\section{The reference profile: requirements and solvable models} \label{sec:rosen-reference-packet} \label{sec:radial-models} Part~\ref{part:reference} constructs one radial profile $w_*$ at which the linearized equation has a single flat infinitesimal bending and a controlled inverse. This section states precisely what is needed (Proposition~\ref{prop:rad-fixed-theorem}), explains the layout of the construction and its vocabulary, and introduces the two explicitly solvable models from which $w_*$ is assembled. \subsection{Angular modes and the design problem} Functions in our symmetry class have the Fourier expansion \[ u(r,\theta)=u_0(r)+\sum_{\substack{j\ge2\\ j\ \mathrm{even}}} u_j(r)\,e_j(\theta), \qquad e_j(\theta)=\sqrt2\cos(j\theta), \] and on the $j$th mode the operator \eqref{eq:intro-linearization} acts as the ordinary differential operator \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-modal-operator} L_ju=(wu')'-j^2\,\frac{w'}r\,u, \qquad\text{that is,}\qquad \mathscr L_w(u\,e_j)=(L_ju)\,e_j . \end{equation} When the dependence on the profile matters we write $L_{j,w}$. We want a profile for which \begin{itemize} \item at $j=2$ there is exactly one solution of $L_2\phi=0$, up to multiples, which is flat at both endpoints. This is the seed of the nonradial height. The frequency two is the lowest one compatible with the half-turn symmetry required in Theorem~\ref{thm:geometric-closure}; \item at every even $j\ge4$ there is no such solution, and $L_j$ has a controlled inverse. The nonlinear equation creates all higher even frequencies, so all of them must be invertible on the same profile. \end{itemize} Two freedoms are available, and separating them is the organizing idea of the construction. The \emph{shape} of a piece of the profile determines the homogeneous solutions on that piece, hence its spectrum and its travel angles. Multiplying a piece by a positive constant, its \emph{amplitude}, changes none of these, but it changes the scale of the flux $wu'$ by which solutions on neighbouring pieces are compared. We use the first freedom to make each piece explicitly solvable, and the second to prevent resonances when the pieces are joined. \subsection{What the reference profile must provide} \label{sec:radial-what} We state the result of Part~\ref{part:reference} before starting the construction. It involves three scales attached to the $n$th piece of the profile near an endpoint. \begin{definition}[The endpoint scales]\label{def:radial-weights} The pieces of the profile approaching either endpoint are called \emph{cells} and are indexed by integers $n\ge N$. We set \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-endpoint-weights} A_n\asymp e^{-n^2},\qquad S_n=\tfrac23\,n^3,\quad H_n=e^{-S_n},\qquad q_n=n^{5/2}\log(e+n),\quad \mathcal E_n=e^{q_n}. \end{equation} \begin{itemize} \item $A_n$ is the \emph{length scale}: cell $n$ has radial length comparable to $A_n$. \item $H_n$ is the \emph{decay scale}: the distinguished solution of $L_j u=0$ at the endpoint decays like $H_n$ across the cells. \item $\mathcal E_n$ is the \emph{coefficient allowance}: reciprocals and derivatives of the coefficients on cell $n$ are bounded by powers of $\mathcal E_n$. \end{itemize} Two expressions built on the third scale are used throughout the paper: \begin{equation}\label{eq:coefficient-power} \begin{aligned} \text{\emph{coefficient power} on cell $n$:}\quad &\text{a quantity bounded by }C\,\mathcal E_n^{C};\\ \text{\emph{coefficient bounds} on cell $n$:}\quad &\text{all derivatives of order $s$ bounded by } C_s\,\mathcal E_n^{C_s}, \end{aligned} \end{equation} with constants independent of $n$. On the finitely many pieces in the middle of the annulus the same words refer to fixed positive constants. For the purpose of estimates a cell includes fixed portions of its neighbours; such an enlargement changes the index by a bounded amount, which is immaterial. \end{definition} The three scales are ordered: for all fixed $a,b,\varepsilon>0$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-scale-separation} \mathcal E_n^{a}\,e^{bn^2}\le C_{a,b,\varepsilon}\,e^{\varepsilon S_n}, \qquad\text{because}\qquad n^2=o(q_n),\quad q_n=o(S_n). \end{equation} So lengths are much larger than coefficient allowances, which are much larger than the decay scale. Section~\ref{sec:radial-tails} derives all three scales from the construction. \paragraph{Weighted norms.