\section{The thirty-six curves}\label{sec:curves} In this section and the next the masses are $A'=(4,4,4,4,1)$, the image of $(1,4,4,4,4)$ under the exchange of bodies $1$ and $5$, so that body $5$ is light. For cube roots of unity $\zeta_1$, $\zeta_2$ let $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ be the affine subspace of the coordinate space of $Y_{A'}$ defined by \begin{gather*} p_{12}=p_{34}=\tfrac{\zeta_1}2,\qquad p_{14}=p_{23}=\tfrac{\zeta_2}2,\qquad p_{15}=p_{35}=-2p_{13},\qquad p_{25}=p_{45}=-2p_{24},\\ u_3=-1,\qquad u_4=-u_2,\qquad v_3=-v_1,\qquad v_4=-v_2, \end{gather*} and put $\cC'(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)=Y_{A'}\cap\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$. On $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ we write $D_1=p_{15}$ and $D_2=p_{25}$. On $Y_{A'}$ the function $\tau=(1+u_2)/(1-u_2)$ is regular, since $u_{12}\ne0$. Let \[ h_1(\tau)=\frac{\tau}{(\tau+1)(\zeta_1\tau+\zeta_2)},\qquad h_2(\tau)=\frac{\tau}{(\tau-1)(\zeta_2-\zeta_1\tau)} . \] \begin{theorem}\label{thm:36} \begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\alph*)}] \item $\cC'(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ is the set of points of $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ with \begin{gather*} u_2=\frac{\tau-1}{\tau+1},\qquad v_1=\frac{(\tau+1)(\zeta_1\tau+\zeta_2)}{\tau},\qquad v_2=\frac{(\tau+1)(\zeta_2-\zeta_1\tau)}{\tau},\\ D_1^2=h_1(\tau),\qquad D_2^2=h_2(\tau) \end{gather*} and $\tau\in\C\setminus\{0,\pm1,\pm\zeta_2/\zeta_1\}$. Thus $(\tau,D_1,D_2)$ identifies it with an unramified four-sheeted cover of $\C\setminus\{0,\pm1,\pm\zeta_2/\zeta_1\}$. \item If $\zeta_1\ne\zeta_2$, then $\cC'(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ is an irreducible curve of genus $3$. Its smooth completion has twelve places at infinity, two over each of $\tau=0,\infty,\pm1,\pm\zeta_2/\zeta_1$, each of ramification index $2$ over the $\tau$-line. \item If $\zeta_1=\zeta_2=\zeta$, then $\cC'(\zeta,\zeta)$ is the disjoint union of two irreducible rational curves $\cC^\pm(\zeta)$, defined by $D_1D_2=\pm i\tau/(\zeta(\tau^2-1))$. Each is parametrized by $s=\sqrt\zeta\,(\tau+1)D_1$, which satisfies $s^2=\tau$, and has six places at infinity, $s=0,\infty,\pm1,\pm i$. \item These twelve curves and their images under the relabellings $(23)$ and $(34)$, which fix $A'$, are $36$ pairwise disjoint irreducible curves in $Y_{A'}$, $18$ of genus $3$ and $18$ rational. \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} We write $\cC_{A'}$ for the union of the $36$ curves and $\cC_A\subset Y_A$, $A=(1,4,4,4,4)$, for its image under the exchange of bodies $1$ and $5$ (\S\ref{ss:slice}). \begin{proof} (a) We first reduce the rows. On $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ the positions are $z=(1,u_2,-1,-u_2,0)$ and $w=(v_1,v_2,-v_1,-v_2,0)$, so $\sum_km_kz_k=\sum_km_kw_k=0$. The ten rows $D_{kl}$ reduce to four equations, since $p_{12}^2=\zeta_1^2/4=1/(4\zeta_1)$ and likewise on the other sides: \begin{align*} (1-u_2)(v_1-v_2)&=4\zeta_1\quad(12,\,34), & (1+u_2)(v_1+v_2)&=4\zeta_2\quad(14,\,23),\\ D_1^2v_1&=1\quad(13,\,15,\,35), & D_2^2u_2v_2&=1\quad(24,\,25,\,45). \end{align*} The rows $Z_k$ and $W_k$ vanish identically on $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$. Indeed, with $p_{kl}^3=\frac18$ on the four sides and $p_{13}=-D_1/2$, $p_{24}=-D_2/2$, \begin{gather*} F_1(u)=1-\tfrac12(1-u_2)-\tfrac12(1+u_2)-8p_{13}^3-D_1^3=0,\\ F_2(u)=u_2-\tfrac12(u_2-1)-\tfrac12(u_2+1)-u_2(8p_{24}^3+D_2^3)=0,\\ F_5(u)=4\big(D_1^3(u_1+u_3)+D_2^3(u_2+u_4)\big)=0, \end{gather*} and $F_3(u)=F_4(u)=0$ by the symmetry $z\mapsto-z$, $1\leftrightarrow3$, $2\leftrightarrow4$ of $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$. The functions $F_k(v)$ vanish in the