\section{Four-dimensional residue images} \label{sec:real-fourfold-images}\label{sec:u4-images} We work in Setting~(T) of Section~\ref{sec:common-lemmas}, with $\nu=8$ and $\Lambda$ indefinite, and let $h(a)=a^THa$, $H=\Lambda^{-1}$, be the nondegenerate indefinite coefficient form. So $G(a)$ is positive semidefinite of rank eight at every nonzero real $a$. Let $\mathcal H$ be the real span of $h$ and the entries $G_{ij}$, and let $V(h,G)\subset\mathbb P^7_{\mathbb C}$ be their common zero locus; it has no real point, since $G(a)$ has rank eight at every nonzero real $a$. A maximal isotropic subspace of the complex form $h$ has dimension four, so $V(h)$ contains no linear $\mathbb P^4$. Complex varieties carry their reduced structure unless a scheme is specified. By Lemma~\ref{lem:scalar-span-fixed-image} and Remark~\ref{rem:scalar-span-radial} (the scalar-span criterion), if the real span of the quadratic entries of $G$ has dimension at most three, then \begin{equation}\label{eq:r4-alignment} \operatorname{Im}B(a)=E\qquad(a\in\R^8\setminus\{0\}). \end{equation} \subsection{The quadratic base} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:u4-union-height} Let $A_1,\ldots,A_k\subset V(h,G)$ be irreducible fourfolds whose union spans $\mathbb P^7_{\mathbb C}$. Then either \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds, or the ideal generated by $\mathcal H$ has height three and $\mathcal H$ contains a real regular sequence of three quadrics whose degree-eight complete intersection contains every $A_i$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The locus $Z=V(h,G)$ contains the $A_i$, so it has dimension at least four. A six-dimensional component would be the irreducible quadric $V(h)$, which has real points. Some real entry $f$ of $G$ is independent of $h$: otherwise every entry is a multiple of $h$, against rank eight at a nonzero real $h$-null vector. Let $Y$ be a five-dimensional component. It is not a linear $\mathbb P^5$, since $V(h)$ contains no linear $\mathbb P^4$, so it spans either $\mathbb P^7$ or a hyperplane. If $Y$ spans $\mathbb P^7$, then $\deg Y\geq3$ by the nondegenerate degree bound \cite[p.~1, $(*)$]{EGHP2004}, and $Y$ lies in the complete intersection $V(h,f)$, of pure dimension five and degree four. If $Y\ne\overline Y$, the two conjugate components would have total degree at least six, more than $\deg V(h,f)=4$; so $Y$ is real-defined; a generic transverse real complementary plane meets it only in conjugate nonreal pairs, so $\deg Y$ is even, hence four. Thus $Y$ exhausts $V(h,f)$ with multiplicity one. A complete intersection has no embedded associated primes, so generic reducedness makes $V(h,f)$ the reduced scheme $Y$; its homogeneous ideal, a complete-intersection ideal of positive dimension, is saturated, so every quadratic entry of $G$ lies in $\Span_{\R}\{h,f\}$, and the scalar-span criterion gives \eqref{eq:r4-alignment}. If $Y$ spans a hyperplane $\ell=0$, the restriction of $h$ to it has rank at least six, so $Y=V(h,\ell)$ is an irreducible quadric and every quadratic entry of $G$ is $g=c_gh+\ell m_g$ with $m_g$ linear. Since the union of the $A_i$ spans $\mathbb P^7$, some $A_j$ is not contained in $\ell=0$; as $g$ and $h$ vanish on $A_j$, so does $\ell m_g$, and integrality gives $m_g|_{A_j}=0$ for every $g$. The vector span of $A_j$ has dimension at least six, since $V(h)$ contains no linear $\mathbb P^4$, so the linear forms vanishing on $A_j$ span at most two dimensions. All entries $g=c_gh+\ell m_g$ therefore lie in one complex space of quadrics of dimension at most three; real linearly independent vectors stay complex linearly independent, so their real span has the same bound, and the scalar-span criterion gives \eqref{eq:r4-alignment}. In the remaining case $\dim Z=4$, so the ideal generated by $\mathcal H$ has height three. Begin with $h$ and a real element of $\mathcal H$ independent of it, and choose a third real element of $\mathcal H$ outside the finitely many height-two associated primes of their complete intersection. None of these primes contains $\mathcal H$, and over the infinite field $\R$ a finite union of proper linear subspaces cannot cover $\mathcal H$. This gives the regular sequence; its degree-eight complete intersection contains every $A_i$. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:u4-degree-budget} Under the hypotheses of Lemma~\ref{lem:u4-union-height}, assume the $A_i$ are distinct and $\sum_i\deg A_i\geq8$. Then \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Otherwise the degree-eight complete intersection of Lemma~\ref{lem:u4-union-height} contains the distinct $A_i$, so the degree sum is eight and the $A_i$ are exactly its components, each of multiplicity one. Unmixedness and generic reducedness make it their reduced union, and its homogeneous ideal, a complete-intersection ideal of positive dimension, is saturated. Every entry of $G$ therefore lies in its degree-two part, spanned by the three defining quadrics, and the scalar-span criterion applies. \end{proof} In particular, the proposition applies to two distinct fourfolds in $V(h,G)$ that each span $\mathbb P^7$ (each then has degree at least four), and to four distinct fourfolds in $V(h,G)$ whose union spans $\mathbb P^7$ (each has degree at least two, since $V(h)$ contains no linear $\mathbb P^4$). In the two-quadratic pole case these are the images of the two geometric quadratics and of the four geometric lines; Proposition~\ref{prop:aq-two-structure} supplies these alternatives, Lemma~\ref{lem:si-saturated-fibres} the distinctness of the images, and Remark~\ref{rem:r4-generic-finish} the vanishing of $G$ on them and their combined span. \subsection{A real integral image} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:r4-real-image} Suppose that a geometrically integral real-defined fourfold $A\subset\mathbb P^7_{\mathbb C}$ spans $\mathbb P^7_{\mathbb C}$ and is contained in $V(h,G)$. Then \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds. \end{proposition} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:r4-base-height} Under the hypotheses of Proposition~\ref{prop:r4-real-image}, either \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds, or the ideal generated by $\mathcal H$ has height three and $\deg A\in\{4,6\}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Apply Lemma~\ref{lem:u4-union-height} with $k=1$. In its second alternative, $A$ is nondegenerate of codimension three, so $\deg A\geq4$. As $A$ is real-defined and has no real point, a generic transverse real complementary plane meets it only in conjugate nonreal pairs, so $\deg A$ is even. The degree is at most eight, since $A$ lies in the degree-eight complete intersection of that lemma, and $\deg A=8$ gives \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} by Proposition~\ref{prop:u4-degree-budget} with $k=1$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:r4-degree-four} If $\deg A=4$, then \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The variety $A$ has minimal degree, so by the Del Pezzo--Bertini classification \cite[Theorem~0.1]{EGHP2004} it is a rational normal scroll or a cone over the Veronese surface. A singular variety in this list has a nonempty intrinsic linear vertex, which, since $A$ is real-defined, would be real-defined and contain a real point; but $A$ has no real point. So $A$ is smooth, its four positive scroll integers sum to $\deg A=4$, so all are one, and $A$ is the Segre variety $\mathbb P^1\times\mathbb P^3\subset\mathbb P(\mathbb C^2\otimes\mathbb C^4)$. Conjugation preserves the two rulings, which have different dimensions, so it lifts, up to a scalar absorbed into one factor, to $\sigma_1\otimes\sigma_2$ with conjugate-linear maps on the two factors. Then $(\sigma_1\otimes\sigma_2)^2=I$ forces $\sigma_1^2=\alpha I$ and $\sigma_2^2=\beta I$ with $\alpha\beta=1$. Each map commutes with its square, so these scalars are real; rescaling makes them signs, and they agree because the ambient real structure has square one. Positive signs would give fixed