\documentclass[11pt]{article} \usepackage[T1]{fontenc} \usepackage{lmodern,amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools,mathrsfs} \usepackage[margin=1in]{geometry} \usepackage{booktabs,array,longtable,needspace,listings} \usepackage[colorlinks=true,linkcolor=blue,citecolor=blue,urlcolor=blue]{hyperref} \lstset{basicstyle=\ttfamily\footnotesize,columns=fullflexible,keepspaces=true,breaklines=true,frame=single} \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary} \theoremstyle{definition}\newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition} \theoremstyle{remark}\newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark} \newcommand{\Z}{\mathbb Z} \newcommand{\Q}{\mathbb Q} \newcommand{\Fp}{\mathbb F_p} \newcommand{\vp}{v_p} \newcommand{\cc}{\mathrm{cc}} \newcommand{\Rea}{\operatorname{Re}} \newcommand{\vol}{\operatorname{vol}} \newcommand{\ceil}[1]{\left\lceil #1\right\rceil} \newcommand{\floor}[1]{\left\lfloor #1\right\rfloor} \newcommand{\Zp}{\mathbb Z_p} \newcommand{\F}{\mathbb F} \newcommand{\C}{\mathcal C} \DeclareMathOperator{\rank}{rank} \DeclareMathOperator{\diag}{diag} \DeclareMathOperator{\coker}{coker} \title{Subrings and cotypes of truncated polynomial rings} \author{Sarthak Chimni \and Ramin Takloo-Bighash} \begin{document} \maketitle \begin{abstract} We study unital finite-index subrings of $R_n=\Z[t]/(t^n)$. We compute the cubic cotype function and the quartic total and cocyclic functions at every prime, including the exceptional factors at $2$, and prove the corresponding global counting theorems in degrees three, four, and five. Explicit Hermite sums with determinantal weights give full cotype formulas for $n=4,5$, without an asserted closed rational evaluation. We extend these calculations by a linear lifting recursion for every degree and by a two-parameter description of every cocyclic subring for $n\ge4$. The latter gives $2-2/(n-1)\le\alpha_n^{\cc}\le2$ for the global cocyclic convergence abscissa, and hence $\alpha_n^{\cc}\to2$. An exact quadratic family of quintic diagonal counts gives absolute convergence of the residual Dirichlet series for $\Rea s>19/13$. All asymptotics are obtained by elementary summation and absolutely convergent convolution. \end{abstract} \tableofcontents \section{Introduction}\label{sec:scope} \subsection{Main results and organization} For $n\ge2$, let $A_n(B)$ count the unital subrings of $R_n=\Z[t]/(t^n)$ of index at most $B$, and let $A_n^{\cc}(B)$ count those whose additive quotient is cyclic. The leading terms are summarized below; all constants displayed in the table are positive. \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{@{}clll@{}} \toprule $n$ & $A_n(B)$ & $A_n^{\cc}(B)$ & Result\\ \midrule $3$ & $C_3B(\log B)^2$ & $D_3B(\log B)^2$ & Theorem~\ref{thm:cubic-asymptotics}\\ $4$ & $K_4B^{3/2}$ & $K_4^{\cc}B^{3/2}$ & Theorem~\ref{thm:quartic-asymptotic}\\ $5$ & $C_5B^{3/2}(\log B)^2$ & $D_5B^{3/2}\log B$ & Theorems~\ref{thm:total} and~\ref{thm:cc}\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{center} Here $C_3=1/(12\zeta(2))$ and $D_3=\frac1{12}\prod_p(1-3p^{-2}+2p^{-3})$. The cited theorems give the other constants and the error terms. The proportion of cocyclic subrings has a positive limit in degrees three and four, but tends to zero in degree five. Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries} supplies the lattice and summation tools. Sections~\ref{sec:cubic} and~\ref{sec:quartic} treat degrees three and four. Section~\ref{sec:quintic-statements} contains the entire quintic argument, including the separate character calculation for cocyclic quotients. Sections~\ref{sec:ext-cotype} and~\ref{sec:ext-lifting} give exact cotype sums and a coefficient recursion in every degree. Section~\ref{sec:ext-universal-cyclic} describes every cocyclic local subring by two polynomial congruences and proves $2-2/(n-1)\le\alpha_n^{\cc}\le2$, hence $\alpha_n^{\cc}\to2$, for the global convergence abscissae. The rational evaluation of the full cotype sums and sharp asymptotics in degrees at least six are left open. Appendix~\ref{app:finite} prints the complete finite enumeration used in the quintic convergence proof. The authors thank Nathan Kaplan, Tobias Rossmann, and Christopher Voll for useful convervastions. We originally learned about this problem from \cite{AKKM}. The second author is partially supported by a collaboration grant from the Simons Foundation. The bulk of this work was included in the first author's doctoral thesis at the University of Illinois at Chicago. The work was further developed with assistance from ChatGPT. Access to ChatGPT 6 Astra was provided through OpenAI's ChatGPT for Academic Researchers program via Julius Ross, whom the authors thank. \section{Lattice and summation preliminaries}\label{sec:preliminaries} \subsection{Cotypes and local lattices} Throughout, a subring contains the identity of the ambient ring. A \emph{cocyclic} subring is one whose additive quotient is cyclic; the trivial quotient is included. A full lattice is an additive submodule of finite index. For $n\ge2$ put $R_n=\Z[t]/(t^n)$, $d=n-1$, and $N_{n,p}=t\Z_p[t]/(t^n)$. If $S\subset R_n$ has finite index, its additive quotient has uniquely determined invariant factors \[ R_n/S\cong\bigoplus_{i=1}^{d}\Z/\alpha_i(S)\Z, \qquad \alpha_{i+1}(S)\mid\alpha_i(S). \] Trivial factors are included. There is a further trivial factor from the identity, which we suppress. Define \[ \mathcal Z_n(s_1,\ldots,s_d) =\sum_S\prod_{i=1}^d\alpha_i(S)^{-s_i},\qquad Z_n(s)=\mathcal Z_n(s,\ldots,s). \] Write $Z_n^{\cc}(s)$ for the same sum over subrings with cyclic additive quotient, and $a_n(q),a_n^{\cc}(q)$ for the respective coefficients. The quotient is only an additive group; no ideal condition on $S$ is being imposed. Its \emph{corank} is the minimum number of additive generators, equivalently the number of nontrivial invariant factors. We use $v_p(p)=1$, $v_p(0)=+\infty$, and $|x|_p=p^{-v_p(x)}$. For a residue modulo $p^m$, a valuation means the minimum of $m$ and the valuation of a lift. The nilpotent algebra $N_{n,p}$ has rank $n-1$, whereas $R_n$ has rank $n$; the words cubic, quartic, and quintic refer to $n=3,4,5$. For clarity, we distinguish the ordinary local generating function from the Dirichlet series: \[ \mathsf Z_{n,p}(T)=\sum_{m\ge0}a_n(p^m)T^m, \qquad Z_{n,p}(s)=\mathsf Z_{n,p}(p^{-s}), \] and use the superscript $\cc$ for their cocyclic counterparts. The local coefficients count unital $\Z_p$-subalgebras of finite index. The local cotype series $\mathcal Z_{n,p}$ is defined by the same invariant-factor weights as the global series. \subsection{Triangular bases and local decomposition} Every local subring with identity is uniquely written as $\Z_p\oplus L$ with $L$ a full lattice in $N_{n,p}$ and $L^2\subseteq L$. Indeed subtracting the constant coefficient of an element of the subring gives an element of $L$, and the converse follows by expanding