\section{Known results: a bath in its ground state gives no rate} \label{sec:known} The statements in this section are standard results or direct consequences of them; the mathematics is the zero-temperature fluctuation--dissipation theorem and the spectral support of Wightman functions. We state them with their hypotheses because the drag theorem of Section~\ref{sec:drag} addresses what they leave open. Throughout, the bath is kept to second cumulant and the static source enters as an external c-number density. \subsection{Any ground state: the noise is the absorption} Let $H\geq0$ generate a time translation of the laboratory under which the bath state and both branch configurations are stationary, and let $\Omega$ be a ground state, $H\Omega=0$. No spatial symmetry is assumed: the Earth, the apparatus and the source may break every spatial translation. The proposition says that the noise then equals the absorption at each frequency, and that a soft enough absorption bounds the loss of coherence for all time. \begin{proposition}[Ground state; standard] \label{prop:ground} (i) $S_B(\omega)=\hbar|\chi''_B(\omega)|$ for $\omega\neq0$, and $S_B(0)=\hbar\chi''_B(0^+)$ when the limit exists. (ii) The rate vanishes if and only if the Fej\'{e}r mean of $\chi''_B$ at $\omega=0$ vanishes and the spectral measure of $\delta B\,\Omega$ has no atom at $\omega=0$. (iii) If $\Lambda_2\equiv\pi^{-1}\int_0^\infty\chi''_B(\omega)\,\omega^{-2}d\omega$ is finite, then \begin{equation} -\ln|z(t)|\leq\frac{2\Lambda_2}{\hbar}\quad\text{for all }t,\qquad -\ln|z(t)|\xrightarrow{\;t\to\infty\;}\frac{\Lambda_2}{\hbar}. \label{eq:all-times} \end{equation} \end{proposition} \begin{proof} With $H\Omega=0$ and $H\geq0$, the spectral measure of $\delta B\,\Omega$ lives on $E\geq0$, so $\langle\delta B(t)\delta B\rangle$ has its Fourier support at $\omega\geq0$ and $\langle\delta B\,\delta B(t)\rangle$ at $\omega\leq0$; (i) is the zero-temperature fluctuation--dissipation theorem~\cite{CallenWelton1951,Kubo1966}. Then Eq.~\eqref{eq:dephasing} reads $-\ln|z(t)|=(\pi\hbar)^{-1}\int_0^\infty\chi''_B(\omega)(1-\cos\omega t)\,\omega^{-2}d\omega$. Substituting $x=\omega t$ in $-\ln|z|/t$ gives (ii); an atom at $\omega=0$ would add a term growing as $t^2$. Bounding $1-\cos\omega t\leq2$ and applying the Riemann--Lebesgue lemma gives (iii). \end{proof} \noindent In (ii), the Fej\'{e}r mean of $\chi''_B$ at $\omega=0$ is $\lim_{t\to\infty}\int_0^\infty\chi''_B(\omega)\,2(1-\cos\omega t)/(\pi t\,\omega^2)\,d\omega$; it equals $\chi''_B(0^+)$ when that limit exists. The proposition means that a ground-state bath produces a rate only if its absorption stays finite down to zero frequency. Since $\chi''_B$ is odd in $\omega$, that requires a response that is discontinuous at $\omega=0$: a Di\'{o}si--Penrose rate would need $\chi''_B(0^+)=2C\EG$, that is, a response tail $\chi_B(t)\simeq4C\EG/(\pi t)$ of the bath to the which-path variable. This is the loophole that the proposition leaves. For $\chi''_B\propto\omega^s$ at small $\omega$, a rate needs $s\leq0$; Ohmic baths, $s=1$, give $-\ln|z|\propto\ln t$, and only $s>1$ gives a bounded exponent~\cite{Unruh1995,Leggett1987,PalmaSuominenEkert1996}. A finite reorganization energy $\pi^{-1}\int_0^\infty\chi''_B\,\omega^{-1}d\omega$ suffices for (ii), but it does not bound decoherence on laboratory times: a $\chi''_B$ that is flat over a band $[\omega_{\rm IR},\omega_{\rm UV}]$ and normalized to reorganization energy $\EG$ mimics Eq.