\section{Places of diagrams 1 and 4}\label{sec:torque} In this section $m\in(\R_{>0})^5$ is arbitrary and $C\subseteq Y_m$ is an irreducible curve. At a place of diagram $1$ or $4$ with triangle $T$, condition (23) of \cite{AK12} is $\lab{E}(T)$, a hypersurface in the masses. The torque identity of \cite[\S5.0]{AK12} yields a second relation, which also involves the masses of the other two bodies. We use the polynomials \[ A_a=s^6(s+2)(1-s)(1+s)^6,\qquad A_b=(2s+1)(1-s)(1+s)^6,\qquad A_c=s^6(s+2)(2s+1), \] and $P_{14}=A_c-A_a-A_b$ and $P_{28}=(A_b-A_a-A_c)^2-4A_aA_c$, which lie in $\Z[s]$ and have degrees $14$ and $28$. Let \[ \Xi(X)=\sum_{k=0}^{28}c_{2k}X^{2k},\qquad c_{56-2k}=c_{2k}, \] with \begin{align*} (c_0,c_2,\dots,c_{8})&=(1,\,40,\,-926,\,-23224,\,512795),\\ (c_{10},c_{12},\dots,c_{18})&=(-2049680,\,-31884,\,8113392,\,-28533847,\,-13730312),\\ (c_{20},c_{22},\dots,c_{28})&=(36197566,\,13354904,\,15851835,\,-139882848,\,-47991080). \end{align*} \begin{lemma}\cert\label{lem:torquepoly} \begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\alph*)}] \item In $(0,1)$ the polynomial $P_{14}$ has exactly one root $s_1$, $P_{28}$ has exactly two roots $s_21$. The other statements are exact computations over $\Q$: the resultant and the factorization of $\Xi$ over $\Q$; the numbers of roots of $P_{14}$, $P_{28}$ and $A_a-A_b-A_c$ in $(0,\frac9{10})$ and in $(\frac9{10},1)$, and of $\Xi$ in $(1,\infty)$, counted by Sturm sequences; and the signs at the ends of the stated intervals. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:torque} Let $P$ be a singular place of $C$ of diagram~$1$ or~$4$, with triangle $T$, and let $\{d,e\}$ be the complement of $T$. \begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\alph*)}] \item The leading coefficients of the $p_{kt}$ satisfy $\sum_{k\in\{d,e\}}\sum_{t\in T}m_km_t\,\hat p_{kt}=0$. \item $\lab{E}(T)$ holds. Write $T=\{a,b,c\}$ with $x_c=x_a+x_b$, where $x_t=m_t^{-1/2}$, and $m_a\le m_b$, and put $s=x_b/x_a$. Then $s<1$, and either $s=s_1$ and $m_e/m_d\in\{\xi_1^{2/3},\xi_1^{-2/3}\}$, or $s\in\{s_2,s_3\}$ and $m_d=m_e$. \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} In terms of the masses, the conditions of (b) say that $(m_a,m_b,m_c,m_d,m_e)$ is a positive multiple of \[ (\lambda,\ \lambda s^{-2},\ \lambda(1+s)^{-2},\ 1,\ \theta),\qquad\lambda>0,\quad(s,\theta)\in\big\{(s_1,\xi_1^{2/3}),\,(s_1,\xi_1^{-2/3}),\,(s_2,1),\,(s_3,1)\big\}, \] where $\xi_1^{2/3}=1.745220274547\dots$. Thus at positive masses the places of diagrams~$1$ and~$4$ occur only for masses on finitely many curves in the projective space of masses, three up to relabelling of the bodies, while $\lab{E}(T)$ defines a hypersurface. In particular, no such place exists if two masses of $T$ are equal. This is the case at $(1,4,4,4,4)$ and $(1,1,4,4,4)$, where $\lab{E}(T)$ holds only for triangles with the masses $1$, $4$, $4$. \begin{proof} We write $a'$ for the parameter $a$ of the type of a place of diagram~$1$ \cite[Table~1]{Tom26}, to keep $a$ for a body, and put $a'=1$ for diagram~$4$. Let $\mu=3a'-2$, so that $\mu\le1$. After an exchange