\documentclass[11pt]{amsart} \pdfsuppressptexinfo=-1 \usepackage[margin=1.1in]{geometry} \usepackage[T1]{fontenc} \usepackage{lmodern} \usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools} \usepackage{booktabs,enumitem} \usepackage[hidelinks]{hyperref} \hypersetup{pdftitle={Bounds for the weak type (1,1) constant of the centred maximal operator over squares}, pdfauthor={Tejasvi Singh Tomar}} \newtheorem{theorem}[equation]{Theorem} \newtheorem{lemma}[equation]{Lemma} \newtheorem{proposition}[equation]{Proposition} \newtheorem{corollary}[equation]{Corollary} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{definition}[equation]{Definition} \theoremstyle{remark} \newtheorem{remark}[equation]{Remark} \numberwithin{equation}{section} \setlength{\emergencystretch}{2em} \newcommand{\R}{\mathbb{R}} \newcommand{\Z}{\mathbb{Z}} \newcommand{\dd}{\,\mathrm{d}} \newcommand{\supp}{\operatorname{supp}} \newcommand{\Cc}{C_c^\infty} \newcommand{\CBOUND}{3.59123} \newcommand{\MASSHALF}{3.591224327\ldots} \newcommand{\ALPHA}{47/40} \newcommand{\RR}{33/20} \newcommand{\HH}{1/32} \newcommand{\CC}{1977601376167/1099511627776} \newcommand{\CCdec}{1.7986179\ldots} \newcommand{\NCLASS}{1{,}181} \newcommand{\MAXIDX}{70} \newcommand{\SUPPU}{9/4} \newcommand{\DENMAX}{2^{40}} \newcommand{\SINGHALF}{3.8721047\ldots} \newcommand{\SPLHALF}{-0.2808804\ldots} \newcommand{\Calpha}{4.2391860\ldots} \newcommand{\Kappa}{6.4600705\ldots} \newcommand{\VAmin}{1.3\cdot10^{-8}} \newcommand{\LocalMinA}{2.8\cdot10^{-4}} \newcommand{\ZENODODOI}{10.5281/zenodo.23716078} \newcommand{\REPOURL}{https://github.com/tejasvi/square-maximal-weak-type/tree/v5} \newcommand{\LBDEC}{1.7027237335} \newcommand{\LBATOMS}{50} \newcommand{\LBROWN}{6} \newcommand{\LBREACH}{1396/125} \newcommand{\LBDENEXP}{40} \newcommand{\LBPX}{3.2873} \newcommand{\LBPY}{2.7437} \newcommand{\LBW}{4.0084} \newcommand{\LBFRAME}{1.6447} \newcommand{\LEANUPTHM}{Hl47a.\allowbreak weakType\allowbreak Constant\_\allowbreak two\_\allowbreak le} \newcommand{\LEANLOWTHM}{CenteredMaximal.\allowbreak ofReal\_\allowbreak le\_\allowbreak weakType\allowbreak Constant\_\allowbreak two} \begin{document} \title[Weak type constant over squares]{Bounds for the weak type $(1,1)$ constant of the centred maximal operator over squares} \author{Tejasvi Singh Tomar} \renewcommand{\urladdrname}{{\itshape ORCID}} \urladdr{\href{https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4668-3639}{https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4668-3639}} \subjclass[2020]{42B25; 35R11, 65G40, 68V05, 68V20} \keywords{Hardy--Littlewood maximal function, weak type $(1,1)$, best constants, fractional Laplacian, partial balayage, computer-assisted proof, formal verification, Lean 4} \begin{abstract} Let $c_2$ be the best constant in the weak type $(1,1)$ inequality for the centred Hardy--Littlewood maximal operator over axis-parallel squares in the plane. We prove $\LBDEC\le c_2\le\CBOUND$, improving the bounds $1.6855\ldots\le c_2<3.615749$ obtained by Lin. The upper bound comes from a new kernel in Lin's comparison principle, which bounds $c_2$ by half the integral of a suitable kernel; closed forms for the fractional operator in this principle make its conditions checkable. The lower bound comes from a periodic measure obtained by modifying Lin's lattice of point masses. Both proofs are computer-assisted and formally verified in Lean. \end{abstract} \maketitle \section{Introduction}\label{sec:intro} For $f\in L^1(\R^2)$ and $x\in\R^2$ let \[ Mf(x)=\sup_{r>0}\frac{1}{|Q(x,r)|}\int_{Q(x,r)}|f(y)|\dd y, \] where $Q(x,r)$ is the closed square with centre $x$, sides parallel to the axes and side length $2r$, and $|E|$ is the Lebesgue measure of $E$. Let $c_2$ be the least constant such that \begin{equation}\label{eq:weak} \lambda\,\bigl|\{x:\ Mf(x)\ge\lambda\}\bigr|\le c_2\,\|f\|_1\qquad(f\in L^1(\R^2),\ \lambda>0). \end{equation} The same constant is obtained with the strict level sets $\{Mf>\lambda\}$, since $\{Mf\ge\lambda\}$ is the decreasing intersection of the sets $\{Mf>\lambda'\}$, $\lambda'<\lambda$, which have finite measure. The best constant in the weak type $(1,1)$ inequality for the centred maximal operator is known only in dimension one, where it is $(11+\sqrt{61})/12$ \cite{Mel03}; in higher dimensions it is not known, and for cubes the constants tend to infinity with the dimension \cite{Ald11}, while for Euclidean balls they grow at most like $\sqrt n\log n$ \cite{SS26}. The plane is thus the first open case. For squares, the Vitali covering argument shows that $c_2\le9$, and a refinement yields $c_2\le4$ \cite[Exercise~42]{Tao10}; both are stated there for balls, and the same arguments apply to squares. Aldaz proved the lower bound $c_2\ge3/4-\sqrt2/4+\sqrt6/2=1.6211\ldots$ \cite{Ald00}. The constant $c_2$ is also entry 47a of the list of optimization constants collected by Tao and others \cite{Tao26}. Lin improved both bounds. He proved $c_2\ge1.6855\ldots$ with a periodic measure \cite{Lin26b}, and an upper bound by comparison with a nonlocal operator \cite{Lin26a}, adapting the partial balayage method of Spector and Stockdale \cite{SS26}. In coordinates $(u,v)$ in which squares become diamonds, let $r=|u|+|v|$ and let $D=\{r\le1\}$ be the unit diamond. For $0<\alpha<2$ let $A_\alpha=-|\partial_u|^\alpha-|\partial_v|^\alpha$, the Fourier multiplier with symbol $-(|\xi_1|^\alpha+|\xi_2|^\alpha)$. Lin's comparison principle states that $c_2\le\frac12\int K$ for every even integrable kernel $K$ with $K\ge\mathbf 1_D$ (that is, $K\ge0$, and $K\ge1$ on $D$) and $A_\alpha K\ge0$ on $\R^2\setminus\{0\}$. With $\alpha=1$ and an explicit kernel, Lin proves $c_2<3.878624$ from this principle; this proof and that of the lower bound are formalized in Lean \cite{Lin26b}. With a kernel for $\alpha=6/5$, made of a truncated power of $r$ and cubic B-splines, Lin obtained $c_2<3.615749$ \cite{Lin26a,Lin26c}, and his formalization \cite{Lin26d} proves the weaker bound $c_2<452/125=3.616$ with this kernel in Lean. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:main} $c_2\le\CBOUND$. \end{theorem} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:lower} $c_2\ge\LBDEC$. \end{theorem} The proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:main} applies the comparison principle to an explicit kernel in Lin's family, \begin{equation}\label{eq:kernel} K(u,v)=c\,\Psi(|u|+|v|)+S(u,v),\qquad S(u,v)=\sum_{i,j}a_{ij}\,B\Bigl(\frac uh-i\Bigr)B\Bigl(\frac vh-j\Bigr), \end{equation} where $\Psi(r)=(r^{-\alpha}-R^{-\alpha})_+$ and $B$ is the centred cubic B-spline. We take $\alpha=\ALPHA$, $R=\RR$ and $h=\HH$ (Section~\ref{sec:kernel}). For Theorem~\ref{thm:lower} we use, as Lin does, that $c_2$ is at least the area of a part of a period cell on which the maximal function of a periodic measure is at least $1$, divided by the mass of the cell (Lemma~\ref{lem:periodic}). We apply this to Lin's lattice of point masses, with slightly changed periods and masses and with $48$ small atoms added to each period cell (Section~\ref{sec:lower}). Section~\ref{sec:principle} states the comparison principle (proved in Appendix~\ref{app:principle}, following \cite{Lin26a}), Section~\ref{sec:closed} computes $A_\alpha K$ in closed form, Section~\ref{sec:kernel} describes the kernel and Section~\ref{sec:verify} its verification. Section~\ref{sec:lower} proves Theorem~\ref{thm:lower}, Section~\ref{sec:gap} discusses the remaining gap, and Appendix~\ref{app:lean} describes the proofs of both theorems in Lean. \section{The comparison principle}\label{sec:principle} \subsection{Diamonds} Let $T(u,v)=(u+v,u-v)$. Then $|\det T|=2$ and $T(D)=[-1,1]^2$, since $\max(|u+v|,|u-v|)=|u|+|v|$. For $g\in L^1(\R^2)$ let \[ M_Dg(z)=\sup_{s>0}\frac{1}{2s^2}\int_{z+sD}|g(w)|\dd w . \] If $g=f\circ T$, then $\int_{z+sD}|g|=\frac12\int_{Q(Tz,s)}|f|$ and $|z+sD|=2s^2$, so $M_Dg=(Mf)\circ T$. Since also $|\{M_Dg>\lambda\}|=\frac12|\{Mf>\lambda\}|$ and $\|g\|_1=\frac12\|f\|_1$, the best weak type $(1,1)$ constant of $M_D$ is $c_2$. \subsection{The operator} For $0<\alpha<2$ and a function $f$ on $\R^2$ let \begin{equation}\label{eq:A} Af(x)=\sum_{j=1}^2\int_{\R}\bigl[f(x+te_j)+f(x-te_j)-2f(x)\bigr]\frac{\dd t}{|t|^{1+\alpha}}, \end{equation} where $e_1,e_2$ are the coordinate vectors. We write $\hat g(\xi)=\int g(x)e^{-ix\cdot\xi}\dd x$, so that $\int g\bar w=(2\pi)^{-2}\int\hat g\,\overline{\hat w}$ for $g,w\in L^2(\R^2)$, and $\psi(\xi)=|\xi_1|^\alpha+|\xi_2|^\alpha$. For $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2)$ the bracket in \eqref{eq:A} is at most $\min(t^2\|\nabla^2\phi\|_\infty,4\|\phi\|_\infty)$ in absolute value, so the integral converges absolutely and $A\phi$ is bounded and continuous. Outside $\supp\phi$ only the terms $\phi(x\pm te_j)$ remain, so $A\phi$ vanishes outside the union of $\supp\phi$ and two strips of bounded width parallel to the axes, and it is $O(|x|^{-1-\alpha})$ along each strip. Hence $A\phi\in L^1\cap L^\infty$, and by Fubini's theorem $\widehat{A\phi}=-d_\alpha\psi\hat\phi$, where \[ d_\alpha=\int_{\R}\frac{2(1-\cos t)}{|t|^{1+\alpha}}\dd t=\frac{4\Gamma(1-\alpha)\cos(\pi\alpha/2)}{\alpha}>0 \] (with $d_1=2\pi$). Thus $A=d_\alpha A_\alpha$ on $\Cc(\R^2)$, where $A_\alpha$ is the Fourier multiplier with symbol $-\psi$. The sign conditions below do not depend on this normalization. For $v\in L^1(\R^2)$ let \[ \mathcal E(v,v)=\sum_{j=1}^2\iint\bigl[v(x+te_j)-v(x)\bigr]^2\frac{\dd t\dd x}{|t|^{1+\alpha}}\in[0,\infty]. \] By Plancherel's identity (in $[0,\infty]$) for each $t$ and Tonelli's theorem, $\mathcal E(v,v)=(2\pi)^{-2}d_\alpha\int\psi|\hat v|^2$. Let $H$ be the space of $v\in L^1(\R^2)$ with $\mathcal E(v,v)<\infty$. Since $\hat v$ is bounded and $\psi(\xi)\ge|\xi|^\alpha$, every $v\in H$ has $\hat v\in L^2$, so $H\subset L^1\cap L^2$. On $H$ we use the bilinear form $\mathcal E(v,w)=(2\pi)^{-2}d_\alpha\int\psi\,\hat v\,\overline{\hat w}$. Then $\Cc(\R^2)\subset H$, and $\mathcal E(v,\phi)=-\int v\,A\phi$ for $v\in H$ and $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2)$ by Plancherel's identity. Since $|a_+-b_+|\le|a-b|$, $v_+\in H$ for every $v\in H$. For $K\in L^1(\R^2)$ we write $AK\ge0$ on $\R^2\setminus\{0\}$ if $\int K\,A\phi\ge0$ for every nonnegative $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2\setminus\{0\})$. \begin{theorem}[Lin]\label{thm:principle} Let $0<\alpha<2$ and let $K\in L^1(\R^2)$ be even, with $K\ge0$ almost everywhere, $K\ge1$ almost everywhere on $D$, and $AK\ge0$ on $\R^2\setminus\{0\}$. Then $c_2\le\frac12\int K$. \end{theorem} This is \cite[Theorem~1]{Lin26a}, where the first two conditions are written $K\ge\mathbf 1_D$; see also \cite[Principle~2 and Corollary~3.1]{Lin26c}. We follow the proof in \cite{Lin26a}, which treats the transfer step (Lemma~\ref{lem:transfer} below) for $f\in\Cc$, and write out the extension to integrable $f$, which \cite{Lin26c} outlines. For $s>0$ let $K_s(x)=s^{-2}K(x/s)$, and for $f\ge0$ let $M_Kf=\sup_{s>0}K_s*f$. \begin{lemma}[{\cite[Lemma~1]{Lin26a}}]\label{lem:domination} If $K\ge0$ almost everywhere and $K\ge1$ almost everywhere on $D$, then $M_Dg\le\frac12M_K|g|$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} $K_s\ge s^{-2}\mathbf 1_{sD}$ almost everywhere and $D=-D$, so $\frac{1}{2s^2}\int_{z+sD}|g|=\frac{1}{2s^2}\int_{sD}|g(z-w)|\dd