{ "schema_version": 2, "date": "2026-11-17", "path_base": "This manuscript directory", "paper_source": "main.tex", "pdf": "paper.pdf", "sources": [ { "source": "main.tex", "sha256": "4ff953480e7899e0e77ec474b26ab92a778e3ffdc433c225f47abbca96ef25c0" }, { "source": "paper.pdf", "sha256": "f53ccff97cbb597f5c546dad92115017c25485d1c61995dabe8ff37fbf36b3ba" }, { "source": "verify.py", "sha256": "0461daf0cb0ab3ff158d8eb44c4427b23a201f2418c3274fddd3d76fede1c16e" }, { "source": "README.md", "sha256": "0d4864d3aacc93885a9ef9df8d5a5f8d28e2217669918f39541df1a8f0d16f7a" }, { "source": "metadata.json", "sha256": "aea7ffece5d249ce6626f0a4bff3f5d42752d663df44ad0b30a35b42bf8cd2e5" } ], "internal_review": { "result": "No unresolved proof gap identified; this is internal AI-assisted review.", "scope": { "exceptional_witnesses": "Sections 2-4 and Appendices A-C: polynomial regularity, subgroup invariance, purity, row degrees, factorial denominators, Wilson congruence, Klein identities, Cartier pullback and nonzero binary coefficients.", "radial_witness": "Section 5: independently derived all-order binomial cancellation of pure moments, positive double-integral formula and triangle evaluation for marked moments, normalizer invariance and explicit radius scaling. The new printed formulas were reread against that derivation.", "connected_classification": "Section 6: compact forms including disconnected stabilizers, line/doublet construction, regular dual matrix coefficients, branching rules, proper SL2 stabilizer images and subdirect products.", "disconnected_classification_and_nullcone": "Section 7: number-field specialization, completely splitting primes, exponent separation, Newton identities, component averaging and the character-lattice criterion. Finite spaces, inversion and factor-permutation examples were also checked.", "recompositions": "Section 8: CRT choice of a fixed marker, valuation extension with unit coefficients, unique negative valuation, descent of algebraicity, finite-generation Eisenstein argument and prime-quotient reduction for coefficient algebras.", "primary_source_dependencies": "All 15 current bibliography entries have inspected supporting passages and recorded scope, including the two missing Long references.", "proof_clarifications": "The exact fixed subspace, representation-coordinate invariant, Cartier scalar cancellation and separable field inclusion were reread after revision; theorem scope is unchanged." }, "executor": "Internal Codex/ChatGPT source audits and mathematical clarification checks; PDF-only reading is recorded separately. No external acceptance claimed." }, "resolved_exposition_findings": [ "Give the full classification strategy, a Laurent-monomial example and a worked first radial moment.", "Distinguish the extension beyond Long's spherical theorem and define K-finiteness and defining doublets.", "Replace the radial partial-fraction calculation with a positive double integral, and prove radial purity independently by phase cancellation.", "Use explicit unit-radius coordinates in the scaling argument; identify the doublet by a unitary equivariant isomorphism.", "Supply algebraic affineness and connected Hilbert-Mumford references with precise scope; pin the corrected Cartier reference.", "Define Gamma, the rational denominator, the extended functional h_R and eventual purity before use.", "Retain the explicit closed-subgroup hypothesis, half-integral branching boundary checks, compact-form citation and coefficient-field reduction.", "Describe the actual AI assistance and internal review scope; keep operational instructions outside the article." ], "primary_references_checked": [ { "bibliography_key": "AchterHowe", "identity": "Achter and Howe, corrected arXiv:1710.10726v5 (2020)", "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1710.10726v5", "inspected_location": "Section 2.2, p.5", "support_and_applicability": "Cartier terminology and the differential extraction description; the manuscript proves its own coordinate-independence and pullback rule." }, { "bibliography_key": "AdamsTaibi", "identity": "Adams and Taibi, author's manuscript dated 12 January 2018", "url": "https://otaibi.perso.math.cnrs.fr/galois.pdf", "inspected_location": "Section 3, Definition 3.3, Lemma 3.4 and Theorems 3.7-3.8, pp.7-8", "support_and_applicability": "Compact forms meeting every component, Lie algebra complexification and containment of compact subgroups. Applies to disconnected H." }, { "bibliography_key": "Arzhantsev", "identity": "Arzhantsev, arXiv:math/0506430v1 (2005)", "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0506430v1", "inspected_location": "Proposition 2.2, p.2", "support_and_applicability": "An