} Choose a smooth partition of unity $\vartheta_m$ on $(r_-,r_+)$ with bounded overlap, subordinate to the cells of both tails and to the finite middle part; the index $m$ records both the endpoint and the cell. Fix a smooth function $\chi_L$ of $r$ equal to one near the left endpoint and to zero near the right one. For exponents $0<\gamma<1$ and $\ea\ge0$, the \emph{source norm} of a pair $(f,c)$, consisting of a function $f$ and a scalar $c$, is \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-source-norm} \|(f,c)\|_{Y_{\gamma,s}}^2 =|c|^2+\sum_m\mathcal E_m^{2\ea}H_m^{-2\gamma} \|\vartheta_m f\|_{L^2(dr)H^s(\T)}^2 . \end{equation} The \emph{output norm} is defined for pairs $(u,\nu)$ of a function and a scalar. Write $u=a_L\chi_L+v$ with a constant $a_L$; then the squared output norm is \[ |a_L|^2+|\nu|^2+\sum_m\mathcal E_m^{-2\eb}H_m^{-2\gamma} \|\vartheta_m v\|_{L^2(dr\,d\theta)}^2 . \] A finite source norm means decay like $H_m^{\gamma}$ towards the endpoints, with $\ea$ powers of the coefficient allowance to spare. A finite output norm means the same decay for $v$, after the loss of $\ea+\eb$ such powers, while $u$ itself tends to $a_L$ at the left endpoint and to $0$ at the right one. \begin{proposition}[The reference profile]\label{prop:rad-fixed-theorem} There are radii $00$ on $(r_-,r_+)$, flat at both endpoints, such that all zeros of $w_*'$ in $(r_-,r_+)$ are simple, with the following properties. \begin{enumerate} \item \textup{(Kernel.)} There is a nonzero function $\phi_*$, flat at both endpoints, with $L_{2,w_*}\phi_*=0$. Every solution of $L_{2,w_*}\phi=0$ which is bounded near both endpoints is a multiple of $\phi_*$, and for every even $j\ge4$ the equation $L_{j,w_*}\phi=0$ has no nonzero solution which is bounded near both endpoints. \item \textup{(Travel angles.)} For every component $m$ of $\{w_*'<0\}$ the travel angle $T_m=\int\sqrt{-w_*'/(rw_*)}\,dr$ over that component satisfies \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-optical-margin} |\sin(kT_m)|\ge\frac{\gamma_m}{k}\quad(k\ge1), \qquad \gamma_m^{-1}\le\mathcal E_m^{C}, \qquad T_m/\pi\ \text{is a quadratic irrational}. \end{equation} \item \textup{(Border.)} There is a smooth function $\chi_*$, compactly supported in a component of $\{w_*'>0\}$, such that \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-target-border} g_*=L'_{2,w_*}[w_*\chi_*]\,\phi_*,\qquad \int g_*\phi_*\,dr=1,\qquad \ell_*u=\int g_*u_2\,dr . \end{equation} Here $L'_{2,w}[\omega]\phi=(\omega\phi')'-4\omega'\phi/r$ is the derivative of $L_{2,w}\phi$ with respect to the profile $w$ in the direction $\omega$. \item \textup{(Inverse.)} The bordered operator \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-bordered-reference} \mathbb L_{w_*}(u,\nu) =\bigl(\mathscr L_{w_*}u+\nu\,g_*e_2,\ \ell_*u\bigr) \end{equation} has a two-sided inverse on the sources $(f,c)$ satisfying the compatibility condition $\int\av f\,dr=0$, where $u$ is required to tend to zero at the right endpoint and to an arbitrary constant at the left one. For every compact interval $[\gamma_-,\gamma_+]\subset(0,1)$ there are exponents $\ea,\eb$ such that this inverse is bounded from $Y_{\gamma,0}$ to the output norm, uniformly for $\gamma\in[\gamma_-,\gamma_+]$. With the same exponents, the part $v$ of the output satisfies \begin{equation}\label{eq:reference-radial-derivative} \sum_m\mathcal E_m^{-2\eb}H_m^{-2\gamma}\, \|\vartheta_m\,\partial_rv\|_{L^2(dr\,d\theta)}^2 \le C\,\|(f,c)\|_{Y_{\gamma,1}}^2 . \end{equation} \item \textup{(Independence of the exponent.)