w\le\frac12(K_s*|g|)(z)$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}[{\cite[Lemma~2]{Lin26a}}]\label{lem:obstacle} Let $0\le f\in\Cc(\R^2)$ and $\mu>0$. There are $U\in H$ with $U\ge0$ and a measurable $\sigma$ with $0\le\sigma\le\mu$ such that $\int U\,A\phi=\int(\sigma-f)\phi$ for every $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2)$, $\sigma=\mu$ almost everywhere on $\Omega=\{U>0\}$, and $\int\sigma=\int f$. In particular $\mu|\Omega|\le\|f\|_1$. \end{lemma} We quote this lemma and outline Lin's proof. Lin states the lemma for $A_\alpha$, and dividing his solution by $d_\alpha$ yields the form above. His proof, in the present normalization, minimizes $\frac12\mathcal E(v,v)+\mu\int v-\int fv$ over nonnegative $v\in H$. The functional is coercive by the fractional Sobolev inequality \cite{DNPV12}, and weak compactness yields a minimizer $U$. Truncation in the variational inequality leads to the Lewy--Stampacchia bound $-f\le AU\le\mu-f$ in the sense of distributions. The function $\sigma=f+AU$ then satisfies $0\le\sigma\le\mu$. Testing the Euler--Lagrange identity with $U$ itself shows that $\int U(\mu-\sigma)=0$, so $\sigma=\mu$ on $\Omega$. Finally, $\int\sigma=\int f$ follows by testing with $\chi(\cdot/\rho)$ and using $\|A[\chi(\cdot/\rho)]\|_\infty=\rho^{-\alpha}\|A\chi\|_\infty$. \begin{lemma}[after {\cite[Lemma~3]{Lin26a}}]\label{lem:transfer} Under the hypotheses of Theorem~\ref{thm:principle}, every bounded, compactly supported, measurable $f\ge0$ and every $\lambda>0$ satisfy $|\{M_Kf>\lambda\}|\le\|K\|_1\|f\|_1/\lambda$. \end{lemma} We prove Lemma~\ref{lem:transfer} and Theorem~\ref{thm:principle} in Appendix~\ref{app:principle}. \section{The operator on the kernel}\label{sec:closed} Throughout this section $1<\alpha<2$. The kernel \eqref{eq:kernel} is continuous on $\R^2\setminus\{0\}$, and, for $c>0$, $K(x)\to\infty$ as $x\to0$. We first show that the pointwise values of $AK$ determine the sign condition of Theorem~\ref{thm:principle}. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:regularity} Let $K$ be given by \eqref{eq:kernel} with finitely many nonzero $a_{ij}$. For every $x=(u,v)$ with $uv\ne0$ and $|u|+|v|\ne R$ the integral \eqref{eq:A} for $AK(x)$ converges absolutely, and $\int K\,A\phi=\int(AK)\phi$ for every $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2\setminus\{0\})$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $G(x)=\sum_j\int|K(x+te_j)+K(x-te_j)-2K(x)|\,|t|^{-1-\alpha}\dd t\in[0,\infty]$. At a point $x$ as in the statement, $K$ is $C^2$ near $x$ and bounded on the two lines $x+\R e_j$, which do not pass through the origin, so $G(x)<\infty$. We show that $G$ is locally integrable on $\R^2\setminus\{0\}$. The part $|t|\ge1$, integrated over a compact set $E$, is at most $C(\|K\|_1+\int_E|K|)$, since $K\in L^1$. For $|t|<1$, the spline part $S$ is $C^2$ with bounded second derivatives, so its second differences are $O(t^2)$. The function $\Psi(|u|+|v|)$ is $C^2$ off the axes, the curve $r=R$ and the origin. Near a point at distance $\delta$ from the axes or from $r=R$ and away from the origin, its second difference along $e_j$ is $O(t^2)$ for $|t|<\delta$ and $O(|t|)$ for $|t|\ge\delta$ (segments that pass near the origin are treated next), so its contribution to $G$ is $O(\delta^{1-\alpha})$, which is integrable because $\alpha<2$. Finally, if the line $x+\R e_j$ passes at distance $\delta$ from the origin, the singularity $(\,|\tau|+\delta)^{-\alpha}$ of $\Psi$ on it contributes $O(\delta^{1-\alpha}|x|^{-1-\alpha})$, again integrable near the axes. Hence $G\in L^1_{\mathrm{loc}}(\R^2\setminus\{0\})$. For $\varepsilon>0$ let $A_\varepsilon$ denote \eqref{eq:A} restricted to $|t|>\varepsilon$. By Fubini's theorem and the substitutions $x\mapsto x\mp te_j$, $\int K\,A_\varepsilon\phi=\int(A_\varepsilon