affine group modulo reductive closed isotropy is affine. Applied to G^0/H^0; finite component quotients preserve affineness." }, { "bibliography_key": "Borel", "identity": "Borel, Linear Algebraic Groups, second edition (1991)", "url": "https://www.math.utah.edu/~ptrapa/math-library/borel/%20Borel-Linear-Algebraic-Groups-1991.pdf", "inspected_location": "Proposition 14.2, pp.181-182; Proposition 14.10, pp.191-192; Sections 24.1 and 24.4, pp.269 and 273", "support_and_applicability": "Central torus and derived-group structure, simple-factor isogeny and simply connected coverings. Semisimple complete reducibility extends by torus weights." }, { "bibliography_key": "DvK", "identity": "Duistermaat and van der Kallen, Indag. Math. (N.S.) 9(2) (1998), 221-231", "url": "https://webspace.science.uu.nl/~kalle101/powers.pdf", "inspected_location": "p.222 and Section 3, pp.223-224", "support_and_applicability": "The constant-term/Newton-polytope implication used for nonzero complex Laurent polynomials. The criterion is not numbered Theorem 1." }, { "bibliography_key": "Flicker", "identity": "Flicker, Manuscripta Math. 167 (2022), 213-243", "url": "https://www.ariel.ac.il/wp/yuval-flicker/wp-content/uploads/sites/316/2023/06/94.FiniteSubgpsSL2Manusc.pdf", "inspected_location": "p.215, finite-subgroup classification and listed generators", "support_and_applicability": "Over algebraically closed characteristic zero, finite SL2 images lie up to conjugacy in N(T), 2O or 2I; the listed generators also show 2T is contained in 2O." }, { "bibliography_key": "Kempf", "identity": "Kempf, original preprint transcribed by Morrison, arXiv:1807.02890v1 (2018)", "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1807.02890v1", "inspected_location": "Introduction, p.1, and Section 2", "support_and_applicability": "Hilbert-Mumford contraction and positive active weights. Applied only to connected G^0 after proving equality of the two nullcones." }, { "bibliography_key": "LongSU2", "identity": "Christopher D. Long, Counterexamples to the xz-Conjecture and the Mathieu Conjecture for SU(2), arXiv:2607.19012v1 (2026)", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.19012v1", "inspected_source": "https://github.com/long-mathematics/xz-mathieu-su2-counterexamples/blob/a2afbce9b5e0d27d7a2fbc84ab08afcd9b6be49d/xz_mathieu_su2_counterexamples.tex", "inspected_location": "Theorem 4.2, equations (13)-(15); Theorem 2.1 for the underlying Laurent example", "support_and_applicability": "An explicit regular SU(2) pair already disproves the original moment implication with a fixed marker at every positive order. This is credited as prior work." }, { "bibliography_key": "LongCompact", "identity": "Christopher D. Long, The Mathieu Property for Compact Connected Lie Groups, arXiv:2609.16178v1 (2026); manuscript dated 30 July 2026", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.16178v1", "inspected_source": "https://github.com/long-mathematics/mathieu-property-compact-connected-lie-groups/blob/51593f1331528072b4d4eb88ad809be0d7429e24/mathieu_property_compact_connected_lie_groups.tex", "inspected_location": "Theorems 1.1, 1.2, 3.1 and 4.1; Section 9 scope remark", "support_and_applicability": "The compact connected group classification and existence of universal radial witnesses precede this paper. Our radial pair and formula are a different realization; the case H={1} is not a new classification." }, { "bibliography_key": "LongSpherical", "identity": "Long, manuscript dated 22 September 2026, revision e9edac262b4b64eb68feb0e6e80496cefe4a1dee", "url": "https://github.com/long-mathematics/mathieu-second-conjecture-spherical-pairs/blob/e9edac262b4b64eb68feb0e6e80496cefe4a1dee/mathieu_second_conjecture_spherical_pairs.tex", "inspected_location": "Theorem 1.1; Proposition 3.1; Lemmas 4.1, 4.2, 6.1 and 6.2; final scope remark", "support_and_applicability": "The connected spherical theorem permits disconnected H. Its line/doublet and subdirect reductions already work beyond spherical spaces; sphericity excludes residual finite SL2 projections. The cited draft does not classify nonspherical spaces or disconnected acting groups." }, { "bibliography_key": "Mathieu", "identity": "Mathieu, Seminaires et Congres 2 (1997), 263-279", "url": "https://smf.emath.fr/sites/default/files/2026-04/smf_sem-cong_2_263-279__sample.pdf", "inspected_location": "Publisher's original excerpt, pp.264-265: Main Conjecture 1.1 and Lemma 1.2", "support_and_applicability": "The original pure-to-safe assertion for K-finite functions and its invariant-projection interpretation. Only the directly accessible excerpt is needed here." }, { "bibliography_key": "Molev", "identity": "Molev, Handbook of