~\eqref{eq:dp-rate} with $C_{\rm eff}=\pi/[2\ln(\omega_{\rm UV}/\omega_{\rm IR})]$ for $1/\omega_{\rm UV}\ll t\ll1/\omega_{\rm IR}$, which is $0.07$ between $0.1$~ps and $1$~ms. The all-times bound~\eqref{eq:all-times} is the statement that excludes this. \subsection{The free linearized gravitational field} In a thermal equilibrium (Kubo--Martin--Schwinger, KMS) state at inverse temperature $\beta$, the fluctuation--dissipation theorem gives $S_B(\omega)=\hbar\chi''_B(\omega)\coth(\beta\hbar\omega/2)$, so \begin{equation} S_B(0)=\frac{2}{\beta}\lim_{\omega\to0}\frac{\chi''_B(\omega)}{\omega}: \label{eq:fdt-floor} \end{equation} a floor at finite temperature needs an Ohmic response. The vacuum restricted to a Rindler wedge~\cite{BisognanoWichmann1975}, or for a conformal field to a causal diamond~\cite{CasiniHuertaMyers2011}, is KMS for its modular flow; describing the vacuum in modular time adds no excitations. A free massless field obeys $\Box\hat\phi=0$, so its commutator, and hence $\chi''_B$, is a c-number supported on $\omega=\pm c|\mathbf{k}|$, the same in every state. Inhomogeneity of the laboratory changes the propagator only at order $GM_\oplus/(R_\oplus c^2)=7\times10^{-10}$. Weight at $\omega\to0$ comes only from $k\to0$. For two equal spheres with form factor $\tilde\rho(k)$, \begin{equation} \bigl\langle|\Delta\tilde\rho_{\mathbf{k}}|^2\bigr\rangle =2\,\tilde\rho(k)^2\Bigl(1-\frac{\sin kd}{kd}\Bigr) \;\xrightarrow{\;kd\to0\;}\;\tfrac13 M^2k^2d^2 . \label{eq:drho} \end{equation} Take as a scalar proxy a propagating field normalized so that its reorganization energy, $\pi^{-1}\int_0^\infty\chi''_B\,\omega^{-1}d\omega$, equals $\EG$ (Appendix~\ref{app:energy}). Then \begin{equation} \chi''_B(\omega)=\frac{G\omega}{c}\bigl\langle|\Delta\tilde\rho_{\omega/c}|^2\bigr\rangle \;\simeq\;\frac{GM^2d^2}{3c^3}\,\omega^3\qquad(\omega d/c\ll1), \label{eq:J} \end{equation} which is super-Ohmic. Only a difference of branch \emph{energies} makes it Ohmic. That is the channel of the graviton master equations~\cite{Anastopoulos2013,Blencowe2013,OnigaWang2016}, whose rates are first order in $G$ for superpositions of different energies and vanish for the equal-mass spatial superposition considered here. Linearized general relativity has less infrared response than the proxy. Its Newtonian potential is fixed by the constraint, an instantaneous real kernel with $\chi''=0$ that fluctuates only through the matter that sources it, at order $G^2$. Its radiative tensor modes couple through the trace-free quadrupole difference of the branches, $\chi''_{\rm TT}=(G/5c^5)\,|\Delta Q^{\rm TF}|^2\,\omega^5$, which for $|\Delta Q^{\rm TF}|^2=\frac23M^2d^4$ (quadrupoles about one branch, the origin of the proper-detector frame; about an origin at distance $D$ the difference grows by terms of order $M^2D^2d^2$, still $\propto\omega^5$) is $\frac25(\omega d/c)^2$ times Eq.~\eqref{eq:J}, less than the proxy for $\omega d/c\ll1$. The response of the field is therefore too soft at low frequency for a floor, in the vacuum and at any temperature: \begin{proposition}[Field channel] \label{prop:field} For a static inertial source with equal branch masses, $S_B(0)=0$ and the dephasing exponent saturates in the vacuum and in every thermal state of the free linearized field, including states that are KMS for modular flow. In a stationary Gaussian state with mode occupation $n(\omega)$, $S_B(0)=0$ if and only if $\lim_{\omega\to0^+}n(\omega)\,\chi''_B(\omega)=0$, and the exponent saturates if and only if $\int_0n(\omega)\,\chi''_B(\omega)\,\omega^{-2}d\omega<\infty$, for example if $n\chi''_B=\order{\omega^{1+\delta}}$ with $\delta>0$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} For a free field $S_B=\hbar\chi''_B\,[1+2n(\omega)]$ with $\chi''_B$ state-independent and $\propto\omega^3$ or softer at small $\omega$. The vacuum, $n=0$, is Proposition~\ref{prop:ground}. A thermal state has $2n\simeq2/(\beta\hbar\omega)$, so $S_B=\order{\omega^2}$. For the vacuum and thermal states $S_B(\omega)/\omega^2$ is therefore integrable at $\omega=0$ and Eq.