products. Its index and nontrivial Smith invariants are those of $N_{n,p}/L$. \begin{lemma}[Row Hermite coordinates]\label{lem:row-hermite} Fix an ordered basis $e_1,\ldots,e_d$ of $\Z_p^d$. Every full lattice has a unique upper triangular row basis matrix $H=(h_{ij})$ satisfying \[ h_{ii}=p^{a_i},\qquad a_i\ge0,\qquad 0\le h_{ij}d$. \end{lemma} \subsection{Smith invariants and congruence measures} For $L\subset N_{n,p}$ write its invariant exponents as $\lambda_1\ge\cdots\ge\lambda_d\ge0$. We use also the formal notation \[ \mathcal C_{n,p}(X_1,\ldots,X_d) =\sum_{\substack{L\subseteq N_{n,p}\text{ full}\\L^2\subseteq L}}\prod_{i=1}^dX_i^{\lambda_i}; \qquad \mathcal Z_{n,p}(\boldsymbol s) =\mathcal C_{n,p}(p^{-s_1},\ldots,p^{-s_d}). \] Each coefficient is finite. The one-variable specialization is obtained by setting every $X_i=T$; the cocyclic specialization sets $X_1=T$ and $X_2=\cdots=X_d=0$, with $0^0=1$. More generally, setting $X_{r+1}=\cdots=X_d=0$ retains the subrings of corank at most $r$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:smith-weight} Let $M$ be a full-rank $d\times d$ matrix over $\Z_p$. Set $\delta_0=0$ and let $\delta_j$ be the minimum valuation of its $j\times j$ minors. Then the decreasing invariant exponents of its row quotient are \[ \lambda_i=\delta_{d-i+1}-\delta_{d-i}\quad(1\le i\le d). \] In particular these differences are nonnegative and occur in decreasing order. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Choose an entry of least valuation, move it to the first diagonal position, and multiply its row by a unit to make it a power of $p$. It divides every entry, so integral row and column operations clear its column and row. Iterating on the remaining block produces a diagonal matrix with entries $p^{e_1},\ldots,p^{e_d}$ and $e_1\le\cdots\le e_d$: after each clearing step all remaining entries are still divisible by the previous pivot. These operations are unimodular and preserve the quotient. They also preserve the ideal generated by the $j$-minors, by multilinearity (or the Cauchy--Binet identity), with equality following from the inverse operations. For the diagonal matrix that ideal is generated by $p^{e_1+\cdots+e_j}$. Hence $\delta_j=e_1+\cdots+e_j$ and $\lambda_i=e_{d-i+1}$, proving the assertion. \end{proof} The same pivot argument applies to rectangular matrices: a matrix of rank $r$ is equivalent, by invertible integral row and column operations, to a rectangular diagonal matrix with nonzero diagonal $p^{e_1},\ldots,p^{e_r}$. In particular, for a matrix with $r$ rows and rank $r$, the index of its column module in $\Z_p^r$ is $p^{e_1+\cdots+e_r}$, the power of $p$ generated by its maximal minors. This is the form used for systems of linear congruences. Normalized additive Haar measure on $\Z_p^k$ assigns measure $p^{-ak}$ to each residue class modulo $p^a$. Thus a condition depending only on these residues has measure equal to its number of solutions divided by $p^{ak}$. Invertible integral linear changes preserve this measure. More generally an injective linear map with determinant of valuation $b$ scales it by $p^{-b}$: Smith reduction reduces this assertion to multiplication of one coordinate by $p^e$. These facts justify all congruence-measure calculations below. \subsection{Elementary analytic tools} \begin{lemma}[Absolutely convergent convolution]\label{lem:convolution-transfer} Let $b(n)$ be a sequence with summatory function $D(Y)=\sum_{n\le Y}b(n)$, and suppose $\sum_{d\ge1}|h(d)|d^{-\beta}<\infty$ for some $\beta<\alpha$. Put $f(n)=\sum_{d\mid n}h(d)b(n/d)$ and $H(\alpha)=\sum_d h(d)d^{-\alpha}$. If $r\ge1$ is an integer and \[ D(Y)=cY^\alpha(\log Y)^r+ O\bigl(Y^\alpha(\log(2Y))^{r-1}\bigr), \] then \[ \sum_{n\le B}f(n)=cH(\alpha)B^\alpha(\log B)^r+ O\bigl(B^\alpha(\log(2B))^{r-1}\bigr). \] If instead $D(Y)=cY^\alpha+O(Y^\gamma)$ with $\gamma<\beta<\alpha$, then \[ \sum_{n\le B}f(n)=cH(\alpha)B^\alpha+O(B^\beta). \] The constants may depend on the sequences and the stated parameters. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Finite rearrangement gives $\sum_{n\le B}f(n)=\sum_{d\le B}h(d)D(B/d)$. For every fixed $j\ge0$, \[ \sum_d|h(d)|d^{-\alpha}(\log d)^j<\infty, \] because $d^{\beta-\alpha}(\log d)^j$ is bounded (with the constant monomial interpreted as $1$ when $j=0$). In the first case the summed error is $O(B^\alpha(\log(2B))^{r-1})$. Expanding $(\log B-\log d)^r$ shows that all nonleading terms have this same bound. Extending the leading sum from $d\le B$ to all $d$ costs $O(B^\beta(\log B)^r)$, which is absorbed since $\beta<\alpha$. In the second case the summed error is at most \[ B^\gamma\sum_{d\le B}|h(d)|d^{-\gamma} \le B^\beta\sum_d|h(d)|d^{-\beta}. \] The tail of the main term is bounded by $B^\alpha B^{\beta-\alpha}\sum_{d>B}|h(d)|d^{-\beta}$. This proves both assertions. \end{proof} \section{The cubic cotype function}\label{sec:cubic} Separating Hermite forms according to their first determinantal divisor gives the cubic cotype formula. The resulting three elementary sums retain the Smith weights throughout. We write $\mathcal C_{3,p}(X,Y)$ for the two-variable series defined in Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries}. \begin{theorem}[Cubic cotype formula]\label{thm:cubic-cotype} For every prime $p$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:cubic-cotype} \mathcal C_{3,p}(X,Y)= \frac{1+X+pX^2-pX^3Y-p^2X^4Y-p^2X^5Y} {(1-XY)(1-pX^2Y)(1-p^2X^3)}. \end{equation} Thus the local cotype Dirichlet series is obtained by setting $X=p^{-s_1}$ and $Y=p^{-s_2}$ wherever the defining sum converges absolutely. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} The split augmentation $R_3\otimes\mathbb Z_p=\mathbb Z_p1\oplus(t)$ is useful because subtracting the constant coefficient from an element of a unital subring stays inside that subring. Hence every such subring is $\mathbb Z_p1\oplus L$, with $L\subset(t)$ a full lattice closed under multiplication, as in Section~\ref{sec:preliminaries}. In the ordered basis $(t^2,t)$, the unique row Hermite normal form of $L$ has rows \[ p^a t^2,\qquad u t^2+p^b t, \qquad a,b\geq0,\quad 0\leq u1$, \begin{align} Z_3(s)&=\frac{\zeta(s)\zeta(2s-1)\zeta(3s-2)} {\zeta(4s-2)},\label{eq:cubic-total-global}\\ Z_3^{\cc}(s)&=\zeta(s)\zeta(2s-1)\zeta(3s-2)H(s), \label{eq:cubic-cyclic-global}\\ H(s)&=\prod_p\left(1-p^{-2s}-p^{1-3s} +p^{1-4s}-p^{2-4s}+p^{2-5s}\right). \label{eq:cubic-H} \end{align} The Euler product defining $H$ has an absolutely convergent Dirichlet-series expansion in $\operatorname{Re}s>3/4$. In particular, the number of cocyclic subrings of index $p^e$ is \begin{equation}\label{eq:cubic-prime-power-cyclic} a_3^{\cc}(p^e)=p^{\lfloor2e/3\rfloor}\qquad(e\geq0). \end{equation} \end{corollary} \begin{proof} In Theorem~\ref{thm:cubic-cotype}, put $X=Y=T$ to count by index, and put $X=T$, $Y=0$ to retain precisely $\lambda _2=0$. They give, respectively, \begin{equation}\label{eq:cubic-local-specializations} \mathsf