Algebra 4 (2006), 109-170; arXiv:math/0211289v2", "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0211289v2", "inspected_location": "Theorem 2.1 and equation (4.4), PDF pp.10 and 50-51", "support_and_applicability": "The GL3/GL2 and Spin5/Spin4 interlacing rules, including half-integral parity. The chosen weights satisfy their boundary inequalities." }, { "bibliography_key": "Rond", "identity": "Rond, arXiv:2412.11738v2, dated 24 December 2024", "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2412.11738v2", "inspected_location": "Theorems 1.1 and 2.2, pp.1-3", "support_and_applicability": "Classical and generalized Eisenstein denominator bounds as context; the finite-generation lemma used here is proved in the manuscript." }, { "bibliography_key": "Stacks", "identity": "The Stacks Project, Tag 00I8", "url": "https://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/00I8", "inspected_location": "Lemma 10.50.2", "support_and_applicability": "A valuation ring dominating a local subring provides the extension of the Gauss valuation." }, { "bibliography_key": "Sutherland", "identity": "Sutherland, MIT 18.785 Lecture 18, dated 10 November 2021", "url": "https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/18-785-number-theory-i-fall-2021/mit18_785f21_lec18.pdf", "inspected_location": "Theorem 18.1, p.1", "support_and_applicability": "Infinitely many primes in a coprime progression. The two exceptional progressions and the CRT-selected recomposition progression satisfy coprimality." } ], "other_standard_inputs": [ "Elementary beta integrals, binomial theorem, Wilson's theorem, Chinese remainder theorem and Newton identities.", "Standard characteristic-zero algebraic-group and function-field facts at the explicitly cited or proved locations." ], "verification_limits": "Exact polynomial and rational identities; direct exceptional Haar moments at m=1,2; binary coefficient checks at the listed primes; radial row/phase moments and beta/double-integral evaluations at m=1,...,8; rejection of the two listed corrupted inputs. The all-order proofs and reductive classification are in main.tex and are not certified by these finite controls.", "independent_replay": false, "formal_verification": false, "external_review": false, "title": "Counterexamples to the Mathieu Property: From Explicit Quotient Constructions to a General Classification", "novelty_comparison": { "already_established": "Long's SU(2) counterexample, compact connected group classification, universal radial transfer and connected spherical classification.", "additional_scope_here": "Explicit right-invariant witnesses on the exceptional nonspherical quotients SL2/2O and SL2/2I, the resulting classification without sphericity, and disconnected acting groups.", "essential_obstacle": "A group counterexample need not descend to a finite right quotient. Averaging the pure function introduces mixed products with uncontrolled moments.", "alternative_proof": "Section 5 supplies a different radial pair and closed marked-moment formula, not new existence of radial transfer." }, "review_response": [ { "finding": "Missing Long SU(2) and compact connected group attribution", "resolution": "Introduction and two bibliography entries give exact theorem citations before presenting the extension; Section 5 separately credits prior radial transfer." }, { "finding": "Finite-quotient descent obstacle unclear", "resolution": "Introduction explains required right invariance and uncontrolled mixed moments under averaging." }, { "finding": "Lemma 6.3 needs the entire fixed subspace", "resolution": "The alternating tensor explicitly spans V^{H0}; normality preserves this full one-dimensional space." }, { "finding": "Corollary 7.2 invariant product ambiguous", "resolution": "The proof defines the K-module W, its coordinate functions z_i and their product in C[W]^K, with values one at the tuple and zero at the origin." }, { "finding": "Cartier scalar and field inclusion compressed", "resolution": "Section 4 states -v is in Fp*, names the intermediate cubic field E and its separable inclusion, and uses Fp-linearity to cancel the scalar." }, { "finding": "Central coefficient mechanism compressed in overview", "resolution": "The introduction explains Haar coefficient reduction, the Klein map to a cubic, Cartier pullback and the nonzero binomial coefficient; Section 4 identifies the affine coefficient by homogeneity." }, { "finding": "Abstract understates recomposition uniformity", "resolution": "The abstract states that each exceptional pair has one fixed multiplier for all recompositions of each prescribed positive degree, independently of coefficients, as already proved in Theorem 8.1." } ] }