} The profile, the function $\phi_*$ and the border are the same for all exponents $\gamma$. \end{enumerate} \end{proposition} Some comments on the statement. \emph{The border.} Since $L_2$ has a one-dimensional kernel, and is formally symmetric, it has a one-dimensional cokernel as well. The standard remedy is to \emph{border} the operator: one adds a scalar unknown $\nu$ multiplying a fixed function $g_*$ (the \emph{column}) and a scalar equation $\ell_*u=c$ (the \emph{row}). The column removes the cokernel and the row removes the kernel; the inverse of the bordered operator is then described by the Schur complement formula (for the general method, also called the Grushin problem, see \cite{SjostrandZworski2007}). Our column has a meaning: if the profile is deformed to $w_*e^{\nu\chi_*}$, then $g_*e_2$ is the derivative of $\mathscr L_w(\phi_*e_2)$ with respect to $\nu$. So $\nu$ will be an actual parameter of the metric in the nonlinear problem. \emph{The compatibility condition and the free constant.} These concern the mode $j=0$, where $L_0u=(wu')'$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:scalar-integral} the sources of interest have $\int\av f\,dr=0$; and the difference of the two endpoint values of the height is not prescribed. \emph{Endpoint-flat kernel.} The precise meaning of this term, and of the two-sided inverse, is given by the weighted graph domain of Definition~\ref{def:radial-graph-domain}. \emph{What is proved here, and what later.} Proposition~\ref{prop:rad-fixed-theorem} is an estimate at angular order zero, together with its first radial derivative. Estimates of all orders are recovered from the differential equation in Section~\ref{sec:stable-inverse}, after the weighted spaces of the nonlinear problem have been introduced. Keeping the two tasks apart means that the geometry of the profile does not depend on the order of regularity. The proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:rad-fixed-theorem} occupies the rest of this section and the next two; it is completed in Section~\ref{subsec:final-border}. \subsection{Layout of the construction and vocabulary} \label{subsec:layout} Figure~\ref{fig:layout} shows how $w_*$ is assembled. The following terms are used throughout Parts~\ref{part:reference} and~\ref{part:nonlinear}. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \begin{tikzpicture}[x=1cm,y=1cm,>=Stealth,font=\small] \draw[->] (-.3,0)--(13.3,0) node[right] {$r$}; \draw[fill=blue!13] (0,.3) rectangle (3.4,.95); \draw[fill=gray!15] (3.4,.3) rectangle (5.3,.95); \draw[fill=orange!22] (5.3,.3) rectangle (7.7,.95); \draw[fill=gray!15] (7.7,.3) rectangle (9.6,.95); \draw[fill=blue!13] (9.6,.3) rectangle (13,.95); \node at (2.3,.62) {left tail}; \node at (4.35,.62) {cones}; \node at (6.5,.62) {central model}; \node at (8.65,.62) {cones}; \node at (10.7,.62) {right tail}; \foreach \x in {.12,.27,.47,.75,1.15}{\draw (\x,.3)--(\x,.95);} \foreach \x in {12.88,12.73,12.53,12.25,11.85}{\draw (\x,.3)--(\x,.95);} \node[below] at (0,-.05) {$r_-$}; \node[below] at (13,-.05) {$r_+$}; \node[align=center] at (1.7,1.55) {cells $\ldots,N+1,N$\\(Morse models)}; \node[align=center] at (11.3,1.55) {cells $N,N+1,\ldots$\\(Morse models)}; \node[align=center] at (6.5,1.55) {harmonic oscillator:\\carries the seed $\phi_*$}; \node[align=center] at (4.35,-.75) {$w=cr$ and\\connectors}; \node[align=center] at (8.65,-.75) {$w=cr$ and\\connectors}; \draw[->] (4.35,-.35)--(4.35,.25); \draw[->] (8.65,-.35)--(8.65,.25); \end{tikzpicture} \caption{The layout of the reference profile $w_*$ (schematic). The cells shrink and accumulate at both endpoints. Consecutive pieces are separated by intervals on which $w_*'>0$.