Z_{3,p}(T)=\frac{1+pT^2}{(1-T)(1-p^2T^3)},\qquad \mathsf Z_{3,p}^{\cc}(T)=\frac{1+T+pT^2}{1-p^2T^3}. \end{equation} As a check independent of the cotype cancellation, the first equality also follows directly from \[ \sum_{b\geq0}\sum_{a=0}^{2b}p^aT^{a+b} =\frac{1}{1-pT}\left(\frac{1}{1-T} -\frac{pT}{1-p^2T^3}\right). \] The last expression reduces to the first expression in \eqref{eq:cubic-local-specializations}. Expanding the second one gives coefficients $p^{2j}$, $p^{2j}$, $p^{2j+1}$ in degrees $3j$, $3j+1$, $3j+2$, proving \eqref{eq:cubic-prime-power-cyclic}. By Lemma~\ref{lem:global-local}, the coefficient functions are multiplicative. Their Euler products converge absolutely for $\operatorname{Re}s>1$: the total factor in \eqref{eq:cubic-local-specializations} is bounded coefficientwise by $((1-T)(1-pT^2)(1-p^2T^3))^{-1}$, whose Euler product is $\zeta(s)\zeta(2s-1)\zeta(3s-2)$ and converges in that half-plane. The cocyclic coefficients are bounded by the total coefficients. Now $1+pT^2=(1-p^2T^4)/(1-pT^2)$ proves \eqref{eq:cubic-total-global}. For the second factor, direct multiplication gives \[ (1+T+pT^2)(1-T)(1-pT^2) =1-T^2-pT^3+(p-p^2)T^4+p^2T^5. \] This proves \eqref{eq:cubic-cyclic-global}--\eqref{eq:cubic-H}. At a real $\sigma>3/4$, the sum over primes of the absolute values of the nonconstant local Dirichlet coefficients is bounded by \[ \sum_p\bigl(p^{-2\sigma}+p^{1-3\sigma} +(p+p^2)p^{-4\sigma}+p^{2-5\sigma}\bigr)<\infty. \] Each exponent of $p$ is strictly less than $-1$. The product of the corresponding local absolute sums is therefore finite. Expanding finite Euler products and passing monotonically to the product of absolute sums proves absolute convergence of the Dirichlet series, including the assertion about $H$. \end{proof} The coefficients of the three zeta factors in \eqref{eq:cubic-total-global} and \eqref{eq:cubic-cyclic-global} are a weighted count of triples. Elementary summation of that count, followed by an absolutely convergent convolution, gives the asymptotics and their error terms. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:cubic-convolution} Suppose $h(d)$ is a complex sequence with $\sum_{d\geq1}|h(d)|d^{-\sigma _0}<\infty$ for some $\sigma _0<1$. If $f(n)$ are the Dirichlet coefficients of \[ \zeta(s)\zeta(2s-1)\zeta(3s-2) \sum_{d\geq1}h(d)d^{-s}, \] then, as $B\to\infty$, \[ \sum_{n\leq B}f(n) =\frac{B(\log B)^2}{12}\sum_{d\geq1}\frac{h(d)}d +O_h\bigl(B\log(2B)\bigr). \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} First consider the three zeta factors alone. Their summatory coefficient function is \[ D(B)=\sum_{ab^2c^3\leq B}bc^2 =\sum_{b^2c^3\leq B}bc^2 \left\lfloor\frac{B}{b^2c^3}\right\rfloor. \] Replacing the floor by its argument gives \[ D(B)=B\sum_{b^2c^3\leq B}\frac1{bc} +O\left(\sum_{c\leq B^{1/3}}c^2 \sum_{b\leq(B/c^3)^{1/2}}b\right). \] For $Y\geq1$, $\sum_{b\leq Y}b\leq Y^2$, so the error is at most $B\sum_{c\leq B^{1/3}}1/c=O(B\log(2B))$. For the main term put $C=B^{1/3}$. Integral comparison gives $\sum_{j\leq Y}1/j=\log Y+O(1)$ for $Y\geq1$, and hence \begin{align*} \sum_{b^2c^3\leq B}\frac1{bc} &=\sum_{c\leq C}\frac1c \left(\frac12\log B-\frac32\log c+O(1)\right)\\ &=\frac12\log B\log C-\frac34(\log C)^2 +O(\log(2B))\\ &=\frac1{12}(\log B)^2+O(\log(2B)). \end{align*} Here $\sum_{c\leq C}(\log c)/c=\tfrac12(\log C)^2+O(1)$ also follows by integral comparison (the function is decreasing for $c>e$, with bounded variation on $[1,\infty)$). We have proved \[ D(B)=\frac1{12}B(\log B)^2+O(B\log(2B)). \] Apply Lemma~\ref{lem:convolution-transfer} with $\alpha=1$, $r=2$, $c=1/12$, and $\beta=\sigma_0$. This proves the claimed convolution asymptotic. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:cubic-asymptotics} Let $A_3(B)$ and $A_3^{\cc}(B)$ denote the numbers of all unital subrings and cocyclic unital subrings of $R_3$, respectively, of index at most $B$. Then \begin{align*} A_3(B)&=\frac1{12\zeta(2)}B(\log B)^2 +O(B\log(2B)),\\ A_3^{\cc}(B)&= \frac1{12}\prod_p(1-3p^{-2}+2p^{-3})\,B(\log B)^2 +O(B\log(2B)). \end{align*} Consequently the limiting proportion of cocyclic subrings exists and is the strictly positive number \[ \lim_{B\to\infty}\frac{A_3^{\cc}(B)}{A_3(B)} =\zeta(2)\prod_p(1-3p^{-2}+2p^{-3}) =\prod_p\left(1-\frac2{p(p+1)}\right). \] \end{theorem} \begin{proof} For the total count, the correction factor is \[ \frac1{\zeta(4s-2)}=\sum_{d\geq1}\mu(d)d^2(d^4)^{-s}, \] whose absolute series converges when $\operatorname{Re}s>3/4$. For the cocyclic count the same convergence was proved for $H(s)$ in Corollary~\ref{cor:cubic-specializations}. Choose any $\sigma _0\in(3/4,1)$ and apply Lemma~\ref{lem:cubic-convolution} to each factorization. The correction factors at $s=1$ are $1/\zeta(2)$ and $\prod_p(1-3p^{-2}+2p^{-3})$, respectively. Every factor of the latter product is $(1-p^{-1})^2(1+2p^{-1})>0$, and the deviations from $1$ are summable. The product is therefore positive. Dividing the two asymptotics is legitimate. The alternative expression for the ratio follows, prime by prime, from \[ \frac{1-3p^{-2}+2p^{-3}}{1-p^{-2}} =\frac{(p-1)(p+2)}{p(p+1)} =1-\frac2{p(p+1)}. \] \end{proof} \section{Quartic local factors and counting functions} \label{sec:quartic} Let $\mathsf Z_{4,p}(x)$ and $\mathsf Z_{4,p}^{\cc}(x)$ count, respectively, all subrings and cocyclic subrings of $p$-power index, with $x$ recording the exponent of the index. A triangular basis gives explicit closure conditions and a determinantal test for cyclicity. The coefficient $2$ in the square of the last basis element requires a separate calculation at the dyadic prime. \begin{lemma}[Quartic triangular coordinates]\label{lem:quartic-hnf} Every local subring has a unique basis consisting of $1$ and \[ v_1=p^kt^3,\qquad v_2=at^3+p^lt^2,\qquad v_3=ct^3+bt^2+p^rt, \] where $k,l,r\geq0$, $0\leq a,c0$ and $l=0$, then $b=0$, $1\leq k\leq r$, and cyclicity says $c$ is a unit. Thus there are $p^{2k}q$ choices. If $k,l>0$, then $r>0$ and the only potentially unit minor is $ab-p^lc$. Consequently $a$ and $b$ must both be units, and $c$ is arbitrary. Suppose $p$ is odd. If $lr$, the expression $2p^{l-r}b-a$ is a unit, so the allowed values satisfy $k+l\leq2r$. If $l=r$ and $k\leq l$, there is no additional constraint. In these three cases the count is $p^{2k+l}q^2$. Finally, when $l=r1$: for each of its finitely many nonconstant monomial types $p^ax^b$, the sum $\sum_p p^{a-b\sigma}$ converges for $\sigma>1$. The four zeta factors in $G_4$ have absolutely convergent Dirichlet expansions for $\Re s>4/3$. Consequently so does their product. For all cocyclic subrings, \[ G_4^{\mathrm{cc}}(s)=\zeta(4s-4) \widetilde M_2(2^{-s})\prod_{p\ne2}M_p(p^{-s}) \] is the residual factor after removing $\zeta(2s-2)$. The most restrictive monomial in the polynomial product is $p^3x^3$; it gives absolute convergence for $\sigma>4/3$. The zeta factor already converges for $\sigma>5/4$. For odd indices replace $\widetilde