\section{From an annular height to a flexible sphere} \label{sec:geometric-closure} This section proves that Theorem~\ref{thm:annulus-intro} implies Theorem~\ref{thm:main}. It uses no analysis beyond the classical theory of surfaces, and it fixes exactly what the remaining sections have to construct. The steps are as follows. \begin{itemize} \item An isometric embedding with prescribed height $z$ exists locally if and only if the remainder metric $g-dz\otimes dz$ is positive and flat (Lemma~\ref{lem:darboux-invariant}). \item On a disk whose rim is planar, a positive flat remainder metric develops onto a round disk, and the development is the identity near the rim (Proposition~\ref{lem:disk-development}). \item The resulting graph is closed by a cap which carries a marker (Lemma~\ref{lem:fixed-cap}). \item Turning the graph inside the cap gives the family of Theorem~\ref{thm:main} (Theorem~\ref{thm:geometric-closure}). \end{itemize} \subsection{Setting} Throughout the section $0=Stealth,font=\small] \begin{scope} \filldraw[fill=blue!6,draw=black] (0,0) circle (1.65); \filldraw[fill=green!12,draw=green!45!black] (0,0) circle (.58); \draw[dashed] (0,0) circle (1.42); \draw[->] (0,0)--(1.25,.55) node[right] {$r$}; \node[below,align=center] at (0,-1.9) {intrinsic disk\\metric $g-dz\otimes dz$}; \end{scope} \draw[->,thick] (2.1,0)--(3.9,0) node[midway,above] {$P$}; \node[align=center] at (3,-.65) {flat,\\no holonomy}; \begin{scope}[xshift=6cm] \filldraw[fill=blue!6,draw=black] (0,0) circle (1.65); \filldraw[fill=green!12,draw=green!45!black] (0,0) circle (.58); \draw[dashed] (0,0) circle (1.42); \draw[->] (.1,.1) arc[start angle=45,end angle=210,radius=.25]; \node at (0,.95) {$P=\id$ near the rim}; \node[below,align=center] at (0,-1.9) {planar image:\\the same round disk}; \end{scope} \end{tikzpicture} \caption{The development $P$. Filling the inner collar removes the holonomy of the annulus; the normalization fixes the outer collar; the half-turn symmetry keeps the inner disk centred, so that $P$ only rotates it. Properness upgrades the local development to a diffeomorphism. The sketch records these constraints, not the pointwise distortion of $P$.} \label{fig:development} \end{figure} \subsection{A stationary cap which distinguishes shapes} The graph of Proposition~\ref{lem:disk-development} is horizontal near its boundary, so it can be closed by a cap. A rotationally symmetric cap would hide the relative rotation: the closed surfaces obtained for different $\tau$ would be congruent. We therefore put on the cap a marker which is recognized by every congruence. \begin{lemma}[The marked cap]\label{lem:fixed-cap} Let $S_0$ be a smooth graph over $D_{r_+}$ which is horizontal near its boundary. Then $S_0$ extends to a smooth embedded sphere $S_0\cup S_1$. The complementary cap $S_1$ can be chosen so that, for any given constant $K_{\max}$, it contains a point $p$ with \[ K(p)>K_{\max},\qquad K(p)>K(p')\ \text{ for every other point }p' \text{ of }S_1, \] and with distinct principal curvatures at $p$. \end{lemma} We shall take $K_{\max}$ to be the maximum of the Gaussian curvature of $S_0$. Then $p$ is the unique point of the closed surface at which the Gaussian curvature is largest. \begin{proof} \step{1: the unmarked cap} Translate so that the boundary height is zero, and extend the horizontal collar to a radius $R>r_+$. Choose a smooth nondecreasing function $\chi:[0,1]\to[0,1]$ which is $0$ near $0$, is $1$ near $1$, and satisfies $\chi(1-t)=1-\chi(t)$. For $L>0$ consider the unit-speed meridian curve $s\mapsto(r(s),z(s))$, $0\le s\le L$, which starts at $(R,0)$ and satisfies \[ r'(s)=\cos(\pi\chi(s/L)),\qquad z'(s)=-\sin(\pi\chi(s/L)). \] Its tangent turns from the outward horizontal direction to the inward one. By the symmetry of $\chi$ the