{ "description": "Public summary of an independent proof audit and the earlier cooperating-session reviews; not a verbatim private audit archive.", "outcome": "PASS in the independent audit of the full general family and in the earlier cooperating-session reviews.", "review_date": "2026-11-13", "reviewed_full_manuscript_sha256": "a2ba5c457feaf89b463f001a2b378952c9e7669a9ec9bf9c633babb29c140627", "reviewed_general_proof_sha256": "523f7d74ba3cd7152569e3f93c2cef2d6ffa094734b90a4adf3346c63ab088f7", "scope": [ "Complete theorem statements, including eventual size hypotheses, the strictly increasing corollary and the one-weight case", "Endpoint common denominator, positive cumulative-log filter and its exact identity", "Both tail estimates with constants uniform in moving endpoints", "Rationality-forced jump bound, eventual-fast peaks and the intermittent near/far split", "Prior-source root comparisons, staircase examples, finite-product substitution comparison and attribution", "Human exposition, including motivation and proof transitions" ], "review_receipts": { "session_1_correctness_sha256": "deea7dd14a0042f2df85aea264ddc879feb3d5078cc9454a9715b639b3b696f6", "session_1_exposition_sha256": "521742fe35da6a383cee29d000c7fd5a4318d9e52cbb1fb7ab2e369b3e701ea1", "session_2_correctness_sha256": "3ed9fb5abe07c90554046edb7489a6c85243ae95891fdbdee846417cd8ae9c7b", "session_2_exposition_sha256": "d893e71586c6c53778c8cb69fc242e21a9d20f7a5fff6394f9be123b3cd16433" }, "subsequent_editorial_changes": [ "Moved the finite-product interpretation before its proof; both cooperating sessions confirmed the finite source diff.", "Removed the forced title line break.", "Replaced the earlier-paper repository citation with its full published Hexagon 2611.00428v1 citation.", "After the independent audit, explicitly labeled the previous-base table column min(rho_w,2).", "Updated the short Verification note to report the independent audit." ], "current_manuscript": { "source": "paper/weighted-family-growth.tex", "source_sha256": "82cc49c80d3c8f98ce0438da52e884eae12f4b8518b6e36b181c73830c24fb6a", "pdf": "output/pdf/weighted-family-growth.pdf", "pdf_sha256": "8e63fb89e2748aa5e3298502305377d3aa8da87a06f813417c0bee358b827d65", "pages": 9, "assembly_checks": "Exact source diff contains only the previous-base table heading and the short Verification note; all theorem statements and proofs are unchanged. The PDF has nine pages and builds without warnings. Pages 2 and 8 were visually checked; the other seven pages are pixel-identical to the independently audited PDF." }, "limits": [ "Neither the independent audit nor the cooperating-session reviews are formal verification.", "No exhaustive priority assessment or sharpness claim.", "This independent audit covers the full generalization; it is distinct from the earlier two-weight paper audit." ], "numerical_dependencies": "None: the proof is self-contained and has no finite numerical certificate inputs.", "independent_audit": { "completed_local_date": "2026-11-13", "completed_utc": "2026-11-14T03:52:55.280197+00:00", "outcome": "PASS: no mathematical gap, missing hypothesis or unresolved uniformity issue in Theorems 1.1-1.2 or Propositions 4.1-4.2.", "audited_source_sha256": "4340714ad4aa6841cd9f2921fe9c178dd6d68ef9ffd2e4f43e74d2006151d113", "audited_pdf_sha256": "26eca1be56ae4276f970bcd76c7edc1d053eb22ffc063960745180a87c7304e5", "report_sha256": "e8e3dc1249cdcaa2cd0919346c99fb645e9d0145fe50ded19a48ea6157dbd330", "independent_conclusions_sha256": "e141136ba642ddca5ffb2cf88e0ea4929fd825c057747a096cd9d813a4c58607", "independence": "The auditor recorded conclusions before opening the earlier review summary.", "scope": "All nine PDF pages and the accompanying TeX; endpoint arithmetic, strictly positive factorization, uniform tail and jump estimates, first-peak and forward-shift arguments, both parts of the same cleared tail, root and staircase comparisons, and finite-product substitutions.", "sources_checked": "BKKKZ v3 Theorem 3, Remark 4, Theorem 5, Lemmas 8-11, Proposition 12 and Section 5; relevant portions of the original Erdos paper, including visual formula checks.", "limits": [ "Not formal verification or an exhaustive literature/priority assessment.", "The full rational-construction proof in BKKKZ Theorem 5 and complete historical papers were not independently re-proved.", "The original Erdos-Graham book page 64 was not directly inspected; its attribution was corroborated by BKKKZ.", "The auditor could not access the live Hexagon record; that publication citation was separately verified during manuscript preparation." ] } }