~\eqref{eq:dephasing} converges as $t\to\infty$; in general $S_B(0)=0$ is the stated limit and integrability is the stated condition. \end{proof} \noindent The free field gives a static equal-mass superposition no rate, whatever its temperature. The occupation condition is not automatic. A statistically homogeneous stochastic gravitational-wave background with strain spectrum $S_h\propto\omega^{-4}$ violates it and gives a white floor at first order in $G$, but $\propto M^2d^4$, not of Di\'{o}si--Penrose form. In the tensor channel such a background has an infrared-divergent energy density, so it can only be band-limited. At closure density at $1$~Hz its rate is $3\times10^{-8}$ of Eq.~\eqref{eq:dp-rate} for the benchmark of Section~\ref{sec:prediction} at $d=1$~mm. For the vacuum, Proposition~\ref{prop:ground}(iii) makes the statement quantitative. For $1~\mu$g of silica the proxy~\eqref{eq:J} gives $\Lambda_2/\hbar=1.1\times10^{-3}$ at $d=2a$ and $4.2\times10^{-3}$ at $d=1$~mm, of order $GM^2/(\hbar c)=2.1\times10^{-3}$; for $\omega d/c\ll1$ the tensor channel gives less. By Eq.~\eqref{eq:all-times} the coherence loss $-\ln|z(t)|$ stays below $2\Lambda_2/\hbar$, which is $2.2\times10^{-3}$ at $d=2a$ and $8.3\times10^{-3}$ at $d=1$~mm, at all times; it tends to $\Lambda_2/\hbar$ and is reversible: it is the overlap of the field states dressing the two branches, not a rate. Direct calculations agree. In the graviton vacuum, the decoherence functional of a spatial superposition that is opened and closed again approaches a constant at late times rather than growing linearly~\cite{KannoSodaTokuda2021}. The which-path information radiated by a superposition is set by the time taken to recombine it, not by the time it is held apart~\cite{DSW2022newton}, and in the inertial Minkowski vacuum it does not grow with the holding time~\cite{DSW2023}. \subsection{The covariant case, and what these results leave open} If the state is invariant under spacetime translations and the energy--momentum spectrum lies in the forward cone, the zero follows without computing any response: \begin{proposition}[Spectrum condition; standard] \label{prop:spectrum} Let $\Omega$ be invariant under spacetime translations $U(a)=e^{iP\cdot a}$, let the joint spectrum of $P^\mu$ lie in the closed forward cone $\bar V_+$, let $\Phi(x)=U(x)\Phi(0)U(x)^\dagger$ (local or gravitationally dressed) have a locally finite connected two-point spectral measure $\mu$, and let the source be rigid. Then $S_B(0)=0$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} In this proof $\hbar=1$: $p=(p^0,\mathbf{p})$ is a wave four-vector and $\mathbf{p}$ is the wavevector called $\mathbf{k}$ elsewhere. With $P|\Omega\rangle=0$, $\langle\Omega|\Phi(x)\Phi(0)|\Omega\rangle_c=\int e^{-ip\cdot x}\,d\mu(p)$ with $\mathrm{supp}\,\mu\subset\bar V_+$. The zero-frequency noise of $B$ is the density at $p^0=0$ of $|\Delta\tilde\rho(\mathbf{p})|^2d\mu(p)$ and its mirror image, $S_B(0)=c_0\lim_{\varepsilon\to0}\varepsilon^{-1}\int_{0\leq p^0\leq\varepsilon} |\Delta\tilde\rho|^2\,d\mu$, with $c_0$ a convention-dependent constant. On the support $|\mathbf{p}|\leq\varepsilon/c$, and a rigid body has $|\Delta\tilde\rho|^2=4|\tilde\rho|^2\sin^2(\mathbf{p}\cdot\mathbf{d}/2)\leq M^2|\mathbf{p}|^2d^2$, so \begin{equation} S_B(0)\leq c_0\lim_{\varepsilon\to0}\frac{M^2d^2}{c^2}\,\varepsilon\, \mu\bigl(\{p^0\leq\varepsilon\}\bigr)=0 \label{eq:nogo2-bound} \end{equation} by local finiteness. \end{proof} \noindent Since the cone implies $P^0\geq0$, Proposition~\ref{prop:spectrum} is the special case of Proposition~\ref{prop:ground} in which the cone and the dipole suppression of an equal-mass source supply $\chi''_B(0^+)=0$. An atom of $\mu$ at $p=0$ is weighted by $|\Delta\tilde\rho(0)|^2=0$, so it needs no separate assumption. This is a standard consequence of the spectral support of Wightman functions~\cite{Wightman1956,Haag1996} combined with the dipole suppression of an equal-mass source. The Lorentz-cone support forces, for any covariant field coupled to a source with vanishing monopole difference, the conclusion that the theory of dephasing reaches for Ohmic and super-Ohmic baths~\cite{Unruh1995,Leggett1987,PalmaSuominenEkert1996}. In asymptotically flat gravity the cone would follow from positivity of the total energy, which we do not derive. The propositions leave open whatever breaks one of their hypotheses. \begin{itemize} \item \emph{The state is not a ground state.} In a thermal, stationary non-equilibrium or infinite-temperature state the generator of time translations that leaves the state invariant is not bounded below; for a thermal state of an infinite system its spectrum is all of $\mathbb{R}$. This is the class of Section~\ref{sec:drag}. Relativistic collapse models escape the same way: a mediating field at each spacetime point~\cite{Bedingham2011}, a scalar field whose energy spectrum takes all real values~\cite{Pearle2015}, a clock field that fixes the foliation~\cite{VaidhyanathanMilburn2025}, or classical noise with a Lorentz-invariant correlation, which as a classical field need not have a positive generator. Why such noise is hard to reconcile with a stable vacuum is the subject of a long literature~\cite{Pearle1999,Pearle2005,Tumulka2006,Myrvold2017,JonesGasbarriBassi2021,Diosi2022GKLS,Diosi2024hybrid}. Gundhi, Di\'{o}si and Carlesso obtain a finite energy rate for Lorentz-invariant, non-Markovian noise~\cite{GundhiDiosiCarlesso2026}; their dynamics still excites the vacuum, as they note, and the finite rate comes from a normal-ordering prescription applied to the evolved observables, which is not a positive map on states. The model therefore supplies no stationary positive-energy bath with a floor, and its kernel is not of Di\'{o}si--Penrose form. \item \emph{Killing horizons} replace the positive generator of laboratory time by a boost generator with spectrum $\mathbb{R}$. They decohere at rates set by horizon data that vanish for an inertial laboratory without a horizon~\cite{DSW2023,DSW2024local,DSW2022,WilsonGerow2024}. \item \emph{Non-inertial laboratories.} The generator of the co-rotating frame is not bounded below. A source fixed on the rotating Earth radiates branch-dependently at a rate of order $10^{-49}$ of Eq.~\eqref{eq:dp-rate} in the scalar proxy, and less in general relativity, where the dipole does not radiate. \item \emph{A quantized source.} Internal dynamics that diffuse the source's trajectory lie outside the c-number treatment~\cite{MoreiraCeleri2026}. So does the source's own Gauss-law sector, where boosts are spontaneously broken; we conjecture that its corrections are of higher order in $GM$ than the leading term, but have not shown it. \item \emph{Beyond second cumulant}: higher cumulants of the bath are not controlled by these propositions. \item \emph{Non-unitary dynamics}: Penrose-type objective reduction~\cite{Penrose1996} and collapse models whose record is a sequence of jumps with a stable vacuum~\cite{Tilloy2018,PiccioneBassi2025} lie outside the bath framework. \end{itemize}