curve stays at radius at least $R$ and returns to radius $R$, and its height decreases by a positive constant times $L$. Take $L$ so large that the curve ends below the minimum of the graph $S_0$, and complete it by the horizontal segment from its endpoint to the axis. Rotating this meridian gives a smooth embedded surface which meets $S_0$ only along the attaching collar. \step{2: the marker} Place a bump in the horizontal annulus $r_+0$ with $A\ne B$, and $k,\rho>0$; put $\xi=Ax^2+By^2$ and \[ u(x,y)=\frac{k}{2}\int_\xi^{\rho^2} e^{-s/(\rho^2-s)}\,ds\quad(\xi<\rho^2), \qquad u=0\quad(\xi\ge\rho^2). \] This function is smooth. With $\Xi=\xi/(\rho^2-\xi)$ one computes $u_x=-kAx\,e^{-\Xi}$ and $u_y=-kBy\,e^{-\Xi}$, and the Gaussian curvature of the graph of $u$ is \begin{equation}\label{eq:marker-curvature} K=\frac{ABk^2e^{-2\Xi}\,(1-2\xi\,\Xi')} {\bigl[1+k^2e^{-2\Xi}(A^2x^2+B^2y^2)\bigr]^2}, \qquad \Xi'=\frac{d\Xi}{d\xi}>0 . \end{equation} At the centre $K=ABk^2$. At every other point of the support the numerator is either nonpositive or strictly smaller than $ABk^2$, and the denominator is at least one. So the centre $p$ is the unique maximum of $K$ on the bump, with value $ABk^2$. First choose $k$ so that $ABk^2$ exceeds both $K_{\max}$ and the curvature of the unmarked cap. Then choose $\rho$ so small that the support $\{\xi<\rho^2\}$ fits inside the horizontal annulus; the bump has height at most $k\rho^2/2$ and does not meet the rest of the surface. At $p$ the gradient of $u$ vanishes and its Hessian is $\diag(-kA,-kB)$, so the principal curvatures are $-kA$ and $-kB$ for the upward normal. They are distinct. \end{proof} \begin{figure}[htbp] \centering \begin{tikzpicture}[x=.8cm,y=.8cm,>=Stealth,font=\small] \draw[thick,blue!70!black] (-3.3,0)--(-2.8,0) .. controls (-2.5,.1) and (-2.5,.9) .. (-1.5,.75) .. controls (-1,.65) and (-.8,.65) .. (-.5,.65)--(.5,.65) .. controls (.8,.65) and (1,.65) .. (1.5,.75) .. controls (2.5,.9) and (2.5,.1) .. (2.8,0)--(3.3,0); \draw[thick,gray!75] (3.3,0)--(4,0) .. controls (5.5,0) and (5.5,-2) .. (4,-2)--(-4,-2) .. controls (-5.5,-2) and (-5.5,0) .. (-4,0)--(-3.3,0); \fill[red!75!black] (3.7,0) circle (2.5pt); \draw[dashed,gray] (-2.8,0)--(-2.8,-2); \draw[dashed,gray] (2.8,0)--(2.8,-2); \node[above] at (0,1.4) {constant inner disk}; \draw[->] (0,1.3)--(0,.7); \node[above] at (-3.3,.3) {flat collar}; \node[above] at (3.8,.65) {marker}; \draw[->,red!75!black] (3.8,.6)--(3.7,.1); \node[below] at (0,-2.1) {fixed cap, below the entire moving graph}; \end{tikzpicture} \caption{A meridional sketch of the closed surface. The blue graph depends on the angle; all its rotated copies stay inside the central cylinder and above the bottom of the cap. The marker lies in the stationary horizontal extension of the collar.} \label{fig:geometric-closure} \end{figure} \subsection{The annulus implies the theorem} \begin{theorem}[Geometric closure]\label{thm:geometric-closure} Let $g$ be a metric of the form \eqref{eq:intro-metric} and let $z$ be a smooth function on the annulus. Suppose that \begin{enumerate} \item $w=0$ on open collars of both ends, and $z$ is constant on each of these collars; \item $z(r,\theta+\pi)=z(r,\theta)$, and $z$ is not independent of $\theta$; \item $g-dz\otimes dz$ is positive definite and flat. \end{enumerate} Then all the conclusions of Theorem~\ref{thm:main} hold. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} \step{1: the family} Let $P$ and $F=(P,z)$ be given by Proposition~\ref{lem:disk-development}, and attach to the graph $F(D_{r_+})$ the marked cap of Lemma~\ref{lem:fixed-cap}, with $K_{\max}$ the maximum of the Gaussian curvature of $F(D_{r_+})$. Let $\Sigma$ be the resulting sphere, with its induced metric $g_\Sigma$. On the disk put \[ F_\tau=R_{-2\pi\tau}\circ F\circ\varrho_{2\pi\tau},\qquad \varrho_\vartheta(r,\theta)=(r,\theta+\vartheta), \] and let $F_\tau$ be the inclusion on the cap. The intrinsic rotation $\varrho_\vartheta$ preserves $g$, so each $F_\tau$ is isometric on the disk. On the outer collar $F(x)=(x,c_R)$, and on the inner disk $F(x)=(R_\gamma x,c_L)$; in both cases the two rotations cancel and $F_\tau=F$. Hence $F_\tau$ agrees with the inclusion near the rim and is smooth on $\Sigma$, jointly in the point and in $\tau$, and $F_{\tau+1}=F_\tau$. The image $F_\tau(D_{r_+})=R_{-2\pi\tau}F(D_{r_+})$ is a graph over the same round disk with the same range of heights, so it meets the cap only along the collar: $F_\tau$ is an embedding. The inner disk and the cap are fixed pointwise. \step{2: the disk images are not all equal} Suppose $R_\vartheta F(D_{r_+})=F(D_{r_+})$ for every $\vartheta$. Then $F^{-1}\circ R_\vartheta\circ F$ is an isometry of $(D_{r_+},g)$, and on the outer collar it equals $\varrho_\vartheta$. An isometry of a connected Riemannian manifold is determined by its value and differential at one point, so $F^{-1}R_\vartheta F=\varrho_\vartheta$ on the whole disk. Comparing the vertical components of $R_\vartheta F=F\varrho_\vartheta$ gives $z(r,\theta+\vartheta)=z(r,\theta)$ for all $\vartheta$, contrary to assumption~(ii). \step{3: the closed images are not all congruent} The Gaussian curvature of $F_\tau(\Sigma)$ is determined by $g_\Sigma$, so by the choice of the marker the point $p$ is, for every $\tau$, the unique point of $F_\tau(\Sigma)$ of largest Gaussian curvature; it lies on the cap and is the same point of $\R^3$ for all $\tau$. Let $\Phi$ be a Euclidean isometry mapping $F_0(\Sigma)$ onto $F_\tau(\Sigma)$. It preserves the Gaussian curvature, so $\Phi(p)=p$. It maps the bounded component of the complement to the bounded component, so it preserves the outward normal at $p$, and then it preserves each of the two principal directions at $p$, which are well defined because the principal curvatures are distinct and which are the same for all $\tau$ because the cap is fixed. There are at most four such isometries. Thus, if all the images were congruent, the family $\tau\mapsto F_\tau(\Sigma)$ would be a continuous family of compact sets taking values in a finite set, hence constant. The part of $F_\tau(\Sigma)$ inside the closed cylinder over $D_{r_+}$ and above the bottom of the cap is $F_\tau(D_{r_+})$, so the disk images would all be equal, which Step~2 excludes. \step{4: the invariants} The area is constant because the metric is. The moving part $F_\tau(D_{r_+})$ is a rotated copy of $F(D_{r_+})$ and the rest of the surface is stationary, so the integral of the oriented mean curvature is constant. Finally let $Z_\tau$ be the height of $F_\tau(D_{r_+})$ as a graph over $D_{r_+}$, and let $c_B$ be the height of the bottom of the cap. The part of the enclosed volume inside the cylinder over $D_{r_+}$ is \[ \int_{D_{r_+}}(Z_\tau(y)-c_B)\,dy =\int_{D_{r_+}}(Z_0(R_{2\pi\tau}y)-c_B)\,dy =\int_{D_{r_+}}(Z_0(y)-c_B)\,dy, \] and the remaining volume is bounded by the stationary part of the surface. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof that Theorem~\ref{thm:annulus-intro} implies Theorem~\ref{thm:main}] Let $w$ and $z$ be as in Theorem~\ref{thm:annulus-intro}. Extend $w$ by zero and $z$ by its two limiting constants to a slightly larger annulus. The extended functions are smooth, and on the added collars $g-dz\otimes dz=g$ is Euclidean, hence positive and flat. All the hypotheses of Theorem~\ref{thm:geometric-closure} hold. \end{proof} What remains is therefore precise: construct one nonradial height on an annulus with a positive flat remainder metric and with constant extensions at both ends. The family of embeddings then follows without any further existence argument.