\section{A geometry that stays fixed during the iteration} \label{sec:fixed-geometry} \label{sec:rosen-physical-grading} \label{sec:optical-graph-height} \label{sec:pp-positive-exact-poisson} \subsection{Overview of Part~\ref{part:nonlinear}} \label{subsec:part3-overview} We now solve the nonlinear equation $\mathcal F_q(w,u)=0$ near the reference pair $(w_*,\Phi_*)$, where \[ \Phi_*=\phi_*\,e_2=\phi_*\sqrt2\cos2\theta,\qquad \mathscr L_{w_*}\Phi_*=0,\qquad \ell_*\Phi_*=1 . \] The inverse of $\mathscr L_{w_*}$ constructed in Part~\ref{part:reference} is useful only if the linearization at a nearby state can be compared with it. Two features of the linearization would normally move with the state: the circles on which it changes type, and the angular positions at which characteristics arrive after crossing a negative component. The first was fixed in Lemma~\ref{lem:type-completion} by a correction proportional to the residual. The second is fixed in the same spirit, at the price of enlarging the problem. \paragraph{Unknowns.} The profile is allowed to vary in a controlled family, \begin{equation}\label{eq:full-height-metric-controls} w=w_*\exp\Bigl(\nu\chi_*+\sum_m\kappa_m\chi_m\Bigr), \end{equation} where $\chi_*$ is the function of Proposition~\ref{prop:rad-fixed-theorem}(iii) and, for every negative component $m$, $\chi_m$ is a bump supported inside that component (Lemma~\ref{lem:quantitative-optical-controls}). In addition every negative component carries a circle diffeomorphism $h_{L,m}$, a \emph{chart} of its left boundary circle. The \emph{state} is $\bx=(u,\nu,\kappa,h_L)$ with $\kappa=(\kappa_m)_m$ and $h_L=(h_{L,m})_m$; see Table~\ref{tab:unknowns}. \begin{table}[htbp] \centering \begin{tabularx}{\linewidth}{@{}l l Y@{}} \toprule Unknown & Lives in & Role\\ \midrule $u$ & $\Phi_*+\ker\ell_*\subset\mathcal X_\beta$ & The height is $z=h+qu$ with $h'=w$.\\ $\nu$ & $\R$ & Amplitude of the metric control $\chi_*$; removes the obstruction in the second angular mode.\\ $\kappa=(\kappa_m)$ & $\mathcal K_\beta$ & Amplitudes of the metric controls $\chi_m$; adjust the mean travel angle of each negative component.\\ $h_L=(h_{L,m})$ & $\id+\mathcal Z_{\beta,\mathrm{odd}}$ & Charts of the left boundary circles; straighten the return maps.\\ \bottomrule \end{tabularx} \caption{The unknowns of the nonlinear problem. The spaces are defined in Definition~\ref{def:readable-physical-grading}; $q$ is a parameter.} \label{tab:unknowns} \end{table} \paragraph{Equations.} There are two. The first is the height equation $\mathcal A:=\mathcal F_q(w,u)=0$. The second, $\mathfrak e=0$, is imposed by us: it says that on every negative component the two characteristic return maps of the linearization, read in the charts, are the rotations by $\pm T_m$, where $T_m$ is the travel angle of the reference profile. The \emph{return residual} $\mathfrak e_m$ is an even function on the circle. Its mean is controlled by the number $\kappa_m$, and its oscillating part by the odd function $h_{L,m}-\id$; solving for the latter involves the small divisors $\sin(jT_m)$ of Proposition~\ref{prop:rad-fixed-theorem}(ii). \paragraph{The corrected linearization.} The derivative of $\mathcal A$ with respect to $u$ will be written as \[ D_u\mathcal A=\widehat L_{\bx} +(\text{a term proportional to }\mathcal A) +(\text{a term proportional to }\mathfrak e), \] where $\widehat L_{\bx}$ changes type exactly at the turning circles of $w_*$ and has exactly the return maps $R_{\pm T_m}$ in the charts. After a change of coordinates all operators $\widehat L_{\bx}$ act on one set of cylinders with one set of transmission conditions, independent of $\bx$. This makes the comparison with the reference operator possible. \paragraph{Plan.} This section introduces the weighted spaces (Section~\ref{subsec:spaces}), the controls and the neighbourhood of the reference state on which everything is defined (Sections~\ref{subsec:root-geometry}--\ref{subsec:neighbourhood}), the return residual and the operator $\widehat L$ (Section~\ref{subsec:return-correction}), and the coordinates (Sections~\ref{subsec:root-coordinate}--\ref{subsec:positive-crossing}). Section~\ref{sec:stable-inverse} inverts $\widehat L_{\bx}$, Section~\ref{sec:solving-the-equation} solves the coupled system by the Nash--Moser method, and Section~\ref{sec:final-proof} concludes. The construction involves infinitely many components, and one smallness condition has to serve for all of them. The room for this comes from a simple fact, used again and again: the deformation decays like $H^\beta$, which is far smaller than any power of the coefficient allowance, while the reference profile decays only like $e^{-n^{5/2}}$. \subsection{Weights and function spaces} \label{subsec:spaces} \paragraph{Continuous weights.} Let $d_\partial$ be the distance to the nearer endpoint. Near that endpoint put, with the constant $d_0$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:tail-flat}, \begin{equation}\label{eq:readable-physical-weights} x_\partial=\sqrt{\log\frac{d_0}{d_\partial}},\quad H=e^{-2x_\partial^3/3},\quad E_0=e^{1+x_\partial^{5/2}\log(e+x_\partial)},\quad M=e^{1+x_\partial^{5/2}\log^2(e+x_\partial)}, \end{equation} and extend these functions smoothly and positively through the middle of the annulus. By \eqref{eq:geometry-endpoint-distance}, $x_\partial=n+O(1)$ on cell $n$. Hence $H$ agrees with $H_n$, and $E_0$ with $\mathcal E_n$, up to coefficient powers, and $M$ is the weight \eqref{eq:M-weight}. For every fixed $A$ and $\epsilon>0$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:full-material-envelope} E_0^A\le C_A\,M,\qquad H^\epsilon M^A\le C_{A,\epsilon}. \end{equation} The extra logarithm in $M$ is deliberate. However many coefficients appear after differentiating a fixed expression, their \emph{whole product} is bounded by a power of $E_0$ and thus costs one power of $M$, a cost that does not grow with the number of derivatives. And the cubic exponent of $H$ still dominates every power of $M$. \paragraph{A unit-scale derivative.} Near the ends put \[ \ell=\frac{d_\partial}{1+x_\partial},\qquad d\varrho=\frac{dr}{\ell},\qquad \Dr=\partial_\varrho=\ell\,\partial_r , \] with a positive extension in between. The variable $\varrho$ ranges over $\R$, and \[ |\Dr x_\partial|=\frac1{2x_\partial(1+x_\partial)},\qquad |\Dr\log H|=\frac{x_\partial}{1+x_\partial}. \] All $\Dr$-derivatives of positive order of $\log H$, $\log M$ and $\log\ell$ are bounded: in the variable $\varrho$ the weights vary on the unit scale. An ordinary radial derivative $\partial_r$ costs a factor bounded by a power of $E_0$. \paragraph{The exponent $\beta$.} We fix $\beta=\tfrac34$. What matters is \begin{equation}\label{eq:beta-choice} \tfrac12<\beta<1 . \end{equation} The upper inequality leaves room for two neighbouring exponents $\beta\pm\epsilon$ in $(0,1)$, at which the reference inverse is available. The lower inequality makes a product of two quantities of size $H^\beta$ smaller than $H$; this gives the improved estimate for the metric in Theorem~\ref{thm:new-annular-height}. \begin{definition}[Spaces of heights, sources and circle data] \label{def:readable-physical-grading} All functions are real, even in $\theta$ and $\pi$-periodic. For $\gamma>0$ and integers $s\ge0$ put \begin{equation}\label{eq:full-physical-norm} \|u\|_{\gamma,s}^2 =\sum_{a+b+c\le s}\bigl\|M^c\,\Dr^a\partial_\theta^b (H^{-\gamma}u)\bigr\|_{L^2(d\varrho\,d\theta)}^2 . \end{equation} \begin{itemize} \item $\mathcal X^0_\gamma$ is the space of functions with all these norms finite. \item $\mathcal X_\gamma=\mathcal X^0_\gamma\oplus\R\chi_L$, where $\chi_L$ is a fixed function of $r$, equal to one near the left endpoint and to zero near the right one, whose derivative is supported in a compact subset of a positive component. The coefficient of $\chi_L$ is the difference of the two endpoint values of a height. \item $\mathcal Y_\beta=\{f\in\mathcal X^0_\beta:\Qint f=0\}$ is the space of compatible sources, where $\Qint f=\int_{r_-}^{r_+}\av f\,dr$. \item For a sequence $a=(a_m)$ of functions on the circle, one for each negative component, \begin{equation}\label{eq:weak-circle-spaces} \|a\|_{\mathcal Z_{\gamma,s}}^2 =\sum_m\sum_{b+c\le s}M_m^{2c}H_m^{-2\gamma} \|\partial_\theta^b a_m\|_{L^2(\T)}^2 , \end{equation} and $\mathcal Z_\gamma$ is the space with all these norms finite. Its subspace of sequences of constants is $\mathcal K_\gamma$, and $\mathcal Z_{\gamma,\mathrm{odd}}$, $\mathcal Z_{\gamma,\mathrm{even}}$ are its subspaces of odd and of even functions. \end{itemize} When no exponent is displayed, a norm of a height or of a source is the one with $\gamma=\beta$. \end{definition} Note that the index $s$ counts derivatives and powers of $M$ together. All these spaces consist of smooth functions which are flat at the endpoints; the exponent $\gamma$ only measures how fast they decay. \paragraph{Tame spaces and tame maps.} We use the terminology of \cite[Part~II]{Hamilton1982}. A \emph{graded} Fr\'echet space is one whose topology is defined by an increasing sequence of norms $\|\cdot\|_0\le\|\cdot\|_1\le\cdots$. A linear map $L$ between graded spaces is \emph{tame} if there is a number $d$, its \emph{loss}, with $\|Lf\|_s\le C_s\|f\|_{s+d}$ for all $s$. For a Banach space $B$, let $\Sigma(B)$ be the space of sequences $(f_k)_{k\ge0}$ in $B$ for which all the norms $\|f\|_s=\sum_ke^{sk}\|f_k\|_B$ are finite. A graded space $F$ is \emph{tame} if there are tame linear maps $J:F\to\Sigma(B)$ and $P:\Sigma(B)\to F$ with $PJ=I$. A map $\mathcal P$ on an open subset of a graded space is \emph{tame} if it is continuous and every point has a neighbourhood on which $\|\mathcal P(f)\|_s\le C_s(1+\|f\|_{s+d})$ for all $s$; it is \emph{smooth tame} if it is smooth and all its derivatives are tame. Since a derivative of order $k$ is linear in its $k$ increments, this amounts to estimates of the form \begin{equation}\label{eq:tame-derivative-shape} \bigl\|D^k\mathcal P(f)[h_1,\ldots,h_k]\bigr\|_s \le C_{s,k}\Bigl[\,\sum_{i}\|h_i\|_{s+d_k}\prod_{j\ne i}\|h_j\|_{b} +(1+\|f\|_{s+d_k})\prod_{j}\|h_j\|_{b}\Bigr] \end{equation} with a fixed low order $b$. \emph{In every term only one factor carries the high order.} All estimates of this part have this shape. Two features will be checked each time: the loss does not depend on $s$, and the neighbourhood is defined by norms of one fixed order. The following elementary lemma produces estimates of this shape. It replaces the usual interpolation inequalities for sup norms by inequalities for the Fourier transform, which can be verified in a few lines. \begin{lemma}[Estimates with one high factor]\label{lem:one-high-factor} Let $\mathsf C$ be the circle $\T$ or the cylinder $\R\times\T$, let $\|\cdot\|_{H^s}$ denote the Sobolev norms on $\mathsf C$, and let $|v|_{\mathcal F}=\|\widehat v\|_{L^1}$ be the $L^1$ norm of the Fourier transform. Then $\sup|v|\le|v|_{\mathcal F}\le C\,\|v\|_{H^b}$, where $b=1$ on the circle and $b=2$ on the cylinder. \begin{enumerate} \item \textup{(Interpolation.)} If $k\le i\le m$ and the point $(i,j)$ lies on the segment from $(k,l)$ to $(m,n)$, then \[ \|f\|_{H^i}\,\|g\|_{H^j} \le\|f\|_{H^k}\,\|g\|_{H^l}+\|f\|_{H^m}\,\|g\|_{H^n}. \] \item \textup{(Products.)