vectors in both factors, hence a real Segre point; so both signs are negative. The standard $\mathrm{SU}(2)$-action on the first factor commutes with its quaternionic real structure $\sigma_1$, so it acts on the real coefficient eight-space, and its three quaternion units make that space a left $\mathbb H$-module. The quadratic ideal of the Segre embedding, the kernel of restricting quadratic polynomials to rank-one tensors, is $\bigwedge^2(\mathbb C^2)^*\otimes\bigwedge^2(\mathbb C^4)^*$, on which the first $\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb C)$ acts trivially. So every entry of $G$ is $\mathrm{SU}(2)$-invariant, and by homogeneity $G(ba)=|b|^2G(a)$ for $b\in\mathbb H$. For every nonzero real $a$, the space $U=\mathbb Ha$ has real dimension four, since nonzero quaternions act invertibly, and this identity makes $\operatorname{Im}G$, hence $\operatorname{Im}B$, one fixed eight-space on $U\setminus\{0\}$; Lemma~\ref{lem:cl-b}(1) identifies it with $E$. Since $a$ was arbitrary, \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:r4-residual-quadric} If $\deg A=6$ and the ideal generated by $\mathcal H$ has height three, there is a reduced real complete intersection $C=A\cup Q$ of three quadrics, where $Q$ is a real-defined quadric fourfold spanning $\mathbb P(U_{\mathbb C})$ for a real six-space $U$ on which $h$ is definite. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The quadratic form $t=\tr G\in\mathcal H$ is positive definite, so it is independent of the indefinite form $h$. By height three, prime avoidance as in Lemma~\ref{lem:u4-union-height} gives a real $f\in\mathcal H$ such that $(h,t,f)$ is a regular sequence. Its complete intersection $C$ has degree eight and no real point. A four-dimensional component of degree one would be a linear $\mathbb P^4$ in $V(h)$, so every component has degree at least two. The component $A$ takes degree six with multiplicity one, so the rest is exactly one component $Q$ of degree two and multiplicity one, preserved by conjugation as the unique residual component. Unmixedness and generic reducedness make $C=A\cup Q$ reduced. A fourfold of degree two spans at most a projective five-space, and $Q$ is not linear, so it spans exactly a projective five-space $\mathbb P(U_{\mathbb C})$, for a real six-space $U$ since $Q$ is conjugation-invariant. Its equation is proportional to $h|_U$, which is nonzero because $V(h)$ contains no linear $\mathbb P^5$. Since $Q$ has no real point, this real form is definite. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:r4-four-quadrics} In Lemma~\ref{lem:r4-residual-quadric}, choose real independent linear forms $u,v$ with $U=\ker u\cap\ker v$. There are real quadrics $s,r,\Delta$ such that \[ I_{C}=(h,s,r),\qquad (I_A)_2\subset\Span_{\R}\{h,s,r,\Delta\},\qquad s|_U=r|_U=0, \] where $(I_A)_2$ is the real degree-two part of the homogeneous ideal. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Since $I_Q=(h,u,v)$, subtracting constant multiples of $h$ from $t,f$ gives \[ s=u a_0+v b_0,\qquad r=u c_0+v d_0,\qquad \Delta=a_0d_0-b_0c_0, \] with real linear forms $a_0,b_0,c_0,d_0$. Work in the graded domain $S=\R[x_1,\ldots,x_8]/(h)$ in coefficient coordinates $x_i$. Both $(s,r)$ and $(u,v)$ are regular sequences in $S$; the latter follows from $h|_U\ne0$ and the Cohen--Macaulay property of the polynomial ring. For $g\in(I_A)_2$, reducedness gives $ug,vg\in I_A\cap I_Q=I_C$, so modulo $h$ \[ ug=a_1s+b_1r,\qquad vg=c_1s+d_1r \] with real linear coefficients. The Koszul syzygies of $(s,r)$, with degrees taken into account, give a real constant $k$ with \[ va_1-uc_1=kr,\qquad vb_1-ud_1=-ks. \] Substituting the expressions for $s,r$ and using the Koszul syzygies of $(u,v)$ gives real constants $e_1,e_2$ with \[ a_1-kd_0=e_1u,\quad c_1+kc_0=e_1v,\qquad b_1+kb_0=e_2u,\quad d_1-ka_0=e_2v. \] Hence $ug=k(d_0s-b_0r)+u(e_1s+e_2r)=u(k\Delta+e_1s+e_2r)$. Cancelling $u$ in the domain $S$ and lifting back, which adds a constant multiple of $h$, proves the assertion. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:r4-real-image}] By Lemmas~\ref{lem:r4-base-height} and~\ref{lem:r4-degree-four}, only $\deg A=6$ remains, with height three, and Lemma~\ref{lem:r4-residual-quadric} applies. Every entry of $G$ vanishes on $A$, so it lies in $(I_A)_2$; as $s|_U=r|_U=0$, Lemma~\ref{lem:r4-four-quadrics} gives constant real symmetric matrices $D_1,D_2$ with $G(b)=h(b)D_1+\Delta(b)D_2$ for $b\in U$. So the entries of $G|_U$ span at most two forms, and, $G(b)$ being positive semidefinite of rank eight for real $b\ne0$, Lemma~\ref{lem:scalar-span-fixed-image} (with $n=\dim U=6$) makes $\operatorname{Im}G(b)$, hence $\operatorname{Im}B(b)$, one fixed eight-space for nonzero $b\in U$. As $\dim U=6$, Lemma~\ref{lem:cl-b}(1) shows that it is $E$, so $K^TB(b)=0$ for $b\in U$. By linearity, $K^TB(a)=u(a)\Theta_1+v(a)\Theta_2$ with constant real matrices $\Theta_1,\Theta_2$. Hence the form $\mathcal Q(a)=\tr\bigl(K^TB(a)B(a)^TK\bigr)=\tr\bigl(K^TG(a)K\bigr)$ is a binary quadratic form in $u,v$, and it vanishes on $A$, where $G=0$. If $\mathcal Q\ne0$, it factors over $\mathbb C$ into two linear forms, and the integral coordinate ring of $A$ forces one of them to vanish on $A$, contrary to full complex span. So $\mathcal Q=0$; on real coefficients it is a sum of squares of real entries, so $K^TB(a)=0$ for every $a$, and rank eight gives \eqref{eq:r4-alignment}. \end{proof} \subsection{A conjugate pair of images} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:u4-conjugate-pair} Suppose $A$ and $\overline A$ are distinct irreducible fourfolds in $V(h,G)$ whose combined complex span is $\mathbb P^7$. Then \eqref{eq:r4-alignment} holds. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Let $U$ be the vector span of $A$ and $d=\dim_{\mathbb C}U$; as in Lemma~\ref{lem:u4-union-height}, $6\leq d\leq8$. If $d=8$, both images have degree at least four and Proposition~\ref{prop:u4-degree-budget} applies. If $d=7$, the restriction $h|_U$ has rank at least six, and the affine coordinate ring of its quadric is factorial by the Klein--Nagata theorem \cite[Theorem~8.2, p.~26]{Samuel1964}, with a polynomial extension for a possible one-dimensional radical. The cone over $A$ is a height-one homogeneous prime, hence generated modulo $h|_U$ by one homogeneous element $f$; full span in $U$ excludes $\deg f=1$, so $\deg A=2\deg f\geq4$ and Proposition~\ref{prop:u4-degree-budget} applies again. Suppose $d=6$. Then $h|_U$ has rank at least four, so its null locus is an irreducible quadric fourfold and equals $A$; so the quadratic entries of $G$ restricted to $U$, which vanish on $A$, are constant multiples of $h|_U$: $G(a)=h(a)D$ for $a\in U$ and one constant complex symmetric matrix $D$. Since $U+\overline U=\mathbb C^8$, the conjugation-invariant space $U\cap\overline U$ has complex dimension four and contains a nonzero real vector $w$. Real rank eight of $G(w)$ forces $h(w)\ne0$, so $D=G(w)/h(w)$ is real of rank eight; put $T=\operatorname{Im}_{\R}D$. For complex $a\in U$ with $h(a)\ne0$ the Gram has image $T_{\mathbb C}$ and rank eight, and since $B(a)$ has eight columns, its image is $T_{\mathbb C}$ as well. So the projection of the linear pencil $B|_U$ to $V_{\mathbb C}/T_{\mathbb C}$ vanishes on a dense open set, hence everywhere, and conjugation gives the same on $\overline U$. As $U+\overline U=\mathbb C^8$, every $B(a)$ maps into this fixed eight-space, and the radial columns identify its real form with $E$. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:r4-generic-finish} For a residue image of type $(\alpha,s)=(4,4)$, the rank identity $\rank G=2s-8$ gives the vanishing of $G$ on the image, as required above; full real support becomes full complex span when the image is geometrically integral and real-defined. For a simple real-irreducible quadratic or quartic pole that splits over $\mathbb C$ with $\alpha=s=4$, Lemma~\ref{lem:si-saturated-fibres} makes the two geometric components give distinct images, and full real residue support gives their combined span. \end{remark}