\documentclass[11pt]{amsart} \usepackage{amssymb,amsmath} \usepackage[margin=1in]{geometry} \usepackage{enumitem} \usepackage{xcolor} \usepackage{longtable} \usepackage{hyperref} \hypersetup{hidelinks, pdftitle={Improving Razmyslov's (1974) bound: the Nagata-Higman index is at most n\textasciicircum 2-2 for n>=3, and other miscellanea}, pdfauthor={Dave Goel}} \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary} \newtheorem{conjecture}[theorem]{Conjecture} \newtheorem{mainthm}{Theorem} \renewcommand{\themainthm}{\Alph{mainthm}} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition} \newtheorem{problem}[theorem]{Problem} \theoremstyle{remark} \newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark} \newcommand{\sgn}{\operatorname{sgn}} \newcommand{\End}{\operatorname{End}} \newcommand{\Res}{\operatorname{Res}} \newcommand{\Stab}{\operatorname{Stab}} \newcommand{\Sym}{\operatorname{Sym}} \newcommand{\tr}{\operatorname{tr}} \newcommand{\Arc}{\operatorname{Arc}} \setlength{\emergencystretch}{3em} \title[The Nagata--Higman index is at most $n^2-2$]{Improving Razmyslov's (1974) bound:\\ the Nagata--Higman index is at most $n^2-2$ for $n\ge3$,\\ and other miscellanea} \author{Dave Goel} \email{david44hello@gmail.com} \subjclass[2020]{Primary 16R10; Secondary 16N40, 20C30} \keywords{Nagata--Higman theorem, nil algebras, nilpotency index, Kuzmin's conjecture, polynomial identities, symmetric group} \date{October 27, 2026} \dedicatory{\normalfont\footnotesize Version 1.86, October 27, 2026.} \begin{document} \begin{abstract} Let $d(n)$ be the least $m$ such that every associative algebra over a field of characteristic zero satisfying $x^n=0$ also satisfies $x_1x_2\cdots x_m=0$ (the Nagata--Higman index). Razmyslov proved $d(n)\le n^2$ in 1974, and the Kuzmin (1975) conjecture is $d(n)=n(n+1)/2$. We prove $d(n)\le n^2-1$ for $n\ge2$ and $d(n)\le n^2-2$ for $n\ge3$; in particular $d(6)\le34$. The proof uses Formanek's criterion in cycle form and studies, one isotypic block of $S_N$ at a time, the span of the $N$-cycles inside the block: a block with two corners meets this span exactly when its shape is a self-conjugate hook, and for every $k\ge2$ the block of $(k+1,2,1^{k-1})$, which has three corners, meets it too. The next step, $d(n)\le n^2-3$, reduces to one statement about the block of $(n^{n-2},n-1,n-2)$; for every $n\ge4$ we prove the part of it that concerns the constituents with at most two rows of length $3$, and for $n=5$ the whole statement (computer-assisted). Through the hook theorem the question becomes one about the polynomial identities of Kemer's superalgebras $M_{k,l}$ over the Grassmann algebra: lower bounds for their PI degrees give upper bounds for $d(n)$, and the lower half of the Samoilov (2010) conjecture on these PI degrees would give $d(n)<\frac89n^2$ for $n\ge3$. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} Let $d(n)$ be the Nagata--Higman index of nil algebras of index $n$ in characteristic zero (defined in Subsection~\ref{subsec:NH}). Below, $\lambda\vdash N$, $C_N$ is the span of the $N$-cycles in $F[S_N]$, $I_\lambda$ is the isotypic block of $\lambda$ and $U_\lambda:=C_N\cap I_\lambda$; $\operatorname{PIdeg}$ is the least degree of a polynomial identity, here of Kemer's superalgebras $M_{k,l}(\Lambda)$ over the Grassmann algebra $\Lambda$ (Section~\ref{sec:PI}). Our main results, each with the best result before this paper: {\footnotesize \renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1.1} \begin{longtable}{|p{0.46\textwidth}|p{0.43\textwidth}|} \hline \textbf{New result} & \textbf{Best result before this paper}\\ \hline \endfirsthead \hline \textbf{New result} (continued) & \textbf{Best result before this paper}\\ \hline \endhead $d(n)\le n^2-2$ for every $n\ge3$ (Theorems~\ref{thm:A}, \ref{thm:B}) & $d(n)\le n^2$ (Razmyslov 1974 \cite{Ra74}), still called the best known upper bound in 2022 \cite{Ro22}\\ \hline $d(6)\le34$ & $d(6)\le36$ \cite{Ra74}; Higman's recursion gives $43$ \cite{Hi56}, from $d(5)\le21$\\ \hline The images of the star elements, the conjugates of the Jucys--Murphy element $J_N$, generate $\End(S^\lambda)$ for every $\lambda\vdash N$ with at least two removable corners (Theorem~\ref{thm:C}) & None known to us; $J_1,\dots,J_N$ generate only the commutative Gelfand--Tsetlin algebra \cite{OV96}\\ \hline A block with two corners meets the span $C_N$ of the $N$-cycles if and only if $\lambda$ is a self-conjugate hook (Theorem~\ref{thm:D}) & No classification known to us; the self-conjugate hooks meet $C_N$ (standard polynomial; cf.\ Kostant \cite{Ko58}), and $(3,3,2)$ does not, as $M_{1,2}(\Lambda)$ has no identity of degree $8$ (Vishne \cite{Vi02}; Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer})\\ \hline The blocks $(k+1,2,1^{k-1})$, $k\ge2$, with three corners, meet $C_N$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Dthree}; one finite computation) & For $k=2$, $(3,2,1)$: classical ($[[x_1,x_2]^2,x_1]$ is Hall's identity of $M_2(F)$ and one of Popov's identities of $M_{1,1}(\Lambda)$ \cite{Po82}; Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer}); no infinite family known to us\\ \hline Every staircase block $\mathrm{St}_m=(m,m-1,\dots,1)$, $m\ge2$, meets $C_N$; equivalently $\operatorname{PIdeg}\bigl(\bigoplus_{k+l=m-1}M_{k,l}(\Lambda)\bigr)=m(m+1)/2-1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:staircase}) & Kuzmin's element behind $d(n)\ge n(n+1)/2$ \cite{Ku75}, not known to lie in a single block; for $m\le3$ classical (Amitsur--Levitzki \cite{AL50}; Hall and Popov \cite{Po82})\\ \hline $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{k,l}(\Lambda))\ge(k+1)(2l-k+1)$ for $1\le k\le l$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:PIresults}(d)) & $(k+1)(l+1)-1$, from the hook theorem \cite{BR87}\\ \hline The Samoilov (2010) conjecture holds for $M_{2,2}(\Lambda)$: $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))=14$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:samoilov22}, computer-assisted) & $9\le\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))\le14$: $9$ because the subalgebra $M_{1,2}(\Lambda)$ has no identity of degree $8$ (Vishne \cite{Vi02}), $14$ by Samoilov \cite{Sa10}; exact values were known for $M_{1,1}(\Lambda)$ ($5$, Popov \cite{Po82}) and $M_{1,2}(\Lambda)$ ($9$, Vishne \cite{Vi02,Vi11})\\ \hline For $n\ge3$: $d(n)\le n^2-3$ follows from one block statement, $U_{B(n,2)}=0$ with $B(n,2)=(n^{n-2},n-1,n-2)$, true for $n=4,5$ (through $d(4)=10$ \cite{VL93}); $d(n)\le n^2-k-1$, $k\le5$, from finitely many (Theorems~\ref{thm:E}, \ref{thm:F}) & Formanek's criterion \cite[Thm.~5]{Fo90} involves all blocks of the box jointly; no reduction to single blocks known to us\\ \hline On $B(n,2)$, $n\ge4$, $N=n^2-3$: the kernel $K_{B(n,2)}$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bdepth}) has no conjugation type with at most two columns, and every type of depth at most $n-1$ or with at most two rows of length $3$ is $(3,1^{N-3})$, once (by hand up to finite exact computations); partial results on the deeper types (Section~\ref{sec:Bn2}) & None; the block and its kernel are introduced here\\ \hline If the lower half of the Samoilov (2010) conjecture holds for $M_{a,b}(\Lambda)$, $b-a\le1$, then $d(n)<\frac89n^2$ for $n\ge3$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:H}) & No link between these PI degrees and $d(n)$ known to us\\ \hline \end{longtable}} \emph{In more detail}, each with its place in the literature: {\small \begin{itemize}[leftmargin=*, itemsep=1pt, topsep=3pt] \item $d(n)\le n^2-2$ for every $n\ge3$ (Theorems~\ref{thm:A} and~\ref{thm:B}); to our knowledge, the first improvement for general $n$ of Razmyslov's bound $d(n)\le n^2$ of 1974 \cite{Ra74}. In particular $d(6)\le34$. \item The images of the star elements, the conjugates of the Jucys--Murphy element $J_N$ \cite{Ju74,Mu81}, generate $\End(S^\lambda)$ whenever $\lambda$ has at least two removable corners (Theorem~\ref{thm:C}). \item A block with two corners meets the span of the $N$-cycles only for the self-conjugate hooks, and there in the image of the standard polynomial (Theorem~\ref{thm:D} and Lemma~\ref{lem:H}; cf.\ Kostant \cite{Ko58}); an infinite family of blocks with three corners meets it (Theorem~\ref{thm:Dthree}, through the Amitsur--Levitzki theorem \cite{AL50} and one finite computation). \item Every staircase block meets the span of the $N$-cycles (Theorem~\ref{thm:staircase}): the element behind Kuzmin's lower bound $d(n)\ge n(n+1)/2$ \cite{Ku75} lies in a single block. \item Steps toward the Kuzmin (1975) conjecture $d(n)=n(n+1)/2$ \cite{Ku75}: for $n\ge3$, $d(n)\le n^2-3$ follows from the single statement $U_{B(n,2)}=0$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:E}), which holds for $n=4,5$ (through $d(4)=10$ \cite{VL93}); and $d(n)\le n^2-k-1$, $k\le5$, follows from finitely many block statements (Theorem~\ref{thm:F}). \item On the first open block $B(n,2)$, for every $n\ge4$: its kernel has no conjugation type with at most two columns, and every type of depth at most $n-1$ or with at most two rows of length $3$ is $(3,1^{N-3})$, and it occurs once (Section~\ref{sec:Bn2}; by hand up to finite exact computations). In its layers $b=3$ ($a\le(n^2-3)/2$) and $b=4$ ($4\le a\le(n^2-4)/2$), no eigenvector of the pencil at $\kappa=n$ has $y$-order $1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Aone}, Corollary~\ref{cor:Aonefour}; finitely many cases computed); no earlier result of this kind is known to us. At $b=3$ and $\kappa=n$, no $\varphi_f$ with $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$, $\tau=(n^2-a-3,a,3)$, $3\le a\le(n^2-3)/2$, has $y$-order $0$ either (Theorem~\ref{thm:Azero}); with Theorem~\ref{thm:EO}, $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau=0$ on the whole layer $b=3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Lthree}; new in type form for $n\ge7$ and $a\ge n-1$, and for $n=4,5,6$ a second proof of results computed here). \item A transfer from the polynomial identities of Kemer's superalgebras \cite{Ke91}: the lower half of the Samoilov (2010) conjecture \cite{Sa10} would give $d(n)<\frac89n^2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:H}); and Samoilov's conjectured value $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))=14$ holds (Theorem~\ref{thm:samoilov22}, computer-assisted). \end{itemize}} \subsection{The Nagata--Higman theorem}\label{subsec:NH} Let $F$ be a field of characteristic zero. Dubnov and Ivanov \cite{DI43}, Nagata \cite{Na52} and Higman \cite{Hi56} proved that a nil algebra of bounded index is nilpotent: for every $n$ there is a number $m$ such that every associative (not necessarily unital) $F$-algebra satisfying $x^n=0$ for all $x$ also satisfies $x_1x_2\cdots x_m=0$ for all $x_1,\dots,x_m$. The theorem is also called the Dubnov--Ivanov--Nagata--Higman theorem \cite[\S5]{Dr23}; Higman's proof gives $m=2^n-1$. The least such $m$ is the \emph{Nagata--Higman index} $d(n)$. Equivalently, $d(n)$ is the least $m$ such that $x_1\cdots x_m$ lies in the T-ideal of the free algebra generated by $x^n$ \cite[\S1.3]{Ro22}; this is the form we use (Section~\ref{sec:criterion}). \subsection{Bounds and known values}\label{subsec:bounds} Razmyslov \cite[final remark]{Ra74} proved $d(n)\le n^2$, using the trace identities of the matrix algebra $M_n(F)$ and the Cayley--Hamilton theorem. Procesi \cite{Pr76} and Formanek \cite{Fo86,Fo87,Fo91} connected $d(n)$ with the degrees of generators of the invariants of several $n\times n$ matrices; see \cite[Thm.~5.6]{Dr23}. In the other direction, Kuzmin \cite{Ku75} proved $d(n)\ge n(n+1)/2$, by the word $x_2x_1x_2x_1^2\cdots x_2x_1^{n-1}$ (of degree $n(n+1)/2-1$, which does not lie in the T-ideal of $x^n$) (see \cite[Thm.~1.7]{Do18}), and Kuzmin conjectured that $d(n)=n(n+1)/2$. The exact values $d(1)=1$, $d(2)=3$ and $d(3)=6$ are classical (Dubnov \cite{Du35}, see \cite{Dr23}; for $n=3$ also Higman \cite{Hi56}), and $d(4)=10$ was computed by Vaughan-Lee \cite{VL93} with a computer. An independent computation (ranks of the relevant matrices modulo two primes; Appendix~\ref{app:dfour}) confirms $d(4)\le10$, and so $d(4)=10$ by Kuzmin's bound. Higman's argument gives $d(n)\le2d(n-1)+1$ \cite{Hi56} (the same recursion, for characteristic $p>n$, appears in \cite[proof of Lemma~4.4]{Lo12}); with $d(4)=10$ this gives $d(5)\le21$. For $n=5$, Shestakov and Zhukavets \cite{SZ04}, using Vaughan-Lee's reduction \cite{VL98} to superalgebras with at most $5$ generators, confirmed Kuzmin's conjecture for $2$-generator superalgebras satisfying $x^5=0$ (they are nilpotent of degree $15$). To our knowledge, in characteristic zero the bound $n^2$ has not been improved since 1974 for general $n$. Drensky \cite{Dr23} gives $n(n+1)/2\le d(n)\le n^2$ as ``the best known bounds'', Romano \cite[\S1.3]{Ro22} writes that $n^2$ ``to this day remains the best known upper bound'', and Procesi \cite[Thm.~5.14]{Pr26}, stating Razmyslov's degree bound $n^2$ for the matrix invariants, calls it ``at the moment the best result''. (For positive characteristic and for finitely generated nil algebras see Klein \cite{Kl00} and Domokos \cite{Do18}.) \subsection{Results} \begin{mainthm}\label{thm:A} For every $n\ge2$, $d(n)\le n^2-1$. \end{mainthm} \begin{mainthm}\label{thm:B} For every $n\ge3$, $d(n)\le n^2-2$. \end{mainthm} Theorems~\ref{thm:A} and~\ref{thm:B} improve Razmyslov's bound $d(n)\le n^2$ of 1974 \cite{Ra74}, which, to our knowledge, had not been improved for general $n$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:bounds}). Once Formanek's criterion is available, the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:A} is short (Lemma~\ref{lem:onecorner}), but we have not found Theorem~\ref{thm:A} in print. With Kuzmin's bound, $n(n+1)/2\le d(n)\le n^2-2$ for $n\ge3$. Since $d(n)$ is known for $n\le4$, and $d(5)\le21$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:bounds}), the new values begin at $n=6$: $d(6)\le34$ (Higman's recursion gives $d(6)\le43$). The remaining results concern single isotypic blocks. For $\lambda\vdash N$ let $I_\lambda\subseteq F[S_N]$ be the isotypic block of $\lambda$, let $C_N$ be the span of the $N$-cycles, and put $U_\lambda:=C_N\cap I_\lambda$. Let $K_\lambda$ be the set of elements of $I_\lambda$ whose coefficient vanishes on every permutation with a fixed point; $K_\lambda\supseteq U_\lambda$ for $N\ge2$. The \emph{star elements} are $X^{(j)}:=\sum_{i\ne j}(i\,j)\in F[S_N]$, $1\le j\le N$. \begin{mainthm}\label{thm:C} Let $\lambda\vdash N$ have at least two removable corners. Then the operators $\rho_\lambda(X^{(j)})$, $1\le j\le N$, generate $\End(S^\lambda)$ as a unital algebra; equivalently, only the scalars commute with all of them. (If $\lambda$ is a rectangle, every $\rho_\lambda(X^{(j)})$ is a scalar.) \end{mainthm} The star element $X^{(N)}$ is the Jucys--Murphy element $J_N=\sum_{i1$, then $d(n)\le\bigl(1-\bigl(\frac{\gamma-1}{\gamma+1}\bigr)^2+o(1)\bigr)n^2$; \item if the lower half of Samoilov's conjecture holds for the algebras $M_{a,b}(\Lambda)$ with $b-a\le1$, then for every $n\ge3$, $d(n)\le n^2-\lfloor(n+2)/3\rfloor\lfloor(n+4)/3\rfloor$, which is less than $\frac89n^2$. \end{enumerate} \end{mainthm} We prove $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{a,a}(\Lambda))\ge(a+1)^2$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:PIresults}(d); its order $(a+1)^2-1$ is classical, by the hook theorem, and (d) adds $1$); this is the constant $\gamma=1$ and gives only Theorem~\ref{thm:A}. At $a=2$ a computer-assisted computation gives Samoilov's value $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))=14$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:samoilov22}), so the Samoilov (2010) conjecture holds for $a=b=2$; it gives no new bound on $d(n)$. Samoilov's theorem gives $\gamma\le2$, and Samoilov's conjecture is $\gamma=2$. So any constant $\gamma>1$ in a lower bound would give a saving quadratic in $n$. By Samoilov's theorem and Lemma~\ref{lem:reach}, for $n\ge3$ no single algebra $M_{a,b}(\Lambda)$ gives more than (b) through Theorem~\ref{thm:H}, and no argument through one shape can give more (Corollary~\ref{cor:ceiling}). The last statement rests on the staircases $\mathrm{St}_m=(m,m-1,\dots,1)$: every staircase block meets the span of the $N$-cycles, that is, $U_{\mathrm{St}_m}\ne0$ for every $m\ge2$, or equivalently $\operatorname{PIdeg}\bigl(\bigoplus_{k+l=m-1}M_{k,l}(\Lambda)\bigr)=m(m+1)/2-1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:staircase}). The element we use is the one behind Kuzmin's lower bound \cite{Ku75}; what is new, as far as we know, is that it lies in a single block. For the first open block $B(n,2)$, $n\ge4$ (Section~\ref{sec:Bn2}), and for the block $\lambda(3,1,1)$ of statement~(iii) in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:F} (Section~\ref{sec:L311}) we prove the partial results listed below. For $B(n,2)$ only the types with three columns, $\kappa'_3\ge3$ and depth at least $n$ remain open, and only for $n\ge6$ (for $n=4$ and $n=5$, $U_{B(n,2)}=0$ holds, see Theorem~\ref{thm:E}; for $n=5$ the whole kernel is computed, with a computer-assisted step, Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfive}). \subsection*{What is proved, what is computer-assisted, and what is open} For the reader's convenience we list the status of the main statements. ``By hand'' means that no step uses a computer; the finite exact computations used by items of (a) are named there. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item \emph{Proved by hand.} $d(n)\le n^2-1$ for $n\ge2$ and $d(n)\le n^2-2$ for $n\ge3$ (Theorems~\ref{thm:A} and~\ref{thm:B}); the star elements (Theorem~\ref{thm:C}); the blocks with two corners (Theorem~\ref{thm:D}); the staircase blocks (Theorem~\ref{thm:staircase}); the reductions of Theorems~\ref{thm:E} and~\ref{thm:F} and Corollary~\ref{cor:program}; the Casimir criterion (Theorems~\ref{thm:casimir} and~\ref{thm:jointkernel}); the PI dictionary and the transfer (Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer}, Theorem~\ref{thm:H}, Proposition~\ref{prop:PIresults}(a), (d)). For the first open block $B(n,2)$ and every $n\ge4$: $K_{B(n,2)}$ has no conjugation type with at most two columns (Corollary~\ref{cor:firstlayer}(b)), and every type of depth at most $n-1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}) or with $\kappa'_3\le2$, that is, with at most two rows of length $3$ (Corollaries~\ref{cor:steptwo} and~\ref{cor:Peven}, and Corollary~\ref{cor:Lthree} for $\kappa'_3=2$), is $(3,1^{N-3})$, and it occurs once; Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}, and through it Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}, also use the small exact computations of step (e) in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} (three matrices, of sizes $9$, $44$, $265$) and of Theorem~\ref{thm:Bwindow}(a) (one rank, on $120$ unknowns). Corollary~\ref{cor:Lthree} uses the finite exact computations named in Remark~\ref{rem:Azero}(2): the certificate of Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroSzero} (over $\mathbb{Q}(x,\kappa)$), the translation equivariance in Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroCH}, the base levels of Theorem~\ref{thm:AzeroK}, Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroRW}, (A3) and the case $(4,6)$ in Part II, the three cases of Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2), and, for $n=4$, one exact rank computation. The finite-$n$ form of Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} holds for every $n$ at $b=2$ ($a\ge3$, $n\ge3$; Corollary~\ref{cor:Bzinj}) and at $b=3$ ($n\ge4$; Corollary~\ref{cor:Bthreezinj}); at every other layer $b$ with $3b\le n^2$ and every $n\ge3$ it is reduced to the part of degree $0$ in $y$ of its kernel vectors (Corollary~\ref{cor:Oone}). Every eigenvector of the pencil has $y$-order at most $2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:EO}), and $y$-order $2$ does not occur for $4\le b\le n+2$, nor for $b=n+3$ with $n\ge5$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:YOtwo}). In every layer $b\ge3$, the $y$-Hessian of an eigenvector of $y$-order $2$ has only monomials of full support (Corollary~\ref{cor:YOfull}). For $n\ge6$, $y$-order $2$ does not occur at $b=n+4$ either (Corollary~\ref{cor:YOnp2}). At $b=3$ and $\kappa=n$, $y$-order $1$ does not occur for $a\le(n^2-3)/2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Aone}; by hand except the three finite cases $(n,a)=(4,5),(4,6),(5,11)$, Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2)). At $b=4$ and $\kappa=n$, $y$-order $1$ does not occur for any $n\ge4$, so every eigenvector has $y$-order $0$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Aonefour}; by hand for $n\ge5$, and one finite computation for $n=4$). For the block $\lambda(3,1)$ of statement~(ii) in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:F} ($k=3$): six weights of its first layer for $n\ge6$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:L31}), and all its two-row types, at every depth, for $n\ge3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:tworow31}). \item \emph{Computer-assisted} (each step is an exact computation, described where it is used). The family of Theorem~\ref{thm:Dthree} (one finite check of $1024$ cases), and through it Proposition~\ref{prop:PIresults}(b), (c); the hypothesis of Theorem~\ref{thm:E} for $n=4,5$ (through $d(4)=10$ \cite{VL93}); the independent check $d(4)\le10$ (Appendix~\ref{app:dfour}); the whole kernel $K_{B(5,2)}$, a single copy of $(3,1^{19})$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfive}); at $n=6$, $75$ of the $108$ possible conjugation types of $K_{B(6,2)}$, all with depth at most $12$ or $\kappa'_3\le4$: $74$ do not occur, and $(3,1^{30})$ occurs once (Theorem~\ref{thm:Ksixsix}); at $n=7$ and $n=8$ some types with $\kappa'_3\le1$, now contained in (a) (Corollaries~\ref{cor:Kseven} and~\ref{cor:Pone}); Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} at $b=4$ for every $n\ge5$ (one rank, Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfourcert}); for $\lambda(3,1,1)$, statement~(iii): no type of depth at most $n-3$ for $n\ge5$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:L311}(b), through the computer-assisted Theorem~\ref{thm:K}) and no two-row type, at every depth, for $n\ge3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:tworow311}); for $\lambda(3,1)$: no three- or four-row type of depth at most $4$, $5$, $6$ for $n\ge7$, $8$, $9$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:shallow31}); and $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))=14$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:samoilov22}). \item \emph{Open.} The types of $K_{B(n,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3\ge3$ and depth at least $n$, for $n\ge6$ (Problem~\ref{prob:Bdeep}); so $d(n)\le n^2-3$ for $n\ge6$, and in particular $d(6)\le33$, is open; at $n=6$, $33$ types remain. Also open: the rest of statements~(ii) and~(iii) for $\lambda(3,1)$ and $\lambda(3,1,1)$ (Problem~\ref{prob:kthree}) (with the hypothesis of Theorem~\ref{thm:E} they give $d(n)\le n^2-4$; Theorem~\ref{thm:F}, $k=3$), Conjecture~\ref{conj:B} beyond the cases above, Conjecture~\ref{conj:D}, the lower half of the Samoilov (2010) conjecture (Problem~\ref{prob:samoilov}(b)), and the Kuzmin (1975) conjecture itself. \end{enumerate} \subsection{Method} Our starting point is Formanek's criterion \cite[Thm.~5]{Fo90} (cf.\ \cite[final remark]{Ra74}, \cite[Thm.~3.3]{Pr76}, \cite{St89}), which we use in the following cycle form (Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion}): $d(n)\le m$ if and only if $C_{m+1}\cap B_n=0$, where $B_n$ is the sum of the blocks $I_\lambda$ over the partitions $\lambda\vdash m+1$ that fit in the $n\times n$ box. This is the nil analogue of the Helling--Razmyslov--Procesi description of the multilinear trace identities of matrix algebras \cite{He74,Ra74,Pr76} (see \cite[Thm.~5.7]{Dr23}). The sign automorphism $\sigma\mapsto\sgn(\sigma)\sigma$ acts on $C_N$ by a scalar and exchanges $I_\lambda$ and $I_{\lambda'}$, so $U_\lambda=0$ unless $\lambda=\lambda'$. On a block we restrict to $S_{N-1}$, where the Jucys--Murphy element $J_N$ acts by the contents of the removable corners \cite{Ju74,Mu81,OV96}, and we use the star elements. The elements that survive are controlled by Frobenius' theorem on the characters of the alternating group \cite[2.5.13]{JK81}, the theorem that Kostant \cite{Ko58} related to the Amitsur--Levitzki theorem \cite{AL50}; for a self-conjugate hook it is the main input to Lemma~\ref{lem:H}. The deletion map of the decoupling step is the trace map $p\mapsto\tr(p)$ of the Razmyslov--Procesi correspondence between elements of $F[S_N]$ and multilinear trace polynomials (cf.\ the canonical projection of Kerov, Olshanski and Vershik \cite{KOV93,KOV04}). In the background, the self-conjugate shapes in the $n\times n$ box are indexed by the subsets of $\{1,3,\dots,2n-1\}$ (Frobenius coordinates, \cite[I.1]{Ma95}), the degrees of the primitive classes of $\mathfrak{gl}_n$. A dual view is also useful: $K_\lambda=0$ if and only if the images $\rho_\lambda(F[\Stab(j)])$, $1\le j\le N$, of the point-stabilizer group algebras span $\End(S^\lambda)$ (for the trace form). \subsection{Organization} Section~\ref{sec:criterion} fixes the setting and proves Formanek's criterion in cycle form. Section~\ref{sec:A} proves Theorem~\ref{thm:A} and Section~\ref{sec:B} proves Theorem~\ref{thm:B}. Section~\ref{sec:blocks} treats single blocks and the star elements (Theorems~\ref{thm:C} and~\ref{thm:D}), the standard polynomials (Subsection~\ref{subsec:hooks}), and the component reduction and the deletion map used later (Subsection~\ref{subsec:deletion}). Section~\ref{sec:decoupling} restricts to $S_{N-1}$ and proves Theorems~\ref{thm:E} and~\ref{thm:F} (the decoupling step), and Section~\ref{sec:casimir} gives the Casimir criterion for the kernels $K_\lambda$. Section~\ref{sec:PI} is the bridge to PI degrees and proves Theorem~\ref{thm:H}. Section~\ref{sec:Bn2} studies the first open block $B(n,2)$: the part of each kernel $K_{\lambda(\nu)}$ near the sign representation is a finite problem that does not depend on $n$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:window}), and for $B(n,2)$, $n\ge4$, it is solved on every type of depth at most $n-1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}), and for $n=5$ on every type (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfive}, computer-assisted); Subsection~\ref{subsec:pencil} relates it to rectangles, Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer} solves the rectangle problem for $\tau_3=1$, and Subsection~\ref{subsec:secondlayer} for $\tau=(ns-5,3,2)$, $n\ge4$; Subsection~\ref{subsec:sorder} shows that a nonzero invariant function of bidegree $(a,b)$ killed by $\mathcal{E}$ lies in the $m$-th power of the ideal of the closure of $\{(X,Y):X\text{ regular},\ Y\in\operatorname{Im}\operatorname{ad}_X\}$ only for $m\le\lfloor a/4\rfloor$; Subsection~\ref{subsec:lowering} applies the lowering operator of $\mathfrak{gl}_3$ to the line of Theorem~\ref{thm:pencil22} and finds the eigenvalue $(a+3)/n$ of the pencil in bidegree $(a,2)$ for all $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+2$; Subsection~\ref{subsec:S12} shows that on the rectangle spaces either of the two tests alone cuts out the kernel, Subsection~\ref{subsec:mirror} proves the mirror symmetry $n\mapsto-n$ of the pencil at $b=2$, Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bzinj} proves Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} at $b=2$ and $a\ge3$ for every $n\ge3$; Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bthree} shows that at $b=3$, for every $n\ge4$, certain rows of $\mathcal{Z}$ at the points $(\operatorname{diag}(x),Z)$ with distinct $x_p$ and $Z$ off-diagonal (the slice rows) vanish on an element of $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,3)}(n)$ exactly when it does not depend on $Z$ at the points $(\operatorname{diag}(x),Z+\operatorname{diag}(y))$; with the rows at the points with $y\ne0$, the subsection then proves Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} at $b=3$; Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bfour} proves it at $b=4$ for every $n\ge5$ (one step computer-assisted); and Subsection~\ref{subsec:theta} shows that $\mu=0$ occurs, and for $n\ge a+2$ with multiplicity at least the number of partitions of $a$ into parts $\ge2$. Subsection~\ref{subsec:link} shows, by the linkage theorem of Bernstein, Gelfand and Gelfand, that an eigenvector in the $\mathfrak{gl}_3$-module generated by passing highest weight vectors of higher weight has $\mu\in\{0,3\}$ or comes from a smaller layer, and so reduces Conjecture~\ref{conj:L2}, by induction on $a$, to one principle. Subsections~\ref{subsec:oddrows} and~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} prove the conclusion of Conjecture~\ref{conj:L2} for every $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+6$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Ltwostable}); at $s=n$ this lies inside Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}. Subsection~\ref{subsec:Pone} shows, with a computer, that $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue at $b=2$ for odd $a$ at $18$ pairs $(n,a)$ with $4\le n\le8$ and $n\le a$; at $s=n$ these are types of depth $a\ge n$, beyond Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}; Subsection~\ref{subsec:Lfive} reduces the statement at $\kappa=n$, for every $n\ge4$ and every dominant $a\ge n$, to one step of that proof. Subsection~\ref{subsec:Kseven} shows, with a computer, that at $n=7$ the eigenvalue $\kappa=7$ does not occur at $b=2$ for any $3\le a\le23$; so every conjugation type $\kappa$ of $K_{B(7,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3\le1$ is $(3,1^{43})$. Subsection~\ref{subsec:steptwo} proves, by hand, at every $n$ and for odd $a$, the one step to which Subsection~\ref{subsec:Lfive} reduces the statement at $\kappa=n$; so $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue at $b=2$ for every $n\ge4$ and every odd $a$ with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$. Subsections~\ref{subsec:evena} and~\ref{subsec:triangle} do the same for even $a$, by hand: there step~(2) fails, and one more row, a triangle of order-one rows computed in closed form, takes its place; so, for every $n\ge4$, every conjugation type $\kappa$ of $K_{B(n,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3\le1$ is $(3,1^{N-3})$. Section~\ref{sec:L311} extends the matrix-pair model to every self-conjugate $\nu$ (one test, built from a grid of $rc$ rank-one matrices, for each outer corner $(r,c)$ of $\nu$ with $rc\le k$) and treats $\lambda(3,1,1)$; Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer311} proves three cases of the first layer for $\nu=(3,1,1)$ (Conjecture~\ref{conj:L1311}); Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer31} extends the corner dictionary to every $\nu$ (the tests are then the live corners of $\nu'$) and, for $n\ge6$, excludes from $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ the types of six weights of the first layer (Theorem~\ref{thm:L31}), a first step on statement (ii) of Theorem~\ref{thm:F}; Subsection~\ref{subsec:zinj31} shows that the leading term is injective on the column $(\tau_2,1,1)$, although its pointwise kernel is not $0$, and for $n\ge4$ excludes the two-row types of depth $1,\dots,n-3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:B31}); Subsection~\ref{subsec:L131} excludes all two-row types, at every depth and for every $n\ge3$, using only the tests at diagonal points (Corollary~\ref{cor:tworow31}); Subsection~\ref{subsec:shallow31}, by exact computer-assisted certificates, excludes the three- and four-row types of depth at most $4$ for $n\ge7$, at most $5$ for $n\ge8$ and at most $6$ for $n\ge9$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:shallow31}); and Subsection~\ref{subsec:L1311col} proves Conjecture~\ref{conj:L1311} on the column $(\tau_2,1,1,1)$ and excludes from $K_{\lambda(3,1,1)}$ the two-row types, at every depth and for every $n\ge3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:tworow311}; with exact symbolic identities checked by computer). Section~\ref{sec:open} collects what is known for small $n$ and the open problems, among them a conjecture on single blocks (Conjecture~\ref{conj:D}) that would give Kuzmin's conjecture block by block. \section{Setting and Formanek's criterion in cycle form}\label{sec:criterion} \subsection{Setting} Throughout, $F$ is a field of characteristic $0$, and $F\langle X\rangle$ is the free \emph{non-unitary} associative algebra on $X=\{x_1,x_2,\dots\}$. Its endomorphisms send each letter to a polynomial without constant term. For $n\ge1$ let $T:=(x^n)^T$ be the T-ideal generated by $x^n$ (the smallest ideal that contains $x^n$ and is closed under all endomorphisms), and \[ d(n):=\min\{m: x_1\cdots x_m\in T\}. \] Let $V_m$ be the space of multilinear polynomials in $x_1,\dots,x_m$ (its basis is the $m!$ words in which each of $x_1,\dots,x_m$ occurs once) and $W_{n,m}:=V_m\cap T$. We use the following standard facts. \begin{enumerate}[label=(F\arabic*),start=0,leftmargin=*] \item $d(n)\le m$ iff $x_1\cdots x_m\in T$ iff $W_{n,m}=V_m$. [$T$ is an ideal, and renaming the variables maps $x_1\cdots x_m$ onto every word of $V_m$; \cite[Prop.~1.8]{Ro22}.] \item \emph{Spanning set.} Let $L(y_1,\dots,y_n):=\sum_{\pi\in S_n}y_{\pi(1)}\cdots y_{\pi(n)}$. In characteristic $0$, $T=(L)^T$: $L$ is the multilinear component of $(y_1+\dots+y_n)^n$, so $L\in T$ (a T-ideal over an infinite field contains the multihomogeneous components of its elements), and $L(x,\dots,x)=n!\,x^n$. The T-ideal $(L)^T$ is spanned by the elements $p\cdot L(h_1,\dots,h_n)\cdot q$, where $p,q$ are monomials or $1$ and the $h_i$ have no constant term. Indeed, this span is an ideal, contains $L$, and is closed under every endomorphism of the non-unitary algebra ($\varphi$ maps $p\,L(h)\,q$ to $\varphi(p)\,L(\varphi(h_1),\dots,\varphi(h_n))\,\varphi(q)$; the $\varphi(h_i)$ have no constant term, and expanding $\varphi(p)$, $\varphi(q)$ into monomials puts this in the span). By multilinearity the $h_i$ may be taken to be monomials. Each such $p\cdot L(h)\cdot q$ is then multihomogeneous, so $V_m\cap T$ is spanned by the spanning elements of multidegree $(1,\dots,1)$. These are exactly the elements \[ a\cdot L(v_1,\dots,v_n)\cdot b,\qquad v_i \text{ nonempty words},\ a,b \text{ words or empty}, \] in which every letter $x_1,\dots,x_m$ occurs exactly once. \item \emph{Wedderburn and Young.} $F[S_N]=\bigoplus_{\lambda\vdash N}I_\lambda$ with $I_\lambda=F[S_N]e_\lambda$, where the element $e_\lambda=(f^\lambda/N!)\sum_\sigma\chi_\lambda(\sigma)\sigma$ is a central primitive idempotent and $f^\lambda=\dim S^\lambda$; $\rho_\lambda$ restricts to an isomorphism $I_\lambda\cong\End(S^\lambda)$. Each $I_\lambda$ is a simple algebra. The Specht modules are defined over $\mathbb{Q}$ and are absolutely irreducible. Writing $a(\sigma)$ for the coefficient of $\sigma$ in $a$, Fourier inversion reads \[ a(\sigma)=\sum_\lambda\frac{f^\lambda}{N!}\tr\bigl(\rho_\lambda(\sigma^{-1})\rho_\lambda(a)\bigr). \] \cite{Ja78} \item \emph{Orthogonality.} Put $\langle a,b\rangle:=\sum_\sigma a(\sigma)b(\sigma)$. The $I_\lambda$ are mutually orthogonal, and $\langle\,,\rangle$ is nondegenerate. [$\langle a,b\rangle$ is the coefficient of $1$ in $a\cdot b^\vee$, where $b^\vee:=\sum_\sigma b(\sigma)\sigma^{-1}$. The map $\vee$ is an anti-automorphism fixing each $e_\lambda$ (characters are real), so $a\cdot b^\vee\in I_\lambda I_\mu=0$ for $a\in I_\lambda$, $b\in I_\mu$, $\lambda\ne\mu$.] \item For $m\ge n$ regard $S_{n+1}\subseteq S_N$ (fixing $n+2,\dots,N$) and put $E:=\sum_{\pi\in S_{n+1}}\sgn(\pi)\pi$. The two-sided ideal generated by $E$ is $I:=\bigoplus_{\ell(\lambda)\ge n+1}I_\lambda$, where $\ell(\lambda)$ is the number of rows. [Each $I_\lambda$ is simple, so a two-sided ideal is the sum of the $I_\lambda$ it meets; $Ee_\lambda\ne0$ iff $\rho_\lambda(E)\ne0$ iff $\Res_{S_{n+1}}S^\lambda$ contains $\sgn$ iff $(1^{n+1})\subseteq\lambda$, by the iterated branching rule (F5).] \item \emph{Branching rule.} $\Res^{S_N}_{S_{N-1}}S^\lambda\cong\bigoplus S^\mu$, over the $\mu$ obtained from $\lambda$ by removing one removable corner. \cite[Thm.~9.2]{Ja78} \item \emph{Burnside.} For an absolutely irreducible module $V$ of a group $G$, $\rho(F[G])=\End_F(V)$. \item \emph{Sign twist.} $\varepsilon(\sigma):=\sgn(\sigma)\sigma$ extends to an algebra automorphism of $F[S_N]$ with $\varepsilon(I_\lambda)=I_{\lambda'}$, where $\lambda'$ is the conjugate partition. On $C_N$ it is the scalar $(-1)^{N-1}$, because every $N$-cycle has sign $(-1)^{N-1}$. \end{enumerate} \subsection{Notation} We compose permutations right to left, $(\sigma\tau)(i)=\sigma(\tau(i))$. All of the following depends on $N$; we write $B_n^{(N)}$ where $N$ must be shown. $C_N$ is the span of the $N$-cycles in $F[S_N]$, and $P$ is the coordinate projection onto $C_N$ (orthogonal for $\langle\,,\rangle$). Put \[ A:=\bigoplus_{\ell(\lambda)\le n}I_\lambda,\qquad A':=\bigoplus_{\lambda_1\le n}I_\lambda,\qquad B_n=B_n^{(N)}:=A\cap A'=\bigoplus_{\lambda\vdash N,\ \lambda\subseteq(n^n)}I_\lambda, \] the last sum being over the partitions of $N$ inside the $n\times n$ box. For a sequence $\alpha=(a_1,\dots,a_r)$ of elements of $[m]$ we write $x_\alpha:=x_{a_1}\cdots x_{a_r}$ (the empty word if $r=0$). \subsection{The criterion} \begin{proposition}[Formanek's criterion, cycle form]\label{prop:criterion} Let $n\ge1$, $m\ge n$ and $N=m+1$. Then \[ \dim W_{n,m}=m!-\dim\bigl(C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}\bigr). \] In particular, $d(n)\le m$ if and only if $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}=0$. (For $1\le mn^2$ no partition of $N$ fits in the $n\times n$ box, so $B_n^{(N)}=0$, and $d(n)\le n^2$. \end{remark} \section{The one-corner step: Theorem~\ref{thm:A}}\label{sec:A} \begin{lemma}[one-corner step]\label{lem:onecorner} For $n\ge2$, $C_{n^2}\cap B_n^{(n^2)}=0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $N=n^2$. The only partition of $n^2$ in the box is the square $\beta:=(n^n)$, so $B_n^{(N)}=I_\beta$. Let $f\in C_N\cap I_\beta$ and $M:=\rho_\beta(f)$. Then $f(\sigma)=(f^\beta/N!)\tr(\rho_\beta(\sigma^{-1})M)$ by (F2). For $\sigma\in\Stab(N)=S_{N-1}$, $\sigma$ is not an $N$-cycle, so $f(\sigma)=0$. The square has \emph{one} removable corner, so $\Res_{S_{N-1}}S^\beta=S^{(n^{n-1},n-1)}$ is absolutely irreducible ((F5), (F2)), and by (F6) the $\rho_\beta(\sigma)$, $\sigma\in S_{N-1}$, span $\End(S^\beta)$. Hence $\tr(YM)=0$ for every $Y\in\End(S^\beta)$, so $M=0$ and $f=0$. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:A}] Apply Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion} with $m=n^2-1$ (here $m\ge n$ because $n\ge2$); by Lemma~\ref{lem:onecorner} and the forward half of the criterion (Remark~\ref{rem:forward}), $d(n)\le n^2-1$. \end{proof} \begin{corollary} $n(n+1)/2\le d(n)\le n^2-1$ for every $n\ge2$ (the lower bound is Kuzmin's \cite{Ku75}). The bound is new only for $n\ge6$: $d(6)\le35$ (for $n=5$, $d(5)\le21$ is known, Subsection~\ref{subsec:bounds}). \end{corollary} \section{The two-corner step: Theorem~\ref{thm:B}}\label{sec:B} \subsection{Reduction to one block} Let $N=n^2-1$. We work over $\mathbb{C}$: every space below ($C_N$, $I_\nu$, their intersection) is defined over $\mathbb{Q}$, so its dimension is the same over $\mathbb{Q}$, over $\mathbb{C}$, and over any field of characteristic $0$. Over $\mathbb{C}$ we may take square roots (to normalize $\Gamma^2=I$ below), and the constituents of the restrictions to $A_N$ are defined. The only partition of $N$ inside the $n\times n$ box is \[ \nu:=(n^{n-1},n-1), \] the box minus one cell, which must be the removable corner $(n,n)$. So $B_n=I_\nu$, and by Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion} it suffices to show $C_N\cap I_\nu=0$. For $f\in I_\nu$ put $M:=\rho_\nu(f)$; then \[ f(\sigma)=\frac{f^\nu}{N!}\tr\bigl(\rho_\nu(\sigma^{-1})M\bigr). \] \subsection{Tools} Besides (F2)--(F6) we use the following facts. For a standard tableau $T$ and an entry $k$, $c_T(k)$ is the content (column minus row) of the cell of $k$ in $T$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\Alph*),leftmargin=*] \item[(J)] \emph{Jucys--Murphy elements.} $J_k:=\sum_{in$ and (F3) applies), and $C_N\cap I\subseteq P(I)=\Phi(W_{n,m})$. \end{remark} \subsection{The star elements: Theorem~\ref{thm:C}}\label{subsec:stars} We work over $\mathbb{R}$, with Young's orthogonal form: $S^\lambda$ has the orthonormal Young basis $v_T$ ($T$ standard), every $\rho(\sigma)$ is orthogonal, and so every $Y_j$ is symmetric. The statement over any field of characteristic~$0$ follows: in Young's seminormal form the $Y_j$ have rational entries, the seminormal form is diagonally conjugate to the orthogonal form, and the dimension of the algebra generated by rational matrices does not change under field extension. The $Y_j$ generate a $*$-closed, hence semisimple, algebra, so by the double commutant theorem the two forms of Theorem~\ref{thm:C} are equivalent. Let $\mathcal{A}$ be the unital algebra generated by $Y_1,\dots,Y_N$. Since $gX^{(j)}g^{-1}=X^{(g(j))}$, $\mathcal{A}$ is stable under conjugation by every $\rho(g)$. A corner is a removable cell; contents of distinct corners differ by at least~$2$. Put $s:=(N-1,N)$ and $s':=(N-2,N-1)$. By (R), $\rho(s)v_T\in\operatorname{span}(v_T,v_{sT})$ with $\rho(s)_{TT}=1/(c_T(N)-c_T(N-1))$, the $v_{sT}$ term occurring only if $sT$ is standard; if $N-1$ and $N$ lie in one row (column) of $T$, then $\rho(s)v_T=+v_T$ ($-v_T$). The same holds for $s'$ with $N-2$, $N-1$. (These facts hold in the orthogonal form as well as in the seminormal form, since the two are diagonally conjugate: same diagonal entries, same support.) If $\lambda$ is a rectangle, $\rho(J_N)$ acts by the content of the one corner, so every $Y_j$ is a scalar. \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:C}] Steps (1)--(3) are those of Lemma~\ref{lem:claimS}, (a)--(d), for any number of corners; steps (4)--(6) settle the one case they leave open. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\arabic*),leftmargin=*] \item $Y_N=\rho(J_N)\in\mathcal{A}$, so the projections $P_X$ onto $V_X:=\operatorname{span}\{v_T: N\text{ at }X\}$ ($X$ a corner) lie in $\mathcal{A}$. \item $Y_{N-1}=\rho(J_{N-1})+\rho(s)$. Put $D:=\sum_XP_XY_{N-1}P_X\in\mathcal{A}$. When $sT$ is standard, $N$ sits in $sT$ at the cell of $N-1$ in $T$, a corner different from the cell of $N$ in $T$. So the off-diagonal entries of $\rho(s)$ join different $V_X$, and $Dv_T=g(c_T(N-1),c_T(N))v_T$ with $g(x,y):=x+1/(y-x)$. \item Fix a corner $X$ with content $c_X$, and $T$ with $N$ at $X$. Then $N-1$ sits at a corner of $\lambda-X$: either at a corner $Y\ne X$ of $\lambda$ (removing $X$ cannot block it), or at $X_-$, the cell left of $X$, or at $X_+$, the cell above $X$ (contents $c_X-1$, $c_X+1$), when these are corners of $\lambda-X$. The values are $g(c_Y,c_X)=c_Y+1/(c_X-c_Y)$ and $g(c_X\pm1,c_X)=c_X$. With $d_Y:=c_X-c_Y$ ($|d_Y|\ge2$), \[ g(c_Y,c_X)=g(c_Z,c_X)\iff(d_Z-d_Y)\Bigl(1+\frac{1}{d_Yd_Z}\Bigr)=0\iff Y=Z\text{ or }d_Yd_Z=-1, \] and $g(c_Y,c_X)=c_X$ iff $d_Y^2=1$. Both exceptions are impossible for $|d|\ge2$. ($Y_N$ and $D$ commute: both are diagonal in the Young basis.) So the joint eigenvalue of the pair $(Y_N,D)$ determines $c_T(N-1)$, except at a \emph{collision corner} $X$, where both $X_-$ and $X_+$ are corners of $\lambda-X$. There the joint eigenspace for $(c_X,c_X)$ is $E:=E^-\oplus E^+$, with $E^\mp:=\operatorname{span}\{v_T: N\text{ at }X,\ N-1\text{ at }X_\mp\}$. \item Let $X=(i,\lambda_i)$ be a collision corner, so $\lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_i$ ($i\ge2$) and $\lambda_{i+1}\le\lambda_i-2$. The joint spectral projection $\Pi_E$ is a polynomial in $Y_N$ and $D$, so $\Pi_E\in\mathcal{A}$. On $E$, $N-1$ and $N$ share a row ($E^-$) or a column ($E^+$), so $\rho(s)=+1$ on $E^-$ and $-1$ on $E^+$. Hence $\rho(s)$ maps $E$ into $E$; it is symmetric, so it also maps $E^\perp$ into $E^\perp$, and it commutes with $\Pi_E$. Put $\theta:=\rho(s)\Pi_E=\Pi_{E^-}-\Pi_{E^+}$. Now $X^{(N-2)}=J_{N-2}+s'+ss's$, so \[ H:=\Pi_EY_{N-2}\Pi_E=\rho(J_{N-2})\Pi_E+R+\theta R\theta,\qquad R:=\Pi_E\rho(s')\Pi_E. \] An off-diagonal entry of $R$ joins $T$ and $s'T$, both in $E$. The tableau $s'T$ has $N-1$ at the cell of $N-2$ in $T$; this must be $X_-$ or $X_+$, and it is not the cell of $N-1$ in $T$. So $s'T$ lies in the \emph{other} summand: the off-diagonal entries of $R$ only join $E^-$ to $E^+$. Then $R+\theta R\theta=2\operatorname{diag}(1/r'_T)$, with $r'_T=c_T(N-1)-c_T(N-2)$, and \[ Hv_T=h(T)v_T,\qquad h(T):=c_T(N-2)+\frac{2}{c_T(N-1)-c_T(N-2)}\qquad(T\in E). \] \item \emph{The values of $h$.} Removing $X$ and $X_-$ changes only row $i$, whose new end $X_{--}$ may become removable, and row $i-1$, whose end $X_+$ is removable; the cell above $X_-$ is blocked by $X_+$. Symmetrically, in $\lambda-X-X_+$ the cell left of $X_+$ is blocked by $X_-$. The end of every other row is removable exactly when it was in $\lambda$ (for $\lambda-X-X_+$, read ``column'' for ``row''; this gives $X_{++}$ below). So the following lists are complete. For $T\in E^-$, $N-2$ sits at a corner of $\lambda-X-X_-$: \begin{itemize} \item $X_+$, with $h=c_X+1-1=c_X$; \item $X_{--}:=(i,\lambda_i-2)$, if it is a corner, with $h=c_X-2+2=c_X$; \item a corner $Y\ne X$ of $\lambda$, with $h=h^-(Y):=c_Y+2/(c_X-1-c_Y)$. \end{itemize} For $T\in E^+$, $N-2$ sits at a corner of $\lambda-X-X_+$: at $X_-$, with $h=c_X$; at $X_{++}:=(i-2,\lambda_i)$, if it is a corner, with $h=c_X$; or at a corner $Y\ne X$, with $h=h^+(Y):=c_Y+2/(c_X+1-c_Y)$. \emph{Claim: every corner $Y\ne X$ has $|d_Y|\ge3$.} Every corner below row $i$ lies in a column $\le\lambda_{i+1}\le\lambda_i-2$ and in a row $\ge i+1$, so its content is $\le c_X-3$. Row $i-1$ has no corner ($\lambda_{i-1}=\lambda_i$), so every corner above $X$ lies in a row $\le i-2$ and a column $\ge\lambda_i+1$, so its content is $\ge c_X+3$. So, for every corner $Y\ne X$, $h^-(Y)$ lies neither in $\{c_X\}$ nor in $\{h^+(Z): Z\ne X\text{ a corner}\}$: \begin{itemize} \item $h^-(Y)=c_X$ iff $d_Y^2-d_Y-2=0$, i.e.\ $d_Y\in\{2,-1\}$. Excluded. \item $h^-(Y)=h^+(Z)$ iff $d_Z-d_Y=2/(d_Z+1)-2/(d_Y-1)$; the denominators are nonzero, as $|d|\ge3$. For $Z=Y$ this needs $d+1=d-1$, which is impossible. For $Z\ne Y$, the left side has absolute value $|c_Y-c_Z|\ge2$. With $|d|\ge3$, $|d_Z+1|\ge2$ and $|d_Y-1|\ge2$, so each term on the right has absolute value $\le1$, with equality only at $d_Z=-3$, $d_Y=3$; there the right side is $-2$ and the left side is $-6$. Otherwise the right side has absolute value $<2$. \end{itemize} Since $\lambda$ has a corner $Y\ne X$, and $Y$ is still a corner of $\lambda-X-X_-$, the shape $\lambda-X-X_--Y$ is a partition, so some $T\in E^-$ has $N-2$ at $Y$. So the $h^-(Y)$-eigenspace $E_Y$ of $H$ on $E$ is nonzero and lies inside $E^-$. Then $\Pi_{E_Y}=\Pi_E\,p(H)\,\Pi_E$ for a Lagrange polynomial $p$ (the outer $\Pi_E$ removes the value $p(0)$ on $E^\perp$), so $\Pi_{E_Y}\in\mathcal{A}$. \item $E^-$ is $\rho(S_{N-2})$-stable and irreducible, isomorphic to $S^{\lambda-X-X_-}$ (the Young vectors with $N-1$, $N$ in fixed cells). Put \[ \operatorname{Avg}:=\frac{1}{(N-2)!}\sum_{g\in S_{N-2}}\rho(g)\,\Pi_{E_Y}\,\rho(g)^{-1}\in\mathcal{A}. \] It commutes with $\rho(S_{N-2})$, maps $E^-$ into $E^-$ and kills its orthogonal complement (each $\rho(g)$ is orthogonal and preserves $E^-$). $S^{\lambda-X-X_-}$ is absolutely irreducible (F2), so Schur's lemma applies over $\mathbb{R}$, and $\operatorname{Avg}=(\dim E_Y/\dim E^-)\,\Pi_{E^-}$ with a nonzero scalar (step (5)). So $\Pi_{E^-}\in\mathcal{A}$, and $\rho(J_{N-1})\Pi_E=(c_X-1)\Pi_{E^-}+(c_X+1)(\Pi_E-\Pi_{E^-})\in\mathcal{A}$. \item The joint spectral projections of $(Y_N,D)$ lie in $\mathcal{A}$ and sum to $I$. On every one except the collision spaces, $\rho(J_{N-1})$ is a known scalar (step (3)). Steps (4)--(6) for one collision corner $X$ use only $\Pi_E$, $Y_{N-2}$, one other corner $Y$ and the conjugation-stability of $\mathcal{A}$, so they apply to each collision corner separately. So $\rho(J_{N-1})\in\mathcal{A}$, and $\rho(s)=Y_{N-1}-\rho(J_{N-1})\in\mathcal{A}$. Conjugating, $\rho(t)\in\mathcal{A}$ for every transposition $t$, so $\mathcal{A}\supseteq\rho(F[S_N])=\End(S^\lambda)$ (F6).