M_2(2^{-s})$ in this expression by $(1-2^{2-2s})(1-2^{4-4s})$. This is a Dirichlet polynomial and therefore does not affect absolute convergence. Apply Lemma~\ref{lem:convolution-transfer} with $\beta=4/3+\varepsilon$ to obtain all three estimates. At $x=2^{-3/2}=\sqrt2/4$, direct substitution gives \[ \widetilde N_2(x)=\frac{314-5\sqrt2}{256},\qquad \widetilde M_2(x)=\frac{14+5\sqrt2}{16},\qquad (1-4x^2)(1-16x^4)=\frac38. \] Inserting these values into $G(3/2)/3$ gives the constants displayed in the theorem. Every numerator Euler factor is positive at $3/2$, because it equals a positive counting series times its positive local denominator. Absolute convergence of the products then makes the products strictly positive. Finally $G$ is holomorphic for $\Re s>4/3$, and $\zeta(2s-2)$ has only its simple pole at $s=3/2$ on the line in question. Since $G(3/2)>0$, that pole does not cancel. \end{proof} \begin{remark}[Dyadic boundaries and index restrictions]\label{rem:quartic-dyadic} The dyadic factors must be calculated from the closure conditions with $v_2(2)=1$. For example, the only diagonal triples at index $4$ are $(k,l,r)=(0,0,2),(1,0,1),(0,1,1)$, contributing $1,4,2$. Thus the coefficient of $x^2$ in \eqref{eq:quartic-even-total} is $7$. For the cocyclic count, the case $r=l+1$ permits $k\leq2l+1$. The sums $G_2,G_3$ above retain this endpoint and treat an empty interval as contributing zero; in particular, \eqref{eq:quartic-even-cc} has coefficient $128$ at $x^6$. The all-index and odd-index asymptotics differ by the local factor at $2$: restricting to odd indices removes that factor from the Euler product. This changes the leading constant while preserving the exponent $3/2$. \end{remark} \begin{remark} The cubic and quartic computations above can also be done using Zeta \cite{Rossmann}. We have included them here to motivate the method used to compute the quintic zeta functions which are not accessible toe Zeta. \end{remark} \section{Quintic counting functions}\label{sec:quintic-statements} We now state the quintic total and cocyclic counting theorems. Their proofs use the closure conditions in Section~\ref{sec:quintic-closure}, uniform bounds for all diagonal types, and exact counts for the exceptional types. An infinite quadratic family gives the convergence region $\Rea s>19/13$ for the residual total series. Throughout this section $R=R_5=\Z[t]/(t^5)$; the notation $a_5(n)$, $a_5^{\cc}(n)$, $Z_5$, and $Z_5^{\cc}$ is as in Section~\ref{sec:scope}. The total factorization is proved in Sections~\ref{sec:quintic-uniform}--\ref{sec:quintic-extraction}; the cocyclic factors are evaluated in Section~\ref{sec:quintic-cc}. Section~\ref{sec:global} completes both asymptotic proofs. \begin{theorem}\label{thm:total} There is a Dirichlet series $H_5(s)$, absolutely convergent for $\Rea s>19/13$, such that, for $\Rea s>3/2$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:totalfactor} Z_5(s)=\zeta(2s-2)\zeta(4s-5)\zeta(6s-8)H_5(s). \end{equation} The right side extends $Z_5$ meromorphically to $\Rea s>19/13$. Moreover $H_5(3/2)>0$. Thus $Z_5$ has abscissa of convergence $3/2$ and a pole of order three there. If $B\ge2$, then \begin{equation}\label{eq:totalasymp} \sum_{n\le B}a_5(n) =C_5 B^{3/2}(\log B)^2+O(B^{3/2}\log B), \qquad C_5=\frac{H_5(3/2)}{144}>0. \end{equation} In particular, \begin{equation}\label{eq:totalconstant} C_5=\frac1{144}\prod_p(1-p^{-1})^3 Z_{5,p}(3/2). \end{equation} \end{theorem} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:cc} Let $x$ be a formal variable and put \[ P_p(x)=1+x+p^2x^2+p^3x^3. \] For $p\ne5$, let $\rho_p$ be the number of roots of $z^2+z-1$ in $\Fp$. Thus $\rho_2=0$, and $\rho_p=1+\left(\frac5p\right)$ for odd $p\ne5$. Then \begin{equation}\label{eq:ccfactor} \mathsf Z_{5,p}^{\cc}(x)= \frac{P_p(x)}{1-p^5x^4} +\frac{(1-p^{-1})\rho_p p^6x^5} {(1-p^5x^4)(1-p^6x^5)}\qquad(p\ne5). \end{equation} At $p=5$ the formula is \begin{equation}\label{eq:ccfactor5} \mathsf Z_{5,5}^{\cc}(x) =\frac{P_5(x)+(1-5^{-1})5^6x^5}{1-5^5x^4}. \end{equation} These are identities of formal power series; substituting $x=p^{-s}$ gives the local Dirichlet series, absolutely convergent for $\Rea s>5/4$. There is a Dirichlet series $H_5^{\cc}$, absolutely convergent for $\Rea s>7/5$, such that, initially for $\Rea s>3/2$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:ccglobal} Z_5^{\cc}(s)=\zeta(2s-2)\zeta(4s-5)H_5^{\cc}(s), \qquad H_5^{\cc}(3/2)>0. \end{equation} The right side extends $Z_5^{\cc}$ meromorphically to $\Rea s>7/5$. The series $Z_5^{\cc}$ has abscissa of convergence $3/2$ and a pole of order two there. Moreover, \begin{equation}\label{eq:ccasymp} \sum_{n\le B}a_5^{\cc}(n) =D_5 B^{3/2}\log B+O(B^{3/2}), \quad D_5=\frac{H_5^{\cc}(3/2)}{12} =\frac1{12}\prod_p(1-p^{-1})^2Z_{5,p}^{\cc}(3/2)>0. \end{equation} \end{theorem} \begin{corollary} The proportion of subrings of index at most $B$ that are cocyclic tends to zero. More precisely, this proportion is asymptotic to \[ \frac{12H_5^{\cc}(3/2)}{H_5(3/2)}\frac1{\log B}. \] \end{corollary} For $\Z[t]/(t^4)$, the total and cocyclic counts in Section~\ref{sec:quartic} both have growth of order $B^{3/2}$. The extra logarithms in degree five arise from additional low-index local contributions. Uniform control of the remaining diagonal types will isolate these contributions in an absolutely convergent product. \subsection{Quintic closure in Hermite normal form}\label{sec:quintic-closure} Triangular division in increasing degree gives the complete closure conditions, by the same method as Lemma~\ref{lem:quartic-hnf}. Let $N=t\Z_p[t]/(t^5)$. Every finite-index subring of $\Z_p[t]/(t^5)$ containing $1$ is uniquely $\Z_p\oplus L$, where $L$ is a full lattice in $N$ satisfying $L^2\subseteq L$. Its index equals $[N:L]$. There is a unique upper-triangular Hermite basis \begin{align*} f_1&=p^at+ut^2+vt^3+wt^4, & f_2&=p^bt^2+xt^3+yt^4,\\ f_3&=p^ct^3+zt^4, & f_4&=p^dt^4, \end{align*} where $a,b,c,d\ge0$ and the representatives satisfy \begin{equation}\label{eq:hnfranges} 0\le ue$, condition \eqref{eq:T} requires $U=p^{c-e}U'$ and has measure $p^{-(c-e)}$. If $c\le e$, put $U'=U$. In either case $U'$ is Haar-uniform on $\Z_p$ after imposing \eqref{eq:T}, and \[ T/p^c=p^{(e-c)_+}U',\qquad q_+=\max(q,0). \] For fixed $U'$ and the other coordinate, the measure of $z$ satisfying \eqref{eq:residual} is at most \[ p^{-\max\{h-(e-c)_+-v_p(U'),0\}}. \] This estimate is valid regardless of the dependence of $u$ on $U'$. For every integer $H\ge0$, \begin{align*} \int_{\Z_p}p^{-\max\{H-v_p(U'),0\}}\,dU' &=\sum_{j=0}^{H-1}(1-p^{-1})p^{-j}p^{-(H-j)}+p^{-H}\\ &=[1+H(1-p^{-1})]p^{-H}\le(H+1)p^{-H}. \end{align*} Taking $H=(h-(e-c)_+)_+$ and using \[ (c-e)_+ +(h-(e-c)_+)_+=(c+h-e)_+, \] we see that the joint measure of \eqref{eq:T} and \eqref{eq:residual} is at most \[ (h+1)p^{-(c+h-e)_+}. \] Multiplication by $p^{-(d-h)}p^{b+2c+3d}$ gives an exponent of \[ b+2c+2d+h-(c+h-e)_+ =b+c+2d+\min(c+h,e), \] which proves \eqref{eq:productbound}. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:uniform} For every prime $p$ and every admissible type of total index exponent $m=a+b+c+d$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:uniform} A_p(a,b,c,d)\le4(m+2)p^{7m/5}. \end{equation} For odd $p$, the factor $4$ may be omitted. Consequently \begin{equation}\label{eq:coefficientbound} a_5(p^m)\le4(m+2)\binom{m+3}{3}p^{7m/5}. \end{equation} \end{proposition} \begin{proof} First suppose $p$ is odd. We bound the exponent in the smaller of \eqref{eq:linearbound} and \eqref{eq:productbound}; their common prefactor may be enlarged to $h+1$. If $b\le a$, then $e=a$ and $h\le a$. The available exponent bounds include \[ A=a+b+c+2d,\qquad F=a+2b+2c+d,\qquad C=3a+2b+d. \] Here $A$ follows from \eqref{eq:productbound}, $F$ from $\delta_p\le b+c$, and $C$ from $\delta_p\le2a+b-c$. If $c\le a$, then \[ \frac25 A+\frac35 F-\frac75m =\frac{-2a+b+c}{5}\le0. \] If $c\ge a$, then \[ \frac25 A+\frac35 C-\frac75m =\frac{4a+b-5c}{5}\le0. \] The minimum of two bounds is at most their weighted average. If $b\ge a$, then $e=2a-b$. The corresponding three bounds are \[ B=2a+c+2d,\qquad G=3a+2c+d,\qquad J=5a+d. \] The last two use $\delta_p\le a+c$ and $\delta_p\le3a-c$. Since $m\ge2a+c+d$, for $c\le a$ we have \[ \frac25 B+\frac35 G-\frac75(2a+c+d)=\frac{c-a}{5}\le0, \] and for $c\ge a$ we have \[ \frac25 B+\frac35 J-\frac75(2a+c+d)=a-c\le0. \] This proves the exponent bound $7m/5$ at every odd prime, including $3$. At $p=2$, the bounds in the case $b\le a$ become $A+1,F+1,C+2$; thus an extra factor at most $2^2=4$ suffices. In the case $b\ge a$, the bounds $B,G,J$ remain valid without change. Finally $h+1\le m+2$. Summing over at most $\binom{m+3}{3}$ diagonal types gives \eqref{eq:coefficientbound}. \end{proof} In particular each individual local factor is holomorphic for $\Rea s>7/5$. The prime-independent bound in \eqref{eq:coefficientbound} is the estimate needed to control the infinite tail of the global Euler product. \subsection{The finite exceptional calculation}\label{sec:quintic-finite} The gap between the uniform local exponent $7/5$ and the global exponent $3/2$ makes a sufficiently long tail summable over primes. We count the remaining initial diagonal types explicitly. For $p\ge5$, set \begin{align*} e_0&=\min(a,2a-b),\qquad h_0=\min(d,e_0),\\ \delta_0&=\min(c+d,c+b,c+a,a+b,d+a,d+2a-b, 2a,2a+b-c,3a-c),\\ E(a,b,c,d)&=\min\{b+c+d+\delta_0+h_0, b+c+2d+\min(c+h_0,e_0)\}. \end{align*} Lemma \ref{lem:twoestimates} gives \begin{equation}\label{eq:Ebound} A_p(a,b,c,d)\le(h_0+1)p^{E(a,b,c,d)}. \end{equation} For $1\le m\le10$, only the following eight types satisfy $E\ge3m/2-1$. Their exact counts are also displayed. Write $\rho_p(j)=\#\{r\bmod p^j:r^2+r-1\equiv0\pmod {p^j}\}$. \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{@{}ccl@{}} \toprule $m$ & $(a,b,c,d)$ & $A_p(a,b,c,d)$\\ \midrule 2 &(1,0,1,0)&$p^2$\\ 3 &(1,1,0,1)&$p^3$\\ 4 &(1,1,1,1)&$p^5$\\ 5 &(1,1,1,2)&$p^5\{1+(p-1)\rho_p(1)\}$\\ 6 &(2,1,1,2)&$p^8$\\ 6 &(2,2,0,2)&$p^7$\\ 8 &(2,2,1,3)&$p^{10}$\\ 10&(2,2,2,4)&$p^{10}\{p^2+(p^2-p)\rho_p(2)\}$\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{center} Appendix~\ref{app:finite} gives the exhaustive integer comparison that produces this list. We verify all eight counts, using the Hermite representatives from \eqref{eq:hnfranges}. \begin{enumerate} \item For $(1,0,1,0)$, the entries $u,w,y,z$ vanish. The two entries $v,x$ are arbitrary modulo $p$, giving $p^2$. \item For $(1,1,0,1)$, one has $v=x=0$, and the final congruence reduces modulo $p$ to $u^2=0$. Thus $u=0$, while $w,y,z$ are arbitrary modulo $p$. \item For $(1,1,1,1)$, the only nontrivial condition is \[ u^2-(2u-x)z=0\quad\text{in }\Fp. \] If $z=0$, there are $p$ choices, with $u=0$ and $x$ arbitrary. If $z\ne0$, each $u$ determines a unique $x$, giving $p(p-1)$ choices. Hence there are $p^2$ choices for $u,x,z$ and $p^3$ independent choices for $v,y,w$. \item For $(1,1,1,2)$, \eqref{eq:L} says $z\equiv x+u\pmod p$. The residual condition is \[ x^2-ux-u^2\equiv0\pmod p. \] There are $1+(p-1)\rho_p(1)$ pairs $(u,x)$. Indeed, the pair with $u=0$ must be $(0,0)$; for $u\ne0$ put $r=-x/u$. For each pair there are $p$ lifts of $z$, $p^2$ choices of $(v,y)$ satisfying the final congruence modulo $p^2$, and $p^2$ choices of $w$. The count follows. \item For $(2,1,1,2)$, \eqref{eq:L} forces $u=0$, after which all remaining conditions hold automatically. The entries $v,x$ each have $p$ choices and $w,y,z$ each have $p^2$ choices. \item For $(2,2,0,2)$, one has $v=x=0$, and the residual condition is $u^2\equiv0\pmod {p^2}$. Thus $u$ has $p$ choices; $w,y,z$ each have $p^2$ choices. \item For $(2,2,1,3)$, \eqref{eq:L} first gives $u+x\equiv0\pmod p$. The final congruence modulo $p$ forces $u\equiv0\pmod p$, hence $x=0$ in its chosen range. Write $u=pU$ with $0\le U19/13$, \[ \sum_{p\ge5}R_p(\sigma)<\infty. \] \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For $p\ge5$ the bound \eqref{eq:Ebound} applies, and the finite comparison of integer expressions in Appendix~\ref{app:finite} gives \[ \begin{array}{c|rrrrrr} m&11&12&13&14&15&16\\ \hline \#\text{ admissible types}&108&136&165&202&242&290\\ \max E&15&16&18&19&21&22 \end{array} \] At $m=15$, the maximum $21$ is attained only at $(3,3,3,6)$; all other types have $E\le20$. Proposition \ref{prop:quadratic-family} improves the bound for this one type to $A_p(3,3,3,6)\le4p^{18}$. Thus the maximum sufficient coefficient exponents, after making this replacement, are \[ 15,\quad16,\quad18,\quad19,\quad20,\quad22 \qquad(11\le m\le16). \] All implied constants here are independent of $p$: there are finitely many types and $h_0+1\le m+1$. For each of the six exponents, summation over primes is justified when $m\sigma-E>1$, where $\sigma=\Rea s$. Their thresholds are \[ \frac{16}{11},\quad\frac{17}{12},\quad\frac{19}{13},\quad \frac{10}{7},\quad\frac75,\quad\frac{23}{16}. \] Their maximum is $19/13$. For $m\le10$, the nonexceptional types have maximum threshold $13/9$, by Appendix~\ref{app:finite}. The five nondominant exceptional rows have bounds $O(p^3)$, $O(p^6)$, $O(p^7)$, $O(p^{10})$, and $O(p^{12})$, respectively, because $\rho_p(j)\le2$ for $p\ge5$. Their thresholds are at most $7/5<13/9$. Thus every retained term with $m\le10$ is prime-summable for $\sigma>13/9$, which is weaker than the asserted condition. It remains to control every larger index. Write $\sigma\ge\sigma_1>7/5$. By \eqref{eq:coefficientbound}, \begin{align*} \sum_{m\ge17}a_5(p^m)p^{-m\sigma} &\le 4\sum_{m\ge17}(m+2)\binom{m+3}{3} p^{-m(\sigma-7/5)}\\ &\ll_{\sigma_1}p^{-17(\sigma-7/5)}. \end{align*} Indeed, after removing the first power $p^{-17(\sigma-7/5)}$, the remaining polynomially weighted geometric series is bounded by replacing $p^{-(\sigma-7/5)}$ with $2^{-(\sigma_1-7/5)}<1$. The prime sum of this bound converges provided \[ \sigma>\frac75+\frac1{17}=\frac{124}{85} <\frac{19}{13}. \] The