K)\phi$. As $\varepsilon\to0$ the left side tends to $\int K\,A\phi$ by dominated convergence, since the bracket for $\phi$ is $O(\min(t^2,1))$ and $K\in L^1$. The right side tends to $\int(AK)\phi$ by dominated convergence with majorant $G|\phi|$. \end{proof} \subsection{B-splines} Let $B(x)=\frac1{12}\sum_{k=-2}^2w_k|x-k|^3$ with $(w_{-2},\dots,w_2)=(1,-4,6,-4,1)$. This is the centred cubic B-spline: $B$ is $C^2$, supported in $[-2,2]$, with $B(x)=(4-6x^2+3|x|^3)/6$ for $|x|\le1$, $B(x)=(2-|x|)^3/6$ for $1\le|x|\le2$, and $\int B=1$. For a function $b$ on $\R$ let $L_\alpha b(s)=\int[b(s+t)+b(s-t)-2b(s)]|t|^{-1-\alpha}\dd t$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:bspline} $L_\alpha B(s)=\kappa\sum_{k=-2}^2w_k|s-k|^{3-\alpha}$ with $\kappa=-2/(\alpha(1-\alpha)(2-\alpha)(3-\alpha))$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} With $\hat b(\xi)=\int b(x)e^{-ix\xi}\dd x$ we have $\hat B(\xi)=(2-2\cos\xi)^2/\xi^4$ and $(2-2\cos\xi)^2=\sum_kw_ke^{-ik\xi}$, and $\widehat{L_\alpha B}(\xi)=-d_\alpha|\xi|^\alpha\hat B(\xi)$ with $d_\alpha$ as in Section~\ref{sec:principle}. For $1-5$. Hence, with $q=3-\alpha$, the Fourier transform of $\sum_kw_k|x-k|^{3-\alpha}$ is $c_{3-\alpha}|\xi|^{\alpha-4}(2-2\cos\xi)^2$, and $\widehat{L_\alpha B}$ is $-d_\alpha/c_{3-\alpha}$ times it. Both $L_\alpha B$ and $\sum_kw_k|x-k|^{3-\alpha}$ are continuous and bounded, so they agree up to this factor. Finally $-d_\alpha/c_{3-\alpha}=-2\Gamma(1-\alpha)/(\alpha\Gamma(4-\alpha))=\kappa$. \end{proof} Consequently, since only finitely many $a_{ij}$ are nonzero, \begin{equation}\label{eq:AS} AS(u,v)=h^{-\alpha}\kappa\sum_m\Bigl[\Bigl|\frac uh-m\Bigr|^{3-\alpha}P_m\Bigl(\frac vh\Bigr)+\Bigl|\frac vh-m\Bigr|^{3-\alpha}P'_m\Bigl(\frac uh\Bigr)\Bigr], \end{equation} where $P_m(y)=\sum_j\bigl(\sum_kw_ka_{m-k,j}\bigr)B(y-j)$ and $P'_m(y)=\sum_i\bigl(\sum_kw_ka_{i,m-k}\bigr)B(y-i)$. \subsection{Powers of the diamond norm} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:power} Let $r=|u|+|v|$ and \[ C_\alpha=-\frac{8\,\Gamma(1-\alpha)\,\Gamma(2\alpha)\cos^2(\pi\alpha/2)}{\Gamma(1+\alpha)}>0 . \] Then $\int r^{-\alpha}A\phi=C_\alpha\int r^{-2\alpha}\phi$ for every $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2\setminus\{0\})$. For every $(u,v)$ with $uv\ne0$ the integral \eqref{eq:A} for $A\,r^{-\alpha}$ converges absolutely and equals $C_\alpha r^{-2\alpha}$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For $0<\operatorname{Re}s<2$ the function $f_s=r^{-s}$ is locally integrable and tempered, and $r^{-s}=\Gamma(s)^{-1}\int_0^\infty\lambda^{s-1}e^{-\lambda|u|}e^{-\lambda|v|}\dd\lambda$. Since $\widehat{e^{-\lambda|x|}}=2\lambda/(\lambda^2+\xi^2)$, Fubini's theorem shows that $\hat f_s=m_s$, where \[ m_s(\xi)=\frac{1}{\Gamma(s)}\int_0^\infty\frac{4\lambda^{s+1}\dd\lambda}{(\lambda^2+\xi_1^2)(\lambda^2+\xi_2^2)}=k_s\,\frac{|\xi_1|^s-|\xi_2|^s}{\xi_1^2-\xi_2^2},\qquad k_s=\frac{2\pi}{\Gamma(s)\sin(\pi s/2)}, \] by partial fractions. Let $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2\setminus\{0\})$ be real. Since $f_\alpha\in L^1+L^2$ and $A\phi\in L^1\cap L^\infty$ with $\widehat{A\phi}=-d_\alpha\psi\hat\phi\in L^1$, Parseval's identity and $(|\xi_1|^\alpha+|\xi_2|^\alpha)(|\xi_1|^\alpha-|\xi_2|^\alpha)=|\xi_1|^{2\alpha}-|\xi_2|^{2\alpha}$ give \[ \int f_\alpha\,A\phi=-\frac{d_\alpha k_\alpha}{(2\pi)^2}\int n(\xi)\,\overline{\hat\phi(\xi)}\dd\xi,\qquad n(\xi)=\frac{|\xi_1|^{2\alpha}-|\xi_2|^{2\alpha}}{\xi_1^2-\xi_2^2}. \] The function $F(s)=\int r^{-s}\phi$ is entire. The function $G(s)=(2\pi)^{-2}\int m_s\overline{\hat\phi}$ is analytic on $0<\operatorname{Re}s<4$, apart from a possible pole of $k_s$ at $s=2$. It is removable, because $(|\xi_1|^s-|\xi_2|^s)/(\xi_1^2-\xi_2^2)$ equals $1$ at $s=2$ and $\int\hat\phi=(2\pi)^2\phi(0)=0$. Since $F=G$ on $0<\operatorname{Re}s<2$, they agree on $0<\operatorname{Re}s<4$, and at $s=2\alpha\in(2,4)$ we get $\int r^{-2\alpha}\phi=k_{2\alpha}(2\pi)^{-2}\int n\,\overline{\hat\phi}$. Hence $\int r^{-\alpha}A\phi=C_\alpha\int r^{-2\alpha}\phi$ with $C_\alpha=-d_\alpha k_\alpha/k_{2\alpha}$, which simplifies to the stated formula. For $1<\alpha<2$, $\Gamma(1-\alpha)<0$, so $C_\alpha>0$. Let $x=(u,v)$ with $uv\ne0$. Then $r^{-\alpha}$ is smooth near $x$ and at most $\min(|u|,|v|)^{-\alpha}$ on the lines $x+\R e_j$, so \eqref{eq:A} converges absolutely, locally uniformly in $x$, and $A\,r^{-\alpha}$ is continuous on $\{uv\ne0\}$. For $\phi\in\Cc(\{uv\ne0\})$ the argument in the second paragraph of the proof of Lemma~\ref{lem:regularity} shows that $\int r^{-\alpha}A\phi=\int(A\,r^{-\alpha})\phi$; on the left, dominated convergence applies because the bracket for $\phi$ vanishes unless $x$ lies in $\supp\phi$ or in one of two strips that avoid a neighbourhood of the origin, where $r^{-\alpha}$ is bounded. Hence $A\,r^{-\alpha}=C_\alpha r^{-2\alpha}$ on $\{uv\ne0\}$. \end{proof} The constants of Lemmas~\ref{lem:bspline} and~\ref{lem:power} are $\kappa=\Kappa$ and $C_\alpha=\Calpha$ for $\alpha=\ALPHA$. \subsection{The truncated power} Let $R>0$ and $\Psi(r)=(r^{-\alpha}-R^{-\alpha})_+$. By the symmetries of $A$ it suffices to consider $u,v\ge0$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:inside} For $u,v>0$ with $r=u+v0$ exactly for $t>R-r$ and for $t<-(R+u-v)$, and the two pieces contribute $2I(R-r)$ and $2I(R+u-v)$. The line $x+te_2$ contributes $2I(R-r)$ and $2I(R+v-u)$. The closed form follows from $\int_0^\infty(R+s)^{-\alpha}(d+s)^{-1-\alpha}\dd s=d^{-2\alpha}(2\alpha)^{-1}{}_2F_1(\alpha,2\alpha;2\alpha+1;1-R/d)$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:outside} For $u,v>0$ with $u+v>R$, \[ A\Psi(|u|+|v|)=2J(u,v)+2J(v,u),\qquad J(x,y)=\int_{y-R}^{R-y}\Psi(|t|+y)\,|x-t|^{-1-\alpha}\dd t\qquad(y0,\ u+v>R\}$ the function $A\Psi$ is nonnegative and nonincreasing in $u$ and in $v$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} $\Psi$ vanishes at $x$, so $A\Psi(x)=\sum_j\int\Psi(|x+te_j|_1)\,2|t|^{-1-\alpha}\dd t$. On the line $x+te_1$, parametrized by $s=u+t$, the integrand is $\Psi(|s|+v)|s-u|^{-1-\alpha}$, supported in $|s|0$ and finitely many atoms $p$ in each bounded set we write $M\mu(x)=\sup_{s>0}\mu(Q(x,s))/(4s^2)$, with the closed squares $Q(x,s)=\{y:|y-x|_\infty\le s\}$ of Section~\ref{sec:intro}. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:rect} Let $\mu$ be such a measure, let $\lambda>0$, let $S$ be a finite set of atoms of $\mu$, and let $0<\rho\le\sqrt{\mu(S)/(4\lambda)}$. Then $M\mu\ge\lambda$ on the rectangle $R_S(\rho)=\bigcap_{p\in S}Q(p,\rho)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} If $x\in R_S(\rho)$, then $|p-x|_\infty\le\rho$ for every $p\in S$, so $S\subset Q(x,\rho)$ and $\mu(Q(x,\rho))\ge\mu(S)\ge4\lambda\rho^2$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:periodic} Let $\mu$ be periodic with respect to the lattice $P_x\Z\times P_y\Z$, with finitely many atoms in the cell $C=[0,P_x)\times[0,P_y)$, and let $\lambda>0$. Let $U$ be the union of the lattice translates of finitely many rectangles $R_1,\dots,R_n$, where each $R_i$ is contained in $R_{S_i}(\rho_i)$ for a finite set $S_i$ of atoms of $\mu$ and a number $0<\rho_i<\sqrt{\mu(S_i)/(4\lambda)}$. Then $c_2\ge\lambda\,|U\cap C|/\mu(C)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} We follow Lin's argument \cite{Lin26b}, which adapts the smoothing of point masses in \cite[Lemma~1.1]{Ald00} to atoms of arbitrary positive mass. Let $q$ be an integer with $q\min(P_x,P_y)\ge\max_i\rho_i$, let $N\ge2q$, and let $\mu_N$ be the restriction of $\mu$ to $B_N=[0,NP_x)\times[0,NP_y)$. Call