\qedhere \end{enumerate} \end{proof} \begin{remark} The separating value in step (5) comes from $N-2$ sitting at \emph{another} corner $Y$. This is why a rectangle with at least two rows and two columns fails (one corner, which is a collision corner), and why two corners always suffice. For self-conjugate two-corner shapes $((u+v)^u,u^v)$, collision corners occur exactly when $u,v\ge2$ (the smallest is $(4,4,2,2)$, $N=12$); non-self-conjugate two-corner shapes can also have them, e.g.\ $(3,3,1)$, $(3,2,2)$, $(4,4,1,1)$, $(5,5,1)$. \end{remark} \subsection{Two corners: Theorem~\ref{thm:D}}\label{subsec:twocorners} \begin{lemma}[two corners and fixed points]\label{lem:twocorners} Let $\lambda$ have exactly two removable corners $A$, $B$, with contents $a>b$, and put $Z_j:=(2Y_j-(a+b))/(a-b)$. Then $f\in I_\lambda$ lies in $K_\lambda$ if and only if $Z_jM=-MZ_j$ for all $j$. If $K_\lambda\ne0$, then every nonzero element of $\rho(K_\lambda)$ is invertible, and $\dim K_\lambda=1$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By (F5), $\Res_{\Stab(N)}S^\lambda=S^{\lambda-A}\oplus S^{\lambda-B}$, two different shapes, and $Y_N=\rho(J_N)$ acts on them by $a$ and $b$ (J); so $Z_N$ acts by $+1$ and $-1$. The proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:anticommute}, with $Z_N$ in place of $Y_N$, gives the first claim. Now let $M\in\rho(K_\lambda)$ be nonzero. For $w\in\ker M$, $MZ_jw=-Z_jMw=0$, so $\ker M$ is invariant under every $Z_j$, hence under the unital algebra they generate, which is that of the $Y_j$, i.e.\ $\End(S^\lambda)$ by Theorem~\ref{thm:C}. So $\ker M=0$. If $M'\in\rho(K_\lambda)$ too, then $M^{-1}M'$ commutes with every $Z_j$, so it is a scalar (Theorem~\ref{thm:C}). \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:D}] If $\lambda\ne\lambda'$, then $U_\lambda=0$ by Proposition~\ref{prop:signtwist}. Let $\lambda=\lambda'$ and write $\lambda=(p^u,q^v)$ with $p>q\ge1$. Then $\lambda'=((u+v)^q,u^{p-q})$, so $\lambda=\lambda'$ iff $q=u$ and $p=u+v$: $\lambda=((u+v)^u,u^v)$. The corners are $A=(u,u+v)$, with content $v$, and $B=(u+v,u)$, with content $-v$; so $Z_j=Y_j/v$. $\Gamma$ anticommutes with every $Y_j$ (a sum of transpositions), and $\Gamma^2=I$; so $M$ anticommutes with every $Z_j$ iff $\Gamma M$ commutes with every $Y_j$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:twocorners} and Theorem~\ref{thm:C}, $\rho(K_\lambda)=\Gamma\cdot\{\text{scalars}\}$, i.e.\ $K_\lambda=\operatorname{span}(f_\Gamma)$. By ($\Gamma$), $f_\Gamma$ is supported exactly on the cycle type $h(\lambda)$. Now $h(\lambda)=(N)$ iff $\lambda$ has one diagonal cell, iff $u=1$. If $u\ge2$, $h(\lambda)$ has $u\ge2$ parts, so $f_\Gamma$ vanishes on the $N$-cycles, and $U_\lambda\subseteq K_\lambda\cap C_N=0$ (an $N$-cycle has no fixed point, as $N\ge2$). If $u=1$, $\lambda=(v+1,1^v)$ is a hook, $f_\Gamma\in C_N$ by step (1) of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:H}, and so $U_\lambda=K_\lambda=\operatorname{span}(f_\Gamma)$. Finally, for $n\ge3$ and $1\le j\le n-2$, the shape $(n^{n-j},(n-j)^j)$ is $((u+v)^u,u^v)$ with $u=n-j\ge2$, $v=j\ge1$; it is self-conjugate with two corners and not a hook, so $U_\lambda=0$. \end{proof} For $j=1$ this is the block $\nu$ of Section~\ref{sec:B} (Theorem~\ref{thm:R2}). For $j\ge2$ it is a single-block statement only: for instance, $d(n)\le n^2-5$ would also need the coupled blocks at $N=n^2-4$ (the decoupling step). The proof also shows $K_\lambda=\operatorname{span}(f_\Gamma)$ for every self-conjugate two-corner shape. For the other two-corner shapes: \begin{corollary}\label{cor:nonsc} Let $\lambda$ have exactly two removable corners $A$, $B$, with contents $a>b$, and suppose $K_\lambda\ne0$. Then $\dim K_\lambda=1$, $f^{\lambda-A}=f^{\lambda-B}$, and $4c(\lambda)=N(a+b)$, where $c(\lambda)$ is the sum of the contents of the cells of $\lambda$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} $\dim K_\lambda=1$ is Lemma~\ref{lem:twocorners}. Let $M\in\rho(K_\lambda)$ be nonzero; it is invertible and $MZ_NM^{-1}=-Z_N$, so $\tr Z_N=0$, i.e.\ $f^{\lambda-A}=f^{\lambda-B}$. Each transposition lies in exactly two stars, so $\sum_jX^{(j)}=2\mathcal{T}$ with $\mathcal{T}:=\sum_{i2$) is a consequence of $s_{2k}$; by Remark~\ref{rem:identities} (both directions) and the partition count in step (6), these identities correspond to $C_N\cap\bigl(I_{A_k}\oplus I_{(k+2,1^k)}\oplus I_{(k+1,1^{k+1})}\bigr)$. Leron's theorem is not used above. \end{remark} \subsection{Components and the deletion map}\label{subsec:deletion} These two facts will be used in the decoupling step (Section~\ref{sec:decoupling}). \begin{proposition}[component reduction]\label{prop:components} Let $S=S'$ and $f\in C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\lambda\in S}I_\lambda$, with components $f_\lambda$ and $M_\lambda:=\rho_\lambda(f_\lambda)$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*),leftmargin=*] \item For each pair $\lambda\ne\lambda'$ in $S$, $f_{\lambda'}=(-1)^{N-1}\varepsilon(f_\lambda)$. \item For each $\lambda=\lambda'$ in $S$, $\Gamma M_\lambda\Gamma^{-1}=(-1)^{N-1}M_\lambda$, so the component $f_\lambda$ (which need not lie in $C_N$) vanishes on every permutation of sign $-(-1)^{N-1}$. \item For a pair, $f_\lambda+f_{\lambda'}$ takes the value $f_\lambda(\sigma)\bigl(1+(-1)^{N-1}\sgn(\sigma)\bigr)$ at $\sigma$. \end{enumerate} So $f$ is determined by its components on one shape of each conjugate pair and on the self-conjugate shapes. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} (i) is the proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:signtwist}. (ii): on $I_\lambda$ with $\lambda=\lambda'$, $\varepsilon$ acts as $M\mapsto\Gamma M\Gamma^{-1}$, because $\rho(\varepsilon(\sigma))=\sgn(\sigma)\rho(\sigma)=\Gamma\rho(\sigma)\Gamma^{-1}$; and $\varepsilon(f_\lambda)=(-1)^{N-1}f_\lambda$ gives $\sgn(\sigma)f_\lambda(\sigma)=(-1)^{N-1}f_\lambda(\sigma)$. (iii): $(\varepsilon g)(\sigma)=\sgn(\sigma)g(\sigma)$. \end{proof} So $f$ vanishes automatically on the permutations of sign $-(-1)^{N-1}$; on those of sign $(-1)^{N-1}$, $f(\sigma)=2\sum f_\lambda(\sigma)+\sum_{\lambda=\lambda'}f_\lambda(\sigma)$, the first sum over one shape of each pair in $S$. The condition ``$f$ vanishes off the $N$-cycles'' says that this sum vanishes on the non-$N$-cycles of sign $(-1)^{N-1}$. Only when $S$ is a single pair is it a condition on one component alone. For example, at $N=n^2-2$ (the step $d(n)\le n^2-3$ of Theorem~\ref{thm:E}) the two box shapes $(n^{n-1},n-2)$ and $(n^{n-2},(n-1)^2)$ are conjugate to each other, so the problem reduces to one block, with the condition only on the permutations of sign $(-1)^{N-1}$. \begin{proposition}[deletion map]\label{prop:deletion} Let $\delta\colon F[S_{N+1}]\to F[S_N]$ send $\sigma$ to the permutation of $[N]$ obtained by cutting the point $N+1$ out of its cycle: $\delta(\sigma)(i)=\sigma(i)$ if $\sigma(i)\ne N+1$, and $\delta(\sigma)(i)=\sigma(N+1)$ otherwise. Then $\delta$ is a map of $S_N$-bimodules, $\delta(C_{N+1})\subseteq C_N$, and for $\lambda\vdash N+1$ \[ \delta(I_\lambda)=\bigoplus\{I_{\lambda-X}: X\text{ a corner of }\lambda,\ c_X\ne-1\}, \] where $c_X$ is the content of $X$. Hence $\delta(C_{N+1}\cap B_n^{(N+1)})\subseteq C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} $\delta(g\sigma h)=g\,\delta(\sigma)h$ for $g,h\in S_N$: check the two cases $\sigma(h(i))\ne N+1$ and $\sigma(h(i))=N+1$ ($h$ fixes $N+1$). Cutting a point out of an $(N+1)$-cycle leaves an $N$-cycle. The preimages of $\tau\in S_N$ are $\tau$ and the $N$ permutations $\tau\circ(i,N+1)$, $i\le N$, so $\delta(f)=\Res_{S_N}\bigl(f\cdot(1+J_{N+1})\bigr)$, where $\Res_{S_N}$ keeps the coefficients on $S_N$. As an $S_N$-bimodule, $I_\lambda$ is the sum of the $S^{\mu}\boxtimes S^{\tilde\mu}$ over the shapes $\mu,\tilde\mu$ obtained from $\lambda$ by removing a corner, while $F[S_N]$ has only the types $S^\mu\boxtimes S^\mu$, inside $I_\mu$; so $\delta(I_\lambda)\subseteq\bigoplus_X I_{\lambda-X}$. For $f\in I_\lambda$, $J_{N+1}$ acts on the child $S^{\lambda-X}$ by $c_X$ (J), so the $I_{\lambda-X}$-part of $\delta(f)$ is $(1+c_X)$ times the $I_{\lambda-X}$-part of $\Res_{S_N}(f)$; and the latter runs over all of $I_{\lambda-X}$, since by (F2) and (F5) it corresponds to the $(\lambda-X)$-diagonal block of $\rho_\lambda(f)$, which is arbitrary. This gives the formula. Every partition inside a box shape is again in the box. \end{proof} Proposition~\ref{prop:deletion} gives no injectivity or surjectivity between the spaces $C_{N+1}\cap B_n^{(N+1)}$ and $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}$: $\delta$ kills whole blocks ($\delta(I_{(2,2,2)})=0$, as its one corner has content $-1$), and $\delta(I_\lambda)$ can miss a child block ($\delta$ kills the $I_{(N)}$-part of $I_{(N,1)}$). \section{Decoupling: Theorems~\ref{thm:E} and~\ref{thm:F}}\label{sec:decoupling} By Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion}, $d(n)\le n^2-k-1$ if and only if $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}=0$ for $N=n^2-k$. For $k\ge2$ the ideal $B_n^{(N)}$ is a sum of several blocks, and an element of $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}$ need not lie in any one of them. In this section we restrict to $S_{N-1}$, where each block splits into the blocks of its children, and we use the central element $\mathcal{T}$ to separate the parents of a common child. This reduces $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}=0$, level by level, to statements about the blocks of a few shapes near the corner of the box. \subsection{Restriction to $S_{N-1}$}\label{subsec:restriction} In this section $\Res\colon F[S_N]\to F[S_{N-1}]$ keeps the coefficients on $S_{N-1}=\Stab(N)$, as in the proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:deletion}. For $f\in F[S_N]$ and $\lambda\vdash N$, $f_\lambda:=fe_\lambda$ is the $I_\lambda$-component of $f$. For a set $S$ of partitions of a number $M$ put \[ U(S):=C_M\cap\bigoplus_{\lambda\in S}I_\lambda , \] so that $U(\{\lambda\})=U_\lambda$, $U(\emptyset)=0$, and $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}=U(S)$ for the set $S$ of the partitions of $N$ inside the box. As in Corollary~\ref{cor:nonsc}, $\mathcal{T}=\sum_{ii}(S)$ is the set of the children with more than $i$ parents. A child with one parent is \emph{private}. \begin{lemma}[restriction]\label{lem:restriction} Let $N\ge2$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item For $h\in I_\lambda$, $\Res h\in\bigoplus_XI_{\lambda-X}$, the sum over the removable corners $X$ of $\lambda$. \item Two different parents of the same child have different content sums. \item For $f\in C_N$ and $i\ge0$, $\Res(f\mathcal{T}^i)\in\mathcal{D}^{(i)}(N-1)$. In particular $\Res f=0$ and $\Res(f\mathcal{T})\in C_{N-1}$. \item For $f\in C_N$, $\Res(f\mathcal{T})=\delta(f)$, where $\delta\colon F[S_N]\to F[S_{N-1}]$ is the deletion map of Proposition~\ref{prop:deletion} (with $N-1$ in place of $N$). \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) Let $M=\rho_\lambda(h)$, so $h(\sigma)=(f^\lambda/N!)\tr(\rho_\lambda(\sigma^{-1})M)$ by (F2). By (F5), in a suitable basis $\rho_\lambda(\sigma)=\bigoplus_X\rho_{\lambda-X}(\sigma)$ for $\sigma\in S_{N-1}$. So for $\sigma\in S_{N-1}$, $h(\sigma)=\sum_X(f^\lambda/N!)\tr(\rho_{\lambda-X}(\sigma^{-1})M_X)$, where $M_X$ is the diagonal block of $M$ for $S^{\lambda-X}$. By (F2) for $S_{N-1}$, the functions $\sigma\mapsto\tr(\rho_\mu(\sigma^{-1})A)$, $A\in\End(S^\mu)$, span $I_\mu$. (b) If $\lambda\ne\lambda'$ are parents of $\mu$, then $\lambda=\mu+x$ and $\lambda'=\mu+x'$ for two different addable cells $x,x'$ of $\mu$, and $c(\lambda)-c(\lambda')=c(x)-c(x')$. The contents of the addable cells of a partition strictly decrease from the top row to the bottom row, so this is not $0$. (c) The coefficient of $\sigma\in S_{N-1}$ in $f\mathcal{T}^i$ is $\sum f(\sigma t_1\cdots t_i)$, over the ordered $i$-tuples of transpositions (each $t$ is an involution, and reversing the order of a tuple is a bijection). Right multiplication by a transposition changes the number of cycles by exactly $1$: it joins two cycles or splits one. Since $f$ vanishes off the $N$-cycles, a nonzero term needs $i$ such steps from $\operatorname{cyc}(\sigma)$ (counted in $S_N$) down to $1$; so $\operatorname{cyc}(\sigma)-1\le i$ and $\operatorname{cyc}(\sigma)-1\equiv i\pmod2$. Since $\sigma$ fixes $N$, its number of cycles on $[N-1]$ is $\operatorname{cyc}(\sigma)-1$, and this is $\ge1$ because $N-1\ge1$. Hence $\Res(f\mathcal{T}^i)\in\mathcal{D}^{(i)}(N-1)$; for $i=0,1$ this is the last claim. (d) By the proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:deletion}, $\delta(f)=\Res(f(1+J_N))$. Write $\mathcal{T}=\mathcal{T}'+J_N$ with $\mathcal{T}':=\sum_{ii}(S)}I_\mu=0 . \] Then $f_\lambda\in K_\lambda$ for every $f\in U(S)$ and every $\lambda\in S$. \end{lemma} So $(H_1)$ says $U(\operatorname{ch}_{>1}(S))=0$, a statement at size $N-1$ about the children with at least two parents; for $p_{\max}(S)=1$ there is no hypothesis. The assumption $N\ge2$ is needed: for $S=\{(1)\}$, the identity lies in $U(S)$, but $K_{(1)}=0$, because the identity of $S_1$ has a fixed point. \begin{proof} Let $f\in U(S)$. For a child $\mu$ and a parent $\lambda$ of $\mu$, let $R_{\lambda,\mu}$ be the $I_\mu$-component of $\Res f_\lambda$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:restriction}(a), $\Res f_\lambda=\sum_\mu R_{\lambda,\mu}$, over the children $\mu$ of $\lambda$. Since $f\mathcal{T}^i=\sum_\lambda c(\lambda)^if_\lambda$, the $I_\mu$-component of $\Res(f\mathcal{T}^i)$ is \[ \eta_i(\mu):=\sum_{\lambda\text{ a parent of }\mu}c(\lambda)^i\,R_{\lambda,\mu}. \] We show by induction on $i$ that $\eta_i(\mu)=0$ for every child $\mu$ and $0\le i\le p_{\max}(S)-1$. For $i=0$, $E_0(\mu)$ is a component of $\Res f=0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:restriction}(c)). Let $1\le i\le p_{\max}(S)-1$ and assume $\eta_0=\dots=\eta_{i-1}=0$ for every child. If $p(\mu)\le i$, the equations $\eta_0(\mu)=\dots=\eta_{p(\mu)-1}(\mu)=0$ form a Vandermonde system in the $p(\mu)$ numbers $c(\lambda)$, $\lambda$ a parent of $\mu$, which are distinct by Lemma~\ref{lem:restriction}(b); so every $R_{\lambda,\mu}=0$, and $\eta_i(\mu)=0$. Hence $\Res(f\mathcal{T}^i)=\sum_\mu \eta_i(\mu)$ lies in $\bigoplus_{\mu\in\operatorname{ch}_{>i}(S)}I_\mu$, and by Lemma~\ref{lem:restriction}(c) also in $\mathcal{D}^{(i)}(N-1)$. By $(H_i)$, $\Res(f\mathcal{T}^i)=0$, so $\eta_i(\mu)=0$ for every $\mu$. Now every child $\mu$ has $\eta_0(\mu)=\dots=\eta_{p(\mu)-1}(\mu)=0$, since $p(\mu)\le p_{\max}(S)$, and the Vandermonde argument gives $R_{\lambda,\mu}=0$ for all $\lambda$ and $\mu$. So $\Res f_\lambda=0$: $f_\lambda$ vanishes on $\Stab(N)$. For $g\in S_N$, $g^{-1}fg$ again lies in $U(S)$ ($C_N$ and every block are stable under conjugation), and $(g^{-1}fg)_\lambda=g^{-1}f_\lambda g$, since $e_\lambda$ is central; the hypotheses do not involve $f$. So $g^{-1}f_\lambda g$ vanishes on $\Stab(N)$, that is, $f_\lambda$ vanishes on $g\Stab(N)g^{-1}=\Stab(g(N))$. Every permutation with a fixed point lies in some $\Stab(j)$, so $f_\lambda\in K_\lambda$. \end{proof} \begin{remark}[the hypotheses]\label{rem:hyps} (1) $(H_1)$ cannot be dropped. Let $N=6$ and $S=\{(4,1,1),\allowbreak(3,1,1,1)\}$. The only common child is the hook $(3,1,1)$, and $U_{(3,1,1)}\ne0$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:D}), so $(H_1)$ fails. The shape $(4,1,1)$ has two corners, with contents $3$ and $-2$, and $4c(\lambda)=12\ne6=N(a+b)$; so $K_{(4,1,1)}=0$ by Corollary~\ref{cor:nonsc}, and $K_{(3,1,1,1)}=\varepsilon(K_{(4,1,1)})=0$. So the conclusion of Lemma~\ref{lem:Rstar} would give $U(S)=0$. But $\dim U(S)=5$, by direct computation. (2) $(H_2)$ cannot be dropped either. By direct computation over all $2^{11}$ sets $S$ of partitions of $6$: exactly $12$ of them have $p_{\max}(S)=3$ and satisfy $(H_1)$ but not $(H_2)$, and for each of these $12$ the conclusion of Lemma~\ref{lem:Rstar} fails. (3) A hypothesis $(H_i)$ can fail for small $N$ by counting alone: two subspaces of $F[S_{N-1}]$ whose dimensions add up to more than $(N-1)!$ meet, so $(H_i)$ needs $\sum_{\mu\in\operatorname{ch}_{>i}(S)}(f^\mu)^2\le(N-1)!-\dim\mathcal{D}^{(i)}(N-1)$. \end{remark} \subsection{Two parents: Theorem~\ref{thm:E}}\label{subsec:twoparents} \begin{proposition}[a conjugate pair]\label{prop:pair} Let $N\ge2$ and let $\lambda\vdash N$ with $\lambda\ne\lambda'$, where $\lambda$ has exactly two removable corners, with contents $a>b$, $4c(\lambda)\ne N(a+b)$, and $c(\lambda)\ne0$. Let $\mathcal{M}$ be the set of the common children of $\lambda$ and $\lambda'$, and choose $g_1,\dots,g_N\in S_N$ with $g_j(N)=j$. Then $\Res(g^{-1}f_\lambda g)=(2c(\lambda))^{-1}\Res(g^{-1}fg\,\mathcal{T})\in U(\mathcal{M})$ for every $f\in U(\{\lambda,\lambda'\})$ and $g\in S_N$, and \[ f\longmapsto\bigl(\Res(g_j^{-1}f_\lambda g_j)\bigr)_{j=1,\dots,N} \] is an injective linear map from $U(\{\lambda,\lambda'\})$ into the direct sum of $N$ copies of $U(\mathcal{M})$. In particular $\dim U(\{\lambda,\lambda'\})\le N\dim U(\mathcal{M})$, and $U(\{\lambda,\lambda'\})=0$ if $U(\mathcal{M})=0$ (for instance, if $\lambda$ and $\lambda'$ have no common child). \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Put $S=\{\lambda,\lambda'\}$. Conjugation negates contents, so $c(\lambda')=-c(\lambda)\ne c(\lambda)$. Let $f\in U(S)$, with $R_{\lambda,\mu}$ as in the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Rstar}. Since $\Res f=0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:restriction}(c)), $R_{\lambda,\mu}=0$ for a private child $\mu$, and $R_{\lambda',\mu}=-R_{\lambda,\mu}$ for $\mu\in\mathcal{M}$. So the $I_\mu$-component of $\Res(f\mathcal{T})$ is $0$ for a private $\mu$, and $c(\lambda)R_{\lambda,\mu}+c(\lambda')R_{\lambda',\mu}=2c(\lambda)R_{\lambda,\mu}$ for $\mu\in\mathcal{M}$. Hence $\Res f_\lambda=\sum_{\mu\in\mathcal{M}}R_{\lambda,\mu}=(2c(\lambda))^{-1}\Res(f\mathcal{T})$, which lies in $C_{N-1}$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:restriction}(c)) and in $\bigoplus_{\mu\in\mathcal{M}}I_\mu$, that is, in $U(\mathcal{M})$. The same holds for $g^{-1}fg\in U(S)$, whose $\lambda$-component is $g^{-1}f_\lambda g$. If all $\Res(g_j^{-1}f_\lambda g_j)$ vanish, then $f_\lambda$ vanishes on every $\Stab(j)$, as in the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Rstar}; so $f_\lambda\in K_\lambda$, and $K_\lambda=0$ by Corollary~\ref{cor:nonsc}, since $4c(\lambda)\ne N(a+b)$. Then $f_{\lambda'}=(-1)^{N-1}\varepsilon(f_\lambda)=0$ by Proposition~\ref{prop:components}(i), and $f=0$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:Rthree} Let $n\ge3$, $N=n^2-2$, $\lambda:=(n^{n-1},n-2)$, and let $B:=B(n,2)=(n^{n-2},n-1,n-2)\vdash N-1$, the $n\times n$ box minus the hook $(2,1)$ at its corner; $B$ is self-conjugate. For every $f\in C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}$ and every $g\in S_N$, \[ \Res\bigl((g^{-1}fg)_\lambda\bigr)=\tfrac12\Res\bigl(g^{-1}fg\,\mathcal{T}\bigr)\in U_B , \] and $\dim(C_N\cap B_n^{(N)})\le N\dim U_B$. Hence, if $U_B=0$, then $d(n)\le n^2-3$; this is Theorem~\ref{thm:E}. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} The partitions of $N$ inside the box are the box minus two cells at its corner: $\lambda$ and $\lambda'=(n^{n-2},(n-1)^2)$, and $\lambda\ne\lambda'$. So $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}=U(\{\lambda,\lambda'\})$. The box has content sum $0$, and $\lambda$ lacks the cells $(n,n-1)$ and $(n,n)$, with contents $-1$ and $0$; so $c(\lambda)=1$. The partition $\lambda$ has two corners: $(n-1,n)$, with content $1$ and $\lambda-(n-1,n)=B$, and $(n,n-2)$, with content $-2$ and $\lambda-(n,n-2)=(n^{n-1},n-3)=:\mu_b$; here $n\ge3$ makes $\mu_b$ a partition. The children of $\lambda'$ are the conjugates $B'=B$ and $\mu_b'$. Now $\mu_b\not\subset\lambda'$ ($\mu_b$ has $n-1$ rows of length $n$, $\lambda'$ only $n-2$), and so $\mu_b'\not\subset\lambda$. So $B$ is the only common child. Finally $a+b=-1$, and $4c(\lambda)=4\ne-N=N(a+b)$. Proposition~\ref{prop:pair} applies, with $\mathcal{M}=\{B\}$ and $c(\lambda)=1$. If $U_B=0$, then $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}=0$, and $d(n)\le N-1=n^2-3$ by Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion}. \end{proof} \emph{The hypothesis $U_{B(n,2)}=0$.} For $n=3$, $B=(3,2,1)$ is the staircase, and $\dim U_{(3,2,1)}=15$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:threecorners}), so the hypothesis fails; Theorem~\ref{thm:E} is sufficient, not necessary, since $d(3)=6$. For $n=4$, $B=(4,4,3,2)\vdash13$ lies in the box, so $U_B\subseteq C_{13}\cap B_4^{(13)}$, which is $0$ by $d(4)=10$ \cite{VL93} and Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion}; since the conclusion $d(4)\le13$ is weaker than this input, the case $n=4$ is a consistency check, not evidence for the hypothesis. For $n=5$ it holds for the same reason, as $d(5)\le21=n^2-4$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:bounds}), and again the conclusion $d(5)\le22$ is weaker than the input. For $n\ge6$ the hypothesis is open. It would follow from $d(n)\le n^2-4$ (as $U_B\subseteq C_{n^2-3}\cap B_n^{(n^2-3)}$), and hence from Kuzmin's conjecture. It is a statement about one self-conjugate block: no coupling between shapes is left. \begin{remark}[the shapes $B(n,2)$]\label{rem:Bn2} The partitions whose removable corners have contents exactly $\{2,0,-2\}$ are exactly the $B(n,2)$, $n\ge3$, one for each size, and all of them are self-conjugate. Indeed, the removable contents $x_1<\dots5$. \end{remark} \section{A Casimir criterion for the kernels $K_\lambda$}\label{sec:casimir} The kernel statements of Section~\ref{sec:decoupling} concern the spaces $K_\lambda$ of the shapes $\lambda=\lambda(\nu)$ near the corner of the box. In this section we put $\lambda(\nu)$ back into the box, using the $|\nu|$ cells that are left over. Inside the single irreducible module of the box, the $N$ conditions ``$f$ vanishes on $\Stab(j)$'' add up to one Casimir identity. This gives a uniform bound on the conjugation types that can occur in $K_{\lambda(\nu)}$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:casimir}) and an exact description of the joint kernel of all box shapes of one size (Theorem~\ref{thm:jointkernel}). Nothing in this section needs the rectangle to be a square. No new bound on $d(n)$ is claimed here. \subsection{Setting}\label{subsec:casimirsetting} Let $R$ be a rectangle, $k\ge0$ and $N=|R|-k\ge1$ (in this section $k$ is $|\nu|$, not the $k$ of a fixed program in Section~\ref{sec:decoupling}). Split $[|R|]=I\sqcup O$ with $I=[N]$ (a set, not the ideal of (F4)) and $O=\{N+1,\dots,|R|\}$, so $|O|=k$. For a partition $\alpha\subseteq R$, $\overline{\alpha}$ is the complement of $\alpha$ in $R$, rotated by $180$ degrees; it is a partition. For $\nu\vdash k$ inside $R$ put $\lambda(\nu):=\overline{\nu}$, the rectangle with $\nu$ removed at its corner, as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:program}. For a partition $\kappa$ with $\kappa_1\le k$, $\kappa^{+k}$ is $\kappa$ with one cell added at the bottom of each of the columns $1,\dots,k$; it has exactly $k$ columns. In this section $F=\mathbb{R}$; the spaces $K_\lambda$ and $JK_N$ (below) are defined over $\mathbb{Q}$, so their dimensions and their decompositions do not depend on the field of characteristic $0$. Each $\rho_\lambda$ is Young's orthogonal form \cite[Ch.~3]{CST10}, so $\rho_\lambda(\sigma^{-1})=\rho_\lambda(\sigma)^T$. On $\End(S^\lambda)$ we use $\langle A,B\rangle:=\tr(A^TB)$ (not the coefficient form of (F3)) and the conjugation action $\operatorname{Ad}(s)A:=\rho_\lambda(s)A\rho_\lambda(s)^T$, extended linearly to $F[S_N]$. For $M\in\End(S^\lambda)$ let $f_M\in F[S_N]$ be the element with $f_M(\sigma)=\langle M,\rho_\lambda(\sigma)\rangle$. By (F2), $f_M=(N!/f^\lambda)\,f$ for the $f\in I_\lambda$ with $\rho_\lambda(f)=M$; so $M\mapsto f_M$ is a linear bijection $\End(S^\lambda)\to I_\lambda$, and $f_{\operatorname{Ad}(s)M}(\sigma)=f_M(s^{-1}\sigma s)$. $K_\lambda$ is stable under conjugation by $S_N$ (vanishing on the permutations with a fixed point is a conjugation-invariant condition), so it is the direct sum of its $\kappa$-isotypic parts; $\kappa$ is a \emph{conjugation type} of $K_\lambda$ if its $\kappa$-part is nonzero. For $j\in[N]$ let $\Delta_j$ be the orthogonal projection of $\End(S^\lambda)$ onto $\rho_\lambda(F[\Stab(j)])$; then $f_M$ vanishes on $\Stab(j)$ iff $\Delta_jM=0$. $g(\alpha,\beta,\gamma)$ is the Kronecker coefficient. Let $\operatorname{Mult}(\tau):=\operatorname{Hom}_{S_{|R|}}(S^\tau,\End(S^R))$ for the action $\operatorname{Ad}$. Under $\operatorname{Ad}$, $\End(S^R)\cong S^R\otimes S^R$, so the $\tau$-isotypic part $\End(S^R)^\tau$ is $S^\tau\otimes\operatorname{Mult}(\tau)$ (an element $x$ of $\operatorname{Mult}(\tau)$ applied to $v\in S^\tau$), with $\dim\operatorname{Mult}(\tau)=g(R,R,\tau)$. $\mathcal{T}=\sum_t t$ (over all transpositions of $S_{|R|}$) and $\mathcal{T}_I$ (over those of $S_I$); $\operatorname{Ad}(\mathcal{T})$ acts on $\End(S^R)^\tau$ by the scalar $c(\tau)$. Let $\Omega(O)$ be the commutant of $\rho_R(S_O)$ in $\End(S^R)$, and for $j\in I$ let $\Omega_j$ be the commutant of $\rho_R(S_{O\cup\{j\}})$. \subsection{Four lemmas} \begin{lemma}[rectangles]\label{lem:rect} For $a+b=|R|$, $\alpha\vdash a$ and $\beta\vdash b$, the Littlewood--Richardson coefficient $c^R_{\alpha,\beta}$ is $1$ if $\alpha\subseteq R$ and $\beta=\overline{\alpha}$, and $0$ otherwise. Hence: \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*),leftmargin=*] \item $\Res_{S_I\times S_O}S^R=\bigoplus_{\nu\vdash k,\ \nu\subseteq R}S^{\lambda(\nu)}\boxtimes S^\nu$, with pairwise different $\nu$ and pairwise different $\lambda(\nu)$; the same holds for $S_{I\setminus\{j\}}\times S_{O\cup\{j\}}$, with the blocks $S^{\overline{\mu}}\boxtimes S^\mu$, $\mu\vdash k+1$; \item $\Omega(O)=\bigoplus_\nu\End(S^{\lambda(\nu)})\otimes1_\nu$; \item $\Omega_j=\rho_R(F[S_{I\setminus\{j\}}])$; \item in Young's orthogonal basis $\{v_T\}$ of $S^R$, ordered by the pair (the restriction of $T$ to $I$, the restriction to $O$), the block of $\nu$ is $S^{\lambda(\nu)}\otimes S^\nu$ with the product orthonormal basis: $S_I$ acts by $\rho_{\lambda(\nu)}\otimes1$, and $S_O$ by $1\otimes\rho'$, with $\rho'$ orthogonally equivalent to $\rho_\nu$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Here and in the proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:tworow}, $s_\alpha$, $s_{R/\alpha}$ and $h_a$ are the Schur, skew Schur and complete symmetric functions (not the standard polynomials of Subsection~\ref{subsec:hooks}), and $\langle\,,\rangle$ on symmetric functions is the Hall inner product \cite[I]{Ma95}. $R/\alpha$ rotated by $180$ degrees is the straight shape $\overline{\alpha}$, and skew Schur functions do not change under this rotation, so $s_{R/\alpha}=s_{\overline{\alpha}}$ and $c^R_{\alpha,\beta}=\langle s_{R/\alpha},s_\beta\rangle=[\beta=\overline{\alpha}]$. The map $\alpha\mapsto\overline{\alpha}$ is injective; this gives (i). (ii): $\Res_{S_O}S^R$ is the sum of the pairwise different $S^\nu$, each with multiplicity space $S^{\lambda(\nu)}$; by Schur's lemma the commutant is $\bigoplus\End(S^{\lambda(\nu)})\otimes1_\nu$. (iii): in the same way the commutant of $S_{O\cup\{j\}}$ is $\bigoplus_\mu\End(S^{\overline{\mu}})\otimes1_\mu$. The $\overline{\mu}$ are pairwise different irreducibles of $S_{I\setminus\{j\}}$, so by (F6) and (F2) $\rho_R(F[S_{I\setminus\{j\}}])$ is this sum too. (iv): in Young's orthogonal form, $s_i=(i,i+1)$ acts on $v_T$ through the contents of the cells of $i$ and $i+1$ only, and changes $T$ only in these two entries. For $iN$ both lie in $T|_O$. So $s_i$ ($iN$) by the orthogonal form of the skew shape $R/\lambda(\nu)$. A rotation of $R/\lambda(\nu)$ by $180$ degrees with reversed entries keeps every axial distance, so the latter is the orthogonal form of $\nu$, relabelled by conjugation with the longest element of $S_O$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:Ej} For $j\in I$ let $\Pi_j:=\frac1{(k+1)!}\sum_{\pi\in S_{O\cup\{j\}}}\operatorname{Ad}(\pi)$, and for $Z\in\End(S^R)$ let $\phi_Z(\sigma):=\langle Z,\rho_R(\sigma)\rangle$ for $\sigma\in S_I$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item $\Pi_j$ is the orthogonal projection of $\End(S^R)$ onto $\Omega_j$, and for every $Z$: $\Pi_jZ=0$ iff $\phi_Z$ vanishes on $S_{I\setminus\{j\}}=\Stab_{S_I}(j)$. \item For $Z=\sum_\nu M_\nu\otimes1_\nu\in\Omega(O)$ with $M_\nu\in\End(S^{\lambda(\nu)})$: $\phi_Z=\sum_\nu f^\nu f_{M_\nu}$, with $f_{M_\nu}\in I_{\lambda(\nu)}$. The map $Z\mapsto\phi_Z$ is a linear bijection $\Omega(O)\to\bigoplus_\nu I_{\lambda(\nu)}$, and $\phi_{\operatorname{Ad}(s)Z}(\sigma)=\phi_Z(s^{-1}\sigma s)$ for $s\in S_I$. \item In particular, for one block $Z=M\otimes1_\nu$: $\Pi_jZ=0$ iff $\Delta_jM=0$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) $\operatorname{Ad}$ is orthogonal for $\langle\,,\rangle$, as $\rho_R$ is orthogonal, so averaging over $S_{O\cup\{j\}}$ is the orthogonal projection onto the $\operatorname{Ad}(S_{O\cup\{j\}})$-fixed space, which is $\Omega_j$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:rect}(iii), $\Omega_j$ is spanned by the $\rho_R(\sigma)$, $\sigma\in S_{I\setminus\{j\}}$, so $\Pi_jZ=0$ iff $Z\perp\rho_R(\sigma)$ for all these $\sigma$. (b) By Lemma~\ref{lem:rect}(iv), $\rho_R(\sigma)$ ($\sigma\in S_I$) acts on the block of $\nu$ as $\rho_{\lambda(\nu)}(\sigma)\otimes1$, so $\langle M_\nu\otimes1_\nu,\rho_R(\sigma)\rangle=f^\nu\langle M_\nu,\rho_{\lambda(\nu)}(\sigma)\rangle$, and different blocks are orthogonal. The $\lambda(\nu)$ are pairwise different, $f^\nu\ne0$, and $M\mapsto f_M$ is a bijection onto $I_\lambda$; so $Z\mapsto\phi_Z$ is a bijection. Equivariance: $\langle\rho(s)Z\rho(s)^T,\rho(\sigma)\rangle=\langle Z,\rho(s^{-1}\sigma s)\rangle$. (c) $\phi_Z=f^\nu f_M$, and by (a), $\Pi_jZ=0$ iff $f_M=0$ on $\Stab(j)$ iff $\Delta_jM=0$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[Casimir identity]\label{lem:casimiridentity} For every $Z\in\Omega(O)$, \[ (k+1)\sum_{j\in I}\Pi_jZ=\Bigl(N-\binom k2\Bigr)Z+\operatorname{Ad}(\mathcal{T})Z-\operatorname{Ad}(\mathcal{T}_I)Z . \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} $S_{O\cup\{j\}}=\bigsqcup_{x\in O\cup\{j\}}t_{xj}S_O$, where $t_{xj}$ is the transposition $(x\,j)$ and $t_{jj}:=\mathrm{id}$ (the left cosets of $S_O$ are told apart by the image of $j$). Since $\operatorname{Ad}(s)Z=Z$ for $s\in S_O$, $(k+1)\Pi_jZ=Z+\sum_{i\in O}\operatorname{Ad}(t_{ij})Z$. Sum over $j\in I$. The transpositions $t_{ij}$ with $i\in O$, $j\in I$ are all transpositions of $S_{|R|}$ except those of $S_I$ and the $\binom k2$ of $S_O$, and each of the latter fixes $Z$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[a minimal horizontal strip]\label{lem:strip} Let $\kappa\vdash N$ and $\tau\supseteq\kappa$ with $\tau/\kappa$ a horizontal strip of $k$ cells, and let $s(\tau/\kappa)$ be the sum of the contents of the cells of $\tau/\kappa$. Then $s(\tau/\kappa)\ge\binom k2-N$, with equality iff $\kappa_1\le k$ and $\tau=\kappa^{+k}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The cells lie in different columns $b_1<\dotsk$, then $f_M\in K_\lambda$ only for $M=0$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} $Z:=M\otimes1_\nu\in\Omega(O)$, and $\operatorname{Ad}(\mathcal{T}_I)Z=c(\kappa)Z$, as $\mathcal{T}_I$ is central in $F[S_I]$ and $Z$ has $S_I$-type $\kappa$. Write $Z=\sum_\tau Z_\tau$ with $Z_\tau\in\End(S^R)^\tau$; these parts are mutually orthogonal. The isotypic projections are $\operatorname{Ad}$ of central idempotents of $F[S_{|R|}]$, so they commute with $\operatorname{Ad}(S_I\times S_O)$: each $Z_\tau$ lies in $\Omega(O)$ and has $S_I$-type $\kappa$. If $Z_\tau\ne0$, then $\Res_{S_I\times S_O}S^\tau$ contains $S^\kappa\boxtimes(\text{trivial})$, so $\tau/\kappa$ is a horizontal strip of $k$ cells (Pieri's rule), and $c(\tau)-c(\kappa)=s(\tau/\kappa)$. Since each $\Pi_j$ is an orthogonal projection, Lemma~\ref{lem:casimiridentity} gives \[ \sum_{j\in I}\|\Pi_jZ\|^2=\sum_{j\in I}\langle Z,\Pi_jZ\rangle=\frac1{k+1}\sum_\tau\Bigl(s(\tau/\kappa)-\Bigl(\binom k2-N\Bigr)\Bigr)\|Z_\tau\|^2 . \] By Lemma~\ref{lem:strip} every coefficient is $\ge0$, with equality iff $\tau=\kappa^{+k}$; if $\kappa_1>k$, then $\kappa^{+k}$ does not exist and every coefficient is $>0$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:Ej}(c), $f_M\in K_\lambda$ iff every $\Pi_jZ=0$, iff the left side is $0$, iff $Z_\tau=0$ for every $\tau\ne\kappa^{+k}$ (for $\kappa_1>k$: iff $Z=0$). \end{proof} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:casimir} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item Every conjugation type $\kappa$ of $K_{\lambda(\nu)}$ has $\kappa_1\le|\nu|$, and its multiplicity is at most $g(R,R,\kappa^{+k})$. \item Let $\Psi\colon S^\kappa\otimes\operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k})\to\Omega(O)$ be the $S_I$-map that sends $v\otimes x$ to $x$ applied to $v$, where $S^\kappa$ is the $\kappa\boxtimes(\text{trivial})$ component of $\Res_{S_I\times S_O}S^{\kappa^{+k}}$ (it occurs once, since $c^{\kappa^{+k}}_{\kappa,(k)}=1$), and let $\pi_{\nu'}\colon\Omega(O)\to\End(S^{\lambda(\nu')})$ be the block projections. Put $X_\nu:=\{x\in\operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k}):\pi_{\nu'}(\Psi(v\otimes x))=0$ for all $v\in S^\kappa$ and all $\nu'\ne\nu\}$. Then the multiplicity space $\operatorname{Hom}_{S_N}(S^\kappa,K_{\lambda(\nu)})$ is isomorphic to $X_\nu$. \end{enumerate} \end{corollary} \begin{proof} $\Psi$ is injective, with image the $S_O$-fixed, $S_I$-type-$\kappa$ part of $\End(S^R)^{\kappa^{+k}}\cong S^{\kappa^{+k}}\otimes \operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k})$ (by Pieri's rule, multiplicity $1$). By Theorem~\ref{thm:casimir}, $f_M\mapsto M\otimes1_\nu$ maps the $\kappa$-part of $K_{\lambda(\nu)}$ injectively and $S_I$-equivariantly onto the part of $\Psi(S^\kappa\otimes\operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k}))$ that lies in the single block $\nu$. Its preimage is an $S_I$-submodule of $S^\kappa\otimes\operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k})$ ($S_I$ acting on the first factor only), hence of the form $S^\kappa\otimes X$, and $X=X_\nu$. This gives (b), and (a) since $\dim X_\nu\le g(R,R,\kappa^{+k})$. \end{proof} For example (by direct computation), for $n=3$ and $\nu=(2,1)$, $K_{\lambda(\nu)}=K_{(3,2,1)}$ has the conjugation types $(3,3)$ and $(3,1,1,1)$, each once and each with $3=|\nu|$ columns. \subsection{The joint kernel}\label{subsec:jointkernel} \begin{theorem}[joint kernel]\label{thm:jointkernel} Let $\mathcal{F}_N\subseteq F[S_N]$ be the span of the permutations of $[N]$ without fixed points, and $JK_N:=\bigl(\bigoplus_{\lambda\vdash N,\ \lambda\subseteq R}I_\lambda\bigr)\cap\mathcal{F}_N$. Under the conjugation action of $S_N$, \[ JK_N\cong\bigoplus_{\kappa\vdash N,\ \kappa_1\le k}S^\kappa\otimes F^{\,g(R,R,\kappa^{+k})} . \] \end{theorem} \begin{proof} (1) The shapes of size $N$ inside $R$ are exactly the $\lambda(\nu)$, $\nu\vdash k$, $\nu\subseteq R$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:Ej}(b), $Z\mapsto\phi_Z$ is an $S_I$-equivariant linear bijection $\Omega(O)\to\bigoplus_\nu I_{\lambda(\nu)}$, and by Lemma~\ref{lem:Ej}(a), $\phi_Z\in JK_N$ iff $\phi_Z$ vanishes on $\Stab_{S_I}(j)$ for every $j\in I$, iff $\Pi_jZ=0$ for every $j\in I$. (2) The space $\{Z\in\Omega(O):\Pi_jZ=0\text{ for all }j\in I\}$ is $\operatorname{Ad}(S_I)$-stable: for $s\in S_I$, $\operatorname{Ad}(s)\Pi_j \operatorname{Ad}(s)^{-1}=\Pi_{s(j)}$, because $s$ fixes $O$ pointwise and $sS_{O\cup\{j\}}s^{-1}=S_{O\cup\{s(j)\}}$. So it is the direct sum of its $\kappa$-parts. (3) For $Z\in\Omega(O)$ of $S_I$-type $\kappa$ (not necessarily in one block), the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:casimir} applies word for word, since it uses only $Z\in\Omega(O)$ and $\operatorname{Ad}(\mathcal{T}_I)Z=c(\kappa)Z$: so $\Pi_jZ=0$ for all $j$ iff $Z\in\End(S^R)^{\kappa^{+k}}$, and $Z=0$ if $\kappa_1>k$. (4) Hence the $\kappa$-part of $JK_N$ is isomorphic to the $S_O$-fixed, $S_I$-type-$\kappa$ part of $\End(S^R)^{\kappa^{+k}}$, which is $S^\kappa\otimes\operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k})$, as in Corollary~\ref{cor:casimir}. \end{proof} For the square $R=(n^n)$ and $N\ge2$, $U(S)\subseteq JK_N$ for the set $S$ of the box shapes of size $N$, since $N$-cycles have no fixed points; so $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}\subseteq JK_N$. For $k=0$ no $\kappa$ has $\kappa_1\le0$, so $JK_{n^2}=0$, which gives Theorem~\ref{thm:A} again. For $k=1$ the only $\kappa\vdash n^2-1$ with $\kappa_1\le1$ is $(1^{n^2-1})$, with $\kappa^{+1}=(1^{n^2})$ and $g(R,R,(1^{n^2}))=1$ (as $R=R'$). So $JK_{n^2-1}$ is one copy of the sign representation. Over $\mathbb{C}$ it is $\operatorname{span}(f_\Gamma)$ for the shape $\lambda(1)=(n^{n-1},n-1)$ (the shape $\nu$ of Section~\ref{sec:B}): by ($\Gamma$) and the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:D}, $K_{\lambda(1)}=\operatorname{span}(f_\Gamma)$ with $f_\Gamma\ne0$; $f_\Gamma$ has conjugation type sign and is supported on $h(\lambda(1))=(2n-1,2n-3,\dots,3)$, which has no fixed point. For $n\ge3$, $h(\lambda(1))$ has $n-1\ge2$ parts, so $C_{n^2-1}\cap B_n^{(n^2-1)}=0$: Theorem~\ref{thm:B} again. \begin{proposition}[two-row Kronecker coefficients of a rectangle]\label{prop:tworow} For every rectangle $R$ and $1\le u\le|R|/2$, \[ g\bigl(R,R,(|R|-u,u)\bigr)=\#_u(R)-\#_{u-1}(R), \] where $\#_i(R)$ is the number of partitions of $i$ inside $R$. \end{proposition} This is a lemma of Pak and Panova \cite[Lemma~3]{PP13}, stated there for every rectangle (see also \cite{PPV16}); we include the short proof from Lemma~\ref{lem:rect}. \begin{proof} By Jacobi--Trudi, $s_{(a,b)}=h_ah_b-h_{a+1}h_{b-1}$ for $a\ge b\ge1$. Let $*$ be the Kronecker product of symmetric functions. Then $\langle s_R*s_R,h_ah_b\rangle=\dim(S^R\otimes S^R)^{S_a\times S_b}=\sum_{\alpha\vdash a,\beta\vdash b}(c^R_{\alpha,\beta})^2$, which by Lemma~\ref{lem:rect} is the number of $\alpha\vdash a$ inside $R$, that is $\#_a(R)=\#_b(R)$ (via $\alpha\mapsto\overline{\alpha}$). So $g(R,R,(a,b))=\#_b(R)-\#_{b-1}(R)$. \end{proof} For the square and $k=2$, Theorem~\ref{thm:jointkernel} and Proposition~\ref{prop:tworow} give the joint kernel explicitly. The types are $\kappa=(2^i,1^{N-2i})$, $0\le i\le N/2$, $N=n^2-2$, and $\kappa^{+2}=(2^{i+1},1^{N-2i})$ has conjugate $(n^2-i-1,i+1)$. Since $g(R,R,\tau')=g(R,R',\tau)=g(R,R,\tau)$ for $R=R'$, \[ JK_{n^2-2}\cong\bigoplus_{0\le i\le N/2}S^{(2^i,1^{N-2i})}\otimes F^{m_i},\qquad m_i=\#_{i+1}(n^n)-\#_i(n^n). \] For $n=3$, $(m_0,\dots,m_3)=(0,1,1,0)$; for $n=4$, $(m_0,\dots,m_7)=(0,1,1,2,0,2,0,1)$. \begin{remark}[scope]\label{rem:casimirscope} For $\lambda(3,1,1)$ (here $|\nu|=5$; this is statement (iii) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:F}, where $k=3$), Theorem~\ref{thm:casimir} says that every conjugation type of $K_{\lambda(3,1,1)}$ has at most $5$ columns. This does not decide (iii). At $n=4$ the joint kernel $JK_{11}$ is large (by direct computation, the type $(4,3,2,1,1)$ occurs $28$ times), while $K_{(4,3,3,1)}=0$, also by direct computation; so the single-block condition of Corollary~\ref{cor:casimir}(b) carries the real content. Lemma~\ref{lem:rect} needs the outer shape to be a rectangle: only then is the restriction of $S^R$ to $S_I\times S_O$ multiplicity-free with one block for each $\nu$. The smallest rectangle containing $\lambda(3,1,1)$ is the square, so $5$ columns is the best bound this method gives for $\lambda(3,1,1)$. \end{remark} \section{A bridge to PI degrees}\label{sec:PI} The blocks $I_\mu$ correspond, through the hook theorem of Berele--Regev and Sergeev, to Kemer's superalgebras $M_{k,l}(\Lambda)$. In this section we show that an element of $C_N$ lies in one block $I_\lambda$ exactly when its polynomial is an identity of each $M_{r-1,c-1}(\Lambda)$, one for each corner $(r,c)$ of $\lambda$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer}), and we translate our results into statements about PI degrees. Conversely, a lower bound for the PI degree of one algebra $M_{a,b}(\Lambda)$ gives an upper bound for $d(n)$ (Theorems~\ref{thm:transfer} and~\ref{thm:transfertwo}). Samoilov \cite{Sa10} proved an upper bound for these PI degrees and conjectured that it is sharp; Corollaries~\ref{cor:samoilov} and~\ref{cor:samoilovquad} record what the lower half of Samoilov's conjecture gives, and Subsection~\ref{subsec:staircase} shows that every staircase block meets the $N$-cycles, and Subsection~\ref{subsec:ceiling} that, therefore, one-shape arguments stop at $k=S(n)-1$. \subsection{Kemer's algebras and the dictionary}\label{subsec:kemer} $\Lambda$ is the Grassmann algebra of Subsection~\ref{subsec:threecorners}, with even part $\Lambda_0$ and odd part $\Lambda_1$. For $k,l\ge0$, $M_{k,l}(\Lambda)$ is the algebra of $(k+l)\times(k+l)$ matrices over $\Lambda$ with entries in $\Lambda_0$ in the two diagonal blocks of sizes $k$ and $l$ and entries in $\Lambda_1$ off them; $M_{1,1}(\Lambda)$ is the algebra of Subsection~\ref{subsec:threecorners}, $M_{k,l}(\Lambda)\cong M_{l,k}(\Lambda)$, and $M_{k,0}(\Lambda)=M_k(\Lambda_0)$ has the same multilinear identities as $M_k(F)$. For an algebra $\mathcal{A}$, $\operatorname{Id}(\mathcal{A})\subseteq F\langle X\rangle$ is the T-ideal of its identities, and $\operatorname{PIdeg}(\mathcal{A})$ is the least degree of a nonzero identity; it is attained by a multilinear identity (take a nonzero multihomogeneous component, as in (F1), and linearize it). Let $\mathcal{H}(k,l):=\{\mu:\mu_{k+1}\le l\}$, the $(k,l)$-hook. A \emph{corner} of $\lambda$ is a cell $(r,c)$ with $\lambda_r=c>\lambda_{r+1}$, and $\lambda$ is the union of the rectangles $(c^r)$ over its corners. The \emph{fat cross} of $(k,l)$ is $\Xi_{k,l}:=((l+1)^{k+1})\cup((k+1)^{l+1})$; it is self-conjugate, $\Xi_{k,l}=\Xi_{l,k}$, and $|\Xi_{k,l}|=(l+1)^2-(l-k)^2=(k+1)(2l-k+1)$ for $k\le l$. Let $\mathcal{W}=F^{k|l}$, with $k$ even and $l$ odd basis vectors, and let $S_N$ act on $\mathcal{W}^{\otimes N}$ by permuting the factors with the Koszul sign. The \emph{hook theorem} of Berele--Regev \cite{BR87} and Sergeev \cite{Se85} says that the kernel of $F[S_N]\to\End(\mathcal{W}^{\otimes N})$ is exactly $\bigoplus_{\mu\notin\mathcal{H}(k,l)}I_\mu$; for $(k,l)=(1,1)$ this is step (5)(a) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:threecorners}. We use both directions: ``no module outside the hook occurs'' ($\bigoplus_{\mu\notin\mathcal{H}}I_\mu$ lies in the kernel) and ``every hook module occurs'' (the kernel lies in $\bigoplus_{\mu\notin\mathcal{H}}I_\mu$). \begin{lemma}[supertrace duality]\label{lem:superduality} Let $N\ge2$, $g\in V_{N-1}$ and $f=\Phi(g)$. Then $f$ acts as $0$ on $\mathcal{W}^{\otimes N}$ if and only if $g\in\operatorname{Id}(M_{k,l}(\Lambda))$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} ``If'' is step (5)(b) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:threecorners}, with $\mathcal{W}=F^{k|l}$ in place of $F^{1|1}$: the supertrace formula for even $X_1,\dots,X_N\in\End(\mathcal{W})\otimes\Lambda$ \cite{Be88,Ra87} holds for every $(k,l)$, and the rest of the argument does not use $k=l=1$. ``Only if'': if $f$ acts as $0$, it acts as $0$ on the $\Lambda$-linear extension to $(\mathcal{W}\otimes\Lambda)^{\otimes N}$, so $\operatorname{str}(g(X_1,\dots,X_{N-1})X_N)=0$ for all $X_i\in M_{k,l}(\Lambda)$. Fix $X_1,\dots,X_{N-1}$ and put $Y:=g(X_1,\dots,X_{N-1})$. For a position $(i,j)$ take $X_N:=e_{ji}\otimes\xi$, with $\xi=1$ if $(j,i)$ is an even position and $\xi$ a Grassmann generator that does not occur in $Y$ if it is odd. Then $\operatorname{str}(YX_N)=\pm Y_{ij}\xi$, which is $0$ only if $Y_{ij}=0$. So $Y=0$. Conventions: $\Phi(g^{\mathrm{rev}})=\Phi(g)^\vee$, where $\vee$ is the map $\sigma\mapsto\sigma^{-1}$ of (F3) and $g^{\mathrm{rev}}$ reverses every monomial. The kernel of the action is a two-sided ideal, hence a sum of blocks, and $\vee$ fixes each $e_\mu$, so every block is $\vee$-stable; so the orientation of the supertrace formula does not matter. Another super-sign convention replaces $\sigma$ by $\varepsilon(\sigma)$, which turns $\mathcal{H}(k,l)$ into $\mathcal{H}(l,k)$; on $C_N$ this does not change the condition, by (F7) ($\varepsilon(f)=(-1)^{N-1}f$, so $f$ acts as $0$ iff $\varepsilon(f)$ does). \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[the Kemer dictionary]\label{lem:kemer} Let $N\ge2$, let $\lambda\vdash N$ have the corners $(r_1,c_1),\dots,(r_s,c_s)$, and let $g\in V_{N-1}$. Then \[ \Phi(g)\in I_\lambda\iff g\in\operatorname{Id}\bigl(M_{r_i-1,c_i-1}(\Lambda)\bigr)\ \text{for every }i=1,\dots,s . \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By the hook theorem and Lemma~\ref{lem:superduality}, $g\in\operatorname{Id}(M_{r-1,c-1}(\Lambda))$ iff $\Phi(g)\in\bigoplus_{\mu\notin \mathcal{H}(r-1,c-1)}I_\mu$, and $\mu\notin\mathcal{H}(r-1,c-1)$ iff $\mu_r\ge c$ iff $\mu\supseteq(c^r)$. The block decomposition is direct, so the intersection over $i$ is $\bigoplus I_\mu$ over the $\mu\vdash N$ that contain every $(c_i^{r_i})$, that is, $\mu\supseteq\lambda$; and the only such $\mu$ is $\lambda$. \end{proof} For one corner this is the super form of the Razmyslov--Procesi duality \cite{Ra87,Be88}; the intersection over several corners is a short observation. The direction ``$\Rightarrow$'' of Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer} uses ``no module outside the hook occurs'' and ``only if'' of Lemma~\ref{lem:superduality}; the direction ``$\Leftarrow$'' uses ``every hook module occurs'' and ``if''. \begin{corollary}[one block]\label{cor:kemerblock} $U_\lambda\ne0$ if and only if the \emph{corner algebra} $\bigoplus_iM_{r_i-1,c_i-1}(\Lambda)$ satisfies a nonzero identity of degree at most $N-1$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} ``Only if'': $\Phi^{-1}$ of a nonzero element of $U_\lambda$ is such an identity, by Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer}. ``If'': take a nonzero multilinear identity of degree $d\le N-1$ (as above), multiply it on the right by new letters $x_{d+1}\cdots x_{N-1}$ (identities form an ideal) and rename the letters; $\Phi$ of the result is a nonzero element of $C_N\cap I_\lambda$, by Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer}. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}[PI degrees]\label{cor:PIdeg} Let $(k_1,l_1),\dots,(k_t,l_t)$ be pairs of nonnegative integers, with some $k_j+l_j\ge1$, and $\Xi:=\bigcup_j\Xi_{k_j,l_j}$. For $N\ge2$, \[ \operatorname{Id}\Bigl(\bigoplus_jM_{k_j,l_j}(\Lambda)\Bigr)\cap V_{N-1}=\Phi^{-1}\Bigl(C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\vdash N,\ \mu\supseteq\Xi}I_\mu\Bigr). \] Hence $\operatorname{PIdeg}\bigl(\bigoplus_jM_{k_j,l_j}(\Lambda)\bigr)=\min\{N:C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\vdash N,\ \mu\supseteq\Xi}I_\mu\ne0\}-1\ge|\Xi|-1$, with equality if and only if $U_\Xi\ne0$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} By the hook theorem and Lemma~\ref{lem:superduality}, $\operatorname{Id}(M_{k,l}(\Lambda))\cap V_{N-1}=\Phi^{-1}(C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\notin \mathcal{H}(k,l)}I_\mu)$. By Proposition~\ref{prop:signtwist} we may intersect the index set with its conjugate, and $\mu'\notin\mathcal{H}(k,l)$ iff $\mu\notin\mathcal{H}(l,k)$; and $\mu\notin\mathcal{H}(k,l)\cup\mathcal{H}(l,k)$ iff $\mu\supseteq((l+1)^{k+1})$ and $\mu\supseteq((k+1)^{l+1})$, iff $\mu\supseteq\Xi_{k,l}$. The identities of a direct sum are the intersection of the identities of the summands, and the blocks are direct; this gives the formula. An identity of degree $d$ gives identities of every degree $N-1\ge d$ (as in the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:kemerblock}), so $\operatorname{PIdeg}$ is the least $N-1$ for which the right side is nonzero. For $N<|\Xi|$ no $\mu\vdash N$ contains $\Xi$, and for $N=|\Xi|$ only $\mu=\Xi$ does. \end{proof} Every self-conjugate $\lambda$ is the union of the fat crosses $\Xi_{r-1,c-1}$ over its corners $(r,c)$ (its corners come in pairs $(r,c)$, $(c,r)$, and $\lambda$ is the union of the rectangles $(c^r)$ over its corners), so Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg} covers the corner algebra of every self-conjugate shape. \subsection{Our results in the language of PI degrees}\label{subsec:PIresults} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:PIresults} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item For $l\ge1$, $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_l(F))=2l$. \item $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{1,1}(\Lambda))=5$. \item For $k\ge2$, $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_k(F)\oplus M_{1,1}(\Lambda))=2k+1$. \item For $1\le k\le l$, $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{k,l}(\Lambda))\ge(k+1)(2l-k+1)$. \end{enumerate} \end{proposition} \begin{proof} (a) $\Xi_{0,l}=(l+1,1^l)$ is a self-conjugate hook, so $U_{\Xi_{0,l}}\ne0$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:D}), and Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg} gives $\operatorname{PIdeg}=|\Xi_{0,l}|-1=2l$. This is the Amitsur--Levitzki theorem \cite{AL50}, and by Lemma~\ref{lem:H} the identity found is $s_{2l}$; nothing here is new. (b) $\Xi_{1,1}=(2,2)$. At $N=4$ only $(2,2)$ contains it, and $U_{(2,2)}=0$ (Remark~\ref{rem:rectangles}). At $N=5$ the shapes containing $(2,2)$ are $(3,2)$ and $(2,2,1)$, and $U(\{(3,2),(2,2,1)\})=0$ (Remark~\ref{rem:nthree}). At $N=6$ the shape $(3,2,1)=A_2$ contains $(2,2)$, and $U_{(3,2,1)}\ne0$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:threecorners}). So $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{1,1}(\Lambda))=6-1=5$. (c) $\Xi_{0,k}\cup\Xi_{1,1}=(k+1,1^k)\cup(2,2)=A_k=(k+1,2,1^{k-1})$, of size $2k+2$, and $U_{A_k}\ne0$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:threecorners}); so Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg} gives $2k+1$. (d) By Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg} it suffices that $U_{\Xi_{k,l}}=0$. If $k=l$, $\Xi_{k,l}=((k+1)^{k+1})$ is a square (Remark~\ref{rem:rectangles}). If $kk$ lies in every box shape of size $n^2-k$, and the nearly square ones reach much further. \begin{theorem}[two-parameter transfer]\label{thm:transfertwo} Let $n\ge2$ and $1\le a\le b\le n-1$, and put $S:=(n-a)(n-b)$. If $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{a,b}(\Lambda))\ge n^2-S+1$, then $d(n)\le n^2-S$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Put $k:=S-1$ and $N:=n^2-k$; as $1\le S\le(n-1)^2$, $k\ge0$ and $N\ge2n$. Every $\lambda\vdash N$ inside the box is the box minus $\operatorname{rot}(\nu)$ for some $\nu\vdash k$, and $\lambda$ contains the cell $(r,c)$ if and only if $\nu$ does not contain the cell $(n+1-r,n+1-c)$. A partition that contains the cell $(i,j)$ contains the rectangle $(j^i)$, so it has at least $ij$ cells. For $(r,c)=(a+1,b+1)$ and $(r,c)=(b+1,a+1)$ this number is $(n-a)(n-b)=S>k$; so $\lambda$ contains both cells, hence the rectangles $((b+1)^{a+1})$ and $((a+1)^{b+1})$, that is, $\lambda\supseteq\Xi_{a,b}$. So $C_N\cap B_n^{(N)}\subseteq C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\vdash N,\ \mu\supseteq\Xi_{a,b}}I_\mu=\Phi(\operatorname{Id}(M_{a,b}(\Lambda))\cap V_{N-1})$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg}), which is $0$ by the hypothesis. So $d(n)\le N-1=n^2-S$ by Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion}. \end{proof} The condition $S>k$ is also necessary for $\Xi_{a,b}$ to lie in every box shape of size $n^2-k$: if $S\le k1$ and $a_0$ with $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{a,a}(\Lambda))\ge\gamma a^2$ for all $a\ge a_0$, then $d(n)\le\bigl(1-\bigl(\tfrac{\gamma-1}{\gamma+1}\bigr)^2+o(1)\bigr)n^2$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} For large $n$ put $a:=\lceil2n/(\gamma+1)\rceil+1$; then $a_0\le a\le n-1$, as $\gamma>1$. Since $(\gamma+1)a-2n\ge\gamma+1$, we have $(\gamma+1)a^2-2an\ge(\gamma+1)a\ge1$, that is, $\gamma a^2\ge2an-a^2+1=n^2-(n-a)^2+1$. So $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{a,a}(\Lambda))\ge n^2-(n-a)^2+1$, and Theorem~\ref{thm:transfertwo} with $b=a$ gives $d(n)\le n^2-(n-a)^2$, where $n-a\ge cn-2$ with $c:=\frac{\gamma-1}{\gamma+1}$; so $d(n)\le n^2-(cn-2)^2$ once $cn\ge2$. \end{proof} By Samoilov's theorem only $\gamma\le2$ is possible, and $\gamma=2$ is Samoilov's conjecture. For a \emph{fixed} saving the route $b=n-1$ asks less: with $p=n-a$, $q=n-b$, Theorem~\ref{thm:transfertwo} needs $2n(q-1)+p^2-3pq+2q$ more than Proposition~\ref{prop:PIresults}(d) gives, which is $(p-1)(p-2)$ for $q=1$, independent of $n$. For example, $d(n)\le n^2-4$ also follows from $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{n-4,n-1}(\Lambda))\ge|\Xi_{n-4,n-1}|+6$, while the square route needs $e(n-2)\ge2n-4$. \begin{lemma}[reach under Samoilov's value]\label{lem:reach} Let $n\ge3$ and $S(n):=\lfloor(n+2)/3\rfloor\lfloor(n+4)/3\rfloor$. Among the pairs $1\le a\le b\le n-1$ with $(a+1)(2b+1)-1\ge n^2-(n-a)(n-b)+1$, the largest value of $(n-a)(n-b)$ is $S(n)$, attained at $(a,b)=(n-\lfloor(n+4)/3\rfloor,\,n-\lfloor(n+2)/3\rfloor)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Put $p:=n-a\ge q:=n-b\ge1$. The condition reads $\Theta(p,q):=n^2-2n(p+q)+3n+3pq-p-2q-1\ge0$, and we maximise $pq$. (a) If $p\ge q+2$ and $\Theta(p,q)\ge0$, then $(p-1,q+1)$ is again admissible ($p-1\ge q+1\ge2$), $\Theta(p-1,q+1)=\Theta(p,q)+3(p-q)-4>0$, and $(p-1)(q+1)=pq+p-q-1>pq$. So every optimum has $p-q\in\{0,1\}$. (b) $p=q=s$: $\Theta=(n-s)(n-3s+3)-1$, and $n-s\ge1$; so $\Theta\ge0$ iff $s\le(n+2)/3$. The best is $s^2$ with $s=\lfloor(n+2)/3\rfloor$. (c) $p=s+1$, $q=s$: $\Theta=(n-s)(n-3s)+n-2$. If $n\ge3s$, $\Theta>0$. If $n=3s-1$, $\Theta=s-2$, which is $\ge0$ iff $s\ge2$. If $v:=3s-n\ge2$, then $p=s+1\le n-1$ gives $s\ge(v+2)/2$, and $\Theta=s(3-2v)+(v-2)(v+1)\le1-3v/2<0$. So $\Theta\ge0$ iff $s\le(n+1)/3$ (with $s\ge2$ when $n=3s-1$), and the best is $s(s+1)$; here $p=s+1\le n-1$ holds for $s=\lfloor(n+1)/3\rfloor$ as $n\ge3$. (d) For $n=3j$, $3j+1$, $3j+2$ the better of (b) and (c) is $j(j+1)$, $(j+1)^2$, $(j+1)(j+2)$, which is $S(n)$ in each case, and the optimal $p=\lfloor(n+4)/3\rfloor$ is at most $n-1$ because $n\ge3$. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}[the lower half of Samoilov's conjecture]\label{cor:samoilovquad} Let $n\ge3$ and $(a,b)=(n-\lfloor(n+4)/3\rfloor,\,n-\lfloor(n+2)/3\rfloor)$. If $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{a,b}(\Lambda))\ge n^2-S(n)+1$ (which the lower half of Samoilov's conjecture gives, by Lemma~\ref{lem:reach}), then $d(n)\le n^2-S(n)$; in particular $d(n)<\frac89n^2$, since $\lfloor(n+2)/3\rfloor\ge n/3$ and $\lfloor(n+4)/3\rfloor\ge(n+2)/3$ give $S(n)>n^2/9$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} Theorem~\ref{thm:transfertwo} and Lemma~\ref{lem:reach}. \end{proof} Here $b-a\le1$. At $n=2$ the formula would need $a=0$ and would say $d(2)\le2$, which is false; so $n\ge3$ is needed. The values of $n^2-S(n)$ are $12$, $19$, $30$, $40$ for $n=4,5,6,7$, and $84$, $344$, $2194$, $8844$ for $n=10,20,50,100$ (Kuzmin's $n(n+1)/2$: $10$, $15$, $21$, $28$, $55$, $210$, $1275$, $5050$; Corollary~\ref{cor:samoilov}: $14$, $22$, $33$, $45$, $95$, $390$, $2475$, $9950$). The needed bound and Samoilov's value at the optimal pair are $13$ and $14$ for $n=4$, $20$ and $20$ for $n=5$, $41$ and $44$ for $n=7$, $8845$ and $8910$ for $n=100$. For small $n$ these conditional bounds are weaker than the known values $d(3)=6$ and $d(4)=10$ (for $n=5$ the value $n^2-S(n)=19$ would be below the known $d(5)\le21$); the method is asymptotic. Since Samoilov's \emph{theorem} bounds every $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{a,b}(\Lambda))$ by $(a+1)(2b+1)-1$, Lemma~\ref{lem:reach} also shows (unconditionally) that no single algebra $M_{a,b}(\Lambda)$ gives more than $d(n)\le n^2-S(n)$ through Theorem~\ref{thm:transfertwo}. \subsection{The staircase blocks}\label{subsec:staircase} Let $\mathrm{St}_n:=(n,n-1,\dots,1)$, a self-conjugate partition of $n(n+1)/2$ whose corners are the cells $(r,n+1-r)$, $1\le r\le n$; so by Lemma~\ref{lem:kemer} its corner algebra (Corollary~\ref{cor:kemerblock}) is $\bigoplus_{k+l=n-1}M_{k,l}(\Lambda)$. For $n\ge2$ put \[ k_n(x,y):=\sum_{\pi}\sgn(\pi)\,x^{\pi(0)}yx^{\pi(1)}y\cdots yx^{\pi(n-1)}\in F\langle x,y\rangle, \] the sum over the permutations $\pi$ of $\{0,1,\dots,n-1\}$, with $x^0$ the empty word. It has degree $n(n+1)/2-1$. Kuzmin's word $yxyx^2\cdots yx^{n-1}$ \cite[Thm.~1.7]{Do18} is its term for $\pi=\mathrm{id}$, with coefficient $1$ (the reversed word is also a term). For example $k_2=[y,x]$ and $k_3=[[x,y]^2,x]$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:knidentity} If $k,l\ge0$ and $k+l\le n-1$, then $k_n$ is an identity of $M_{k,l}(\Lambda)$. For $k+l=n$ it is not, in general: in $M_n(F)\subseteq M_{n,0}(\Lambda)$, with rows and columns indexed $0,\dots,n-1$, take $x=\operatorname{diag}(0,1,\dots,n-1)$ and $y=\sum_ie_{i,i+1}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For elements $z_0,\dots,z_{n-1},y$ of a unital algebra $R$ put \[ \mathcal{C}(z_0,\dots,z_{n-1}):=\sum_\pi\sgn(\pi)\,z_{\pi(0)}yz_{\pi(1)}y\cdots yz_{\pi(n-1)}. \] It is multilinear over the centre of $R$ and alternating: if $z_i=z_j$ with $i\ne j$, then $\pi$ and $(i\,j)\circ\pi$ give the same product with opposite signs. Also $k_n(x,y)=\mathcal{C}(1,x,\dots,x^{n-1})$. If $x^d=\sum_{ik$, the hypothesis of Theorem~\ref{thm:transferstar} is weaker than that of Theorem~\ref{thm:transfertwo}; so under the lower half of Samoilov's conjecture Theorem~\ref{thm:transferstar} reaches $k=S(n)-1$, and, by Corollary~\ref{cor:ceiling}, no one-shape argument goes further: every such argument stops at about $\frac89n^2$ and cannot reach Kuzmin's $n^2/2$. For example, for $n=5$ and $k=6,7,8$, $\Xi^\cap_k\subseteq(4,4,3,2)\subseteq\mathrm{St}_5$, so $k_5$, of degree $14$, is a common identity of $\mathcal{A}^\cap_k$, while Theorem~\ref{thm:transferstar} would need none of degree at most $24-k$. \section{The first open block $B(n,2)$}\label{sec:Bn2} By Theorem~\ref{thm:E}, $d(n)\le n^2-3$ follows from $U_{B(n,2)}=0$, and $B(n,2)=\lambda(2,1)$ is statement (i) in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:F}. The shape has three corners, so Theorem~\ref{thm:D} does not apply, and Theorem~\ref{thm:casimir} says only that the conjugation types of $K_{B(n,2)}$ have at most $3$ columns. In this section we show that the part of $K_{\lambda(\nu)}$ near the sign representation, the conjugation types with many rows, is one finite problem for all large $n$, posed in the group algebra of only $|\nu|+m$ letters (Theorem~\ref{thm:window}), and we show that this holds for $n\ge m+|\nu|/2+1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:windowrange}). For $B(n,2)$ it gives one explicit element of $K_{B(n,2)}$ for every $n\ge4$ and determines $K_{B(n,2)}$ near the sign exactly (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bwindow}); so $U_{B(n,2)}=0$ cannot be proved by showing $K_{B(n,2)}=0$. For $\lambda(3,1,1)$, statement (iii), it shows by computation that there is no type near the sign (Proposition~\ref{prop:window311}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:pencil} writes the test as a pencil in the exponent of $\det(P_1)$ and, for integer exponents, as a problem on $n\times s$ rectangles, with a duality $n\leftrightarrow s$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:duality}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer} shows that for $\tau_3=1$ the pencil has no eigenvalue other than $(d-2)/n$, for every $n$: then $\mathrm{K}_s(n)_\tau=0$, and $K_{B(n,2)}$ has no type with at most two columns (Corollary~\ref{cor:firstlayer}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:secondlayer} writes the test with $\tau_3=2$ in closed form at diagonal base points and shows that every eigenvalue of the pencil at bidegree $(3,2)$ is $3/n$ or $6/n$; so $\mathrm{K}_s(n)_{(ns-5,3,2)}=0$ for every $n\ge4$ and every integer $s\ge1$ with $ns\ge8$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:secondlayer}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:sorder} shows that a nonzero invariant function of bidegree $(a,b)$ killed by $\mathcal{E}$ lies in the $m$-th power of the ideal of the closure of $\{(X,Y):X\text{ regular},\ Y\in\operatorname{Im}\operatorname{ad}_X\}$ only for $m\le\lfloor a/4\rfloor$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:sorder}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:lowering} applies the lowering operator of $\mathfrak{gl}_3$ to the line of Theorem~\ref{thm:pencil22} and shows that the pencil has the eigenvalue $\kappa=(a+3)/n$ on the invariant functions of bidegree $(a,2)$ killed by $\mathcal{E}$, for all $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+2$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:LW1}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:S12} shows that (S1) and (S2) are equivalent on $\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:S12}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:mirror} proves the mirror symmetry $(\kappa,n)\mapsto(-\kappa,-n)$ of the pencil at $b=2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:mirror}) and that $\kappa=-2$ is an eigenvalue for every even $a\ge4$ and $n\ge a+6$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:mirrorminus}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bzinj} shows that $\mathcal{Z}$ is injective on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$ for every $a\ge3$ and $n\ge3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Bzinj}), Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bthree} that it is injective on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,3)}(n)$ for every $n\ge4$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Bthreezinj}) and that, for every $(a,b)$ and $n\ge3$, an invariant function killed by $\mathcal{Z}$ is determined by its parts of degree $0$ and $1$ in the diagonal of $Y$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:orderred}), Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bfour} that $\ker\mathcal{Z}\cap\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,4)}(n)=0$ for every $n\ge5$ and $a\ge4$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Bfourzinj}; one step computer-assisted), and Subsection~\ref{subsec:theta} that $\mu=0$ is an eigenvalue for every $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:thetaall}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:topblock} shows that, at $b=2$, $n\ge a+6$ and $\kappa\ne0$, the coefficient of the top power-sum monomial in the data of an eigenvector has degree at most $3$ in the two points (Corollary~\ref{cor:topblock}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:oddrows} shows that, at $b=2$ and $n\ge a+6$, an eigenvector with $\mu\ne0$ lies on one explicit line, and that for odd $a$ every eigenvalue has $\mu\in\{0,3,5,\dots,a\}$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:oddrows}); with Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} this gives the conclusion of Conjecture~\ref{conj:L2} for every $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+6$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Ltwostable}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:Pone} shows that $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue at $b=2$ for odd $a$ at $18$ pairs with $4\le n\le8$, $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$ (at $n=7,8$ only $a\le n+5$; Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone}, computer-assisted). Subsection~\ref{subsec:Lfive} proves its step~(5) by hand for every $n$ and every dominant $a\ge n$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive}); so, for these $(n,a)$ with $n\ge4$, $\kappa=n$ is excluded wherever step~(2) holds (Corollary~\ref{cor:Lfive}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:Kseven} shows that at $n=7$, $\kappa=7$ is not an eigenvalue at $b=2$ for any $3\le a\le23$, of either parity (Theorem~\ref{thm:Kseven}, computer-assisted); so every type $\kappa$ of $K_{B(7,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3\le1$ is $(3,1^{43})$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Kseven}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:steptwo} counts the solutions of \eqref{eq:starn} by hand at every $n$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo}); so step~(2) holds for odd dominant $a$, and $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue at $b=2$ for every $n\ge4$ and every odd $a$ with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:steptwo}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:evena} reduces the even case to one polynomial, a triangle of order-one rows on the stable line (Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV}), and Subsection~\ref{subsec:triangle} computes it in closed form and shows that it is not $0$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:triangle}); so $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue at $b=2$ for every $n\ge4$ and every even $a$ with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$, and every type $\kappa$ of $K_{B(n,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3\le1$ is $(3,1^{N-3})$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}). At $b=3$, for $\varphi_f$ with $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$ and $3\le a\le(n^2-3)/2$, Subsections~\ref{subsec:EO}, \ref{subsec:Aone} and~\ref{subsec:Azero} exclude every $y$-order at $\kappa=n$ (Theorems~\ref{thm:EO}, \ref{thm:Aone} and~\ref{thm:Azero}; $y$-order $2$ cannot occur at $b=3$, Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape}), so no type with $\kappa'_3=2$ occurs (Corollary~\ref{cor:Lthree}). \subsection{The twisted window}\label{subsec:window} Throughout this section $R=(n^n)$, and we use the setting of Subsection~\ref{subsec:casimirsetting}: $\nu\vdash k$ lies inside $R$, $k\ge1$, $\lambda=\lambda(\nu)$, $N=n^2-k$, $[n^2]=I\sqcup O$ with $|O|=k$, and $F=\mathbb{R}$; all spaces below are defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. For $\kappa\vdash N$ we call $N-\ell(\kappa)$ the \emph{depth} of $\kappa$; the sign representation $(1^N)$ has depth $0$. Since $R=R'$, ($\Gamma$) gives an invertible $\Gamma_R\in\End(S^R)$ with $\Gamma_R\rho_R(\sigma)=\sgn(\sigma)\rho_R(\sigma)\Gamma_R$ for all $\sigma\in S_{n^2}$. Let $e_\nu\in F[S_O]$ be the central idempotent of $\nu$ (F2). Fix $D\subseteq I$ with $|D|=mp+q$ the shape $\lambda(\nu_{p,q})$ has three corners. Then $\nu_{1,1}=(2,1)$, $\nu_{1,2}=(3,3,2)$, $\nu_{2,1}=(3,1,1)$, $\nu_{2,2}=(4,4,2,2)$, $\nu_{3,1}=(4,1,1,1)$ and $\nu_{4,1}=(5,1^4)$. The computed values of $\dim\mathcal{Y}_m$ split by $p$: \begin{itemize}[leftmargin=*] \item $p=1$: for $(2,1)$, $\binom m2$ for $m\le6$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bwindow}); for $(3,3,2)$, $0,0,1,3,6$ for $m=0,\dots,4$, exact. Here an exact element of $\mathcal{Y}_2$ is known, $S_D$ acts on it (by $y\mapsto sys^{-1}$) by the sign, and $\mathcal{Y}_1=0$; as in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Bwindow}, its type is $(3,1^{N-3})$, which gives the lower bound $\binom m2$. By Theorem~\ref{thm:windowrange} ($k=8$: (R0) at $m=2$ and (R1) at $m=1$ for $n\ge6$, and (R1) for $n\ge m+5$), $K_{\lambda(3,3,2)}\ne0$ for every $n\ge6$, and it has the type $(3,1^{N-3})$ once and no other type of depth at most $m$ for $n\ge m+5$, $m\le4$. \item $p\ge2$: $0$ for $(3,1,1)$, $m\le7$; for $(4,4,2,2)$, $m\le2$; for $(4,1,1,1)$, $m\le4$; for $(5,1^4)$, $m\le3$. \end{itemize} For comparison, the squares $\nu=(1)$ and $(2,2)$ (two corners) give $1$ at every computed depth $m\le3$ (the element $f_\Gamma$), $\nu=(3)$ gives $0$, and the staircases $(3,2,1)$ and $(4,3,2,1)$ (four and five corners) give the upper bounds $1,2,6,13,26$ ($m\le4$) and $0,0,2$ ($m\le2$). \end{remark} \begin{remark}[what the window does not give]\label{rem:locality} Theorem~\ref{thm:window} controls only the types of depth at most $m$. Suppose that every conjugation type of $K_{\lambda(\nu)}$ has depth at most $J$, with $J$ independent of $n$. Then $U_{\lambda(\nu)}=0$ for $n\ge J+2k+1$. Indeed, take $|D|=J$. Each $\kappa$-part of $K_\lambda$ then meets $K^{[J]}_\lambda$, so $K_\lambda$ is spanned by the $S_N$-conjugates of the elements of $K^{[J]}_\lambda$, which are the $f_{M_y}$, $y\in\mathcal{Y}_J(\nu)$, by Theorem~\ref{thm:window}(b). By Lemma~\ref{lem:Ej}(b), $f_{M_y}(\sigma)=\frac1{f^\nu}\langle\Gamma_R\rho_R(y),\rho_R(\sigma)\rangle$. Here $\Gamma_R^T$ satisfies the same relation as $\Gamma_R$, so $\Gamma_R^T=c'\Gamma_R$ by Schur's lemma, with $c'=\pm1$ (transpose twice), and $\rho_R(\pi)^T=\rho_R(\pi^{-1})$; so $f_{M_y}(\sigma)=c\sum_\pi y(\pi)\,\psi_R(\sigma\pi^{-1})$ with a constant $c\ne0$, where $\psi_R(\tau):=\tr(\rho_R(\tau)\Gamma_R)$ is the function $\psi$ of ($\Gamma$) for the shape $R$. By ($\Gamma$), $\psi_R$ vanishes off the class $h(R)=(2n-1,2n-3,\dots,1)$, which has $n$ cycles. A permutation $\pi\in S_Q$ moves at most $J+k$ letters, so it is a product of at most $J+k-1$ transpositions, and each changes the number of cycles by $1$. An $N$-cycle of $S_I$ has $k+1$ cycles in $S_{n^2}$, so $\sigma\pi^{-1}$ has at most $J+2k5$, along every curve $P_1(s)$ with $\det P_1(0)=0$ (exactly) the left side vanishes to order at least $d-5$ at $s=0$. \end{enumerate} Both are linear conditions on $\varphi$. \emph{Exact dimensions.} By Cauchy's formula $\mathbb{C}[M_5]_a=\bigoplus_{\alpha\vdash a,\,\ell(\alpha)\le5}S_\alpha V\otimes S_\alpha V^*$, and by the Littlewood--Richardson rule, the $\mathrm{GL}_5$-invariants of bidegree $(a,b)$ on $M_5\times M_5$ have dimension \[ \textstyle f_{\mathfrak{gl}}(a,b)=\sum_{\rho\vdash a,\ \pi\vdash b}\frac1{z_\rho z_\pi}\sum_{\mu\vdash a+b,\ \ell(\mu)\le5}\chi^\mu(\rho\cup\pi)^2 . \] As $M_5=\mathfrak{sl}_5\oplus\mathbb{C}I$ and the traces are invariant, the bigraded Hilbert series of the $\dim\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}$ is $(1-x)(1-y)$ times that of the $f_{\mathfrak{gl}}(a,b)$. Finally $\mathfrak{gl}_2$ acts on $\bigoplus_{a+b=d}\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}$ by polarization, completely reducibly, and for $a\ge b$ the raising operator $\mathcal{E}$ maps $\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}$ onto $\mathcal{F}_{(a+1,b-1)}$; so $\operatorname{hw}(a,b):=\dim\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}=\dim\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}-\dim\mathcal{F}_{(a+1,b-1)}$. These numbers are computed exactly from characters (Murnaghan--Nakayama), with tests against $n=2$, against Teranishi's Hilbert series for $n=3$ \cite{Te86}, and against the independence of trace monomials below degree $n+1$. \emph{Ranks modulo $p$.} Let $T(a,b)$ be the set of trace monomials of bidegree $(a,b)$ (products of traces of cyclic words of length at least $2$ in $A$, $B$), $\operatorname{ev}\colon\mathbb{Q}^{T(a,b)}\to\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}$ the evaluation, $\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}\colon \mathbb{Q}^{T(a,b)}\to\mathbb{Q}^{T(a+1,b-1)}$ the formal operator (replace one $B$ by $A$, summed over the $B$'s), so that $\operatorname{ev}\circ\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}=\mathcal{E}\circ\operatorname{ev}$, and $H:=\ker\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}$. Let $p>5$ be a prime. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:Bfiverank} Suppose that (R1) $\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}$ has rank $|T(a+1,b-1)|$ modulo $p$; (R2) the values of a basis of $H_p:=\ker(\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}\bmod p)$ at some points of $\mathfrak{sl}_5(\mathbb{F}_p)^2$ have rank $\operatorname{hw}(a,b)$; and (R3) a set of rows, each a condition (G) or (P) at an $\mathbb{F}_p$-point and computed modulo $p$ as below, has rank $r$ on $H_p$. Then $\dim\mathcal{K}(\tau)\le\operatorname{hw}(a,b)-r$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} The rank of a $p$-integral matrix can only drop modulo $p$. So (R1) gives $\operatorname{rank}_p\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}=\operatorname{rank}_{\mathbb{Q}} \mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{f}}$, $\dim H_p=\dim H$, and $H_p$ is the reduction of the saturated lattice $L:=H\cap\mathbb{Z}_{(p)}^{T(a,b)}$. Lift every point to a rational point of the same kind: a traceless matrix to a traceless integer matrix; for (G), $P_1$ with $\det P_1\not\equiv0$ to an integer matrix, so $\det P_1\ne0$; for (P), the curve $P_1(s)=p_0+se$, where the last row of $p_0$ is a combination $r_1\,\mathrm{row}_1+r_2\,\mathrm{row}_2$ of the first two rows, by lifting the first four rows, $r_1$, $r_2$, $e$, $P_2$, $P_3$ and defining the last row over $\mathbb{Z}$ by the same combination, so that $\det p_0=0$ exactly. (An entrywise lift of $p_0$ has $\det p_0\ne0$ in general, and there (P) is not a condition.) At these points every row is a true condition, and the computation uses only ring operations, $1/5$ (traceless parts), the inverse of a matrix with determinant prime to $p$, the cofactor adjugate, and the interpolation of the expansion in $s$ at $s=1,\dots,5$ (Vandermonde determinant $288$); all of these are $p$-integral. So the rows of (R3) are the reductions of a $p$-integral matrix $S$ of true conditions, and $r\le\operatorname{rank}_{\mathbb{Q}}(S|_H)$. In the same way (R2) gives $\operatorname{rank}(\operatorname{ev}|_H)\ge\operatorname{hw}(a,b)$, and as $\operatorname{ev}(H)\subseteq\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}$, $\operatorname{ev}(H)=\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}$. Each row of $S$ is a linear form in $\varphi=\operatorname{ev}(h)$, so it vanishes on $\ker(\operatorname{ev}|_H)$, and the solutions of $S$ in $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}$ form a space of dimension $\operatorname{hw}(a,b)-\operatorname{rank}_{\mathbb{Q}}(S|_H)\le\operatorname{hw}(a,b)-r$. It contains $\varphi_f$ for every $f\in\mathcal{K}(\tau)$, and $f\mapsto\varphi_f$ is injective. \end{proof} Nothing random enters the conclusion: bad points can only lower $r$. The first fundamental theorem for matrix invariants is not needed, as (R2) gives $\operatorname{ev}(H)=\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}$ directly. \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfive}] With $p=33554393$ and the rows (G) and (P) (for (P), the coefficients of $s^0,\dots,s^{d-6}$) at random points, (R1) and (R2) hold for all $52$ types, and Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfiverank} gives $\dim\mathcal{K}(\tau)=0$ for every $\tau$ except $\tau=(21,2,2)$, where it gives $\dim\mathcal{K}(\tau)\le1$. This $\tau$ is $\kappa=(3,1^{19})$, which occurs in $K_{B(5,2)}$ exactly once, in the copy generated by $f_W$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bwindow}(b)). \end{proof} \begin{remark}[checks]\label{rem:Bfivechecks} (a) The values $\operatorname{hw}(a,b)$ go up to $590$, at $(a,b)=(9,7)$. The rows (P) alone cut $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}$ down to exactly $g(R,R,\tau)=\dim\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$ on every type, a check of Theorem~\ref{thm:matrixpair}. (b) The same program finds, for $n=3$, the bound $1$ exactly at the two types $(3,1,1,1)$ and $(3,3)$ of $K_{(3,2,1)}$, both of which occur (the example after Corollary~\ref{cor:casimir}), and $0$ elsewhere; for $n=4$ it finds only $(3,1^{10})$ (Remark~\ref{rem:Bwindowsmall}). (c) An independent program, by another method (one weight of $\mathrm{GL}_3$, $(9,8,8)$, which occurs in all $52$ types, a determinantal basis, and the tests only at points with $P_1=I+t_1uy^T$, so with no rows (P)), gives the theorem again; this is a second complete certificate. An exact rational re-implementation of the first program on $8$ of the $52$ types gives the same bounds; it is a partial check. (d) Two more runs of the first program, with the chart form of the tests (Lemma~\ref{lem:chartformula}), with and without the rows (P), agree with it type by type on the types they cover. \end{remark} \subsection{The pencil and the rectangle problem}\label{subsec:pencil} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$. The test (S1) at $P_1=I$ has an exact form in which $n$ appears explicitly only as the exponent of $\det(P_1)^n$ in the chart (it also appears through the size of the matrices). Letting the exponent vary gives a pencil, and for integer exponents a family of problems on $n\times s$ rectangles. Let $\varphi$ be a polynomial on $\mathfrak{sl}_n\times\mathfrak{sl}_n$, invariant under simultaneous conjugation, of bidegree $(a,b)$, $d:=a+b$, and put $\tilde\varphi(X,Y):=\varphi(X_0,Y_0)$ on $M_n\times M_n$. For $s\in\mathbb{C}$ let \[ f_s(P_1,P_2,P_3):=\det(P_1)^s\,\tilde\varphi\bigl(P_1^{-1}P_2,P_1^{-1}P_3\bigr) \] near $P_1=I$ (for $s\in\mathbb{Z}$ a rational function on $\det P_1\ne0$); for $s=n$ this is the chart of Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair}. At a base point $(A_2,A_3)\in M_n^2$ put $\beta(X,Y):=\partial_{A_2}[X]\,\partial_{A_3}[Y]\,\tilde\varphi$ (the coefficient of $\epsilon_1\epsilon_2$ in $\tilde\varphi(A_2+\epsilon_1X,A_3+\epsilon_2Y)$), $\omega(X,Y):=\beta(X,Y)-\beta(Y,X)$, \[ \Omega f_s(B_1,B_2,B_3):=\sum_{\sigma\in S_3}\sgn(\sigma)\,[t_1t_2t_3]\,f_s\bigl(I+t_1B_{\sigma(1)},A_2+t_2B_{\sigma(2)},A_3+t_3B_{\sigma(3)}\bigr), \] and, writing $\hat B_i$ for the other two of $B_1,B_2,B_3$ in their order, $W\circ X:=\frac12(WX+XW)$ and $J(W):=(W\circ A_2,W\circ A_3)$, \[ (\tr\wedge\omega)(B_1,B_2,B_3):=\sum_i(-1)^{i-1}\tr(B_i)\,\omega(\hat B_i),\qquad (\mathfrak{L}\omega)(B_1,B_2,B_3):=\sum_i(-1)^{i-1}D_{J(B_i)}\,\omega(\hat B_i), \] where $D_V$ is the derivative in the base point along $V$, with the arguments $\hat B_i$ fixed. \begin{lemma}[identity J]\label{lem:identityJ} For every $s\in\mathbb{C}$, every base point and all $B_1,B_2,B_3\in M_n$: $\Omega f_s=s\,(\tr\wedge\omega)-\mathfrak{L}\omega$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Modulo $t_a^2$: $\det(I+t_1X_1)^s=1+st_1\tr X_1$, $(I+t_1X_1)^{-1}=I-t_1X_1$, and $(I+t_1X_1)^{-1}(A_2+t_2X_2)=A_2+t_2X_2-t_1X_1A_2-t_1t_2X_1X_2$, and likewise for $A_3$, $t_3$, $X_3$. So the coefficient of $t_1t_2t_3$ in $f_s(I+t_1X_1,A_2+t_2X_2,A_3+t_3X_3)$ is $s\tr(X_1)\beta(X_2,X_3)-D_{L(X_1)}\beta(X_2,X_3)-\beta(X_1X_2,X_3)-\beta(X_2,X_1X_3)$, with $L(W):=(WA_2,WA_3)$. Alternating the first term gives $s(\tr\wedge\omega)$. Write $L(W)=J(W)+\frac12C(W)$ with $C(W):=([W,A_2],[W,A_3])$; the $J$-part alternates to $-\mathfrak{L}\omega$. Differentiating the conjugation invariance $\beta_{gAg^{-1}}(gXg^{-1},gYg^{-1})=\beta_A(X,Y)$ at $g=\exp(\epsilon W)$ gives $D_{C(W)}\beta(X,Y)=-\beta([W,X],Y)-\beta(X,[W,Y])$. In the alternation, $\beta(X_1X_2,X_3)$ may be replaced by $\frac12\beta([X_1,X_2],X_3)$ (exchange $X_1$, $X_2$) and $\beta(X_2,X_1X_3)$ by $\frac12\beta(X_2,[X_1,X_3])$ (exchange $X_1$, $X_3$); with the previous identity the $C$-part and these two terms cancel. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}[the pencil]\label{cor:pencil} Put $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi):=\tr\wedge\omega$ and $\mathcal{J}(\varphi):=\mathfrak{L}\omega$, both at $B_i=uy_i^T$ ($i=1,2,3$). \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item $\Omega f_s=\lambda\,(\tr\wedge\omega)-\mathfrak{L}_0\omega$ with $\lambda=s-(d-2)/n$, where $\mathfrak{L}_0$ is $\mathfrak{L}$ with every $B_i$ replaced by its traceless part. \item Let $s\in\mathbb{Z}$. Then $f_s$ satisfies (S1) at every $P$ with $\det P_1\ne0$ if and only if $s\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ for all base points and all $u,y_1,y_2,y_3$; and it satisfies (S2) there if and only if the same holds for $\varphi^T(X,Y):=\varphi(X^T,Y^T)$. \end{enumerate} \end{corollary} \begin{proof} (a) $J(B)=J(B_0)+\frac{\tr B}{n}(A_2,A_3)$, and $\omega$ is homogeneous of degree $d-2$ in the base point, so $\mathfrak{L}\omega=\mathfrak{L}_0\omega+ \frac{d-2}{n}\,\tr\wedge\omega$. (b) For $g,h\in\mathrm{GL}_n$, $f_s(gP)=\det(g)^sf_s(P)$ and $f_s(Ph^T)=\det(h)^sf_s(P)$ (conjugation invariance of $\tilde\varphi$). Writing $P_1=g$, the test at $P$ is $\det(g)^s$ times the test at $(I,g^{-1}P_2,g^{-1}P_3)$ with $u$ replaced by $g^{-1}u$; and at $P_1=I$ it is $\Omega f_s(uy_1^T,uy_2^T,uy_3^T)$, which is $s\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)-\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:identityJ}. For (S2), $f_s(P^T)$ is the function $f_s$ built from $\varphi^T$, and (S2) for $f$ is (S1) for $P\mapsto f(P^T)$. \end{proof} At rank-one arguments, $\tr\wedge\omega=\operatorname{Alt}_y\bigl[(y_1\cdot u)\,\beta(uy_2^T,uy_3^T)\bigr]$, so $\mathcal{Z}$ is the operator of Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair}; Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} describes its kernel on $\mathrm{HW}_{(a,b)}$ in the stable range. At $b=2$ and $a\ge3$, $\mathcal{Z}$ is injective on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$ for every $n\ge3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Bzinj}). For fixed $n$ and $(a,b)$, $s\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ is a linear pencil in $s$ on the invariant functions killed by $\mathcal{E}$, and the test of Theorem~\ref{thm:matrixpair} is its value at $s=n$, exactly. For integer $s$ the pencil asks the same question for $n\times s$ rectangles: \emph{The rectangle problem.} For integers $s,n\ge1$ and $\tau\vdash ns$ with at most three rows, let $\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$ be the space of the polynomials $f$ on $M_n^3$ with $f(gPh^T)=f(P)$ for $g,h\in\mathrm{SL}_n$ that are highest weight vectors of weight $\tau$ for $\mathrm{GL}_3$ (as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair}), and let $\mathrm{K}_s(n)_\tau\subseteq\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$ be the subspace cut out by (S1) and (S2). \begin{lemma}\label{lem:rectangle} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*),leftmargin=*] \item $\dim\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau=g\bigl((s^n),(s^n),\tau\bigr)$, and every $f\in\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$ has degree $s$ in each row and in each column of $P$. \item $f\mapsto\varphi_f:=f(I,\cdot,\cdot)$ is injective on $\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$; $f=\det(P_1)^s\varphi_f\bigl((P_1^{-1}P_2)_0,(P_1^{-1}P_3)_0\bigr)$ on $\det P_1\ne0$; and $\varphi_f$ is a conjugation-invariant polynomial in the traceless parts, of bidegree $(\tau_2,\tau_3)$, killed by $\mathcal{E}$. Conversely, let $\varphi$ be such a polynomial, of bidegree $(a,b)$, $d:=a+b$, with $\tau:=(ns-d,a,b)$ a partition; then $\varphi$ comes from $\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$ if $d\le s$, and, if $d>s$, if and only if $\det(P_1)^{d-s}$ divides $\varphi\bigl((\operatorname{adj}(P_1)P_2)_0,(\operatorname{adj}(P_1)P_3)_0\bigr)$. (If $ns-db-m$, for every such $x$; and $F_{b-m}\ne0$ for all $x$ in a nonempty Zariski-open set, which depends on $\varphi$; so, for such $x$, $\operatorname{ord}(\varphi)=\min\{b-k:F_k\ne0\}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} On the slice $\Sigma_x:=\{\operatorname{diag}x\}\times\mathfrak{sl}_n$, $\ell_i(\operatorname{diag}x,D+Z)=\tau_i(D):=\sum_lx_l^iD_l$, linear in $D$ and free of $Z$. Write $\varphi=\sum_{|\alpha|=m}\ell^\alpha g_\alpha+r$ with $r\in\mathfrak{p}^{m+1}$, so $\sigma(\varphi)=\sum_\alpha\bar g_\alpha t^\alpha$. (a) Every element of $\mathfrak{p}^j$ restricts to $\Sigma_x$ with $D$-degree at least $j$; so the part of $\varphi|_{\Sigma_x}$ of $D$-degree $m$ is $\sigma(\varphi)(\operatorname{diag}x,Z)$ at $t=\tau(D)$, and the parts of $D$-degree less than $m$ vanish. (b) On traceless $D$, $D\mapsto(\tau_1(D),\dots, \tau_{n-1}(D))$ is a linear isomorphism (Vandermonde, with $\tau_0(D)=0$), so $F_{b-m}\ne0$ if and only if $\sigma(\varphi)(\operatorname{diag}x,Z)\in\mathbb{C}[t]_m$ is nonzero for some $Z$. (c) The coefficients of $\sigma(\varphi)$ are $\mathrm{GL}_n$-invariant functions on $\mathcal{S}$, not all $0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:ordS}). The pairs with $X$ regular semisimple form a dense open subset of the irreducible $\mathcal{S}$, and each is conjugate to some $(\operatorname{diag}x,Z)$ with $Z$ off-diagonal (dimension check: $(n-1)+(n^2-n)$ for these pairs and $n^2-n$ for $\mathrm{GL}_n/T$ add up to $\dim\mathcal{S}=2n^2-n-1$). So $\sigma(\varphi)(\operatorname{diag}x,Z)\ne0$ for $(x,Z)$ in a nonempty open set. \end{proof} One fixed $x$ need not work for a whole space, since every $r\in R$ is the constant $r(x)$ on $\Sigma_x$: for $n=3$, $\varphi=(P_2(x)^3P_3^2-P_3(x)^2P_2^3)\,w_{12}\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(10,1)}(3)$ has $\operatorname{ord}(\varphi)=1$, but every $F_k=0$ at that $x$. \begin{theorem}[the order bound]\label{thm:sorder} Let $n\ge2$. Every nonzero $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$ has $\operatorname{ord}(\varphi)\le\lfloor a/4\rfloor$. For $n\ge3$ the bound is attained: $w_{12}^m\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(4m,m)}(n)$ has order $m$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Let $m:=\operatorname{ord}(\varphi)$ and $\sigma:=\sigma(\varphi)\ne0$. (i) $\mathcal{E}$ maps $\mathfrak{p}^m$ into $\mathfrak{p}^{m-1}$, and on the graded pieces it induces $1\otimes\mathcal{D}$ with $\mathcal{D}:=\sum_i\tr(X^{i+1})\,\partial/\partial t_i$: indeed $\mathcal{E}(\ell^\alpha g)=\sum_i\alpha_i\tr(X^{i+1})\ell^{\alpha-e_i}g+\ell^\alpha\,\mathcal{E}g$, with the last term in $\mathfrak{p}^m$. As $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$, $\mathcal{D}\sigma=0$ in $\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}][t]_{m-1}$. (ii) On $R[t]$, with $q_i:=\tr(X^{i+1})$ (generators of $R$), $\mathcal{D}=\sum_iq_i\,\partial/\partial t_i$ is the basic Weitzenb\"ock derivation of $n-1$ copies of $\mathbb{C}^2$. Its kernel is generated by the $q_i$ and the minors $q_it_j-q_jt_i$; this is Nowicki's conjecture \cite[\S6.9]{Now94}, proved by Khoury \cite{Kh08} and by Drensky and Makar-Limanov \cite{DML09}. The minor $q_jt_i-q_it_j$ is the symbol of $w_{ij}$, so in $t$-degree $m$ the kernel of $\mathcal{D}$ is the $R$-span of the products of $m$ symbols of $w_{ij}$'s. (iii) $\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}]$ is flat over $R$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:Sci}) and $\mathcal{D}$ is $R$-linear between free $R$-modules, so the kernel of $1\otimes\mathcal{D}$ on $\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}][t]_m$ is $\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}]\otimes_R\ker\mathcal{D}$: $\sigma=\sum_Jc_J\sigma(w_J)$, with $w_J$ running over the products of $m$ factors $w_{ij}$ and $c_J\in\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}]$ bihomogeneous. (iv) $\deg_Xw_{ij}=i+j+1\ge4$ and $\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}]$ is nonnegatively graded, so $\sigma\ne0$ forces $a\ge4m$. Sharpness: $w_{12}^m$ lies in $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(4m,m)}(n)$ ($\mathcal{E}$ is a derivation), and its symbol $(\tr(X^3)t_1-\tr(X^2)t_2)^m$ is nonzero in the domain $\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}][t]$, as $\tr(X^2)\ne0$ on $\mathcal{S}$; so its order is $m=a/4$. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:sorder} Let $n\ge2$ and $a<16$. Every nonzero $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$ has $\operatorname{ord}(\varphi)\le3$, so, by Lemma~\ref{lem:transverse}, at generic diagonal $X$ (generic for this $\varphi$) some $F_k$ with $k\ge b-3$ is nonzero. \end{corollary} \begin{remark}\label{rem:sorder} (1) For $n=2$ there is one $\ell$ only, and $\ker\mathcal{D}=R$ on $R[t]=\mathbb{C}[P_2,t_1]$: $(1\otimes\mathcal{D})(ct^m)=2mP_2ct^{m-1}=0$ forces $c=0$. So every nonzero element of $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(2)$ has order $0$. (2) The proof uses only that $\varphi$ is bihomogeneous with $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$, so the bound holds for every such $\varphi\in\mathbb{C}[V]$. Since $\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{p}}$ is a domain, the order is additive; for $n\ge3$ the bound is attained also at $(4m+2,m)$ and $(4m+3,m)$, by $w_{12}^mP_2$ and $w_{12}^mP_3$. To leading order along $\mathcal{S}$ every element of $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$ is a combination $\sum_Jc_Jw_J$, with $\mathrm{GL}_n$-invariant coefficients $c_J\in\mathbb{C}[\mathcal{S}]$ (apply the Reynolds operator to (iii)), of products of elements of the first layer. (3) Corollary~\ref{cor:sorder} does not show that the rows of the test (S1) with the corner $B_1=\mathbf{1}\mathbf{1}^T$ at the points $(\operatorname{diag}x,Z)$ of $\mathcal{S}$ alone decide the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$; we do not know whether they do, and by the example after Lemma~\ref{lem:transverse} an argument of this kind must let $x$ vary, or treat the multiples by elements of $R$ separately. (Computations, not used.) The orders of Lemma~\ref{lem:transverse}, measured for $n=4$ with a fresh random $x$ for each sample, are within $\lfloor a/4\rfloor$: every nonzero element has order $0$ at $(a,b)=(3,3)$, $(4,3)$, $(5,3)$, $(4,4)$, $(5,4)$ and $(6,4)$; at $(6,3)$ and $(7,3)$ the elements of positive order form subspaces of dimensions $3$ and $4$, of order $1$; at $(8,2)$ the part of order $2$ is spanned by $w_{12}^2$. In $24$ cases with $b=2,3,4$ and $n=4,\dots,10$ the eigenvalues of the pencil from the rows with the corner $B_1=\mathbf{1}\mathbf{1}^T$ at points of $\mathcal{S}$ alone are those from all rows, and every eigenvector found has order $0$; with $u=e_1$ (not cyclic for $\operatorname{diag}x$) in place of $\mathbf{1}$ these rows are not enough. \end{remark} \subsection{Lowering}\label{subsec:lowering} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$ and $n\ge3$. We show that the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$ has the eigenvalue $\kappa=(a+3)/n$, that is $\mu=3$ in the notation of Subsection~\ref{subsec:secondlayer}, for every $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+2$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:LW1}), with an explicit eigenvector: the image of the line of Theorem~\ref{thm:pencil22} under a power of the lowering operator of $\mathfrak{gl}_3$. For $a=3$ the eigenvector is a multiple of $n\varphi_1+6\varphi_2$, for every $n\ge4$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:LWthree}). We do not show here that there is no other eigenvalue (Conjecture~\ref{conj:L2}; for $n\ge a+6$ see Theorem~\ref{thm:Ltwostable}), that $\mu=0$ occurs (that is shown in Subsection~\ref{subsec:theta}), or that the eigenvector spans the eigenspace of $\mu=3$ when $a\ge4$. \emph{Setting.} Let $\mathcal{N}\subset\mathrm{GL}_n$ be a convex neighbourhood of $I$ that is stable under transposition (for example $\|P_1-I\|<\frac12$), and fix, for $s\in\mathbb{C}$, the branch of $\det^s$ on $\mathcal{N}$ with $\det(I)^s=1$. For $g\in\mathcal{N}$ and $Q_1$ in a ball $\mathcal{B}\subseteq\mathcal{N}$ around $I$ with $g\mathcal{B}\subseteq\mathcal{N}$ we have $\det(gQ_1)^s=\det(g)^s\det(Q_1)^s$: both sides are branches of $\det(gQ_1)^s$ on the connected set $\mathcal{B}$, so their ratio is continuous with values in the countable set $\{e^{2\pi ijs}:j\in\mathbb{Z}\}$, hence constant, and it is $1$ at $Q_1=I$. In the same way, $\det(P_1^T)^s=\det(P_1)^s$ on $\mathcal{N}$. For $k\ge2$ and $1\le i,j\le k$ let $E_{ij}:=\sum_{r,c}(P_i)_{rc}\,\partial/\partial(P_j)_{rc}$ on functions of $k$ matrices $P=(P_1,\dots,P_k)$, so that $E_{ij}f(P)=\frac{d}{dt}f(\dots,P_j+tP_i,\dots)|_{t=0}$ for $i\ne j$, $E_{ii}$ is the Euler operator in $P_i$, and $[E_{ij},E_{pq}]=\delta_{jp}E_{iq}-\delta_{qi}E_{pj}$. The $E_{ij}$ with $iv$), the leading monomial of its image is $u^{i+1}v^j$, with the coefficient multiplied by $-(i+1)$. For $c$, $[X,Y]_{rt}=(x_r-x_t)Y_{rt}$ gives the data $-(u-v)^2$; for $G$, $\langle Y,Y\rangle=\tr(Y^2)=\sum_{r\ne t}Y_{rt}Y_{tr}$ and $\langle X,Y\rangle=0$ give the data $\langle X,X\rangle=p_2-p_1^2/n$. So $\psi_0=\tilde\varphi'$ has $\mathsf{F}^\circ=-(a+1)(u-v)^2$, and $\psi_{a-2}$ has $\mathsf{F}^\circ=O^{a-2}\bigl(-(a+1)(u-v)^2\bigr)\ne0$. Finally, for $n\ge a+2$ the functions $x_r$, $x_t$, $p_1,\dots,p_a$ on $\mathbb{C}^n$ are algebraically independent: subtracting $x_r^j+x_t^j$ from $p_j$ (a triangular change of variables) leaves the power sums $p_1,\dots,p_a$ of the other $n-2\ge a$ coordinates. So the data of $\psi_{a-2}$, a nonzero polynomial in $u,v,p_1,\dots,p_a$, give a nonzero function of $x$; hence $\psi_{a-2}\ne0$, and $\varphi_{\mathrm{LW}}\ne0$, as $\tilde\varphi_{\mathrm{LW}}=\psi_{a-2}$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:LW1}). \end{proof} At $a=3$: $O(-4(u-v)^2)=12(u+v)(u-v)^2$, which is $\mathsf{F}^\circ$ of $-4(n\varphi_1+6\varphi_2)$ by the data in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:secondlayer}(b) (written there in the variables $z_l=x_l-p_1/n$). \begin{corollary}\label{cor:LW1} For every $a\ge3$ and every $n\ge a+2$, $\kappa=(a+3)/n$ (that is, $\mu=3$) is an eigenvalue of the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$, with eigenvector $\varphi_{\mathrm{LW}}$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} Proposition~\ref{prop:LW1} and Lemma~\ref{lem:LWnonzero}. \end{proof} (Computations, not used.) The computations of Remark~\ref{rem:secondlayer}(4) at $(a,n)=(5,11)$, $(5,12)$ and $(6,13)$ find a kernel of dimension $1$ at $\mu=3$. \emph{The block $\nu=(2,2)$.