASS: m=1,...,8", "direct_moments": { "1": "1/30", "2": "4/3465", "3": "1/30940", "4": "8/9561123", "5": "1/48072024", "6": "1/1981823025", "7": "7/581462519880", "8": "16/56371222841175" } }, "negative_controls": { "octahedral_middle_coefficient_14_to_13": "REJECTED", "radial_marked_m1_claim_1_over_31": "REJECTED" } }, "scope": "Exact polynomial and rational identities; direct exceptional Haar moments at m=1,2; binary coefficient checks at the listed primes; radial row/phase moments and beta/double-integral evaluations at m=1,...,8; rejection of the two listed corrupted inputs. The all-order proofs and reductive classification are in main.tex and are not certified by these finite controls.", "formal_verification": false, "external_review": false }, "pdf_review": { "build": "latexmk -pdf -jobname=paper -interaction=nonstopmode -halt-on-error main.tex", "standalone_build": "PASS: main.tex alone copied to ignored staging and compiled with the declared command; staged bytes match current source.", "result": "PASS", "latex_warnings_or_box_diagnostics": [], "rendering": "All 18 pages rendered with PyMuPDF and visually inspected in contact sheets; title and AI-assistance pages inspected individually after removing publication-status wording.", "out_of_page_text_blocks": [], "unresolved_reference_markers": false, "pdf_links_checked": 115, "invalid_internal_links": 0, "pdf_title_matches_metadata": true, "versioned_long_source_hyperlink_present": true }, "independent_replay": false, "formal_verification": false, "external_review": false, "remaining_review": "Obtain external mathematical review and an independent replay before submission; finite controls are not all-order theorem certificates.", "repository_checks": { "check_navigation": "PASS: make check-navigation", "catalogue": "8 topics, 32 principal results; source references, evidence and checker hashes checked", "portfolio": "4 sealed published papers and 11 unpublished manuscripts checked", "input_manifests": "112 pinned references and cached primary sources checked", "local_links": "484 references in 125 maintained Markdown files checked", "navigation_unit_tests": "PASS: 20 tests", "bundle_identities": "PASS: source, PDF, checker and audit hashes; matching metadata abstract; no assurance upgrade" }, "review_checklist": { "mathematics": "Internal dependency review and fresh reconstruction complete; theorem scope unchanged; no unresolved proof gap identified.", "references": "All 15 current bibliography entries checked; prior SU(2), compact connected, spherical and radial results distinguished from the additional quotient/disconnected scope.", "readability": "The supplied review findings are addressed; 18 rendered pages inspected. PDF-only reading and recheck are recorded separately.", "computation": "Exact finite coverage and two rejection controls recorded; no unrestricted certification claimed.", "bundle": "Standalone source build, PDF inspection, matching abstract and byte identities checked.", "external_review": "Not performed; remains required before submission.", "submission": "Not requested; no deposit or published-edition change.", "pdf_only_blind_reading": "Performed on the initial PDF and rechecked after the recorded revisions; actual editions, supplied context, answers and limits are recorded." }, "title": "Counterexamples to the Mathieu Property: From Explicit Quotient Constructions to a General Classification", "editorial_scope": "Prior-work attribution, quotient-descent obstacle, proof clarifications and overview improved; the abstract now spells out the degree-only multiplier already proved in Theorem 8.1. No theorem scope was changed.", "review_response": [ { "finding": "Missing Long SU(2) and compact connected group attribution", "resolution": "Introduction and two bibliography entries give exact theorem citations before presenting the extension; Section 5 separately credits prior radial transfer." }, { "finding": "Finite-quotient descent obstacle unclear", "resolution": "Introduction explains required right invariance and uncontrolled mixed moments under averaging." }, { "finding": "Lemma 6.3 needs the entire fixed subspace", "resolution": "The alternating tensor explicitly spans V^{H0}; normality preserves this full one-dimensional space." }, { "finding": "Corollary 7.2 invariant product ambiguous", "resolution": "The proof defines the K-module W, its coordinate functions z_i and their product in C[W]^K, with values one at the tuple and zero at the origin." }, { "finding": "Cartier scalar and field inclusion compressed", "resolution": "Section 4 states -v is in Fp*, names the intermediate cubic field E and its separable inclusion, and uses Fp-linearity to cancel the scalar." }, { "finding": "Central coefficient mechanism compressed in overview", "resolution": "The