the $(N-2q)^2$ cells $[kP_x,(k+1)P_x)\times[lP_y,(l+1)P_y)$ with $q\le k,l0$. The kernel $K_s$ is even, nonnegative and integrable with $\|K_s\|_1=\|K\|_1$, and $AK_s\ge0$ on $\R^2\setminus\{0\}$, because $\int K_s\,A\phi=s^{-\alpha}\int K\,A[\phi(s\,\cdot)]$. For $\phi\in\Cc(\R^2)$ let $\Lambda\phi=K_s*A\phi$, a bounded, continuous, integrable function. We show that $\Lambda$ satisfies the positive maximum principle. Let first $\phi\ge0$ with $\phi(0)=0$. Choose $\eta\in\Cc(\R^2)$ with $0\le\eta\le1$ and $\eta=1$ near $0$, and put $g_\varepsilon=\eta(\cdot/\varepsilon)\phi$. Since $\phi$ has a minimum at $0$, $\|g_\varepsilon\|_\infty\le C\varepsilon^2$ and $\|\nabla^2g_\varepsilon\|_\infty\le C$, hence $\|Ag_\varepsilon\|_\infty\le C\varepsilon^{2-\alpha}$. Since $K_s$ is even, \[ \Lambda\phi(0)=\int K_s\,A\phi=\int K_s\,A(\phi-g_\varepsilon)+\int K_s\,Ag_\varepsilon\ge-\|K\|_1\,C\varepsilon^{2-\alpha}, \] because $\phi-g_\varepsilon\ge0$ vanishes near $0$. Hence $\Lambda\phi(0)\ge0$, and by translation invariance $\Lambda\phi(x_0)\ge0$ whenever $\phi\ge0$ and $\phi(x_0)=0$. If $\phi$ attains a nonnegative global maximum $m$ at $x_0$, apply this to $m\chi(\cdot/\rho)-\phi$, where $\chi\in\Cc$ satisfies $0\le\chi\le1$ and $\chi=1$ on the unit ball, and let $\rho\to\infty$, using $\|\Lambda[\chi(\cdot/\rho)]\|_\infty\le\|K\|_1\rho^{-\alpha}\|A\chi\|_\infty$. We obtain $\Lambda\phi(x_0)\le0$. By Courr\`ege's theorem \cite{Cou64}, \[ \Lambda\phi=-\gamma\phi+b\cdot\nabla\phi+\operatorname{tr}(\Theta\nabla^2\phi)+\int\bigl(\phi(\cdot+z)-\phi-\mathbf 1_{|z|<1}\,z\cdot\nabla\phi\bigr)\dd\nu(z) \] with $\gamma\ge0$, a positive semidefinite matrix $\Theta$ and a L\'evy measure $\nu$. Testing with $\chi(\cdot/\rho)$ shows that $\gamma=0$. Since $K_s$ and $A$ are even, $\Lambda$ commutes with $\phi\mapsto\phi(-\cdot)$; after averaging the representation with its reflection we may take $b=0$ and $\nu$ symmetric. We compare the Fourier transforms of the two expressions for $\Lambda\phi$, which Fubini's theorem permits since $\int\min(1,|z|^2)\dd\nu(z)<\infty$, and obtain \begin{equation}\label{eq:symbol} \xi\cdot\Theta\xi+\int(1-\cos z\cdot\xi)\dd\nu(z)=d_\alpha\psi(\xi)\hat K_s(\xi)\qquad(\xi\in\R^2). \end{equation} The right side is at most $d_\alpha\|K\|_1\psi(\xi)=O(|\xi|^\alpha)$, and the left side is at least $\xi\cdot\Theta\xi$, so $\Theta=0$ because $\alpha<2$. For $v,w\in H$ let $\mathcal E_\Lambda(v,w)=(2\pi)^{-2}d_\alpha\int\psi\hat K_s\,\hat v\,\overline{\hat w}$. By \eqref{eq:symbol} with $\Theta=0$, Plancherel's identity for each $z$, Tonelli's theorem and polarization, \[ \mathcal E_\Lambda(v,w)=\frac12\iint\bigl[v(x+z)-v(x)\bigr]\bigl[w(x+z)-w(x)\bigr]\dd x\dd\nu(z), \] and $0\le\mathcal E_\Lambda(v,v)\le\|K\|_1\,\mathcal E(v,v)$. Since $\sigma-f\in L^1\cap L^\infty$, the function $\Lambda U:=K_s*(\sigma-f)$ is bounded and lies in $L^2$. By the equation of Lemma~\ref{lem:obstacle} and Plancherel's identity, the tempered, locally integrable function $g=\hat\sigma-\hat f+d_\alpha\psi\hat U$ satisfies $\int g\,\overline{\hat\phi}=0$ for every $\phi\in\Cc$. The functions $\hat\phi$ are dense in the Schwartz space, so $g=0$, that is, $\hat\sigma-\hat f=-d_\alpha\psi\hat U$. Hence $\widehat{\Lambda U}=-d_\alpha\psi\hat K_s\hat U$; likewise $\widehat{\Lambda\phi}=-d_\alpha\psi\hat K_s\hat\phi$ for $\phi\in\Cc$. Therefore, by Plancherel's identity, \begin{equation}\label{eq:pairings} -\int(\Lambda U)w=\mathcal E_\Lambda(U,w),\qquad-\int(\Lambda\phi)w=\mathcal E_\Lambda(\phi,w)\qquad(w\in H). \end{equation} Let $0\le\phi\in\Cc$, $\varepsilon>0$ and $W=(\varepsilon\phi-U)_+\in H$. Applying the pointwise inequality $(a-b)(a_+-b_+)\ge(a_+-b_+)^2$ inside the double integral for $\mathcal E_\Lambda$, we find $\mathcal