} \label{fig:layout} \end{figure} \begin{description}[leftmargin=1.5em,style=sameline,font=\normalfont\itshape] \item[Positive and negative components.] A \emph{positive component} is a component of $\{w'>0\}$; the equation is elliptic there. A \emph{negative component} is a component of $\{w'<0\}$; the equation is hyperbolic there. They are separated by the turning circles, also called \emph{roots}. \item[Travel angle.] The travel angle of a negative component is $T=\int\sqrt{-w'/(rw)}\,dr$ over that component: the angle by which a characteristic of $\mathscr L_w$ turns while crossing it. \item[Model.] A piece of the profile on which, in a suitable \emph{model coordinate} $X$, every $L_j$ is conjugate to an explicitly solvable Schr\"odinger operator (Section~\ref{subsec:liouville}). There are two kinds: the \emph{central model} and the Morse \emph{cells}. \item[Cell.] The $n$th cell consists, in the direction of increasing $r$, of a \emph{short positive ramp}, one negative component, and a \emph{long positive ramp} (Figure~\ref{fig:cell}). \item[Join.] A very short positive interval between two consecutive cells, on which $w$ rises steeply from the amplitude of one cell to that of the next. \item[Cone.] An interval on which $w=cr$. There $L_ju=c\,[(ru')'-j^2u/r]$ has the solutions $r^{\pm j}$. \item[Connector.] A positive interval joining the central model or a tail to a cone, built so that the seed solution is preserved exactly (Section~\ref{subsec:rad-cone-bump-target-match}). \item[Tail.] The union of the cells and joins near one endpoint. \item[Buffer.] A positive interval, viewed as a region across which the solutions of $L_ju=0$ grow or decay exponentially; it decouples the pieces on its two sides. \item[Natural line, incoming line.] At a point of a tail, and for a fixed frequency $j$, the \emph{natural line} is the one-dimensional space of solutions of $L_ju=0$ that decay towards the endpoint (Lemma~\ref{lem:radial-deep-inverse}). The \emph{incoming line} is the one-dimensional space of solutions satisfying the condition imposed on the interior side. A homogeneous solution of the whole problem exists exactly when the two lines coincide. \item[Outward.] Towards the nearer endpoint. \end{description} The plan of Part~\ref{part:reference} is as follows. \begin{itemize} \item Section~\ref{subsec:liouville} explains how a Schr\"odinger potential determines a radial profile. Sections~\ref{subsec:rad-central-singlepoint} and~\ref{subsec:morse} treat the central model and the Morse model on the whole line: spectrum, spectral gap at energy zero, travel angle. \item Section~\ref{sec:radial-tails} builds the tails. It proves that at every frequency the natural line exists, is unique, and consists of flat functions, and it chooses the amplitudes of the cells so that natural and incoming lines stay apart. \item Section~\ref{sec:radial-reference-inverse} joins all pieces and proves that the local information combines to an inverse on the whole annulus. \end{itemize} \subsection{From a Schr\"odinger potential to a radial profile} \label{subsec:liouville} It is easier to design the spectrum first and the radius afterwards. \begin{lemma}[Liouville transformation]\label{lem:liouville} Let $X$ range over an interval, let $r(X)$ be a smooth function with $r>0$ and $r_X>0$, let $\mathcal P(X)>0$ be smooth, and let $\lambda>0$. Define a profile $w$ and two functions $\rho,V_0$ of $X$ by \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc0} w(r(X))=\lambda\,\mathcal P(X)\,r_X(X),\qquad \rho=-\frac{r_{XX}+(\mathcal P_X/\mathcal P)\,r_X}{r},\qquad V_0=\frac{(\sqrt{\mathcal P})_{XX}}{\sqrt{\mathcal P}} . \end{equation} Then $w'=-\lambda\mathcal P\rho\,r/r_X$, and for every $j$ and every function $\psi(X)$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:liouville-identity} L_j\bigl(\mathcal P^{-1/2}\psi\bigr) =-\frac{\lambda\sqrt{\mathcal P}}{r_X}\, \bigl(-\psi_{XX}+(V_0-j^2\rho)\,\psi\bigr). \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For a function $u$ of $r$ we have $wu_r=\lambda\mathcal Pu_X$, hence $(wu_r)_r=\lambda(\mathcal Pu_X)_X/r_X$. Differentiating $w=\lambda\mathcal Pr_X$ and using the definition of $\rho$ gives the formula for $w'$. Therefore $L_ju=(\lambda/r_X)\,[(\mathcal Pu_X)_X+j^2\mathcal P\rho\,u]$, and with $u=\mathcal