} If $k\ge1$ and $\alpha_1,\ldots,\alpha_k$ are multi-indices with $|\alpha_1|+\cdots+|\alpha_k|\le s$, then \[ \Bigl\|\prod_{i=1}^k\partial^{\alpha_i}v_i\Bigr\|_{L^2} \le C_k\sum_{i=1}^k\|v_i\|_{H^s}\prod_{j\ne i}|v_j|_{\mathcal F}. \] In particular $\|v_1v_2\|_{H^s}\le C_s\bigl(\|v_1\|_{H^s}|v_2|_{\mathcal F} +|v_1|_{\mathcal F}\|v_2\|_{H^s}\bigr)$. \item \textup{(Functions.)} Let $v$ be a real function and let $\Phi$ be smooth on a neighbourhood of an interval $I$ which contains $0$ and the closure of the range of $v$. Then $\|\Phi(v)-\Phi(0)\|_{H^s}\le C_s\,\|v\|_{H^s}$ for every $s\ge0$, where $C_s$ depends only on an upper bound for $|v|_{\mathcal F}$ and on the suprema over $I$ of $|\Phi^{(m)}|$ for $1\le m\le\max\{1,s\}$. The same holds for a smooth function of several real functions, with $I$ replaced by a convex set which contains $0$ and the closure of the joint range. \item \textup{(Composition and inversion on the circle.)} Let $h$ be the lift of a diffeomorphism of the circle with $h'\ge c_0>0$. Then, for $s\ge1$, \[ \|u\circ h\|_{H^s} \le C_s\bigl(\|u\|_{H^s}+\|u\|_{H^3}\,\|h'-1\|_{H^{s-1}}\bigr), \qquad \|(h^{-1})'-1\|_{H^{s-1}}\le C_s\,\|h'-1\|_{H^{s-1}}, \] where $C_s$ depends only on $c_0$ and $\|h'-1\|_{H^3}$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The first assertion is the Cauchy--Schwarz inequality for $\widehat v=\langle\zeta\rangle^{-b}\cdot\langle\zeta\rangle^b\widehat v$, since $\langle\zeta\rangle^{-2b}$ is summable over the frequencies of $\mathsf C$ exactly when $2b$ exceeds its dimension. (i) Let $i=\vartheta k+(1-\vartheta)m$; then $j=\vartheta l+(1-\vartheta)n$. By H\"older's inequality for the Fourier transform, $\|f\|_{H^i}\le\|f\|_{H^k}^{\vartheta}\|f\|_{H^m}^{1-\vartheta}$, and likewise for $g$. The product of the two right sides is $X^\vartheta Y^{1-\vartheta}\le X+Y$ with $X=\|f\|_{H^k}\|g\|_{H^l}$ and $Y=\|f\|_{H^m}\|g\|_{H^n}$. (ii) The Fourier transform of the product at the frequency $\zeta$ is bounded by the integral of $\prod_i|\zeta_i|^{|\alpha_i|}|\widehat v_i(\zeta_i)|$ over $\zeta_1+\cdots+\zeta_k=\zeta$. Since $\langle\zeta_i\rangle\ge1$ and the exponents add up to at most $s$, \[ \prod_i|\zeta_i|^{|\alpha_i|} \le\max_i\langle\zeta_i\rangle^{s} \le\sum_i\langle\zeta_i\rangle^{s}. \] So the Fourier transform of the product is bounded by a sum of $k$ convolutions, in each of which one factor is $\langle\zeta\rangle^s|\widehat v_i|\in L^2$ and the others are $|\widehat v_j|\in L^1$. Young's inequality and Plancherel's theorem give the claim. (iii) A derivative $\partial^\alpha$ of order between $1$ and $s$ of $\Phi(v)$ is a sum of terms $\Phi^{(m)}(v)\prod_{i=1}^m\partial^{\alpha_i}v$ with $\alpha_1+\cdots+\alpha_m=\alpha$; bound $\Phi^{(m)}(v)$ by its supremum and apply (ii). In $L^2$, $|\Phi(v)-\Phi(0)|\le\sup_I|\Phi'|\,|v|$, by the mean value theorem on the segment from $0$ to the value of $v$; this segment lies in $I$. The interval $I$ cannot be replaced by the range of $v$. For the constant function $v=1$ on the circle and $\Phi_M(x)=M(2x-x^2)$ we have $\Phi_M(0)=0$ and $\Phi_M'=0$ on the range $\{1\}$, while $\|\Phi_M(v)\|_{H^1}=M\,\|v\|_{H^1}$. The first derivative is needed also for $s=0$, as $\Phi(x)=Mx$ shows. (iv) Change of variables gives $\|f\circ h\|_{L^2}\le c_0^{-1/2}\|f\|_{L^2}$. For $s\le3$ the chain rule expresses the derivatives of $u\circ h$ through $u^{(m)}\circ h$, $m\le s$, and bounded functions, which proves the first estimate without its second term. Let $s\ge4$ and assume the estimate for $s-1$. Since $(u\circ h)'=(u'\circ h)\,h'$, part~(ii) on the circle gives \[ \|u\circ h\|_{H^s} \le C\bigl(\|u\|_{L^2}+\|u'\circ h\|_{H^{s-1}}\,\|h'\|_{H^1} +\|u'\circ h\|_{H^1}\,(1+\|h'-1\|_{H^{s-1}})\bigr). \] By the induction hypothesis $\|u'\circ h\|_{H^{s-1}}\le C(\|u\|_{H^s}+\|u\|_{H^4}\|h'-1\|_{H^{s-2}})$, and by (i), applied to the points $(3,s-1)$, $(4,s-2)$ and $(s,2)$, \[ \|u\|_{H^4}\,\|h'-1\|_{H^{s-2}} \le\|u\|_{H^3}\,\|h'-1\|_{H^{s-1}}+\|u\|_{H^s}\,\|h'-1\|_{H^{2}} . \] This proves the first estimate. For the inverse $\iota=h^{-1}$ we have $\iota'-1=G\circ\iota$ with $G=-(h'-1)/h'$, a smooth function of $h'-1$. By the chain rule $\iota'$ is bounded below by $1/\sup h'$ and $\|\iota'-1\|_{H^3}$ is bounded in terms of $c_0$ and $\|h'-1\|_{H^3}$; and $\|G\|_{H^k}\le C\|h'-1\|_{H^k}$ by (iii). The first estimate, with $\iota$ in the place of $h$, gives \[ \|\iota'-1\|_{H^{s-1}} \le C\bigl(\|G\|_{H^{s-1}}+\|G\|_{H^3}\,\|\iota'-1\|_{H^{s-2}}\bigr), \] and induction on $s$ proves the second estimate. \end{proof} Functions on a cylinder with boundary, such as the pieces of Section~\ref{sec:stable-inverse}, are first extended to $\R\times\T$ by a fixed extension operator which is bounded in all Sobolev norms; parts (i)--(iii) then apply to them as well. \begin{lemma}[Flows on the circle]\label{lem:circle-flow} Let $G(t,\theta)$ be smooth and periodic in $\theta$, and let $\Theta$ solve $\partial_t\Theta=G(t,\Theta)$ for $0\le t\le1$ with $\Theta(0,\theta)=\theta$. Put $\Lambda_s=\int_0^1\|G_\theta(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\,dt$. Then \[ \Theta_\theta=\exp\int_0^tG_\theta(\tau,\Theta(\tau,\theta))\,d\tau \in\bigl[e^{-C\Lambda_1},e^{C\Lambda_1}\bigr], \qquad \sup_t\|\Theta_\theta(t,\cdot)-1\|_{H^s}\le C_s\,\Lambda_s , \] where $C_s$ depends only on $\Lambda_4$. If $G_*$ does not depend on $\theta$ and $\Theta_*=\theta+\int_0^tG_*$ is its flow, then $\sup_t\|\Theta-\Theta_*\|_{H^s} \le C_s\int_0^1\|(G-G_*)(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\,dt$, with $C_s$ depending only on $\Lambda_4$ and on $\int_0^1\|(G-G_*)(t,\cdot)\|_{H^3}\,dt$. If $G$ depends smoothly on parameters, every derivative of $\Theta$ with respect to the parameters solves a linear equation $\partial_t\Theta'=(G_\theta\circ\Theta)\,\Theta'+R$ with the same integrating factor, where $R$ involves derivatives of $G$ and derivatives of $\Theta$ of lower order. A derivative of order $k$ with respect to the parameters satisfies estimates of the same form in which the norms of $G$ and of its parameter derivatives are taken at the order $s+k$ instead of $s$. \end{lemma} The loss of $k$ angular derivatives in the last statement cannot be avoided. Let $G=a\,\alpha(t)+\beta(t)\,f(\theta)$, where $\alpha$ and $\beta$ have integral one and are supported in $(0,\tfrac13)$ and $(\tfrac23,1)$. The flow at time one is the time-one flow of $f$ applied to $\theta+a$. At $f=0$ its derivative in the direction $h$ of $f$ is $h(\theta+a)$, and $k$ further derivatives with respect to $a$ give $h^{(k)}(\theta+a)$. This is why the loss $d_k$ in \eqref{eq:tame-derivative-shape} is allowed to depend on $k$. \begin{proof} The formula for $\Theta_\theta$ follows from $\partial_t\Theta_\theta=(G_\theta\circ\Theta)\,\Theta_\theta$, and the bounds from $|G_\theta|\le C\|G_\theta\|_{H^1}$. The derivatives $\partial_\theta^k\Theta$, $2\le k\le4$, solve linear equations with the same integrating factor, whose sources are polynomials in the lower derivatives and in $(\partial_\theta^mG)\circ\Theta$, $2\le m\le4$; hence they are bounded in terms of $\Lambda_4$. Now let $y=\Theta_\theta-1$, so that $\partial_ty=(G_\theta\circ\Theta)(1+y)$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(ii) and~(iv), with the low norms just bounded, \[ \|\partial_ty\|_{H^s} \le C_s\bigl(\|G_\theta(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s} +\|G_\theta(t,\cdot)\|_{H^3}\,\|y\|_{H^s}\bigr), \] and Gronwall's inequality gives the second assertion. For the last one, $\partial_t(\Theta-\Theta_*)=(G-G_*)(t,\Theta)$; apply Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(iv) and integrate. For the parameters, differentiate the equation $k$ times. By the chain rule the source $R$ is a sum of products of derivatives of $\Theta$ of order less than $k$ with functions $(\partial_\theta^a\partial^bG)\circ\Theta$, where $\partial^b$ denotes $b$ derivatives with respect to the parameters and $a+b\le k$; so at most $k$ additional angular derivatives fall on $G$ or on one of its parameter derivatives. Induction on $k$, with Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(ii) and~(iv) for the products and compositions and Gronwall's inequality as before, gives the last statement. \end{proof} The point of the last statement is that a flow with a large speed which does not depend on the angle, as for the reference profile, does not enter the constants: only the angular derivative of the speed does. \begin{lemma}[Calculus in the weighted spaces] \label{prop:full-physical-tame} Let $\gamma,\gamma_1,\gamma_2>0$ and let $s\ge0$ be an integer. \begin{enumerate} \item \textup{(Tameness.)} The spaces of Definition~\ref{def:readable-physical-grading}, graded by $s$, are tame Fr\'echet spaces. \item \textup{(Products.)} For $u_1\in\mathcal X^0_{\gamma_1}$ and $u_2\in\mathcal X^0_{\gamma_2}$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:weighted-product} \|u_1u_2\|_{\gamma_1+\gamma_2,s} \le C_s\bigl(\|u_1\|_{\gamma_1,s}\,\|u_2\|_{\gamma_2,2} +\|u_1\|_{\gamma_1,2}\,\|u_2\|_{\gamma_2,s}\bigr) . \end{equation} \item \textup{(Reference functions.)} If $c$ is a function of $r$ with $|\Dr^ac|\le E_0^{A}$ for $0\le a\le s$, then \begin{equation}\label{eq:weighted-reference} \|c\,u\|_{\gamma,s}\le C_{s,A}\,\|u\|_{\gamma,s+1}, \qquad\text{and}\qquad \|\partial_ru\|_{\gamma,s}\le C_s\,\|u\|_{\gamma,s+2}. \end{equation} \item \textup{(Functions of small quantities.)} Let $\Phi(t,\rho)$ be smooth for $t$ in the cube $[-\delta,\delta]^p$ and $\rho$ in a compact set $K\subset\R^{p'}$. Let $\varepsilon_1,\ldots,\varepsilon_p\in\mathcal X^0_\gamma$ with $\sup|\varepsilon_k|\le\delta$, and let $\rho_1,\ldots,\rho_{p'}$ be functions of $r$ with values in $K$ which are bounded together with all their $\Dr$-derivatives. Then \begin{equation}\label{eq:weighted-function} \|\Phi(\varepsilon,\rho)-\Phi(0,\rho)\|_{\gamma,s} \le C_s\sum_k\|\varepsilon_k\|_{\gamma,s}, \end{equation} where $C_s$ depends only on $s$, on $\Phi$, on the bounds for the $\rho_l$ and on $\max_k\|\varepsilon_k\|_{\gamma,2}$. \item \textup{(Flat extension.)