} The same mechanism works for other tests. Let $k=4$ and $\nu=(2,2)$. The live corners of $\nu$ are $(1,3)$ and $(3,1)$, and by Lemma~\ref{lem:cornerrule}(iii), (iv) a function $f$ passes the corner tests $(T_{1,3})$ and $(T_{3,1})$ of Subsection~\ref{subsec:corner} at $P$ if and only if $\Omega f(P)$ vanishes on $\bigoplus_{\alpha\ne(2,2)}S_\alpha V\otimes S_{\alpha'}V$, a subspace of $\Lambda^4M_n$ that does not depend on $P$. So these two tests together are a test $\Pi$ as in Theorem~\ref{thm:LW}; we call it the test of $\nu=(2,2)$. \begin{corollary}\label{cor:LW2} Let $\varphi_0(X_2,X_3,X_4):=\tr(X_2[X_3,X_4])$ and, for $s\in\mathbb{C}$, \[ f_s(P):=\det(P_1)^s\varphi_0\bigl(P_1^{-1}P_2,P_1^{-1}P_3,P_1^{-1}P_4\bigr)\quad\text{on }\mathcal{U}=\mathcal{N}\times M_n^3. \] \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item For every $s\in\mathbb{C}$, $f_s$ is a highest weight vector of weight $(ns-3,1,1,1)$, and it passes the test of $\nu=(2,2)$ on $\mathcal{U}$. \item For every integer $m\ge1$ and $s_0:=(m+3)/n$, the function $E_{21}^mf_{s_0}$ is killed by the $E_{ij}$ with $i0$, so $b'\in\{0,1\}$); $(23)$ gives $a'=1$ and $b'=a+1>2$; one $3$-cycle gives $b'=a+1>2$, and the other gives $a'=1$. (5) For $n\ge3$ the layers $(1,0)$, $(1,1)$, $(1,2)$, $(0,1)$, $(0,2)$ have $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}=0$: $\mathcal{F}_{(1,0)}(n)=0$ as $\tr A=0$; $\mathcal{F}_{(1,1)}(n)=\mathbb{C}\tr(AB)$ with $\mathcal{E}\tr(AB)=\tr(A^2)\ne0$; $\mathcal{F}_{(1,2)}(n)=\mathbb{C}\tr(AB^2)$ with $\mathcal{E}\tr(AB^2)=2\tr(A^2B)\ne0$; $\mathcal{F}_{(0,1)}(n)=0$; $\mathcal{F}_{(0,2)}(n)=\mathbb{C}\tr(B^2)$ with $\mathcal{E}\tr(B^2)=2\tr(AB)\ne0$. So only $(12)$ with $a'\ge2$ and $(13)$ remain. (6) In case $(13)$ with $b'=1$, $v'_j$ comes from $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,1)}(n)$ and lies in $\mathcal{P}_s$, so $ns=a-1$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:Vmodule}(d) and Theorem~\ref{thm:firstlayer}, while $(13)$ needs $ns=a+1$; this is excluded. Case $(13)$ with $b'=0$ is (A). (7) In case $(12)$, $a'=2$ gives $ns=a+3$, which is (B). For $3\le a'\le a-1$, $v'_j$ comes from an eigenvector at $\kappa=s$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a',2)}(n)$, by Lemma~\ref{lem:Vmodule}(d); this is (C). \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:link} (1) In (A) the step is the $\theta$-step of Lemma~\ref{lem:thetasing} ($m=2$), and in (B) it is $E_{21}^m$ with $m=a-2=\tau_1-\tau_2+1$ for the weight $\tau=(ns-4,2,2)$ of the source, as in Theorem~\ref{thm:LW}. (2) For $n\ge a+2$ both (A) and (B) occur: the theta vectors of Theorem~\ref{thm:thetamult} and the vector $\varphi_{\mathrm{LW}}$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:LW1} are descents. (3) In (A)--(C), $0k_2\ge0$ the function $\mathsf{H}(s,t)=s^{k_1}t^{k_2}-s^{k_2}t^{k_1}$ has $\mathsf{H}(s,v,t)=a_{(k_1,k_2,0)}(s,v,t)$ (expand the determinant along its last column), $a_{\lambda+\delta}=a_\delta s_\lambda$ with $\delta=(2,1,0)$, and $a_\delta(s,v,t)=(s-v)(s-t)(v-t)=-(s-v)(v-t)(t-s)$. For $\lambda=(\lambda_1,\lambda_2)$ take $k_1=\lambda_1+2$, $k_2=\lambda_2+1$: then $\mathsf{F}:=-(s^{k_1}t^{k_2}-s^{k_2}t^{k_1})/(s-t)=-(st)^{\lambda_2+1}h_{\lambda_1-\lambda_2}(s,t)=-st\,s_\lambda(s,t,0)$ (as $s_{(\lambda_1,\lambda_2)}(s,t)=(st)^{\lambda_2}h_{\lambda_1-\lambda_2}(s,t)$) has $\mathsf{H}(s,v,t)=-a_{(k_1,k_2,0)}=(s-v)(v-t)(t-s)s_\lambda$, that is, $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}=s_\lambda$. By linearity over $\mathbb{C}[p_1,p_2,\dots]$, $\mathsf{F}:=-st\,\vartheta(s,t,0)$ has $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}=\vartheta$ for every $\vartheta\in\mathrm{TR}$. Conversely, every $\mathsf{F}\in\mathrm{Sym}$ is, modulo $\mathrm{Dif}$, of the form $st\,\mathsf{F}_1$: if $f_d$ is the coefficient of $s^d$ in $\mathsf{F}(s,0)$, then $\mathsf{F}-\sum_df_dh_d(s,t)$ vanishes at $t=0$, so it is divisible by $t$ and, being symmetric, by $st$; and $h_d(s,t)=(v^{d+1})[s,t]\in\mathrm{Dif}$. As $\mathsf{F}_1$ is a combination of the $s_\lambda(s,t)$, $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}\in\mathrm{TR}$ by the computation above. (iv) $\mathsf{F}:=-st\,\vartheta(s,t,0)$ has $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}=\vartheta$ by (iii), and $\vartheta_{\mathbb{T}\mathsf{F}}=\mathbb{T}\vartheta=0$ by (ii); so $\mathbb{T}\mathsf{F}\in\mathrm{Dif}$ by (i), and $\mathbb{T}(\mathsf{F}^\perp)=(\mathbb{T}\mathsf{F})^\perp=0$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}. Finally $\vartheta_w=\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}$ by (i). \end{proof} Let $\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp:=\mathrm{Sym}_a^{\mathrm{inv}}\cap\ker\operatorname{pr}$. \begin{theorem}[the data]\label{thm:Spairs} Let $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})\in\mathrm{Sym}_a^{\mathrm{inv}}\times\mathrm{Sym}_a^{\mathrm{inv}}$ satisfy \eqref{eq:Cone}. Then \eqref{eq:Ctwo} holds if and only if $\mathfrak{h}_{\mathsf{G}}=0$, that is, $\mathsf{G}\in\ker\operatorname{pr}$. Two such pairs with the same $(\mathsf{G},\mathsf{F}^\perp)$ are equal, and for every $(\mathsf{G},w)\in\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp\times\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp$ there is exactly one such pair with these values: $\mathsf{F}=g[s,t]+w$, where $g'(s)=-\langle\mathsf{G}(s,u)\rangle_u-w(s,s)$. So $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})\mapsto(\mathsf{G},\mathsf{F}^\perp)$ is a bijection from the pairs with \eqref{eq:Cone} and \eqref{eq:Ctwo} onto $\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp\times\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} $s\cdot$\eqref{eq:Cone}$-$\eqref{eq:Ctwo} is $\langle(s-u)\mathsf{G}(s,u)\rangle_u=\mathfrak{h}_{\mathsf{G}}(s)$; this gives the first claim. As \eqref{eq:Cone} is linear, for the uniqueness let $\mathsf{G}=0$ and $\mathsf{F}^\perp=0$: then $\mathsf{F}=g[s,t]$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}), and \eqref{eq:Cone} gives $\mathsf{F}(s,s)=g'(s)=0$, so $\mathsf{F}=0$. Existence: with $g$ as stated, $\mathsf{F}(s,s)=g'(s)+w(s,s)=-\langle\mathsf{G}(s,u)\rangle_u$, and $\operatorname{pr}\mathsf{F}=g[s,t]$, $\mathsf{F}^\perp=w$. Shift invariance: $g'$ is shift invariant (by the identity before Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}), so $\mathbb{T}g$ has the derivative $\mathbb{T}g'=0$; so $\mathbb{T}g$ is a constant, and $\mathbb{T}(g[s,t])=(\mathbb{T}g)[s,t]=0$. Take $g(v):=\int_0^vg'$, of weighted degree $a+1$. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}[the line]\label{cor:Rline} Let $\varphi$ be a kernel vector at $\kappa$ with $\mu\ne0$, with data $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$, and $w:=\mathsf{F}^\perp\in\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp$. Then \[ \mu(a+1)(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})=v'(\mu,w):=\bigl(g[s,t]+\mu(a+1)w,\,-2nw\bigr),\qquad g'(s)=2n\langle w(s,u)\rangle_u-\mu(a+1)w(s,s), \] and $\varphi=0$ if and only if $w=0$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} By the display before Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}, $\mu(a+1)\mathsf{G}=2(\mathfrak{h}_{\mathsf{F}}[s,t]-n\mathsf{F})=2n(\operatorname{pr}\mathsf{F}-\mathsf{F})=-2nw$. Both $\mu(a+1)(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ and $v'(\mu,w)$ satisfy \eqref{eq:Cone} and have $(\mathsf{G},\mathsf{F}^\perp)=(-2nw,\mu(a+1)w)$, so they are equal by Theorem~\ref{thm:Spairs}. If $w=0$, then $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})=0$, and $\varphi=0$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[the odd rows]\label{lem:oddO} Let $\mathsf{F}_{rt}$, $\mathsf{G}_{rt}$ be any symmetric data ($\mathsf{G}\mathbf{1}=0$, $\mathsf{G}x=0$ and the shift invariance are not used), and for distinct $p,q,i,j$ let $R_{pq}:=\Psi_{pq}(e_i,e_j)$ be the generic order-one row of Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone} and $R^-_{pq}:=\frac12(R_{pq}-R_{qp})$, as in Lemma~\ref{lem:mirrorrows}. Then, with $\mathsf{c}_l:=\mathsf{c}^{(pq)}_l$, \[ R^-_{pq}=\kappa(\mathsf{c}_j-\mathsf{c}_i)-x_{ij}(\partial_i\mathsf{c}_j+\partial_j\mathsf{c}_i). \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} We use the shifted form of Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone} with $c=-(x_p+x_q)/2$ for both rows ($c$ is chosen at each point, and no derivative acts on it). Put $x''_l:=x_l-(x_p+x_q)/2$, so $x''_p=x_{pq}/2=-x''_q$, and $\nabla_m:=\partial_m-\delta_m$. With $\psi:=\psi^{(pq)}$, \[ R_{pq}=\kappa(\psi_j-\psi_i)-x''_i(\nabla_i\psi)_j+x''_j(\nabla_j\psi)_i-\tfrac12\bigl[\partial_i(\mathsf{G}_{pj}+\mathsf{G}_{qj})-\partial_j(\mathsf{G}_{pi}+\mathsf{G}_{qi})\bigr], \] as the $\Theta$-term is $-(x''_p\Theta_p-x''_q\Theta_q)/x_{pq}=-\frac12(\Theta_p+\Theta_q)$. Write $\psi^{(rt)}_w=\mathsf{e}^{(rt)}_w+\mathsf{c}^{(rt)}_w$ with $\mathsf{e}^{(rt)}_w:=\partial_w\mathsf{F}_{rt}+(\mathsf{G}_{tw}-\mathsf{G}_{rw})/x_{rt}$. Under $p\leftrightarrow q$ the $x''_l$, the $\mathsf{G}$-term and $\mathsf{e}$ are unchanged ($\mathsf{e}^{(qp)}=\mathsf{e}^{(pq)}$), and $\mathsf{c}^{(qp)}=-\mathsf{c}^{(pq)}$ (as $\mathsf{H}_{qwp}=-\mathsf{H}_{pwq}$ and $x_{qw}x_{wp}=x_{pw}x_{wq}$). So the $\kappa$-terms give $\kappa(\mathsf{c}_j-\mathsf{c}_i)$. For $m\in\{i,j\}$ and $w$ the other spectator, $\psi^{(rt)}+\psi^{(tr)}=2\mathsf{e}^{(rt)}$ gives \[ \tfrac12\bigl[(\delta_m\psi)_w-\bigl((\delta_m\psi)_w\text{ with }p\leftrightarrow q\bigr)\bigr]=\Bigl[\frac{\mathsf{e}^{(pq)}-\mathsf{e}^{(pm)}}{x_{mq}}-\frac{\mathsf{e}^{(pq)}-\mathsf{e}^{(mq)}}{x_{mp}}\Bigr]_w. \] Its $\mathsf{G}$-part is $0$: over the denominator $x_{pq}x_{mq}x_{mp}$, the coefficients of $\mathsf{G}_{qw}$, $\mathsf{G}_{pw}$ and $\mathsf{G}_{mw}$ have the numerators $x_{mp}-x_{mq}+x_{pq}=0$, $x_{mq}-x_{mp}-x_{pq}=0$ and $0$. Its $\mathsf{F}$-part is $\partial_w[(\mathsf{F}_{pq}-\mathsf{F}_{pm})/x_{mq}-(\mathsf{F}_{pq}-\mathsf{F}_{mq})/x_{mp}]=-\partial_w\mathsf{c}_m$. So the half-difference of $(\nabla_i\psi)_j$ is $\partial_i\mathsf{c}_j+\partial_j\mathsf{c}_i$, and that of the row is $\kappa(\mathsf{c}_j-\mathsf{c}_i)-(x''_i-x''_j)(\partial_i\mathsf{c}_j+\partial_j\mathsf{c}_i)$, with $x''_i-x''_j=x_{ij}$. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}[the equation $(\star)$]\label{cor:star} In two-point form put $s=x_p$, $t=x_q$, $u_1=x_i$, $u_2=x_j$ and $\vartheta(v):=\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}(s,t,v)$, and let $\vartheta[u_1,u_2]$ be its divided difference in the third slot. Then \[ R^-_{pq}=-(u_1-u_2)(t-s)\bigl[\kappa\,\vartheta[u_1,u_2]+\mathcal{D}_{u_1}\vartheta(u_2)+\mathcal{D}_{u_2}\vartheta(u_1)\bigr], \] which depends on the data only through $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}=\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}^\perp}$. If $\varphi$ is a kernel vector at $\kappa$ (any $\mu$) with data $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ and $w:=\mathsf{F}^\perp$, then $\vartheta:=\vartheta_w$ is symmetric, shift invariant, of weighted degree $m:=a-2$, lies in $\mathrm{TR}$, and satisfies, identically in $s,t,u_1,u_2$ and the $p_k$, \[ \kappa\,\vartheta[u_1,u_2]+\mathcal{D}_{u_1}\vartheta(u_2)+\mathcal{D}_{u_2}\vartheta(u_1)=0.\tag{$\star$}\label{eq:star} \] \end{corollary} \begin{proof} By Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle}, $\mathsf{c}_l=C(s,t;x_l)=(t-s)\vartheta(x_l)$, and $\mathsf{c}_j$ depends on $x_i$ only through the $p_k$, so $\partial_i\mathsf{c}_j=(t-s)\mathcal{D}_{u_1}\vartheta(u_2)$; insert this into Lemma~\ref{lem:oddO}. For a kernel vector every row vanishes, in every shift, so the bracket vanishes for all $x$ with distinct coordinates; it involves only $p_k$ with $k\le m$, so by the independence it vanishes as a polynomial ($\mathbb{C}[s,t,u_1,u_2,p_1,p_2,\dots]$ is a domain). $\vartheta_w$ is shift invariant by Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle}(ii), as $w$ is (Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}), and lies in $\mathrm{TR}$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle}(iii). \end{proof} \emph{Solving $(\star)$.} Let $\beta:=\kappa/2$, \[ \mathbf{E}(\tau):=\exp\Bigl(-\beta\sum_{k\ge1}\frac{p_k\tau^k}k\Bigr)=\sum_{k\ge0}\mathbf{E}_k\tau^k,\qquad \mathbf{R}_k:=[\tau^k]\,\mathbf{E}(\tau)\prod_{y\in\{s,t,v\}}(1-y\tau)^{-1}, \] so $\mathbf{E}_0=1$ and $\mathbf{R}_k(0,0,0)=\mathbf{E}_k$ ($\mathbf{R}_k$ is the complete symmetric function $h_k$ of the formal alphabet $\{s,t,v\}-\beta\{x_1,\dots,x_n\}$). Let $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}:=(r+1)\partial/\partial p_{r+1}$, so that $\mathcal{D}_u=\sum_{r\ge0}u^r\mathcal{D}^{[r]}$; then $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}\mathbf{E}(\tau)=-\beta\tau^{r+1}\mathbf{E}(\tau)$, so $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}\mathbf{E}_k=-\beta\mathbf{E}_{k-r-1}$. For $\beta\ne0$, $\mathbf{E}_k=-(\beta/k)p_k+(\text{a polynomial in }p_1,\dots,p_{k-1})$, so the $\mathbf{E}_k$ are algebraically independent generators of $\mathbb{C}[p_1,p_2,\dots]$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:Hdet} Let $\kappa\ne0$ and let $\vartheta$ be symmetric and solve \eqref{eq:star}. Then $\vartheta$ is determined by $f_\circ:=\vartheta(0,0,0)$. Moreover $f(v):=\vartheta(0,0,v)=\sum_if_iv^i$ satisfies $f_0=f_\circ$ and \[ \kappa f_{r+r'+1}+\mathcal{D}^{[r]}f_{r'}+\mathcal{D}^{[r']}f_r=0\qquad(r,r'\ge0).\tag{$\star_1$}\label{eq:starone} \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Write $\vartheta(s,t,v)=\sum_i\vartheta_i(s,t)v^i$. As $\vartheta[u_1,u_2]=\sum_{r,r'}\vartheta_{r+r'+1}u_1^ru_2^{r'}$, the coefficient of $u_1^ru_2^{r'}$ in \eqref{eq:star} is $\kappa\vartheta_{r+r'+1}+\mathcal{D}^{[r]}\vartheta_{r'}+\mathcal{D}^{[r']}\vartheta_r=0$; at $s=t=0$ this is \eqref{eq:starone}. At $r'=0$ it gives $\vartheta_{r+1}=-(\mathcal{D}^{[r]}\vartheta_0+\mathcal{D}^{[0]}\vartheta_r)/\kappa$ (the $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}$ do not act on $s$, $t$), so $\vartheta(s,t,\cdot)$ is determined by $\vartheta(s,t,0)$. If $f_\circ=0$, then $\vartheta(0,0,\cdot)=0$; by symmetry $\vartheta(0,y,0)=\vartheta(0,0,y)=0$, so $\vartheta(0,y,\cdot)=0$; by symmetry again $\vartheta(s,y,0)=\vartheta(0,y,s)=0$, so $\vartheta=0$. The claim follows by linearity. \end{proof} Let $\mathrm{Sol}_m$ be the set of the $f_\circ\in\mathbb{C}[p_1,p_2,\dots]$ of weighted degree $m$ for which the $f_i$ defined by \eqref{eq:starone} with $r'=0$ satisfy all of \eqref{eq:starone}. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:Hprod} Call a polynomial $f(v)$ an \emph{$\mathbf{R}$-function} if $\mathcal{D}_{u_1}f(u_2)=-\beta f[u_1,u_2]$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*),leftmargin=*] \item $\mathbf{R}_k$ (in the third slot, with $s$, $t$ as parameters) and $\sum_i\mathbf{E}_{k-i}v^i$ are $\mathbf{R}$-functions. \item If $f$ and $g$ are $\mathbf{R}$-functions, then $fg$ solves \eqref{eq:star} at $\kappa=2\beta$. \end{enumerate} So each $\mathbf{R}_p\mathbf{R}_q$ is a symmetric solution of \eqref{eq:star} in $\mathrm{TR}$, and $\mathbf{E}_p\mathbf{E}_q\in\mathrm{Sol}_{p+q}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) $\mathcal{D}_{u_1}\mathbf{E}(\tau)=-\beta\tau\mathbf{E}(\tau)/(1-u_1\tau)$, so $\mathcal{D}_{u_1}\bigl[\mathbf{E}(\tau)/(1-u_2\tau)\bigr]=-\beta\tau\mathbf{E}(\tau)/((1-u_1\tau)(1-u_2\tau))=-\beta\bigl[\mathbf{E}(\tau)/(1-v\tau)\bigr][u_1,u_2]$; take the coefficient of $\tau^k$ (times $(1-s\tau)^{-1}(1-t\tau)^{-1}$ for $\mathbf{R}_k$). (ii) $(fg)[u_1,u_2]=f(u_1)g[u_1,u_2]+g(u_2)f[u_1,u_2]$, so $2\beta(fg)[u_1,u_2]+\mathcal{D}_{u_1}(fg)(u_2)+\mathcal{D}_{u_2}(fg)(u_1)$ is \begin{multline*} \beta g[u_1,u_2](f(u_1)-f(u_2))-\beta f[u_1,u_2](g(u_1)-g(u_2))\\ =\beta(u_1-u_2)\bigl(g[u_1,u_2]f[u_1,u_2]-f[u_1,u_2]g[u_1,u_2]\bigr)=0. \end{multline*} Finally, $\mathbf{R}_p\mathbf{R}_q=\sum_{i,j}\mathbf{E}_i\mathbf{E}_jh_{p-i}h_{q-j}(s,t,v)$, and each $h_{p'}h_{q'}$ is a sum of Schur polynomials with at most two rows (Pieri); and at $s=t=0$, $\mathbf{R}_k$ becomes $\sum_i\mathbf{E}_{k-i}v^i$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:Hone} For $\beta\ne0$, $\mathrm{Sol}_m$ is spanned by the $\mathbf{E}_p\mathbf{E}_{m-p}$, $0\le p\le m/2$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Identify $\mathbb{C}[p_1,p_2,\dots]$ with the ring $\Lambda$ of symmetric functions by $\mathbf{E}_k\mapsto h_k$, an algebra isomorphism. Then $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}$ is the derivation with $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}h_k=-\beta h_{k-r-1}$, so $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}=-\beta\pi_{r+1}^\perp$, where the $\pi_j$ are the power sums of $\Lambda$ and $\pi_j^\perp=j\,\partial/\partial\pi_j$ is the adjoint of the multiplication by $\pi_j$ for the Hall inner product, with $\pi_j^\perp h_k=h_{k-j}$ \cite[I, \S5, Ex.~3]{Ma95}. With $\kappa=2\beta$, \eqref{eq:starone} becomes free of $\beta$: $2f_{r+r'+1}=\pi_{r+1}^\perp f_{r'}+\pi_{r'+1}^\perp f_r$. The equations with $r'=0$ give $f_r=q_r^\perp f_\circ$ with $q_0=1$ and $q_{r+1}=(\pi_1q_r+\pi_{r+1})/2$ (as $(fg)^\perp=f^\perp g^\perp$); the generating function is $\sum_rq_rv^r=(2+\Pi(v))/(2-\pi_1v)$, $\Pi(v):=\sum_{j\ge1}\pi_jv^j$. The other equations are $g_{r,r'}^\perp f_\circ=0$ ($r,r'\ge1$) with $g_{r,r'}:=2q_{r+r'+1}-\pi_{r+1}q_{r'}-\pi_{r'+1}q_r$; so $\mathrm{Sol}_m=(J_g)_m^\perp$ for the Hall inner product, where $J_g$ is the ideal generated by the $g_{r,r'}$. Let $I_{\ge3}:=(e_3,e_4,\dots)$, which is spanned by the $s_\lambda$ with $\ell(\lambda)\ge3$, so that $I_{\ge3}^\perp$ is spanned by the $s_\lambda$ with $\ell(\lambda)\le2$, that is, by the $h_ph_q$ (\cite[I, \S\S2--3]{Ma95}: $s_\lambda(x_1,x_2)=0$ if and only if $\ell(\lambda)\ge3$; the Jacobi--Trudi formula $s_{(p,q)}=h_ph_q-h_{p+1}h_{q-1}$ \cite[I, (3.4)]{Ma95}; the $s_\lambda$ are orthonormal \cite[I, (4.8)]{Ma95}). (a) $J_g\subseteq I_{\ge3}$: by Lemma~\ref{lem:Hprod}, every $h_ph_q$ ($=\mathbf{E}_p\mathbf{E}_q$) lies in $J_g^\perp$, so $(I_{\ge3})_m^\perp\subseteq(J_g)_m^\perp$ for every $m$; the Hall inner product is non-degenerate on each $\Lambda_m$, so $(J_g)_m\subseteq(I_{\ge3})_m$. (b) $I_{\ge3}\subseteq J_g$: we show $e_k\in J_g$ by induction on $k\ge3$. The element $g:=g_{1,k-2}$ has degree $k$ and lies in $I_{\ge3}$ by (a), so in $\mathbb{C}[e_1,e_2,\dots]$ each of its monomials contains some $e_j$ with $j\ge3$: $g=c\,e_k+(\text{terms with a factor }e_j,\ 3\le ji_0$; $i_0=0$ gives $\mathbf{R}_m$, and $i_0=1$ gives $(m-2)\mathbf{R}_m+\mathbf{R}_1\mathbf{R}_{m-1}$. For even $m$: $c_j=(-1)^j\prod_{iq$, $\mathbb{L}s_{(q,q)}=s_{(q,q-2)}-3s_{(q-1,q-1)}$, and $s_{(p,q)}(u_1,u_2)=(u_1u_2)^qh_{p-q}(u_1,u_2)$; $\langle f,\mathrm{disc}\,\hat u_1\hat u_2\rangle=(\mathbb{L}f)(u_1,u_2)$, as $\mathrm{disc}=(h_2-3e_2)(z_1,z_2)$ and $\langle f,\hat u_1\hat u_2\rangle=f(u_1,u_2)$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} By the two preceding paragraphs it suffices that each residual above is $\mathbb{T}^*_\zeta H_k$ after the substitutions $n\beta=3-\zeta$, $M=(4-2\zeta-\mathrm{E})(\mathrm{E}+3)$. Each residual is $r_0+\zeta r_1$ with $r_0$, $r_1$ free of $\zeta$, and $\mathbb{T}^*_\zeta H=\mathsf{d}H+\zeta e_1H$; so it suffices that $r_1=e_1H_k$ and $r_0=\mathsf{d}H_k$, with \begin{gather*} H_k:=(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2\Bigl[\frac2{k+1}h_k(z_1,z_2)S_{12}-2h_{k-1}(z_1,z_2)\Bigr]\quad(h_{-1}:=0),\\ S_{12}:=\sum_{\upsilon\in\{u_1,u_2\}}\upsilon(\upsilon e_1-2)U(\upsilon); \end{gather*} so $H_0=2(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2S_{12}$, $H_1=(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2(e_1S_{12}-2)$ and $H_2=(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2(\frac23h_2S_{12}-2e_1)$. $k=0$ (the common factor $u_2-u_1$ dropped on both sides): $r_1=\mathsf{Y}-4(\mathrm{E}+2)\hat u_1\hat u_2=2\hat u_1\hat u_2e_1S_{12}$ (for each $\upsilon$: $2\upsilon^2\mathrm{disc}\,U-4\upsilon(e_1-2\upsilon e_2)U=2\upsilon e_1(\upsilon e_1-2)U$, with $(2-\upsilon e_1)^2U=4+\upsilon^2\mathrm{disc}\,U$). Next, $r_0=-2\mathsf{Y}-12\hat u_1\hat u_2+2\,\mathrm{Sq}+2(4-\mathrm{E})(\mathrm{E}+3)\hat u_1\hat u_2$; dividing $\mathsf{d}H_0-r_0$ by $2\hat u_1\hat u_2$: the $U^2$-terms are $2\upsilon^2[(\upsilon e_1-2)\mathsf{f}_\upsilon+(e_1-2\upsilon e_2)^2]U^2=-2\upsilon^2\mathrm{disc}\,U$ (with $\mathsf{f}_\upsilon:=e_1^2-2e_2-\upsilon e_1e_2$, $(\upsilon e_1-2)\mathsf{f}_\upsilon+(e_1-2\upsilon e_2)^2=-\mathrm{disc}\,\mathsf{q}_\upsilon$), the $U$-terms are $3\upsilon^2\mathrm{disc}\,U$ for each $\upsilon$ plus the constant $4$ in total, and the $\hat u_1\hat u_2$-terms are $\mathsf{X}\hat u_1\hat u_2$ with \[ \mathsf{X}=\sigma_2\sigma_1e_1^3-2\sigma_2^2e_1^2e_2-2\sigma_2e_1^2+4\sigma_2^2e_2^2-4-\sigma_1^2e_1^2+4\sigma_1e_1 =-4\mathsf{q}_{u_1}\mathsf{q}_{u_2}-\mathrm{disc}\,(u_1^2\mathsf{q}_{u_2}+u_2^2\mathsf{q}_{u_1}), \] that is, $\mathsf{X}\hat u_1\hat u_2=-4-\sum_\upsilon\upsilon^2\mathrm{disc}\,U(\upsilon)$. So $(\mathsf{d}H_0-r_0)/(2\hat u_1\hat u_2)=4+\sum_\upsilon\upsilon^2\mathrm{disc}\,U(\upsilon) +\mathsf{X}\hat u_1\hat u_2=0$. $k=1$: $r_1=(u_2-u_1)e_1\hat u_1\hat u_2\bigl[\sum_\upsilon(4-6\upsilon e_1+\upsilon^2e_1^2+4\upsilon^2e_2)U(\upsilon)-10\bigr]=e_1H_1$, as $(4-6\upsilon e_1+\upsilon^2e_1^2+4\upsilon^2e_2)U=4+\upsilon e_1(\upsilon e_1-2)U$. For $r_0=\mathsf{d}H_1$ write $H_1/(u_2-u_1)=\frac{e_1}2(2\hat u_1\hat u_2S_{12})-2\hat u_1\hat u_2$ and use $k=0$: what remains is \begin{gather*} W_1=(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2\Bigl\{\sum_\upsilon\mathsf{Q}_1(\upsilon)U(\upsilon)-6e_1+e_1\hat u_1\hat u_2N_{12}^2\Bigr\},\\ \mathsf{Q}_1(\upsilon):=4e_1-6\upsilon e_1^2+8\upsilon e_2+2\upsilon^2e_1^3-4\upsilon^2e_1e_2, \end{gather*} and both sides, multiplied by $\mathsf{q}_{u_1}^2\mathsf{q}_{u_2}^2/(u_2-u_1)$, equal \begin{multline*} 6e_1-8e_1^2\sigma_1+8e_2\sigma_1+3e_1^3\sigma_1^2-6e_1e_2\sigma_1^2+2e_1^3\sigma_2+4e_1e_2\sigma_2+8e_2^2\sigma_1\sigma_2\\ -2e_1^4\sigma_1\sigma_2-10e_1e_2^2\sigma_2^2+4e_1^3e_2\sigma_2^2. \end{multline*} $k=2$: $r_1=(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2\bigl[\frac23h_2\sum_\upsilon(4-6\upsilon e_1+\upsilon^2e_1^2+4\upsilon^2e_2)U(\upsilon)-\frac{16}3h_2-2e_1^2\bigr]=e_1H_2$. For $r_0=\mathsf{d}H_2$ write $H_2/(u_2-u_1)=\frac{h_2}3(2\hat u_1\hat u_2S_{12})-2e_1\hat u_1\hat u_2$ ($\mathsf{d}h_2=2e_1^3-5e_1e_2$) and use $k=0$: what remains is \[ W_0=(u_2-u_1)\hat u_1\hat u_2\Bigl\{\tfrac13\sum_\upsilon\mathsf{Q}_2(\upsilon)U(\upsilon)+\tfrac23h_2\hat u_1\hat u_2N_{12}^2-\tfrac83e_1^2-\tfrac43e_2\Bigr\}, \] $\mathsf{Q}_2(\upsilon):=8e_1^2-8e_2-14\upsilon e_1^3+32\upsilon e_1e_2+6\upsilon^2e_1^4-22\upsilon^2e_1^2e_2+16\upsilon^2e_2^2$, and both sides, multiplied by $3\mathsf{q}_{u_1}^2\mathsf{q}_{u_2}^2/(u_2-u_1)$, equal \begin{multline*} 16e_1^2-28e_2-22e_1^3\sigma_1+52e_1e_2\sigma_1+8e_1^4\sigma_1^2-24e_1^2e_2\sigma_1^2+4e_2^2\sigma_1^2+8e_1^4\sigma_2-8e_1^2e_2\sigma_2-24e_2^2\sigma_2\\ -6e_1^5\sigma_1\sigma_2+8e_1^3e_2\sigma_1\sigma_2+28e_1e_2^2\sigma_1\sigma_2+12e_1^4e_2\sigma_2^2-44e_1^2e_2^2\sigma_2^2+20e_2^3\sigma_2^2. \end{multline*} The part of $[y^2]\mathsf{P}$ with $\beta^2$ is that of $\mathrm{tg}_2$ by (Rf), and the parts linear in $\beta$ vanish by (Rd). The argument is uniform in $\zeta$, so it covers every shift invariant two-row $f$, $\beta=0$ included. \end{proof} \emph{The kernel of $\mathbb{T}_\zeta$.} Let $f=\sum_bc_bs_{(d-b,b)}$ have degree $d$ and at most two rows. By the Jacobi--Trudi formula $s_{(p,q)}=h_ph_q-h_{p+1}h_{q-1}$ ($h_{-k}:=0$; it gives $s_{(q-1,q)}=0$), both sides of $\mathbb{T}_\zeta s_{(p,q)}=(\zeta+p-1)s_{(p-1,q)}+(\zeta+q-2)s_{(p,q-1)}$ expand to $(\zeta+p-1)h_{p-1}h_q+(q-p-1)h_ph_{q-1}-(\zeta+q-2)h_{p+1}h_{q-2}$. So the coefficient of $s_{(d-1-b,b)}$ in $\mathbb{T}_\zeta f$ is $t_bc_b+t'_bc_{b+1}$, with $t_b:=\zeta+d-b-1$ and $t'_b:=\zeta+b-1$ ($0\le b\le\lfloor(d-1)/2\rfloor$; $c_{b+1}:=0$ when $(d-b-1,b+1)$ is not a partition). For odd $d$ the matrix is square upper bidiagonal with determinant $\prod_bt_b$; the kernel is not $0$ if and only if $\zeta=b+1-d$ for some $0\le b\le(d-1)/2$, that is, $\xi=2(a-b)$, and it is then spanned by \[ f^{(r)}_j:=\sum_{b'=0}^{j-1}\binom{r-b'}{j-1-b'}s_{(r+j-1-b',\,b')}\qquad(j=b+1,\ r=a-1-j,\ \mu=a+2-2j). \] For even $d=2h$ there are $h$ rows and $h+1$ unknowns, and for every $\zeta$ the kernel is the line spanned by the signed maximal minors $f_d(\zeta):=\sum_{b=0}^hc_bs_{(d-b,b)}$, $c_b:=(-1)^b\prod_{iq$, as $r\ge j$ if and only if $\mu\ge3$); its coefficient at $b=j-1$ is $1$, on $s_{(r-2,j-1)}$, which is a partition if and only if $r\ge j+1$, that is, $\mu\ge4$. At $\mu=3$ ($r=j$), $\binom{j-2-b}{j-1-b}=0$ on every partition ($b\le j-2$), and the term $b=j-1$ (with $\binom{-1}0$) sits on $s_{(j-2,j-1)}$, which is not a partition and is $0$; so $\mathbb{L}f=0$. (This uses only the shapes of $f^{(r)}_j$, not the parity of $d$.) Even $d=2h$ ($a\ge4$): by Lemma~\ref{lem:Vprime} and the paragraph before it, $\mathbb{L}f_d(\zeta)=\lambda(\zeta)f_{d-2}(\zeta+2)$ for a scalar $\lambda(\zeta)$. Compare the coefficients of $s_{(h-1,h-1)}$: on the left, $c_{h-1}-3c_h=2(-1)^{h-1}(2\zeta+d-1)\prod_{i=0}^{h-2}(\zeta+d-i-1)$ ($s_{(h+1,h-1)}$ gives $c_{h-1}$, and $\mathbb{L}s_{(h,h)}=s_{(h,h-2)}-3s_{(h-1,h-1)}$ gives $-3c_h$); on the right, $\lambda(-1)^{h-1}\prod_{i=0}^{h-2}(\zeta+d-i-1)$ (the last signed minor of degree $d-2$ at $\zeta+2$, whose entries $t_i$ are $(\zeta+2)+(d-2)-i-1$). So $\lambda=2(2\zeta+d-1)$ off finitely many $\zeta$; both sides are polynomials in $\zeta$, hence \[ \mathbb{L}f_d(\zeta)=2(2\zeta+d-1)f_{d-2}(\zeta+2)\qquad\text{for every }\zeta, \] and, as $f_{d-2}(\zeta+2)\ne0$, $\mathbb{L}f=0$ if and only if $2\zeta+a-3=0$, that is, $\mu=3$ (as $\mu=2n\beta-a=6-2\zeta-a$). For $d=2$, $\mathbb{L}f_2=2(2\zeta+1)$. Finally, two-row Schur polynomials of partitions are linearly independent in two variables, so $(\mathbb{L}f)(u_1,u_2)=0$ if and only if $\mathbb{L}f=0$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:Htwo} Let $a\ge3$ and $n\ge a+6$. Then (H2) of Theorem~\ref{thm:oddrows} holds: for every $\xi$ with $\ker\mathbf{B}(\xi)\ne0$, $\mu=\xi-a\notin\{0,3\}$ and $\xi\ne\pm2n$, the coefficient $[y^2]$ of the row $\mathsf{P}$ on $v'(\mu,w_\xi)$ at $p=0$ and $y'=0$ is $\frac13(u_2-u_1)M(1-\beta^2)(\mathbb{L}f_\xi)(u_1,u_2)$, which is a nonzero polynomial in $u_1$, $u_2$ ($M\ne0$, $\beta^2\ne1$, Lemma~\ref{lem:Vzero}). Moreover: \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item for even $a$, $\kappa=0$ is not an eigenvalue (with Theorem~\ref{thm:oddrows}(3)): there $\zeta=3$, $\mu=-a$, $M=-a(a+1)$, and $\mathbb{L}f_d(3)\ne0$; \item at $\xi=2a$ ($f=h_d$, $\mu=a$), $\mathbb{L}h_d=h_{d-2}$, and $[y^2]\mathsf{P}$ is $\frac13(u_2-u_1)a(a+1)(1-a^2/n^2)$ times $h_{a-4}(u_1,u_2)$; \item for odd $a\ge5$ and $f=f^{(a-3)}_2$ ($\mu=a-2$), $\mathbb{L}f=(a-4)h_{a-4}-(u_1^{a-4}+u_2^{a-4})$ as a function of $u_1,u_2$. \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} \begin{proof} $\vartheta_\xi=f_\xi[\mathbf{R}]$ is shift invariant (Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(ii); Lemma~\ref{lem:Hzero}(ii) at $\xi=0$), so $\mathbb{T}_\zeta f_\xi=0$, and $f_\xi$ has at most two rows and degree $a-2$; apply Theorem~\ref{thm:Lprobe} and Lemma~\ref{lem:Vzero}. $M\ne0$ as $\mu\ne0$, and $\beta^2\ne1$ as $\xi\ne\pm2n$. (a)--(c) are the cases $\kappa=0$, $\xi=2a$ and $\xi=2a-2$ of this, with the values of $\mathbb{L}$ above. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:Ltwostable} Let $a\ge3$ and let $n\ge a+6$ be an integer. Every eigenvalue $\kappa$ of the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$ satisfies $n\kappa-a\in\{0,3\}$ or $\kappa\in\{2,-2\}$; in particular, $\kappa=0$ is not an eigenvalue. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Theorem~\ref{thm:oddrows}(3) and Theorem~\ref{thm:Htwo}. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:Ltwostable} (1) At $a=3$ this is Theorem~\ref{thm:secondlayer}, which holds for every $n\ge4$. The computed cases of Conjecture~\ref{conj:L2} in Remark~\ref{rem:secondlayer}(4) ($a=4$ for all but finitely many $n$; $a=5$ at $n=11,12$; $a=6$ at $n=13$) are proved here by hand for $n\ge a+6$ (at $a=4$: $n\ge10$), and extended to every $n\ge a+6$; so at $a=4$ the conclusion can fail only for $n\le9$. (2) With Theorem~\ref{thm:oddrows}, this answers Remark~\ref{rem:topblock}(2) and (4) for $n\ge a+6$, $\kappa=0$ included. The route uses the order-zero rows (Lemma~\ref{lem:elim}) and $\mathsf{G}\mathbf{1}=0$, $\mathsf{G}x=0$, the two sources named in Remark~\ref{rem:topblock}(4), and it is consistent with the count at $a=4$ there (the data lie on the line of Theorem~\ref{thm:oddrows}). It is different from Corollary~\ref{cor:linkred}: it does not use the principle (P1), and it does not prove it. (3) At $s=n$ the range $n\ge a+6$ is depth at most $n-6$, inside Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}; so Theorem~\ref{thm:Ltwostable} gives no new bound on $d(n)$. We do not treat $nd$; so $\mathfrak{r}=0$ and $\mathfrak{e}_{ij}=0$. At $\tau=x_i$: $(\kappa-1)\mathfrak{c}(x_i)+x_{ij}(\partial_j\mathfrak{c})(x_i)=0$ for every $j\ne i$. By Euler's identity and shift invariance, $\sum_l(x_i-x_l)\partial_l\mathfrak{c}=(\tau-x_i)\mathfrak{c}'-d\,\mathfrak{c}$, so summing over $j\ne i$ gives $[(n-1)(\kappa-1)-d]\,\mathfrak{c}(x_i)=0$. So $\mathfrak{c}$, of $\tau$-degree at most $d0$, hence $0$) and may be taken homogeneous (Euler: $f=(\deg f)^{-1}\sum_lx_l\partial_lf$). For $y\ne y'$, $\partial_{y'}F_y=-(\beta-1)\rho_{y'}F_y$, so $\partial_{y'}[u^{-a'}v^{-b'}](S_yF_y)=[u^{-a'}v^{-b'}](M_{yy'}X_{yy'})$ with $M_{yy'}:=(\mathbf{K}\,\mathrm{q}(x_y)\mathrm{q}(x_{y'}))^{-1}$ (symmetric in $y,y'$, nonnegative powers, constant term $1$) and $X_{yy'}:=\mathrm{q}(x_{y'})H_{yy'}+\mathfrak{k}(u+2vx_{y'})S_y$, $H_{yy'}:=\partial_{y'}S_y$. So all lower layers exist if and only if $[u^{-a'}v^{-b'}](M_{yy'}Z_{yy'})=0$ for all $a',b'\ge0$ with $a'+b'\le\bar n-1$, where $Z_{yy'}:=X_{yy'}-X_{y'y}$. The part of $Z_{yy'}$ of total exponent $-\bar n$ is $H_{yy'}-H_{y'y}=0$ (the mixed partials of the top layer), so $Z_{yy'}=\sum z_{a'b'}u^{-a'}v^{-b'}$ over $a'+b'=\bar n-1$, $a',b'\ge-1$. As $M_{yy'}$ has nonnegative powers and constant term $1$, the coefficient at $a'+b'=\bar n-1$, $a',b'\ge0$, is $z_{a'b'}$, and the deeper ones are combinations of these (the terms with $a'=-1$ or $b'=-1$ do not contribute). So the condition is $z_{\bar n-1-j,j}=0$ for $0\le j\le\bar n-1$, and with $k:=y$, $l:=y'$, \[ z_{\bar n-1-j,j}=x_{lk}\,\partial_k\partial_ls_j+(x_l^2-x_k^2)\,\partial_k\partial_ls_{j+1}+\mathfrak{k}(\partial_k-\partial_l)s_j+2\mathfrak{k}(x_l\partial_k-x_k\partial_l)s_{j+1}; \] dividing by $x_{lk}$ gives \textup{(TL)}. As the $s_j$ are symmetric, \textup{(TL)} for one pair gives it for every pair. (c) Every solution satisfies \textup{(AC)} (Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoAC}), so it has the form of Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoB}, and $\vartheta\mapsto(c_{ij})\mapsto(d_{a'b'})$ is bijective (the $c_{ij}$ are unique and the system is unitriangular), $s_j$ has degree $m-\bar n-j$, and by (a), (b) the solutions are a top layer with \textup{(TL)} together with one free constant for each $(a',b')$ with $a'+b'<\bar n$ and $a'+2b'=m$. \end{proof} \emph{Dunkl operators.} For $1\le i\le n$ let $\mathbb{D}_i:=\partial_i+\mathfrak{k}\sum_{l\ne i}(1-\sigma_{il})/x_{il}$, with $\sigma_{il}$ the transposition acting on polynomials (the Dunkl operators of $S_n$). They commute (see \cite{DJO94}), and $[\mathbb{D}_i,x_l]=-\mathfrak{k}\sigma_{il}$ for $i\ne l$. On symmetric $s$, $\mathbb{D}_k\mathbb{D}_ls$ is the expression in Proposition~\ref{prop:steptwochain}(b), and $\mathbb{B}_{kl}s=(x_k+x_l)\mathbb{D}_k\mathbb{D}_ls+\mathfrak{k}(\partial_k+\partial_l)s$. A \emph{singular} polynomial is a $q\ne0$ with $\mathbb{D}_iq=0$ for all $i$; let $d_{\mathrm{sing}}$ be the least degree $\ge1$ of a singular polynomial ($d_{\mathrm{sing}}=\infty$ if there is none). \begin{lemma}[the intertwiner]\label{lem:steptwoV} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item There is a linear map $\mathbb{V}$ on the polynomials of degree less than $d_{\mathrm{sing}}$, bijective in each degree, with $\mathbb{V}1=1$, $\sigma\mathbb{V}=\mathbb{V}\sigma$ for $\sigma\in S_n$, and $\mathbb{D}_i\mathbb{V}q=\mathbb{V}\partial_iq$ for every $q$ of degree less than $d_{\mathrm{sing}}$. \item A singular polynomial of degree $d$ in the isotypic component of $\eta\vdash n$ has $d+\mathfrak{k}N_\eta=0$, where $N_\eta:=\binom n2-\operatorname{ct}(\eta)$ and $\operatorname{ct}(\eta)$ is the sum of the contents of $\eta$. Here $N_{(n)}=0$, $N_{(n-1,1)}=n$, and $N_\eta\ge2(n-1)$ for every other $\eta$. \item At $\kappa=n$, $\mathfrak{k}=-(n-2)/2$, and $d_{\mathrm{sing}}\ge(n-2)(n-1)$ if $n$ is odd, $d_{\mathrm{sing}}\ge n(n-2)/2$ if $n$ is even. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) For polynomials $p,q$ put $[p,q]_{\mathfrak{k}}:=(p(\mathbb{D})q)(0)$, where $p(\mathbb{D})$ is $p$ with $x_i\mapsto\mathbb{D}_i$; it is $0$ between different degrees, $[x_ip,q]_{\mathfrak{k}}=[p,\mathbb{D}_iq]_{\mathfrak{k}}$, and $[\cdot,\cdot]_0$ is $(p(\partial)q)(0)$, which is nondegenerate. For $d0$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:steptwo} For every $n\ge4$, $\kappa=n$ and $0\le m\le m_{\max}=n^2/2-3$, the shift invariant elements of $\mathcal{X}_m$ form a space of dimension $1$ if $m$ is even and $0$ if $m$ is odd. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} First, $\dim\mathcal{X}_m=\lfloor m/2\rfloor+1$ for $0\le m\le m_{\max}$: for odd $n$ by Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwoD}(ii); for even $n$, $\mathfrak{k}=-(n-2)/2$ is an integer, $d_{\mathrm{sing}}\ge n(n-2)/2$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoV}(c), and $m-\bar n\le m_{\max}-\bar n=n(n-2)/2$, with equality only at $m=m_{\max}$ (the degree $a-2$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:steptwo} at $a=(n^2-2)/2$); for that one degree we use from \cite{DJO94} only that an integer $\mathfrak{k}$ admits no singular polynomial, and then Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoDunkl}(v) applies. Next, $m_{\max}\ge5$, and on $\mathcal{X}_0=\mathbb{C}$, $-\partial_{\mathbf{1}}\mathbb{K}''(1)=n\kappa-6=2m_{\max}>0$. For $0\le j0$; so $\mathcal{A}_j$ is invertible and $\partial_{\mathbf{1}}$ maps $\mathcal{X}_{j+1}$ onto $\mathcal{X}_j$. Hence, for $1\le m\le m_{\max}$, the kernel of $\partial_{\mathbf{1}}$ on $\mathcal{X}_m$ has dimension $\dim\mathcal{X}_m-\dim\mathcal{X}_{m-1}=(\lfloor m/2\rfloor+1)-(\lfloor(m-1)/2\rfloor+1)$, which is $1$ for even $m$ and $0$ for odd $m$; and at $m=0$ it is $\mathcal{X}_0=\mathbb{C}$. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:steptwo} For every $n\ge4$ and every odd $a$ with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$, $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue of the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$. Hence $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_{(n^2-a-2,a,2)}=0$, and the conjugation type with conjugate $(n^2-a-3,a-1,1)$ does not occur in $K_{B(n,2)}$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} Let $\varphi$ be a kernel vector at $\kappa=n$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:starn} and step~(1) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone}, $\vartheta_{123}$ is a shift invariant element of $\mathcal{X}_{a-2}$. As $a$ is odd, $a-2$ is odd, and $a-2\le(n^2-2)/2-2=m_{\max}$; so $\vartheta_{123}=0$ by Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo}, which is the hypothesis of Corollary~\ref{cor:Lfive}, and $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue. By Corollary~\ref{cor:pencil}(b) and Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(ii), as in the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:Pone}, $f\mapsto\varphi_f$ is an injection of $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$ into the kernel vectors at $\kappa=n$ ($\tau=(n^2-a-2,a,2)$ is a partition, as $a\le(n^2-2)/2$); so $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau=0$, and the type has multiplicity $\dim\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau=0$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(iii). \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:steptwo} (1) (Scope.) Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo} is stated only for $m\le m_{\max}$, where $\partial_{\mathbf{1}}$ is shown to be onto, and the limit is real: at $n=4$ and $\kappa=3$ ($\mathfrak{k}=-1/2$, of the form $-j/q$) a computation finds a shift invariant solution in degree $5>m_{\max}=3$. The bound in Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwoD}(ii) comes from the proof: at $n=5$ the dimension $\lfloor m/2\rfloor+1$ holds also at $m=14,15$ (a computation; not used). For even dominant $a$, Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo} gives a line of shift invariant solutions in degree $a-2$, so step~(2) fails and Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo} does not give the hypothesis of Corollary~\ref{cor:Lfive}; even $a$ are treated in Subsections~\ref{subsec:evena} and~\ref{subsec:triangle} (Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}). No bound on $d(n)$ follows. (2) (What is new.) The conclusion $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau=0$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:steptwo} was known at $n=4$ (Remark~\ref{rem:Bwindowsmall}), $n=5$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfive}), $n=6$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Ksixsix}), $n=7$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Kseven}) and at $n=8$ for $a\le13$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Pone}); it is new at $n=8$ for $a\ge15$ and at every $n\ge9$. The pencil statement is new beyond the $18$ pairs of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone} and $n=7$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Kseven}). (3) (Computations, supporting; not used.) The steps were checked by exact computation at small $n$: Lemmas~\ref{lem:steptwoAC} and~\ref{lem:steptwoB} at $15$ triples $(n,m,\kappa)$; Proposition~\ref{prop:steptwochain}, line by line, at $n=4$ ($m\le8$, $\kappa=4,5/2$), $n=5$ ($m\le9$, $\kappa=5$) and $n=6$ ($m\le8$); Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoDunkl}(i) with $\mathfrak{k}$ a variable at $n=4,5$ in degrees $1,\dots,5$; and Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoDunkl}(ii)--(iv) (the necessity of the triple products, the two kernels, and that every $s$ with vanishing triple products has an $s'$) at $\mathfrak{k}=-1,-3/2,-2,0$ in degrees $d\le6$. Independently, the number of shift invariant solutions at $\kappa=n$ was computed directly (certified): it is $0$ for odd $a$ at $n=7$, at $n=8$ for odd $a=9,\dots,29$, at $n=9$ for odd $a=9,\dots,21$, and at $n=10,11,12$ in the computed cases, where it is $1$ for even $a$. (4) (Context.) The singular polynomials of $S_n$ are described in \cite{Du04} and \cite{Du05}. This is not used: the bounds of Lemma~\ref{lem:steptwoV}(b), (c) are proved above, and the singular set of \cite{DJO94} is used only in Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwoD}(i) and, at even $n$, for the one degree $m=m_{\max}$ in Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo}. \end{remark} \subsection{Even $a$ at $\kappa=n$: the triangle row}\label{subsec:evena} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$, $b=2$, $n\ge4$ and $\kappa=n$, and we keep the notation of Subsections~\ref{subsec:oddrows}, \ref{subsec:Pone} and~\ref{subsec:Lfive}. For even dominant $a$, step~(2) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone} fails: the shift invariant solutions of \eqref{eq:starn} in degree $a-2$ form a line (Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo}), which contains the stable vector $\vartheta_\xi$ ($\xi=n^2$) read at this $n$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:evenread}); it is spanned by it, as $\vartheta_\xi|_n\ne0$ (Remark~\ref{rem:evenEV}(1) and Theorem~\ref{thm:triangle}). We show that a kernel vector whose $\vartheta_{123}$ lies on that line has data $c\,v'+(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$, where $v'$ is the pair of Corollary~\ref{cor:Rline} (it spans the stable line) read at $n$ and $\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}}\in\mathsf{Z}(n,a)$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:evenA}); that a \emph{triangle} of three order-one rows (two coincident, one generic) vanishes on every $(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:evenB}); and so, if the triangle is not $0$ on $v'$, that $c=0$, after which Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive} kills $\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}}$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV}). Subsection~\ref{subsec:triangle} shows by hand that the triangle is not $0$ on $v'$, at every $n$. \emph{Setting.} Let $a$ be even, $n\le a\le(n-1)^2$, $\mu:=n^2-a$ (so $\mu\ge2n-1>0$), $M:=\mu(a+1)$, $\beta=n/2$, $m:=a-2$ and $\xi:=n^2$. By Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(iii), $\ker\mathbf{B}(\xi)$ is a line (as $m$ is even); let $c=(c_p)$ span it, and let $\vartheta_\xi=\sum_pc_p\mathbf{R}_p\mathbf{R}_{m-p}$ and $w_\xi\in\mathrm{Sym}_a^\perp$ be as after Lemma~\ref{lem:Hzero} (so $\vartheta_{w_\xi}=\vartheta_\xi$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle}(iv)). Put \[ v':=v'(\mu,w_\xi)=(\mathsf{F}',\mathsf{G}')=\bigl(g[s,t]+Mw_\xi,\,-2nw_\xi\bigr),\qquad g'(s)=2n\langle w_\xi(s,u)\rangle_u-Mw_\xi(s,s), \] the pair of Corollary~\ref{cor:Rline}. These are \emph{formal} identities in the slots and $p_1,p_2,\dots$. \emph{No stable range is used.} Subsection~\ref{subsec:oddrows} assumes $n\ge a+6$, but every result of it cited below is an identity in $\mathbb{C}[\text{slots},p_1,p_2,\dots]$ with $p_0=n$ a parameter: Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}; Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle}(i), (iv); the existence part of Theorem~\ref{thm:Spairs}; the definition of $v'$ in Corollary~\ref{cor:Rline} (not its conclusion); Lemma~\ref{lem:Hprod}(ii); Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(i)--(iii). The stable range enters there only in (a) the two-point form and the uniqueness of the data of an actual $\varphi$, (b) the independence statement for $n\ge N+4$ (used in the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:star} and in the probe of Theorem~\ref{thm:Lprobe}), (c) the conclusions of Corollary~\ref{cor:Rline} and of Theorem~\ref{thm:oddrows}(2), and (d) Corollary~\ref{cor:oddrows}; none of them is used here. For kernel vectors we use only results proved at a fixed $n$: Lemma~\ref{lem:elim}, the first sentence of Corollary~\ref{cor:twopoint}, Lemmas~\ref{lem:starn} and~\ref{lem:tie}, Proposition~\ref{prop:Zspace}, Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive} and step~(6) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone}. \emph{Reading at $n$.} For a formal pair $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ of symmetric two-point functions let $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})|_n$ be the torus family $\mathsf{F}_{rt}=\mathsf{F}(x_r,x_t)$ ($r\ne t$), $\mathsf{G}_{rt}=\mathsf{G}(x_r,x_t)+\delta_{rt}\mathsf{F}(x_r,x_r)$, with $p_k:=\sum_{l=1}^nx_l^k$ ($p_0=n$). Every formal identity specializes. \begin{lemma}[reading at $n$]\label{lem:evenread} Write $\mathsf{F}'$, $\mathsf{G}'$, $\mathsf{H}'$ for the torus data of $v'|_n$ and their $\mathsf{H}$. Then: \begin{enumerate}[label=(f\arabic*),leftmargin=*] \item $\mathsf{H}'_{rwt}=M\,x_{rw}x_{wt}x_{tr}\,\vartheta_\xi(x_r,x_w,x_t)$; \item $\sum_t\mathsf{G}'_{jt}=0$; \item $M\,\mathsf{G}'(x_j,x_t)=\frac2{x_{tj}}\sum_{w\notin\{t,j\}}\mathsf{H}'_{twj}$ for $j\ne t$; \item $\mathsf{F}'|_n$ and $\mathsf{G}'|_n$ are shift invariant, homogeneous of degree $a$, symmetric and $S_n$-equivariant; \item $\mathsf{G}'_{rr}=\mathsf{F}'_{rt}+\mathsf{G}'_{rt}$ on $x_r=x_t$. \end{enumerate} Moreover $\vartheta_\xi|_n$ solves \eqref{eq:starn}, is symmetric in $x_1,x_2,x_3$ and in $x_4,\dots,x_n$, and is shift invariant; so $\mathbb{C}\,\vartheta_\xi|_n$ lies in the space of shift invariant solutions of \eqref{eq:starn} in degree $m$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (f1) Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle} gives $\mathsf{H}(s,v,t)=(s-v)(v-t)(t-s)\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}(s,t,v)$, with $\vartheta_{g[s,t]}=0$ (by its part (i)) and $\vartheta_{w_\xi}=\vartheta_\xi$ (by its part (iv)). (f2) \eqref{eq:Cone} holds for $v'$ by the existence construction of Theorem~\ref{thm:Spairs} ($g'=-\langle\mathsf{G}'(s,u)\rangle_u-Mw_\xi(s,s)$). (f3) Corollary~\ref{cor:twopoint} is an identity at every $n$: the sum is $\mathfrak{h}(x_t)-\mathfrak{h}(x_j)-nx_{tj}\mathsf{F}'(x_t,x_j)$ with $\mathfrak{h}=\mathfrak{h}_{\mathsf{F}'}$; formally $\mathfrak{h}_{\mathsf{F}'}=ng-\langle g\rangle$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}: $\mathfrak{h}_{w_\xi}=0$), so $2(\mathfrak{h}_{\mathsf{F}'}[s,t]-n\mathsf{F}')=-2nMw_\xi=M\mathsf{G}'$. (f4) $\mathsf{F}'$ and $\mathsf{G}'$ are symmetric, shift invariant and of weighted degree $a$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Spairs} and Lemma~\ref{lem:Pproj}); reading at $n$ keeps this and gives $S_n$-equivariant families. (f5) By the convention $\mathsf{G}_{rr}=\mathsf{G}(x_r,x_r)+\mathsf{F}(x_r,x_r)$. Finally, $\vartheta_\xi$ solves \eqref{eq:star} formally (Lemma~\ref{lem:Hprod}(ii) with Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(i); Corollary~\ref{cor:star} supplies only the equation, and its conclusion for kernel vectors uses the stable range), and \eqref{eq:star} specializes to \eqref{eq:starn} (in the form of Lemma~\ref{lem:starn}: $\partial_3$ of a function of $x_1,x_2,x_4$ and the $p_k$ is $\mathcal{D}_{x_3}$); $\vartheta_\xi|_n$ is symmetric as stated, and shift invariant by Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(ii). \end{proof} For even $a$ with $n\le a\le(n-1)^2$ consider the condition \[ \text{every kernel vector at }\kappa=n\text{ has }\vartheta_{123}\in\mathbb{C}\,\vartheta_\xi|_n.\tag{2$'$} \] So (2$'$) says that $\vartheta_{123}$ of every kernel vector lies on $\mathbb{C}\,\vartheta_\xi|_n$; it holds when $\mathbb{C}\,\vartheta_\xi|_n$ is the whole space of shift invariant solutions of \eqref{eq:starn} in degree $m$ (see Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}). \begin{lemma}[the even data]\label{lem:evenA} Let $\varphi$ be a kernel vector at $\kappa=n$ with data $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ and $\vartheta_{123}=c\,\vartheta_\xi|_n$. Put $\mathsf{D}:=M(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})-c\,v'|_n$ (torus families). Then $\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}=0$ and $\mathsf{F}^{\mathsf{D}}\in\mathsf{Z}(n,a)$; so $M(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})=c\,v'|_n+(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$ with $\mathfrak{c}$ shift invariant and homogeneous of degree $a-n$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:Zspace}(b)). \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) $\mathsf{H}^{\mathsf{D}}=0$: $\mathsf{H}_{rwt}(\mathsf{F})=x_{rw}x_{wt}x_{tr}\vartheta_{rwt}$ and $\vartheta_{rwt}=c\,\vartheta_\xi(x_r,x_w,x_t)$ (both sides are obtained from the $123$ one by permuting coordinates), so $\mathsf{H}(M\mathsf{F})=c\,\mathsf{H}(\mathsf{F}'|_n)$ by (f1). (ii) $\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}_{jt}=0$ for $j\ne t$: Lemma~\ref{lem:elim} for $\varphi$ ($\mu\ne0$) gives $M\mathsf{G}_{jt}=\frac2{x_{tj}}\sum_w\mathsf{H}_{twj}$; with (f3), $M\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}_{jt}=\frac2{x_{tj}}\sum_w\mathsf{H}^{\mathsf{D}}_{twj}=0$, at distinct coordinates and so as polynomials. (iii) $\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}_{jj}=0$: $\mathsf{G}\mathbf{1}=0$ for $\varphi$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:secondlayer}, the torus form) and (f2) give $\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}\mathbf{1}=0$. (iv) $\mathsf{F}^{\mathsf{D}}_{rt}=0$ on $x_r=x_t$: Lemma~\ref{lem:tie} for $\varphi$ and (f5) for $v'$ give $\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}_{rr}=\mathsf{F}^{\mathsf{D}}_{rt}+\mathsf{G}^{\mathsf{D}}_{rt}$ there; use (ii) and (iii). (v) $\mathsf{F}^{\mathsf{D}}$ is symmetric, equivariant, shift invariant and homogeneous of degree $a$ by (f4), with $\mathsf{H}^{\mathsf{D}}=0$ and (iv): so $\mathsf{F}^{\mathsf{D}}\in\mathsf{Z}(n,a)$. \end{proof} \emph{The triangle.