introduction explains Haar coefficient reduction, the Klein map to a cubic, Cartier pullback and the nonzero binomial coefficient; Section 4 identifies the affine coefficient by homogeneity." }, { "finding": "Abstract understates recomposition uniformity", "resolution": "The abstract states that each exceptional pair has one fixed multiplier for all recompositions of each prescribed positive degree, independently of coefficients, as already proved in Theorem 8.1." } ], "blind_reader_test": { "reviewer": "Internal AI subagent /root/pdf_blind_reader, started with fork_turns=none", "supplied_context": "Only the compiled PDF and the five reader questions. No research history, repository files, manuscript source, audit records, external literature or conversation was supplied. The reader reports respecting that restriction.", "initial_pdf_sha256": "a6b32e58102c4c610a595ff86c3634b176d7f6418dee4681d1c0e032b3e1edc5", "rechecked_pdf_sha256": "f53ccff97cbb597f5c546dad92115017c25485d1c61995dabe8ff37fbf36b3ba", "coverage": "Complete 18-page initial reading, including appendices and references; complete revised-PDF recheck, with visual inspection of the affected Cartier passage.", "answers": { "what_is_new": "The explicit invariant exceptional quotient pairs supply nonspherical finite-stabilizer cases for the general/disconnected classification. The text credits Long's earlier group and spherical results. Further recomposition and coefficient-algebra claims are identifiable; the reader cannot establish priority from the PDF alone.", "conceptual_reason": "Weights and integration by parts force purity; a selected prime denominator and nonzero binary coefficient force marked nonvanishing. Klein identities and Cartier pullback compute that coefficient on a cubic. Structural reductions and finite-trace separation propagate the examples.", "hardest_step_and_location": "Section 4's cubic/Cartier coefficient comparison, equations (4.5)-(4.6), with Appendices B-C; structural reductions in Section 6 and finite-trace separation in Lemma 7.1.", "limitations": "Complex groups with reductive identity components and regular functions; exceptional marked nonvanishing at selected orders; representation-theoretic existence rather than coordinate bounds for general quotients; recomposition/ring statements concern the constructed polynomial subalgebra.", "verification_obstacles": "The binary-to-affine coefficient bridge is now explicit. Remaining work is checking cited structural results, polynomial identities and the Section 8 valuation/descent argument; these are supplied proof obligations, with no definite missing central proof data identified by the reader." }, "obstacles_and_revisions": [ { "obstacle": "Connecting the homogeneous binary coefficient to the affine coefficient took reconstruction.", "revision": "Added the affine coefficient formula and its total-degree explanation in Section 4.", "recheck": "Reader verified n(p-1)/b=2(p-1) and confirmed that the bridge fits the Cartier comparison." }, { "obstacle": "The reader initially described the spherical-draft citation as lacking an accessible locator.", "revision": "Made the existing versioned GitHub link label explicit and added exact theorem/lemma locators.", "recheck": "Reader inspected embedded links and corrected the initial criticism: the original PDF already contained the revision-specific permalink." }, { "obstacle": "The abstract's coefficient uniformity could be read too broadly.", "revision": "Tied coefficient independence explicitly to the fixed multiplier for each prescribed degree.", "recheck": "Reader confirmed agreement with Theorem 8.1; no common nonvanishing-order set is asserted." } ], "result": "The reader identifies the contribution, mechanism, hardest step and limits; the concrete communication obstacles were resolved on recheck. No new mathematical inconsistency identified. This is internal AI assessment, not external acceptance, formal verification or independent literature confirmation." }, "editorial_refresh": { "scope": "Removed the title-date draft label and transient review-status sentence from the AI disclosure; retained the material assistance, including proof review. Removed the draft label from the versioned spherical-pair bibliography entry. No mathematical statements, arguments, checker or assurance flags changed.", "previous_source_sha256": "4ff953480e7899e0e77ec474b26ab92a778e3ffdc433c225f47abbca96ef25c0", "previous_pdf_sha256": "f53ccff97cbb597f5c546dad92115017c25485d1c61995dabe8ff37fbf36b3ba", "validation": "Declared LaTeX build passed with no warnings, unresolved references or box diagnostics; all pages rendered and visually inspected. Prior mathematical-review, blind-reader and finite-control records retain their recorded editions and scopes." } }