} For $u\in\mathcal X^0_\gamma$ and all $a,b,k\ge0$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:weighted-flat} d_\partial^{-k}\,|\partial_r^a\partial_\theta^bu| \le C_{a,b,k}\;H^\gamma\,E_0^{C_{a,b,k}}\;\|u\|_{\gamma,a+b+2}. \end{equation} Consequently $u$ extends smoothly by zero across both endpoints. \end{enumerate} Parts \textup{(i)}, \textup{(ii)} and \textup{(iv)} hold also in the spaces $\mathcal Z_\gamma$ of circle data, with the low order $1$ in place of $2$. \end{lemma} The meaning of \eqref{eq:weighted-product} is that weights add under multiplication and only one factor carries the high order. The meaning of \eqref{eq:weighted-reference} is that a factor bounded by a coefficient power costs \emph{one} order, whatever the power: this is why the weight $M$ was introduced. \begin{proof} \step{1: tameness} Write $v=H^{-\gamma}u$. Choose functions $\phi_i(\varrho)$, $i\in\Z$, with bounded derivatives, finite overlap and $\sum_i\phi_i^2=1$, supported on intervals of unit length. Since $\log M$ has bounded derivatives, $M\asymp M_i:=M(i)$ on the support of $\phi_i$, and the norm of $v$ is equivalent to \[ \sum_{i,j}\int(M_i^2+\xi^2+j^2)^s\, |\widehat{\phi_iv}(\xi,j)|^2\,d\xi . \] Let $\omega_i=(M_i^2+\xi^2+j^2)^{1/2}$. A smooth partition $\zeta_k$ in the variable $\log\omega_i$ gives maps $J$ and $P$ with $PJ=I$ to and from the space of exponentially decreasing sequences in $\ell^2_iL^2_\xi\ell^2_j$: namely $(Jv)_{k,i}=\zeta_k(\omega_i)\,\widehat{\phi_iv}$ and $Pb=\sum_i\phi_i\,\mathcal F^{-1}\sum_k\widetilde\zeta_k(\omega_i)\,b_{k,i}$, where $\widetilde\zeta_k$ equals one on the support of $\zeta_k$. By the Cauchy--Schwarz inequality in $k$, $\|Jv\|_s\le C_s\|v\|_{s+1}$, and by finite overlap $\|Pb\|_s\le C_s\|b\|_s$. This exhibits the space as a tame direct summand of a model space, and provides smoothing operators. Parity projections preserve the construction, and the scalar multiple of $\chi_L$ is a finite-dimensional summand. If $\psi$ is compactly supported with $\Qint\psi=1$, then $f\mapsto f-\psi\,\Qint f$ is a projection onto $\mathcal Y_\beta$; the functional $\Qint$ is continuous because it is the pairing of $H^{-\beta}f$ with the square integrable function $H^\beta\ell$. The same Fourier construction applies to the spaces of circle data. \step{2: products} Let $v_k=H^{-\gamma_k}u_k$, so that $H^{-\gamma_1-\gamma_2}u_1u_2=v_1v_2$. On the support of $\phi_i$ the norm of order $s$ of $v$ is equivalent to $\sum_{c\le s}M_i^c\,\|\phi_iv\|_{H^{s-c}}$. Write $\phi_iv_1v_2=(\phi_iv_1)(\widetilde\phi_iv_2)$ with a cutoff $\widetilde\phi_i$ equal to one on the support of $\phi_i$, apply Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(ii) on the cylinder, and attach the power $M_i^c$ to the factor of high order. Summing the squares over $i$, with the low factor estimated uniformly in $i$, gives \eqref{eq:weighted-product}. Products of several factors, and products of derivatives of total order at most $s$, are estimated in the same way. \step{3: reference functions} By Leibniz' rule, $M^{c}\,\Dr^a\partial_\theta^b(H^{-\gamma}c\,u)$ is a sum of terms $(\Dr^{a_1}c)\cdot M^{c}\,\Dr^{a-a_1}\partial_\theta^b(H^{-\gamma}u)$, and $|\Dr^{a_1}c|\le E_0^A\le C_AM$ by \eqref{eq:full-material-envelope}. Each term is therefore bounded by a term of the norm of order $s+1$ of $u$. For the second estimate, $\partial_r=\ell^{-1}\Dr$; the operator $\Dr$ costs one order, because $\Dr\log H$ is bounded with all its derivatives, and $\ell^{-1}$ is a reference function of the kind just treated. \step{4: functions of small quantities} Write $\Phi(\varepsilon,\rho)-\Phi(0,\rho) =\sum_k\varepsilon_k\,\Phi_k(\varepsilon,\rho)$ with the smooth functions $\Phi_k(t,\rho)=\int_0^1\partial_{t_k}\Phi(\tau t,\rho)\,d\tau$. Then $H^{-\gamma}(\Phi(\varepsilon,\rho)-\Phi(0,\rho)) =\sum_k(H^{-\gamma}\varepsilon_k)\,\Phi_k(\varepsilon,\rho)$. A derivative of $\Phi_k(\varepsilon,\rho)$ is a sum of products of derivatives of the $\varepsilon_l$ and of the $\rho_l$ with bounded coefficients; the derivatives of the $\rho_l$ are bounded, and the products of derivatives of the $\varepsilon_l$ are estimated on the support of $\phi_i$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(ii), as in the proof of part~(iii) of that lemma. Since $H\le C$, Sobolev norms of $\varepsilon_l$ on the support of $\phi_i$ are bounded by its weighted norms. The product estimate of Step~2, with the power $M_i^c$ attached to the factor of high order, gives \eqref{eq:weighted-function}. \step{5: flat extension} The operator $\partial_r^a$ is a combination of $\Dr$-derivatives of order at most $a$ with coefficients bounded by $E_0^{C_a}$, and $d_\partial^{-1}\le E_0^{C}$. By the Sobolev embedding on unit intervals of $\varrho$, the supremum of $|\Dr^{a'}\partial_\theta^b(H^{-\gamma}u)|$, $a'\le a$, is bounded by $\|u\|_{\gamma,a+b+2}$. This gives \eqref{eq:weighted-flat}. Its right side tends to zero at the endpoints by \eqref{eq:full-material-envelope}, so all derivatives of the extension by zero exist and vanish at the endpoints. \end{proof} \paragraph{The small quantities.} In the height equation and its linearization, part~(iv) of the lemma is applied to the following six functions only. Let $Z=qu$ and $f=\nu\chi_*+\sum_m\kappa_m\chi_m$, so that $w=w_*e^f$, and put \begin{equation}\label{eq:small-quantities} \varepsilon_1=f,\quad \varepsilon_2=\frac{Z_r}{w_*},\quad \varepsilon_3=\frac{Z_{\theta\theta}}{r\,w_*},\quad \varepsilon_4=\frac{Z_\theta}r,\quad \varepsilon_5=\frac{Z_{r\theta}-Z_\theta/r}{w_*},\quad \varepsilon_6=\frac{f'}{r\,v_0^2}, \end{equation} the last one on the negative components, where $v_0=\sqrt{-w_*'/(rw_*)}$; it is supported in the supports of the controls $\chi_m$. Each is a reference function times a derivative of positive order of the height, or a control term. The bounded parameters are $\rho=(r,w_*,w_*')$. With $E=1+w_*^2e^{2\varepsilon_1}$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:coefficients-by-small-quantities} \begin{gathered} \frac w{w_*}=e^{\varepsilon_1},\qquad \frac Qw=1+e^{-\varepsilon_1}(\varepsilon_2+E\,\varepsilon_3),\qquad D=1-w_*^2\,(2e^{\varepsilon_1}\varepsilon_2+\varepsilon_2^2) -E\,\varepsilon_4^2,\\ d=-\frac Er\,\frac{e^{-\varepsilon_1}\,\varepsilon_5}{Q/w},\qquad v=v_0\,\sqrt{1-\varepsilon_6}\;\frac{\sqrt D}{Q/w}, \end{gathered} \end{equation} where $d\pm v$ are the characteristic speeds \eqref{eq:completed-characteristics}. The coefficients \eqref{eq:linear-coefficients} are $a=w\,(Q/w)\,D^{-3/2}$, $b=-(E/r)\,w_*\varepsilon_5\,D^{-3/2}$ and $c=r^{-1}(w'+EZ_{rr}-ww'Z_r)\,D^{-3/2}$; the residual $\mathcal N_h$ and $\bar c$ are polynomials in $w$, $w'$ and the derivatives of $Z$ of order at most two, times powers of $D$ and $Q$. On the neighbourhood of Lemma~\ref{lem:common-geometric-neighborhood} below, $\varepsilon_1,\ldots,\varepsilon_6$ are small in the supremum norm, so the reciprocals and roots in these formulas are evaluated where they are smooth. \subsection{The geometry at the roots, and the travel-angle controls} \label{subsec:root-geometry} \paragraph{Scales in a cell.} Recall from Section~\ref{sec:radial-tails} that on cell $n$ \[ A_n\asymp e^{-n^2},\quad B_n\asymp A_n^9,\quad c\,\mathfrak r_nA_n^5\le r_X\le C\,\mathfrak r_nA_n,\quad w_*=\lambda_n\,r_X,\quad \log\lambda_n=-n^{5/2}+O(n), \] with $\mathfrak r_n$ bounded above and below, that $r_X=\partial r/\partial X$ satisfies $r_{XX}=-\rho\,r$ with $\rho=A_n(e^{-X}-e^{-2X})-B_n$, that $cA_{n+1}\le d_\partial\le CA_n$, and that every fixed derivative of $w_*^{\pm1}$ costs a coefficient power (Lemma~\ref{lem:tail-flat}). These comparisons persist on a bounded enlargement of a cell. \paragraph{The characteristic speed near a root.} Let $x$ be the distance from a root of a negative component, counted positively into the component and negatively on the positive side. On a cell, $w_*=\lambda_nr_X$ and $r_{XX}=-\rho\,r$ give $w_*'=-\lambda_n\rho\,r/r_X$, so the reference characteristic speed \eqref{eq:completed-characteristics} is \[ v_0=\sqrt{-\frac{w_*'}{rw_*}}=\frac{\sqrt\rho}{r_X} =\sqrt x\;c_i(x),\qquad i\in\{L,R\}, \] where $c_i$ is smooth and positive on a neighbourhood of the root, on both sides. \begin{lemma}[Root zones]\label{lem:quantitative-root-collars} At the left and right roots of the negative component of cell $n$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-root-scales} c_L(0)\asymp\mathfrak r_n^{-3/2}A_n^{-1},\qquad c_R(0)\asymp\mathfrak r_n^{-3/2}A_n^{-3}, \end{equation} and for every $k$, on the interval $|x|\le c\,\mathfrak r_nA_n^5$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-normalized-root-jets} \Bigl|\partial_r^k\Bigl(\frac{c_i}{c_i(0)}\Bigr)^{\pm1}\Bigr| \le C_k\,(\mathfrak r_nA_n^5)^{-k}. \end{equation} Fix a sufficiently small $\epsilon_{\rm root}>0$ and put \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-root-collar-width} \delta_n^{\rm root}=\epsilon_{\rm root}\,\mathfrak r_n\,A_n^{20}. \end{equation} The interval $|x|<8\delta_n^{\rm root}$ is called the \emph{zone} of the root. The zones of the two roots are disjoint and lie inside the cell, and on them $c_i(x)/c_i(0)\in[\tfrac12,2]$. The finitely many roots of the central model have zones with the same properties and fixed constants. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} \step{1: the value at the root} Let $X_i$ be the value of the model coordinate at the root. Since $v_0^2=\rho/r_X^2$ and $x=|r-r(X_i)|$, division by $x$ and passage to the limit give \[ c_i(0)^2=\frac{|\rho_X(X_i)|}{r_X(X_i)^3}. \] With $t=e^{-X}$ the roots solve $A_n(t-t^2)=B_n$; hence $e^{-X_L}=1+O(A_n^8)$ and $e^{-X_R}\asymp A_n^8$, and $|\rho_X(X_L)|\asymp A_n$, $|\rho_X(X_R)|\asymp A_n^9$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:cell} and the choice of the solution in Section~\ref{subsec:one-cell}, $r_X(X_L)\asymp\mathfrak r_nA_n$ and $r_X(X_R)=\epsilon_R\,\mathfrak r_nA_n^5$. This gives \eqref{eq:geometry-root-scales}. \step{2: derivatives} Division of a function with a simple zero by the distance to the zero is the operation $f(s)/s=\int_0^1f'(ts)\,dt$; it costs one derivative and preserves bounds. On $|X-X_i|\le c$ the quotient $\rho/(X_i-X)$, with the sign which makes it positive, is comparable to $|\rho_X(X_i)|$, and its derivatives in $X$ are bounded by multiples of it; this is read off from the explicit function $\rho$. At a root $r_{XX}=0$ and $r_{XXX}=-\rho_Xr$, and the differential equation shows that $r_X$ is comparable to $r_X(X_i)$ on $|X-X_i|\le c$, with derivatives in $X$ bounded by multiples of it. The same then holds for the quotient $(r-r(X_i))/(X-X_i)$. Since \[ c_i^2=\frac{\rho}{X_i-X}\cdot\frac{X_i-X}{r(X_i)-r}\cdot\frac1{r_X^2}, \] with the signs chosen as above, and $\partial_r=r_X^{-1}\partial_X$ with $r_X\ge c\,\mathfrak r_nA_n^5$, we obtain \eqref{eq:geometry-normalized-root-jets} on the image of $|X-X_i|\le c$, an interval of radial length at least $c\,\mathfrak r_nA_n^5$ on either side of the root. At the left root the same argument gives the better scale $\mathfrak r_nA_n$. \step{3: zones} The width $8\delta_n^{\rm root}$ divided by $\mathfrak r_nA_n^5$ is $8\epsilon_{\rm root}A_n^{15}$. So for small $\epsilon_{\rm root}$ the case $k=1$ of \eqref{eq:geometry-normalized-root-jets} keeps $c_i(x)/c_i(0)$ in $[\tfrac12,2]$ on the zone. The zones lie in the cell and are disjoint because each part of the cell has radial length comparable to $A_n$. The central model has finitely many roots, at which $c_i(0)>0$, and fixed zones are chosen there. The width of a zone, its reciprocal, and the derivatives of cutoffs adapted to it are coefficient powers. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[Travel-angle controls] \label{lem:quantitative-optical-controls} For a profile $w$ let $T_n(w)=\int\sqrt{-w'/(rw)}\,dr$ be the travel angle of its $n$th negative component. There are functions $\chi_n$, supported in $\delta_n^{\rm root}0$ are fixed once. They are determined by six requirements, each of the form $b_0\ge b^{(i)}$, $\epsilon_0\le\epsilon^{(i)}$: \begin{center} \renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1.1} \begin{tabular}{@{}lll@{}} \toprule & imposed in & purpose\\ \midrule (N1) & Lemma~\ref{lem:common-geometric-neighborhood} & type and denominators\\ (N2) & Lemma~\ref{lem:uniform-characteristic-flow-constants} & flows of $\bar L$ close to the reference flows\\ (N3) & Proposition~\ref{prop:optical-residual-completion} & corrected speeds of the same sign\\ (N4) & Proposition~\ref{prop:uniform-physical-geometry} & coordinate maps invertible\\ (N5) & Lemma~\ref{lem:relative} & relative operator of norm less than $\tfrac12$\\ (N6) & Proposition~\ref{prop:approx-inverse} & control equation solvable\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{center} The numbers $b^{(i)}$ and $\epsilon^{(i)}$ of the $i$th requirement depend on the reference profile, on $\beta$, and on the constants of the statements with smaller index; they do not depend on the order $s$ of any estimate. Since $\mathfrak n_b\le\mathfrak n_{b'}$ for $b\le b'$, a statement which holds on $\{\mathfrak n_b<\epsilon\}$ holds with the same constants on every smaller set $\{\mathfrak n_{b'}<\epsilon'\}$, $b'\ge b$, $\epsilon'\le\epsilon$. So the six requirements can be imposed one after the other, and we let $b_0$ be the largest of the $b^{(i)}$ and $\epsilon_0$ the smallest of the $\epsilon^{(i)}$. In the proof of the $i$th statement only the requirements up to $i$ are used. \begin{lemma}[One neighbourhood for the type and the denominators] \label{lem:common-geometric-neighborhood} On $\mathfrak N$ the profile $w$ has the same positive and negative components and the same germs at the roots as $w_*$, and, with $Z=qu$ and $E=1+w^2$, \[ \frac{w}{w_*}\in\bigl[\tfrac12,2\bigr],\qquad \frac Qw\in\bigl[\tfrac78,\tfrac98\bigr],\qquad D\in\bigl[\tfrac12,\tfrac32\bigr],\qquad 1-\Bigl(\frac{Z_\theta}{r}\Bigr)^2\ge\tfrac34 \] on the whole annulus. Here \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-low-QD} Q=w+Z_r+\frac{E\,Z_{\theta\theta}}r,\qquad D=1-2wZ_r-Z_r^2-E\Bigl(\frac{Z_\theta}r\Bigr)^2 \end{equation} are the quantities \eqref{eq:height-jet-notation} for $z=h+Z$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Only finitely many derivatives of low order enter these conditions. \step{1: low-order bounds on all components} On the neighbourhood, $\|u\|_{b_0}\le\|\Phi_*\|_{b_0}+\epsilon_0$ and $|q|<\epsilon_0$, so the geometric displacement $(Z,\nu,\kappa,h_L-\id)$ is of size $C\epsilon_0$ in the norms of order $b_0$. Let $K$ be the largest order of a derivative that occurs in the conditions, and take $b_0\ge K+2$. The Sobolev embedding on unit intervals of the variable $\varrho$, and the conversion of $\Dr$ into $\partial_r$ at the cost of coefficient powers, give on component $m$ \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-low-jets} \max_{1\le a+b\le K}|\partial_r^a\partial_\theta^bZ| +|\kappa_m|\,\|\chi_m\|_{C^K}+\|h_{L,m}-\id\|_{C^K} \le C\,\epsilon_0\,H_m^\beta\,\mathcal E_m^{C}. \end{equation} Only derivatives of positive order of $Z$ occur: the endpoint constant of a height does not decay, but it does not enter any coefficient. The compact control $\nu\chi_*$ obeys the same bound on the finitely many components it meets. Now \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-smallness-absorption} \sup_mH_m^\beta\,\mathcal E_m^{A}<\infty \qquad\text{and}\qquad H_m^\beta\,\mathcal E_m^{A}\longrightarrow0 \qquad\text{for every fixed }A, \end{equation} because $\log\mathcal E_m=o(S_m)$. Hence, for any fixed coefficient power, a condition $\epsilon_0\le\epsilon$ makes the right side of \eqref{eq:geometry-low-jets} times that power as small as we wish on all components at once. Requirement (N1) is the condition of this kind needed in Steps~2 and~3; the later requirements are of the same form. \step{2: the type} Write $w=w_*e^f$ with $f=\nu\chi_*+\sum_m\kappa_m\chi_m$. The controls vanish near every root, so the germs of $w$ at the roots are those of $w_*$. On the support of $\chi_n$, Lemma~\ref{lem:quantitative-optical-controls} gives \[ \frac{|\kappa_n\chi_n'|}{|w_*'/w_*|}\le C\,|\kappa_n|\,A_n^{-29}, \] which is small by Step~1. On the support of $\chi_*$ the function $w_*'/w_*$ has a positive minimum. So $w'/w=w_*'/w_*+f'$ has the sign of $w_*'/w_*$ away from the roots, and $|f|\le\log2$. \step{3: the denominators} By \eqref{eq:geometry-profile-jets}, $w^{-1}=w_*^{-1}e^{-f}$ is bounded by a coefficient power. So \eqref{eq:geometry-low-QD}, \eqref{eq:geometry-low-jets} and \eqref{eq:geometry-smallness-absorption} make $(Q-w)/w$, $D-1$ and $Z_\theta/r$ uniformly small. \end{proof} The second lemma of this subsection controls the characteristic flows of $\bar L$. Everything constructed afterwards is built from them. \begin{lemma}[Speeds and flows of $\bar L$] \label{lem:uniform-characteristic-flow-constants} On $\mathfrak N$ the following holds on every negative component $m$. The characteristic speeds $c_\pm=d\pm v$ of $\bar L$ satisfy \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-flow-low-bound} \int\|\partial_\theta c_\pm(r,\cdot)\|_{H^s_\theta}\,dr \le C_s\,\mathcal E_m^{C_s}\,H_m^\beta\;\mathfrak g_{s+3,m}, \end{equation} the integral being taken over the component. The flows of $c_\pm$ across the component and their inverses have angular derivatives in $[\tfrac12,2]$, and the constants of Lemma~\ref{lem:circle-flow} for them are the same for all $m$. In the zone of a root, $v=\sqrt x\,c_0(x,\theta)$ with \begin{equation}\label{eq:root-factor-state} c_0=c_i(x)\,\sqrt{1-\varepsilon_6}\;\frac{\sqrt D}{Q/w}, \qquad \tfrac14\,c_i(0)\le c_0\le4\,c_i(0). \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} \step{1: the speeds} By \eqref{eq:coefficients-by-small-quantities}, $d$ and $v/v_0-1$ are smooth functions of the small quantities \eqref{eq:small-quantities} which vanish when these are zero, and only the small quantities depend on $\theta$. Apply Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(ii) and~(iii) on the circle for each $r$, and the Cauchy--Schwarz inequality in $r$. The reference functions $1/w_*$, $v_0$ and $1/(rv_0^2)$ on the supports of the controls are bounded by coefficient powers (Lemmas~\ref{lem:tail-flat} and~\ref{lem:quantitative-optical-controls}), and the length of the component is bounded. The small quantities contain at most two derivatives of $Z$, and $\partial_\theta$ adds one. This gives \eqref{eq:geometry-flow-low-bound}; the factor $H_m^\beta$ is the weight of the deformation on the component. \step{2: the flows} Rescale the radial variable on the component to the unit interval; this multiplies the speeds by its length. By \eqref{eq:geometry-smallness-absorption} the right side of \eqref{eq:geometry-flow-low-bound} for $s\le4$ is as small as we wish on the neighbourhood, uniformly in $m$. Lemma~\ref{lem:circle-flow} gives the statement about the flows; the derivative of an inverse flow is the reciprocal of that of the flow. The speed $v_0$ of the reference profile may be large, but it does not depend on $\theta$ and so does not enter. \step{3: the root factor} In the zone of a root $v_0=\sqrt x\,c_i(x)$, so the formula for $v$ in \eqref{eq:coefficients-by-small-quantities} gives \eqref{eq:root-factor-state}. The bounds follow from $c_i(x)/c_i(0)\in[\tfrac12,2]$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:quantitative-root-collars}) and the smallness of the quantities \eqref{eq:small-quantities}. \end{proof} The objects constructed in the next three subsections, and the estimates they satisfy, are collected in Table~\ref{tab:objects} and Proposition~\ref{prop:uniform-physical-geometry} of Section~\ref{subsec:geometry-proofs}. The constructions themselves use only the two lemmas of this subsection. \subsection{Fixing the return maps by their own residual} \label{subsec:return-correction} \paragraph{Characteristics of $\bar L$.} Start from the operator $\bar L$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:type-completion}, with coefficients $(a,b,\bar c)$, on a negative component. By \eqref{eq:completed-characteristics} its characteristic slopes are \[ c_\pm=d\pm v,\qquad d=\frac ba,\qquad v=\frac{\sqrt{b^2-a\bar c}}{a}. \] Because the height is even in $\theta$, the reflection $\refl\theta=-\theta$ exchanges the two families: $c_+=-c_-\circ\refl$. Let $f$ be the \emph{minus return map}: the map from the left boundary circle of the component to the right one along the characteristics of slope $c_-$. Let $T$ be the travel angle of the reference profile on this component. At the reference state $f=R_{-T}$. \paragraph{Charts and the return residual.} Given the chart $h_L$ of the left circle, define \begin{equation}\label{eq:full-height-one-chart} \widetilde h_R=R_{-T}\circ h_L\circ f^{-1},\qquad h_R=\Odd\,\widetilde h_R,\qquad \mathfrak e=(\Even\,\widetilde h_R)\circ h_R^{-1}, \end{equation} where $\Odd$ and $\Even$ denote the odd and even parts of a function of $\theta$. The derivative of $h_R$ is an average of two positive derivatives, so $h_R$ is increasing; it is the chart of the right circle. By construction $\widetilde h_R=(\id+\mathfrak e)\circ h_R$, hence \begin{equation}\label{eq:return-identity} (\id+\mathfrak e)\circ h_R\circ f\circ h_L^{-1}=R_{-T}. \end{equation} So $\mathfrak e=0$ means that the minus return map is the rotation $R_{-T}$ when read in the charts $h_L$ and $h_R$. Since the charts are odd and the plus return map is $\refl\circ f\circ\refl$, the plus return map is then $R_{T}$. Thus the single even equation $\mathfrak e=0$ imposes both return conditions. Its mean concerns the travel angle, its oscillating part the parametrization of the boundary circles. \paragraph{The derivative with respect to the chart.} Vary the chart by $\delta h_L=\psi\circ h_L$ with $\psi$ odd, keeping $f$ fixed. Then \begin{equation}\label{eq:full-height-chart-derivative} \begin{split} D_h\mathfrak e[\psi]&=\mathcal M_T\psi+\mathcal Q_h(\mathfrak e,\psi),\qquad \mathcal M_T\psi=\Even\bigl[\psi(\theta+T)\bigr],\\ \mathcal Q_h(\mathfrak e,\psi)&= \Even\Bigl[\mathfrak e\int_0^1 \psi'(\theta+T+t\mathfrak e)\,dt\Bigr] -\mathfrak e'\;\Odd\bigl[\psi(\theta+T+\mathfrak e)\bigr]. \end{split} \end{equation} Indeed, the variation of $\widetilde h_R$, composed with $h_R^{-1}$, is $\psi(\theta+T+\mathfrak e)$; its odd part is the variation of $h_R$ in the same coordinates, and the formula follows by differentiating $\mathfrak e\circ h_R=\Even\,\widetilde h_R$. The term $\mathcal Q_h$ is bilinear in $(\mathfrak e,\psi)$ in the sense needed later and vanishes when $\mathfrak e=0$. The leading term is explicit: \begin{equation}\label{eq:rewrite-circle-inverse} \mathcal M_T\bigl(\sin j\theta\bigr)=\sin(jT)\cos j\theta, \qquad\text{so}\qquad \mathcal M_T^{-1}\bigl(g_j\cos j\theta\bigr) =\frac{g_j}{\sin(jT)}\,\sin j\theta \quad(j>0\ \text{even}). \end{equation} By Proposition~\ref{prop:rad-fixed-theorem}(ii) the inverse loses one angular derivative and a coefficient power. It does not exist on constants: the mean of $\mathfrak e$ cannot be corrected by a chart. This is the reason for the radial controls $\kappa_m$. \begin{proposition}[The return correction] \label{prop:optical-residual-completion} On $\mathfrak N$ the operator $\bar L$ can be replaced by a symmetric operator in divergence form \[ \widehat L=\partial_r(a\,\partial_r+\widehat b\,\partial_\theta) +\partial_\theta(\widehat b\,\partial_r +\widehat c\,\partial_\theta) \] which has the same coefficient $a$, coincides with $\bar L$ on the positive components and near the roots, and whose two return maps $\widehat f_\pm$ on every negative component satisfy \[ h_R\circ\widehat f_\pm\circ h_L^{-1}=R_{\pm T} \] exactly. The difference has the form \begin{equation}\label{eq:optical-residual-completion} \bar L-\widehat L=\mathscr E_{\bx}(\mathfrak e), \end{equation} where $(e,\eta)\mapsto\mathscr E_{\bx}(e)\eta$ is bilinear with values in $\mathcal Y_\beta$, and \begin{equation}\label{eq:return-error-tame} \|\mathscr E_{\bx}(e)\eta\|_{\beta,s} \le C_s\bigl[\|e\|_{\mathcal Z_{\beta,s+5}}\,\|\eta\|_{\beta,b_0} +\|e\|_{\mathcal Z_{\beta,b_0}}\,\|\eta\|_{\beta,s+5} +\mathfrak n_{s+5}\,\|e\|_{\mathcal Z_{\beta,b_0}}\, \|\eta\|_{\beta,b_0}\bigr]. \end{equation} Its derivatives with respect to the state satisfy estimates of the shape \eqref{eq:tame-derivative-shape}. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} \step{1: deforming the flow} Let $\Phi_r$ be the flow of the minus characteristics from the left boundary to the radius $r$, so that $f$ is its value at the right boundary. The return map we want is $f_*=h_R^{-1}\circ R_{-T}\circ h_L$. With $\mathsf g=h_R\circ f$, \eqref{eq:return-identity} gives \[ K:=f^{-1}\circ f_*=\mathsf g^{-1}\circ(\id+\mathfrak e)\circ\mathsf g, \qquad \Delta:=K-\id . \] Let $\chi(r)$ be the cutoff of Lemma~\ref{lem:quantitative-optical-controls}, rising from $0$ to $1$ inside the component, and put \[ J_r=\id+\chi(r)\,\Delta,\qquad \widehat\Phi_r=\Phi_r\circ J_r . \] Each $J_r$ is increasing, being a convex combination of increasing maps, and $\widehat\Phi_r$ runs from the identity to $f\circ K=f_*$. The curves $r\mapsto\widehat\Phi_r(\theta_0)$ have the slope \begin{equation}\label{eq:readable-optical-velocity} \widehat c_-(r,\theta)=c_-(r,\theta)+ \Phi_r'(\Phi_r^{-1}\theta)\;\chi'(r)\; \Delta\bigl(J_r^{-1}\Phi_r^{-1}\theta\bigr). \end{equation} \step{2: the new coefficients} Define $\widehat c_+=-\widehat c_-\circ\refl$ and \[ \widehat d=\frac{\widehat c_++\widehat c_-}2,\quad \widehat v=\frac{\widehat c_+-\widehat c_-}2,\qquad \widehat b=a\,\widehat d,\quad \widehat c=a\,(\widehat d^{\,2}-\widehat v^{\,2}). \] Then $\widehat L$ has the characteristic slopes $\widehat c_\pm$, its minus return map is $f_*$, and its plus return map is the reflection of $f_*$; these are the asserted returns. On the support of $\chi'$ the speed $v$ is bounded below by a coefficient power (Lemma~\ref{lem:quantitative-optical-controls}). The correction in \eqref{eq:readable-optical-velocity} is at most $C\epsilon_0H_m^\beta\mathcal E_m^C$: indeed $\Phi_r'\le2$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:uniform-characteristic-flow-constants}, $\chi'$ is a coefficient power, and $\Delta$ is bounded by $\mathfrak e$, which by its definition and \eqref{eq:geometry-low-jets} is bounded by the low-order norms of the deformation on the component. By \eqref{eq:geometry-smallness-absorption} the correction is less than $v/2$ on $\mathfrak N$; this is requirement (N3). So $\widehat v>0$. Near the roots and on positive components nothing is changed. \step{3: the error is bilinear} From the definition of $K$, \[ \Delta(\theta)=\mathfrak e(\mathsf g\theta) \int_0^1(\mathsf g^{-1})'\bigl(\mathsf g\theta +t\,\mathfrak e(\mathsf g\theta)\bigr)\,dt . \] Keep the state and the points at which the functions in this formula are evaluated, and replace only the leading factor $\mathfrak e$ by an independent function $e$. This defines increments $d_1[e]$ and $v_1[e]$ of $d$ and $v$ which are linear in $e$ and equal the actual increments $d_1=\widehat d-d$, $v_1=\widehat v-v$ when $e=\mathfrak e$. The coefficients of $\bar L-\widehat L$ are then $\delta b[\mathfrak e]$ and $\delta c[\mathfrak e]$, where \[ \delta b[e]=-a\,d_1[e],\qquad \delta c[e]=-a\,(2d+d_1)\,d_1[e]+a\,(2v+v_1)\,v_1[e] , \] and $\mathscr E_{\bx}(e)\eta$ is the corresponding expression in divergence form applied to $\eta$. It is bilinear in $(e,\eta)$. It is supported in the interior of the component, so it is flat at the endpoints and has integral zero. \step{4: the estimate} We first list the factors of $\delta b[e]$ and $\delta c[e]$. By \eqref{eq:readable-optical-velocity} and the formula for $\Delta$ in Step~3, the increment of the minus speed is \[ \widehat c_-[e]-c_- =\bigl(\Phi_r'\circ\Phi_r^{-1}\bigr)\;\chi'(r)\; \bigl(e\,\mathsf m\bigr)\circ\mathsf h_r, \qquad \mathsf m=\int_0^1(\mathsf g^{-1})'(\,\cdot+t\,\mathfrak e)\,dt, \quad \mathsf h_r=\mathsf g\circ J_r^{-1}\circ\Phi_r^{-1}, \] and $d_1[e]$, $v_1[e]$ are the half sum and the half difference of this function and its reflection. So $\delta b[e]$ and $\delta c[e]$ are sums of products of the following factors: \begin{itemize} \item[(1)] the coefficients $a$, $d$, $v$ of row~1 and the increments $d_1$, $v_1$, which are of the form considered here with $e=\mathfrak e$; \item[(2)] the reference function $\chi'$; \item[(3)] $\Phi_r'\circ\Phi_r^{-1}$ and $\mathsf m\circ\mathsf h_r$; \item[(4)] $e\circ\mathsf h_r$, which occurs exactly once in each product. \end{itemize} Fix $r$ in the support of $\chi'$ and estimate each factor in $H^s_\theta$. The maps $\Phi_r$, $f$, $h_L$, $h_R$, $J_r$ and their inverses have derivatives bounded above and below (Lemma~\ref{lem:uniform-characteristic-flow-constants} and Step~2). By Lemma~\ref{lem:circle-flow} and \eqref{eq:geometry-flow-low-bound}, \[ \|\Phi_r'-1\|_{H^s}+\|f'-1\|_{H^s} \le C_s\,\mathcal E_m^{C_s}\,\mathfrak g_{s+3,m}, \] and $h_L'-1$ is part of the state. By Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(iv), applied to each composition and each inverse in the definitions of $h_R$, $\mathfrak e$, $\mathsf g$, $J_r$, $\mathsf h_r$ and $\mathsf m$, the same bound holds for $\mathsf h_r'-1$ in $H^{s-1}$ and for the factors~(3) minus one in $H^s$, and \[ \|e\circ\mathsf h_r\|_{H^s} \le C_s\bigl(\|e\|_{H^s}+\|e\|_{H^3}\,\|\mathsf h_r'-1\|_{H^{s-1}}\bigr). \] The factors~(1) differ from functions of $r$ by at most $C_s\mathcal E_m^{C_s}\mathfrak g_{s+3,m}$ in $H^s_\theta$, by Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(iii) and \eqref{eq:coefficients-by-small-quantities}, and the functions of $r$ and the factor~(2) are bounded by coefficient powers. The product estimate of Lemma~\ref{lem:one-high-factor}(ii), with the high order on one factor at a time, gives on the component $m$ and for each $r$ \[ \|\delta b[e]\|_{H^s_\theta}+\|\delta c[e]\|_{H^s_\theta} \le C_s\,\mathcal E_m^{C_s}\bigl(\|e\|_{H^s} +(1+\mathfrak g_{s+3,m})\,\|e\|_{H^3}\bigr). \] A radial derivative of a factor is expressed through the equations of the flows: \[ \partial_r\Phi_r=c_-(r,\Phi_r),\qquad \partial_r\Phi_r^{-1}=-c_-\,(\Phi_r^{-1})',\qquad \partial_rJ_r=\chi'\,\Delta . \] So it is again a sum of products of factors of the four kinds and of speeds, in which one factor carries one more angular derivative, and the bound just proved holds for $\partial_r\delta b[e]$ and $\partial_r\delta c[e]$ with $s+1$ in place of $s$ and $H^4$ in place of $H^3$. The same is true of further radial derivatives. We now count. The expression $\mathscr E_{\bx}(e)\eta=\partial_r(\delta b[e]\,\eta_\theta) +\partial_\theta(\delta b[e]\,\eta_r+\delta c[e]\,\eta_\theta)$ contains two derivatives of $\eta$ and one derivative of the coefficients. Its norm of order $s$ therefore involves $\eta$ to the order $s+2$, $e$ to the order $s+1$, and the state to the order $s+4$, with one of the three at the high order in each term. The reference functions cost one further order by \eqref{eq:weighted-reference}. So the loss is at most $5$, as stated in \eqref{eq:return-error-tame}. Each term contains the factor $e$ and a derivative of positive order of $\eta$, both of weight $H_m^\beta$; after division by the weight of the source space a factor $H_m^\beta$ is left, which by \eqref{eq:full-material-envelope} absorbs the coefficient powers and the powers of $M$. The product estimate \eqref{eq:weighted-product} and summation over the components give \eqref{eq:return-error-tame}. The state enters $\delta b[e]$ and $\delta c[e]$ through the factors (1) and (3) and through the map $\mathsf h_r$. A derivative of order $j$ with respect to the state of a flow, of a composition or of an inverse is a sum of products of the same kinds in which at most $j$ additional angular derivatives fall on one factor (Lemma~\ref{lem:circle-flow} and the chain rule). The count above, with $5+j$ in place of $5$, gives the estimates \eqref{eq:tame-derivative-shape} for the derivatives with respect to the state. \end{proof} Combining Lemma~\ref{lem:type-completion} with Proposition~\ref{prop:optical-residual-completion} we obtain the exact identity \begin{equation}\label{eq:readable-completed-height-derivative} D_u\mathcal F_q(w,u)\,\eta=\widehat L\eta +q\,\partial_\theta\bigl(B\,\mathcal A\,\eta_\theta\bigr) +\mathscr E_{\bx}(\mathfrak e)\,\eta, \qquad \mathcal A=\mathcal F_q(w,u),\quad B=\frac{E}{rQ}. \end{equation} Both additional terms vanish at a solution of $(\mathcal A,\mathfrak e)=0$. We shall invert $\widehat L$ and carry these terms as errors in the nonlinear theorem. \subsection{Coordinates on a negative component} \label{subsec:root-coordinate} \paragraph{Travel coordinates.} Let $S_\pm(r,\theta)$ be the angle at which the plus or minus characteristic of $\widehat L$ through $(r,\theta)$ meets the left boundary circle. Put \begin{equation}\label{eq:fixed-strip-coordinates} U=h_L\circ S_+,\qquad V=h_L\circ S_-,\qquad \sigma=\frac{V-U}2,\qquad\varphi=\frac{U+V}2 . \end{equation} On the left boundary $(\sigma,\varphi)=(0,h_L)$, and by the exact returns of $\widehat L$, on the right boundary $(\sigma,\varphi)=(T,h_R)$. Moreover $U_\theta,V_\theta>0$ and \[ \det\frac{\partial(\sigma,\varphi)}{\partial(r,\theta)} =\widehat v\,U_\theta V_\theta>0 . \] For fixed $\varphi$ the function $\sigma$ increases strictly from $0$ to $T$, so $(\sigma,\varphi)$ is a diffeomorphism of the interior of the component onto the fixed cylinder $(0,T)\times\T$. In these coordinates the principal part of $\widehat L$, as a divergence expression, has the density $\delta\,\diag(1,-1)$ with $\delta=a\widehat v$: it is a wave operator, degenerate at the two ends, where $\delta$ vanishes. \paragraph{The root coordinate.} At a root the speed is $\widehat v=\sqrt x\,c_0(x,\theta)$ with $c_0$ smooth and positive, so $\sigma$ is of order $x^{3/2}$. The coordinates which are smooth at the two roots are \[ \xi_L=\bigl(\tfrac32\sigma\bigr)^{2/3},\qquad \xi_R=\bigl(\tfrac32(T-\sigma)\bigr)^{2/3}, \] used on the halves $\sigma\le T/2$ and $\sigma\ge T/2$ of the component (Figure~\ref{fig:root-regularization}). For an ordinary differential equation with a simple turning point this is Langer's change of variable \cite{Langer1949}, \cite[Chapter~11]{Olver1974}. When the coefficients depend on the angle, smoothness of $\xi_L$ at the root is not obvious. To prove it, with estimates, we solve the characteristic equation in a form in which $x^{3/2}$ is replaced by an independent variable $\zeta$: \begin{equation}\label{eq:fixed-strip-root-flow} \Theta_t=2xt\;d(xt^2,\Theta)+2\zeta t^2\,c_0(xt^2,\Theta), \qquad 0\le t\le1 . \end{equation} For $\zeta=\pm x^{3/2}$ this is the equation of the plus and minus characteristics, parametrized by $x'=xt^2$. We use it for $0\le x\le3\delta_n^{\rm root}$, where $\widehat L=\bar L$, so that $d$ and $c_0$ are the functions of Lemma~\ref{lem:uniform-characteristic-flow-constants}; on the rest of the component the characteristics are smooth curves in $(r,\theta)$ and no such device is needed. The inverse of the time-one map of \eqref{eq:fixed-strip-root-flow}, followed by the boundary chart, is one smooth function $G(x,\zeta,\theta)$, and \[ U=G(x,x^{3/2},\theta),\qquad V=G(x,-x^{3/2},\theta). \] That both families come from one function, with one boundary chart, is essential for the cancellation in the following lemma. \begin{lemma}[Substitution at a root] \label{lem:rewrite-root-composition} Let $G(x,\zeta,\theta)$ be smooth on the rectangle $0\le x\le1$, $|\zeta|\le1$, and define \[ \Ev\,G=\frac{G(x,x^{3/2},\theta)+G(x,-x^{3/2},\theta)}2,\qquad \Od\,G=\frac{G(x,x^{3/2},\theta)-G(x,-x^{3/2},\theta)} {2x^{3/2}} . \] Both functions extend smoothly to $x=0$, with $\Od\,G=\partial_\zeta G(0,0,\theta)$ there, and for every integer $s\ge0$ \begin{equation}\label{eq:rewrite-root-composition-bound} \|\Ev\,G\|_{C^s_{x,\theta}}\le C_s\|G\|_{C^s_{x,\zeta,\theta}}, \qquad \|\Od\,G\|_{C^s_{x,\theta}} \le C_s\|G\|_{C^{s+1}_{x,\zeta,\theta}} . \end{equation} The estimates hold also after any fixed number of differentiations with respect to parameters. \end{lemma} The point of the lemma is that the half-integer power $x^{3/2}$ does not cost half-integer many derivatives: an even function of $\zeta$ is a function of $\zeta^2=x^3$. \begin{proof} \step{1: $G$ even in $\zeta$} Fix $00,\qquad \xi_L=x\,\bigl(\tfrac32\chi_0\bigr)^{2/3} . \] So $\xi_L$ is a smooth function with nonvanishing radial derivative up to the root, and $(\xi_L,\varphi)$ are smooth coordinates there. The right root is treated in the same way with the chart $h_R$. Rescaling from the unit rectangle of the lemma to a zone of a root introduces powers of the zone width and its reciprocal, which are coefficient powers; their complete product costs one power of $M$. The substitution $\Ev$ uses $s$ derivatives of its argument and $\Od$ uses $s+1$, and these counts do not grow with the output order. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \begin{tikzpicture}[x=2.5cm,y=2.0cm,font=\small,>=Stealth] \draw[->] (0,0)--(1.45,0) node[right] {$x$}; \draw[->] (0,0)--(0,1.45); \draw[thick,blue!65!black] plot[domain=0:1.2,samples=50] (\x,{pow(\x,1.5)}); \draw[thick,orange!85!black] (0,0)--(1.2,1.2); \node[blue!65!black,anchor=west] at (.74,.48) {$\sigma\sim x^{3/2}$}; \node[orange!85!black,anchor=east] at (.72,1.1) {$\xi\sim x$}; \draw[dashed] (1,0)--(1,1); \node[align=left,anchor=west] at (1.65,.85) {The travel coordinate $\sigma$ has zero\\derivative at the root; its $2/3$ power\\has a nonzero derivative.}; \end{tikzpicture} \caption{Regularization at a turning circle; $x$ is the distance to the root. The graph shows the leading powers with unit coefficients. The positive coefficient of $x$ in $\xi$ is controlled uniformly at all turning circles.} \label{fig:root-regularization} \end{figure} \paragraph{The canonical form.} Let $i\in\{L,R\}$, let $\Psi_i=(\xi_i,\varphi)$ be the coordinate map on the corresponding half of the component, and put \[ \alpha_i=\frac{\delta\circ\Psi_i^{-1}}{\sqrt{\xi_i}} =\frac{a\,|\det D\Psi_i|}{U_\theta V_\theta}\circ\Psi_i^{-1}, \qquad h_i=\alpha_i^{-1/2} . \] The second expression shows that $\alpha_i$ is smooth and positive up to the root. In the coordinates $\Psi_i$ the principal density of $\widehat L$ is $\alpha_i\,\diag(1,-\xi_i)$, and conjugation by $h_i$ removes its first-order terms: for $u=(h_iW_i)\circ\Psi_i$, the equation $\widehat Lu=f$ becomes \begin{equation}\label{eq:fixed-strip-airy-equation} \begin{split} \bigl(\partial_{\xi_i}^2-\xi_i\,\partial_\varphi^2+V_i\bigr)W_i&=F_i,\\ V_i&=-\alpha_i^{-1/2}\, \bigl(\partial_{\xi_i}^2-\xi_i\,\partial_\varphi^2\bigr)\, \alpha_i^{1/2},\\ F_i&=h_i\,\Bigl(\frac{f}{|\det D\Psi_i|}\circ\Psi_i^{-1}\Bigr). \end{split} \end{equation} The principal part is the Tricomi operator $\partial_\xi^2-\xi\,\partial_\varphi^2$ \cite{Tricomi1923}, the same for all states; only the potential $V_i$ depends on the state. The transformation of the source preserves the pairing: $\int uf\,dr\,d\theta=\int W_iF_i\,d\xi_i\,d\varphi$. We call $W_i$ the \emph{canonical unknown}, $h_i$ the \emph{conjugating factor} and $F_i$ the \emph{canonical source}. \paragraph{Transmission in the middle.} The two halves meet at $\sigma=T/2$, where $\xi_L=\xi_R=\xi_c:=(3T/4)^{2/3}$. There $\alpha_L=\alpha_R$ and $\partial_\sigma\log\alpha_R-\partial_\sigma\log\alpha_L=\xi_c^{-3/2}$. Continuity of $u$ and of its derivative therefore reads \begin{equation}\label{eq:fixed-strip-cut} \binom{W_R}{\partial_{\xi_R}W_R} =\begin{pmatrix}1&0\\-1/(2\xi_c)&-1\end{pmatrix} \binom{W_L}{\partial_{\xi_L}W_L} \qquad\text{at }\xi_L=\xi_R=\xi_c . \end{equation} This matrix does not depend on the state. \paragraph{Boundary data at a root.} At a root, where the boundary chart is $h_{\rm bd}$ ($=h_L$ or $h_R$), the value of $u$ and its inward normal flux $p_{\rm in}$ are \begin{equation}\label{eq:fixed-strip-root-pair} u=(h_iW_i)(0,h_{\rm bd}),\qquad p_{\rm in}=\frac{h_{\rm bd}'}{h_i(0,h_{\rm bd})}\, \bigl(\partial_{\xi_i}W_i+(\partial_{\xi_i}\log h_i)\,W_i\bigr) (0,h_{\rm bd}) . \end{equation} No tangential derivative of $W_i$ appears, because $a\varphi_r+\widehat b\varphi_\theta=0$ at the root. The identity is exact, and it includes the zero mode. \paragraph{Bounds.} At the reference state all these objects are explicit functions of $r$; their bounds by coefficient powers are proved in Lemma~\ref{lem:reference-regularized-charts}. For a general state they are estimated in Proposition~\ref{prop:uniform-physical-geometry}. These objects are rows 5--11 of Table~\ref{tab:objects}. \subsection{Coordinates on a positive component} \label{subsec:positive-crossing} \paragraph{The reference coordinate.} On a positive component, continue the root coordinates of the two adjacent roots across them and put $y_i=-\xi_i$, which is positive on the positive side; here $i=L$ at the left end of the positive component and $i=R$ at its right end. Choose a coordinate $y\in[0,1]$, a function of $r$, equal to $y_L$ near the left end and to $1-y_R$ near the right end, by prescribing its derivative: the given derivatives on disjoint zones of the two ends and a positive constant in between, interpolated with cutoffs. Similarly interpolate the logarithms of the two conjugating factors $h_i$, taking the conjugating factor equal to one in the middle. The explicit formulas are \eqref{eq:geometry-positive-coordinate} and \eqref{eq:geometry-positive-height}; that all these reference quantities have coefficient bounds is Lemma~\ref{lem:positive-reference-charts}. \paragraph{The coordinate of a general state.} For a general state the coordinates and conjugating factors of the adjacent negative components differ from the reference ones. Extend these \emph{differences} into the positive component: the jets of the coordinates up to order four and the jets of the logarithms of the conjugating factors up to order three, by Taylor polynomials multiplied with cutoffs. The cutoffs are chosen so that the reference coordinate is unchanged on a fixed compact interval $J_*$ of radii which contains the support of $g_*$ in the normalization $\ell_*$ and the support of the metric control $\chi_*$. Since the differential is close to the reference one, the resulting map $\Psi_{\bx}$ is a diffeomorphism onto $[0,1]\times\T$: it is proper, locally invertible, and of degree one on the boundary (rows 12--14 of Table~\ref{tab:objects}). \paragraph{The canonical operator.} Let $h_{\bx}$ be the conjugating factor in the original variables, $\Psi_{\bx}$ the coordinate map and $J_{\bx}$ its Jacobian determinant. For the equation $-\widehat Lu=F_{\rm ph}$ on a positive component, the canonical operator and source are \begin{equation}\label{eq:pp-fixed-canonical-source} P_{\bx}U =-\Bigl(\frac{h_{\bx}}{|J_{\bx}|}\, \widehat L\bigl[h_{\bx}\,(U\circ\Psi_{\bx})\bigr]\Bigr) \circ\Psi_{\bx}^{-1},\qquad F=\Bigl(\frac{h_{\bx}F_{\rm ph}}{|J_{\bx}|}\Bigr) \circ\Psi_{\bx}^{-1} . \end{equation} These formulas again preserve the pairing. At the reference state \[ P_*=-\partial_y(a\,\partial_y)-c\,\partial_\varphi^2+V, \qquad a=h_*^2\,w_*\,y_r,\quad c=\frac{h_*^2\,w_*'}{r\,y_r}, \] where in this formula $a$ and $c$ denote the coefficients of $P_*$. Near a root $a=1$ and $c=y_i$ exactly: $P_*$ is the continuation $-\partial_{y_i}^2-y_i\,\partial_\varphi^2$ of the Tricomi operator. On the whole component, with \[ \bd=y\,(1-y), \] we have \begin{equation}\label{eq:positive-coefficients} a\ge\mathcal E_m^{-C},\qquad c\ge\mathcal E_m^{-C}\,\bd , \end{equation} and all derivatives of the coefficients of fixed order are bounded by coefficient powers (Lemma~\ref{lem:positive-reference-charts}); away from the roots this comes from the lower bounds for $w_*'/w_*$ on the positive parts of the models and on the joins. \paragraph{The difference vanishes to third order at the roots.} Since the jets specified above match the principal densities of $P_{\bx}$ and $P_*$ to second order at both roots, \begin{equation}\label{eq:readable-positive-difference} P_{\bx}-P_*=-\partial_a\bigl(\bd^{\,3}\,e_{\bx}^{ab}\,\partial_b\bigr) +\delta V_{\bx} , \end{equation} with smooth coefficients $e^{ab}_{\bx}$, where $a,b$ are indices running over $y,\varphi$, and a potential $\delta V_{\bx}$ on which no boundary condition is imposed. Division by $\bd^3$ has a fixed cost: if $F$, $F'$ and $F''$ vanish at $0$, then \[ \frac{F(y)}{y^3}=\frac12\int_0^1(1-t)^2\,F'''(ty)\,dt , \] each further derivative differentiates the integrand, and the factor $t^{-1/2}$ produced by rescaling in $L^2$ is integrable; this is row~16 of Table~\ref{tab:objects}. The cubic vanishing is what will allow a second-order perturbation to be controlled without boundary conditions (Section~\ref{subsec:cubic-estimate}). \subsection{The objects of a state and their bounds} \label{subsec:geometry-proofs} Table~\ref{tab:objects} lists every object that Sections~\ref{subsec:neighbourhood}--\ref{subsec:positive-crossing} attach to a state: its defining formula, the earlier rows from which it is built, and a number $k$. The number $k$ counts derivatives: \emph{the object, measured at order $s$, involves derivatives of the state of order at most $s+k$}. Each entry of the last column can be checked against the defining formula. An object built from earlier rows inherits their largest $k$, and the following operations increase it: \begin{itemize} \item a derivative of an earlier object: by $1$; \item the divided difference $\Od$ at a root (Lemma~\ref{lem:rewrite-root-composition}): by $1$; \item a Taylor polynomial of degree $p$ at a boundary circle: by $p$; \item division by $\bd^3$: by $3$. \end{itemize} Solving an ordinary differential equation, composing maps, inverting a map, and applying a smooth function do not increase $k$. These rules are stated with their hypotheses in Lemma~\ref{lem:cs-calculus}. \renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1.15}\setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt} \begin{longtable}{@{}r p{.37\linewidth} p{.25\linewidth} p{.17\linewidth} r@{}} \caption{The objects attached to a state. A circle marks positive quantities whose reciprocals are bounded as well.