} For distinct $p,p',i,j$ and any torus data $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ put \[ \mathsf{T}^{(ij)}_{pp'}(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G}):=x_{pi}\Psi_{pi}(e_i,e_j)-x_{p'i}\Psi_{p'i}(e_i,e_j)-x_{pp'}\Psi_{pp'}(e_i,e_j), \] with the rows of Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone}, each in its \emph{shifted} form of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} (shift $c=-x_p$ for the row's own $p$; this is the form used in every computation below). Here $\Psi_{pi}(e_i,e_j)$ is the coincident row $\Psi_{pq}(e_q,e_l)$ at $(q,l)=(i,j)$, and $\Psi_{pp'}(e_i,e_j)$ is a generic row. \begin{lemma}[cycles kill $\mathsf{Z}$]\label{lem:evenB} $\mathsf{T}^{(ij)}_{pp'}(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)=0$ identically in $x$, for every $\kappa$ and every shift invariant homogeneous $\mathfrak{c}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} On $(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$, with $h=\mathfrak{H}_{\mathfrak{c}}$ and $\mathfrak{K}_{ij}=\kappa(h_j-h_i)-x_{ij}h_{ij}$: the generic row is $\Psi_{pq}(e_i,e_j)=\mathfrak{K}_{ij}[x_p,x_q]$ (proof of Proposition~\ref{prop:Rgeneric}; that step uses no degree bound), and the coincident row is $\Psi_{pi}(e_i,e_j)=\mathfrak{K}_{ij}[x_p,x_i]$ (step~(1) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive}). So $x_{pq}\Psi_{pq}(e_i,e_j)=\mathfrak{K}_{ij}(x_p)-\mathfrak{K}_{ij}(x_q)$ for $q\in\{i,p'\}$, and $\mathsf{T}=[\mathfrak{K}(x_p)-\mathfrak{K}(x_i)]-[\mathfrak{K}(x_{p'})-\mathfrak{K}(x_i)]-[\mathfrak{K}(x_p)-\mathfrak{K}(x_{p'})]=0$. \end{proof} The shifted form is safe for both uses: every shifted row vanishes on a kernel vector (Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone} holds with every explicit coefficient $x_l$ replaced by $x_l+c$; apply it at each point), and $(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$ is the data of the actual function $\varphi_{\mathfrak{c}}$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:Zspace}(d)), so its rows do not depend on the shift. (The same telescoping kills every closed path in which each edge $\{q,r\}$ enters as $\pm x_{qr}\Psi_{qr}(e_i,e_j)$ with $q\notin\{i,j\}$; for example the square $x_{pi}\Psi_{pi}(e_i,e_j)-x_{p'i}\Psi_{p'i}(e_i,e_j)+x_{p'j}\Psi_{p'j}(e_i,e_j)-x_{pj}\Psi_{pj}(e_i,e_j)$ of coincident rows only, as $\Psi_{pj}(e_i,e_j)=-\Psi_{pj}(e_j,e_i)=-\mathfrak{K}_{ji}[x_p,x_j]=\mathfrak{K}_{ij}[x_p,x_j]$.) Fix distinct $p,p',i,j$ once and for all, and put $\mathsf{T}_{v'}:=\mathsf{T}^{(ij)}_{pp'}(v'|_n)$, a polynomial in $x$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV} needs $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$ at this one choice only). (If $\vartheta_\xi|_n=0$, then (2$'$) is step~(2) and Corollary~\ref{cor:Lfive} applies; this case does not occur when $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$, see Remark~\ref{rem:evenEV}(1).) \begin{lemma}[the triangle sees only $\vartheta$]\label{lem:evenBprime} In two-point form (formal, or read at any $n$), $\mathsf{T}=0$ on $(0,\tilde g)$ for every symmetric $\tilde g$ and on $(\eta[s,t],0)$ for every $\eta(\tau)$. So $\mathsf{T}(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ depends only on $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}$, and $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=M\,\mathsf{T}((w_\xi,0)|_n)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Write the generic row of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} (the row $\mathsf{P}$, shift $c=-x_p$) with $y=P:=x_p$, $y'=Q:=x_q$, $u_1=A:=x_i$, $u_2=B:=x_j$; the $\Lambda_{[1]}$-term is $-(\Lambda(P,Q;B)-\Lambda(A,Q;B))$ after the factor $A-P$, so \begin{multline*} \mathsf{R}=\kappa\bigl(\Lambda(P,Q;B)-\Lambda(P,Q;A)\bigr)-(A-P)\mathcal{D}_A\Lambda(P,Q;B)+(B-P)\mathcal{D}_B\Lambda(P,Q;A)\\ -(A-P)\Lambda(P,[Q,A];B)+(B-P)\Lambda(P,[Q,B];A)-\Lambda(P,Q;B)+\Lambda(A,Q;B)\\ +\Lambda(P,Q;A)-\Lambda(B,Q;A)-\bigl(\mathcal{D}_A\mathsf{G}(Q,B)-\mathcal{D}_B\mathsf{G}(Q,A)\bigr). \end{multline*} \emph{On $(0,\tilde g)$}: $\Lambda(s,s';t)=\gamma_t[s,s']$ with $\gamma_t(\tau):=-\tilde g(\tau,t)$; the divided-difference terms cancel in pairs ($\gamma_B[P,Q,A]$ twice), and with $\gamma_{BA}:=-\mathcal{D}_A\tilde g(\cdot,B)$, $\gamma_{AB}:=-\mathcal{D}_B\tilde g(\cdot,A)$ one gets \[ (P-Q)\mathsf{R}=\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}(P)-\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}(Q),\qquad\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}(\tau):=\kappa(\gamma_B-\gamma_A)(\tau)+(\tau-A)\gamma_{BA}(\tau)-(\tau-B)\gamma_{AB}(\tau) \] (the $\mathsf{G}$-term of the row cancels the two non-telescoping pieces $(Q-P)\gamma_{BA}(Q)$ and $-(Q-P)\gamma_{AB}(Q)$). \emph{On $(\eta[s,t],0)$}: $\Lambda=\eta_t[s,s']$ with $\eta_t:=\mathcal{D}_t\eta$; the divided-difference terms cancel as before, and $(P-Q)\mathsf{R}=\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}(P)-\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}(Q)$ with $\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}=\kappa(\eta_B-\eta_A)-(A-B)\eta_{AB}$, $\eta_{AB}:=\mathcal{D}_A\mathcal{D}_B\eta$ (the $\mathfrak{K}_{AB}$ of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Lfive}; the two non-telescoping pieces $(Q-P)\eta_{AB}(Q)$ cancel each other). The coincident rows are these formulas at $Q:=A$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:mirrorrows}(ii), for every symmetric datum), with the \emph{same} $\widetilde{\mathfrak{K}}$ (it depends on $(A,B)$ only), so every closed path telescopes. For two-point data read at $n$, Lemma~\ref{lem:mirrorrows}(ii) is an identity between \emph{formulas}---two-point algebra and the chain rule $d/dx_q=\partial_{\mathrm{slot}}+\mathcal{D}_{x_q}$---valid at every $n$; step~(1) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive} is an instance. What fails at a given $n$ is the different statement ``the generic rows vanish, therefore the coincident rows vanish'' (Remark~\ref{rem:Lfive}(2)). Finally $v'=(g[s,t]+Mw_\xi,-2nw_\xi)=M(w_\xi,0)+(g[s,t],0)+(0,-2nw_\xi)$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:evenEV} Let $n\ge4$, $a$ even with $n\le a\le(n-1)^2$, $\kappa=n$ and $\xi=n^2$, and assume \textup{(2$'$)}. If the polynomial $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ is not identically $0$, then $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue of the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Let $\varphi$ be a kernel vector at $\kappa=n$. By (2$'$) and Lemma~\ref{lem:evenA}, $M(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})=c\,v'|_n+(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$. Every row of Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone} is linear in the torus data and vanishes on $(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$; so $0=c\,\mathsf{T}_{v'}+\mathsf{T}(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)= c\,\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:evenB}, and $c=0$ as $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$. Then $M(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})=(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$ passes every coincident order-one row at $\kappa=n$, and $a\le(n-1)^2$, so $\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}}=0$ by Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive}; then $\mathsf{F}=\mathsf{G}=0$, and $\varphi=0$ by step~(6) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone}. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:evenEV} (1) $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$ forces $\vartheta_\xi|_n\ne0$: if $\vartheta_\xi|_n=0$, then $\mathsf{H}(\mathsf{F}'|_n)=0$ by (f1), $\mathsf{G}'_{jt}=0$ ($j\ne t$) by (f3), $\mathsf{G}'_{jj}=0$ by (f2), $\mathsf{F}'|_n\in\mathsf{Z}(n,a)$ by (f5), and $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=0$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:evenB}. (2) (Uses.) Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV} uses $\mu\ne0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:elim}), $n\ge4$ (four indices), $a\ge n$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:Zspace}(b), Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive}) and $a\le(n-1)^2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive}); dominance, $a\le(n^2-2)/2$, only makes $\tau=(n^2-a-2,a,2)$ a partition. Its proof uses only Lemmas~\ref{lem:evenA} and~\ref{lem:evenB}, Theorem~\ref{thm:Lfive} and step~(6) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone}; Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime} serves the computation of $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ in Subsection~\ref{subsec:triangle}. For odd $a$ the same argument with $c=0$ is Corollary~\ref{cor:Lfive}. (3) (Structure; only the two-point form of $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ is used below, in Subsection~\ref{subsec:triangle}.) In two-point form write $\mathsf{R}(P,Q;A,B):=\Psi_{pq}(e_i,e_j)$ at $(x_p,x_q,x_i,x_j)=(P,Q,A,B)$ and $\mathsf{X}(P,Q;B):=\mathsf{R}(P,Q;Q,B)$ ($=\Psi_{pq}(e_q,e_l)$, Lemma~\ref{lem:mirrorrows}(ii), as an identity between formulas). Then, with $Q:=x_{p'}$, $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=(P-A)\mathsf{X}(P,A;B)-(Q-A)\mathsf{X}(Q,A;B)-(P-Q)\mathsf{R}(P,Q;A,B)$. $\mathsf{R}$ is antisymmetric in $(A,B)$, and on $v'$ its odd part $\mathsf{R}(P,Q;\dots)-\mathsf{R}(Q,P;\dots)$ is $0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:oddO} and the formal \eqref{eq:star}: the display of Corollary~\ref{cor:star} with $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}'}=M\vartheta_\xi$, which solves \eqref{eq:star} formally by Lemma~\ref{lem:Hprod}; \eqref{eq:starn} at distinct points is not enough for these substitutions). Hence $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ vanishes at $P=Q$, at $Q=A$, at $P=A$ and at $A=B$, so it is divisible by $(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)(A-B)$; the closed form of Corollary~\ref{cor:closedform} exhibits this factor. (4) (Computations, supporting; superseded by Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}.) $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ was evaluated exactly at a point of $\mathbb{C}^n$ (a nonzero value certifies $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$ as a polynomial): from the rows directly at $9$ pairs $(n,a)$, and by the seed device of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} at all $66$ dominant even pairs with $4\le n\le10$, with no zero; the two computations agree at the $9$ pairs, and an independent program from the rows as printed in Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone} finds $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$ at all $66$. (At points with many zero coordinates the top degrees die at even $n$, as $\beta$ is an integer; a generic point is needed.) With the certified bound $\le1$ for the dimension of the shift invariant solutions of \eqref{eq:starn} at $18$ of these pairs, or with Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo} at all $66$, Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV} gave $\kappa=n$ not an eigenvalue there before Subsection~\ref{subsec:triangle}. Controls: $\mathsf{T}=0$ on $(\mathsf{F}^{\mathfrak{c}},0)$ (for $\mathfrak{c}=1$ and $\tau-p_1/4$ at $n=4$, $(\tau-p_1/5)^2$ at $n=5$) while the single rows are not $0$, and $\mathsf{T}=0$ as a formal polynomial on random $(0,g)$ and $(\eta[s,t],0)$. \end{remark} \subsection{The triangle is not $0$, and the layer $\tau_3=2$ at every $n$}\label{subsec:triangle} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$, $b=2$, $n\ge4$, $\kappa=n=2\beta$, and $a$ is even with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$; we keep the notation of Subsection~\ref{subsec:evena}. We compute $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ in closed form by hand (Proposition~\ref{prop:seed} and Corollary~\ref{cor:closedform}): it is $M(\beta^2-1)$ times four linear forms times a plethystic value of $\mathbb{L}f_\xi$, the same operator $\mathbb{L}=(h_2-3e_2)^\perp$ and the same factor $1-\beta^2$ as in the stable probe of Theorem~\ref{thm:Lprobe}. We then show that this value is not the zero polynomial (Proposition~\ref{prop:gpoints}), so $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$ at every $n$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:triangle}), and with Theorems~\ref{thm:evenEV} and~\ref{thm:steptwo} $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue for even $a$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}). With Corollary~\ref{cor:steptwo} for odd $a$, this settles the layer $\tau_3=2$ of $K_{B(n,2)}$ at every $n\ge4$. \emph{Setting.} In two-point form (Remark~\ref{rem:evenEV}(3)), with $(P,Q,A,B):=(x_p,x_{p'},x_i,x_j)$, $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=(P-A)\mathsf{X}(P,A;B)-(Q-A)\mathsf{X}(Q,A;B)-(P-Q)\mathsf{R}(P,Q;A,B)$, the rows in the shifted form of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable}; at a given $n$, Lemma~\ref{lem:mirrorrows}(ii) is used as an identity between formulas (Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime}), not as the vanishing statement of Remark~\ref{rem:Lfive}(2). Every input from Subsections~\ref{subsec:oddrows} and~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} below is a formal identity in the slots and $p_1,p_2,\dots$ ($p_0=n$ a parameter); $n\ge a+6$ is not used; $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ is the formal $\mathsf{T}$ read at $n$, so that $\mathbf{E}(z)\mapsto\prod_l(1-x_lz)^\beta$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime}, $\mathsf{T}(\mathsf{F},\mathsf{G})$ depends only on $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}$, and $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=M\,\mathsf{T}((w_\xi,0))$; for $\mathsf{G}=0$ the row is \begin{multline*} \mathsf{R}=\kappa\bigl(\Lambda(P,Q;B)-\Lambda(P,Q;A)\bigr)-(A-P)\mathcal{D}_A\Lambda(P,Q;B)+(B-P)\mathcal{D}_B\Lambda(P,Q;A)\\ -(A-P)\Lambda(P,[Q,A];B)+(B-P)\Lambda(P,[Q,B];A)-\Lambda(P,Q;B)+\Lambda(A,Q;B)\\ +\Lambda(P,Q;A)-\Lambda(B,Q;A), \end{multline*} $\Lambda(s,s';t):=\mathcal{D}_t\mathsf{F}(s,s')+(s'-s)\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}(s,s',t)$, with $\kappa=2\beta=n$. Here $\vartheta_\xi=\sum_{p\le m/2}c_p\mathbf{R}_p\mathbf{R}_{m-p}$ (the definition after Lemma~\ref{lem:Hzero}; $\ker\mathbf{B}(\xi)$ is a line by Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(iii)), $m=a-2$. So $\vartheta_\xi=\sum_pc_p[z_1^pz_2^{m-p}]\,\mathrm{seed}$, with \[ \mathrm{seed}:=K\,U(s)U(t)U(v),\qquad K:=\mathbf{E}(z_1)\mathbf{E}(z_2),\qquad U(y):=\frac1{(1-yz_1)(1-yz_2)}, \] and, as $\mathcal{D}^{[r]}\mathbf{E}=-\beta\tau^{r+1}\mathbf{E}$, we have $\mathcal{D}_uK=-\beta\,\ell_uK$ with $\ell_u=U'(u)/U(u)=z_1/(1-uz_1)+z_2/(1-uz_2)$, as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable}. $\mathsf{T}$ is linear and acts on the slots and the $p_k$ only, so $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=M\sum_pc_p[z_1^pz_2^{m-p}]\,\mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]$ (coefficientwise in $z_1,z_2$), where $\mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]:=\mathsf{T}(\mathsf{F},0)$ with $\mathsf{F}$ of Step~0 below, by Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime}. This is the seed device of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} (the Cauchy identity \cite[I, \S4]{Ma95}; the probe is linear in $\vartheta$), here at a finite $n$. \begin{proposition}[the seed identity]\label{prop:seed} For every $\beta$ (with $\kappa=2\beta$), $\mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]/K$ is a rational function of $z_1,z_2,P,Q,A,B,\beta$, and, coefficientwise in $z_1,z_2$, \[ \mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]=K\,(\beta^2-1)\,(z_1-z_2)^2\,(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)(A-B)\,U(P)U(Q)U(A)^2U(B). \] \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Put $\delta:=z_1-z_2$, $e:=z_1z_2$, $\alpha_1(y):=z_1/(1-yz_1)$ and $\alpha_2(y):=z_2/(1-yz_2)$ (slot functions; no $p_k$). In this proof $\delta$, $e$ (a scalar, not an elementary symmetric function), $\alpha_1$, $\alpha_2$, $\Pi$, $V$, $W$, $\sigma_1$, $\sigma_2$ are local symbols. (P1) $\alpha_1(y)-\alpha_1(y')=(y-y')\alpha_1(y)\alpha_1(y')$, and the same for $\alpha_2$ (as $1/\alpha_1(y)=1/z_1-y$). (P2) $U(y)=(\alpha_1(y)-\alpha_2(y))/\delta=\alpha_1(y)\alpha_2(y)/e$ and $\ell_y=\alpha_1(y)+\alpha_2(y)$. (P3) $U[y,y']=(\alpha_1(y)\alpha_1(y')-\alpha_2(y)\alpha_2(y'))/\delta$ (by (P1), (P2)); at $y'=y$, $U'(y)=U(y)\ell_y$. (P4) $\alpha_1(y)\alpha_2(y')-\alpha_1(y')\alpha_2(y)=(y-y')\,\delta e\,U(y)U(y')$: the left side is $\alpha_1(y)\alpha_1(y')\alpha_2(y)\alpha_2(y')[(1/z_1-y')(1/z_2-y)-(1/z_1-y)(1/z_2-y')]=e^2U(y)U(y')(y-y')(1/z_2-1/z_1)$. \emph{Step 0 (a representative).} $\mathsf{F}:=-K\,U(s)U(s')/e$ has $\vartheta_{\mathsf{F}}=\mathrm{seed}$. Indeed, with $\mathsf{H}(s,t)=(s-t)\mathsf{F}(s,t)$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:cocycle}), $\mathsf{H}(s,v,t)=-(K/e)U(s)U(v)U(t)\sum_{\mathrm{cyc}}(s-v)\Pi(t)$ with $\Pi(y):=1/U(y)=1-(z_1+z_2)y+ey^2$, and $\sum_{\mathrm{cyc}}(s-v)t^k=0,0,-(s-v)(v-t)(t-s)$ for $k=0,1,2$; so $\mathsf{H}(s,v,t)=(s-v)(v-t)(t-s)K\,U(s)U(v)U(t)$. (Coefficientwise in $z_1,z_2$ the exponents of $\mathsf{F}$ are $\ge-1$, and the coefficients with a negative exponent have $\vartheta=0$, the seed having none; so by Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime} they add nothing to $\mathsf{T}$.) By Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime}, $\mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]=\mathsf{T}(\mathsf{F},0)$, and \[ \Lambda=(\beta/e)\Lambda_\ell+\Lambda_u,\qquad\Lambda_\ell:=K\,U(s)U(s')\ell_t,\qquad\Lambda_u:=K(s'-s)U(s)U(s')U(t). \] \emph{Step 1 (powers of $\beta$).} $\mathcal{D}$ acts on $K$ only ($\mathcal{D}_u\mapsto-\beta \ell_u$), so $\mathsf{R}=\beta\mathsf{R}^1[\Lambda]+\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda]$ with \[ \mathsf{R}^1[\Lambda]:=2\bigl(\Lambda(P,Q;B)-\Lambda(P,Q;A)\bigr)+(A-P)\ell_A\Lambda(P,Q;B)-(B-P)\ell_B\Lambda(P,Q;A), \] and $\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda]$ the six $\beta$-free terms (the two divided differences and the four swaps). Write $W(x,y):=(x-y)\mathsf{R}(x,y;A,B)$ (row point $x$, second slot $y$; at $y=A$ the coincident row is the continuous extension) and $\mathsf{T}(W):=W(P,A)-W(Q,A)-W(P,Q)$; then $\mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]=\mathsf{T}(W)$, and so, with $\mathsf{T}^i[\Lambda]$ the value of $\mathsf{T}$ on $(x-y)\mathsf{R}^i[\Lambda]$, \[ \mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]=(\beta^2/e)\,\mathsf{T}^1[\Lambda_\ell]+\beta\bigl(\mathsf{T}^1[\Lambda_u]+\mathsf{T}^0[\Lambda_\ell]/e\bigr)+\mathsf{T}^0[\Lambda_u]. \] \emph{Step 2 (the rows).} (2a) $\mathsf{R}^1[\Lambda_\ell]=K\,U(x)U(y)\bigl[2(\ell_B-\ell_A)+(A-B)\ell_A\ell_B\bigr]$ (the $x$-terms cancel) $=-K(A-B)\delta^2U(A)U(B)U(x)U(y)$, since $2(\ell_A-\ell_B)-(A-B)\ell_A\ell_B=(A-B)[2\alpha_1(A)\alpha_1(B)+2\alpha_2(A)\alpha_2(B)-\ell_A\ell_B]= (A-B)(\alpha_1(A)-\alpha_2(A))(\alpha_1(B)-\alpha_2(B))$. (2b) $\mathsf{R}^1[\Lambda_u]+\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda_\ell]/e=0$. Here $\mathsf{R}^1[\Lambda_u]=K(y-x)U(x)U(y)\bigl[2(U(B)-U(A))+(A-x)\ell_AU(B)-(B-x)\ell_BU(A)\bigr]$, and $\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda_\ell]=K(\ell_B\chi^{(\ell)}(A)-\ell_A\chi^{(\ell)}(B))$ with $\chi^{(\ell)}(A):=-(A-x)U(x)U[y,A]-U(x)U(y)+U(A)U(y)=(y-x)(U(A)U[x,y]-U(x)U[y,A])$ (write $(A-x)/(y-A)=-1+(y-x)/(y-A)$) $=e(y-x)(A-x)U(A)U(x)U(y)$ (by (P2), (P3): $\delta^2(U(A)U[x,y]-U(x)U[y,A])=(\alpha_1(y)-\alpha_2(y))(\alpha_1(A)\alpha_2(x)-\alpha_1(x)\alpha_2(A))$, then (P4)). The sum is $K(y-x)U(x)U(y)\bigl[2(U(B)-U(A))+(A-B)(\ell_AU(B)+U(A)\ell_B)\bigr]$, and the bracket is $0$: $U(B)-U(A)=(B-A)(\alpha_1(A)\alpha_1(B)-\alpha_2(A)\alpha_2(B))/\delta$ and $\ell_AU(B)+U(A)\ell_B=2(\alpha_1(A)\alpha_1(B)-\alpha_2(A)\alpha_2(B))/\delta$. (2c) $\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda_u]=K(A-B)U(A)U(B)\bigl[e(y-x)^2U(x)U(y)-(U(x)+U(y))\bigr]$. Indeed $\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda_u]=K(U(B)\chi^{(u)}(A)-U(A)\chi^{(u)}(B))$ with $\chi^{(u)}(A):=-(y-x)^2U(x)U[y,A]-(y+A-2x)U(x)U(A)+(y-A)U(A)U(y)$ (the same rewriting of $(A-x)/(y-A)$, and $[(\cdot-x)U][y,A]=(y-x)U[y,A]+U(A)$); so $\mathsf{R}^0[\Lambda_u]=-K(y-x)^2U(x)(U(B)U[y,A]-U(A)U[y,B])+K(B-A)U(A)U(B)(U(x)+U(y))$, and $U(B)U[y,A]-U(A)U[y,B]=(\alpha_1(A)\alpha_2(B)-\alpha_1(B)\alpha_2(A))(\alpha_2(y)-\alpha_1(y))/\delta^2=-(A-B)e\,U(A)U(B)U(y)$ by (P4). (All three are symmetric in $x,y$---a consistency check, in line with Corollary~\ref{cor:star}.) \emph{Step 3 (the triangle).} With $V:=(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)$, $\sigma_1:=P+Q+A$, $\sigma_2:=PQ+QA+AP$ and $\Pi=1/U$: for $\Sigma_k:=(P-A)^3Q^k-(Q-A)^3P^k-(P-Q)^3A^k$ and $\Sigma'_k:=(P-A)Q^k-(Q-A)P^k-(P-Q)A^k$ ($k=0,1,2$), putting $P=A+u_1$, $Q=A+u_2$ gives $\Sigma_0=3V$, $\Sigma_1=V\sigma_1$, $\Sigma_2=V\sigma_2$ and $\Sigma'_0=\Sigma'_1=0$, $\Sigma'_2=-V$. Hence \begin{gather*} \mathsf{T}\bigl((x-y)U(x)U(y)\bigr)=U(P)U(Q)U(A)\,(\Sigma'_0-(z_1+z_2)\Sigma'_1+e\Sigma'_2)=-e\,V\,U(P)U(Q)U(A),\\ \mathsf{T}\bigl((x-y)^3U(x)U(y)\bigr)=V\bigl(3-(z_1+z_2)\sigma_1+e\sigma_2\bigr)U(P)U(Q)U(A),\\ \mathsf{T}\bigl((x-y)(f(x)+f(y))\bigr)=f(A)(P-Q)+f(P)(Q-A)+f(Q)(A-P)=V\,f[P,Q,A], \end{gather*} and for $f=U$, $U[P,Q,A]=\bigl((z_1+z_2)^2-e-e(z_1+z_2)\sigma_1+e^2\sigma_2\bigr)U(P)U(Q)U(A)$ (from $U[P,Q]=((z_1+z_2)-e(P+Q))U(P)U(Q)$, as $\Pi[P,Q]=-(z_1+z_2)+e(P+Q)$, and one more divided difference). \emph{Step 4 (assembly).} Put $\Delta_0:=K\delta^2V(A-B)U(P)U(Q)U(A)^2U(B)$. Then $\mathsf{T}^1[\Lambda_\ell]=-K(A-B)\delta^2U(A)U(B)\cdot(-eVU(P)U(Q)U(A))=e\Delta_0$ by (2a); $\mathsf{T}^1[\Lambda_u]+\mathsf{T}^0[\Lambda_\ell]/e=0$ by (2b); and by (2c) and Step~3, $\mathsf{T}^0[\Lambda_u]=K(A-B)U(A)^2U(B)U(P)U(Q)V\bigl[4e-(z_1+z_2)^2\bigr]=-\Delta_0$, as $(z_1+z_2)^2-4e=\delta^2$. So $\mathsf{T}[\mathrm{seed}]=(\beta^2/e)e\Delta_0-\Delta_0=(\beta^2-1)\Delta_0$. \end{proof} For a symmetric function $f$, $Y:=\{P,Q,A,A,B\}$ and the alphabet $X:=\{x_1,\dots,x_n\}$ let $f[Y-\beta X]$ be the image of $f$ under $h_k\mapsto[t^k]\prod_{y\in Y}(1-yt)^{-1}\prod_l(1-x_lt)^\beta$, and put $f_\xi:=\sum_{p=0}^{m/2}c_ph_ph_{m-p}$ (Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable}) and $\mathsf{g}:=\mathbb{L}f_\xi$ (not the $g$ of $v'$). \begin{corollary}[closed form]\label{cor:closedform} $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=M(\beta^2-1)(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)(A-B)\,\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} By Proposition~\ref{prop:seed}, $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=M(\beta^2-1)(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)(A-B)\sum_pc_p[z_1^pz_2^{m-p}](z_1-z_2)^2H(z_1)H(z_2)$ with $H(z):=\mathbf{E}(z)/((1-Pz)(1-Qz)(1-Az)^2(1-Bz))=\sum_kh_k[Y-\beta X]z^k$, so that $K\,U(P)U(Q)U(A)^2U(B)=H(z_1)H(z_2)$. And \begin{multline*} [z_1^pz_2^{m-p}](z_1-z_2)^2H(z_1)H(z_2)=(h_{p-2}h_{m-p}-2h_{p-1}h_{m-p-1}+h_ph_{m-p-2})[Y-\beta X]\\ =(\mathbb{L}(h_ph_{m-p}))[Y-\beta X], \end{multline*} as $e_2^\perp(h_ih_j)=h_{i-1}h_{j-1}$ and $h_2^\perp(h_ih_j)=h_{i-2}h_j+h_{i-1}h_{j-1}+h_ih_{j-2}$. Summing gives $\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]$. \end{proof} \emph{The factor $\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]$.} In the ring $\Lambda$ of symmetric functions write $\pi_k$ for the power sums, $\langle\,,\rangle$ for the Hall inner product and $f^\perp$ for the adjoint of multiplication by $f$; $\mathbb{T}_\sigma$ is the derivation of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Ltwostable} with $\mathbb{T}_\sigma h_k=(\sigma+k-1)h_{k-1}$, and $\zeta=3-n\beta$. Put $d_g:=a-4=\deg\mathsf{g}$ (even, $\ge0$) and $S:=-(\zeta+2)=n^2/2-5$. (In Lemma~\ref{lem:Vzero} the letter $d$ is $\deg f_\xi=m$.) We show that $\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]$ is not the zero polynomial in $x$; as $\mathbb{C}[x]$ is a domain, it may be tested at points where $(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)(A-B)$ vanishes. \begin{corollary}\label{cor:gtworow} $\mathsf{g}$ is a combination of Schur functions $s_\lambda$ with $\ell(\lambda)\le2$ and $|\lambda|=d_g$, and $\mathbb{T}_{\zeta+2}\mathsf{g}=0$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} $h_ph_{m-p}$ is two-row (Pieri), and skewing keeps $\ell(\lambda)\le2$, so $f_\xi$ and $\mathsf{g}$ are two-row. The shift invariance of $\sum_pc_p\mathbf{R}_p\mathbf{R}_{m-p}$ is $c\in\ker\mathbf{B}(\xi)$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Hsol}(ii)): with $\mathbb{T}\mathbf{R}_k=(k+2-n\beta)\mathbf{R}_{k-1}$ and the $\mathbf{R}_i\mathbf{R}_{m-1-i}$ independent, it says $\mathbb{T}_\zeta f_\xi=0$ in $\Lambda$ (as in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Htwo}). Lemma~\ref{lem:Vprime} gives $\mathbb{T}_{\zeta+2}\mathsf{g}=\mathbb{T}_{\zeta+2}\mathbb{L}f_\xi=\mathbb{L}\mathbb{T}_\zeta f_\xi=0$. \end{proof} (On all of $\Lambda$, $\mathbb{T}_{\sigma+2}\mathbb{L}=\mathbb{L}\mathbb{T}_\sigma-12e_3^\perp$ for every $\sigma$, from $\mathbb{L}=-\partial_{\pi_1}^2+4\partial_{\pi_2}$, $[\partial_{\pi_1},\mathbb{T}_\sigma]=2\partial_{\pi_2}$, $[\partial_{\pi_2},\mathbb{T}_\sigma]=3\partial_{\pi_3}$ and $\mathbb{T}_{\sigma+2}=\mathbb{T}_\sigma+2\partial_{\pi_1}$; $e_3^\perp$ kills every two-row function, which is why Lemma~\ref{lem:Vprime} is stated on two-row functions.) \begin{lemma}[two-letter values]\label{lem:twoletter} For weights $w_1,w_0$ and letters $y_1,y_0$ let $\mathrm{ev}\colon\Lambda\to\mathbb{C}$ be the ring map $\pi_k\mapsto w_1y_1^k+w_0y_0^k$ ($k\ge1$), so that $h_k\mapsto[t^k](1-y_1t)^{-w_1}(1-y_0t)^{-w_0}$. If $\mathbb{T}_\sigma f=0$ with $\sigma=w_1+w_0$, then $\mathrm{ev}(f)$ does not change under $(y_1,y_0)\mapsto(y_1+\epsilon,y_0+\epsilon)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} $d/d\epsilon$ of the image of $\pi_k$ is $k(w_1y_1^{k-1}+w_0y_0^{k-1})$, the image of $k\pi_{k-1}$ ($\pi_0\mapsto w_1+w_0=\sigma$); so by the chain rule $\frac{d}{d\epsilon}\mathrm{ev}_\epsilon(f)=\mathrm{ev}_\epsilon(\mathbb{T}_\sigma f)=0$, and $\mathrm{ev}_\epsilon(f)$ is a polynomial in $\epsilon$. \end{proof} Let $\gamma(D)$ be $\mathsf{g}$ at $h_k\mapsto[t^k](1-t)^D=(-1)^k\binom Dk$, that is, Lemma~\ref{lem:twoletter} with weight $-D$ at the letter $1$ (and the letter $0$, which contributes nothing). $\gamma$ is a polynomial in $D$ of degree $\le d_g$ ($\pi_k\mapsto-D$, so $\pi_\lambda\mapsto(-D)^{\ell(\lambda)}$). \emph{At a $0/1$ point}: if $x_l\in\{0,1\}$ for all $l$, $k_1:=\#\{l:x_l=1\}$ and $j_Y$ is the number of $1$s in $Y$ ($x_i$ counted twice), then $\prod_{y\in Y}(1-yt)^{-1}\prod_l(1-x_lt)^\beta=(1-t)^{\beta k_1-j_Y}$, so $\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]$ at that point is $\gamma(\beta k_1-j_Y)$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:gamma} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*),leftmargin=*] \item $\gamma(D)=\gamma(S-D)$ for every complex $D$ (an identity of polynomials in $D$). \item $\gamma(j)=0$ for the integers $0\le j\le d_g/2-1$, hence $\gamma(S-j)=0$ too. \item $\gamma(-1)=c_0(3-\mu)/(3-\xi/2)\ne0$. \item $\gamma(D)=C\prod_{j=0}^{d_g/2-1}(D-j)(S-j-D)$ with $C\ne0$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) Take weight $-D$ at $y_1=1$ and $\zeta+2+D$ at $y_0=0$ (total $\zeta+2$); by Corollary~\ref{cor:gtworow} and Lemma~\ref{lem:twoletter} the value is unchanged at $(y_1,y_0)=(0,-1)$, where $\pi_k\mapsto(\zeta+2+D)(-1)^k$; as $\mathsf{g}$ is homogeneous of degree $d_g$ this is $(-1)^{d_g}\gamma(-(\zeta+2)-D)=\gamma(S-D)$ ($d_g$ even). Lemma~\ref{lem:twoletter} takes any complex weights, so this holds for every complex $D$; at odd $n$ the roots $S-j$ of (ii) are half-integers, and it is this polynomial identity that is used. (ii) For an integer $D\ge0$, $\pi_k\mapsto-D=(-1)^k((-1)^{k-1}D)$, so $\gamma(D)=(-1)^{d_g}(\omega\mathsf{g})(1^D)$ ($\omega\colon\pi_k\mapsto(-1)^{k-1}\pi_k$; the sign $(-1)^k$ is $x\mapsto-x$ on a function of degree $d_g$). By Corollary~\ref{cor:gtworow}, $\omega\mathsf{g}=\sum b_\lambda s_{\lambda'}$, and $s_{\lambda'}(1^D)=0$ when $\lambda_1>D$ (\cite[I, \S\S2--3]{Ma95}: $\omega s_\lambda=s_{\lambda'}$, and $s_\nu(x_1,\dots,x_D)=0$ when $\ell(\nu)>D$; here $\ell(\lambda')=\lambda_1$); every two-row $\lambda$ of size $d_g$ has $\lambda_1\ge d_g/2$. So $\gamma(j)=0$ for $0\le j3$; $\xi/2=n^2/2>3$; and $c_0\ne0$, since $c_0=0$ would give $c_1=c_2=\dots=0$ through the rows $d_ic_i+d'_ic_{i+1}=0$, as $d'_i=i+3-n^2/2\ne0$ for $i\le m/2-1$ ($m/2+2S-d_g/2\ge d_g/2$ ($d_g\le S-1$ at even $n$, as $S$ is odd and $d_g$ even; $d_g\le(n^2-13)/2S-d_g/2$ when $a>n^2/2-6$, a root, for example at $(8,28)$ and $(8,30)$. The slots must carry part of the weight.) \begin{theorem}\label{thm:triangle} For every $n\ge4$ and every even $a$ with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$, the polynomial $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ is not identically $0$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} By Corollary~\ref{cor:closedform}, $\mathsf{T}_{v'}=M(\beta^2-1)(P-Q)(P-A)(Q-A)(A-B)\,\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]$ in the domain $\mathbb{C}[x_1,\dots,x_n]$. Here $M=\mu(a+1)\ne0$ ($\mu\ge n^2/2+1$), $\beta^2-1=n^2/4-1\ne0$ ($n\ge4$), the four linear forms are nonzero, and $\mathsf{g}[Y-\beta X]\ne0$ by Proposition~\ref{prop:gpoints}. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:Peven} For every $n\ge4$ and every even $a$ with $n\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$, $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue of the pencil $\kappa\mathcal{Z}-\mathcal{J}$ on $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,2)}(n)$; so $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_{(n^2-a-2,a,2)}=0$. Hence, for every $n\ge4$, every conjugation type $\kappa$ of $K_{B(n,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3\le1$ is $(3,1^{N-3})$, and it occurs once (as in Corollary~\ref{cor:Kseven}(b)). \end{corollary} \begin{proof} Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV} needs (2$'$) and $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$. The latter is Theorem~\ref{thm:triangle}. For (2$'$): $m=a-2$ is even and $m\le m_{\max}=n^2/2-3$ (as $a\le(n^2-2)/2$), so by Theorem~\ref{thm:steptwo} the shift invariant elements of $\mathcal{X}_m$ form a line; $\vartheta_{123}$ of a kernel vector lies there (Lemma~\ref{lem:starn} and step~(1) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Pone}), and so does $\vartheta_\xi|_n$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:evenread}), which is not $0$ as $\mathsf{T}_{v'}\ne0$ (Remark~\ref{rem:evenEV}(1)); so the line is $\mathbb{C}\,\vartheta_\xi|_n$, which is (2$'$). Then $\kappa=n$ is not an eigenvalue, and $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau=0$ by Corollary~\ref{cor:pencil}(b) and Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(ii), as in the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:Kseven}(a) (and Corollary~\ref{cor:Pone}). For the type statement: every type has three columns (Corollary~\ref{cor:firstlayer}(b)), so $\kappa'_3\le1$ means $\tau=(n^2-a-2,a,2)$ with $2\le a\le(n^2-2)/2$ ($\kappa'$ is a partition), and the multiplicity is $\dim\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(iii). Then: for $2\le a\le n-1$ Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth} applies (depth $a$; only $(3,1^{N-3})$, once, at $a=2$; also Theorem~\ref{thm:pencil22} with $s=n\ge4$); odd $a\ge n$ is Corollary~\ref{cor:steptwo}; even $a\ge n$ is the first part. This is exactly the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:Kseven}(b). \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:triangle} (1) (Scope.) Nothing is claimed for the types with $\kappa'_3\ge2$ ($\tau_3\ge3$), and no bound on $d(n)$ follows. Theorem~\ref{thm:evenEV} works for even $a\le(n-1)^2$, but (2$'$) is proved here only for $a\le(n^2-2)/2$. (2) (Context.) Theorem~\ref{thm:Lprobe} (the probe of one generic row, in the stable range $n\ge a+6$) with Theorem~\ref{thm:Htwo} is the stable analog: the same $\mathbb{L}=(h_2-3e_2)^\perp$ and the same factor $1-\beta^2$. Corollary~\ref{cor:closedform} is the statement at a finite $n$, for the triangle, with no probe and no stable range. In the type form, Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven} was known at $n=4$ (Remark~\ref{rem:Bwindowsmall}), $n=5$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfive}), $n=6$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Ksixsix}) and $n=7$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Kseven}); in the pencil form, $n=7$ is Theorem~\ref{thm:Kseven}. So the type statement is new for every $n\ge8$, and the pencil statement for every $n\ne7$ (Remark~\ref{rem:pencilcomp}(d) had computed some small $d$, not as a proof). (3) (Computations, supporting; not used.) The closed form agrees with the seed computation of Remark~\ref{rem:evenEV}(4) at $31$ pairs with $4\le n\le8$, and, by an independent program from the rows as printed in Proposition~\ref{prop:orderone}, with $\mathsf{T}_{v'}$ at all $120$ dominant even pairs with $4\le n\le12$; Proposition~\ref{prop:seed} was checked at $185$ random points with rational $\beta$, and a direct computation from the definitions (without Lemma~\ref{lem:evenBprime} and without the seed) agrees with the closed form at $10$ points. At the point ``slots $0$, the other $n-4$ coordinates $1$'' ($D=n(n-4)/2$, $S-D=2n-5$) the window $[d_g/2,S-d_g/2]$ is exactly $a\le4n-6$, which is where a computation found nonzero values ($n=5,\dots,40$) and zeros beyond, in line with the failing point after Proposition~\ref{prop:gpoints}. \end{remark} \subsection{The part of degree $1$ in $y$ at every layer}\label{subsec:Oone} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$, $n\ge3$, $a$ is arbitrary and $b\ge2$; we keep the notation of Subsections~\ref{subsec:Bthree} and~\ref{subsec:Bfour}: slice points $(D,Z)$, $\theta_{pq}=1/x_{qp}$, $\Delta_{pq}=e_p-e_q$, the parts $\Phi_j$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:order}, $\Phi_1=\sum_sy_s\mathsf{N}_s(Z)$, $\mathsf{N}(v)=\sum_sv_s\mathsf{N}_s$, $\mathsf{G}$ the $y$-Hessian of $\Phi_2$ at $y=0$, and $\partial_Z[A]$, $W^{pq}=[E_{pq},Z]$ as before \eqref{eq:BfourJ}; \eqref{eq:BfourJ} is the expansion of $\Phi$ at $y=0$ and holds for every $b$. By Corollary~\ref{cor:orderred}(b), Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} at $(a,b,n)$ says that $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=0$ and $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$ force $\Phi_0=\Phi_1=0$. We show, by hand, that $\Phi_0=0$ forces $\Phi_1=0$ for every even $b$ and every odd $b\le n(n-1)+1$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Oone}); this covers every layer that occurs in $K_{B(n,2)}$, so there Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} is its part of degree $0$ in $y$ alone (Corollary~\ref{cor:Oone}). At $b=4$ this is step~B4-1 of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Bfour}, here also for $n=3$ and without the step $\mathsf{G}=0$. The rows used are the slice rows $[l^3]$ and $\mathsf{c}$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreecoef}, whose proof does not use $b$ (it is multilinear algebra on $\mathsf{Q}_u=u\wedge\omega^u$). \begin{lemma}[the rows at $\Phi_0=0$]\label{lem:Oonerows} Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}(n)$ with $\Phi_0=0$ identically in $x$ and $Z$. At every slice point: \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*),leftmargin=*] \item for off-diagonal $(p,q)$ and $(i,j)$ with $(i,j)\notin\{(p,q),(q,p)\}$, \[ \omega(E_{pq},E_{ij})=-\theta_{pq}Z_{qp}\,\partial_{Z_{ij}}\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{pq})+\theta_{ij}Z_{ji}\,\partial_{Z_{pq}}\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{ij}); \] \item for distinct $l,k,m$, \[ \mathsf{c}(l,k,m)=\omega(E_{lk},E_{km})-\theta_{lm}\bigl[Z_{ml}\,\Delta_{lm}^T\mathsf{G}\Delta_{lk}+\partial_Z[W^{lm}]\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{lk})\bigr]. \] \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) Use \eqref{eq:BfourJ} with $\Phi_0=0$, $(E_{ij})_d=0$, $\partial_Z[E_{ij}]=\partial_{Z_{ij}}$ and $(W^{pq})_d=Z_{qp}\Delta_{pq}$. As $(i,j)\ne(q,p)$, $[E_{pq},E_{ij}]$ has zero diagonal, so $\partial_Y[[E_{pq},E_{ij}]]\tilde\varphi=0$, and \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta} gives \[ \partial_Y^2\tilde\varphi(W^{pq},E_{ij})=Z_{qp}\,\partial_{Z_{ij}}\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{pq}),\qquad\beta(E_{pq},E_{ij})=-\theta_{pq}Z_{qp}\,\partial_{Z_{ij}}\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{pq}); \] and $\omega(E_{pq},E_{ij})=\beta(E_{pq},E_{ij})-\beta(E_{ij},E_{pq})$. (ii) Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfourrows}(i) holds for every $b$; with $\Phi_0=0$ its terms $\mathrm{R}_1,\dots,\mathrm{R}_4$ vanish, and $\mathrm{R}_6+\mathrm{R}_7=\omega(E_{lk},E_{km})$ by (i). \end{proof} \emph{Circulation.} For a monomial $S=\prod Z_{pq}^{m_{pq}}$ put $\operatorname{circ}_{pq}(S):=m_{pq}-m_{qp}$. Every monomial of $\mathsf{N}_s$ has torus weight $0$ (proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfourshape}), that is $\sum_q\operatorname{circ}_{pq}(S)=0$ at every $p$. For a polynomial $F$, $[S]F$ is its coefficient of $S$; put $\mathsf{c}_s(S):=[S]\mathsf{N}_s$, a polynomial in $x$ invariant under $x\mapsto x+c\mathbf{1}$ (as in Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfourshape}). If $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$, then $\sum_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$ and $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$: the parts of degree $0$ in $y$ of $\sum_s\partial\Phi/\partial y_s=0$ and of $\sum_sx_s\partial\Phi/\partial y_s=0$ (proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfourshape}). \begin{lemma}[circulation]\label{lem:Oonecirc} Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$ with $\Phi_0=0$ identically, and let every row $[l^3]$ vanish at every slice point. Then $\mathsf{c}_s(S)=0$ for every $s$ and every monomial $S$ with $\operatorname{circ}(S)\ne0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Fix $S$ and a pair with $\operatorname{circ}_{lh}(S)>0$; we induct on $m_{hl}(S)$, with $l$, $h$ and the circulation fixed. Take $j\notin\{l,h\}$ and $T:=Z_{jl}S/Z_{lh}$ (a monomial, as $m_{lh}(S)\ge\operatorname{circ}_{lh}(S)\ge1$). By Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonerows}(i) the row $[l^3]$ at $e_l\wedge e_j\wedge e_h$ is $-\theta_{lj}Z_{jl}\,\partial_{Z_{lh}}\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{lj})+\theta_{lh}Z_{hl}\,\partial_{Z_{lj}}\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{lh})$. Fact~(b) in the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfourrows}(ii) (here $(j,l)\ne(l,h)$ and $(h,l)\ne(l,j)$) gives \[ -\theta_{lj}\,m_{lh}(S)\,[S]\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{lj})+\theta_{lh}\,(m_{lj}(T)+1)\,[S']\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{lh})=0,\qquad S':=\frac{Z_{jl}Z_{lj}}{Z_{lh}Z_{hl}}\,S, \] where the second term is present only if $Z_{hl}$ divides $T$, that is $m_{hl}(S)\ge1$. Then $S'$ is a monomial with $\operatorname{circ}(S')=\operatorname{circ}(S)$ and $m_{hl}(S')=m_{hl}(S)-1$, so $[S']\mathsf{N}_s=0$ for all $s$ by induction. Either way $[S]\mathsf{N}(\Delta_{lj})=0$: $\mathsf{c}_l(S)=\mathsf{c}_j(S)$ for every $j\notin\{l,h\}$, so $\mathsf{c}_s(S)=\mathsf{c}$ for all $s\ne h$. At traceless $x$, $\sum_s\mathsf{c}_s(S)=0$ and $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{c}_s(S)=0$ give $(n-1)\mathsf{c}+\mathsf{c}_h(S)=0$ and $x_h(\mathsf{c}_h(S)-\mathsf{c})=0$, so $\mathsf{c}_h(S)=\mathsf{c}=0$ where $x_h\ne0$; by the invariance under $x\mapsto x+c\mathbf{1}$, $\mathsf{c}_s(S)=0$ identically. \end{proof} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:Ooneeven} Under the hypotheses of Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc}, if $b$ is even, then $\Phi_1=0$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} $\mathsf{N}_s$ has odd degree $b-1$, and a monomial with $\operatorname{circ}=0$ has $m_{pq}=m_{qp}$ for all pairs, so even degree. So Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc} applies to every monomial of $\mathsf{N}$. \end{proof} Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc} is empty at $b=3$, where $\mathsf{N}_s$ has no circulation (Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape}); at $b=4$ it gives all of $\mathsf{N}$ (the directed $3$-cycles; compare step~(2) of B4-1); at $b=5$ it gives the directed $4$-cycles. \emph{The part without circulation.} Let $b$ be odd, $\delta:=(b-1)/2$, and $z_e:=Z_{pq}Z_{qp}$ for a pair $e=\{p,q\}$. A monomial with $\operatorname{circ}=0$ is a monomial $z^\mu$ in the $n(n-1)/2$ variables $z_e$, and distinct $\mu$ give distinct monomials. By Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc}, $\mathsf{N}_s=\mathsf{P}_s(z)$, a form of degree $\delta$ in $z$ with coefficients in $\mathbb{K}:=\mathbb{C}(x)$. Write $\partial_e:=\partial/\partial z_e$ and $\mathsf{P}_v:=\sum_sv_s\mathsf{P}_s$; then $\partial_{Z_{pq}}\mathsf{P}_v=Z_{qp}\,\partial_{pq}\mathsf{P}_v$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:Oonez} Under the hypotheses of Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc}, let $b$ be odd and let every row $\mathsf{c}$ vanish at every slice point. Then: \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item $\theta_{lh}\,\partial_{lj}\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lh}}=\theta_{lj}\,\partial_{lh}\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lj}}$ for distinct $l,j,h$; \item $(\partial_{lr}-\partial_{mr})\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lk}}\in z_{lm}\mathbb{K}[z]$ for distinct $l,k,m$ and every $r\notin\{l,m\}$ ($r=k$ included). \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) By Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonerows}(i), $[l^3]=Z_{jl}Z_{hl}\bigl[\theta_{lh}\,\partial_{lj}\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lh}}-\theta_{lj}\,\partial_{lh}\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lj}}\bigr](z)$, $Z_{jl}Z_{hl}\ne0$, and $z\mapsto Z$ is injective on monomials. (b) By Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonerows}(i), $\omega(E_{lk},E_{km})=Z_{kl}Z_{mk}\bigl[\theta_{km}\,\partial_{lk}\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{km}}-\theta_{lk}\,\partial_{km}\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lk}}\bigr]$, and the row $[k^3]$ at $e_k\wedge e_l\wedge e_m$ is $Z_{lk}Z_{mk}$ times the same bracket ($\theta_{kl}\Delta_{kl}=\theta_{lk}\Delta_{lk}$), which is $0$ by (a) with apex $k$. By the formula after \eqref{eq:BfourJ}, $\partial_Z[W^{lm}]\mathsf{P}_v=\sum_{r\notin\{l,m\}}Z_{mr}Z_{rl}(\partial_{lr}-\partial_{mr})\mathsf{P}_v$, the sum including $r=k$. So, by Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonerows}(ii), $\mathsf{c}(l,k,m)=0$ reads \[ Z_{ml}\,\Delta_{lm}^T\mathsf{G}\Delta_{lk}+\sum_{r\notin\{l,m\}}Z_{mr}Z_{rl}\,(\partial_{lr}-\partial_{mr})\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lk}}=0. \] Every monomial of the first term is divisible by $Z_{ml}$. A monomial $Z_{mr}Z_{rl}z^\mu$ is divisible by $Z_{ml}$ if and only if $\mu_{lm}\ge1$, and it determines $r$ (its circulation is the path $m\to r\to l$). So the part of the sum not divisible by $Z_{ml}$ vanishes term by term: $(\partial_{lr}-\partial_{mr})\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lk}}$ is $0$ at $z_{lm}=0$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[the linear case]\label{lem:Oonelin} Fix a traceless $x$ with distinct coordinates and $p_2:=\sum_sx_s^2\ne0$. Let $X$ be a set of pairs, not all pairs, and let $\mathsf{R}(s,f)\in\mathbb{C}$ ($s\in[n]$, $f$ a pair; $\mathsf{R}(v,f):=\sum_sv_s\mathsf{R}(s,f)$, $\rho_f:=\mathsf{R}(\cdot,f)\in\mathbb{C}^n$) satisfy $\sum_s\mathsf{R}(s,f)=0$ and $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{R}(s,f)=0$ for every $f$, and \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*$'$),leftmargin=*] \item $\theta_{lh}\,\mathsf{R}(\Delta_{lh},\{l,j\})=\theta_{lj}\,\mathsf{R}(\Delta_{lj},\{l,h\})$ for distinct $l,j,h$ (``(a$'$) at $(l;j,h)$''); \item $\mathsf{R}(\Delta_{lk},\{l,r\})=\mathsf{R}(\Delta_{lk},\{m,r\})$ for distinct $l,k,m$, $r\notin\{l,m\}$ ($r=k$ allowed) and $\{l,m\}\notin X$. \end{enumerate} Then $\mathsf{R}=0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Fix a pair $\{l,m\}\notin X$. (1) For $r\notin\{l,m\}$ put $w:=\rho_{lr}-\rho_{mr}$. (b$'$) at $(l,k,m;r)$ and at $(m,k,l;r)$ give $w_l=w_k$ and $w_m=w_k$ for every $k\notin\{l,m\}$, $k=r$ included (at $n=3$ the only $k$). So $w$ is constant, and $\sum_sw_s=0$ gives $w=0$: $\rho_{lr}=\rho_{mr}=:\sigma_r$. (2) Put $u:=\rho_{lm}$. (a$'$) at $(l;m,r)$ and at $(m;l,r)$ give $\theta_{lr}(u_l-u_r)=\theta_{lm}(\sigma_r[l]-\sigma_r[m])=\theta_{mr}(u_m-u_r)$ for every $r\notin\{l,m\}$. So every point $(x_r,u_r)$ lies on the line through $(x_l,u_l)$ and $(x_m,u_m)$: $u=\alpha\mathbf{1}+\gamma x$. Then $\sum_su_s=n\alpha=0$ and $\sum_sx_su_s=\gamma p_2=0$ give $u=0$ (here $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$ enters), hence $\sigma_r[l]=\sigma_r[m]$. (3) (a$'$) at $(r;l,m)$ gives $(\theta_{rm}-\theta_{rl})(\sigma_r[r]-\sigma_r[l])=0$, so $\sigma_r[r]=\sigma_r[l]=\sigma_r[m]=:\mathsf{a}_r$. (4) For $k\notin\{l,m,r\}$ put $A:=\mathsf{a}_r-\sigma_r[k]$ and $B:=\mathsf{a}_k-\sigma_k[r]$. (a$'$) at $(l;r,k)$ and at $(m;r,k)$ give $\theta_{lk}A=\theta_{lr}B$ and $\theta_{mk}A=\theta_{mr}B$; the determinant $\theta_{lk}\theta_{mr}-\theta_{lr}\theta_{mk}$ has numerator $(x_m-x_l)(x_k-x_r)\ne0$, so $A=B=0$. So $\sigma_r=\mathsf{a}_r\mathbf{1}$, and $\sum=0$ gives $\sigma_r=0$. Thus $\rho_f=0$ for every pair $f$ that meets $\{l,m\}$. (5) For $h,k\notin\{l,m\}$, (a$'$) at $(h;k,l)$, $(h;k,m)$ and $(k;h,l)$ give $\rho_{hk}[h]=\rho_{hk}[k]=\rho_{hk}[l]=\rho_{hk}[m]=:\mathsf{a}_{hk}$. (6) For distinct $h,k,t\notin\{l,m\}$ put $u:=\mathsf{a}_{hk}-\rho_{hk}[t]$, $v:=\mathsf{a}_{ht}-\rho_{ht}[k]$, $w:=\mathsf{a}_{kt}-\rho_{kt}[h]$. (a$'$) at $(h;k,t)$, $(k;h,t)$ and $(t;h,k)$ give $\theta_{ht}u=\theta_{hk}v$, $\theta_{kt}u=\theta_{kh}w$ and $\theta_{tk}v=\theta_{th}w$. As $\theta_{th}\theta_{kt}/\theta_{kh}=-\theta_{tk}\theta_{ht}/\theta_{hk}$, this gives $2\theta_{tk}\theta_{ht}u/\theta_{hk}=0$, so $u=v=w=0$, $\rho_{hk}=\mathsf{a}_{hk}\mathbf{1}$, and $\sum=0$ gives $\rho_{hk}=0$ (at $n=4$, step~(5) already covers every index). So $\mathsf{R}=0$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}[order $1$ at every layer]\label{thm:Oone} Let $n\ge3$, $b\ge2$, $a$ arbitrary and $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$. Suppose that $\Phi_0=0$ identically in $x$ and $Z$, and that every row $[l^3]$ and every row $\mathsf{c}$ vanishes at every slice point (both hold if $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=0$, by Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreecoef}). If $b$ is even, or $b$ is odd and $b\le n(n-1)+1$, then $\Phi_1=0$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} For even $b$ this is Corollary~\ref{cor:Ooneeven}. Let $b$ be odd, so $\delta=(b-1)/2\ge1$ and $\mathsf{N}_s=\mathsf{P}_s(z)$. For a multi-index $\mu$ over the pairs with $|\mu|=\delta-1$, $\mathsf{P}^\mu:=\partial^\mu\mathsf{P}$ is linear in $z$: $\mathsf{P}^\mu_s=\sum_f\mathsf{R}^\mu(s,f)z_f$. It satisfies $\sum_s\mathsf{P}^\mu_s=0$ and $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{P}^\mu_s=0$, Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonez}(a) (apply $\partial^\mu$), and Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonez}(b) for every $\{l,m\}\notin X:=\operatorname{supp}(\mu)$: then $\partial^\mu$ preserves the ideal $z_{lm}\mathbb{K}[z]$, and $\partial^\mu(\partial_{lr}-\partial_{mr})\mathsf{P}_{\Delta_{lk}}= \mathsf{R}^\mu(\Delta_{lk},\{l,r\})-\mathsf{R}^\mu(\Delta_{lk},\{m,r\})$ is a constant in that ideal, so it is $0$. $X$ has at most $\delta-1$ elements, so it is not the set of all pairs when $\delta-1n(n-1)+1$; anything about $\mathsf{G}$ (not needed, by Corollary~\ref{cor:orderred}); any bound on $d(n)$. (2) (What is used.) \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta} and \eqref{eq:BfourJ} at $\Phi_0=0$; the rows $[l^3]$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc}, Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonez}(a)) and $\mathsf{c}$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonez}(b)); $\sum_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$; $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$; the invariance under $x\mapsto x+c\mathbf{1}$. Not used: the bidegree, homogeneity in $x$, the rows $\mathsf{P}$, and $\mathsf{G}$. $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$ enters only in Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonecirc} (end) and in step~(2) of Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonelin}, and it is essential for odd $b$, consistent with Remark~\ref{rem:order}(2): without $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$, $\mathsf{N}_s=(x_s-p_1/n)(\sum_ez_e)^\delta$ and $\mathsf{G}=0$ satisfy every row $[l^3]$ and $\mathsf{c}$ and $\sum_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$. (3) (Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonelin} is sharp.) At $X=$ all pairs its solution space has dimension $\binom{n-1}{2}$; this is why the odd range stops at $b=n(n-1)+1$. (4) (Computations, supporting; not used.) Exact computations modulo $2^{31}-1$ at one random traceless point, with the rows built from \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta} and \eqref{eq:BfourJ} directly and all coefficients of $\mathsf{N}$ and $\mathsf{G}$ unknown, give $\mathsf{N}=0$ at $(n,b)=(3,4),(3,5),(3,6),(3,7),(3,8),(4,5),(4,6),(4,7),(4,8),(5,4),(5,5)$; a second program, with $\mathsf{G}$ free and the rows from entrywise derivatives, gives the same at $13$ pairs $(n,b)$ including $(6,5)$, and at $(3,7),(3,9),(4,9)$, and the solution space of Lemma~\ref{lem:Oonelin} is $0$ for every $X$ other than all pairs ($n=3,4,5$; random $X$ at $n=6,7$). Without $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{N}_s=0$ the solution space at $(4,5)$ is the line of (2); with the rows $\mathsf{c}$ alone it is $0$ at $(3,4),(4,5),(4,6)$. \end{remark} \subsection{Pencil eigenvectors have $y$-order at most $2$}\label{subsec:EO} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$, $n\ge3$, and $a$, $b$ are arbitrary; we use the pencil of Subsection~\ref{subsec:pencil}, the base points $(D,Y)$, $Y=Z+\operatorname{diag}(y)$, of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Bthree}, and the parts $\Phi_j$ and the $y$-order of Lemma~\ref{lem:order}. As $y$ denotes the diagonal of $Y$, we write the corners as $B_i=u\eta_i^T$. An \emph{eigenvector} is a $\varphi\ne0$ in $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,b)}(n)$ with $\kappa\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ for one $\kappa\in\mathbb{C}$, at every base point and every corner. For a function $g$ of $y$ let $[g]_j$ be its part of degree $j$ in $y$. Lemma~\ref{lem:order} says that $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=0$ forces $y$-order at most $1$; here we show that $\kappa\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ forces $y$-order at most $2$, for every $\kappa$. \begin{lemma}[the lowest part of $\mathcal{J}$]\label{lem:PJ} Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}_{(a,b)}(n)$ have $y$-order $k\ge3$ (neither $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$ nor the invariance under $Y\mapsto Y+cI$ is used; only the conjugation invariance). Let $\mathsf{C}$ be the $y$-Hessian of $\Phi_k$ and $\mathsf{T}$ the symmetric $3$-tensor of its third $y$-derivatives (of degree $k-3$ in $y$; both may depend on $x$ and $Z$). For a matrix $B$ put $(v_B)_t:=x_t\sum_{r\ne t}\theta_{rt}(B_{tr}Z_{rt}+B_{rt}Z_{tr})$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item At every base point and every corner, $[\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)]_j=0$ for $j0$, and a vertex of degree $1$ is \emph{single}. $\mathsf{G}_{lq}[m]$ is the coefficient of $m$ in $\mathsf{G}_{lq}$, and $\operatorname{row}_l(m):=(\mathsf{G}_{lq}[m])_q$; it lies in $U:=\{w:\sum_qw_q=\sum_qx_qw_q=0\}$. Put $N:=n-1$. For $f\notin\operatorname{supp}(m)$ and a single $v$, $m[v\to f]$ is $m$ with $v$ renamed $f$. If $m$ misses exactly one vertex $p$, put $h^m:=\operatorname{row}_p(m)$ and $\alpha(m):=\mathsf{G}_{pp}[m]$. \begin{lemma}[Lemma T]\label{lem:YOT} Assume (H$_D$) at the apex $l$ (and the traces of row $l$). Fix $f\ne l$ and a monomial $\mu$ without $Z_{fl}$. Its $L_{lf}$-preimages are the $m$ in which one edge $c\to f$ ($c\notin\{l,f\}$) becomes $c\to l$, with coefficients $k_m:=k_{cf}(m)$; its $R_{lf}$-preimages are the $m'$ in which one edge $l\to c$ ($c\notin\{l,f\}$) becomes $f\to c$, with coefficients $k'_{m'}:=k_{lc}(m')$. For $w\in U$ put \[ (T^{(l)}_fw)_q:=\frac{(x_q-x_f)w_q+(x_f-x_l)w_l}{x_q-x_l}\ (q\notin\{l,f\}),\qquad (T^{(l)}_fw)_f:=-Nw_l, \] and $(T^{(l)}_fw)_l:=-\sum_{q\ne l}(T^{(l)}_fw)_q$. Then $T^{(l)}_f$ maps $U$ injectively to $U$, and (i) at $(l,f)$ at the target $\mu$ is equivalent to $\sum_{m'}k'_{m'}\operatorname{row}_l(m')=T^{(l)}_f\sum_mk_m\operatorname{row}_l(m)$. Two consequences: \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item (transfer) if $d_l(m)\ge1$, $f\notin\operatorname{supp}(m)$, $f\ne l$, and $l\to e$ is an edge of $m$, then $k_{le}(m)\operatorname{row}_l(m)=T^{(l)}_f\sum_c\operatorname{row}_l(m_c)$, over the distinct in-neighbours $c$ of $l$, with $m_c$ the monomial $m$ with $(c\to l,\ l\to e)$ replaced by $(c\to f,\ f\to e)$; if $d_l(m)=1$, $\operatorname{row}_l(m)=T^{(l)}_f\operatorname{row}_l(m[l\to f])$; \item ($l$-avoiding system) if $l\notin\operatorname{supp}(m)$, $f\notin\operatorname{supp}(m)+l$ and $c\to r$ is an edge of $m$, then $\sum_eT^{(l)}_f\operatorname{row}_l(m_e)=k_{cr}(m)\,T^{(l)}_r\operatorname{row}_l(m)$, over the distinct out-neighbours $e$ of $r$, with $m_e$ the monomial $m$ with one $c\to r$ and one $r\to e$ replaced by $c\to f\to e$. Its $f$-component reads $k_{cr}(m)\,L^{(f)}_m(x_r)=-N\sum_e\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m_e]$, where $L^{(f)}_m(t):=[(x_f-t)\mathsf{G}_{lf}[m]+(t-x_l)\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m]]/(x_f-x_l)$; for single $r$, $L^{(f)}_m(x_r)=-N\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m[r\to f]]$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} With $\mathsf{G}_{ql}=\mathsf{G}_{lq}$, the coefficient of $\mu$ in $\Psi_l(f;q)$ is $(x_f-x_l)v_l+(x_q-x_f)v_q-(x_q-x_l)w_q$, with $v:=\sum k_m\operatorname{row}_l(m)$, $w:=\sum k'_{m'}\operatorname{row}_l(m')$ (both in $U$). So (i) gives the $q$-components of $w=T_fv$ for $q\notin\{l,f\}$; summing them over $q$ with the traces of $v$ and $w$ gives $w_f=-Nv_l$, and $w_l$ is fixed by $\sum_qw_q=0$. $T_fv\in U$ by the same computation; $T_fv=0$ gives $v_l=0$ (component $f$), then $v_q=0$ ($q\notin\{l,f\}$), then $v_f=0$. (a) is the target $\mu:=m$ with one $l\to e$ replaced by $f\to e$: its only $R_{lf}$-preimage is $m$, its $L_{lf}$-preimages are the $m_c$, with coefficient $1$. (b) is (i) at $(l,r)$ at the target $\mu:=m$ with one $c\to r$ replaced by $c\to l$: its only $L_{lr}$-preimage is $m$ (coefficient $k_{cr}(m)$), its $R_{lr}$-preimages $\mu_e$ have $d_l=1$, and $\operatorname{row}_l(\mu_e)=T_f\operatorname{row}_l(m_e)$ by (a). The $f$-component uses $(T_fw)_f=-Nw_l$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}[$b\le n+1$]\label{thm:YOsmall} Let $n\ge4$ and $2\le D\le n-1$. Then (H$_D$) forces $\mathsf{G}=0$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Fix an apex $l$; a vertex $f$ is \emph{free} for $m$ if $f\notin\operatorname{supp}(m)+l$; $\operatorname{def}(m):=D-|\operatorname{supp}(m)|$. (1) \emph{Hexagon.