three subtracted monomials are the complete contributions of the diagonal types \[ (1,0,1,0),\qquad (1,1,1,1),\qquad (2,1,1,2), \] in that order. Thus $R_p$ has nonnegative coefficients. The finite estimates and the tail bound prove the asserted prime summability. \end{proof} \subsubsection{Extraction of the global factors}\label{sec:quintic-extraction} For a local series $F(s)=\sum_{m\ge0}c_m p^{-ms}$, put \[ \|F\|_{p,\sigma}=\sum_{m\ge0}|c_m|p^{-m\sigma}. \] This coefficient norm is submultiplicative whenever both norms on the right are finite. Lemma~\ref{lem:quintic-remainder} gives \[ Z_{5,p}(s)=1+p^{2-2s}+p^{5-4s}+p^{8-6s}+R_p(s), \qquad \sum_{p\ge5}\|R_p\|_{p,\sigma}<\infty \quad(\sigma>19/13). \] We prove that \begin{equation}\label{eq:Hproduct} H_5(s)=\prod_p(1-p^{2-2s})(1-p^{5-4s})(1-p^{8-6s})Z_{5,p}(s) \end{equation} has an absolutely convergent Dirichlet-series expansion in that half-plane. Let $H_{5,p}$ denote the $p$th factor of \eqref{eq:Hproduct}, and set \[ X_1=p^{2-2s},\quad X_2=p^{5-4s},\quad X_3=p^{8-6s}, \qquad t_i=\|X_i\|_{p,\sigma}. \] For $p\ge5$, we have \[ H_{5,p}=(1-X_1)(1-X_2)(1-X_3) (1+X_1+X_2+X_3+R_p). \] In the part not involving $R_p$, the constant term is $1$ and all terms of degree one in the $X_i$ cancel. Since $019/13$, submultiplicativity gives the uniform estimate \begin{equation}\label{eq:localnorm} \|H_{5,p}-1\|_{p,\sigma} \ll (t_1+t_2+t_3)^2+\|R_p\|_{p,\sigma}. \end{equation} Indeed every remaining polynomial term has degree at least two, and the norm of the coefficient multiplying $R_p$ is at most $\prod_i(1+t_i)\le8$. The prime sums of $t_1^2,t_2^2,t_3^2$ converge for $\sigma>5/4,11/8,17/12$, respectively. By $(t_1+t_2+t_3)^2\le3\sum_i t_i^2$, all of them are summable in the half-plane under consideration. The two factors at $2,3$ have finite coefficient norms for $\sigma>7/5$, by Proposition \ref{prop:uniform}. Write $H_{5,p}(s)=\sum_{m\ge0}h_p(m)p^{-ms}$, with $h_p(0)=1$, and define $h(n)=\prod_p h_p(v_p(n))$. The preceding bounds imply \[ \sum_{n\ge1}|h(n)|n^{-\sigma} =\prod_p\|H_{5,p}\|_{p,\sigma}<\infty \qquad(\sigma>19/13). \] The equality follows first for integers supported on a finite set of primes and then by monotone convergence. This proves the asserted absolute Dirichlet-series convergence of $H_5$. The remainder estimate and the three displayed monomials show that $\sum_p(Z_{5,p}(\sigma)-1)$ converges for $\sigma>3/2$. Consequently \eqref{eq:totalfactor} first holds by absolutely convergent Euler products in that half-plane and then gives the asserted meromorphic continuation. At $s=3/2$ each local factor in \eqref{eq:Hproduct} is $(1-p^{-1})^3 Z_{5,p}(3/2)>0$. Absolute convergence makes their product nonzero. The three Riemann zeta factors therefore give a pole of order exactly three. The counting asymptotic will be proved in Section \ref{sec:global}. \subsection{Exact enumeration of quintic cocyclic subrings}\label{sec:quintic-cc} A cocyclic lattice is the kernel of a primitive additive character. Multiplicative closure forces that character to be a unit at $t$, so we normalize its value there to $1$. The resulting product equations involve only two free coordinates after elimination. \subsubsection{A cyclic quotient parametrization} Fix $m\ge1$, and put $A=\Z/p^m\Z$. A cocyclic lattice $L\subset N$ of index $p^m$ is the kernel of a primitive (that is, surjective) $\Z_p$-linear map $N\to A$, unique up to multiplication by a unit of $A$. If $L$ is closed under multiplication, its image modulo $p$ is a three-dimensional subalgebra of $t\Fp[t]/(t^5)$. That subalgebra must equal $t^2\Fp[t]/(t^5)$. In fact the first four powers of an element with nonzero $t$ coefficient would span the whole four-dimensional algebra. Thus every such kernel has a unique normalized defining map \begin{equation}\label{eq:character} \phi(t)=1,\quad \phi(t^2)=B,\quad \phi(t^3)=C,\quad \phi(t^4)=D,\qquad B,C,D\in pA. \end{equation} The kernel is generated by $p^mt,t^2-Bt,t^3-Ct,t^4-Dt$. Checking their six possibly nonzero pairwise products gives \begin{align} D-2BC+B^3&=0,\label{eq:cyc1}\\ -BD-C^2+B^2C&=0,\label{eq:cyc2}\\ D(B^2-C)&=0,\label{eq:cyc3}\\ C(BC-2D)&=0,\label{eq:cyc4}\\ D(BC-D)&=0,\label{eq:cyc5}\\ BD^2&=0\label{eq:cyc6} \end{align} in $A$. Products with $p^mt$ impose no additional condition. The first equation determines $D=2BC-B^3$, and the second becomes \begin{equation}\label{eq:cycF} F(B,C):=C^2+B^2C-B^4=0. \end{equation} Modulo $F$, both \eqref{eq:cyc3} and \eqref{eq:cyc4} become \begin{equation}\label{eq:cycG} G(B,C):=5B^3C-3B^5=0. \end{equation} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:cyclicvaluation} The solutions of \eqref{eq:cyc1}--\eqref{eq:cyc6} are exactly the following two disjoint classes, with $D=2BC-B^3$: \begin{enumerate} \item $v_p(B)\ge\ceil{m/4}$ and $v_p(C)\ge\ceil{m/2}$; \item $r=v_p(B)$ satisfies \[ \ceil{m/5}\le r< m/4, \] and $C=B^2z$, where \[ z^2+z-1\equiv0\pmod {p^{m-4r}}. \] Here valuations of residue classes are truncated at $m$; the parameter $z$ is considered modulo $p^{m-2r}$ in the second class. \end{enumerate} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Take lifts of $B,C$ to $\Z_p$, choosing valuation $m$ for a zero residue, and use the lift $D=2BC-B^3$. Valuation bounds at least $m$ then imply the required congruences. Put $r=v_p(B)$. If $4r\ge m$, equation \eqref{eq:cycF} forces $v_p(C)\ge\ceil{m/2}$: otherwise $C^2$ has strictly smaller valuation than the other two terms and has valuation less than $m$. Conversely these two divisibilities imply \eqref{eq:cycF}. If $q=\min(v_p(C),2r)$, then $q\ge m/2$ and $v_p(D)\ge r+q$. Hence \eqref{eq:cyc3}--\eqref{eq:cyc6} all hold: their terms have valuations at least $r+2q$, $v_p(C)+r+q$, $2r+2q$, and $3r+2q$, respectively, each at least $m$. Suppose now that $4r7/5). \] Its prime sum converges. The nonconstant terms in the displayed polynomial are prime-summable already for $\sigma>4/3$; at $5$ the adjusted factor is a polynomial. As in Section~\ref{sec:quintic-extraction}, expanding the local factors and using their absolute coefficient norms proves absolute Dirichlet-series convergence of $H_5^{\cc}$ for $\Rea s>7/5$. For $\Rea s>3/2$, the original cocyclic series converges because its coefficients are bounded by the total coefficients. Euler multiplication therefore proves \eqref{eq:ccglobal} in that half-plane. The right side then gives the stated continuation. At $s=3/2$ every adjusted local factor is positive, so absolute convergence makes the product nonzero. The two zeta factors give a pole of order exactly two. \subsection{Elementary passage to the counting functions}\label{sec:global} The following elementary sums determine the constants and error terms. Let $b_2(n)$ and $b_3(n)$ be the Dirichlet coefficients of \[ \zeta(2s-2)\zeta(4s-5),\qquad \zeta(2s-2)\zeta(4s-5)\zeta(6s-8), \] respectively, and put $B_j(Y)=\sum_{n\le Y}b_j(n)$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:elementary} For $Y\ge1$, \begin{align*} B_2(Y)&=\frac1{12}Y^{3/2}\log Y+O(Y^{3/2}),\\ B_3(Y)&=\frac1{144}Y^{3/2}(\log Y)^2 +O(Y^{3/2}\log(2Y)). \end{align*} \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Using $\sum_{i\le X}i^2=X^3/3+O(X^2)$ for $X\ge1$, \begin{align*} B_2(Y) &=\sum_{j\le Y^{1/4}}j^5\sum_{i\le Y^{1/2}/j^2}i^2\\ &=\frac{Y^{3/2}}3\sum_{j\le Y^{1/4}}\frac1j +O\left(Y\sum_{j\le Y^{1/4}}j\right), \end{align*} which gives the first formula. Similarly, \begin{align*} B_3(Y) &=\sum_{j^4k^6\le Y}j^5k^8 \sum_{i\le Y^{1/2}/(j^2k^3)}i^2\\ &=\frac{Y^{3/2}}3\sum_{j^4k^6\le Y}\frac1{jk} +O\left(Y\sum_{j^4k^6\le Y}jk^2\right). \end{align*} The error is $O(Y^{3/2}\log(2Y))$, since summing over $j$ bounds it by a constant times $Y^{3/2}\sum_{k\le Y^{1/6}}k^{-1}$. For the main harmonic sum, putting $K=Y^{1/6}$ gives \begin{align*} \sum_{j^4k^6\le Y}\frac1{jk} &=\sum_{k\le K}\frac1k \left(\frac14\log Y-\frac32\log k+O(1)\right)\\ &=\frac1{48}(\log Y)^2+O(\log(2Y)), \end{align*} because $\sum_{k\le K}k^{-1}=\log K+O(1)$ and $\sum_{k\le K}(\log k)/k=\tfrac12(\log K)^2+O(1)$. This gives the second formula. \end{proof} To finish Theorem~\ref{thm:total}, apply Lemma~\ref{lem:convolution-transfer} to $b_3$ and the Dirichlet coefficients of $H_5$, taking $\alpha=3/2$, $r=2$, and any $19/13<\beta<3/2$. Lemma~\ref{lem:elementary} gives $c=1/144$, so the leading constant is $H_5(3/2)/144$ and the error is $O(B^{3/2}\log B)$. For Theorem~\ref{thm:cc}, use $b_2$, $H_5^{\cc}$, $r=1$, $c=1/12$, and $7/5<\beta<3/2$. The leading constant is $H_5^{\cc}(3/2)/12$ and the error is $O(B^{3/2})$. These positive asymptotics, together with convergence to the right of $3/2$, prove that both convergence abscissae are exactly $3/2$. \section{Cotype refinements in degrees four and five}\label{sec:ext-cotype} We now attach the determinantal weights of Lemma~\ref{lem:smith-weight} to the Hermite parametrizations in Sections~\ref{sec:quartic} and~\ref{sec:quintic-closure}. Fix a prime $p$ and write $N_n=N_{n,p}$. For a full-rank $r\times r$ matrix $H$, let $\delta_j(H)$ be the minimum valuation of its $j\times j$ minors, with $\delta_0(H)=0$. Lemma~\ref{lem:smith-weight} gives \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-smith} \lambda_i=\delta_{r-i+1}(H)-\delta_{r-i}(H) \qquad(1\le i\le r). \end{equation} Thus Hermite diagonal valuations need not coincide with the invariant exponents used in $\mathcal C_{n,p}$. All the identities below are identities of formal power series. They also hold absolutely when $\min_i\Re s_i>n-2$ locally and when $\min_i\Re s_i>n-1$ in the global Euler product. To justify these sufficient domains, there are at most $\binom{m+r-1}{r-1}p^{(r-1)m}$ lattices of index $p^m$ in rank $r=n-1$, by Lemma~\ref{lem:row-hermite}. The number of subrings is no larger. Summing this bound first over $m$ proves local convergence, and then summing the nonconstant local factors over primes proves the stated global convergence. These are sufficient domains, not claims of optimal convergence. \begin{theorem}[Explicit quartic cotype sum]\label{thm:ext-four} Let \[ \mathsf{H}_4=\begin{pmatrix}p^a&u&v\\0&p^b&x\\0&0&p^c\end{pmatrix}, \qquad a,b,c\ge0, \qquad 0\le ud-1$, \[ \mathcal Z_{n,p}(\boldsymbol s) =\frac1{(1-p^{-1})^d}\int_{\mathscr M_{n,p}} \prod_{j=1}^d|m_{jj}|_p^{-j} \prod_{i=1}^d \left(\frac{D_{d-i+1}(M)}{D_{d-i}(M)}\right)^{s_i}\,dM. \] For $n=4,5$, the domains of this integral are specified explicitly through their Hermite representatives by the closure conditions in Theorems~\ref{thm:ext-four} and~\ref{thm:ext-five}. Direct row elimination gives the equivalent conditions for arbitrary nonzero diagonal entries. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Fix a Hermite representative $H$ with diagonal $p^{a_1},\ldots,p^{a_d}$. All upper triangular integral bases for its row lattice are exactly $UH$, where $U$ is upper triangular integral with unit diagonal entries. Necessity follows because both $H$ and $UH$ are bases of the same lattice; their change-of-basis matrix and its inverse are integral and upper triangular. Conversely such a $U$ preserves the lattice. This representation is unique. The linear map $U\mapsto UH$ on the vector space of upper triangular matrices has determinant $\prod_{j=1}^d(p^{a_j})^j$: in row $i$ its diagonal factors are $p^{a_i},\ldots,p^{a_d}$. The domain of $U$ has measure $(1-p^{-1})^d$, so this orbit has measure \[ (1-p^{-1})^d p^{-\sum_jj a_j}. \] On the orbit, $|m_{jj}|_p=p^{-a_j}$, and all determinantal ideals are constant. Lemma~\ref{lem:smith-weight} says that their ratios give $p^{-\lambda_i}$. Thus the normalized integral over this orbit is exactly $\prod_i p^{-s_i\lambda_i}$. The orbits partition the domain. There are at most $\binom{m+d-1}{d-1}p^{(d-1)m}$ Hermite lattices of index $p^m$; this proves absolute convergence in the asserted local domain and justifies summing the orbit integrals. \end{proof} \section{Lifting through the last annihilator}\label{sec:ext-lifting} The last monomial $t^{n-1}$ annihilates $N_n$. This turns the passage from degree $n-1$ to degree $n$ into a system of linear congruences. Let $n\ge3$, put $r=n-2$, and project $\pi:N_n\longrightarrow N_{n-1}$. Write $e=t^{n-1}$, so that $\ker\pi=\mathbb Z_pe$ and $eN_n=0$. Denote by $\sigma:N_{n-1}\to N_n$ the additive section represented by polynomials of degree at most $n-2$. If $M\subseteq N_{n-1}$ is a closed full lattice with fixed Hermite basis $g_1,\ldots,g_r$, uniquely write \[ g_i g_j=\sum_{k=1}^r c_{ij,k}g_k\quad\text{in }N_{n-1}, \qquad c_{ij,k}\in\mathbb Z_p, \] and put \[ \gamma_{ij}=[t^{n-1}]\bigl(\sigma(g_i)\sigma(g_j)\bigr) \quad(1\le i\le j\le r). \] Thus $C_M=(c_{ij,k})$ is an $r(r+1)/2$ by $r$ matrix, and $\gamma_M=(\gamma_{ij})$ is an explicitly computable column. \begin{theorem}[Linear lifting recursion]\label{thm:ext-lifting} Fix $M$ as above and an integer $a\ge0$. The closed full lattices $L\subseteq N_n$ with \[ \pi(L)=M,\qquad L\cap\mathbb Z_pe=p^a\mathbb Z_pe \] are in bijection with the solutions \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-lift-system} C_Mz\equiv\gamma_M\pmod {p^a}, \qquad z\in(\mathbb Z_p/p^a\mathbb Z_p)^r. \end{equation} The solution $z$ gives the basis matrix \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-block} H(M,z,a)=\begin{pmatrix}H_M&\widetilde z\\0&p^a\end{pmatrix}, \end{equation} where $\widetilde z$ consists of the representatives $0\le\widetilde z_i\ell). \end{equation} When they exist, their number is \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-number-lifts} p^{a(r-\ell)+\sum_{i=1}^{\ell}\min(a,e_i)}. \end{equation} \end{theorem} \begin{proof} For a lattice $L$ with the specified image and intersection, lift each $g_i$ to an element of $L$. Its difference from $\sigma(g_i)$ is some multiple $z_i e$. Replacing the lift changes $z_i$ by a multiple of $p^a$ and has no other effect. Thus $L$ determines a unique $z\bmod p^a$. Conversely the vectors $\sigma(g_i)+\widetilde