} \label{tab:objects}\\ \toprule & Object & Defined by & Built from & $k$\\ \midrule \endfirsthead \toprule & Object & Defined by & Built from & $k$\\ \midrule \endhead \multicolumn{5}{@{}l}{\emph{On a negative component}}\\[2pt] 1 & coefficients $a,b,\bar c$ of $\bar L$; speeds $c_\pm=d\pm v$; root factor $c_0^{\,\circ}$ & \eqref{eq:linear-coefficients}, Lemma~\ref{lem:type-completion}, \eqref{eq:root-factor-state} & the state & $2$\\ 2 & flows of $c_\pm$; return map $f$ & Section~\ref{subsec:return-correction} & row 1 & $2$\\ 3 & chart $h_R$; return residual $\mathfrak e$ & \eqref{eq:full-height-one-chart} & row 2, $h_L$ & $2$\\ 4 & $\Delta$; corrected speeds $\widehat c_\pm$; coefficients $\widehat b,\widehat c$; $\delta b[e]$, $\delta c[e]$ & \eqref{eq:readable-optical-velocity}, Proposition~\ref{prop:optical-residual-completion} & rows 2, 3; one derivative of a flow & $3$\\ 5 & travel coordinates $U,V,\sigma,\varphi$ & \eqref{eq:fixed-strip-coordinates} & row 4, $h_L$ & $3$\\ 6 & root function $G(x,\zeta,\theta)$ & \eqref{eq:fixed-strip-root-flow} & rows 1, 3, $h_L$ & $2$\\ 7 & root coordinates $\xi_L,\xi_R$ & $\xi=x\,(\tfrac32\,\Od\,G)^{2/3}$ & row 6; $\Od$ & $3$\\ 8 & coordinate map $\Psi_i=(\xi_i,\varphi)$ and its inverse & Section~\ref{subsec:root-coordinate} & rows 5, 7 & $3$\\ 9 & Jacobian $|\det D\Psi_i|^{\circ}$; density $\alpha_i^{\,\circ}$; conjugating factor $h_i^{\,\circ}$; source factor $(h_i/|\det D\Psi_i|)^{\circ}$ & \eqref{eq:fixed-strip-airy-equation} and the lines before it & rows 1, 5, 8; one derivative & $4$\\ 10 & boundary term $\partial_{\xi_i}\log h_i$ & \eqref{eq:fixed-strip-root-pair} & row 9; one derivative & $5$\\ 11 & potential $V_i$ & \eqref{eq:fixed-strip-airy-equation} & row 9; two derivatives & $6$\\[4pt] \multicolumn{5}{@{}l}{\emph{On a positive component}}\\[2pt] 12 & coordinate map $\Psi_{\bx}$ and its inverse & Section~\ref{subsec:positive-crossing} & row 8; Taylor polynomials of degree $4$ & $7$\\ 13 & conjugating factor $h_{\bx}^{\,\circ}$ & Section~\ref{subsec:positive-crossing} & row 9; Taylor polynomials of degree $3$ & $7$\\ 14 & Jacobian $J_{\bx}^{\,\circ}$; source factor $(h_{\bx}/|J_{\bx}|)^{\circ}$ & \eqref{eq:pp-fixed-canonical-source} & rows 12, 13; one derivative & $8$\\ 15 & principal coefficients of $P_{\bx}$ & \eqref{eq:pp-fixed-canonical-source} & rows 1, 12--14 & $8$\\ 16 & divided coefficients $e^{ab}_{\bx}$ & \eqref{eq:readable-positive-difference} & row 15; division by $\bd^3$ & $11$\\ 17 & potential of $P_{\bx}$ & \eqref{eq:pp-fixed-canonical-source} & rows 1, 13, 14; two derivatives of $h_{\bx}$ & $9$\\ \bottomrule \end{longtable} \begin{proposition}[Uniform bounds for the objects of a state] \label{prop:uniform-physical-geometry} \label{lem:current-geometric-jets} On $\mathfrak N$ the following holds for every object $\mathfrak o$ of Table~\ref{tab:objects} on every component $m$, with $k$ the number in its row. Let $\mathfrak o_*$ be the value of $\mathfrak o$ at the reference state. The norms $C^s$ are taken in the variables of the object, after rescaling to unit size: on the component for the functions of $(r,\theta)$ in rows 1--5 and 12--14; on the part $\sigma_*\le\tfrac34T$, respectively $\sigma_*\ge\tfrac14T$, of the component for $\xi_i$ and $\Psi_i$; on the fixed cylinders for the functions of $(\xi_i,\varphi)$ and of $(y,\varphi)$; on the set $0\le x\le3\delta^{\rm root}$, $|\zeta|\le(3\delta^{\rm root})^{3/2}$ for row~6; and on the circle for $f$, $h_R$, $\mathfrak e$ and $\Delta$. The speeds of rows 1 and~4, the flows of row~2 and the travel coordinates of row~5 are not smooth in $r$ at the roots, where they are smooth functions of $x$, $\sqrt x$ and $\theta$. For these objects $\|\cdot\|_{C^s}$ denotes the norm $C^s$ in $(r,\theta)$ on the part of the component at distance at least $2\delta^{\rm root}$ from both roots, plus the supremum over the remaining radii of the norm $C^s$ in $\theta$. Near the roots they are used only through $d=b/a$, the root factor $c_0$ and rows 6--9, which are smooth up to the roots. Here $x$ is the distance from a root and $\delta^{\rm root}$ is the number \eqref{eq:geometry-root-collar-width} of the cell. \begin{enumerate} \item \textup{(Reference.)} The object $\mathfrak o_*$ depends on $r$ only, apart from the terms $\theta$ in $U_*$, $V_*$, $\varphi_*$ and in the flows, and $\|\mathfrak o_*\|_{C^s}\le C_s\,\mathcal E_m^{C_s}$. For the quantities marked with a circle the reciprocal satisfies the same bound. \item \textup{(Differences.)} \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-current-jet-bound} \|\mathfrak o-\mathfrak o_*\|_{C^s} \le C_s\,\mathcal E_m^{C_s}\,H_m^\beta\;\mathfrak g_{s+k+3,m}. \end{equation} In particular the differentials of the coordinate maps, the Jacobians and the conjugating factors remain comparable to their reference values. \item \textup{(Derivatives with respect to the state.)} For increments $\eta_1,\ldots,\eta_j$ of the state, \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-parameter-bound} \begin{split} \bigl\|D^j\mathfrak o\,[\eta_1,\ldots,\eta_j]\bigr\|_{C^s} \le C_{s,j}\,\mathcal E_m^{C_{s,j}}\,H_m^\beta \Bigl[\,&\sum_i|\eta_i|_{s+k+3+j}\prod_{l\ne i}|\eta_l|_{b_0}\\ &+(1+\mathfrak n_{s+k+3+j,m})\prod_l|\eta_l|_{b_0}\Bigr], \end{split} \end{equation} where $|\eta|_s$ denotes the localized seminorm of order $s$ of an increment on the neighbourhood of $m$. The loss grows with the order $j$ of the derivative, as \eqref{eq:tame-derivative-shape} allows; the neighbourhood and the low order $b_0$ do not depend on $j$. \end{enumerate} In particular \eqref{eq:geometry-current-jet-bound} holds for all objects with $\mathfrak g_{s+d_{\rm geo},m}$ on the right, where \[ d_{\rm geo}=14 . \] \end{proposition} The Sobolev embedding on a cell costs two derivatives; the constant $3$ in $s+k+3$ leaves one to spare. The proof occupies the rest of this subsection. The reference values are treated first (Lemmas~\ref{lem:reference-regularized-charts}--\ref{lem:geometric-weight-conversion}); they involve functions of $r$ only. Lemma~\ref{lem:cs-calculus} then states the rules of the count, and the rows of the table are taken in order, each with its formula, the rules applied to it, and the hypotheses of these rules. \begin{lemma}[Root charts of the reference profile] \label{lem:reference-regularized-charts} \label{lem:reference-height-source-factors} On each half of the negative component of cell $n$, the root coordinate of the reference profile is the function of $r$ \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-regular-root-coordinate} \xi=x\,\Bigl[\tfrac32\int_0^1\sqrt t\;c_i(xt)\,dt\Bigr]^{2/3}, \end{equation} where $x$ is the distance from the root of that half, and \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-root-inverse} \mathcal E_n^{-C}\le|\xi_r|\le\mathcal E_n^{C},\qquad \|\xi\|_{C^s}+\|r(\xi)\|_{C^s}\le C_s\,\mathcal E_n^{C_s}. \end{equation} Moreover \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-root-density} \alpha_i=w_*\,|\xi_r|,\qquad h_i=\alpha_i^{-1/2}, \end{equation} and the functions $\alpha_i^{\pm1}$, $h_i^{\pm1}$, $|\xi_r|^{\pm1}$, the potential $V_i=-\alpha_i^{-1/2}\partial_\xi^2\alpha_i^{1/2}$, the source factors $h_i/|\xi_r|$ and $|\xi_r|/h_i$, and $\partial_\xi\log h_i$ have derivatives of order $s$ bounded by $C_s\mathcal E_n^{C_s}$. These bounds persist when the half is rescaled to unit length. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} At the reference state the charts are the identity, so $\varphi=\theta$ and, on each half, $\xi=(\tfrac32\sigma_i)^{2/3}$, where $\sigma_i=\int v_0\,dr$ is the travel angle from the root of that half. \step{1: near the root} Since $v_0=\sqrt x\,c_i(x)$, the substitution $x'=xt$ gives $\sigma_i=x^{3/2}\int_0^1\sqrt t\,c_i(xt)\,dt$, which is \eqref{eq:geometry-regular-root-coordinate}. The bracket is smooth and positive, and equals $c_i(0)$ at $x=0$; so $|\xi_r|=c_i(0)^{2/3}$ at the root. On the zone $|x|<8\delta_n^{\rm root}$ the bracket lies between $\tfrac12c_i(0)$ and $2c_i(0)$, and by \eqref{eq:geometry-normalized-root-jets} its logarithmic derivative times $|x|$ is at most $C\epsilon_{\rm root}A_n^{15}$. Hence $|\xi_r|$ is comparable to $c_i(0)^{2/3}$ on the zone, and the derivatives of $\xi$ have coefficient bounds there. \step{2: away from the zones} Differentiating $\xi^{3/2}=\tfrac32\sigma_i$ gives $|\xi_r|=v_0/\sqrt\xi$, so we need upper and lower bounds for $v_0$ and $\xi$. In the model coordinate the zone of the left root ends at a distance comparable to $A_n^{19}$ from $X_L$, and that of the right root at a distance comparable to $A_n^{15}$ from $X_R$, because $r_X$ is comparable to $\mathfrak r_nA_n$ and $\mathfrak r_nA_n^5$ there. The function $\rho$ has one maximum on the component and vanishes only at its two ends, where $|\rho_X|$ is comparable to $A_n$ and $A_n^9$. Hence $\rho\ge cA_n^{24}$ outside the zones, and \[ c\,\mathfrak r_n^{-1}A_n^{11}\le v_0=\frac{\sqrt\rho}{r_X} \le C\,\mathfrak r_n^{-1}A_n^{-9/2}. \] By Step~1, $\xi\ge cA_n^{20}$ at the end of its zone, hence beyond it, and $\xi\le\xi_c=(3T_n/4)^{2/3}\asymp A_n^{1/3}$. So $|\xi_r|$ is bounded above and below by powers of $A_n$. The higher derivatives follow by differentiating $\xi_r=\pm v_0\,\xi^{-1/2}$, using the lower bounds for $r_X$, $\rho$ and $\xi$ on this region. \step{3: the inverse} From $r(\xi(r))=r$ we get $r_\xi=1/\xi_r$, and every higher derivative of $r(\xi)$ is a polynomial in lower ones and in derivatives of $\xi$, divided by $\xi_r$. This proves \eqref{eq:geometry-root-inverse}. The length $\xi_c$ of a half and its reciprocal are powers of $A_n$, so rescaling to unit length costs a fixed power of $A_n$ for each derivative. \step{4: the factors} For the reference operator $a=w_*$, $\widehat b=0$, $\delta=w_*v_0$, $U_\theta=V_\theta=1$ and $|\det D\Psi_i|=|\xi_r|$. Hence $\alpha_i=\delta/\sqrt\xi=w_*|\xi_r|$, which is \eqref{eq:geometry-root-density}. By \eqref{eq:geometry-profile-jets} and \eqref{eq:geometry-root-inverse} the functions $\alpha_i^{\pm1}$ have coefficient bounds, and the remaining quantities are obtained from $\alpha_i$ and $\xi_r$ by products, powers and differentiation in $\xi$. All of them are functions of $r$, so no angular frequency is involved. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[The reference coordinate on a positive component] \label{lem:positive-reference-charts} \label{lem:positive-reference-coefficient-bounds} Let $(r_1,r_2)$ be a positive component with index $n$, let $y_L,y_R$ be the continued root coordinates at its two ends, and let $\eta_L,\eta_R$ be cutoffs with disjoint supports in the zones of the two ends, equal to one on smaller zones. Define \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-positive-coordinate} \begin{split} y_r&=\eta_L\,(y_L)_r-\eta_R\,(y_R)_r+\mu_0\,(1-\eta_L-\eta_R), \qquad y(r)=\int_{r_1}^ry_r\,dr,\\ \mu_0&=\frac{1-\int\eta_L\,(y_L)_r\,dr+\int\eta_R\,(y_R)_r\,dr} {\int(1-\eta_L-\eta_R)\,dr}, \end{split} \end{equation} and \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-positive-height} \log h_*=\eta_L\log h_L+\eta_R\log h_R, \qquad h_i=\bigl(w_*\,|(y_i)_r|\bigr)^{-1/2}. \end{equation} Then $y$ is a diffeomorphism of $[r_1,r_2]$ onto $[0,1]$ with $y=y_L$ near $r_1$ and $y=1-y_R$ near $r_2$, and $y_r^{\pm1}$, $h_*^{\pm1}$, the inverse function $r(y)$ and the source factors $h_*/y_r$, $y_r/h_*$ have derivatives of order $s$ bounded by $C_s\mathcal E_n^{C_s}$. The coefficients of the reference operator $P_*=-\partial_y(a\,\partial_y)-c\,\partial_\varphi^2+V$ are \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-positive-coefficients} a=h_*^2\,w_*\,y_r,\qquad c=\frac{h_*^2\,w_*'}{r\,y_r},\qquad V=-\frac{h_*}{y_r}\,\bigl(w_*\,h_{*,r}\bigr)_r . \end{equation} Near the ends $a=1$ and $c=y_i$; on the whole component \eqref{eq:positive-coefficients} holds, and the derivatives of order $s$ of $a$, $c$, $V$ and $a^{-1}$ are bounded by $C_s\mathcal E_n^{C_s}$. On the component which contains the interval $J_*$, the zones can be chosen disjoint from $J_*$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} \step{1: the zones} The continued coordinates $y_i=-\xi_i$ have positive inward derivatives with the bounds of Lemma~\ref{lem:reference-regularized-charts}, since \eqref{eq:geometry-normalized-root-jets} holds