same way. Hence $\cC'(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ is defined in $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ by the four equations and by the nonvanishing of the coordinates and their differences. With $\tau=(1+u_2)/(1-u_2)$ we have $1-u_2=2/(\tau+1)$ and $1+u_2=2\tau/(\tau+1)$. Then $v_1-v_2=2\zeta_1(\tau+1)$ and $v_1+v_2=2\zeta_2(\tau+1)/\tau$, which give the stated $v_1$ and $v_2$, and $D_1^2=1/v_1=h_1$, $D_2^2=1/(u_2v_2)=h_2$. Since $u_2$ is finite and $u_{12}\ne0$, the function $\tau$ takes neither the value $-1$ nor $\infty$. The values $\tau=0$, $1$, $-\zeta_2/\zeta_1$ and $\zeta_2/\zeta_1$ mean $u_{23}=0$, $u_2=0$, $v_1=0$ and $v_2=0$. For every other $\tau$ and every choice of $D_1$, $D_2$, all coordinates and their differences are nonzero. Since $\tau$, $D_1$ and $D_2$ are regular functions on $Y_{A'}$, the map is an isomorphism onto its image. Neither $h_1$ nor $h_2$ has a zero or a pole over the base, so the cover is unramified. (b) If $\zeta_1\ne\zeta_2$, then $\zeta_2/\zeta_1$ is a primitive cube root of unity, and $\pm1$, $\pm\zeta_2/\zeta_1$ are four distinct points. None of $h_1$, $h_2$, $h_1h_2$ is a square in $\C(\tau)$: $h_1$ has a simple pole at $-1$, $h_2$ at $1$, and $h_1h_2$ at $\pm1$ and $\pm\zeta_2/\zeta_1$. Hence $\C(\tau)(\sqrt{h_1},\sqrt{h_2})$ has degree $4$ over $\C(\tau)$, and the curve is irreducible. Over each of $0$, $\infty$, $\pm1$, $\pm\zeta_2/\zeta_1$ at least one of $h_1$, $h_2$ has odd order: both have order $1$ at $0$ and at $\infty$, $h_1$ has a simple pole at $-1$ and at $-\zeta_2/\zeta_1$, where $h_2$ is a unit, and the reverse holds at $1$ and $\zeta_2/\zeta_1$. The inertia group therefore has order $2$, and there are two places of index $2$ over each of these six points. By the Riemann--Hurwitz formula, $2g-2=4\cdot(-2)+6\cdot2$, so $g=3$. (c) If $\zeta_1=\zeta_2=\zeta$, then $h_1=\tau/(\zeta(\tau+1)^2)$, $h_2=-\tau/(\zeta(\tau-1)^2)$ and $h_1h_2=\big(i\tau/(\zeta(\tau^2-1))\big)^2$. Thus $D_1D_2=\pm i\tau/(\zeta(\tau^2-1))$ on $\cC'(\zeta,\zeta)$, and the two signs define disjoint closed subsets. On each of them $D_2$ is determined by $D_1$, and $s=\sqrt\zeta\,(\tau+1)D_1$ satisfies $s^2=\zeta(\tau+1)^2h_1=\tau$. Each of them is therefore isomorphic to $\C\setminus\{0,\pm1,\pm i\}$. (d) Distinct pairs $(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ yield disjoint curves, since $p_{12}$ or $p_{14}$ differs, and $\cC^+(\zeta)\cap\cC^-(\zeta)=\emptyset$ by (c). The relabellings $(23)$ and $(34)$ fix bodies $1$ and $5$, so they act by $u_k\mapsto u_{\sigma(k)}$. The curves above satisfy $u_3=-1$. Their images under $(23)$ satisfy $u_2=-1$, and those under $(34)$ satisfy $u_4=-1$. Two of these conditions together force a collision of two heavy bodies. \end{proof} The diagonals of the curves of Theorem~\ref{thm:36}(a)--(c) are the pairs $13$ and $24$; we say that they belong to the \emph{split} $13|24$. Their images under $(23)$ and $(34)$ belong to the splits $12|34$ and $14|23$. \subsection{The real points}\label{ss:real} Let $\sigma$ be the composition of complex conjugation with the colour exchange $\sigma_c$ of \S\ref{ss:slice}: \[ \sigma(u,v,p)=(\bar v/\bar v_1,\ \bar v_1\bar u,\ \bar p), \] an antiholomorphic involution of $Y_{A'}$. On configurations it is $(z,w,p)\mapsto(\bar w,\bar z,\bar p)$. \begin{proposition}\label{prop:real} \begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\alph*)}] \item The fixed points of $\sigma$ are the points given by real configurations, with real $p_{kl}=\pm1/r_{kl}$. The positive normalized central configurations correspond to fixed points with all $p_{kl}>0$. \item The thirty of the $36$ curves that lie in a set $\cC'(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ with $(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)\ne(1,1)$, or in its image under $(23)$ or $(34)$, contain no fixed point of $\sigma$, and $\sigma$ maps each of them onto another of the $36$ curves. \item The other six curves, $\cC^\pm(1)$ and their images, are mapped onto themselves. Their fixed points are the points with $|\tau|=1$, $\tau\ne\pm1$. At each of them $p_{13}=-p_{15}/2$, in the labelling of the split $13|24$, so $p_{13}p_{15}<0$. \end{enumerate} In particular no point of $\cC_{A'}$, and no point of $\cC_A$, corresponds to a positive normalized central configuration. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} (a) Let $x=\sigma(x)$. Then $p$ is real and $v_1=\bar v_1\bar u_1=\bar v_1$. The row $D_{15}$ shows that $v_1=1/p_{15}^2>0$. With $c=\sqrt{v_1}>0$, the rotated point $z=cu$, $w=c^{-1}v$ satisfies $w=c^{-1}v_1\bar u=c\bar u=\bar z$. This is a real configuration, with real $p_{kl}=\pm1/r_{kl}$. Conversely, a real configuration rotated to $u_1=1$ is fixed by $\sigma$. (b) The colour exchange maps $\Lambda(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ onto itself: $(v/v_1,v_1u)$ has again the form $(1,\ast,-1,-\ast)$, $(\ast,\ast,-\ast,-\ast)$, and $p$ is unchanged. Hence $\sigma_c$ maps $\cC'(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)$ onto itself, by $\tau\mapsto\zeta_2/(\zeta_1\tau)$ and keeping $D_1$, $D_2$. Conjugation maps it onto $\cC'(\bar\zeta_1,\bar\zeta_2)$. If $(\zeta_1,\zeta_2)\ne(1,1)$, then $p_{12}$ or $p_{14}$ is not real, so the curve has no fixed point, and its image $\cC'(\bar\zeta_1,\bar\zeta_2)$ is another curve. For each split this accounts for the six curves of genus $3$ and the four curves $\cC^\pm(\zeta)$ with $\zeta\ne1$. The relabellings commute with $\sigma$. (c) Let $\zeta_1=\zeta_2=1$. The map $\sigma_c$ acts by $\tau\mapsto1/\tau$ and keeps $D_1D_2$, while $i\tau/(\tau^2-1)$ changes sign. So $\sigma_c$ exchanges $\cC^+(1)$ and $\cC^-(1)$. Conjugation exchanges them as well, so $\sigma$ maps each of them onto itself and acts on $\tau$ by $\tau\mapsto1/\bar\tau$, and a fixed point has $|\tau|=1$. Write $\tau=e^{i\theta}$ with $\theta\notin\pi\Z$. Then \begin{gather*} u=\big(1,\ i\tan\tfrac\theta2,\ -1,\ -i\tan\tfrac\theta2\big),\\ D_1^2=\frac1{4\cos^2(\theta/2)},\qquad D_2^2=\frac1{4\sin^2(\theta/2)},\qquad D_1D_2=\pm\frac1{2\sin\theta}. \end{gather*} All $p_{kl}$ are real, and one checks directly that these points are fixed. On each of $\cC^\pm(1)$ they form four arcs, one for each sign pattern of $(D_1,D_2)$. At each of them $p_{13}=-D_1/2=-p_{15}/2$. \end{proof} The fixed points of Proposition~\ref{prop:real}(c) are rhombi with the light body at the centre and sides of length $2$. On the arcs with $D_1,D_2<0$ the diagonal and side inverse distances are positive, and $p_{k5}<0$ for $k\le4$. Changing $(m_5,p_{k5})$ into $(-m_5,-p_{k5})$ preserves the rows $D_{kl}$ and the terms $m_5p_{k5}^3(z_k-z_5)$ in the equations of bodies $k\le4$. It changes the sign of the right side of the equation of body $5$, which vanishes on these rhombi by their symmetry. This change maps these arcs onto Roberts' continuum of central configurations with the masses $(4,4,4,4,-1)$ \cite{Rob99}, in the normalization of \cite[(2.1)]{Tom26}. The arcs are the continuum of solutions of \cite[(2.1)]{Tom26} with the masses $(4,4,4,4,1)$ that Albouy and Kaloshin obtained from Roberts' continuum, the \emph{modified Roberts continuum} \cite[p.~543 and Remark~8]{AK12}, which Chen and Tong write explicitly \cite[Remark~7.14]{CT26}. The fixed points of $\sigma$ on $\cC_{A'}$ form an infinite set. Therefore the finiteness of the positive normalized central configurations at $A'$ does not follow from the complex equations, even together with the real structure $\sigma$. It requires the signs of the $p_{kl}$, which enter here as $p_{13}p_{15}<0$.