P^{-1/2}\psi$ one has $(\mathcal Pu_X)_X=\sqrt{\mathcal P}\,(\psi_{XX}-V_0\psi)$. \end{proof} We use the lemma in the opposite direction. Given a density $\mathcal P$ and a function $\rho$, the homogeneous equation $L_ju=0$ is equivalent to the Schr\"odinger equation \[ H_j\psi:=-\psi_{XX}+(V_0-j^2\rho)\,\psi=0 , \] \emph{provided} the linear equation $r_{XX}+(\mathcal P_X/\mathcal P)\,r_X+\rho\,r=0$ for the radius has a solution which is positive and increasing. Three features of the dictionary are used constantly. \begin{itemize} \item The amplitude $\lambda$ does not enter the homogeneous equation. \item The profile is falling where $\rho>0$ and rising where $\rho<0$. The negative components are the components of $\{\rho>0\}$, the turning circles are the zeros of $\rho$, and the travel angle of a negative component is \begin{equation}\label{eq:travel-angle-model} T=\int\sqrt{-w'/(rw)}\,dr=\int_{\{\rho>0\}}\sqrt\rho\,dX . \end{equation} \item Frequency enters only through the coupling constant $j^2$ in front of $\rho$. \end{itemize} We use two potentials with complementary roles (Figure~\ref{fig:two-spectral-models}). The harmonic oscillator, in the middle, has a zero mode at $j=2$ and is used to create the seed. The Morse potential, near the ends, has a spectral gap at energy zero for all $j$, and its cells are short enough in radius to accumulate at a finite point. It is the explicit spectra of the two models, not merely the shapes of their potentials, that make them useful. \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \begin{tikzpicture}[x=.92cm,y=.78cm,>=stealth] \begin{scope} \draw[->] (-2.5,0)--(2.5,0) node[right] {$X$}; \draw[dashed,gray] (-2.3,0)--(2.3,0); \draw[thick,blue!70!black,domain=-2.05:2.05,samples=45] plot (\x,{.68*\x*\x-.65}); \node[align=center] at (0,3.1) {central oscillator}; \node[fill=white,inner sep=2pt] at (0,0) {energy $0$}; \node[align=center,font=\small] at (0,-1.45) {$j=2$: zero is an eigenvalue\\$j\ge4$: arithmetic gap}; \end{scope} \begin{scope}[xshift=7.1cm] \draw[->] (-2.5,0)--(2.5,0) node[right] {$X$}; \draw[dashed,gray] (-.1,.65)--(2.3,.65); \draw[thick,teal!70!black] (-2.05,2.6) .. controls (-1.7,.6) and (-1.3,-.8) .. (-.6,-.65) .. controls (.15,-.6) and (.35,.57) .. (2.25,.64); \node[align=center] at (0,3.1) {Morse model}; \node[anchor=west,font=\small] at (.25,.95) {threshold $j^2B>0$}; \node[align=center,font=\small] at (0,-1.45) {all $j$: gap at energy zero\\shrinking cells: flat endpoint}; \end{scope} \end{tikzpicture} \caption{The potentials $V_0-j^2\rho$ of the two models on the whole line, drawn schematically with an arbitrary vertical scale. Only finite pieces of them are used in the profile, and the pieces are separated by regions where the potential is positive.} \label{fig:two-spectral-models} \end{figure} \subsection{The central oscillator} \label{subsec:rad-central-singlepoint} \paragraph{Definition and spectrum.} Fix the constants \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc1} A_c=\frac1{\sqrt2},\qquad a_c=\sqrt{4A_c-2},\qquad c_c=3A_c-2>0,\qquad \alpha_c=\frac{c_c+1}2, \end{equation} and take \[ \mathcal P=e^{-2a_cX},\qquad \rho=A_c-X^2 . \] Then $V_0=a_c^2$, and the Schr\"odinger operator of Lemma~\ref{lem:liouville} is a shifted harmonic oscillator, \[ H_{j,c}=-\partial_X^2+j^2X^2+a_c^2-j^2A_c , \] with eigenvalues \cite[\S8.3, equations (8.33)--(8.42)]{Teschl2009} \begin{equation}\label{eq:central-spectrum-new} E_{m,j}=j(2m+1)+a_c^2-j^2A_c,\qquad m=0,1,2,\ldots \end{equation} The value of $a_c$ is chosen so that $E_{0,2}=0$: at $j=2$ the eigenvalues are $E_{m,2}=4m$, and the kernel is spanned by the ground state $e^{-X^2}$. The irrationality of $A_c$ keeps all other even frequencies away from zero: \begin{lemma}[Spectral gap of the central model]\label{lem:central-gap} Let $\delta_c=\tfrac34(3-2\sqrt2)>0$. Then \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc3} \|H_{j,c}^{-1}\|\le\frac2{\delta_c}\quad(j\ge4\ \text{even}), \qquad \ker H_{2,c}=\operatorname{span}\{e^{-X^2}\}, \end{equation} and the inverse of $H_{2,c}$ on the orthogonal complement of its kernel has norm $1/4$. Here $H_{j,c}$ is the self-adjoint operator on $L^2(\R)$ defined by its closed quadratic form. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Only the first bound needs proof; it says $|E_{m,j}|\ge\delta_c/2$ for even $j\ge4$. Put $\Phi_j=jA_c-a_c^2/j$, so that $E_{m,j}=j\,(2m+1-\Phi_j)$. Since $A_c^2=\tfrac12$, \[ N_j:=\frac{j^2}2-\Phi_j^2=2A_ca_c^2-\frac{a_c^4}{j^2} \in\Bigl[\tfrac{13}4-\tfrac{3\sqrt2}2,\ 4-2\sqrt2\Bigr) \qquad(j\ge4), \] and this interval lies in $(1,2)$ at distance $\delta_c$ from the integers. Suppose $|E_{m,j}|<1$. Then $2m+1+\Phi_j<2j$, and because $j^2/2-(2m+1)^2$ is an integer, \[ \delta_c\le\bigl|(2m+1)^2-\Phi_j^2\bigr| =\frac{|E_{m,j}|}{j}\,(2m+1+\Phi_j)<2\,|E_{m,j}| . \] If $|E_{m,j}|\ge1$ there is nothing to prove. \end{proof} \paragraph{The model is a radial profile.} We need a positive increasing solution of the radius equation, which for the present $\mathcal P$ and $\rho$ reads $r_{XX}-2a_cr_X+(A_c-X^2)\,r=0$. An arbitrary solution would not do; here is an explicit one. \begin{lemma}[The central radius]\label{lem:central-radius} Let \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc6} \psi_1(X)=e^{-X^2/2}\int_0^\infty t^{\alpha_c-1}e^{-t^2/2+\sqrt2\,Xt}\,dt, \qquad r=e^{a_cX}\psi_1,\qquad \upsilon=\frac{r_X}r . \end{equation} Then $r$ is a positive solution of the radius equation, increasing from $0$ to $\infty$, with $\upsilon>a_c$. Moreover \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc6a} \upsilon= \begin{cases} -X+a_c-\alpha_c/X+O(X^{-3}),&X\to-\infty,\\[2pt] \phantom{-}X+a_c+(\alpha_c-1)/X+O(X^{-3}),&X\to+\infty, \end{cases} \end{equation} and these expansions may be differentiated any fixed number of times. In particular $\upsilon\asymp1+|X|$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} An integration by parts in $t$ shows $\psi_1''=(X^2+c_c)\,\psi_1$. Since $c_c-a_c^2+A_c=0$, the function $r=e^{a_cX}\psi_1$ solves the radius equation. Clearly $\psi_1>0$, and $\psi_1,\psi_1'\to0$ as $X\to-\infty$; then $\psi_1''>0$ implies $\psi_1'>0$, so $\upsilon=a_c+\psi_1'/\psi_1>a_c$. The leading terms of \eqref{eq:rad-eq-sc6a} can be read off from the equation: as $|X|\to\infty$ the solutions of $\psi''=(X^2+c_c)\psi$ behave like $|X|^{\alpha_c-1}e^{X^2/2}$ or like $|X|^{-\alpha_c}e^{-X^2/2}$, and $\psi_1$ is of the second kind at $-\infty$ and of the first kind at $+\infty$. To prove the expansions with their remainders, use the integral. For the expansion at $X=-L$, substitute $t=z/(\sqrt2L)$: the remaining integral is $\Gamma(\alpha_c)(1+O(L^{-2}))$ and may be differentiated under an exponentially integrable majorant. For $X>0$, complete the square and expand $t^{\alpha_c-1}$ about $t=\sqrt2X$ against the Gaussian; the region $|t-\sqrt2X|>X/2$ contributes an exponentially small amount. Logarithmic differentiation gives \eqref{eq:rad-eq-sc6a}, and with it the range of $r$. \end{proof} \paragraph{The seed and the two ends.} By Lemma~\ref{lem:liouville} the kernel of $H_{2,c}$ corresponds to the solution \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc2} \phi_0=\mathcal P^{-1/2}e^{-X^2}=e^{a_cX-X^2},\qquad \frac{\partial_y\phi_0}{\phi_0}=\frac{a_c-2X}{\upsilon} \longrightarrow \begin{cases}\phantom{-}2&\text{as }X\to-\infty,\\ -2&\text{as }X\to+\infty,\end{cases} \end{equation} of $L_2\phi_0=0$, where $y=\log r$. So at its two ends $\phi_0$ behaves like the solutions $r^{2}$ and $r^{-2}$ on a cone. The profile itself also becomes conical: writing $w=re^f$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-sc6b} 1+f_y=\frac{rw'}{w}=\frac{X^2-A_c}{\upsilon^2}\longrightarrow1 \qquad(X\to\pm\infty). \end{equation} Both limits hold with any fixed number of $y$-derivatives, by \eqref{eq:rad-eq-sc6a}. We may therefore cut the model so far out on both sides that the two end regions are positive, with uniformly bounded jets in the logarithmic coordinate $y$. The retained piece contains exactly two turning circles, at $X=\pm\sqrt{A_c}$. By \eqref{eq:travel-angle-model} its travel angle is \[ T=\int_{-\sqrt{A_c}}^{\sqrt{A_c}}\sqrt{A_c-X^2}\,dX =\frac{\pi A_c}2=\frac{\pi}{2\sqrt2}, \] and $|\sin(kT)|\ge c/k$ for all $k\ge1$, because $k^2-8m^2$ is a nonzero integer for all integers $k\ge1$ and $m$. \paragraph{The inverse in radial units.