} If $m$ avoids $l$, $f$ is free and $r,u$ are single in $m$, then $\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m]=0$. Rename around $(f,r,u)$: $m_0:=m$, $m_{i+1}:=m_i[p_{i+1}\to p_i]$ with free vertices $p_i=f,r,u,f,r,u$; then $m_6=m_0$. With $y_i:=\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m_i]$ and $L_i:=L^{(p_i)}_{m_i}$, $L_i(x_{p_i})=y_i$ by definition, and Lemma~\ref{lem:YOT}(b) gives $L_i(x_{p_{i\pm1}})=-Ny_{i\pm1}$; collinearity of these three points reads $z_i=N(z_{i-1}+z_{i+1})$ with $z_i:=y_is_{p_i}$, $s_f:=x_r-x_u$, $s_r:=x_u-x_f$, $s_u:=x_f-x_r$ ($i\in\mathbb{Z}/6$). The circulant has eigenvalues $1-2N\cos(\pi j/3)\in\{1\pm N,1\pm2N\}$, all nonzero: $y=0$. (2) \emph{One apex.} If $D\le n-2$, then $\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m]=0$ for every $l$-avoiding $m$; if $D=n-1$ ($n\ge5$), for those with $|\operatorname{supp}(m)|\le n-2$. Such $m$ have a free vertex; induct on $\operatorname{def}(m)$: with two single vertices use (1); otherwise there are two vertices of degree $\ge2$ (if there were at most one, then $|\operatorname{supp}(m)|\le2$ and $m=(Z_{ru}Z_{ur})^k$, which has two single vertices if $k=1$ and two of degree $\ge2$ if $k\ge2$), and Lemma~\ref{lem:YOT}(b) at both, with the induction hypothesis for the $m_e$ ($\operatorname{def}(m_e)=\operatorname{def}(m)-1$), gives $L^{(f)}_m(x_r)=0$ at two points, so $L^{(f)}_m=0$ and $\mathsf{G}_{ll}[m]=L^{(f)}_m(x_f)=0$. For $D=n-1$, $\operatorname{def}(m)=1$ is the hexagon case and otherwise $|\operatorname{supp}(m_e)|\le n-2$. (3) For these $m$, the components of $\operatorname{row}_l(m)$ at free vertices vanish ($L^{(f)}_m(x_r)=0$ at one more point, by (b) at a single $r$, as $m[r\to f]$ has the support size of $m$, or, if $m$ has no single vertex, at a vertex $r$ of degree $\ge2$: then $|\operatorname{supp}(m)|\le D/2$, so $|\operatorname{supp}(m_e)|\le n-2$ also for $D=n-1$), and at single $q$: $\mathsf{G}_{lq}[m]=\mathsf{G}_{ql}[m]=-N\mathsf{G}_{qq}[m[q\to l]]=0$, by (a) at the apex $q$ and (2) there. (4) $D\le n-2$. For $l$-avoiding $m$, (2)--(3) leave only components at vertices of degree $\ge2$; if $\operatorname{def}(m)=0$ there are none, and otherwise (b) at a vertex of degree $\ge2$ and induction on $\operatorname{def}$ give $\operatorname{row}_l(m)=0$ ($T_r$ is injective). For $m$ containing $l$, $|\operatorname{supp}(m)|\kappa(n-2)>a$; for every other $\kappa\ne0$ no resonance occurs. At $\kappa=n$ and $a\le(n^2-3)/2$, (s1)--(s3) and (s5) hold, and (s4) fails only for $(n,a)=(4,5),(4,6),(5,11)$, where Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneE} is a finite exact computation (Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2)). \emph{The rows as a $t$-free condition.} Fix $r$, $I:=[n]\setminus\{r\}$, $g^t_\sigma:=\mathsf{M}(\sigma,t)$ ($t\in I$), $A^t_l:=\kappa+(x_t-x_l)\partial_l$ (so $A^t_t=\kappa$) and $\Gamma_t(l,k):=A^t_lg^t_k-A^t_kg^t_l$ for $l,k,t\in I$. Expanding, $\Gamma_h(i,j)-\Gamma_i(i,j)=\kappa\,\mathsf{M}(\Delta_{ij},\Delta_{ih})+(x_h-x_i)\partial_ig^h_j+(x_j-x_h)\partial_jg^h_i+(x_i-x_j)\partial_jg^i_i$, so ($\mathrm{E}_r$)$(i,j,h)$ says $\Gamma_h(i,j)=\Gamma_i(i,j)$. With ($\mathrm{E}_r$)$(j,i,h)$ and $h$ running over $I\setminus\{i,j\}\ne\emptyset$: the rows ($\mathrm{E}_r$) say exactly that $\Gamma_t(l,k)$ does not depend on $t\in I$, for every pair $l\ne k$ in $I$. Only the $g^t_\sigma$ with $\sigma,t\in I$ occur. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:AoneSone} Assume \textup{(s1)}. For each $r$, every solution of \textup{($\mathrm{E}_r$)} has the form $g^t_\sigma=\partial_\sigma H^{(r)}+A^t_\sigma h^{(r)}_t$ ($\sigma,t\in I$), with $H^{(r)}$ and $h^{(r)}_t$ invariant under $x\mapsto x+c\mathbf{1}$ and homogeneous of degrees $a+1$ and $a$; and these are solutions. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Conversely: $\partial H$ gives $\Gamma_t(l,\sigma)=\kappa(\partial_\sigma-\partial_l)H+(x_\sigma-x_l)\partial_\sigma\partial_lH$, free of $t$, and $A^th_t$ gives $0$, as $A^t_l$ and $A^t_\sigma$ commute. Now let $g$ be a solution. Replacing $g^t$ by $g^t-A^t(g^t_t/\kappa)$ does not change $\Gamma_t$, so we may assume $g^t_t=0$. Then $\Gamma_t(t,\sigma)=\kappa g^t_\sigma$, and $\Gamma_t(t,\sigma)=\Gamma_\sigma(t,\sigma)$ makes $\gamma(t,\sigma):=g^t_\sigma$ antisymmetric. Work in $w_b:=x_b-x_r$ ($b\in I$, $m:=n-1$ variables; translation-invariant functions are the polynomials in $w$, and $\partial_b=\partial/\partial w_b$ on them), let $\Omega^p_D$ be the $p$-forms in the $dw_b$ with coefficients homogeneous of degree $D$, $d$ the exterior derivative, $e_b:=w_b\partial_b$, $Q_b:=e_b-\kappa$ and $k:=\sum_bdw_b\wedge Q_b$, so $\gamma=\sum_{t<\sigma}\gamma(t,\sigma)\,dw_t\wedge dw_\sigma\in\Omega^2_a$. For a triangle $\{i,j,l\}$ of $I$ the remaining rows say $\Gamma_l(i,j)=\Gamma_i(i,j)$, i.e.\ $\kappa(\gamma(i,j)+\gamma(j,l)+\gamma(l,i))=E^l$ with $E^l:=(w_l-w_i)\partial_i\gamma(l,j)-(w_l-w_j)\partial_j\gamma(l,i)$, for each choice of the apex $l$. One computes $E^l=\sum_{\mathrm{cyc}}e_i\gamma(j,l)-w_l\,(d\gamma)(i,j,l)$; so the rows are equivalent to $d\gamma=0$ (two apexes) and then $k\gamma=0$. We use: (F1) $d^2=0$, $k^2=0$ and $dk=-kd$ (as $\partial_bQ_c=Q_c\partial_b+\delta_{bc}\partial_c$); (F2) for $p\ge1$, a closed form in $\Omega^p_D$ is exact (Poincar\'e; $D+p\ge1$); (F3) on forms with coefficient $w^\alpha$, $k$ is the wedge with $\sum_b(\alpha_b-\kappa)dw_b$, so for $p\ge1$ a $k$-closed form in $\Omega^p_D$ is in $k\Omega^{p-1}_D$, unless $\alpha=(\kappa,\dots,\kappa)$ has degree $D$, i.e.\ $\kappa m=D$ with $\kappa\in\mathbb{Z}_{\ge0}$. By (s1) this does not occur for $D\le a$. \emph{Claim} $P(D)$, $D\le a$: if $\eta\in\Omega^1_D$ and $d\eta\in k\Omega^1_{D-1}$, then $\eta\in d\Omega^0_{D+1}+k\Omega^0_D$. For $D=0$, $d\eta=0$ and (F2) applies. For $D\ge1$ let $d\eta=k\zeta$; then $kd\zeta=-dk\zeta=0$, so $d\zeta\in k\Omega^1_{D-2}$ by (F3), and $P(D-1)$ gives $\zeta=dF'+kf'$; so $d\eta=kdF'=-dkF'$, $\eta+kF'$ is closed, and $\eta=dF''-kF'$ by (F2). Now $k\gamma=0$ gives $\gamma=k\eta$ with $\eta\in\Omega^1_a$ (F3), $kd\eta=-dk\eta=-d\gamma=0$ gives $d\eta\in k\Omega^1_{a-1}$ (F3), and $P(a)$ gives $\eta=dF''+kf$, so $\gamma=kdF''=-dkF''$, i.e.\ $\gamma(t,\sigma)=A^t_\sigma\partial_tF''-\kappa\partial_\sigma F''$. Undoing the first step, $g^t_\sigma=\partial_\sigma H+A^t_\sigma h_t$ for all $\sigma,t\in I$, with $H:=-\kappa F''$ and $h_t:=(g^t_t-\partial_tH)/\kappa$. \end{proof} \emph{Parameters.} Write $\nu^{[r]}_t(\sigma):=\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{tr}$ ($t\ne r$, $\sigma\in[n]$). As $\sum_\sigma\partial_\sigma H=0$ and $\sum_\sigma A^t_\sigma h=(n\kappa-a)h$ (translation invariance and Euler), Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneSone} and the first trace give, for every $\sigma\in[n]$, \[ \nu^{[r]}_t(\sigma)=\partial_\sigma H^{(r)}+A^t_\sigma h^{(r)}_t-(n\kappa-a)\,h^{(r)}_t\,[\sigma=r],\tag{P} \] and the second trace at the pair $\{t,r\}$ reads \[ (a+1)H^{(r)}+O^{(r)}_th^{(r)}_t=0,\qquad O^{(r)}_t:=\kappa\Bigl(\sum_\sigma x_\sigma-nx_r\Bigr)+a(x_t+x_r)-\sum_\sigma x_\sigma^2\partial_\sigma.\tag{V} \] The symmetry $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{tr}=\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{rt}$ is the \emph{coupling} $\nu^{[r]}_t=\nu^{[t]}_r$ (C). (P), (V), (C) are linear in the parameters $(H^{(r)},h^{(r)}_t)$. \emph{The gauge at $r$}, $G_r$: $H^{(r)}:=H^{(r)}_g:=[\tau^{a+1}]\prod_{\sigma\ne r}(1-(x_\sigma-x_r)\tau)^\kappa$ (a formal power series if $\kappa\notin\mathbb{Z}_{\ge0}$), $h^{(r)}_t:=-\partial_tH^{(r)}_g/\kappa$, all other parameters $0$. With $D_{kl}:=\kappa(\partial_k-\partial_l)+(x_k-x_l)\partial_k\partial_l$, one has $D_{kl}\prod_{\sigma\in I}(1-w_\sigma\tau)^\kappa=0$; so (P) gives $\nu=0$ (at $\sigma=t$ directly, at $\sigma\in I\setminus\{t\}$ as $\nu=-D_{t\sigma}H^{(r)}_g/\kappa$, at $\sigma=r$ by the sum), and $G_r$ satisfies (V) and (C). $H^{(r)}_g$ is symmetric in $[n]\setminus\{r\}$, and it is not $0$ by (s5). \emph{The edge equations.} Fix an edge $\{t,r\}$, $S:=[n]\setminus\{t,r\}$, $p:=h^{(r)}_t$, $q:=h^{(t)}_r$, $\bar h:=(p+q)/2$, $\mu:=p-q$, $u:=x_r-x_t$, $y_\sigma:=x_\sigma-(x_r+x_t)/2$ and $K:=H^{(r)}-H^{(t)}-u\bar h$. Translation-invariant polynomials are the polynomials in $(u,y_S)$. (C) with (P) on both sides reads, for every $\sigma\in[n]$ ($n\lambda=n\kappa-a-1$), \[ \partial_\sigma K+(\kappa-y_\sigma\partial_\sigma)\mu-(n\kappa-a)\tfrac{\mu}{2}([\sigma=r]+[\sigma=t])=n\lambda\,\bar h\,([\sigma=r]-[\sigma=t]). \] For $\sigma\in S$ this is (E1): $d_SK=k_S\mu$, with $k_S:=\sum_{\sigma\in S}dy_\sigma\wedge(y_\sigma\partial_\sigma-\kappa)$ and $u$ a parameter. The sum over all $\sigma$ vanishes identically, and the $r$-component minus the $t$-component is (E3): $2n\lambda\bar h=2\partial_uK+\frac u2\sum_{\sigma\in S}\partial_{y_\sigma}\mu$. By (s3), (E3) gives $\bar h$ from $(K,\mu)$, then $p=\bar h+\mu/2$, $q=\bar h-\mu/2$, and (V) gives $H^{(r)}=-O^{(r)}_tp/(a+1)$ and $H^{(t)}=-O^{(t)}_rq/(a+1)$. \begin{lemma}[one edge, (E1)]\label{lem:Aoneedge} Assume \textup{(s2)}. The solutions $(K,\mu)$ of \textup{(E1)}, translation-invariant and homogeneous of degrees $a+1$ and $a$, are exactly \[ \mu=[\tau^a]\,\Gamma(u\tau)E(\tau),\qquad K=-[\tau^{a+1}]\,\Gamma(u\tau)E(\tau)+k_{\mathrm{top}}u^{a+1},\qquad E(\tau):=\prod_{\sigma\in S}(1+y_\sigma\tau)^\kappa, \] with $\Gamma(\tau)=\sum_{j=0}^ac_j\tau^j$: the $a+2$ parameters $c_0,\dots,c_a,k_{\mathrm{top}}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (E1) has no $u$-derivative, so it splits by powers of $u$: $\mu=\sum_ju^j\mu_j(y)$, $K=\sum_ju^jK_j(y)$ with $dK_j=k_S\mu_j$ ($d$ in the $y_S$ only). Let $V_i$ be the space of $f$ of degree $i$ in $y_S$ with $k_Sf$ exact. Then $\dim V_i\le1$: for $f\in V_i$, $k_Sdf=-dk_Sf=0$; on $y^\alpha$, $k_S$ is the wedge with $\sum(\alpha_\sigma-\kappa)dy_\sigma$, nonzero unless $\alpha=(\kappa,\dots,\kappa)$ of degree $\kappa(n-2)$, which by (s2) is not in degree $i-1\le a-1$; so $df=k_Sf'$ with a unique $f'$ of degree $i-1$, $f'\in V_{i-1}$, and $f\mapsto f'$ is injective ($f'=0$ gives $df=0$, $f=0$ as $i\ge1$). And $e_i:=[\tau^i]E\in V_i$: $(y_\sigma\partial_\sigma-\kappa)E=-\kappa E/(1+y_\sigma\tau)=-\tau^{-1}\partial_\sigma E$ gives $k_Se_i=-de_{i+1}$; $e_i\ne0$ for $i\le a$ by (s2). So $\mu_j=c_je_{a-j}$, $K_j=-c_je_{a+1-j}$ for $j\le a$, and $K_{a+1}=k_{\mathrm{top}}$ is free. \end{proof} \emph{Symmetry.} On the edge $\{t,r\}$, $\mu$ and $K$ are symmetric in $y_S$, and $\partial_u$, $\sum_S\partial_{y_\sigma}$ and $O^{(r)}_t$ commute with the permutations of $x_S$; so $H^{(r)}=-O^{(r)}_t(\bar h+\mu/2)/(a+1)$ is symmetric in $S$. As $H^{(r)}$ does not depend on $t$, and the groups $\Sym([n]\setminus\{r,t\})$, $t\ne r$, generate $\Sym([n]\setminus\{r\})$ ($n-1\ge3$), \emph{$H^{(r)}$ is symmetric in $[n]\setminus\{r\}$} for every $r$. \begin{lemma}[the one-edge lemma]\label{lem:AoneE} Fix an edge $\{t,r\}$, take $(K,\mu)$ as in Lemma~\ref{lem:Aoneedge}, $\bar h$ from \textup{(E3)} and $H^{(r)}$, $H^{(t)}$ from \textup{(V)}. If $H^{(r)}$ is symmetric in $[n]\setminus\{r\}$ and $H^{(t)}$ in $[n]\setminus\{t\}$, then $(K,\mu)$ lies in the span of the edge data of $G_r$ and $G_t$. Under \textup{(s1)}--\textup{(s5)} the symmetry of $H^{(r)}$ alone suffices. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} $G_r$ and $G_t$ solve the system, so their edge data lie in the family; they are independent ($G_r$ has $H^{(r)}=H^{(r)}_g\ne0$, $G_t$ has $H^{(r)}=0$ and nonzero edge data). So it suffices to bound the solutions by dimension $2$. Put $x_r=0$, $v_\sigma:=x_\sigma-x_r$ (so $u=-v_t$, $y_\sigma=v_\sigma-v_t/2$), fix $s_0\in S$, and let $F_{(i,k)}:=[v_t^iv_{s_0}^k]H^{(r)}$, a polynomial in $v_{S\setminus\{s_0\}}$, and $F_i:=[v_t^i]H^{(r)}$. As $H^{(r)}$ is symmetric in $S$, its symmetry in $[n]\setminus\{r\}$ gives $F_{(i,k)}=F_{(k,i)}$. \emph{Lowest terms.} $c_j$ enters $\mu$ and $K$ only through $c_ju^je_{a-j}(y)$ and $-c_ju^je_{a+1-j}(y)$, and $k_{\mathrm{top}}$ only through $k_{\mathrm{top}}u^{a+1}$. In (E3), $2\partial_u$ lowers the $u$-degree by one and $\frac u2\sum\partial_y$ raises it, so the $c_j$-part of $p=\bar h+\mu/2$ has $u$-degree $\ge j-1$, with $u^{j-1}$-part $-jc_ju^{j-1}e_{a+1-j}(y)/(n\lambda)$. In $v$, $u^ig(y)=(-1)^iv_t^ig(v_S)+O(v_t^{i+1})$, and $O^{(r)}_t=(\kappa Y-R)+(\kappa+a)v_t-v_t^2\partial_{v_t}$ with $Y:=\sum_Sv_\sigma$, $R:=\sum_Sv_\sigma^2\partial_{v_\sigma}$; it keeps or raises the $v_t$-degree, and $(\kappa Y-R)e_d=(d+1)e_{d+1}$ for $e_d:=[\tau^d]\prod_{\sigma\in S}(1+v_\sigma\tau)^\kappa$ (as $(\kappa Y-R)E=\partial_\tau E$). Hence $c_j$ ($j\ge1$) enters $H^{(r)}$ only in $v_t$-degrees $\ge j-1$, and \[ F_{j-1}=\frac{(-1)^{j-1}j(a+2-j)}{(a+1)n\lambda}\,c_j\,e_{a+2-j}(v_S)+(\text{terms in }c_0,\dots,c_{j-1})\qquad(1\le j\le a); \] the $k_{\mathrm{top}}$-part of $H^{(r)}$ is exactly $-(-1)^a\kappa k_{\mathrm{top}}v_t^a(v_t+Y)/(n\lambda)$. \emph{Triangular system.} $F_0$ contains only $c_0,c_1$ ($k_{\mathrm{top}}$ sits in $v_t$-degrees $\ge a\ge1$). For $2\le j\le a$ the row $F_{(j-1,0)}=F_{(0,j-1)}$ has its right side in $c_0,c_1$, and its left side is $\frac{(-1)^{j-1}j(a+2-j)}{(a+1)n\lambda}c_je^{(\kappa)}_{a+2-j}+(\text{terms in }c_0,\dots,c_{j-1})$, with $e^{(\kappa)}_d:=[\tau^d]\prod_{\sigma\in S\setminus\{s_0\}}(1+v_\sigma\tau)^\kappa\ne0$ for $d\le a$ by (s4). So $c_2,\dots,c_a$ are linear in $(c_0,c_1)$; and if $a\ge1$ the row $F_{(a,0)}=F_{(0,a)}$ contains $k_{\mathrm{top}}$ only on the left, with the coefficient $-(-1)^a\kappa\sum_{\sigma\in S\setminus\{s_0\}}v_\sigma/(n\lambda)\ne0$. (If $a=0$ the family has only the two parameters $c_0$, $k_{\mathrm{top}}$.) So the solutions form a space of dimension $\le2$. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Aone}] Under (s1)--(s5) Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneE} holds; in case (a) at $(n,a)=(4,5)$, $(4,6)$, $(5,11)$ it holds by Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2). Take the parameters of a solution. On each edge $e=\{t,r\}$ the edge data solve (E1), so they lie in the family of Lemma~\ref{lem:Aoneedge}; $H^{(r)}$ and $H^{(t)}$ are symmetric; so the edge data are $\alpha^e_r(G_r)+\alpha^e_t(G_t)$. As $H^{(r)}$ is determined by the edge data and $G_t$ has $H^{(r)}=0$, $H^{(r)}=\alpha^e_rH^{(r)}_g$, so $\alpha_r:=\alpha^e_r$ does not depend on $e$; likewise at $t$. The difference $\Delta$ of the solution and $\sum_r\alpha_rG_r$ satisfies (V) and (C) and has zero edge data on every edge ($G_{r'}$ has zero edge data on the edges not containing $r'$). By (E3) and (s3), $\bar h=0$, so $p=q=0$ on every edge; (V) gives $H^{(r)}(\Delta)=0$ for every $r$, and (P) gives $\nu(\Delta)=0$. So $\nu=\sum_r\alpha_r\nu(G_r)=0$. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:Aone} (1) (What is used.) The two traces, $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{pq}=\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{qp}$, translation invariance, homogeneity and the rows ($\mathrm{E}_r$) (Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows}); not the near rows, the rows $[l^3]$ and $\mathsf{P}$, nor $\mathsf{C}$. The relation (E4) $=$ (V) at both ends is not needed. At $\kappa=n$, case (b) alone gives $\mathsf{N}=0$ for $a\le n(n-3)$, which contains the range of (a) for $n\ge6$. \begin{sloppypar} (2) (The finite input.) At $\kappa=n$ and $(n,a)=(4,5),(4,6),(5,11)$, outside (s4), Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneE} (with both symmetry conditions) is an exact computation of the whole one-edge system (the family, (E3), (V), and the invariance of $H^{(r)}$ under $x_t\leftrightarrow x_{s_0}$ and of $H^{(t)}$ under $x_r\leftrightarrow x_{s_0}$): rank $5$, $6$, $11$ on $7$, $8$, $13$ parameters, solution dimension $2$, spanned by the two gauges. The program, its negative controls and the logs are in the ancillary files. \end{sloppypar} (3) (Not claimed.) $\lambda=0$ is excluded by the method; there the kernels of the system are nonzero at $n=4$, $a=3,\dots,6$, at $(n,a)=(5,4)$ and $(5,5)$, but $0$ at $(6,3)$ and $(5,3)$ (data only). Positive integers $\kappa$ with $a>\kappa(n-3)$, apart from the three cases above, are not treated. Nor is $y$-order $0$ ($\mathsf{F}\ne0$) treated here; for $\kappa=0$ it is excluded by Theorem~\ref{thm:Bthreezero}, and at $\kappa=n$, for $\varphi_f$ with $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$, by Theorem~\ref{thm:Azero}. \end{remark} \subsection{$y$-order $1$ at $b=4$: the spectator-edge rows force $\mathsf{N}=0$}\label{subsec:Aonefour} We keep the setting of Subsections~\ref{subsec:Bthree} and~\ref{subsec:EO}, now with $b=4$, $n\ge4$ and $a\ge0$. Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,4)}(n)$ satisfy $\kappa\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ for one $\kappa\in\mathbb{C}$, and $\Phi(x,y,Z):=\tilde\varphi(D,Z+\operatorname{diag}(y))$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:Bfourshape}, $\Phi_1=\sum_sy_s\mathsf{N}_s$ with $\mathsf{N}_s=\sum_C\mathsf{n}^s_CZ_C$, the sum over the directed $3$-cycles $C=(a\,b\,c)$ ($a\to b\to c\to a$, $Z_C:=Z_{ab}Z_{bc}Z_{ca}$), and $\sum_s\mathsf{n}^s_C=0$; as $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,4)}(n)$, the part of degree $0$ in $y$ of $\sum_sx_s\partial\Phi/\partial y_s=0$ gives $\sum_sx_s\mathsf{n}^s_C=0$. By Theorem~\ref{thm:EO} and Subsection~\ref{subsec:YOtwo}, $\varphi$ has $y$-order $0$ or $1$, and $y$-order $1$ means $\Phi_0=0\ne\Phi_1$. Here we exclude $y$-order $1$ at $\kappa=n$. So let $\Phi_0=0$. For a directed \emph{spectator edge} $r\to r'$ put $I:=[n]\setminus\{r,r'\}$ and \[ \mathsf{M}(\sigma,t)=\mathsf{M}^{(r\to r')}(\sigma,t):=\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{(t\,r\,r')}\qquad(\sigma,t\in I), \] $(t\,r\,r')$ being the cycle $t\to r\to r'\to t$, and $\mathsf{M}(v,w):=\sum_{\sigma,t}v_\sigma w_t\mathsf{M}(\sigma,t)$. \begin{lemma}[the spectator-edge rows at $b=4$, $\Phi_0=0$]\label{lem:Aonefourrows} Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}_{(a,4)}(n)$ with $\Phi_0=0$, let $l,k,m$ be distinct, $r\ne r'$ two indices outside $\{l,k,m\}$, and $\mu:=Z_{mr}Z_{rr'}Z_{r'l}$. At a slice point $(D,Z)$, the coefficient of $\mu$ in $\mathsf{c}(l,k,m)$ is $-\theta_{lm}\mathsf{M}(\Delta_{lk},\Delta_{lm})$, and its coefficient in $\mathsf{c}^{\mathcal{J}}(l,k,m)$ (defined as in Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows}) is \[ \theta_{lm}\bigl[x_{ml}\,\partial_l\mathsf{M}(k,m)+x_{lk}\,\partial_k\mathsf{M}(l,l)+x_{km}\,\partial_k\mathsf{M}(l,m)\bigr]. \] Neither $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$ nor the traces are used, and $\mathsf{G}$ does not occur. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (1) \emph{The operators.} Step (1) of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows} uses only Lemma~\ref{lem:PJ} and the brackets, so its display for $\mathsf{c}^{\mathcal{J}}$ holds here; at $y=0$, $D_{J(E_{pp})}$ acts on a monomial in $Z$ as $x_p\partial_p$ plus half the number of its edges at $p$. The monomial $\mu$ has one edge at $l$ and none at $k$. (2) \emph{Which terms reach $\mu$.} In $D_{(0,\eta_{pq})}$ (step (2) there), the term $Z_{qp}(x_q\partial_{y_q}-x_p\partial_{y_p})$ leaves a factor $Z_{qp}$ with $p,q\in\{l,k,m\}$, which $\mu$ does not have, and the term with $\partial/\partial Z_{pq}$ vanishes at $y=0$. So only the two sums count, acting on the parts of degree $0$ in $y$; the first turns an edge $c\to q$ into $c\to p$ (factor $x_q$), the second an edge $p\to c$ into $q\to c$ (factor $-x_p$). The $\theta_{kl}$-term gives nothing, as $\mu$ has no edge into $k$ and none out of $l$. The monomials that are moved onto $\mu$ are: by $D_{(0,\eta_{lk})}$, $Z_{mr}Z_{rr'}Z_{r'k}$ (factor $x_k$); by $D_{(0,\eta_{lm})}$, the $3$-cycles $Z_{(m\,r\,r')}$ (factor $x_m$) and $Z_{(l\,r\,r')}$ (factor $-x_l$); by $D_{(0,\eta_{km})}$, $Z_{kr}Z_{rr'}Z_{r'l}$ (factor $-x_k$). (3) \emph{The coefficients at $y=0$}, from \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta}; as $\Phi_0=0$, every first and second $Z$-derivative of $\Phi$ vanishes at $y=0$. (R) For $p\ne q$, any index $\sigma$ and distinct $\rho,\rho'\notin\{p,q\}$, the coefficient of the path $Z_{q\rho}Z_{\rho\rho'}Z_{\rho'p}$ in $\omega(E_{\sigma\sigma},E_{pq})$ is $\theta_{pq}(\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{(p\,\rho\,\rho')}-\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{(q\,\rho\,\rho')})$: indeed $\beta(E_{\sigma\sigma},E_{pq})=\partial_\sigma\partial\Phi/\partial Z_{pq}$ vanishes at $y=0$, $[E_{pq},E_{\sigma\sigma}]$ is a multiple of $E_{pq}$, and in $\partial_{y_\sigma}\partial_Y[[E_{pq},Z]]\Phi$ the diagonal part $Z_{qp}(E_{pp}-E_{qq})$ of $[E_{pq},Z]$ leaves a factor $Z_{qp}$, and the path comes from $Z_{q\rho}\,\partial\mathsf{N}_\sigma/\partial Z_{p\rho}$ with $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{(p\,\rho\,\rho')}$ and from $-Z_{\rho'p}\,\partial\mathsf{N}_\sigma/\partial Z_{\rho'q}$ with $-\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{(q\,\rho\,\rho')}$. (Z) For $p\ne q$ and $a\ne b$, $\omega(E_{pq},E_{ab})$ at $y=0$ is a multiple of $Z_{qp}$ plus a multiple of $Z_{ba}$, plus, if $(a,b)=(q,p)$, the bracket terms $-\theta_{pq}(\mathsf{N}_p-\mathsf{N}_q)$ of $\beta(E_{pq},E_{qp})$ and $\beta(E_{qp},E_{pq})$, which cancel in $\omega$: in $\partial_Y[E_{ab}]\partial_Y[[E_{pq},Z]]\Phi$ only the diagonal part $Z_{qp}(E_{pp}-E_{qq})$ of $[E_{pq},Z]$ survives at $y=0$. So: by (Z), $\omega(E_{lk},E_{km})$, $\omega(E_{kl},E_{lm})$ and $\omega(E_{kl},E_{lk})$ contribute nothing ($\mu$ and the moved monomials have no $Z_{kl}$, $Z_{mk}$, $Z_{lk}$, $Z_{ml}$, and the cycles $(m\,r\,r')$, $(l\,r\,r')$ avoid $k$). By (R), the coefficient of $\mu$ is $\theta_{lm}(\mathsf{M}(k,l)-\mathsf{M}(k,m))$ in $\omega(E_{kk},E_{lm})$ and $\theta_{lm}(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))$ in $\mathsf{w}=\omega(E_{ll},E_{lm})$, so $\mathsf{c}_\mu=-\theta_{lm}\mathsf{M}(\Delta_{lk},\Delta_{lm})$; that of $Z_{mr}Z_{rr'}Z_{r'k}$ in $\omega(E_{ll},E_{km})$ is $\theta_{km}(\mathsf{M}(l,k)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))$; that of $Z_{kr}Z_{rr'}Z_{r'l}$ in $\omega(E_{ll},E_{lk})$ is $\theta_{lk}(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,k))$; and the coefficient of $Z_C$ in $\omega(E_{ll},E_{kk})=\partial_l\mathsf{N}_k-\partial_k\mathsf{N}_l$ is $\partial_l\mathsf{n}^k_C-\partial_k\mathsf{n}^l_C$. (4) \emph{Collecting}, with $\partial_l\theta_{lm}=\theta_{lm}^2$, $\frac12-\gamma_{lm}=-x_l\theta_{lm}$, $\gamma_{km}-\gamma_{kl}=x_k(\theta_{lk}+\theta_{km})$ and $\theta_{lm}(\theta_{lk}+\theta_{km})=\theta_{lk}\theta_{km}$. The first two terms of the display give $\theta_{lm}[x_l\partial_l(\mathsf{M}(k,l)-\mathsf{M}(k,m))-x_k\partial_k(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))]+x_k\theta_{lk}\theta_{km}(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))$. The moves give $-\theta_{lk}x_k\theta_{km}(\mathsf{M}(l,k)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))$, $\theta_{lm}[x_m(\partial_l\mathsf{M}(k,m)-\partial_k\mathsf{M}(l,m)) -x_l(\partial_l\mathsf{M}(k,l)-\partial_k\mathsf{M}(l,l))]$ and $-\theta_{km}x_k\theta_{lk}(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,k))$. The terms without derivatives add up to $x_k\theta_{lk}\theta_{km}$ times $(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))-(\mathsf{M}(l,k)-\mathsf{M}(l,m))-(\mathsf{M}(l,l)-\mathsf{M}(l,k))=0$, the terms $\pm x_l\partial_l\mathsf{M}(k,l)$ cancel, and the rest is the stated coefficient. \end{proof} As $\kappa\,\mathsf{c}=\mathsf{c}^{\mathcal{J}}$ at every slice point, Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonefourrows} gives, multiplied by $x_{ml}=1/\theta_{lm}$, for every directed spectator edge $r\to r'$ and all distinct $l,k,m\in I$, \[ x_{ml}\,\partial_l\mathsf{M}(k,m)+x_{lk}\,\partial_k\mathsf{M}(l,l)+x_{km}\,\partial_k\mathsf{M}(l,m)=-\kappa\,\mathsf{M}(\Delta_{lk},\Delta_{lm}),\tag{P1} \] which is \textup{($\mathrm{E}_r$)}$(l,k,m)$ of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Aone} on the index set $I$; and, as shown above, for every directed $3$-cycle $C$, \[ \textstyle\sum_\sigma\mathsf{n}^\sigma_C=0,\qquad\sum_\sigma x_\sigma\mathsf{n}^\sigma_C=0.\tag{Tr$_4$} \] \begin{theorem}[$y$-order $1$ at $b=4$]\label{thm:Aonefour} Let $n\ge5$, $a\ge0$, and let the polynomials $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_C$ in $x$ ($\sigma\in[n]$, $C$ a directed $3$-cycle), homogeneous of degree $a$ and invariant under $x\mapsto x+c\mathbf{1}$, satisfy \textup{(Tr$_4$)} and \textup{(P1)} for every directed spectator edge and all distinct $l,k,m\in I$. Then $\mathsf{n}=0$ in each of the cases \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item $\kappa=n$ and $0\le a\le n(n-3)$; \item $\kappa$ satisfies \textup{(h1)}--\textup{(h3)} below. \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:Aonefour} Let $n\ge4$ and $4\le a\le(n^2-4)/2$. No eigenvector $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,4)}(n)$ of the pencil with $\kappa=n$ has $y$-order $1$; so every such eigenvector has $y$-order $0$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} The range $4\le a\le(n^2-4)/2$ is the one where $\tau=(n^2-a-4,a,4)$ is a partition (Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(ii) at $s=n$), and it lies in $a\le n(n-3)$ for $n\ge5$ ($n=5$: $a\le10$; $n\ge6$: $n^2-6n+4>0$). $y$-order $1$ means $\Phi_0=0\ne\mathsf{N}$; for $n\ge5$ Theorem~\ref{thm:Aonefour}(a) gives $\mathsf{N}=0$. For $n=4$ ($a=4,5,6$; there are no spectator edges) $\mathsf{N}=0$ is the finite computation of Remark~\ref{rem:Aonefour}(2). The last claim is Theorem~\ref{thm:EO} with Subsection~\ref{subsec:YOtwo}. \end{proof} The proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Aonefour} occupies the rest of the subsection. The conditions on $\kappa$ are (h1) $\kappa$ is not an integer $\ge0$ with $\kappa(n-2)\le a$ (so $\kappa\ne0$) (Lemma~\ref{lem:AonefourSone}); (h2) $\kappa$ is not an integer $\ge0$ with $\kappa(n-3)\le a-1$ (the family $\mathrm{Fam}_C$, and hence the steps after it); (h3) $n\kappa-d\ne0$ for $0\le d\le a$ and for $d=a+2$ (the traces and Lemma~\ref{lem:AonefourZ}). At $\kappa=n$ and $a\le n(n-3)$: $n(n-2)>a$, $n(n-3)\ge a$ and $a+2\kappa$, $i:=\max(0,N_k-\kappa m'-j)\le\kappa$ is a partner and $b_i\ne0=b_j$, so $\psi_{jk}=0$. (b) For $j_{\mathrm{lo}}\le i$ and $i+1\le\min(N_k,\kappa)$, every $j$ in $[\max(N_k-\kappa m'-i,j_{\mathrm{lo}}),\min(N_k-i-1,\kappa)]$ is a partner of both $i$ and $i+1$, so $\psi_{ik}/b_i=\psi_{i+1,k}/b_{i+1}$; the interval is not empty, as $\kappa m'\ge1$, $i\ge j_{\mathrm{lo}}$ gives $N_k-\kappa m'-i\le\kappa$, and $i+1\le N_k$, $i+1\le\kappa\le\kappa(m'+1)$ give $j_{\mathrm{lo}}\le N_k-i-1$ (and $j_{\mathrm{lo}}\le i<\kappa$). Hence $\psi_{jk}=\gamma_kb_j$ for every relevant $j$, and $F=\sum_k\gamma_kw_r^k[\tau^{N_k}]\prod_{\sigma\in T}(1+w_\sigma\tau)^\kappa$. \end{proof} \emph{Gauges off.} By the symmetry, $H^{(q\to r)}=H_p$ is invariant under $x_p\leftrightarrow x_{s_0}$, so by Lemma~\ref{lem:AonefourG} (with $\tau\mapsto-\tau$) it is a gauge of its block. Subtracting this gauge pair changes no $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{(t\,q\,r)}$ and makes $H^{(q\to r)}=0$; the steps above hold for any parameters of Lemma~\ref{lem:AonefourSone}, in particular for the new ones. So we may assume every $H^e=0$ (only $\kappa\ne0$ is used). \begin{lemma}\label{lem:AonefourZ} If every $H^e=0$, then every $h^e_t=0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Fix $C$. Now $\mathcal{H}_v=\xi_vh_v$; write $h_v=\sum_{d=0}^af_{v,d}(\xi)\,e_d$ ($f_{v,d}$ of degree $a-d$, $f_{v,a+1}:=0$; $e_0,\dots,e_a$ are nonzero by (h2) and of distinct $y$-degrees, hence independent over $\mathrm{Pol}(\xi)$). The trace $\sum_\sigma\mathsf{n}^\sigma_C=0$ with $\mathsf{n}^v_C=\kappa h_v$ reads $(n\kappa-\sum_Sy_\sigma\partial_\sigma)\bar h+\sum_S\partial_\sigma\bar{\mathcal{H}}=0$, with $e_d$-coefficient \[ (n\kappa-d)\,\bar f_d+(\kappa(n-3)-d)\,\bar F_{d+1}=0,\qquad\bar F_{d+1}:=\operatorname{mean}_v\xi_vf_{v,d+1}.\tag{T$_d$} \] First let $e_{a+1}\ne0$. Applied to $(\xi_vh_v-\xi_wh_w,h_v-h_w)$, the criterion for $\mathrm{Fam}_C$ says that $g_d:=f_{v,d}+\xi_vf_{v,d+1}$ does not depend on $v$ ($0\le d\le a$); so $\bar f_d=g_d-\bar F_{d+1}$ and (T$_d$) becomes $(n\kappa-d)g_d=3\kappa\bar F_{d+1}$. Downward from $d=a$: if every $f_{v,d+1}=0$, then $\bar F_{d+1}=0$, $g_d=0$ by (h3), and $f_{v,d}=g_d-\xi_vf_{v,d+1}=0$. So $h_v=0$. If $e_{a+1}=0$, then $\kappa$ is a positive integer and $a=\kappa(n-3)$ (by (h2)). Now $g_d$ is $v$-free for $d\le a-1$, and $f_{v,a}=:c_v$ are constants. The second trace with $\mathcal{H}_v=\xi_vh_v$ reads $(\sum_Sy_\sigma\partial_\sigma+3\kappa)\bar{\mathcal{H}}=R_S\bar h$, with $e_d$-coefficient $(d+3\kappa)\bar F_d+d\bar f_{d-1}=0$. (T$_a$) gives $\sum_vc_v=0$; (T$_{a-1}$), where $\kappa(n-3)-a+1=1$, gives $(n\kappa-a+1)\bar f_{a-1}+\phi=0$ with $\phi:=\bar F_a=\operatorname{mean}_v\xi_vc_v$; and the second trace at $d=a$ gives $(a+3\kappa)\phi+a\bar f_{a-1}=0$. So $\phi(a+3\kappa-a/(n\kappa-a+1))=0$, and as $n\kappa-a+1=3\kappa+1>1$ the bracket is positive: $\phi=0$. On $\{\sum\xi_v=0\}$ this forces $c_p=c_q=c_r$, so every $c_v=0$, and the induction runs from $d=a-1$. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Aonefour}] By the gauges off and Lemma~\ref{lem:AonefourZ}, every block parameter is $0$; so $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_C=0$ for $\sigma\in S\cup\{v\}$ and every $v\in C$, that is, $\mathsf{n}=0$. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:Aonefour} (1) (What is used.) The two traces, translation invariance, homogeneity and the rows (P1) (Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonefourrows}); not $\mathsf{G}$, the parts of $\Phi$ of degree $\ge2$ in $y$, or any row other than (P1). The analogous result at $b=3$ is Theorem~\ref{thm:Aone}; Lemma~\ref{lem:AonefourSone} is Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneSone} with $n-2$ variables and one parameter. (2) (The finite input at $n=4$.) For $n=4$ there are no spectator edges. At $\kappa=4$ and $a=4,5,6$, all $192$ $\mathsf{c}$-rows at $y=0$, $\Phi_0=0$ (closed forms of the rows, checked against the definition) together with the first trace, imposed on all translation-invariant coefficients of the $\mathsf{n}^\sigma_C$ and of $\mathsf{G}$, have full rank ($1380$, $1932$, $2576$ unknowns), mod $p=2^{61}-1$ at $20$ random points with all $x_p-x_q$ nonzero mod $p$; evaluation and reduction mod $p$ can only lower the rank, so the kernel is $0$ over $\mathbb{Q}$. Without the traces the kernel is $13$ ($a=4$) and $14$ ($a=5$). The program and logs are in the ancillary files. (3) (Checks, supporting; not used.) All $120$ rows (P1) with both traces at $(n,a,\kappa)=(5,4,5)$ have kernel $0$ on the $3500$ unknowns, and kernel $56$ without the second trace. Independent code gives kernel $0$ at $(5,2,5)$, $(5,4,5)$, $(5,5,5)$, $(6,4,6)$ and $(5,10,5)$ (the case $a=\kappa(n-3)$). The rows: their closed forms agree with $\mathcal{J}$ and $\mathsf{c}$ computed from the definitions on $288$ monomials at $n=4,5$ (with failing controls), and Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonefourrows} was derived by hand a second time, independently. The programs and logs are in the ancillary files. (4) (Not claimed.) $y$-order $0$ at $b=4$ ($\Phi_0\ne0$); anything about $\mathsf{G}$; other $b$; $\kappa$ outside (a), (b). \end{remark} \subsection{$y$-order $0$ at $b=3$: Theorem L3}\label{subsec:Azero} We keep the setting of Subsections~\ref{subsec:Bthree}, \ref{subsec:EO} and~\ref{subsec:Aone} with $b=3$ and $n\ge4$. Here we exclude $y$-order $0$ at $\kappa=n$: the cubic part $\mathsf{F}$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape} vanishes. With Theorems~\ref{thm:Aone} and~\ref{thm:EO} this settles the whole layer $b=3$ at $\kappa=n$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:Lthree}). \begin{theorem}[$y$-order $0$ at $b=3$]\label{thm:Azero} Let $n\ge4$, $3\le a\le(n^2-3)/2$ and $\tau:=(n^2-a-3,a,3)$. For every $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$, the cubic part $\mathsf{F}$ of $\varphi_f$ in Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape} is $0$. \end{theorem} By Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(ii) and Corollary~\ref{cor:pencil}(b) at $s=n$, $\varphi:=\varphi_f$ lies in $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,3)}(n)$ and satisfies $n\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$; we use this throughout, with $\kappa=n$, and write $s:=\kappa=n$ for the eigenvalue where the component notes do. The restriction to $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$ (not every eigenvector) is used twice: the transpose keeps $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$ (Part~0), and $f$ has degree $n$ in each row of $P$ (the degree bound in Part~I). \emph{Notation.} $\mathsf{F}^+$ and $\mathsf{F}^-$ are the parts of $\mathsf{F}$ that are even and odd under the orientation of a triangle, and $\mathsf{F}^+(T)$ is the value on a triangle $T$ ($\sigma$ stays the upper index of $\mathsf{n}^\sigma$, as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:Aone}). For a polynomial $P(y)$ in one variable $y$ (with coefficients functions of $x$) and a triangle $T=\{p,q,r\}$, $P[x_T]:=P[x_p,x_q,x_r]$ is the second divided difference in $y$ at the nodes of $T$. For a vertex set $X$, $\mathrm{R}_X$ is the space of $\mathsf{F}$ on the triangles of $X$ with $\mathsf{F}^-=0$ and $\mathsf{F}^+(T)=P[x_T]$ for one polynomial $P\in\mathbb{C}[y,x]$. \emph{Node class.} For a function $G$ on the triangles of a $4$-set $Q$, let $c(t)$ be the cubic in $t=x_w-\bar x_Q$ ($\bar x_Q$ the mean of $x_Q$) that interpolates $w\mapsto G(Q\setminus w)$ at the four nodes of $Q$; $b(G)=(b_2,b_3)$ are its coefficients of $t^2$ and $t^3$. Pointwise, $G$ is a second divided difference $P[x_T]$ if and only if $c$ is affine, i.e.\ $b(G)=0$. For a triangle $T\subset Q$, $E_Q(T):=e_2(x_T-\bar x_Q\mathbf{1})$. On a $5$-set $W$, $x'$ denotes the variables $x_o$, $o\notin W$, and $\theta$ the symmetric polynomial of the global form below. \emph{Plan.} Part 0: $\mathsf{F}^-=0$. Part I: $\mathsf{F}^+|_Q\in\mathrm{R}_Q$ for every $4$-set $Q$; it has four steps: the $4$-set statement, the $5$-set data, every level is a Kummer line (Theorem~\ref{thm:AzeroK}), and $\theta=0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroSEK}). Part II: $\mathsf{F}\in\mathrm{R}_{[n]}$, and then $\mathsf{F}=0$. \paragraph{The $\mathcal{J}$-entries at the positions $[l^3]$ and $\mathsf{P}$.} Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows} gives the $\mathsf{c}$-rows of $\mathcal{J}$ at $\mathsf{F}=0$. For $\mathsf{F}\ne0$ we need two more entries. Put $\mathsf{C}_{tuv}:=\partial^3\mathsf{C}/\partial y_t\partial y_u\partial y_v$ (constants in $y$) and, as in Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows}, $\gamma_{pq}:=\frac12(x_p+x_q)\theta_{pq}$. For distinct $l,i,j$ let $\Xi_l(i,j)$ be the coefficient in Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreerows}(i), so that $\omega(E_{li},E_{lj})=\Xi_l(i,j)\,Z_{il}Z_{jl}$, and for distinct $l,m,i,j$ let $\mathsf{A}(l,m;i,j)$ be the $\mathsf{A}$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreerows}(iii). \begin{lemma}[{the $\mathcal{J}$-entries at $[l^3]$ and $\mathsf{P}$}]\label{lem:AzeroJ} Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}_{(a,3)}(n)$, at a slice point $(D,Z)$, and let $l,m,i,j$ be distinct. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item The coefficient of $u_l^3$ in $\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ at $e_l\wedge e_i\wedge e_j$ is $\Xi^{\mathcal{J}}_l(i,j)\,Z_{il}Z_{jl}$ with \[ \Xi^{\mathcal{J}}_l(i,j)=(x_l\partial_l+1-\gamma_{li}-\gamma_{lj})\,\Xi_l(i,j)-\theta_{li}\mathsf{K}_l(i,j)+\theta_{lj}\mathsf{K}_l(j,i), \] \[ \begin{aligned} \mathsf{K}_l(i,j):={}&x_i\bigl[\partial_l\mathsf{F}_{lji}-\theta_{lj}\mathsf{F}_{lji}+2\theta_{lj}(\mathsf{n}^l_{li}-\mathsf{n}^l_{ij})\bigr] +2(x_i\,\partial_l\mathsf{n}^i_{lj}-x_l\,\partial_l\mathsf{n}^l_{lj})-2\theta_{lj}(x_i\mathsf{n}^i_{lj}-2x_l\mathsf{n}^l_{lj})\\ &+\theta_{lj}\bigl[x_i(\mathsf{C}_{lli}-\mathsf{C}_{lji})-x_l(\mathsf{C}_{lll}-\mathsf{C}_{llj})\bigr]. \end{aligned} \] \item The coefficient of $u_l^2u_m$ in $\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ at $e_l\wedge e_i\wedge e_j$ is $\mathsf{P}^{\mathcal{J}}(l,m;i,j)\,Z_{il}Z_{jm}-\mathsf{P}^{\mathcal{J}}(l,m;j,i)\,Z_{im}Z_{jl}$ with \[ \begin{aligned} \mathsf{P}^{\mathcal{J}}(l,m;i,j)={}&\theta_{ml}x_l\,\Xi_l(i,j)+(x_l\partial_l+\tfrac12-\gamma_{ml}-\gamma_{li}-\gamma_{lj})\,\mathsf{A}(l,m;i,j) -\theta_{li}(x_i\mathsf{d}_i-x_l\mathsf{d}_l)\\ &+\theta_{lj}(x_j\mathsf{g}_j-x_l\mathsf{g}_l)-\theta_{mi}(x_i\mathsf{a}_i-x_m\mathsf{a}_m)+\theta_{mj}(x_j\mathsf{e}_j-x_m\mathsf{e}_m), \end{aligned} \] where, with $\delta$ the Kronecker symbol, \[ \begin{aligned} \mathsf{d}_i&=-2\theta_{ml}(\mathsf{n}^i_{mj}-\mathsf{n}^i_{lj})+2\theta_{lj}(\mathsf{n}^i_{lm}-\mathsf{n}^i_{mj})+2\partial_l\mathsf{n}^i_{mj} +\theta_{mj}(\mathsf{C}_{lmi}-\mathsf{C}_{lji}),\\ \mathsf{d}_l&=-\theta_{ml}\bigl[\mathsf{F}_{ljm}+2(\mathsf{n}^l_{mj}-\mathsf{n}^l_{lj})\bigr]-\theta_{lj}\bigl[\mathsf{F}_{ljm}-2(\mathsf{n}^l_{lm}-\mathsf{n}^l_{mj})\bigr] +2\partial_l\mathsf{n}^l_{mj}+\theta_{mj}(\mathsf{C}_{llm}-\mathsf{C}_{llj}),\\ \mathsf{g}_j&=-\theta_{ml}(\mathsf{F}_{mij}-\mathsf{F}_{lij})+\theta_{li}(\mathsf{F}_{ljm}-\mathsf{F}_{mij})+\partial_l\mathsf{F}_{mij} +2\theta_{mi}(\mathsf{n}^l_{mj}-\mathsf{n}^l_{ij}),\\ \mathsf{g}_l&=-\theta_{ml}\bigl[\mathsf{F}_{lmi}+2(\mathsf{n}^m_{li}-\mathsf{n}^l_{li})\bigr]-\theta_{li}\bigl[\mathsf{F}_{lmi}-2(\mathsf{n}^l_{lm}-\mathsf{n}^i_{lm})\bigr] +\partial_l\mathsf{F}_{lmi}+2\theta_{mi}(\mathsf{n}^l_{lm}-\mathsf{n}^l_{li}),\\ \mathsf{a}_r&=\partial_l\mathsf{F}_{ljr}-\theta_{lj}\mathsf{F}_{ljr}+2\theta_{lj}(\mathsf{n}^l_{lr}-\mathsf{n}^l_{rj})\quad(r=i,m),\\ \mathsf{e}_t&=2\partial_l\mathsf{n}^t_{li}+\theta_{li}(\mathsf{C}_{llt}-\mathsf{C}_{lit})+2\theta_{li}(\delta_{ti}-\delta_{tl})\mathsf{n}^l_{li}-2\theta_{li}\mathsf{n}^t_{li} \quad(t=j,m). \end{aligned} \] \end{enumerate} At a slice point the corresponding coefficients of $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)$ are $\Xi_l(i,j)$ and $\mathsf{A}(l,m;i,j)$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreecoef}); so the eigen-rows are $\Xi^{\mathcal{J}}_l(i,j)=\kappa\,\Xi_l(i,j)$ and $\mathsf{P}^{\mathcal{J}}(l,m;i,j)=\kappa\,\mathsf{A}(l,m;i,j)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (1) \emph{Positions.} $\mathfrak{L}\omega(ue_l^T,ue_i^T,ue_j^T)$ is trilinear in the three columns $u$, so its coefficient of $u_l^3$ is $\mathfrak{L}\omega(E_{ll},E_{li},E_{lj})$ and that of $u_l^2u_m$ is $\mathfrak{L}\omega(E_{ml},E_{li},E_{lj})+\mathfrak{L}\omega(E_{ll},E_{mi},E_{lj}) +\mathfrak{L}\omega(E_{ll},E_{li},E_{mj})$. On the $\mathcal{Z}$ side the same coefficients are $\omega(E_{li},E_{lj})$ and $\omega(E_{li},E_{mj})+\omega(E_{mi},E_{lj})=\mathsf{P}(l,m;i,j)$, as in the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreecoef}. By torus weight ($e_i+e_j-2e_l$, resp.\ $e_i+e_j-e_l-e_m$) the values are combinations of $Z_{il}Z_{jl}$, resp.\ of $Z_{il}Z_{jm}$ and $Z_{im}Z_{jl}$, with no $y$-terms; the second coefficient in (b) follows from the first, because $\mathfrak{L}\omega$ is alternating (exchange $i$ and $j$). (2) \emph{The operators.} We use step (1) of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows}, which does not use $\mathsf{F}=0$: $D_{J(E_{pq})}\omega(U,V)=\theta_{pq}D_{(0,\eta_{pq})}\omega(U,V)-\gamma_{pq}[\omega([E_{pq},U],V)+\omega(U,[E_{pq},V])]$ and $D_{J(E_{pp})}=x_p\partial_p+D_{(0,E_{pp}\circ Y)}$, where at $y=0$ the last operator multiplies a monomial in $Z$ by half the number of its edges at $p$; and $D_{(0,\eta_{pq})}$ as in step (2) there. The brackets give $-(\gamma_{li}+\gamma_{lj})\Xi_l$ in (a) and $-(\gamma_{ml}+\gamma_{li}+\gamma_{lj})\mathsf{A}$ in (b). The Euler terms give $(x_l\partial_l+1)\Xi_l$ (two edges at $l$) and $(x_l\partial_l+\frac12)\mathsf{A}$ (one edge at $l$). (3) \emph{The transport terms.} In (a): $-\theta_{li}D_{(0,\eta_{li})}\omega(E_{ll},E_{lj})+\theta_{lj}D_{(0,\eta_{lj})}\omega(E_{ll},E_{li})$. By weight, $\omega(E_{ll},E_{lj})=\sum_r\mathsf{a}^{(j)}_rZ_{jr}Z_{rl}+\sum_ty_t\,\varepsilon^{(j)}_tZ_{jl}$. At $Z_{il}Z_{jl}$, $D_{(0,\eta_{li})}$ meets only its $y$-part $Z_{il}(x_i\partial_{y_i}-x_l\partial_{y_l})$ and the transport $x_iZ_{jl}\partial/\partial Z_{ji}$ on $Z_{ji}Z_{il}$; so $\mathsf{K}_l(i,j)=x_i\mathsf{a}^{(j)}_i+x_i\varepsilon^{(j)}_i-x_l\varepsilon^{(j)}_l$. In (b) the five transport terms \[ \begin{gathered} \theta_{ml}D_{(0,\eta_{ml})}\omega(E_{li},E_{lj}),\quad-\theta_{li}D_{(0,\eta_{li})}[\omega(E_{ml},E_{lj})+\omega(E_{ll},E_{mj})],\\ \theta_{lj}D_{(0,\eta_{lj})}[\omega(E_{ml},E_{li})+\omega(E_{ll},E_{mi})],\quad -\theta_{mi}D_{(0,\eta_{mi})}\omega(E_{ll},E_{lj}),\quad\theta_{mj}D_{(0,\eta_{mj})}\omega(E_{ll},E_{li}) \end{gathered} \] give, at $Z_{il}Z_{jm}$, in this order: $\theta_{ml}x_l\Xi_l$; the $y$-coefficients $\mathsf{d}_i,\mathsf{d}_l$ of $Z_{jm}$; the coefficients $\mathsf{g}_j,\mathsf{g}_l$ of $Z_{ij}Z_{jm}$ and $Z_{il}Z_{lm}$; the coefficients $\mathsf{a}_i,\mathsf{a}_m$ of $Z_{ji}Z_{il}$ and $Z_{jm}Z_{ml}$; and the $y$-coefficients $\mathsf{e}_j,\mathsf{e}_m$ of $Z_{il}$. Every other term of $D_{(0,\eta)}$ produces a monomial with an edge that $Z_{il}Z_{jm}$ does not have. (4) \emph{The coefficients.} By \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta}, $\beta(E_{pq},V)=-\theta_{pq}\,\partial_Y[V]\bigl(\partial_Y[[E_{pq},Y]]\tilde\varphi\bigr)$ for $p\ne q$ and $\beta(E_{pp},V)=\partial_{x_p}\partial_Y[V]\tilde\varphi$, with $[E_{pq},Y]=Z_{qp}\Delta_{pq}+(y_q-y_p)E_{pq}+\sum_{r\notin\{p,q\}} (Z_{qr}E_{pr}-Z_{rp}E_{rq})$. With Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape} (and $\partial^2\Phi/\partial Z_{ij}\partial Z_{hk}=\mathsf{F}Z$ exactly when the edges $i\to j$, $h\to k$ lie in one directed $3$-cycle) each coefficient is a short computation; for example $\omega(E_{ll},E_{lj})=\partial_l\,\partial\Phi/\partial Z_{lj}+\theta_{lj}\,\partial_{y_l}\partial_Y[[E_{lj},Y]]\Phi$ gives $\mathsf{a}^{(j)}_r=\mathsf{a}_r$ and \[ \varepsilon^{(j)}_t=2\partial_l\mathsf{n}^t_{lj}+\theta_{lj}(\mathsf{C}_{llt}-\mathsf{C}_{ljt})-2\theta_{lj}\mathsf{n}^t_{lj}+2\theta_{lj}(\delta_{tj}-\delta_{tl})\mathsf{n}^l_{lj}, \] whence $\mathsf{K}_l(i,j)$; $\mathsf{e}_t$ is $\varepsilon^{(i)}_t$. Likewise for $\mathsf{d}$ and $\mathsf{g}$ (a short collection of the same kind; each coefficient was compared term by term with an independent derivation, and the whole entry with $\mathfrak{L}\omega$ computed from the definition), from $\omega(E_{ml},E_{lj})=-\theta_{ml}\partial_Y[E_{lj}](\partial_Y[[E_{ml},Y]]\Phi)+\theta_{lj}\partial_Y[E_{ml}](\partial_Y[[E_{lj},Y]]\Phi)$, $\omega(E_{ll},E_{mj})=\partial_l\partial\Phi/\partial Z_{mj}+\theta_{mj}\partial_{y_l}\partial_Y[[E_{mj},Y]]\Phi$ and the two analogous expressions with $j$ replaced by $i$ in the second slot. \end{proof} (Computations, not used in the proofs below.) The formulas were also derived independently from the definition and checked against a direct evaluation of $\mathfrak{L}\omega$ at random rational slice points for several invariant functions with $\mathsf{F},\mathsf{n},\mathsf{C}\ne0$. \paragraph{Part 0: $\mathsf{F}^-=0$.