E_\Lambda(U-\varepsilon\phi,W)\le-\mathcal E_\Lambda(W,W)\le0$. Combined with \eqref{eq:pairings}, this yields \[ -\int(\Lambda U)\frac W\varepsilon=\frac1\varepsilon\mathcal E_\Lambda(U,W)\le\mathcal E_\Lambda(\phi,W)=-\int(\Lambda\phi)\,W\le\varepsilon\|\Lambda\phi\|_\infty\int\phi . \] As $\varepsilon\to0$, $W/\varepsilon\to\phi\mathbf 1_{\{U=0\}}$ with $0\le W/\varepsilon\le\phi$, so $\int_{\{U=0\}}(\Lambda U)\phi\ge0$. Hence $\Lambda U\ge0$ almost everywhere on $\{U=0\}$, and there \[ K_s*f=K_s*\sigma-\Lambda U\le K_s*\sigma\le\mu\|K_s\|_1=\lambda . \] The second inequality uses $K_s\ge0$ and $\sigma\le\mu$. For each $x$, $s\mapsto K_s*f(x)$ is continuous, since $s\mapsto K_s$ is continuous in $L^1$. Taking the inequality for all rational $s$ outside a common null set, we get $M_Kf\le\lambda$ almost everywhere on $\{U=0\}$, so $|\{M_Kf>\lambda\}|\le|\Omega|\le\|f\|_1/\mu=\|K\|_1\|f\|_1/\lambda$. Now let $f\ge0$ be bounded, measurable and compactly supported, and let $f_\varepsilon=f*\rho_\varepsilon$ for a mollifier $\rho_\varepsilon$. Then $\|f_\varepsilon\|_1=\|f\|_1$. Each $K_s*f$ is continuous, being the convolution of an integrable function with a bounded one, so $K_s*f_\varepsilon=(K_s*f)*\rho_\varepsilon\to K_s*f$ everywhere. Hence $M_Kf\le\liminf_{\varepsilon\to0}M_Kf_\varepsilon$, every point of $\{M_Kf>\lambda\}$ lies in $\{M_Kf_\varepsilon>\lambda\}$ for all small $\varepsilon$, and $|\{M_Kf>\lambda\}|\le\liminf_\varepsilon|\{M_Kf_\varepsilon>\lambda\}|\le\|K\|_1\|f\|_1/\lambda$. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:principle}] Let $g\in L^1(\R^2)$ and $f_n=\min(|g|,n)\mathbf 1_{\{|x|\le n\}}$. Since $K\ge0$, $K_s*f_n\uparrow K_s*|g|$ for each $s$ by monotone convergence, hence $M_Kf_n\uparrow M_K|g|$ and $\{M_K|g|>\lambda\}=\bigcup_n\{M_Kf_n>\lambda\}$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:transfer}, $|\{M_K|g|>\lambda\}|\le\|K\|_1\|g\|_1/\lambda$. By Lemma~\ref{lem:domination}, $|\{M_Dg>\lambda\}|\le|\{M_K|g|>2\lambda\}|\le\frac12\|K\|_1\|g\|_1/\lambda$, so the weak type constant of $M_D$ is at most $\frac12\|K\|_1=\frac12\int K$. It equals $c_2$. \end{proof} \section{Formal verification}\label{app:lean} Both theorems are also proved in Lean~4 with Mathlib. The formal statements use Lin's definitions \cite{Lin26b}, which take the strict level sets $\{Mf>\lambda\}$; these give the same constant (Section~\ref{sec:intro}). Both proofs use only the standard axioms \texttt{propext}, \texttt{Classical.choice} and \texttt{Quot.sound}, and their numerical data are checked by evaluation in the Lean kernel. Lin's formalization \cite{Lin26b} proves Lemma~\ref{lem:obstacle} for bounded, measurable, compactly supported $f\ge0$ and every $0<\alpha<2$, and the passage from such $f$ to integrable $f$. Its version of the transfer step assumes that $K$ has compact support and that $AK$ is a finite measure minus a multiple of the point mass at $0$. The kernel \eqref{eq:kernel} with $\alpha>1$ is outside that class, because $A\,r^{-\alpha}$ is not integrable near the origin (Lemma~\ref{lem:power}). The formal version of Theorem~\ref{thm:main} is the theorem \texttt{\LEANUPTHM}, which states that $c_2\le359123/100000$; the formal development also proves the strict inequality and the inequality \eqref{eq:weak} with $359123/100000$ in place of $c_2$. The formal proof adapts Lin's formalization of the partial balayage argument for squares \cite{Lin26d} to our kernel. Lin's analytic chain is kept, with our constants. Unlike that transfer step, the argument of \cite{Lin26d} does not need $AK$ to be integrable near the origin; Lin's formalization treats his kernel, with $\alpha=6/5$, and ours treats our kernel, with $\alpha=\ALPHA$. The spline part of our kernel, unlike Lin's, does not vanish outside the diamond $r