} Estimates in the radial variable are made in a weighted $L^2$ space. Define \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-ha2} \varpi=\frac{12\,w}{r^2},\qquad B_j=-\varpi^{-1}L_j, \qquad \|u\|_{L^2(\varpi\,dr)}^2=12\lambda\,\|\upsilon\psi\|_{L^2(dX)}^2 \quad\text{for }u=\mathcal P^{-1/2}\psi . \end{equation} The operator $B_j$ is symmetric in $L^2(\varpi\,dr)$, and on a cone it is $\tfrac1{12}(-\partial_y^2+j^2)$. By \eqref{eq:liouville-identity}, $B_j$ corresponds to $\tfrac1{12}\upsilon^{-2}H_{j,c}$, so in the variable $\upsilon\psi$ its inverse is $12\,\upsilon H_{j,c}^{-1}\upsilon$, not merely $H_{j,c}^{-1}$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:central-weighted} The operators $\upsilon H_{j,c}^{-1}\upsilon$, $j\ge4$ even, are bounded on $L^2(dX)$ uniformly in $j$. The same holds at $j=2$ for the inverse on the complement of the kernel. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The potential $V_j=j^2X^2+a_c^2-j^2A_c$ satisfies $V_j\ge cj^2\upsilon^2-Cj^2$. For $\psi=H_{j,c}^{-1}G$ this and Lemma~\ref{lem:central-gap} give $cj^2\|\upsilon\psi\|^2\le\langle G,\psi\rangle+Cj^2\|\psi\|^2 \le Cj^2\|G\|^2$, so $\|\upsilon H_{j,c}^{-1}\|\le C$, and by taking adjoints $\|H_{j,c}^{-1}\upsilon\|\le C$. Now let $\psi=H_{j,c}^{-1}(\upsilon F)$. In the same way \[ cj^2\|\upsilon\psi\|_2^2 \le\|\upsilon\psi\|_2\|F\|_2+Cj^2\|F\|_2^2 , \] and absorbing the first term on the right proves the claim. At $j=2$, add to $H_{2,c}$ the orthogonal projection onto $e^{-X^2}$, apply the same argument, and subtract the projection, whose weighted norm is finite. \end{proof} \paragraph{A temporary border.} During the construction, mode two of the central model is bordered by a compactly supported function $g_0$ with $\int g_0\phi_0\,dr=1$ and by the row $\ell_0u=\int g_0u\,dr$. A source is made orthogonal to $\phi_0$ by subtracting a multiple of $g_0$, and the row is fulfilled by adding a multiple of $\phi_0$; so the bordered inverse obeys the bounds of Lemma~\ref{lem:central-weighted}. The scalar is normalized so that under a rescaling $w\mapsto\lambda w$ of the amplitude one has $g_0\mapsto\sqrt\lambda\,g_0$ and $\phi_0\mapsto\phi_0/\sqrt\lambda$; then row and column have bounded norms in the Hilbert space $L^2(\varpi\,dr)$. This auxiliary border is replaced by the final one \eqref{eq:rad-eq-target-border} in Section~\ref{subsec:final-border}, after all geometric choices have been made. \subsection{The Morse model} \label{subsec:morse} \paragraph{Definition and spectrum.} For the tails take $\mathcal P=1$, so $V_0=0$, and for parameters $A>4B>0$ \[ \rho(X)=A\,(e^{-X}-e^{-2X})-B, \qquad H_{j,M}=-\partial_X^2-j^2\rho . \] The potential $-j^2\rho$ is confining as $X\to-\infty$ and tends to $j^2B$ exponentially as $X\to+\infty$. Hence the essential spectrum of $H_{j,M}$ is $[j^2B,\infty)$ \cite[Theorem~6.19]{Teschl2009}. Below it there are finitely many simple eigenvalues, given by Morse's formula \cite{Morse1929} \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-fs1} E_{m,j}=j^2B-(\alpha_j-m)^2, \qquad \alpha_j=\frac{j\sqrt A-1}2,\qquad 0\le m<\alpha_j . \end{equation} For completeness we recall the factorization, in the sense of Infeld and Hull \cite{InfeldHull1951}, which proves \eqref{eq:rad-eq-fs1} and fixes its normalization. Let $\omega=j\sqrt A$, and for real $\alpha$ put \[ D_\alpha=\partial_X+\alpha-\omega e^{-X},\qquad H_\alpha=-\partial_X^2+\omega^2e^{-2X}-(2\alpha+1)\,\omega e^{-X}+j^2B, \] so that $H_{j,M}=H_{\alpha_j}$. A direct computation gives \[ H_\alpha=D_\alpha^*D_\alpha+j^2B-\alpha^2, \qquad H_{\alpha-1}=D_\alpha