} \begin{lemma}[pure $\mathsf{F}^-$]\label{lem:AzeroPT} Let $n\ge3$, $\kappa\notin\{3,-5/3\}$, and let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}_{(a,3)}(n)$ satisfy $\kappa\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ at every slice point. If $\mathsf{F}^+=0$, $\mathsf{N}=0$ and $\mathsf{C}=0$ in Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape}, then $\varphi=0$. Only three rows per triangle are used, and all their indices lie in the triangle. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Fix a triangle $T=\{l,k,m\}$ and put $\phi_T:=\mathsf{F}_{lmk}$ (the rows below are linear and homogeneous, so the sign convention is irrelevant). As $\mathsf{F}^+=0$, $\mathsf{F}_{lkm}=-\phi_T$; as $\mathsf{N}=\mathsf{C}=0$, every $\mathsf{n}$- and $\mathsf{C}$-term drops. \emph{Step 1 (the row $[l^3]$: one first-order equation per apex).} By Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreerows}(i), $\Xi_l(k,m)=\theta_{lk}\mathsf{F}_{lmk}-\theta_{lm}\mathsf{F}_{lkm}=A_l\phi_T$ with $A_l:=\theta_{lk}+\theta_{lm}$. In Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroJ}(a), $\mathsf{K}_l(k,m)=x_k(\partial_l\phi_T-\theta_{lm}\phi_T)$ and $\mathsf{K}_l(m,k)=-x_m(\partial_l\phi_T-\theta_{lk}\phi_T)$. The coefficient of $\partial_l\phi_T$ in $\Xi^{\mathcal{J}}_l(k,m)$ is $x_lA_l-\theta_{lk}x_k-\theta_{lm}x_m=-2$, and the coefficient of $\phi_T$ is $A_l$ (write $x_k=x_l+1/\theta_{lk}$, $x_m=x_l+1/\theta_{lm}$; then $\gamma_{lk}+\gamma_{lm}=x_lA_l+1$ and the rest cancels). So the eigen-row $\Xi^{\mathcal{J}}_l(k,m)=\kappa\,\Xi_l(k,m)$ reads \begin{equation}\label{eq:AzeroODE} 2\,\partial_l\phi_T=-(\kappa-1)A_l\phi_T,\qquad A_l=\frac1{x_k-x_l}+\frac1{x_m-x_l}, \end{equation} that is, $\partial_l(\phi_T/V_T^{(\kappa-1)/2})=0$ with $V_T$ the Vandermonde of $T$. The same holds at the apex $k$ (row $[k^3]$). \emph{Step 2 (the near row).} Take the coefficient of $Z_{mk}Z_{kl}$ in the row $\mathsf{c}(l,k,m)$ at $e_l\wedge e_k\wedge e_m$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:Bthreerows}(ii) its $\mathcal{Z}$-part is $\mathsf{c}_k=(\partial_k-\partial_l)\phi_T+(\theta_{lm}-\theta_{lk}-\theta_{km})\phi_T$. For the $\mathcal{J}$-part we use the collection in step (1) of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:Aonerows} (it does not use $\mathsf{F}=0$) and select, as in step (2) there, the terms that reach $Z_{mk}Z_{kl}$: the Euler and bracket terms give $(x_l\partial_l+\frac12)(\mathsf{c}_k+\mathsf{w}_k)-\gamma_{lm}\mathsf{c}_k-(x_k\partial_k+1)\mathsf{w}_k+(\gamma_{km}-\gamma_{kl}-\gamma_{lm})\mathsf{w}_k$ (one edge at $l$, two at $k$), with $\mathsf{w}_k$ the coefficient of $Z_{mk}Z_{kl}$ in $\omega(E_{ll},E_{lm})$; the four transport terms give $\theta_{kl}x_l\Xi_l(k,m)$, $-\theta_{lk}[x_k(\rho_k+\varpi_k)-x_l(\rho_l+\varpi_l)]$, $\theta_{lm}(x_m\mu_{km}-x_l\mu_{lk})$ and $\theta_{km}(x_m\varepsilon^{(k)}_m-x_k\varepsilon^{(k)}_k)$, where $\rho_t,\varpi_t$ are the coefficients of $y_tZ_{mk}$ in $\omega(E_{kl},E_{lm})$ and $\omega(E_{ll},E_{km})$, and $\mu_{pq}$ is the coefficient of $Z_{pq}Z_{qp}$ in $\omega(E_{kl},E_{lk})+\omega(E_{ll},E_{kk})$. With $\mathsf{F}^+=\mathsf{N}= \mathsf{C}=0$, \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta} gives $\Xi_l(k,m)=A_l\phi_T$, $\rho_k=\theta_{kl}\phi_T$, $\rho_l=-(\theta_{kl}+\theta_{lm})\phi_T$, $\varpi=\varepsilon^{(k)}=0$, $\mu_{km}=-2\theta_{kl}\phi_T$, $\mu_{lk}=0$ and $\mathsf{w}_k=\partial_l\phi_T-\theta_{lm}\phi_T$. Collecting (a short collection, also checked by computer; program and log in the ancillary files), with $u:=x_{kl}$ and $v:=x_{km}$, \[ \mathsf{c}^{\mathcal{J}}_k-\kappa\,\mathsf{c}_k=x_{lk}\,\partial_l\partial_k\phi_T+\frac{\kappa x_{km}+x_{lk}}{x_{km}}\,\partial_l\phi_T -\frac{\kappa x_{lm}+x_{kl}}{x_{lm}}\,\partial_k\phi_T+\frac{\kappa(u^2-uv+v^2)-u^2-3uv+3v^2}{uv(v-u)}\,\phi_T. \] The rows hold identically in $x$, so the $x_l$-derivative of \eqref{eq:AzeroODE} at the apex $k$ holds too; inserting it and \eqref{eq:AzeroODE} at the apexes $l$ and $k$ gives \[ \mathsf{c}^{\mathcal{J}}_k-\kappa\,\mathsf{c}_k=-\frac{(\kappa-3)(3\kappa+5)}{4(x_k-x_l)}\,\phi_T. \] So the eigen-row forces $\phi_T=0$ when $\kappa\notin\{3,-5/3\}$. For every triangle, $\mathsf{F}^-=0$; with $\mathsf{F}^+=\mathsf{N}=\mathsf{C}=0$ the slice data vanish, so $\varphi=0$ (an invariant function is determined on the slice). \end{proof} (Computations, not used.) Each step was also checked exactly: Step 1 symbolically for all triangles through the indices $2$ and $3$; Step 2 in the form above by sympy, and from the row engine (independent of Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroJ}) for $u=e_2+ce_3$: the same factor $(\kappa-3)(3\kappa+5)/(4x_{23})$ (programs in the ancillary files; Remark~\ref{rem:AzeroChecks}). \begin{theorem}[$\mathsf{F}^-=0$ for the counted eigenvectors]\label{thm:Azerotranspose} Let $n\ge4$, $b=3$, $s=n$, $\tau=(n^2-a-3,a,3)$ and $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$. Then $\varphi_f^T=\varphi_f$, where $\varphi^T(X,Y):=\varphi(X^T,Y^T)$; in particular $\mathsf{F}^-=0$ for $\varphi_f$, at every $y$-order. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} (1) $\varphi\mapsto\varphi^T$ maps $\mathcal{F}^{\mathcal{E}}_{(a,3)}(n)$ to itself. On the slice $X=\operatorname{diag}(x)$ is symmetric, so $\Phi^T(x,y,Z)=\Phi(x,y,Z^T)$: every $3$-cycle is reversed ($\mathsf{F}^+$ is fixed, $\mathsf{F}^-$ changes sign), $\mathsf{N}^T=\mathsf{N}$ (each monomial of $\mathsf{N}_q$ is a $2$-cycle $Z_{pq}Z_{qp}$) and $\mathsf{C}^T=\mathsf{C}$. (2) By Theorem~\ref{thm:S12}, $f$ satisfies (S2) as well as (S1); by Corollary~\ref{cor:pencil}(b), (S1) says that $\varphi_f$ is an eigenvector at $\kappa=n$ and (S2) says the same for $\varphi_f^T$. (Also $f^T(P):=f(P^T)$ lies in $\mathrm{R}_n(n)_\tau$ and $\varphi_{f^T}=\varphi_f^T$.) (3) So $\varphi_\pm:=\frac12(\varphi_f\pm\varphi_f^T)$ are eigenvectors at $\kappa=n$, and $\varphi_-$ has $\mathsf{F}^+=\mathsf{N}=\mathsf{C}=0$ by (1). (4) Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroPT} ($\kappa=n\ge4$, so $\kappa\notin\{3,-5/3\}$) gives $\varphi_-=0$. Hence $\varphi_f=\varphi_+$ and $\mathsf{F}^-=0$. \end{proof} This covers $\varphi_f$ with $f$ in $\mathrm{R}_n(n)_\tau$, which is what Theorem~\ref{thm:matrixpair} counts; a pencil eigenvector that does not come from $\mathrm{R}_n(n)_\tau$ is not covered, and Theorem~\ref{thm:Azero} is stated for $\varphi_f$, $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$. \paragraph{The four-point $\mathsf{F}^+$-part.} Let $\mathsf{F}^-=0$, so $\mathsf{F}_{pqr}=\mathsf{F}_{prq}=\mathsf{F}^+_T$ on each triangle $T=\{p,q,r\}$. Fix a $4$-set $Q$, put $g_w:=\mathsf{F}^+_{Q\setminus\{w\}}$ for $w\in Q$, and take divided differences in the node variables $x_w$ with the values $g_w$: \[ \Theta_r:=g[Q\setminus\{r\}]=\sum_{w\in Q\setminus\{r\}}\frac{g_w}{\prod_{v\in Q\setminus\{r,w\}}x_{wv}},\qquad c_3:=g[Q]=\sum_{w\in Q}\frac{g_w}{\prod_{v\in Q\setminus\{w\}}x_{wv}}. \] The weights of $\Theta_r$ do not involve $x_r$. $\Theta_r=0$ for all $r$ says that $w\mapsto g_w$ is affine in $x_w$ (then $c_3=0$ too); then $g_w=\alpha+\beta x_w$ with $\alpha,\beta$ independent of $w$, which is $g_w=P[x_{Q\setminus\{w\}}]$ for $P=(\alpha+\beta\sum_{v\in Q}x_v)y^2-\beta y^3$. \begin{lemma}[S0]\label{lem:AzeroSzero} Let $\varphi\in\mathcal{F}_{(a,3)}(n)$ satisfy $\kappa\,\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=\mathcal{J}(\varphi)$ at every slice point, with $\kappa\notin\{0,-2\}$ and $\mathsf{F}^-=0$. Then for every $4$-set $Q$ and every $r\in Q$ \begin{equation}\label{eq:AzeroSzero} \partial_r\Theta_r+(\kappa-1)\,c_3=0. \end{equation} Only the eigen-rows $[l^3]$ and $\mathsf{P}$ with all indices in $Q$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroJ}), and their first $x_r$-derivatives, are used; neither the translation invariance nor $\mathcal{E}\varphi=0$ is used. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For $l\in Q$ write $\mathrm{L}(l;i,j):=\Xi^{\mathcal{J}}_l(i,j)-\kappa\,\Xi_l(i,j)$ and $\mathrm{P}(l,m;i,j):=\mathsf{P}^{\mathcal{J}}(l,m;i,j)-\kappa\, \mathsf{A}(l,m;i,j)$ ($Q=\{l,m,i,j\}$); all vanish. Each differentiates only along its apex $l$, and $\mathsf{C}$ enters with no derivative. \emph{Step 1 ($\mathsf{C}$ drops out inside one apex).} For $i\in Q\setminus\{l\}$ and $\{m,j\}=Q\setminus\{l,i\}$ with $mn$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) By Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(i), $f$ has degree $n$ in each row of $P=(P_1,P_2,P_3)$, and $\Phi(x,y,Z)=\widetilde\varphi_f(\operatorname{diag}x,Z+\operatorname{diag}y)=f(I,\operatorname{diag}x,Z+\operatorname{diag}y)$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(ii)); $x_o$ sits only in row $o$ of $P_2$, so $\deg_{x_o}\mathsf{F}_T\le n$ for $o\notin T$. (ii) $b_2(\mathsf{F}|_Q)$ is a combination of the $\mathsf{F}_T$, $T\subset Q$, with coefficients rational in $x_Q$, so $\deg_{x_o}b_2(\mathsf{F}|_Q)\le n$ for $o\in O$. (iii) By Lemma~\ref{lem:Azeroglobal} and homogeneity in $Y_Q$, the $Y_Q$-degree-$0$ part of $b_2(\mathsf{F}|_Q)$ is $\pm\theta(x_O-\bar x\mathbf{1})$, whose $x_o$-degree is the degree of $\theta$ in its $o$-th variable. \end{proof} This is the second place where $\varphi=\varphi_f$ with $f\in K_n(n)_\tau$ is used (the first is Part~0). \begin{theorem}[every level is a Kummer line]\label{thm:AzeroK} Let $\kappa=n\ge5$. Every component of the actual $\mathsf{F}$, at every level $r\ge1$, satisfies $(\mathrm{K}_r)$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} \emph{Base.} At levels $1$ and $2$ the conditions (C1)--(C2b) are empty, and the five-point identity of Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroS} leaves exactly the Kummer lines $K_1$, $K_2$ for every $\kappa\ne2$ (a finite exact computation with $\kappa$ symbolic: the lines $(5\kappa-7)/\kappa$ and $\bigl((5\kappa-8)(5\kappa-7)/(\kappa(\kappa-1)),\,2(5\kappa-8)/(\kappa-1)\bigr)$, rank drop only at $\kappa=2$; program \texttt{base12.py} and its log in the ancillary files). The part $\alpha+\beta(x_v+x_w)+\gamma x_vx_w$ in $\mathrm{R}_W$ of a component has coefficients symmetric in $x_W$ (by covariance) and zero defect in Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroS} (Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroRW}), so that lemma may be applied to one particular realizer. \emph{Step} ($3\le r\le n$). Let every level-$(r-1)$ component be a multiple of $K_{r-1}$. For a level-$r$ component $\psi_\mu$, $\partial_t\psi_\mu$ is a combination of level-$(r-1)$ components, so $\partial_t\psi_\mu=-cK_{r-1}=\partial_t(cK_r)$ (as $\partial_tK_r=-K_{r-1}$), hence $\psi_\mu=cK_r+d\,w^r$. Both $\psi_\mu$ and $K_r$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroE}) are realizable, so $d\,w^r$ is, and Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroN} gives $d=0$. So $\psi_\mu=cK_r$, which satisfies $(\mathrm{K}_r)$ by Kummer's ratio $k_{r-1}/k_r$ ($k_r\ne0$ for $r\le n$). \emph{Levels $r>n$.} By Lemma~\ref{lem:Azerodeg}, $\theta_r=0$, so $p_0=0$; at $r=n+1$ the factor $\kappa+1-r$ is $0$, and at $r\ge n+2$ also $\theta_{r-1}=0$, so $p_1=0$. In both cases $(\mathrm{K}_r)$ holds. \end{proof} Since $a-2$ goes up to $(n^2-7)/2>n$, most levels are $r>n$. Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroCF} is used only for $k\le r+2$ with $r\le n$, so $k\le n+2$ suffices. \begin{lemma}[symmetric extension]\label{lem:AzeroSEK} Let $m\ge1$, $s\in\mathbb{C}$ and $\theta$ a symmetric polynomial in $m$ variables, homogeneous of degree $k\ge1$. Distinguish one variable $w$, write $\theta_r:=[w^r]\theta$ and let $D$ be the sum of the partial derivatives in the other $m-1$ variables. Assume, for every $r\ge1$, \[ r(r+6-5s)\,\theta_r=(s+1-r)\,D\theta_{r-1}.\tag{$\mathrm{K}_r$} \] If $6+k-(m+4)s\ne0$ and $4s\ne7$, then $\theta=0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Multiply ($\mathrm{K}_r$) by $w^{r-1}$ and sum over $r\ge1$; with $r(r+6-5s)=r(r-1)+(7-5s)r$ this gives $w\theta_{ww}+B\,\theta_w+wD\theta_w+A\,D\theta=0$ with $A=-s$, $B=7-5s$. Put $D=D_{\mathrm{all}}-\partial_w$ ($D_{\mathrm{all}}$ the sum of all $m$ partials): the terms $w\theta_{ww}$ cancel, and $(B-A)\partial_w\theta+w\partial_w(D_{\mathrm{all}}\theta)+A\,D_{\mathrm{all}}\theta=0$. By symmetry this holds with $w$ replaced by each variable $x_i$. Sum over $i$ and use Euler for $\phi:=D_{\mathrm{all}}\theta$, homogeneous of degree $k-1$: $(B-A+k-1+mA)\phi=0$, and $B-A+k-1+mA=6+k-(m+4)s$. So $\phi=0$, and then $(B-A)\partial_i\theta=0$ with $B-A=7-4s\ne0$: $\theta$ is constant, hence $0$ as $k\ge1$. \end{proof} At $s=n$ and $m=n-4$ the conditions read $k\ge1$, $6+k\ne n^2$ and $4n\ne7$; all hold for $1\le k=a-2\le(n^2-7)/2$. Theorem~\ref{thm:AzeroK} gives $(\mathrm{K}_r)$ for the components on a $5$-set $W$ in the form $(n+1-r)p_1=r(5n-6-r)p_0$; with $w$ the variable of the node $v$, $p_0=[x'^\mu]\theta_r$ and $p_1=-[x'^\mu]D\theta_{r-1}$, where $D$ is the sum of the partials in the $n-5$ variables $x'$ (not the $D$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:Azeroglobal}, which is $D_{\mathrm{all}}$); so these relations for all $\mu$ are ($\mathrm{K}_r$) of Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroSEK}. So, with Theorem~\ref{thm:AzeroK} (which gives ($\mathrm{K}_r$) for every $r\ge1$ at $s=n$) and the global form, $\theta=0$, and $\mathsf{F}^+|_Q\in\mathrm{R}_Q$ for every $4$-set $Q$ (this includes the class $E_Q$ of degree $2$). This ends Part I. \paragraph{Part II: $\mathsf{F}\in\mathrm{R}_{[n]}$, then $\mathsf{F}=0$.} \begin{lemma}[gluing]\label{lem:Azeroglue} Let $n\ge4$ and let $\mathsf{F}_T$ ($T$ a triangle of $[n]$) be polynomials in $x$ with $\mathsf{F}^-=0$. If for every $4$-set $Q$ there are functions $\alpha_Q,D_Q$ with $\mathsf{F}^+(Q\setminus w)=\alpha_Q-D_Qx_w$ for all $w\in Q$ (this holds if $\mathsf{F}^+|_Q\in\mathrm{R}_Q$ pointwise), then $\mathsf{F}^+(T)=P[x_T]$ for one $P\in\mathbb{C}[y,x]$ and all $T$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) $D_Q$ is a polynomial: with $g_w:=\mathsf{F}^+(Q\setminus w)$, $D_Q=(g_p-g_r)/(x_r-x_p)=(g_q-g_r)/(x_r-x_q)$, so the denominator of $D_Q$ divides the coprime $x_r-x_p$ and $x_r-x_q$. (ii) Put $f_1=f_2:=0$ and $f_i:=(x_i-x_1)(x_i-x_2)\mathsf{F}^+(\{1,2,i\})$ ($i\ge3$), polynomials; then $f[x_1,x_2,x_i]=\mathsf{F}^+(\{1,2,i\})$. The affine form on $\{1,2,p,q\}$ gives $f[x_1,x_2,x_p,x_q]=D_{\{1,2,p,q\}}$, hence $f[x_2,x_p,x_q]=\mathsf{F}^+(\{2,p,q\})$ and likewise $f[x_1,x_p,x_q]=\mathsf{F}^+(\{1,p,q\})$; the affine form on $\{1,p,q,r\}$ then gives $f[x_p,x_q,x_r]=\mathsf{F}^+(\{p,q,r\})$. (iii) Every divided difference $f[x_U]$, $|U|\ge3$, is a polynomial: for $|U|=3$ by (ii), and for $|U|\ge4$, $f[x_U]=(f[x_{U\setminus p}]-f[x_{U\setminus t}])/(x_t-x_p)$ for every pair $p\ne t$ in $U$, so its denominator divides coprime differences. (iv) The Newton form $P(y):=\sum_{k=0}^{n-1}f[x_1,\dots,x_{k+1}]\prod_{j\le k}(y-x_j)$ lies in $\mathbb{C}[y,x]$ and $P(x_i)=f_i$, so $P[x_T]=f[x_T]=\mathsf{F}^+(T)$. \end{proof} By Part 0, Part I and Lemma~\ref{lem:Azeroglue}, $\mathsf{F}_{pqr}=P[x_p,x_q,x_r]$ for one $P\in\mathbb{C}[y,x]$. \emph{Normalizing $P$.} Conjugation by a permutation matrix fixes $\varphi$, so $\mathsf{F}_{\pi p\,\pi q\,\pi r}(\pi x)=\mathsf{F}_{pqr}(x)$ and $P(\cdot;\pi x)$ represents $\mathsf{F}$ as well; replace $P$ by its average over $S_n$, then by $P(y-\bar x;x-\bar x\mathbf{1})$ ($\bar x$ the mean of $x$; $\mathsf{F}$ is translation invariant), then by its part of joint degree $a+2$ in $(y,x)$ ($\mathsf{F}$ is homogeneous of degree $a$). So $P$ is symmetric in $x$, invariant under $(y,x)\mapsto(y+c,x+c\mathbf{1})$, and homogeneous of joint degree $a+2$. Write $P[t,r,r]$ for $P[x_t,x_r,x_r]$ etc., $P'$ for $\partial P/\partial y$, and $\partial_\sigma P$ for the derivative in $x_\sigma$ at fixed $y$. \emph{The source.} With $\mathsf{F}\ne0$ the spectator rows (Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroSrow}) are the rows ($\mathrm{E}_r$) of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Aone} for $\nu^{[r]}_t(\sigma):=\mathsf{n}^\sigma_{tr}$ with a source linear in $\mathsf{F}$. Put, for $t\ne r$ and $\sigma\ne r$, \[ \nu_0{}^{[r]}_t(\sigma):=\tfrac12\bigl[\delta_{t\sigma}P[t,t,r]+(x_t-x_r)(\partial_\sigma P)[t,r,r]\bigr],\qquad \nu_0{}^{[r]}_t(r):=-\textstyle\sum_{\sigma\ne r}\nu_0{}^{[r]}_t(\sigma); \] $\nu_0$ is a polynomial, translation invariant and homogeneous of degree $a$, and it satisfies the first trace of (Tr). \begin{enumerate}[label=(A\arabic*),leftmargin=*] \item $\sum_\sigma x_\sigma\,\nu_0{}^{[r]}_t(\sigma)=\frac{a+1}2(x_t-x_r)P[t,r,r]$. \item $\nu_0{}^{[r]}_t(\sigma)-\nu_0{}^{[t]}_r(\sigma)=\partial_\sigma Q_e$ for every $\sigma\in[n]$, with $Q_e:=\frac12(x_t-x_r)(P[t,r,r]+P[r,t,t])$. \item $\nu_0$ solves the spectator rows with the source $\mathsf{F}$. \end{enumerate} \begin{proof} (A1) By the first trace, the left side is $\sum_{\sigma\ne r}(x_\sigma-x_r)\nu_0{}^{[r]}_t(\sigma)$. Joint translation invariance and joint Euler give $\sum_\sigma\partial_\sigma P=-P'$ and $\sum_\sigma x_\sigma\partial_\sigma P=(a+2)P-yP'$, so $\sum_\sigma(x_\sigma-x_r)\partial_\sigma P=(a+2)P-(y-x_r)P'$; the Leibniz rule at the nodes $[t,r,r]$ gives $((y-x_r)P')[t,r,r]=(x_t-x_r)P'[t,r,r]+P''(x_r)$, and the $\delta$-term adds $(x_t-x_r)P[t,t,r]$. So the left side is $\frac12(x_t-x_r)[P[t,t,r]+(a+2)P[t,r,r]-(x_t-x_r)P'[t,r,r]-P''(x_r)]$. For every polynomial $P$ in $y$, $P[t,t,r]+P[t,r,r]-(x_t-x_r)P'[t,r,r]-P''(x_r)=0$ (both sides are shift invariant; at $x_r=0$ on $y^k$ the left side is $((k-1)+1-k)x_t^{k-2}=0$ for $k\ge3$, $1+1-0-2=0$ for $k=2$, and $0$ for $k\le1$), which gives (A1). (A2) For $\sigma\notin\{t,r\}$ the nodes do not move, and both sides are $\frac12(x_t-x_r)\partial_\sigma(P[t,r,r]+P[r,t,t])$. At $\sigma=t$, $\partial_t$ also moves the nodes ($\partial_tP[t,r,r]=P[t,t,r,r]$, $\partial_tP[r,t,t]=2P[r,t,t,t]$), and the two sides agree because $P'[r,t,t]=P[r,r,t,t]+2P[r,t,t,t]$ (the $y$-derivative of a divided difference repeats each node once). At $\sigma=r$ it follows from the sum over $\sigma$, as both sides satisfy the first trace and $Q_e$ is translation invariant. (A3) is a finite exact computation: the rows are linear in $P$, and the generating function $P=c(x)/(1-zy)$ covers every $P$ ($s$ symbolic, $c$ generic: $0$ nonzero of $24$; the control without the derivative term fails; program and log in the ancillary files). \end{proof} So $\nu':=\nu-\nu_0$ solves the rows ($\mathrm{E}_r$) without source and the first trace, and Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneSone} gives its parameters $(H^{(r)},h^{(r)}_t)$ in (P). By (A1) the second trace of $\nu$ reads $(a+1)H^{(r)}+O^{(r)}_th^{(r)}_t+\frac{a+1}2(x_t-x_r)P[t,r,r]=0$, i.e. \[ H^{(r)}=\hat H^{(r)}_t-W(t),\qquad\hat H^{(r)}_t:=-O^{(r)}_th^{(r)}_t/(a+1),\qquad W(t):=\tfrac12(x_t-x_r)P[t,r,r], \] and $W(t)=\tfrac12(P[t,r]-P'(x_r))$. By (A2), on each edge $\{t,r\}$ the coupling of $\nu'$ has the defect $-\partial_\sigma Q_e$, so the edge equations hold for $(K+Q_e,\mu)$ in place of $(K,\mu)$: $(K+Q_e,\mu)$ lies in the family of Lemma~\ref{lem:Aoneedge} (parameters $c_0,\dots,c_a,k_{\mathrm{top}}$), and (E3) gives $\bar h$ from it. By the divided-difference recursion, for $t'\ne t$ (both $\ne r$), \[ W(t)-W(t')=\tfrac12(P[t,r]-P[t',r])=(x_t-x_{t'})\,\Omega_{rtt'},\qquad\Omega_{rtt'}:=\tfrac12\mathsf{F}_{rtt'}. \] \emph{Symmetry.} As in Subsection~\ref{subsec:Aone}: on the edge $\{t,r\}$, $\hat H^{(r)}_t$ is symmetric in $S=[n]\setminus\{t,r\}$, and so is $W(t)$ ($P$ is symmetric); $H^{(r)}$ does not depend on $t$; so $H^{(r)}$ is symmetric in $[n]\setminus\{r\}$. \begin{lemma}[one edge with the source]\label{lem:AzeroEprime} Assume \textup{(s1)}--\textup{(s5)} of Subsection~\ref{subsec:Aone}. Fix an edge $\{t,r\}$ and $s_0\in S$, let $(K+Q_e,\mu)$ be in the family of Lemma~\ref{lem:Aoneedge}, $\hat H^{(r)}$, $\hat H^{(t)}$ as above, $H^{(r)}:=\hat H^{(r)}-W(t)$ and $H^{(t)}:=\hat H^{(t)}-W'(r)$ with $W'(r):=\frac12(x_r-x_t)P[r,t,t]$. If $H^{(r)}$ is invariant under $x_t\leftrightarrow x_{s_0}$ and $H^{(t)}$ under $x_r\leftrightarrow x_{s_0}$, then $\mathsf{F}_{rts_0}=0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Coordinates of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneE}: $x_r=0$, $v_\sigma:=x_\sigma-x_r$, $F_{(i,k)}(H):=[v_t^iv_{s_0}^k]H$, a polynomial in $v_{S\setminus\{s_0\}}$, $F_i(H):=[v_t^i]H$. $W(s_0)$ is $W(t)$ with $t$ and $s_0$ exchanged ($P$ is symmetric), so the invariance of $H^{(r)}$ is the set of rows \[ F_{(i,k)}(\hat H^{(r)})-F_{(k,i)}(\hat H^{(r)})=[v_t^iv_{s_0}^k]\bigl((v_t-v_{s_0})\Omega\bigr),\qquad\Omega:=\Omega_{rts_0}=\tfrac12\mathsf{F}_{rts_0}, \tag{$\mathrm{R}_{ik}$} \] and $\Omega$ is invariant under the permutations of $x_r,x_t,x_{s_0}$. Write $\Omega=\sum_d\Omega^{(d)}$ with $\Omega^{(d)}$ homogeneous of degree $d$ in $(v_t,v_{s_0})$ (coefficients in $v_{S\setminus\{s_0\}}$); each $\Omega^{(d)}$ is symmetric in $(v_t,v_{s_0})$. From the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneE}: $c_j$ ($j\ge1$) enters $\hat H^{(r)}$ only in $v_t$-degrees $\ge j-1$, $F_{j-1}=\chi_jc_je_{a+2-j}(v_S)+(\text{terms in }c_0,\dots,c_{j-1})$ with $\chi_j:=(-1)^{j-1}j(a+2-j)/((a+1)n\lambda)\ne0$, and the $k_{\mathrm{top}}$-part of $\hat H^{(r)}$ is $-(-1)^a\kappa k_{\mathrm{top}}v_t^a(v_t+Y)/(n\lambda)$. (0) \emph{Gauges.} $F_0$ involves only $c_0,c_1$. The span of the gauges $G_r$, $G_t$ maps injectively to the $(c_0,c_1)$-plane: for $\alpha_rG_r+\alpha_tG_t$ with $c_0=c_1=0$, $F_0=\alpha_rH^{(r)}_g|_{x_t=x_r}=0$, and $H^{(r)}_g|_{x_t=x_r}=[\tau^{a+1}]\prod_{\sigma\in S}(1-v_\sigma\tau)^\kappa\ne0$ (at $\kappa=n$, $a+1\le(n^2-1)/2\le n(n-2)$ for $n\ge4$; for other $\kappa$ by (s4)); so $\alpha_r=0$, and likewise $\alpha_t=0$. So the $2$-dimensional gauge span maps onto that plane, and after subtracting a gauge combination (which has $\mathsf{F}=0$ and leaves $\Omega$ unchanged) $c_0=c_1=0$; at the $t$-end the swap acts by $c'_0=-c_0$, $c'_1=c_1$, so this holds there too. (1) \emph{Both ends.} ($\mathrm{R}_{10}$) reads $\chi_2c_2e_a(v_{S\setminus\{s_0\}})=\Omega^{(0)}$, and $\Omega^{(0)}$ is $\Omega$ at $x_r=x_t=x_{s_0}$. The swap $r\leftrightarrow t$ maps the family by $c'_j=-(-1)^jc_j$, $k'_{\mathrm{top}}=(-1)^ak_{\mathrm{top}}$, maps $W$ to $W'$ and keeps the triple $\{t,r,s_0\}$; so the $t$-end row is $\chi_2c'_2e_a=\Omega^{(0)}$ with $c'_2=-c_2$. Hence $c_2=0$ (by (s4), $e_a(v_{S\setminus\{s_0\}})\ne0$) and $\Omega^{(0)}=0$. (For $a=1$ the family is $c_0,c_1,k_{\mathrm{top}}$, and the same argument on ($\mathrm{R}_{10}$), whose left side is the $k_{\mathrm{top}}$-term, gives $k_{\mathrm{top}}=0$ and $\Omega^{(0)}=0$; go to (3).) (2) \emph{Induction.} Let $c_0=\dots=c_J=0$, $2\le J\le a$. Then $\hat H^{(r)}$ has $v_t$-degree $\ge J$, so $F_{(i,k)}(\hat H^{(r)})=0$ for $i\le J-1$. (2a) For $i,k\le J-1$ the left side of ($\mathrm{R}_{ik}$) is $0$; the rows of total degree $D\le J-1$ give $(v_t-v_{s_0})\Omega^{(D-1)}=0$, so $\Omega^{(d)}=0$ for $d\le J-2$; in degree $J$ the rows $(i,J-i)$, $1\le i\le J-1$, say that $(v_t-v_{s_0})\Omega^{(J-1)}$ contains only $v_t^J$ and $v_{s_0}^J$, so $\Omega^{(J-1)}=\alpha\,h_{J-1}(v_t,v_{s_0})$ ($h$ complete homogeneous). (2b) Let $g(a',b';z):=\Omega$ at $x_r=0$, $x_t=a'$, $x_{s_0}=b'$, $x_{S\setminus\{s_0\}}=z$. Invariance under $x_r\leftrightarrow x_t$ and translation invariance give $g(a',b';z)=g(-a',b'-a';z-a'\mathbf{1})$; the shift of $z$ only raises the $(a',b')$-degree and $\Omega^{(d)}=0$ for $dn(n-3)$; in our range this happens only at $(n,a)=(4,5),(4,6),(5,11)$. There (1) is replaced by the swap parity: if $(c,P)$ solves the one-edge system, so does $(c',P)$, so $(c-c',0)$ solves the system without source, and Lemma~\ref{lem:AoneE} at these cases (Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2)) puts it in the gauge span; its $(c_0,c_1)$ is $(2c_0,0)=(0,0)$, so by (0) every even $c_j$ is $0$, in particular $c_2=0$, and ($\mathrm{R}_{10}$) gives $\Omega^{(0)}=0$. At $(4,5)$ and $(5,11)$, (2c) needs only $d\le n(n-3)$, so Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroEprime} holds. At $(4,6)$, (2c) at $J=2$ needs $d=5>4$; there Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroEprime} is a finite exact computation: the one-edge system at $(n,a,\kappa)=(4,6,4)$ with the unknowns $c_0,\dots,c_6$, $k_{\mathrm{top}}$ and a general symmetric translation-invariant $P$ of degree $8$ ($11$ basis elements, $4$ of them with $\mathsf{F}\ne0$) has a solution space of dimension $9=7+2$ (the $7$ such $P$ with $\mathsf{F}=0$ and the two gauges), on which $\mathsf{F}_{rts_0}=0$ (controls with the source decoupled fail; program and log in the ancillary files). \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:Azero}] At $\kappa=n$, $\lambda=(n^2-a-1)/n\ne0$, and (s1)--(s3), (s5) hold for $a\le(n^2-3)/2$. Part 0 gives $\mathsf{F}^-=0$, Part I gives $\mathsf{F}^+|_Q\in\mathrm{R}_Q$ for every $4$-set $Q$, Lemma~\ref{lem:Azeroglue} gives $\mathsf{F}=P[x_T]$, and for every triangle $\{p,q,r\}$ Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroEprime} (with the three cases above) on the edge $\{t,r\}:=\{q,r\}$ with $s_0:=p$ gives $\mathsf{F}_{pqr}=0$. For $n=4$ ($m=0$: there are no outside variables) the theorem is a finite exact computation (Remark~\ref{rem:Azero}(2)). \end{proof} \begin{corollary}[Theorem L3: the layer $b=3$ at the eigenvalue $n$]\label{cor:Lthree} For every $n\ge4$ and every $a$ with $3\le a\le(n^2-3)/2$, $\mathrm{K}_n(n)_{(n^2-a-3,a,3)}=0$. Hence, for every $n\ge4$, no conjugation type $\kappa$ of $K_{B(n,2)}$ with $\kappa'_3=2$ occurs; with Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}, every type with $\kappa'_3\le2$ is $(3,1^{N-3})$, and it occurs once. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} Let $f\in\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau$, $\tau=(n^2-a-3,a,3)$, and $\varphi=\varphi_f$. Theorem~\ref{thm:Azero} gives $\mathsf{F}=0$; then Theorem~\ref{thm:Aone}(a) gives $\mathsf{N}=0$; so $\Phi=\mathsf{C}$, which Theorem~\ref{thm:EO} excludes unless $\Phi=0$. So $\tilde\varphi$ vanishes on the slice, hence $\varphi=0$, and $f=0$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(ii). A type $\kappa$ with $\kappa'_3=2$ has $\tau=\kappa'+(1,1,1)=(n^2-a-3,a,3)$ with $\kappa'_2=a-1\ge2$ and $\tau_1\ge\tau_2$, i.e.\ $3\le a\le(n^2-3)/2$, and its multiplicity is $\dim\mathrm{K}_n(n)_\tau=0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(iii)). \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:Azero} (1) (What is used.) Besides the lemmas of this subsection: Theorem~\ref{thm:S12}, Corollary~\ref{cor:pencil}(b), Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(i)--(iii), Lemmas~\ref{lem:Bthreeshape}, \ref{lem:Bthreecoef}, \ref{lem:Bthreerows} and~\ref{lem:Aonerows}, \eqref{eq:Bthreebeta}, Lemmas~\ref{lem:AoneSone}, \ref{lem:Aoneedge}, \ref{lem:AoneE} and Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2) (Part II), and, for the corollary, Theorems~\ref{thm:Aone} and~\ref{thm:EO} and Corollary~\ref{cor:Peven}. (2) (Finite exact computations.) The proof is by hand up to the following finite exact computations, each named where it is used: the certificate of Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroSzero}; the translation equivariance in Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroCH}; the base levels of Theorem~\ref{thm:AzeroK}; Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroRW}; (A3) and the case $(4,6)$ in Part II; the three cases of Remark~\ref{rem:Aone}(2); and $n=4$: the full row system with the traces at $\kappa=4$ has kernel $0$ for $a=3,\dots,6$, by full column rank modulo a prime of $p$-integral rows, with the rows from the definition (the row engine, not the hand rows of Lemma~\ref{lem:AzeroJ}; the engine is checked against the definition at random points, with controls in which a genuine eigenvector at $\lambda=0$ survives). The programs and logs of this and of every other computation in this part are in the ancillary files. (3) (Not claimed.) Other layers $b$, eigenvalues $\kappa\ne n$, and any bound on $d(n)$ by itself. \end{remark} \section{The block $\lambda(3,1,1)$}\label{sec:L311} Statement (iii) in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:F} asks for $U_{\lambda(3,1,1)}=0$. Proposition~\ref{prop:window311} settled the types of depth at most $7$ by computing the windows. In this section we extend the matrix-pair model of Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair} to every self-conjugate $\nu$: the single block $\nu$ is cut out by one test, built from a grid of $rc$ rank-one matrices, for each outer corner $(r,c)$ of $\nu$ with $rc\le k$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:cornerdict}). For $\nu=(3,1,1)$ the leading term in $n$ of the three tests is a pointwise condition through one $\mathrm{GL}_n$-module $\mathcal{K}_\nu(n)$ of $4$-forms, which is $0$ for every $n$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:K}, computer-assisted and exact); Capelli's identity then gives an analogue of Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj} without an exceptional line (Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj311}). As a consequence, $\mathcal{Y}_m((3,1,1))=0$ for every $m$, and for every $n\ge5$ the kernel $K_{\lambda(3,1,1)}$ has no conjugation type of depth at most $n-3$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:L311}). The deeper types remain open. Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer31} removes the hypothesis $\nu=\nu'$ (the tests are then the live corners of $\nu'$) and, for $\nu=(3,1)$ and $n\ge6$, excludes from $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ the types of six weights of the first layer. Subsection~\ref{subsec:zinj31} shows that the leading term is injective on the column $(\tau_2,1,1)$, although its pointwise kernel is not $0$, and excludes from $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ the two-row types of depth $1,\dots,n-3$. Subsection~\ref{subsec:L131} excludes all two-row types, at every depth and for every $n\ge3$, using only the tests at diagonal points. Subsection~\ref{subsec:shallow31} excludes the three- and four-row types of depth at most $6$ (for $n$ at least the depth plus $3$), by exact computer-assisted certificates. Subsection~\ref{subsec:L1311col} returns to $\nu=(3,1,1)$: it proves Conjecture~\ref{conj:L1311} on the column $(\tau_2,1,1,1)$, by the method of Subsection~\ref{subsec:L131} with exact symbolic identities checked by computer, and so excludes from $K_{\lambda(3,1,1)}$ the two-row types, at every depth and for every $n\ge3$. \subsection{The corner dictionary}\label{subsec:corner} In this subsection $F=\mathbb{C}$, as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair}. Let $\nu\vdash k$ lie inside $R$ with $\nu=\nu'$, $\lambda=\lambda(\nu)$ and $N=n^2-k$. By Corollary~\ref{cor:casimir}(a) every conjugation type $\kappa$ of $K_\lambda$ has $\kappa_1\le k$; put $\tau:=\kappa'+(1^k)=(\kappa^{+k})'$, a partition of $n^2$ with exactly $k$ rows. Let $V$, $M_n=V\otimes V$ and the action of $\mathrm{SL}_n\times\mathrm{SL}_n$ be as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair}, and let $\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$ be the space of the polynomials $f(P_1,\dots,P_k)$ on $M_n^k$ that are $\mathrm{SL}_n\times\mathrm{SL}_n$-invariant, homogeneous of degree $\tau_a$ in $P_a$, and highest weight vectors for $\mathrm{GL}_k$: $f(\dots,P_b+tP_a,\dots)=f$ for all $a3$). For $\nu=(3,1,1)$ all three corners $(1,4)$, $(2,2)$, $(4,1)$ are live, with $rc=4=k-1$. \begin{theorem}[corner dictionary]\label{thm:cornerdict} Let $\nu=\nu'\vdash k$ lie inside $R$ and $\kappa$, $\tau$ be as above. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item There is a linear isomorphism $\operatorname{Mult}(\kappa^{+k})\to\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$; in particular $\dim\mathrm{Pol}_\tau=g(R,R,\tau)$. \item It maps the space $X_\nu$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:casimir}(b) onto the space of the $f\in\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$ that pass $(T_{r,c})$ for every live corner $(r,c)$ of $\nu$. Hence the multiplicity of $\kappa$ in $K_\lambda$ is the dimension of this space. \item For every $n$, $f\mapsto\varphi_f:=f(I,\cdot,\dots,\cdot)$ is injective on $\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$, and \[ f=\det(P_1)^n\varphi_f\bigl((P_1^{-1}P_2)_0,\dots,(P_1^{-1}P_k)_0\bigr) \] where $\det P_1\ne0$ ($X_0$ is the traceless part of $X$). If $d:=\tau_2+\dots+\tau_k\le n$, it is a bijection onto the space $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ of the polynomials $\varphi(A_2,\dots,A_k)$ in traceless matrices that are invariant under simultaneous conjugation, homogeneous of degree $\tau_a$ in $A_a$, and satisfy $\varphi(\dots,A_b+tA_a,\dots)=\varphi$ for $2\le an$ or $\ell(\alpha')>n$ is $0$), and the isotypic projector of $e_\mu$, with $S_k$ permuting the second factors, maps $\Lambda^kW$ onto the summand $\alpha=\mu'$. \item For $\alpha\vdash k$ inside the $n\times n$ box the cell wedge $h_\alpha:=\bigwedge_{(i,j)\in\alpha}(e_i\otimes e_j)$ spans the highest weight line of $S_\alpha V\otimes S_{\alpha'}V$. \item For a cell $(r,c)$ with $rc\le k$ let $\Gamma_{r,c}\subseteq\Lambda^kW$ be the span of the vectors $\bigl(\bigwedge_{p\le r,\,q\le c}u_p\otimes y_q\bigr)\wedge X_{rc+1}\wedge\dots\wedge X_k$. Then $\Gamma_{r,c}=\bigoplus_{\alpha\supseteq(c^r)}S_\alpha V\otimes S_{\alpha'}V$. \item $\sum_{(r,c)}\Gamma_{r,c}=\bigoplus_{\alpha\ne\nu}S_\alpha V\otimes S_{\alpha'}V$, the sum over the live corners of $\nu$. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (i) is Schur--Weyl duality on the $k$ slots, as in Step~2 of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:matrixpair} (the skew Cauchy decomposition; \cite{ABW82}). (ii) $h_\alpha\ne0$ has weight $(\alpha,\alpha')$. A raising operator $E_{i,i+1}$ on the first factor turns a factor $e_{i+1}\otimes e_j$ into $e_i\otimes e_j$, which is already a factor since $(i,j)\in\alpha$; so every term is $0$, and the same holds on the second factor. A highest weight vector of weight $(\alpha,\beta)$ lies in a summand $S_\alpha V\otimes S_\beta V$, and by (i) only $\beta=\alpha'$ occurs, once. (iii) $\Gamma_{r,c}$ is $\mathrm{GL}_n\times\mathrm{GL}_n$-stable. If the $u_p$ (or the $y_q$) are dependent, the $rc$ factors $u_p\otimes y_q$ lie in a space of dimension less than $rc$ and the wedge is $0$; otherwise $r,c\le n$ and the wedge of the grid is $(g,h).h_{(c^r)}$ for some $g,h$. The span of the orbit of a highest weight vector is the irreducible module it generates, so the grids span $S_{(c^r)}V\otimes S_{(r^c)}V$. The wedge product $\Lambda^{rc}W\otimes\Lambda^{k-rc}W\to\Lambda^kW$ is equivariant, and the first factor of the image of $S_{(c^r)}V\otimes(\text{anything})$ lies in the sum of the $S_\alpha V\subseteq S_{(c^r)}V\otimes S_\gamma V$, which have $\alpha\supseteq(c^r)$ (Littlewood--Richardson); with (i) this gives ``$\subseteq$''. Conversely, for $\alpha\supseteq(c^r)$ (if $\alpha$ does not fit in the $n\times n$ box the summand is $0$), $h_\alpha=\pm h_{(c^r)}\wedge\bigwedge_{(i,j)\in\alpha\setminus(c^r)}(e_i\otimes e_j)$ lies in $\Gamma_{r,c}$ and generates $S_\alpha V\otimes S_{\alpha'}V$. (iv) A partition $\mu\vdash k$ with $\mu\ne\nu$ is not inside $\nu$, so it has a cell outside $\nu$; take one, $(r,c)$, minimal for the product order. Then $(r-1,c)$ and $(r,c-1)$, when they exist, lie in $\mu$ and not in $\mu\setminus\nu$, hence in $\nu$; so $(r,c)$ is an addable cell of $\nu$, and $\mu\supseteq(c^r)$ gives $rc\le k$. Conversely, if $\mu\supseteq(c^r)$ for an addable cell $(r,c)$ of $\nu$, then $(r,c)\in\mu\setminus\nu$ and $\mu\ne\nu$. With (iii) this gives (iv). \end{proof} Part (iii) is the exterior analogue of the description of the $\mathrm{GL}\times\mathrm{GL}$-stable ideals of $\Sym(V\otimes W)$ by De Concini, Eisenbud and Procesi \cite{DEP80}. \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:cornerdict}] Steps~1, 3 and 4 of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:matrixpair} hold with $k$ in place of $3$, with these changes. In Step~3 there are $k$ groups $G_1,\dots,G_k$ of slots, and for $a0$. For $A=(A_2,A_3,A_4)$ let \[ \omega=\omega_A(X_1,X_2,X_3):=\sum_{\pi\in S_3}\sgn(\pi)\,\partial_2[X_{\pi1}]\,\partial_3[X_{\pi2}]\,\partial_4[X_{\pi3}]\,\tilde\varphi(A), \] an alternating $3$-form of degree $\tau_j-1$ in $A_j$ (in the first layer it does not depend on $A_4$), with $\omega_A(B)=\omega_A(B_0)$ and $\omega_A=\omega_{A_0}$; put $Z_\omega:=\tr\wedge\omega$. \begin{lemma}[$k=4$]\label{lem:pencil31} Let $\tau$ be a $4$-row weight, $\varphi\in\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ and $s\in\mathbb{C}$. \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item For every $A$, $\Omega f_s(I,A)=s\,Z_\omega-\mathfrak{L}\omega$, with $\mathfrak{L}$ as in Lemma~\ref{lem:pencil311} (four arguments, $CA:=(CA_2,CA_3,CA_4)$); both sides are unchanged under $A_j\mapsto A_j+cI$. \item For all $B_1,B_2,B_3$, $\Omega f_s(I,A)(B_1,B_2,B_3,I)=-\mu\,\omega_A(B_1,B_2,B_3)$. \item For traceless $A$, $\omega_A(A_2,A_3,A_4)=(\tau_2+2)(\tau_3+1)\tau_4\,\varphi(A)$; so $\varphi\mapsto\omega_\varphi$ is injective. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) is Lemma~\ref{lem:pencil311} for $k=4$, with the same proof. (b) is the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:freeslot} for $k=4$: moving the argument $P_1$ from position $4$ to position $1$ takes three transpositions, so the sign is $(-1)^{k-1}=-1$, and each of the three slots $j\ge2$ adds one $\Omega'f_s$; at $P=(I,A)$, $\Omega'f_s=\omega_A$. (c) is Capelli's identity, as in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj311}, for the three columns $2,3,4$: the factor is $\prod_{j=2}^4(\tau_j+4-j)\ne0$. \end{proof} For the six weights below the factor in (c) is $6,8,10,12,12,15$. Let $g_{r,c}(u,y):=\bigwedge_{p\le r,\,q\le c}u_py_q^T$ and $h_{(2,2)}=E_{11}\wedge E_{12}\wedge E_{21}\wedge E_{22}$ be as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer311}. We call $\varphi\in\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ a \emph{kernel vector at $s$} if, for every $A$, $\Omega f_s(I,A)$ vanishes on the rows (R1) $g_{1,3}(u,y)\wedge X$, for all $u$, $y$, $X$; (R2) $h_{(2,2)}$; (R3) $g_{4,1}(u,y)$, for all $u$, $y$. They lie in $\Gamma_{1,3}$, $\Gamma_{2,2}$ and $\Gamma_{4,1}$. If $f\in\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$ passes the three tests, then $\varphi_f$ is a kernel vector at $s=n$: the tests hold at every $P$, in particular at $P=(I,A)$, and $f_n=f$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:cornerdict}(c)). The rows (R3) are not used below. By Lemma~\ref{lem:pencil31}(b) (rows (R1) with $X=I$), for $\mu\ne0$ every kernel vector lies in the space $V_{\mathrm{FS}}$ of the $\varphi$ such that $\omega_A$ vanishes on every $g_{1,3}(u,y)$, for every $A$. \emph{Trace forms and the rules for $\mathfrak{L}$.} We use $\boldsymbol\theta$, $\varrho$, $\boldsymbol\theta_0$, graded cyclicity and the insertion rule for $d$ of Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer311}. By the first fundamental theorem \cite{Pr76}, $\omega$ is a combination of products of traces of words in the letters $(A_j)_0$ and $\boldsymbol\theta_0$; we write such a form with $A_j$ and $\boldsymbol\theta$, and a hat ($\hat w$) means the same form with $(A_j)_0$ and $\boldsymbol\theta_0$. Necessary conditions from $\varphi\in\mathrm{HW}_\tau$: $\omega$ is invariant under conjugation, it is closed in each base slot ($d_j\omega=0$, as two derivatives in slot $j$ commute and are alternated), and $\omega(\dots,A_b+tA_a,\dots)=\omega$ for $2\le a2s$ it is not $0$ either, so $\varkappa_j$ is determined by $\varkappa_{j-2}$. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}[the rows $\{a,a,b,c\}$]\label{prop:aabc31} At $A=\operatorname{diag}(x)$ and for $c\notin\{a,b\}$: $\Omega_A(W_5)=0$, \[ \tfrac12\,\Omega_A(W_1)=\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[\varkappa_{ab}]:=-3s\,\varkappa_{ab}+s\,x_{ab}(\partial_c-\partial_a)\varkappa_{ab} +(3x_c-2x_a-x_b)\,\partial_c\varkappa_{ab}-x_{ab}(x_a-x_c)\,\partial_a\partial_c\varkappa_{ab}, \] and $\Omega_A(W_3)(x)=\Omega_A(W_1)(\sigma_{bc}x)=2\mathcal{Q}_{acb}[\varkappa_{ac}]$. Hence, if $\varphi$ passes the tests at $s$, $\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[\varkappa_{ab}]+\mathcal{Q}_{acb}[\varkappa_{ac}]=0$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:loc31}(ii)). \end{proposition} \begin{proof} As for Proposition~\ref{prop:hab31}. $Z_\omega(W_1)=\omega_{ab,c}-\omega_{ab,a}$, and $(\mathfrak{L}\omega)(W_1)=x_a\partial_a\omega_{ab,c}-x_c\partial_c\omega_{ab,a}+2\gamma_{ab}\,\omega_{ab,c}$ (the two terms with $\omega^{\mathfrak t}$, from $[E_{ab},E_{ba}]=E_{aa}-E_{bb}$ and $[E_{ba},E_{ab}]$, cancel). For $W_5$, $Z_\omega(W_5)=0$, and the four slots give $\gamma_{ab}(\omega_{abc}-\omega_{ac,a}+\omega_{ac,b})+\gamma_{ac}(\omega_{abc}-\omega_{ab,a}+\omega_{ab,c}) -\gamma_{ab}(\omega_{abc}+\omega_{ac,b}-\omega_{ac,a})+\gamma_{ac}(-\omega_{abc}-\omega_{ab,c}+\omega_{ab,a})=0$; before cancelling, the part with $\omega_{abc}$ is $(\gamma_{ab}-\gamma_{ac})(\omega_{acb}-\omega_{abc})$, which is $0$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:diag31}(b). \end{proof} The identities of Propositions~\ref{prop:hab31} and~\ref{prop:aabc31} are proved at regular diagonal points; both sides are polynomials in $x$, so they hold at every diagonal point. Proposition~\ref{prop:divis31} uses only the polynomial identity $\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[\varkappa_{ab}]+\mathcal{Q}_{acb}[\varkappa_{ac}]\equiv0$ on $\mathbb{C}^n$ and the recursion of Lemma~\ref{lem:indicial31}. \begin{lemma}[local form]\label{lem:local31} Fix a point $P_0$ with $x_a=x_b=x_c=t_0$ (the other $x$ fixed), put $\bar x_p:=x_p-t_0$ for $p\in\{a,b,c\}$, $q:=\bar x_a-\bar x_b$ and $z:=\bar x_c-(\bar x_a+\bar x_b)/2$. Then $\mathcal{Q}_{abc}$ has coefficients homogeneous of degree $0$ in $(\bar x_a,\bar x_b,\bar x_c)$, maps functions of $(q,z)$ to functions of $(q,z)$, and \[ \mathcal{Q}_{abc}[q^jz^l]=(l-s)(j+3)\,q^jz^l+\tfrac l2(3s-j-l)\,q^{j+1}z^{l-1}+\tfrac{l(l-1)}4\,q^{j+2}z^{l-2}. \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} $\partial_a=\partial_q-\frac12\partial_z$ and $\partial_c=\partial_z$ on such functions, $3x_c-2x_a-x_b=3z-q/2$ and $x_a-x_c=q/2-z$; expand. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:divis31} Let $s=m\ge1$ be an integer, and suppose that $\varphi$ passes the tests at $s$. Then for every $c\notin\{a,b\}$ the coefficient $\varkappa_{2m}$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:indicial31}(b) (a polynomial on the hyperplane $x_a=x_b$, in $r$ and the other $x$) is divisible by $(x_c-r)^m$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Induction on $p=0,\dots,m-1$: suppose $\varkappa_{2m}=(x_c-r)^pU_c$. At any point $P_0$ of $\{x_c=r\}$ (on $x_a=x_b$) let $\zeta:=U_c(P_0)$, and put $\Upsilon_p:=\sum_i\upsilon_i\,\frac{p!}{(p-2i)!}\,q^{2m+2i}z^{p-2i}$ with the $\upsilon_i$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:indicial31}(b). With $z=x_c-r$ and $\partial_rz=-1$, $\partial_r^{2i}(z^pU_c)=\frac{p!}{(p-2i)!}z^{p-2i}U_c+(\text{terms of order}>p-2i\text{ at }P_0)$, and for $2i>p$ every term has order at least $0$; so $q^{2m+2i}\varkappa_{2m+2i}$ has order at least $2m+p$ at $P_0$, and the part of $\varkappa_{ab}$ of degree $2m+p$ in $(\bar x_a,\bar x_b,\bar x_c)$ is $\zeta\Upsilon_p(q,z)$. As $\sigma_{bc}$ fixes $P_0$ and $\varkappa_{ac}(x)=\varkappa_{ab}(\sigma_{bc}x)$, the part of $\varkappa_{ac}$ is $\zeta\Upsilon_p(q',z')$ with $q'=\bar x_a-\bar x_c$, $z'=\bar x_b-(\bar x_a+\bar x_c)/2$. As $\mathcal{Q}$ preserves degrees, Proposition~\ref{prop:aabc31} gives $\zeta\,[\tilde\Upsilon_p(q,z)+\tilde\Upsilon_p(q',z')]=0$ with $\tilde\Upsilon_p:=\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[\Upsilon_p]$. In the coordinates $u:=q$, $v:=q'$ we have $z=u/2-v$ and $z'=v/2-u$. Every monomial of $\tilde\Upsilon_p$ has $q$-degree at least $2m$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:local31}), so $\tilde\Upsilon_p(v,v/2-u)$ has no term $v^h$ with $h<2m$, and the coefficient of $v^h$ in the sum is $\frac{(-1)^h}{h!}\partial_z^h\tilde\Upsilon_p(u,u/2)$. As $p<2m$, these $h$ cover the $z$-degree of $\tilde\Upsilon_p$, so $\zeta\ne0$ would force $\tilde\Upsilon_p\equiv0$. But the coefficient of $q^{2m}z^p$ in $\tilde\Upsilon_p$ is $(p-m)(2m+3)\ne0$ (only the monomial $q^{2m}z^p$ of $\Upsilon_p$ contributes, by Lemma~\ref{lem:local31}). So $\zeta=0$ at every point of $\{x_c=r\}$, $U_c$ is divisible by $x_c-r$, and the induction goes on. \end{proof} At $p=m$ the coefficient $(p-m)(2m+3)$ is $0$, and in fact $\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[\Upsilon_m]\equiv0$ (for instance $\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[q^2z]=0$ for $m=1$ and $\mathcal{Q}_{abc}[q^4z^2+q^6/36]=0$ for $m=2$), so the method gives no factor $(x_c-r)^{m+1}$; it is not needed. \begin{corollary}\label{cor:deg31} In the situation of Proposition~\ref{prop:divis31}, if $\tau_2-1\tau_2-1$, then $\varkappa\equiv0$ by Corollary~\ref{cor:deg31}. Then Lemma~\ref{lem:cartan31} applies. For $n=3$ it applies for every $s$. \end{proof} Here $\mu=ns-d+3$ with $d=\tau_2+2$, as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:firstlayer31}; the theorem is a containment, and it does not say that the allowed values occur. \begin{corollary}[every exponent $s$]\label{cor:allexp31} Let $n\ge3$, let $s\ge1$ be an integer, and let $\tau\vdash ns$ be a partition with four rows and $\tau_3=\tau_4=1$. Then no nonzero polynomial $f$ on $M_n^4$, homogeneous of degree $\tau_j$ in $P_j$, a highest weight vector for $\mathrm{GL}_4$ (as in the definition of $\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$), with $f(gPh^T)=\det(g)^s\det(h)^sf(P)$, passes the three tests at every $P$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} $f(gP)=\det(g)^sf(P)$, so $f=\det(P_1)^s\varphi_f((P_1^{-1}P_j)_0)$ with $\varphi_f:=f(I,\cdot,\cdot,\cdot)\in\mathrm{HW}_{(\tau_2,1,1)}$, and $f\mapsto\varphi_f$ is injective (the set $\det P_1\ne0$ is dense); thus $f=f_s$ for $\varphi_f$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:content31} (whose proof is pointwise and holds for such $f$), the tests at $P=(I,A)$ say $\Omega_A\circ(C+2)=0$. For such $\tau$, $\tau_1=ns-d\ge\tau_2$, so $\mu=ns-\tau_2+1=\tau_1+3\ge\tau_2+3>0$, while Theorem~\ref{thm:L131} needs $\mu\le0$ for $s\ne0$. So $\varphi_f=0$ and $f=0$. \end{proof} This is a statement on functions for every $s$; a statement on multiplicities for $n\times s$ rectangles would need the rectangle form of Theorem~\ref{thm:cornerdictall}, which we do not claim. \begin{corollary}[two-row types]\label{cor:tworow31} For every $n\ge3$, $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ has no conjugation type $\kappa$ with $\kappa'=(N-j,j)$, $0\le j\le N/2$, and neither has $K_{\lambda(2,1,1)}$. \end{corollary} \begin{proof} By Theorem~\ref{thm:cornerdictall}, a copy of $\kappa$ gives a nonzero $f\in\mathrm{Pol}_\tau$, $\tau=\kappa'+(1^4)=(N-j+1,j+1,1,1)$, that passes the three tests. By Theorem~\ref{thm:cornerdict}(c), $f\mapsto\varphi_f$ is injective for every $n$ (the hypothesis $d\le n$ of the bijection is not used) and $f=f_n$, and by Lemma~\ref{lem:content31} the tests at $P=(I,A)$ say $\Omega_A\circ(C+2)=0$ at $s=n$. Here $\tau_2=j+1$ and $\tau_1=n^2-j-3\ge\tau_2$, so $\mu=n^2-\tau_2+1=\tau_1+3>0$, and $s=n$ is not exceptional in Theorem~\ref{thm:L131}: $\varphi_f=0$. No hypothesis $n\ge d$ is used. For $K_{\lambda(2,1,1)}$ see the last paragraph of the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:B31}. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:L131} (1) Against Corollary~\ref{cor:B31} ($1\le j\le n-3$, $n\ge4$) this adds every depth, the case $n=3$, and Corollary~\ref{cor:allexp31} for every $s$. The parallel for the main block ($k=3$) is Theorem~\ref{thm:firstlayer}: there $\eta$ is a $1$-form, so at a diagonal point it has only a Cartan part, and the argument of Lemma~\ref{lem:cartan31} for $2$-forms on $\mathfrak t$ gives ``no eigenvalue other than $(d-2)/n$''. Consistency: for $\tau_2=1$ ($\tau=(1,1,1)$, Theorem~\ref{thm:L31}(a)) one may take $\varkappa=1$, and the row $h^{ab}$ gives $-12s=0$; for $\tau_2=2$, $\Omega_A(h^{ab})=-12s(x_a+x_b)$ at traceless $x$. (2) Context, not used. Corollary~\ref{cor:indicial31}(b) says that $\eta_{ab}=x_{ab}\varkappa_{ab}$, which is odd under $x_a\leftrightarrow x_b$, vanishes to order $2m+1$ on $x_a=x_b$: the condition of $m$-quasi-invariance of Chalykh and Veselov at that wall \cite{CV90}. The bound $\tau_2\ge nm+1$ of Corollary~\ref{cor:deg31} is the lowest degree of the nonconstant $m$-harmonic polynomials of $S_n$ \cite[\S4.5]{FV03}, equivalently (by the freeness theorem of \cite{EG02}) of the non-symmetric $m$-quasi-invariants; $x_1+\dots+x_n$ is a symmetric one of degree $1$. (3) Not covered: the types with $\tau_3\ge2$ (the rest of the first layer and the deeper layers; for depth at most $6$ see Subsection~\ref{subsec:shallow31}). Not claimed: that the allowed values of Theorem~\ref{thm:L131} occur. The proof uses only the rows $h^{ab}$, the rows $\{a,a,b,c\}$ and one row with four distinct indices, at diagonal points: on $\{a,a,b,c\}$ only $\alpha=(3,1),(2,2),(2,1,1)$ occur, so $T_1+T_3+T_5=0$ is a combination of the conditions of the corners $(1,3)$ and $(2,2)$, and the corner $(4,1)$ enters only through $\sum_\pi\Omega_A(w_\pi)=0$ in Lemma~\ref{lem:cartan31}. No bound on $d(n)$ follows by itself. \end{remark} \subsection{Three- and four-row types of depth at most $6$}\label{subsec:shallow31} We keep $\nu=(3,1)$, $k=4$, $N=n^2-4$ and the notation of Subsections~\ref{subsec:firstlayer31}--\ref{subsec:L131}. Corollary~\ref{cor:tworow31} removes the two-row types (depth $0$ and the one-row tails) for every $n\ge3$. Here we remove the types with $\kappa'=(N-|t|,t)$ for the sixteen tails $t$ with two or three parts and $|t|\le6$, \[ \begin{array}{ll} |t|\le4: & (1,1),\ (2,1),\ (1,1,1),\ (3,1),\ (2,2),\ (2,1,1);\\ |t|=5: & (4,1),\ (3,2),\ (3,1,1),\ (2,2,1);\\ |t|=6: & (5,1),\ (4,2),\ (3,3),\ (4,1,1),\ (3,2,1),\ (2,2,2), \end{array} \] for $n\ge|t|+3$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:shallow31}). As $\kappa'$ has at most four rows (Corollary~\ref{cor:casimir}(a): $\kappa_1\le k=4$), the tails of depth at most $6$ are the empty tail, the one-row tails $(j)$ and these sixteen; so no type of depth at most $4$ occurs in $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ or $K_{\lambda(2,1,1)}$ for $n\ge7$, none of depth at most $5$ for $n\ge8$, and none of depth at most $6$ for $n\ge9$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:shallow31}(b)). The chain is that of Corollary~\ref{cor:B31}, with its step (1) replaced: the injectivity of $\mathcal{Z}$ on the formal $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ at the sixteen weights $\tau=t+(1,1,1)$ (a two-part $t$ is padded with a $0$, so $(4,1)$ gives $(5,2,1)$) comes from an exact computer-assisted certificate (Theorem~\ref{thm:cert31}). So that the computer checks $\mathcal{Z}$ itself, Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} rewrites $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi)=0$, for $n\ge d+1$, in the $n$-free basis as finitely many linear equations on the coefficient function of $\varphi$. \emph{The coefficient function.} Let $\tau=(\tau_2,\tau_3,\tau_4)$ be a weight, $d=\tau_2+\tau_3+\tau_4$, and write $[d]=\mathsf{A}\sqcup\mathsf{B}\sqcup\mathsf{C}$ with $|\mathsf{A}|=\tau_2$, $|\mathsf{B}|=\tau_3$, $|\mathsf{C}|=\tau_4$, and $X_c=A_2,A_3,A_4$ for $c\in\mathsf{A},\mathsf{B},\mathsf{C}$. As in the chart paragraph of Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair} and the formal model of Subsection~\ref{subsec:test311}, every $\varphi\in\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ is $\varphi_g=\sum_\sigma g(\sigma)\operatorname{tr}_\sigma$ for a function $g$ on the derangements of $S_d$, invariant under conjugation by $S_{\mathsf{A}}\times S_{\mathsf{B}}\times S_{\mathsf{C}}$ and unique for $n\ge d$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:indep5}); the highest weight conditions are \[ \text{(HW)}\qquad g+\textstyle\sum_{a\in\mathsf{X}}g^{(a\,b)}=0\quad\text{for every pair of colours }\mathsf{X}<\mathsf{Y}\text{ and every }b\in\mathsf{Y}, \] with $g^{(a\,b)}(\sigma):=g((a\,b)\,\sigma\,(a\,b))$: the operator that turns one letter $b$ of colour $\mathsf{Y}$ into colour $\mathsf{X}$, symmetrized over the cosets $e$, $(a\,b)$ of $S_{\mathsf{X}}$ in $S_{\mathsf{X}\cup\{b\}}$, as $g$ is $S_{\mathsf{X}}$-invariant. \begin{lemma}[the permutation form of $\mathcal{Z}$]\label{lem:perm31} Let $n\ge d+1$. Fix cut letters $i\in\mathsf{A}$, $j\in\mathsf{B}$, $l\in\mathsf{C}$, add a letter $0$, and put $Q:=\{0,i,j,l\}$. For $\pi\in S_{\{0\}\cup[d]}$ put $\hat g(\pi):=g(\pi|_{[d]})$ if $\pi(0)=0$ and $\hat g(\pi):=0$ otherwise, and $z(\pi):=\sum_{\beta\in S_Q}\sgn(\beta)\,\hat g(\beta^{-1}\pi\beta)$; products are $\varsigma\pi:=\varsigma\circ\pi$. Let $T:=\tr\wedge\omega_{\varphi_g}$ with the formal derivatives (Lemma~\ref{lem:lead5} for $k=4$), so that $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi_g)=T\circ\Pi_{\ne\nu'}$. Then $\mathcal{Z}(\varphi_g)=0$ in the $n$-free basis of the targets if and only if \[ \textstyle\sum_\varsigma z(\varsigma\pi)+2z(\pi)=0\qquad\text{for every }\pi\in S_{\{0\}\cup[d]}\text{ with no fixed point outside }Q, \] where $\varsigma$ runs over the six transpositions of $Q$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) Evaluate $T$ on rank-one arguments $B_q=u_qy_q^T$, $q\in Q$, with $B_0$ the trace slot. Polarizing $\varphi_g$ once in each colour replaces one letter of each colour by an argument. By the invariance of $g$ all cut triples give the same contribution up to the factor $\tau_2\tau_3\tau_4$; this factor and the nonzero normalization of $\omega$ are common to all $\pi$, so they do not affect the equations, and one may fix the cut $(i,j,l)$. As $g$ lives on derangements, the only trace factor of an argument is slot $0$, as the fixed letter $0$; this is the formal $\mathcal{Z}$ of Lemma~\ref{lem:lead5} (for $k=4$), with no projections. A permutation $\pi$ of $\{0\}\cup[d]$ then contributes the monomial \[ \mathbf{m}_\pi:=\prod_{q\in Q}\bigl(y_q^TW_qu_{\pi^+(q)}\bigr)\cdot\prod_{\text{cycles of }\pi\text{ avoiding }Q}\tr(\text{word in the }X_c), \] where $W_q$ is the word in the $X_c$ after $q$ and $\pi^+(q)$ is the next letter of $Q$. The alternation over the four argument slots relabels $Q$ by $\beta\in S_Q$ and sends $\pi$ to $\beta^{-1}\pi\beta$, which gives the coefficient $z(\pi)$. Monomials with a fixed point outside $Q$ contain the trace of a traceless letter, which is $0$. (b) $T$ is multilinear in each $B_q$, and the rank-one matrices span $M_n$. Lemma~\ref{lem:indep5} applies with $d-3$ traceless letters and $4$ letters in $M_n$, that is, $d+1$ slots, and $d+1\le n$. So distinct $\pi$ with no fixed point outside $Q$ give linearly independent monomials (after $X=Y-\tr(Y)I/n$ each extra term has an extra fixed point outside $Q$, so the system is triangular). Setting the letters of one colour equal again identifies $\pi$ with its orbit under $S_{\mathsf{A}\setminus i}\times S_{\mathsf{B}\setminus j}\times S_{\mathsf{C}\setminus l}$, and distinct orbits give independent orbit sums. The left side of each equation is constant on an orbit, as $g$ is invariant, so the coefficient of an orbit sum is the size of the orbit times one equation. (c) By the last two sentences of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:content31}, which are algebra in the centre of $F[S_4]$ valid for every alternating $4$-form, $T\circ\Pi_{\ne\nu'}=0$ if and only if $T\circ(C+2)=0$: $C$ acts on the summand $\alpha$ by $c(\alpha)$, the five contents are distinct, and $(2,1,1)$ is the only partition of $4$ with content $-2$. Exchanging $u_p$ and $u_q$ in $\mathbf{m}_\pi$ gives $\mathbf{m}_{\varsigma\pi}$ with $\varsigma=(p\,q)$, so $T\circ C=\sum_\pi\bigl(\sum_\varsigma z(\varsigma\pi)\bigr)\mathbf{m}_\pi$. By (b), $T\circ(C+2)=0$ if and only if every coefficient $\sum_\varsigma z(\varsigma\pi)+2z(\pi)$ vanishes. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:perm31} (1) The side does not matter. Exchanging $y_p$ and $y_q$ instead corresponds to $\pi\varsigma$. As $z(\beta^{-1}\pi\beta)=\sgn(\beta)z(\pi)$, we have $z(\pi\varsigma)=-z(\varsigma\pi)$, so the test with $+2$ on that side is the test with $-2$ on this one. Moreover $\varphi\mapsto\varphi^T$ maps $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ onto itself and turns $T\circ(C+2)$ into $-(T\circ(C-2))^T$ (as in (iii) of the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:K31}). So $\dim(\ker\mathcal{Z}\cap\mathrm{HW}_\tau)$ does not depend on the side; compare Remark~\ref{rem:zinj31}(3). (2) On each coset $S_Q\pi$ the equations say that $\sum_{\gamma\in S_Q}z(\gamma\pi)[\gamma]$ lies in the $(2,1,1)$-isotypic ideal of $F[S_4]$. This is not used. \end{remark} \begin{theorem}[computer-assisted]\label{thm:cert31} For each of the sixteen weights $\tau$: $(2,2,1)$, $(3,2,1)$, $(2,2,2)$, $(4,2,1)$, $(3,3,1)$, $(3,2,2)$ ($d\le7$); $(5,2,1)$, $(4,3,1)$, $(4,2,2)$, $(3,3,2)$ ($d=8$); $(6,2,1)$, $(5,3,1)$, $(5,2,2)$, $(4,4,1)$, $(4,3,2)$, $(3,3,3)$ ($d=9$), $\mathcal{Z}$ is injective on the formal $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$: the equations of Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} together with (HW) have only the solution $g=0$. (This holds also for $(4,1,1)$ and $(5,1,1)$, where Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj31} and the paragraph after it already give it.) \end{theorem} \begin{proof} An exact computation, as in the paragraph on computations in Subsection~\ref{subsec:window}. The columns of the matrix are the orbits of the derangements $\sigma\in S_d$ under conjugation by $S_{\mathsf{A}}\times S_{\mathsf{B}}\times S_{\mathsf{C}}$; the rows are the equations of Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} for one cut (the first letter of each colour), over all $\pi\in S_{d+1}$ with no fixed point outside $Q$, and the rows (HW) for the pairs of colours $(\mathsf{A},\mathsf{B})$, $(\mathsf{B},\mathsf{C})$, $(\mathsf{A},\mathsf{C})$, with one $b$ for each pair, at every derangement $\sigma$. The matrix has integer entries (each row of Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} is $\sum_\varsigma z(\varsigma\pi)+2z(\pi)$ with every $z(\cdot)$ a sum of entries $\pm1$, and each row (HW) is a sum of entries $1$) and full column rank modulo the prime $p=2^{61}-1$; as the rank over $\mathbb{Q}$ is at least the rank modulo $p$, it has full column rank over $\mathbb{Q}$. The numbers of columns are $12,27,42,51,64,92$ for the six weights of $d\le7$ in the order of the statement, and $\dim\mathrm{HW}_\tau=1,4,5,12,8,8$; for the four weights of $d=8$ they are $93,138,206,252$ ($\dim\mathrm{HW}_\tau=25,24,27,12$), and for the six weights of $d=9$ they are $157,266,386,316,586,756$ ($\dim\mathrm{HW}_\tau=46,66,52,32,59,20$). \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:cert31} Independent computations, not used in the proof. (1) The dimensions of the $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ agree with a computation by characters (Murnaghan--Nakayama) at $15$ weights. (2) With (HW) the kernel is $0$ also for the kept content $+2$ (the other side); without (HW) it is $4,6,8,25,19,31,36,44$ at $(2,1,1)$, $(3,1,1)$, $(2,2,1)$, $(2,2,2)$, $(3,2,1)$, $(4,2,1)$, $(3,3,1)$, $(3,2,2)$, for both contents. So (HW) is what kills the kernel. (3) A numerical evaluation of $T\circ(C\pm2)$ at random integer points ($n=d+1$, modulo the prime $2^{26}-5$) has the same row space as the equations of Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} at $(2,1,1)$, $(2,2,1)$, $(3,1,1)$, $(2,2,2)$, for both pairings (the shift $+2$ with the kept content $-2$, and $-2$ with $+2$); with (HW) both kernels are $0$. (4) A direct certificate without Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} (numerical rows of $\mathcal{Z}$ and of (HW) at $n=d+1$, shift $\pm2$) gives kernel $0$ at $(2,2,2)$, $(3,2,1)$, $(4,2,1)$, $(3,3,1)$, $(3,2,2)$, and numerical $\mathrm{HW}$ kernels $5,4,12,8,8$. (5) A second program gives kernel $0$ at $(2,2,1)$ and $(2,2,2)$. A third program builds $\mathcal{Z}$ from the definition at size $n$ ($n=4,\dots,7$, modulo the prime $999983$, on the grids of the live corners) and gives $\dim(\ker\mathcal{Z}\cap\mathrm{HW}_\tau(n))=0$ at $(2,2,1)$, $(2,2,2)$, $(3,2,1)$, $(2,1,1)$, $(3,1,1)$ (a proof at the $n$ where it finds no zero functions, among them $(2,2,1)$ for $n=5,6,7$ and $(2,2,2)$, $(3,2,1)$ for $n=6,7$); its kernels without (HW) at $n=d+1$ agree with (2). (6) At the ten weights of $d=8,9$: the dimensions of the $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ agree with a computation by characters; with (HW) the kernel is $0$ also for the kept content $+2$ at the four weights of $d=8$ and at $(6,2,1)$; without (HW) it is $57,78,94,104$ at $(5,2,1)$, $(4,3,1)$, $(4,2,2)$, $(3,3,2)$ and $91$ at $(6,2,1)$, for both contents. The second program of (5), in the formal ($n$-free) model and modulo the prime $1000003$, gives $\ker\mathcal{Z}\cap\mathrm{HW}_\tau=0$ at all ten weights, for both blocks, with the same dimensions of $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$; with the corner $(4,1)$ alone its kernels are not $0$ ($22,20,19,7$ at $d=8$ and $39,51,32,23,31,10$ at $d=9$, in the order of the statement). \end{remark} \begin{corollary}\label{cor:shallow31} \begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*),leftmargin=*] \item Let $t$ be one of the sixteen tails with two or three parts and $|t|\le6$ (listed at the start of this subsection) and $n\ge|t|+3$. The conjugation type $\kappa$ with $\kappa'=(N-|t|,t)$ does not occur in $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$, nor in $K_{\lambda(2,1,1)}$. \item $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ and $K_{\lambda(2,1,1)}$ have no type of depth at most $4$ for $n\ge7$, no type of depth at most $5$ for $n\ge8$, and no type of depth at most $6$ for $n\ge9$. \end{enumerate} \end{corollary} \begin{proof} (a) As for Corollary~\ref{cor:B31}. Here $\tau=\kappa'+(1^4)$, so $(\tau_2,\tau_3,\tau_4)=t+(1,1,1)$ and $d=|t|+3$. (1) $\mathcal{Z}$ is injective on the formal $\mathrm{HW}_\tau$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:cert31}, through Lemma~\ref{lem:perm31} at any $n\ge d+1$). This replaces the route of step (1) of Corollary~\ref{cor:B31} through one $n_1$ and Theorem~\ref{thm:zinj31}. (2) So $\kappa$ does not occur in $K_{\lambda(3,1)}$ for all but finitely many $n$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:largen5} for $k=4$, as in the paragraph on the leading term for $k=4$ in Subsection~\ref{subsec:zinj31}). (3) Step (3) of the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:B31} holds for every tail $t$: nothing in it uses the number of parts of $t$. Written out, for $n\ge m+3$ the character of $K^{[m]}_{\lambda(3,1)}$, twisted by the sign, is \[ \textstyle\sum_{|t'|14$). Theorem~\ref{thm:samoilov22} (Subsection~\ref{subsec:computed}; computer-assisted) answers (a): the conjectured value holds at $(2,2)$. The last problem is a conjecture about single blocks. For a self-conjugate $\lambda$ let $h(\lambda)=(h_{11},\dots,h_{dd})$ be its diagonal hook lengths, as in Frobenius' theorem in Section~\ref{sec:B}; here $d$ is the size of the Durfee square, the $h_{ii}$ are distinct odd numbers, and $h_{ii}=2(\lambda_i-i)+1$. \begin{conjecture}\label{conj:D} Let $\lambda=\lambda'$. Then $U_\lambda\ne0$ if and only if $h_{ii}-h_{i+1,i+1}\ge4$ for $1\le i\lambda_2>\dots>\lambda_d$. \end{conjecture} The two forms agree since $h_{ii}-h_{i+1,i+1}=2(\lambda_i-\lambda_{i+1})+2$. Call such a $\lambda$ a \emph{gap shape}. \begin{remark}[what Conjecture~\ref{conj:D} would give]\label{rem:conjD} A gap shape $\lambda$ inside the $n\times n$ box has $|\lambda|\le n(n+1)/2$, with equality only for $\mathrm{St}_n$. Indeed $h_{11}\le2n-1$, so $h_{ii}\le2n+3-4i$; the diagonal hooks partition the cells of $\lambda$, so $|\lambda|=\sum_ih_{ii}$ is at most the sum of the positive numbers $2n+3-4i$, which are the diagonal hook lengths of $\mathrm{St}_n$; and equality forces $h(\lambda)=h(\mathrm{St}_n)$, hence $\lambda=\mathrm{St}_n$. So Conjecture~\ref{conj:D} implies $U_\lambda=0$ for every shape $\lambda$ inside the box with $|\lambda|>n(n+1)/2$ (for $\lambda\ne\lambda'$ this holds anyway, by Proposition~\ref{prop:signtwist}): Kuzmin's conjecture block by block. It does not give $d(n)$, since Formanek's criterion is joint (Proposition~\ref{prop:criterion}); but it implies the hypothesis of Theorem~\ref{thm:E} for $n\ge4$ and statement (iii) in the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:F} for $n\ge4$ (neither shape is a gap shape, as each has two equal rows inside its Durfee square, and both have more than $n(n+1)/2$ cells), though not the kernel statement (ii). It agrees with every block result of this paper. A self-conjugate rectangle is a square $(m^m)$; for $m\ge2$ it has equal rows and $U=0$ (Remark~\ref{rem:rectangles}), and $U_{(1)}=C_1\ne0$. A self-conjugate shape with two corners is a hook ($d=1$) or $((u+v)^u,u^v)$ with $u\ge2$, which has $\lambda_1=\lambda_2$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:D}). The shapes $A_k$ have $h=(2k+1,1)$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:Dthree}), and the staircases have all gaps equal to $4$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:staircase}): they are the extreme gap shapes. Of the $27$ self-conjugate partitions of $N\le15$, these results and $d(4)=10$ decide $22$, all as the conjecture predicts; the other five are open: $(5,3,2,1,1)$, $(6,3,2,1^3)$ and $(5,4,2,2,1)$, predicted $U\ne0$, and $(5,3,3,1,1)$ and $(6,3,3,1^3)$, predicted $U=0$. In the language of Section~\ref{sec:PI}: for $a\le b$, the smallest gap shape containing $\Xi_{a,b}$ has size $(a+1)(2b+1)$. Indeed a gap shape $\mu\supseteq\Xi_{a,b}$ has $d\ge a+1$ and $\mu_{a+1}\ge b+1$, so $\mu_i\ge a+b+2-i$ and $h_{ii}\ge2(a+b+2-2i)+1$ for $i\le a+1$, and these $a+1$ hooks sum to $(a+1)(2b+1)$; the shape with exactly these diagonal hooks contains $\Xi_{a,b}$ (it is $\mathrm{St}_{a+b+1}$ when $b-a\le1$). So, by Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg}, Conjecture~\ref{conj:D} predicts an identity of $M_{a,b}(\Lambda)$ of degree $(a+1)(2b+1)-1$, which is Samoilov's theorem. The lower half of Samoilov's conjecture is a joint statement over all $\mu\supseteq\Xi_{a,b}$ and does not follow from Conjecture~\ref{conj:D}. \end{remark} For each fixed $k$, the reduction of Theorem~\ref{thm:F} (Corollary~\ref{cor:program} for $k>5$) leads to finitely many patterns, but their number grows fast with $k$ (Remark~\ref{rem:table}), and no one-shape argument passes $k=S(n)-1$ (Corollary~\ref{cor:ceiling}). A saving that grows with $n$ therefore needs statements that are uniform in the shape. Conjecture~\ref{conj:D} is one such statement for single blocks, and Samoilov's conjecture, through Theorem~\ref{thm:H}, is another for one algebra at a time. \subsection{Two computed cases}\label{subsec:computed} This subsection proves Conjecture~\ref{conj:B} at $(n,s)=(6,6)$ for $74$ of its $107$ types (Theorem~\ref{thm:Ksixsix}) and answers Problem~\ref{prob:samoilov}(a) (Theorem~\ref{thm:samoilov22}); both proofs are computer-assisted. The method of Theorem~\ref{thm:Ksixsix} treats one $\mathrm{GL}_3$-weight space at a time. Let $\mathrm{Inv}_s(n)$ be the space of the $\mathrm{SL}_n\times\mathrm{SL}_n$-invariant polynomials on $M_n^3$ of total degree $ns$ (with $\mathrm{GL}_3$ acting as in Subsection~\ref{subsec:matrixpair}), $\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)$ its subspace cut out by (S1) and (S2), and, for partitions $\tau,\tau_0$ with at most three rows, $\mathrm{Kos}(\tau,\tau_0)$ the Kostka number, the multiplicity of the weight $\tau_0$ in the $\mathrm{GL}_3$-module $V_\tau$; it is positive if and only if $\tau$ dominates $\tau_0$, $\tau\trianglerighteq\tau_0$. \begin{lemma}[weight spaces]\label{lem:WS} $\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)$ is a $\mathrm{GL}_3$-submodule of $\mathrm{Inv}_s(n)$, and for every weight $\tau_0$, \[ \dim\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)_{\tau_0}=\sum_\tau\dim\mathrm{K}_s(n)_\tau\cdot\mathrm{Kos}(\tau,\tau_0), \] the sum over the partitions $\tau$ of $ns$ with at most three rows. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} (a) $\Omega_uf(P)=\sum_{\sigma\in S_3}\operatorname{sgn}(\sigma)\,D^3f(P)[uy_{\sigma(1)}^T\otimes e_1,uy_{\sigma(2)}^T\otimes e_2,uy_{\sigma(3)}^T\otimes e_3]$, where $D^3f(P)$ is the third derivative (a symmetric trilinear form) and $X\otimes e_a$ puts $X$ in slot $a$. (b) Put $F(y_1,y_2,y_3;v_1,v_2,v_3):=D^3f(P)[uy_1^T\otimes v_1, uy_2^T\otimes v_2,uy_3^T\otimes v_3]$ for row vectors $v_a\in\mathbb{C}^3$; here, for $v=(\nu_1,\nu_2,\nu_3)$, $X\otimes v:=(\nu_1X,\nu_2X,\nu_3X)$. $F$ is trilinear in $(v_1,v_2,v_3)$ and invariant under permuting the pairs $(y_a,v_a)$, as $D^3f(P)$ is symmetric. So $\operatorname{Alt}_yF(y;v):=\sum_\sigma\operatorname{sgn}(\sigma) F(y_{\sigma(1)},y_{\sigma(2)},y_{\sigma(3)};v_1,v_2,v_3)$ satisfies $\operatorname{Alt}_yF(y;v_{\pi(1)},v_{\pi(2)},v_{\pi(3)})=\operatorname{sgn}(\pi)\operatorname{Alt}_yF(y;v)$: it is an alternating trilinear form in $(v_1,v_2,v_3)$, so $\operatorname{Alt}_yF(y;e_1g,e_2g,e_3g)=\det(g)\operatorname{Alt}_yF(y;e_1,e_2,e_3)$. (c) $\mathrm{Inv}_s(n)$ is $\mathrm{GL}_3$-stable (the action commutes with $\mathrm{SL}_n\times\mathrm{SL}_n$ and keeps the total degree), and \[ D^3(g.f)(P)[X_a\otimes e_a]=D^3f(Pg)[X_a\otimes e_ag]; \] by (b), $\Omega_u(g.f)(P)=\det(g)\,\Omega_uf(Pg)$, and the same holds for (S2) with the updates $y_au^T$ (only the trilinearity and the pair symmetry are used). So $\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)$ is a $\mathrm{GL}_3$-submodule; this is the classical identity behind the Cayley $\Omega$-process (compare Lemma~\ref{lem:Vmodule}(c), its Lie algebra form for (S1) on $\mathcal{V}_s$). (d) $\mathrm{GL}_3$ is reductive, so $\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)=\bigoplus_\tau M_\tau\otimes V_\tau$ with $M_\tau$ the highest weight vectors of weight $\tau$ in $\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)$, that is $\mathrm{K}_s(n)_\tau$; take the weight space $\tau_0$. (The tests are linear conditions with rational coefficients, so the dimensions over $\mathbb{Q}$ and $\mathbb{C}$ agree.) \end{proof} If $\tau_3=0$, then $\mathrm{K}_s(n)_\tau$ is all of $\mathrm{R}_s(n)_\tau$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(iii), and its dimension is $g((s^n),(s^n),\tau)$ by Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(i). Also $\dim\mathrm{K}_s(n)_{(ns-4,2,2)}=1$ for $n\ge3$ and $s\ge4$ (Theorem~\ref{thm:pencil22}), and $\mathrm{Kos}((ns-4,2,2),\tau_0)$ is $1$ if $\tau_0\trianglelefteq(ns-4,2,2)$ and $0$ otherwise (in a semistandard tableau of this shape row $3$ is $(3,3)$ and row $2$ is $(2,2)$). So, with $T(\tau_0):=\sum_{\tau_3=0}g((s^n),(s^n),\tau)\,\mathrm{Kos}(\tau,\tau_0)$ (the two-row part), \begin{equation}\label{eq:WSlower} \dim\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_s(n)_{\tau_0}\ge T(\tau_0)+\mathrm{Kos}((ns-4,2,2),\tau_0), \end{equation} with equality if and only if $\mathrm{K}_s(n)_\tau=0$ for every three-row $\tau\trianglerighteq\tau_0$ other than $(ns-4,2,2)$. \begin{theorem}[computer-assisted]\label{thm:Ksixsix} Let $n=s=6$. For every $\tau\vdash36$ with exactly three rows, $\tau\ne(32,2,2)$, and $\tau_1\ge22$ or $\tau_3\le5$, $\mathrm{K}_6(6)_\tau=0$ ($74$ types; at $(32,2,2)$ the space is a line, Theorem~\ref{thm:pencil22}). Equivalently (Lemma~\ref{lem:rectangle}(iii), Theorem~\ref{thm:matrixpair}), among the conjugation types $\kappa$ of $K_{B(6,2)}$ with $\tau=\kappa'+(1,1,1)$ satisfying $\tau_1\ge22$ (depth at most $12$) or $\tau_3\le5$ ($\kappa'_3\le4$), only $(3,1^{30})$ occurs, once. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} For three-row $\tau\vdash36$: $\tau\trianglerighteq(22,7,7)$ if and only if $\tau_1\ge22$ (then $\tau_3\le7$, so $\tau_1+\tau_2\ge29$), and $\tau\trianglerighteq(16,15,5)$ if and only if $\tau_3\le5$ ($\tau_1+\tau_2\ge31$ forces $\tau_1\ge16$). At these two weights the computed upper bound below equals the lower bound \eqref{eq:WSlower}, so Lemma~\ref{lem:WS} gives the claim: \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{cccccc} $\tau_0$ & $\dim\mathrm{Inv}_6(6)_{\tau_0}$ & $T(\tau_0)$ & $\mathrm{Kos}((32,2,2),\tau_0)$ & lower bound & computed\\\hline $(22,7,7)$ & $4796$ & $212$ & $1$ & $213$ & $213$\\ $(16,16,4)$ & $4320$ & $271$ & $1$ & $272$ & $272$\\ $(16,15,5)$ & $9209$ & $317$ & $1$ & $318$ & $318$ \end{tabular} \end{center} (the weight $(16,16,4)$, which settles $\tau_3\le4$, is a second certificate for the $20$ types with $\tau_1\le21$, $\tau_3\le4$). \emph{The computed upper bound.} The program draws $nb=D+12$ determinantal invariants ($D$ the rank below) $g_T(P)=[z^{\tau_0}]\det(\sum_az_aT_a\otimes P_a)$, $T_a\in M_6(\mathbb{Z})$, $T_1=I$; each $g_T$ has integer coefficients and lies in $\mathrm{Inv}_6(6)_{\tau_0}$. Their evaluation matrix at random points has rank $D$ modulo $p=999983$, so $\dim\mathrm{Inv}_6(6)_{\tau_0}\ge D$; $D$ equals $\dim\mathrm{Inv}_6(6)_{\tau_0}$ as computed in two independent ways ($\sum_\tau g\,\mathrm{Kos}$ with Kronecker coefficients by characters, and a character-free count by Littlewood--Richardson coefficients), so the $g_T$ span the weight space over $\mathbb{Q}$ and their relation space has dimension $nb-D=12$. The rows are the tests (S1), (S2) at integer base points $P=(I,A,B)$ with integer $u$, $y$; the program uses $f(P)=\det(P_1)^sf(I,P_1^{-1}P_2,P_1^{-1}P_3)$, true for every $f\in\mathrm{Inv}_s(n)$, and an exp-trace formula whose denominators are prime to $p$, so each row is the reduction modulo $p$ of a true integer linear condition on the coefficients $c$ whenever $\sum_ic_ig_{T_i}\in\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_6(6)$. So the nullity of the row matrix modulo $p$ is at least $\dim\mathrm{Inv}^{\mathrm{S}}_6(6)_{\tau_0}+nb-D$, and the computed value, the nullity minus $nb-D$, is an upper bound. One prime suffices, as the two bounds are equal. $T(\tau_0)$ is computed by Littlewood--Richardson without characters: $g((6^6),(6^6),(36-k,k))$ is given by Proposition~\ref{prop:tworow}, and the two-row Kostka numbers are counted by hand. \end{proof} \begin{remark}\label{rem:Ksixsix} (1) The paper had $23$ of these $75$ types before: depth at most $n-1=5$ ($\tau_1\ge29$, $12$ types, Theorem~\ref{thm:Bdepth}) and $\tau_3=1$ ($17$ types, Corollary~\ref{cor:firstlayer}), $6$ in both; $52$ are new. The method comes from the certificate at $n=5$ (one weight $(9,8,8)$, the tests at points with $P_1=I+t_1uy^T$; Remark~\ref{rem:Bfivechecks}(c), Remark~\ref{rem:pencilcomp}(a)); new are Lemma~\ref{lem:WS} as a written proof of the $\mathrm{GL}_3$-stability and the use of non-balanced weights with the lower bound \eqref{eq:WSlower}. (2) Controls. In every $n=6$ run the computed value equals the proved lower bound, consistent with the rows vanishing on the known part of the weight space; at $n=s=3$, $\tau_0=(3,3,3)$, the method gives $10=8+1+1$, above the value $9=8+1$ of the two-row part and the type $(3,1,1,1)$ alone; $10$ is the known answer (the types $(3,1,1,1)$ and $(3,3)$, each once: Remark~\ref{rem:Bwindowsmall}, Theorem~\ref{thm:GK}); at $n=4$ and $n=5$ it gives the known answers $30=29+1$ and $122=121+1$. A second program (the tests (S1) from the definition at $s=n=6$, exact modulo a prime, with spanning certified by the dimension by characters) settles $68$ of the $75$ types independently; the types $(16,16,4)$, $(17,15,4)$, $(18,14,4)$, $(16,15,5)$, $(17,14,5)$, $(18,13,5)$, $(19,12,5)$ rest on the first program alone. (3) Open: the $33$ types with $\tau_1\le21$ and $\tau_3\ge6$, all with $g((6^6),(6^6),\tau)>0$ (from $(12,12,12)$, $g=58$, to $(16,12,8)$, $g=985$). On the route of Problem~\ref{prob:Bdeep}, $d(6)\le33$ follows once they are excluded (or once $U_{B(6,2)}=0$); Theorem~\ref{thm:Ksixsix} gives no bound on $d(6)$ by itself. \end{remark} \begin{theorem}[computer-assisted]\label{thm:samoilov22} Let $F$ be a field of characteristic $0$. Then $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))=14$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} ($\le$) Lemma~\ref{lem:knidentity} with $n=5$ ($k+l=4\le n-1$): $k_5(x,y)=\sum_\pi\operatorname{sgn}(\pi)\,x^{\pi(0)}yx^{\pi(1)}y\cdots yx^{\pi(4)}$ is an identity of $M_{2,2}(\Lambda)$ of degree $0+1+2+3+4=10$ in $x$ and $4$ in $y$; it is nonzero, as distinct $\pi$ give distinct words. ($\ge$) Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg} with the single pair $(2,2)$, $\Xi_{2,2}=(3,3,3)$, gives $\operatorname{PIdeg}(M_{2,2}(\Lambda))= \min\{N:C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\vdash N,\ \mu\supseteq(3,3,3)}I_\mu\ne0\}-1$. If this intersection were nonzero for some $N\le14$, there would be an identity of degree $N-1\le13$, and multiplying by new letters one of degree exactly $13$ (as in the proof of Corollary~\ref{cor:PIdeg}); so the intersection would be nonzero at $N=14$, against Proposition~\ref{prop:Cfourteen}. $C_N$ and the $I_\mu$ are defined over $\mathbb{Q}$ (the central idempotents have rational coefficients), so the dimension of the intersection is the same for every field of characteristic $0$. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}[computer-assisted]\label{prop:Cfourteen} Over $\mathbb{Q}$, $C_{14}\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\vdash14,\ \mu\supseteq(3,3,3)}I_\mu=0$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} We work over $\mathbb{Q}\subset\mathbb{R}$. Put $N=14$, $m=13$, let $S_m=\operatorname{Sym}([13])$ (it fixes the extra letter $14$) and fix the $N$-cycle $c=(14\;1\;2\;\cdots\;13)$. $S_m$ acts on the $N$-cycles by conjugation; the centralizer of $c$ in $S_N$ is $\langle c\rangle$ and $\langle c\rangle\cap S_m=1$, so the action is free, and as $13!$ is the number of $14$-cycles it is transitive. So $\sigma\mapsto\sigma c\sigma^{-1}$ identifies $\mathbb{Q}[S_m]$ with $C_N$. For $S:=\{\mu\vdash14:\mu\supseteq(3,3,3)\}$ the central idempotent $e_S=\sum_{\mu\in S}(f^\mu/N!)\chi^\mu$ is real, so multiplication by $e_S$ is the orthogonal projection $P_S$ onto $\bigoplus_SI_\mu$ (the permutations orthonormal). Let $Q$ be the orthogonal projection onto $C_N$. For $v\in C_N$, $v\in\operatorname{Im}P_S$ if and only if $QP_SQv=v$ (if $QP_SQv=v$, then $\langle P_Sv,v\rangle=|v|^2$ and $|P_Sv|\le|v|$ force $P_Sv=v$). Under the identification, $QP_SQ$ is right multiplication by $h=\sum_\pi h(\pi)\pi$, $h(\pi):=e_S(c^{-1}\pi c\pi^{-1})$ ($\pi\in S_m$), and $h(\pi^{-1})=h(\pi)$, as $e_S$ is a class function with $e_S(g)=e_S(g^{-1})$. By the Fourier transform on $S_m$, \[ \dim\Bigl(C_N\cap\bigoplus_{\mu\in S}I_\mu\Bigr)=\sum_{\alpha\vdash13}f^\alpha\dim\ker(\rho_\alpha(h)-I). \] $x:=N!\,h$ has the integer values $x(\pi)=\sum_{\mu\in S}f^\mu\chi^\mu(c^{-1}\pi c\pi^{-1})$, and $\ker(\rho_\alpha(h)-I)=\ker(\rho_\alpha(x)-14!\cdot I)$. So the proposition says that the $101$ matrices $\rho_\alpha(x)-14!\cdot I$, $\alpha\vdash13$ (of size $f^\alpha\le21450$), are nonsingular. This is an exact computation modulo the prime $p=999983$: the Fourier transform of $x$ on $S_{13}$ by the coset recursion $S_k=\bigsqcup_ic_iS_{k-1}$ in Young's seminormal form, and the rank of each matrix by exact elimination; all $101$ nullities are $0$. In Young's seminormal form the entries are $1/r$, $1$ and $1-1/r^2$ with $|r|\le12m$ the entries are $p$-integral, and the rank modulo $p$ of a $p$-integral matrix is at most its rank over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence full rank modulo $p$ gives full rank over $\mathbb{Q}$, and so over every field of characteristic $0$. For $(n,m)=(4,10)$ the stacked matrices have full rank $f^\mu$ modulo $p=2147483629$ and modulo $p=2147483587$, for all $42$ partitions $\mu\vdash10$. (One prime suffices; the second one checks the program.) Few of the $g_c$ are needed: the program adds the matrices $\rho_\mu(g_c)$ in a random order and stops at full rank, and for every $\mu$ it stopped after at most $8$ of the $462$ elements. Hence $W_{4,10}=V_{10}$, that is $d(4)\le10$, and $d(4)=10$ by Kuzmin's bound. For every $\mu\vdash10$ the program's matrices $\rho_\mu(s_k)$ satisfy the Coxeter relations of $S_{10}$ modulo $p=2147483629$, and the trace of $\rho_\mu(\sigma)$ equals $\chi_\mu(\sigma)$ modulo $p$ for one $\sigma$ in each conjugacy class (an independent program). The programs and logs are in the ancillary files. \section*{Acknowledgments} This work was done overwhelmingly by AI models and supervised by the author. The models were Anthropic's Claude and OpenAI's ChatGPT. The author takes full responsibility for the paper. \begin{thebibliography}{KOV04} \bibitem[ABW82]{ABW82} K.~Akin, D.~A. Buchsbaum and J.~Weyman, Schur functors and Schur complexes, \emph{Adv. Math.} \textbf{44} (1982), 207--278. \bibitem[AL50]{AL50} S.~A. Amitsur and J.~Levitzki, Minimal identities for algebras, \emph{Proc. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{1} (1950), 449--463. \bibitem[Be88]{Be88} A.~Berele, Trace identities and $\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}$-graded invariants, \emph{Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{309} (1988), 581--589. \bibitem[BR87]{BR87} A.~Berele and A.~Regev, Hook Young diagrams with applications to combinatorics and to representations of Lie superalgebras, \emph{Adv. Math.} \textbf{64} (1987), 118--175. \bibitem[BGG71]{BGG71} I.~N. Bernstein, I.~M. Gelfand and S.~I. Gelfand, Structure of representations generated by vectors of highest weight, \emph{Funct. Anal. Appl.} \textbf{5} (1971), 1--8. \bibitem[BWZ10]{BWZ10} A.~A.~H. Brown, S.~van~Willigenburg and M.~Zabrocki, Expressions for Catalan Kronecker products, \emph{Pacific J. Math.} \textbf{248} (2010), 31--48. \bibitem[CE48]{CE48} C.~Chevalley and S.~Eilenberg, Cohomology theory of Lie groups and Lie algebras, \emph{Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{63} (1948), 85--124. \bibitem[CLR10]{CLR10} P.~Caputo, T.~M. Liggett and T.~Richthammer, Proof of Aldous' spectral gap conjecture, \emph{J. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{23} (2010), 831--851. \bibitem[CST10]{CST10} T.~Ceccherini-Silberstein, F.~Scarabotti and F.~Tolli, \emph{Representation Theory of the Symmetric Groups: The Okounkov--Vershik Approach, Character Formulas, and Partition Algebras}, Cambridge Stud. Adv. Math. \textbf{121}, Cambridge Univ. Press, 2010. \bibitem[CV90]{CV90} O.~A. Chalykh and A.~P. Veselov, Commutative rings of partial differential operators and Lie algebras, \emph{Comm. Math. Phys.} \textbf{126} (1990), 597--611. \bibitem[CW12]{CW12} S.-J.~Cheng and W.~Wang, \emph{Dualities and Representations of Lie Superalgebras}, Grad. Stud. Math. \textbf{144}, Amer. Math. Soc., 2012. \bibitem[Cv08]{Cv08} P.~Cvitanovi\'c, \emph{Group Theory: Birdtracks, Lie's, and Exceptional Groups}, Princeton University Press, 2008. \bibitem[DEP80]{DEP80} C.~De~Concini, D.~Eisenbud and C.~Procesi, Young diagrams and determinantal varieties, \emph{Invent. Math.} \textbf{56} (1980), 129--165. \bibitem[DI43]{DI43} Ya.~S. Dubnov and V.~K. Ivanov, Sur l'abaissement du degr\'e des polyn\^omes en affineurs, \emph{C. R. (Doklady) Acad. Sci. URSS} \textbf{41} (1943), 95--98. \bibitem[DJO94]{DJO94} C.~F. Dunkl, M.~F.~E. de~Jeu and E.~M. Opdam, Singular polynomials for finite reflection groups, \emph{Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{346} (1994), 237--256. \bibitem[DML09]{DML09} V.~Drensky and L.~Makar-Limanov, The conjecture of Nowicki on Weitzenb\"ock derivations of polynomial algebras, \emph{J. Algebra Appl.} \textbf{8} (2009), 41--51. \bibitem[Do18]{Do18} M.~Domokos, Polynomial bound for the nilpotency index of finitely generated nil algebras, \emph{Algebra Number Theory} \textbf{12} (2018), 1233--1242. \bibitem[Dr95]{Dr23} V.~Drensky, Commutative and noncommutative invariant theory, in: \emph{Math. and Education in Math.} (Proc. 24th Spring Conf. Union Bulg. Math., Svishtov, 1995), 14--50; arXiv:2302.10052. \bibitem[Du04]{Du04} C.~F. Dunkl, Singular polynomials for the symmetric groups, \emph{Int. Math. Res. Not.} \textbf{2004}, no.~67, 3607--3635. \bibitem[Du05]{Du05} C.~F. Dunkl, Singular polynomials and modules for the symmetric groups, \emph{Int. Math. Res. Not.} \textbf{2005}, no.~39, 2409--2436. \bibitem[Du35]{Du35} J.~Dubnov, Sur une g\'en\'eralisation de l'\'equation de Hamilton--Cayley et sur les invariants simultan\'es de plusieurs affineurs, \emph{Proc. Seminar Vector Tensor Analysis, Moscow State Univ.} \textbf{2/3} (1935), 351--367. \bibitem[dR54]{dR54} G.~de Rham, Sur la division de formes et de courants par une forme lin\'eaire, \emph{Comment. Math. Helv.} \textbf{28} (1954), 346--352. \bibitem[EF01]{EF01} D.~Eisenbud and E.~Frenkel, Appendix to \cite{Mu01}. \bibitem[EFP11]{EFP11} D.~Ellis, E.~Friedgut and H.~Pilpel, Intersecting families of permutations, \emph{J. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{24} (2011), 649--682. \bibitem[EG02]{EG02} P.~Etingof and V.~Ginzburg, On $m$-quasi-invariants of a Coxeter group, \emph{Mosc. Math. J.} \textbf{2} (2002), 555--566. \bibitem[FV03]{FV03} G.~Felder and A.~P. Veselov, Action of Coxeter groups on $m$-harmonic polynomials and Knizhnik--Zamolodchikov equations, \emph{Mosc. Math. J.} \textbf{3} (2003), 1269--1291. \bibitem[Fo86]{Fo86} E.~Formanek, Generating the ring of matrix invariants, in: \emph{Ring Theory (Antwerp, 1985)}, Lecture Notes in Math. \textbf{1197}, Springer, 1986, 73--82. \bibitem[Fo87]{Fo87} E.~Formanek, The invariants of $n\times n$ matrices, in: \emph{Invariant Theory}, Lecture Notes in Math. \textbf{1278}, Springer, 1987, 18--43. \bibitem[Fo90]{Fo90} E.~Formanek, The Nagata--Higman theorem, \emph{Acta Appl. Math.} \textbf{21} (1990), 185--192. \bibitem[Fo91]{Fo91} E.~Formanek, \emph{The Polynomial Identities and Invariants of $n\times n$ Matrices}, CBMS Regional Conf. Ser. Math. \textbf{78}, Amer. Math. Soc., 1991. \bibitem[GWXZ09]{GWXZ09} A.~Garsia, N.~Wallach, G.~Xin and M.~Zabrocki, Hilbert series of invariants, constant terms and Kostka--Foulkes polynomials, \emph{Discrete Math.} \textbf{309} (2009), 5206--5230. \bibitem[Ga98]{Ga98} F.~R. Gantmacher, \emph{The Theory of Matrices}, Vol.~2, translated from the Russian by K.~A. Hirsch, AMS Chelsea Publishing, Providence, RI, 1998. \bibitem[Ge94]{Ge94} F.~Geoffriau, Sur le centre de l'alg\`ebre enveloppante d'une alg\`ebre de Takiff, \emph{Ann. Math. Blaise Pascal} \textbf{1} (1994), no.~2, 15--31. \bibitem[He74]{He74} H.~Helling, Eine Kennzeichnung von Charakteren auf Gruppen und assoziativen Algebren, \emph{Comm. Algebra} \textbf{1} (1974), 491--501. \bibitem[Hi56]{Hi56} G.~Higman, On a conjecture of Nagata, \emph{Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc.} \textbf{52} (1956), 1--4. \bibitem[HU91]{HU91} R.~Howe and T.~Umeda, The Capelli identity, the double commutant theorem, and multiplicity-free actions, \emph{Math. Ann.} \textbf{290} (1991), 565--619. \bibitem[Hu72]{Hu72} J.~E. Humphreys, \emph{Introduction to Lie Algebras and Representation Theory}, Grad. Texts in Math. \textbf{9}, Springer, 1972. \bibitem[Hu08]{Hu08} J.~E. Humphreys, \emph{Representations of Semisimple Lie Algebras in the BGG Category $\mathcal{O}$}, Grad. Stud. Math. \textbf{94}, Amer. Math. Soc., 2008. \bibitem[Ja77]{Ja77} J.~C. Jantzen, Kontravariante Formen auf induzierten Darstellungen halbeinfacher Lie-Algebren, \emph{Math. Ann.} \textbf{226} (1977), 53--65. \bibitem[Ja78]{Ja78} G.~D. James, \emph{The Representation Theory of the Symmetric Groups}, Lecture Notes in Math. \textbf{682}, Springer, 1978. \bibitem[JK81]{JK81} G.~James and A.~Kerber, \emph{The Representation Theory of the Symmetric Group}, Encyclopedia Math. Appl. \textbf{16}, Addison-Wesley, 1981. \bibitem[Ju74]{Ju74} A.-A.~A. Jucys, Symmetric polynomials and the center of the symmetric group ring, \emph{Rep. Math. Phys.} \textbf{5} (1974), 107--112. \bibitem[KT99]{KT99} I.~Kantor and I.~Trishin, On the Cayley--Hamilton equation in the supercase, \emph{Comm. Algebra} \textbf{27} (1999), 233--259. \bibitem[Ke91]{Ke91} A.~R. Kemer, \emph{Ideals of Identities of Associative Algebras}, Transl. Math. Monogr. \textbf{87}, Amer. Math. Soc., 1991. \bibitem[KV05]{KV05} H.~M. Khudaverdian and Th.~Th. Voronov, Berezinians, exterior powers and recurrent sequences, \emph{Lett. Math. Phys.} \textbf{74} (2005), 201--228. \bibitem[Kh08]{Kh08} J.~Khoury, A Groebner basis approach to solve a conjecture of Nowicki, \emph{J. Symbolic Comput.} \textbf{43} (2008), 908--922. \bibitem[Ki71]{Ki71} R.~C. King, The dimensions of irreducible tensor representations of the orthogonal and symplectic groups, \emph{Canad. J. Math.} \textbf{23} (1971), 176--188. \bibitem[Kl00]{Kl00} A.~A. Klein, Bounds for indices of nilpotency and nility, \emph{Arch. Math. (Basel)} \textbf{74} (2000), 6--10. \bibitem[Ko58]{Ko58} B.~Kostant, A theorem of Frobenius, a theorem of Amitsur--Levitzki and cohomology theory, \emph{J. Math. Mech.} \textbf{7} (1958), 237--264. \bibitem[Ko63]{Ko63} B.~Kostant, Lie group representations on polynomial rings, \emph{Amer. J. Math.} \textbf{85} (1963), 327--404. \bibitem[Kos50]{Kos50} J.-L.~Koszul, Homologie et cohomologie des alg\`ebres de Lie, \emph{Bull. Soc. Math. France} \textbf{78} (1950), 65--127. \bibitem[KOV93]{KOV93} S.~Kerov, G.~Olshanski and A.~Vershik, Harmonic analysis on the infinite symmetric group. A deformation of the regular representation, \emph{C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris S\'er. I Math.} \textbf{316} (1993), 773--778. \bibitem[KOV04]{KOV04} S.~Kerov, G.~Olshanski and A.~Vershik, Harmonic analysis on the infinite symmetric group, \emph{Invent. Math.} \textbf{158} (2004), 551--642. \bibitem[Ku75]{Ku75} E.~N. Kuz'min, On the Nagata--Higman theorem (Russian), in: \emph{Mathematical Structures, Computational Mathematics, Mathematical Modelling} (Proc. dedicated to the 60th birthday of Acad.\ L.~Iliev), Sofia, 1975, 101--107. \bibitem[Le73]{Le73} U.~Leron, Multilinear identities of the matrix ring, \emph{Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{183} (1973), 175--202. \bibitem[Lo12]{Lo12} A.~A. Lopatin, On the nilpotency degree of the algebra with identity $x^n=0$, \emph{J. Algebra} \textbf{371} (2012), 350--366. \bibitem[LO13]{LO13} J.~M. Landsberg and G.~Ottaviani, Equations for secant varieties of Veronese and other varieties, \emph{Ann. Mat. Pura Appl.} \textbf{192} (2013), 569--606. \bibitem[LS01]{LS01} A.~S. Lewis and H.~S. Sendov, Twice differentiable spectral functions, \emph{SIAM J. Matrix Anal. Appl.} \textbf{23} (2001), 368--386. \bibitem[Ma95]{Ma95} I.~G. Macdonald, \emph{Symmetric Functions and Hall Polynomials}, 2nd ed., Oxford Univ. Press, 1995. \bibitem[Man11]{Man11} L.~Manivel, On rectangular Kronecker coefficients, \emph{J. Algebraic Combin.} \textbf{33} (2011), 153--162. \bibitem[Mat86]{Mat86} H.~Matsumura, \emph{Commutative Ring Theory}, Cambridge Stud. Adv. Math.~8, Cambridge University Press, 1986. \bibitem[MFF86]{MFF86} F.~G. Malikov, B.~L. Feigin and D.~B. Fuchs, Singular vectors in Verma modules over Kac--Moody algebras, \emph{Funct. Anal. Appl.} \textbf{20} (1986), no.~2, 103--113. \bibitem[MV11]{MV11} R.~L. Mkrtchyan and A.~P. Veselov, On duality and negative dimensions in the theory of Lie groups and symmetric spaces, \emph{J. Math. Phys.} \textbf{52} (2011), 083514. \bibitem[Mu01]{Mu01} M.~Musta\c{t}\u{a}, Jet schemes of locally complete intersection canonical singularities, \emph{Invent. Math.} \textbf{145} (2001), 397--424. \bibitem[Mu81]{Mu81} G.~E. Murphy, A new construction of Young's seminormal representation of the symmetric groups, \emph{J. Algebra} \textbf{69} (1981), 287--297. \bibitem[Na52]{Na52} M.~Nagata, On the nilpotency of nil-algebras, \emph{J. Math. Soc. Japan} \textbf{4} (1952), 296--301. \bibitem[Now94]{Now94} A.~Nowicki, \emph{Polynomial Derivations and their Rings of Constants}, Uniwersytet Miko\l{}aja Kopernika, Toru\'n, 1994. \bibitem[OV96]{OV96} A.~Okounkov and A.~Vershik, A new approach to representation theory of symmetric groups, \emph{Selecta Math. (N.S.)} \textbf{2} (1996), 581--605. \bibitem[Ol99]{Ol99} P.~J. Olver, \emph{Classical Invariant Theory}, London Math. Soc. Student Texts \textbf{44}, Cambridge University Press, 1999. \bibitem[PP13]{PP13} I.~Pak and G.~Panova, Strict unimodality of $q$-binomial coefficients, \emph{C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris} \textbf{351} (2013), 415--418. \bibitem[PPV16]{PPV16} I.~Pak, G.~Panova and E.~Vallejo, Kronecker products, characters, partitions, and the tensor square conjectures, \emph{Adv. Math.} \textbf{288} (2016), 702--731. \bibitem[Po82]{Po82} A.~P. Popov, Identities of the tensor square of the Grassmann algebra, \emph{Algebra and Logic} \textbf{21} (1982), 296--316. \bibitem[Pr76]{Pr76} C.~Procesi, The invariant theory of $n\times n$ matrices, \emph{Adv. Math.} \textbf{19} (1976), 306--381. \bibitem[Pr15]{Pr15} C.~Procesi, On the theorem of Amitsur--Levitzki, \emph{Israel J. Math.} \textbf{207} (2015), 151--154. \bibitem[Pr26]{Pr26} C.~Procesi, Fermionic matrices and super Cayley--Hamilton algebras, arXiv:2605.22745 (2026). \bibitem[PY12]{PY12} D.~Panyushev and O.~Yakimova, A remarkable contraction of semisimple Lie algebras, \emph{Ann. Inst. Fourier} \textbf{62} (2012), 2053--2068. \bibitem[Ra74]{Ra74} Yu.~P. Razmyslov, Trace identities of full matrix algebras over a field of characteristic zero, \emph{Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR Ser. Mat.} \textbf{38} (1974), 723--756; English transl.: \emph{Math. USSR Izv.} \textbf{8} (1974), 727--760. \bibitem[Ra87]{Ra87} Yu.~P. Razmyslov, Trace identities and central polynomials in the matrix superalgebras $M_{n,k}$, \emph{Math. USSR Sb.} \textbf{56} (1987), 187--206 (Russian original: \emph{Mat. Sb.} \textbf{128(170)} (1985), 194--215). \bibitem[Rai88]{Rai88} M.~Ra\"{\i}s, Champs de vecteurs invariants sur une alg\`ebre de Lie r\'eductive complexe, \emph{J. Math. Soc. Japan} \textbf{40} (1988), 615--628. \bibitem[Ro22]{Ro22} A.~Romano, On the T-ideal generated by the identity $f=x^n$, arXiv:2212.05994 (2022). \bibitem[Ros76]{Ros76} S.~Rosset, A new proof of the Amitsur--Levitski identity, \emph{Israel J. Math.} \textbf{23} (1976), 187--188. \bibitem[RT92]{RT92} M.~Ra\"{\i}s and P.~Tauvel, Indice et polyn\^omes invariants pour certaines alg\`ebres de Lie, \emph{J. Reine Angew. Math.} \textbf{425} (1992), 123--140. \bibitem[Sa10]{Sa10} L.~M. Samoilov, An analog of the Amitsur--Levitzki theorem for matrix superalgebras, \emph{Sib. Math. J.} \textbf{51} (2010), 491--495. \bibitem[Se85]{Se85} A.~N. Sergeev, The tensor algebra of the identity representation as a module over the Lie superalgebras $\mathfrak{gl}(n,m)$ and $Q(n)$, \emph{Math. USSR Sb.} \textbf{51} (1985), 419--427. \bibitem[SZ04]{SZ04} I.~P. Shestakov and N.~Zhukavets, On associative algebras satisfying the identity $x^5=0$, \emph{Algebra Discrete Math.} (2004), no.~1, 112--120. \bibitem[Str83]{Str83} V.~Strassen, Rank and optimal computation of generic tensors, \emph{Linear Algebra Appl.} \textbf{52/53} (1983), 645--685. \bibitem[St89]{St89} E.~Strickland, On algebras satisfying the identity $x^N=0$, \emph{Comm. Algebra} \textbf{17} (1989), 2795--2799. \bibitem[Te86]{Te86} Y.~Teranishi, The ring of invariants of matrices, \emph{Nagoya Math. J.} \textbf{104} (1986), 149--161. \bibitem[VL93]{VL93} M.~Vaughan-Lee, An algorithm for computing graded algebras, \emph{J. Symbolic Comput.} \textbf{16} (1993), 345--354. \bibitem[VL98]{VL98} M.~Vaughan-Lee, Superalgebras and dimensions of algebras, \emph{Internat. J. Algebra Comput.} \textbf{8} (1998), 97--125. \bibitem[Ve68]{Ve68} D.-N. Verma, Structure of certain induced representations of complex semisimple Lie algebras, \emph{Bull. Amer. Math. Soc.} \textbf{74} (1968), 160--166. \bibitem[Vi02]{Vi02} U.~Vishne, Polynomial identities of $M_2(G)$, \emph{Comm. Algebra} \textbf{30} (2002), 443--454. \bibitem[Vi11]{Vi11} U.~Vishne, Polynomial identities of $M_{2,1}(G)$, \emph{Comm. Algebra} \textbf{39} (2011), 2044--2050. \bibitem[Vu74]{Vu74} Th.~Vust, \emph{Covariants de groupes alg\'ebriques r\'eductifs}, Th\`ese no.~1671, Universit\'e de Gen\`eve, 1974. \end{thebibliography} \end{document}