on both sides of the root. The increment of $y_i$ over its zone is at most $8\delta^{\rm root}\sup|\xi_r|=O(A_n^{18})$. So the two zones together account for less than $\tfrac14$ of the total increment $1$ on all but finitely many components, and on those as well if $\epsilon_{\rm root}$ is small. This is the last of the finitely many smallness conditions on the constant $\epsilon_{\rm root}$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:quantitative-root-collars}; like the others it involves the reference profile only. The interval $J_*$ has positive distance from the roots. \step{2: the coordinate} Note that $(y_R)_r<0$, since $y_R$ increases inwards from the right end. The numerator of $\mu_0$ lies between $\tfrac34$ and $1$, and its denominator is comparable to $r_2-r_1$; so $\mu_0$ and $\mu_0^{-1}$ are coefficient powers. The function $y_r$ is a convex combination of positive functions with coefficient bounds above and below, and its integral over the component is $1$ by the choice of $\mu_0$. Hence $y=y_L$ near $r_1$ and $y=1-y_R$ near $r_2$, and the inverse function is estimated as in Step~3 of the preceding proof. \step{3: the conjugating factor} The logarithms $\log h_i$ are bounded by $C(n^{5/2}+n^2)$ by \eqref{eq:geometry-profile-jets}, and their derivatives of positive order have coefficient bounds. Differentiating \eqref{eq:geometry-positive-height} and exponentiating gives the bounds for $h_*^{\pm1}$. \step{4: the coefficients} The formulas \eqref{eq:geometry-positive-coefficients} follow by inserting $u=h_*\,U(y(r))\cos(j\theta)$ into $-(h_*/y_r)\,\mathscr L_{w_*}u$; the terms with $U_y$ which do not belong to $(aU_y)_y$ cancel. In a zone $h_*=(w_*\,|(y_i)_r|)^{-1/2}$ gives $a=1$. Differentiating \eqref{eq:geometry-regular-root-coordinate} gives $\xi\,\xi_r^2=x\,c_i(x)^2=-w_*'/(rw_*)$ on both sides of the root, so $w_*'/(rw_*)=y_i\,(y_i)_r^2$ and $c=y_i$. The upper bounds and the lower bound for $a$ follow from Steps~2 and~3. \step{5: the lower bound for $c$} It suffices to show \begin{equation}\label{eq:geometry-wprime-distance} w_*'(r)\ge\mathcal E_n^{-C}\,\min(r-r_1,\,r_2-r), \end{equation} because $y(1-y)\le\mathcal E_n^{C}\min(r-r_1,r_2-r)$ by the bounds for $y_r$. On a short positive ramp $-\rho\ge cA_n\min(|X-X_L|,1)$, and on a long positive ramp $-\rho\ge cA_n^9\min(|X-X_R|,1)$; since $w_*'=-\lambda_n\rho\,r/r_X$, the bounds of Lemma~\ref{lem:cell} give \eqref{eq:geometry-wprime-distance} on the ramps. On a join $w_*'/w_*\ge2/r$ by \eqref{eq:join-slope}, and on the connectors of Lemma~\ref{lem:connector} $w_*'/w_*\ge3/(4r)$; with the lower bound for $w_*$ this gives \eqref{eq:geometry-wprime-distance} there, since the distance to the ends is bounded. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[Conversion of weights and derivatives] \label{lem:geometric-weight-conversion} On cell $n$ and its neighbours, the continuous weights $H$, $E_0$, $M$ and the discrete weights $H_n$, $\mathcal E_n$, $M_n$ differ by factors bounded by $\mathcal E_n^{C}$. Changes between the variables $r$, $\varrho$, the root coordinates and the coordinates $y$ transfer derivatives of total order $s$ to derivatives of total order at most $s$, with coefficients bounded by $E_0^{C_s}$; so do the source factors and cutoffs. A restriction to a circle costs one radial derivative. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By \eqref{eq:geometry-endpoint-distance}, $x_\partial=n+O(1)$ on cell $n$, so \[ \log\frac H{H_n}=O(n^2),\qquad \log\frac{E_0}{\mathcal E_n}=O\bigl(n^{3/2}\log(e+n)\bigr),\qquad \log\frac M{M_n}=O\bigl(n^{3/2}\log^2(e+n)\bigr), \] and the same bounds hold for the ratios of the weights of neighbouring cells; all of them are $O(\log\mathcal E_n)$. In the variable $\varrho$, \[ |\Dr\log M|\le C\,(1+x_\partial)^{-1/2}\log^2(e+x_\partial), \] which is bounded together with its derivatives, and the same is true of $\log H$, $\log E_0$ and $\log\ell$; so the weights are uniformly comparable on unit intervals of $\varrho$, and $\ell^{\pm1}$ is bounded by a power of $E_0$. The chain rule expresses derivatives of total order $s$ in one set of variables through derivatives of order at most $s$ in another, with coefficients which are polynomials in the derivatives of the coordinate functions and in reciprocals of their first derivatives; these are bounded by Lemmas~\ref{lem:reference-regularized-charts} and~\ref{lem:positive-reference-charts}. The inequality $E_0^{C_s}\le C_sM$ is applied to the complete product. The trace inequality on an interval of unit length costs one derivative, and the rescaling to unit length costs coefficient powers. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[The rules of the count]\label{lem:cs-calculus} Let $\Omega$ and $\Omega'$ be products of finitely many unit intervals and circles, with the norms $C^s$ of functions which are smooth up to the boundary; for a circle factor, maps and segments are understood in the lift. In each statement $C_s$ denotes a polynomial in the quantities named there, whose coefficients depend only on $s$ and on the domains. \begin{enumerate} \item[\textup{(R1)}] \textup{(Products and functions.)} If $|\alpha_1|+\cdots+|\alpha_p|\le s$, then \[ \sup\Bigl|\prod_{i=1}^p\partial^{\alpha_i}v_i\Bigr| \le C_s\sum_{i=1}^p\|v_i\|_{C^s}\prod_{l\ne i}\|v_l\|_{C^0}. \] Let $v$ and $\delta$ be functions on $\Omega$ with values in $\R^p$, and let $\Phi$ be smooth on a neighbourhood of the set $I$ of the values of $v+t\delta$, $0\le t\le1$. Then \[ \|\Phi(v+\delta)-\Phi(v)\|_{C^s}\le C_s\,\|\delta\|_{C^s}, \] where $C_s$ is a polynomial in $\|v\|_{C^s}$, $\|\delta\|_{C^0}$ and the suprema over $I$ of the derivatives of $\Phi$ of orders $1,\ldots,s+1$. \item[\textup{(R2)}] \textup{(Derivatives.)} $\|\partial v\|_{C^s}\le\|v\|_{C^{s+1}}$ for a derivative $\partial$ of the first order. \item[\textup{(R3)}] \textup{(Composition and inversion.)} Let $h,h_*\colon\Omega'\to\Omega$ be smooth maps and $u,u_*$ functions on $\Omega$. For $s\ge1$, \begin{align*} \|u\circ h\|_{C^s} &\le C_s\bigl(\|u\|_{C^s}+\|u\|_{C^1}\,\|h\|_{C^s}\bigr),\\ \|u\circ h-u_*\circ h_*\|_{C^s} &\le C_s'\bigl(\|u-u_*\|_{C^s}+\|h-h_*\|_{C^s}\bigr), \end{align*} where $C_s$ is a polynomial in $\|h\|_{C^1}$ and $C_s'$ is a polynomial in $\|u_*\|_{C^{s+1}}$, $\|h_*\|_{C^s}$, $\|u-u_*\|_{C^1}$ and $\|h-h_*\|_{C^1}$. Let now $h$ and $h_*$ be diffeomorphisms of $\Omega'$ onto sets which contain $\Omega$, and let $h_*^{-1}$ be defined and smooth on a product $\Omega_*$ of intervals and circles which contains both images. Then, on $\Omega$, \[ \|h^{-1}-h_*^{-1}\|_{C^s}\le C_s''\,\|h-h_*\|_{C^s}, \] where $C_s''$ is a polynomial in $\|h_*\|_{C^{s+1}}$, in the norm $C^{s+1}$ of $h_*^{-1}$ on $\Omega_*$, in $\|h-h_*\|_{C^2}$ and in $\sup|(Dh)^{-1}|$. \item[\textup{(R4)}] \textup{(Flows.)} Let $P$ be a product of unit intervals, or a point. Let $G(t,p,\theta)$ and $G_*(t,p)$ be continuous for $0\le t\le1$, $p\in P$, $\theta\in\T$, and smooth in $(p,\theta)$, and let $\Theta$ and $\Theta_*$ be the solutions of $\partial_t\Theta=G(t,p,\Theta)$ and $\partial_t\Theta_*=G_*(t,p)$ with the initial value $\theta$. Put $|F|_s=\sup_t\|F(t,\cdot)\|_{C^s(P\times\T)}$. Then \[ \sup_t\|\Theta(t,\cdot)-\Theta_*(t,\cdot)\|_{C^s} \le C_s\,|G-G_*|_s , \] where $C_s$ is a polynomial in $|G_*|_s$, $|G-G_*|_1$ and $\exp|\partial_\theta G|_0$. \item[\textup{(R5)}] \textup{(Substitution at a root.)} $\|\Ev\,G\|_{C^s}\le C_s\|G\|_{C^s}$ and $\|\Od\,G\|_{C^s}\le C_s\|G\|_{C^{s+1}}$ \textup{(Lemma~\ref{lem:rewrite-root-composition})}. \item[\textup{(R6)}] \textup{(Taylor polynomials.)} For a function $F(x,\theta)$ on $[0,1]\times\T$ let $T_pF(x,\theta)=\sum_{i\le p}\partial_x^iF(0,\theta)\,x^i/i!$, considered for $|x|\le1$. Then $\|T_pF\|_{C^s}\le C_s\|F\|_{C^{s+p}}$. \item[\textup{(R7)}] \textup{(Division.)} If $F$, $F_y$ and $F_{yy}$ vanish at $y=0$, then $\|F/y^3\|_{C^s}\le C_s\|F\|_{C^{s+3}}$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} We use the interpolation inequalities $\|v\|_{C^i}\le C_s\|v\|_{C^0}^{1-i/s}\,\|v\|_{C^s}^{i/s}$, $0\le i\le s$, which hold on such domains \cite[Part~II, Section~2.2]{Hamilton1982}, \cite[Appendix~A]{Hormander1976}. (R1) Let $a_i=\|v_i\|_{C^0}\le b_i=\|v_i\|_{C^s}$ and $\vartheta_i=|\alpha_i|/s$, so that $\sum\vartheta_i\le1$. By interpolation the product is at most \[ C\prod_ia_i^{1-\vartheta_i}b_i^{\vartheta_i} =C\prod_la_l\,\prod_i\Bigl(\frac{b_i}{a_i}\Bigr)^{\vartheta_i} \le C\prod_la_l\,\max_i\frac{b_i}{a_i} \le C\sum_ib_i\prod_{l\ne i}a_l . \] For the second statement write $\Phi(v+\delta)-\Phi(v)=\sum_i\delta_i\,\Phi_i$ with $\Phi_i=\int_0^1\partial_i\Phi(v+t\delta)\,dt$. A derivative of order between $1$ and $s$ of $\partial_i\Phi(w)$, $w=v+t\delta$, is a sum of terms $(\partial^\gamma\partial_i\Phi)(w)\prod_l\partial^{\alpha_l}w$ with $|\gamma|$ factors, whose orders add up to at most $s$. By the first statement $\|\Phi_i\|_{C^s}\le C(1+\|v\|_{C^s}+\|\delta\|_{C^s})$, with $C$ a polynomial in the sup norms. The first statement, applied to $\delta_i\Phi_i$, gives the claim; note that $\|\delta\|_{C^0}\|\delta\|_{C^s}$ is of the required form. (R3) A derivative of order $j$, $1\le j\le s$, of $u\circ h$ is a sum of terms $(\partial^\beta u)\circ h\,\prod_{i=1}^{|\beta|} \partial^{\gamma_i}h$ with $|\gamma_i|\ge1$ and $\sum|\gamma_i|=j$. Such a term is bounded by $\|Du\|_{C^{|\beta|-1}}\prod\|Dh\|_{C^{|\gamma_i|-1}}$, and $(|\beta|-1)+\sum(|\gamma_i|-1)=j-1\le s-1$. Interpolating $Du$ and $Dh$ between $C^0$ and $C^{s-1}$, as in (R1), gives the first estimate. For the second, \[ u\circ h-u_*\circ h_* =(u-u_*)\circ h+\Bigl[\int_0^1Du_*\bigl(h_*+t(h-h_*)\bigr)\,dt\Bigr] (h-h_*) . \] Apply the first estimate to the first term and to the integrand, and (R1) to the product. No derivative of $u-u_*$ of order higher than $s$ occurs, because the additional derivative falls on $u_*$. For the inverses let $\iota=h^{-1}$ and $\iota_*=h_*^{-1}$. Since $D\iota=(Dh)^{-1}\circ\iota$, the first estimate and induction on $s$ give $\|\iota\|_{C^s}\le C(1+\|h\|_{C^s})$, with $C$ a polynomial in $\|h\|_{C^2}$ and $\sup|(Dh)^{-1}|$. For $y\in\Omega$ and $x=\iota(y)$ the segment from $h_*(x)$ to $h(x)=y$ lies in $\Omega_*$, which is convex in the lift. Therefore $\iota_*(y)-\iota(y)=\iota_*(h(x))-\iota_*(h_*(x))$, that is, \[ \iota-\iota_*=-\Bigl(\Bigl[\int_0^1D\iota_*\bigl(h_*+t(h-h_*)\bigr) \,dt\Bigr](h-h_*)\Bigr)\circ\iota , \] where the bracket is a function on $\Omega'$. The first estimate, (R1) and the bound for $\iota$ give the claim. (R4) Let $\delta G=G-G_*$ and $\delta\Theta=\Theta-\Theta_*$, and let $\Xi_t(p,\theta)=(p,\Theta(t,p,\theta))$. Since $G_*$ does not depend on $\theta$, a derivative $\partial^\alpha$ in $(p,\theta)$ of order $s\ge1$ satisfies \[ \partial_t\,\partial^\alpha\delta\Theta =(\partial_\theta\delta G)\circ\Xi_t\;\partial^\alpha\delta\Theta +(\partial_\theta\delta G)\circ\Xi_t\;\partial^\alpha\Theta_* +\sum(\partial_p^{a}\partial_\theta^{b}\delta G)\circ\Xi_t\, \prod_{i=1}^{b}\partial^{\gamma_i}\Theta , \] where in the sum $|a|+\sum|\gamma_i|=s$ and $1\le|\gamma_i|0$, so that repeated differentiation matches all higher normal derivatives. This is the result of the section: all the operators $\widehat L_{\bx}$ act, in canonical form, on one domain. It is what makes it possible to regard them as perturbations of the reference operator in the next section.