D_\alpha^*+j^2B-\alpha^2 . \] The null function of $D_\alpha$ is $e^{-\alpha X-\omega e^{-X}}$, which is square integrable exactly when $\alpha>0$. Passing from $H_\alpha$ to $H_{\alpha-1}$ thus removes the ground state $j^2B-\alpha^2$ and keeps the rest of the spectrum. For $-1<\alpha\le0$ one has $H_\alpha-j^2B=D_0^*D_0-2\omega\alpha\,e^{-X}\ge0$, so there are no eigenvalues below $j^2B$. So every eigenvalue below $j^2B$ of $H_{j,M}$ is met in the descent and is one of the numbers \eqref{eq:rad-eq-fs1}. Conversely none of them is lost on the way back: if $H_{\alpha-1}\phi=(j^2B-\alpha_0^2)\phi$ with $0<\alpha_0<\alpha$, then $\|D_\alpha^*\phi\|^2=(\alpha^2-\alpha_0^2)\|\phi\|^2>0$, so $D_\alpha^*\phi$ is an eigenfunction of $H_\alpha$ with the same eigenvalue. Each eigenvalue is simple, because the Wronskian of two square integrable eigenfunctions is constant and vanishes at the confining end. The identities are justified on the form domain by integration against cutoffs: an eigenfunction below the threshold decays exponentially as $X\to+\infty$, and the form bound controls it as $X\to-\infty$. \paragraph{An arithmetic choice of the parameters.} We only need the resolvent at energy zero, and we need the travel angle. One irrationality controls both. \begin{lemma}[Gap and travel angle of a Morse model] \label{lem:morse-arithmetic} Let $d\ge2$ be an integer which is not a square, and let \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-rm5} A=\bigl(d^{-1/2}+2d^{-9/2}\bigr)^2, \qquad B=d^{-9}. \end{equation} Then, for every integer $j\ge2$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-rm1} \|H_{j,M}^{-1}\|\le8d^9 . \end{equation} The travel angle of the negative component $\{\rho>0\}$ is \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-rm2} T=\int_{\{\rho>0\}}\sqrt\rho\,dX =\pi\Bigl(\frac{\sqrt A}2-\sqrt B\Bigr)=\frac\pi{2\sqrt d}, \end{equation} and \begin{equation}\label{eq:rad-eq-morse-small-divisor} |\sin(kT)|\ge\frac1{3k\sqrt d}\qquad(k\ge1). \end{equation} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Note that $\sqrt A-2\sqrt B=d^{-1/2}$. \step{1: the gap} For integers $j\ge1$ and $m\ge0$ we claim \[ \Bigl|\frac j{\sqrt d}-(2m+1)\Bigr|\ge\frac1{4j\sqrt d}. \] If the left side is at least $\tfrac12$ this is clear. Otherwise $(2m+1)\sqrt d<2j$, and the claim follows by factoring the nonzero integer $j^2-d(2m+1)^2$. Now consider an eigenvalue \eqref{eq:rad-eq-fs1} and write $\kappa=\alpha_j-m=(j\sqrt A-(2m+1))/2>0$. Then $j\sqrt B-\kappa=\tfrac12\,\bigl((2m+1)-j/\sqrt d\bigr)$, hence \[ |E_{m,j}|=|j\sqrt B-\kappa|\,(j\sqrt B+\kappa) \ge\frac{j\sqrt B}{2}\,\Bigl|\frac j{\sqrt d}-(2m+1)\Bigr| \ge\frac1{8d^5}. \] The essential spectrum starts at $j^2B\ge4d^{-9}$. Both lower bounds are at least $1/(8d^9)$, which proves \eqref{eq:rad-eq-rm1}. \step{2: the travel angle} With $t=e^{-X}$ we have $\rho=A(t-t_-)(t_+-t)$, where $t_-+t_+=1$ and $t_-t_+=B/A$, and $dX=-dt/t$. The substitution $t=c+h\cos\xi$ with $c=\tfrac12$ and $c^2-h^2=B/A$ gives the elementary integral \[ \int_{t_-}^{t_+}\frac{\sqrt{(t-t_-)(t_+-t)}}{t}\,dt =\pi\bigl(c-\sqrt{c^2-h^2}\bigr), \] and \eqref{eq:rad-eq-rm2} follows. \step{3: the small divisors} We have $kT/\pi=k/(2\sqrt d)$. If $k<\sqrt d$, its distance to $\Z$ is $k/(2\sqrt d)$ itself. Otherwise let $m$ be the nearest integer; factoring the nonzero integer $k^2-4dm^2$ and using $2m\sqrt d\le2k$ gives a distance of at least $1/(6k\sqrt d)$. In both cases $|\sin(\pi x)|\ge2\dist(x,\Z)$ yields \eqref{eq:rad-eq-morse-small-divisor}. \end{proof} Thus a single choice of parameters gives, for one Morse model on the whole line, both of the separations of Section~\ref{sec:worked-example}: a spectral gap and a Diophantine travel angle. They remain different conditions when models are joined. A junction does not change any travel angle, since it adds only positive intervals; but it can create a new matching resonance. That remaining issue is resolved by the choice of amplitudes in the next section.