of the colours if necessary, $de$ is a $z$-edge with $z$-circles $d$ and $e$, and $T$ is a $w$-triangle (diagram~$1$) or a $zw$-triangle (diagram~$4$) without circles. By Lemma~\ref{lem:allcurves}(b), \cite[Lemma~3.6]{Tom26} and (O3), (O6), $(\zeta_{kl},\omega_{kl})$ is $(2-a',\mu)$ on the pairs of $T$, $(-2,\mu)$ on the six pairs $kt$ with $k\in\{d,e\}$ and $t\in T$, and $(-2,2)$ on $de$. Since $d$ and $e$ are $z$-circled and no body of $T$ is, $e(z_d)=e(z_e)=-2\mu=\omega_{te}$ and $\zeta_{de}=\zeta_{te}=-2$. Hence $e(w_t)=\mu$ and $\hat w_t=-\hat w_{dt}\ne0$ for $t\in T$, the leading coefficients of $z_{kt}$ and $w_{kt}$ are $\hat z_k$ and $-\hat w_t$ for $k\in\{d,e\}$, and the rows $D_{kt}$ become \begin{equation}\label{eq:torquelead} \hat p_{kt}^2\,\hat z_k\,\hat w_t=-1\qquad(k\in\{d,e\},\ t\in T). \end{equation} (a) We multiply the equations $z_k=\sum_{l\ne k}m_lp_{kl}^3z_{kl}$ and $w_k=\sum_{l\ne k}m_lp_{kl}^3w_{kl}$ of \cite[(2.1)]{Tom26} by $m_kw_k$ and by $m_kz_k$, subtract, and sum over $k\in\{d,e\}$. The terms with $l\in\{d,e\}$ cancel in pairs, and we obtain the torque identity of \cite[\S5.0]{AK12}, \[ \textstyle\sum_{k\in\{d,e\}}\sum_{t\in T}m_km_tp_{kt}^3\,(z_kw_t-w_kz_t)=0 . \] The terms $p_{kt}^3z_kw_t$ have the exponent $\frac32(2-\mu)+\mu-2=1-\frac\mu2$ and, by \eqref{eq:torquelead}, the leading coefficients $-\hat p_{kt}$. The terms $p_{kt}^3w_kz_t$ have larger exponents, as $e(w_kz_t)>0>\mu-2=e(z_kw_t)$. Comparing the coefficients of the exponent $1-\frac\mu2$, we obtain (a). (b) Let $t\in T$. In the equations $z_t=\sum_{l\ne t}m_lZ_{tl}$ and $w_t=\sum_{l\ne t}m_lW_{tl}$, where $Z_{tl}=p_{tl}^3z_{tl}$ and $W_{tl}=p_{tl}^3w_{tl}$, the terms with $l\in T$ have the exponents $2-4a'$ and $-2$, and those with $l\in\{d,e\}$ the larger exponents $4-\frac92a'$ and $4-\frac32a'$. Also $e(w_t)=\mu>-2$ and $e(z_t)>2-4a'$. For the latter, let $z_T$ be the centre of mass of $T$. Then $M_T(z_t-z_T)=\sum_{t'\in T}m_{t'}z_{tt'}$ has an exponent at least $2-a'$, and $M_Tz_T=\sum_{t'\in T}\sum_{k\in\{d,e\}}m_{t'}m_kZ_{t'k}$ has an exponent at least $4-\frac92a'$. Comparing the coefficients of the exponents $2-4a'$ and $-2$, we obtain \[ \textstyle\sum_{t'\in T\setminus\{t\}}m_{t'}\hat Z_{tt'}=\sum_{t'\in T\setminus\{t\}}m_{t'}\hat W_{tt'}=0, \] which are the relations (21) and (22) of \cite{AK12}. We conclude as in \cite[\S5.3]{AK12}. Writing $T=\{a,b,c\}$, these relations say that $\hat Z_{ab}/m_c=\hat Z_{bc}/m_a=\hat Z_{ca}/m_b$, and the same for $\hat W$. As $\hat Z_{tt'}/\hat W_{tt'}=\hat z_{tt'}/\hat w_{tt'}$, there is $\rho\ne0$ with $\hat w_{tt'}=\rho\hat z_{tt'}$ on the three pairs. Then $\hat Z_{tt'}^2=\hat p_{tt'}^6\hat z_{tt'}^2=\rho^{-3}\hat z_{tt'}^{-4}$, so the numbers $m_{t''}\hat z_{tt'}^2$, with $t''$ the third body, agree up to sign. Hence $\hat z_{bc}=\lambda\epsilon_ax_a$, $\hat z_{ca}=\lambda\epsilon_bx_b$ and $\hat z_{ab}=\lambda\epsilon_cx_c$ with $\lambda\ne0$ and $\epsilon_t^4=1$, and $\epsilon_ax_a+\epsilon_bx_b+\epsilon_cx_c=0$. If $\epsilon_b/\epsilon_a=\pm i$, the imaginary part of this relation, divided by $\epsilon_a$, forces $\epsilon_c/\epsilon_a=\mp i$ and $x_b=x_c$, and its real part gives $x_a=0$. Hence $\epsilon_b/\epsilon_a$ and likewise $\epsilon_c/\epsilon_a$ are $\pm1$, and one of $x_a$, $x_b$, $x_c$ is the sum of the other two. This is $\lab{E}(T)$. We now name the bodies of $T$ as in (b). Since $x_c=x_a+x_b$, the relation $\epsilon_ax_a+\epsilon_bx_b+\epsilon_cx_c=0$ forces $\epsilon_a=\epsilon_b=-\epsilon_c$. After replacing $\lambda$ by $\lambda\epsilon_a$, $\hat z_{tt'}=\lambda(z^0_t-z^0_{t'})$ with $z^0_a=-x_b$, $z^0_c=0$ and $z^0_b=x_a$. The centre of mass gives $\sum_{t\in T}m_t\hat w_t=0$, as $e(w_d),e(w_e)>\mu$. Hence $\hat w_t=\rho\lambda r_t$ with $r_t=z^0_t-\sum_{t'\in T}m_{t'}z^0_{t'}/M_T$, and $r_t\ne0$ as $\hat w_t\ne0$. The relations below are homogeneous in $(x_a,x_b)$, and we take $x_a=1$ and $x_b=s$, so that $m_a=1$, $m_b=s^{-2}$, $m_c=(1+s)^{-2}$ and \[ r_a=-\frac{2s+1}{s^2+s+1},\qquad r_b=\frac{s^2(s+2)}{s^2+s+1},\qquad r_c=\frac{(s-1)(s+1)^2}{s^2+s+1}. \] So $s\ne1$, that is, $s<1$, and then $r_a,r_c<0-2$, so $\hat z_d=m_e\hat c$ and $\hat z_e=-m_d\hat c$ with $\hat c\ne0$. For real $r\ne0$ we write $r^{-1/2}$ for $|r|^{-1/2}$ if $r>0$ and for $i|r|^{-1/2}$ if $r<0$. Let $K$ be a square root of $-1/(\hat c\rho\lambda)$. By \eqref{eq:torquelead}, $\hat p_{dt}=\epsilon_{dt}Km_e^{-1/2}r_t^{-1/2}$ and $\hat p_{et}=\epsilon_{et}Km_d^{-1/2}(-r_t)^{-1/2}$ with signs $\epsilon_{kt}=\pm1$, and (a), divided by $Km_dm_e^{-1/2}$, becomes \[ \textstyle\sum_{t\in T}m_t\big(\epsilon_{dt}\,r_t^{-1/2}+\xi\,\epsilon_{et}(-r_t)^{-1/2}\big)=0,\qquad\xi=(m_e/m_d)^{3/2}. \] With $g_t=m_t|r_t|^{-1/2}$, its real and imaginary parts are \[ \epsilon_{db}g_b+\xi(\epsilon_{ea}g_a+\epsilon_{ec}g_c)=0,\qquad\epsilon_{da}g_a+\epsilon_{dc}g_c+\xi\epsilon_{eb}g_b=0 . \] Their product gives $(\epsilon_{da}g_a+\epsilon_{dc}g_c)(\epsilon_{ea}g_a+\epsilon_{ec}g_c)=\sigma_bg_b^2$, where $\sigma_t=\epsilon_{dt}\epsilon_{et}$. If $\sigma_a=\sigma_c$, the left side is $\sigma_a(g_a\pm g_c)^2$, so $\sigma_b=\sigma_a$ and $g_b=|g_a\pm g_c|$, and the second equation implies $\xi=1$. If $\sigma_a=-\sigma_c$, the left side is $\sigma_a(g_a^2-g_c^2)$, so $g_a^2=g_b^2+g_c^2$ or $g_c^2=g_a^2+g_b^2$, and in the second case the second equation gives $\xi=(g_c\pm g_a)/g_b$. Finally, the formulas for $m_t$ and $r_t$ yield $g_t^2=(s^2+s+1)A_t(s)/D(s)$ with $D=s^6(1-s)(1+s)^6(2s+1)(s+2)>0$. The three cases are therefore: $P_{28}(s)=0$ and $\xi=1$; $A_a(s)-A_b(s)-A_c(s)=0$; and $P_{14}(s)=0$ and $\xi^{\pm1}=(\sqrt{A_c}+\sqrt{A_a})/\sqrt{A_b}=\sqrt y+\sqrt{1+y}$ with $y=A_a(s)/A_b(s)$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:torquepoly}, the first case leads to $s\in\{s_2,s_3\}$ and $m_d=m_e$, the second does not occur, and the third leads to $s=s_1$ and $\xi^{\pm1}=\xi_1$. \end{proof} For diagram~$4$, part~(a) is the condition $f_1=f_2$ of \cite[Lemma~8.9(a)]{CT26}. In their notation the bodies $d$, $e$ are $1$, $2$, and the leading coefficient $\hat p_{ik}$ corresponds to $D_{ik}$. With $S_i=\sum_{k\in T}m_kD_{ik}$ and \cite[Lemma~8.7(a)]{CT26}, the condition $f_1=f_2$ reads $m_1S_1+m_2S_2=0$, which is~(a).