z_i e$ and $p^ae$ generate a full lattice with precisely that image and intersection. This proves the bijection for lattices before imposing closure and also proves the block matrix and index assertions. Since $eN_n=0$, multiplication of two lifted basis vectors is independent of $z$: \[ (\sigma(g_i)+\widetilde z_i e)(\sigma(g_j)+\widetilde z_j e) =\sum_k c_{ij,k}\sigma(g_k)+\gamma_{ij}e. \] Subtracting $\sum_k c_{ij,k}(\sigma(g_k)+\widetilde z_ke)$ leaves $(\gamma_{ij}-\sum_kc_{ij,k}\widetilde z_k)e$. It lies in $L$ precisely when its coefficient is divisible by $p^a$. Products with $p^ae$ vanish. Bilinearity therefore makes \eqref{eq:ext-lift-system} necessary and sufficient. Finally $z=Qw$ and multiplication by $P$ give $p^{e_i}w_i\equiv\eta_i\pmod {p^a}$ for $i\le\ell$ and $0\equiv\eta_i\pmod {p^a}$ for the remaining rows. The first congruence is soluble exactly under its condition in \eqref{eq:ext-compatibility}; when soluble it has $p^{\min(a,e_i)}$ solutions. The other $r-\ell$ variables are unrestricted. Multiplication gives \eqref{eq:ext-number-lifts}. \end{proof} In particular the unrestricted local function has the coefficientwise recursion, absolutely convergent for $\Rea s>n-2$, \[ Z_{n,p}(s)=\sum_{\substack{M\subseteq N_{n-1}\\M^2\subseteq M}} [N_{n-1}:M]^{-s}\sum_{a\ge0}p^{-as} \#\{z\bmod p^a:C_Mz=\gamma_M\}. \] The corresponding cotype recursion assigns the full block-matrix weight to each lift: \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-cotype-recursion} \mathcal C_{n,p}(\boldsymbol X) =\sum_{\substack{M\subseteq N_{n-1}\text{ full}\\M^2\subseteq M}} \sum_{a\ge0}\ \sum_{\substack{z\in(\Z/p^a\Z)^r\\C_Mz\equiv\gamma_M\ (\mathrm{mod}\ p^a)}} \prod_{i=1}^{n-1}X_i^{\lambda_i(H(M,z,a))}. \end{equation} Here the exponents are obtained from the minors as in \eqref{eq:ext-smith}. For a fixed total index exponent $m$, only $a\le m$ and lattices $M$ of index at most $p^m$ are relevant, so each coefficient is computed by a finite calculation. The recursion starts with the zero-multiplication algebra $N_2=t\Z_p$, whose lattices are $p^bt\Z_p$ and whose cotype series is $(1-X_1)^{-1}$. It retains the multiplication constants and last-degree product coefficients of $M$ in addition to its cotype. \section{Two parameters for cocyclic subrings in every degree} \label{sec:ext-universal-cyclic} The products $(t^2-Bt)(t^j-b_jt)$ extend the quintic cyclic-kernel calculation to every degree. They produce a second-order recurrence; an addition identity then checks all the other products at once. Define polynomials in $\mathbb Z[B,C]$ by \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-U} U_1=1,\quad U_2=B,\qquad U_{j+2}=B U_{j+1}+(C-B^2)U_j\quad(j\ge1). \end{equation} In particular $U_3=C$. \begin{lemma}[Addition identity]\label{lem:ext-addition} For all $i,j\ge1$, \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-addition} U_{i+j}=U_iU_{j+1}+U_jU_{i+1}-BU_iU_j. \end{equation} Also $U_j$ is homogeneous of weight $j-1$ when $B$ has weight $1$ and $C$ has weight $2$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} For fixed $j$, both sides of \eqref{eq:ext-addition}, viewed as sequences in $i$, obey the recurrence \eqref{eq:ext-U}. At $i=1$ the identity is immediate from $U_1=1,U_2=B$. At $i=2$ its right side is $BU_{j+1}+(C-B^2)U_j=U_{j+2}$. Induction proves the identity. The weight assertion holds for $U_1,U_2$ and is preserved by the recurrence, because both summands defining $U_{j+2}$ have weight $j+1$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem}\label{thm:ext-universal-cyclic} Let $n\ge4$, $m\ge1$, and $A=\mathbb Z/p^m\mathbb Z$. There is a bijection between the cocyclic unital subrings of $\mathbb Z_p[t]/(t^n)$ of index $p^m$ and the pairs \begin{equation}\label{eq:ext-two-parameters} (B,C)\in(pA)^2,\qquad U_n(B,C)=U_{n+1}(B,C)=0\quad\text{in }A. \end{equation} For the corresponding nilpotent lattice $L$, its uniquely normalized defining character is \[ L=\ker\phi,\qquad \phi(t)=1,\qquad\phi(t^j)=U_j(B,C)\quad(2\le j2$, the upper bound gives \[ \sum_{m\ge1}a_n^{\mathrm{cc}}(p^m)p^{-m\sigma} \le \frac{p^{-\sigma}}{1-p^{2-\sigma}}. \] Summing over primes is finite, since the denominator is bounded below by $1-2^{2-\sigma}>0$. The Euler product of these nonnegative local series then converges absolutely; the identity with the global series follows from the prime-by-prime lattice correspondence. This proves $\alpha_n^{\mathrm{cc}}\le2$. On the other hand set $m=n-1$ in the lower bound, giving $a_n^{\mathrm{cc}}(p^{n-1})\ge p^{2n-5}$. The global series at $\sigma=2-2/(n-1)$ therefore dominates \[ \sum_p p^{2n-5-(n-1)\sigma}=\sum_p\frac1p=\infty. \] For clarity, the last divergence follows from Euler's argument: convergence of $\sum_p1/p$ would make $\prod_p(1-1/p)^{-1}$ finite, whereas its partial products dominate the partial sums of the divergent harmonic series. Thus the lower bound for the abscissa follows, and the limit is the squeeze consequence of the two bounds. Finally the inverse image of a unital subring under $\mathbb Z[t]/(t^{n+1})\to\mathbb Z[t]/(t^n)$ has the same additive quotient as that subring. Inverse image is injective and preserves both index and cyclicity. This proves coefficientwise monotonicity and hence monotonicity of the abscissae. The same inverse-image observation preserves all nontrivial cotype factors, adding one trivial factor. \end{proof} \appendix \section{Finite comparisons and coefficient checks}\label{app:finite} The numerical calculations given here are available from \begin{center} \texttt{https://github.com/rtakloo/Chimni} \end{center} The quintic argument needs exact maxima over a finite set of diagonal types. This appendix records that entire calculation, so its role in the proof can be checked without an external data file. The loops use only integer arithmetic; they are also an explicit enumeration prescription that can be followed directly. The restrictions $a+b+c+d=m$ and \eqref{eq:cone} make it finite; every admissible quadruple occurs exactly once. The test uses $2E\ge3m-2$ to avoid floating-point arithmetic. \begin{lstlisting}[language=Python] from fractions import Fraction def diagonal_data(m): for a in range(m + 1): for b in range(min(2*a, m-a) + 1): for c in range(min(a+b, m-a-b) + 1): d = m-a-b-c if not 0 <= d <= min(a+c, 2*b): continue e = min(a, 2*a-b) h = min(d, e) delta = min(c+d, c+b, c+a, a+b, d+a, d+2*a-b, 2*a, 2*a+b-c, 3*a-c) E = min(b+c+d+delta+h, b+c+2*d+min(c+h, e)) yield (a,b,c,d), E counts = [1, 3, 6, 11, 17, 27, 35, 50, 64, 87] nexceptional = [0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 0, 1, 0, 1] thresholds = [(1,1), (1,1), (4,3), (5,4), (7,5), (4,3), (10,7), (11,8), (13,9), (7,5)] exceptional = [] for m in range(1, 11): rows = list(diagonal_data(m)) bad = [typ for typ, E in rows if 2*E >= 3*m-2] good = [E for typ, E in rows if 2*E < 3*m-2] assert len(rows) == counts[m-1] assert len(bad) == nexceptional[m-1] assert max(Fraction(E+1, m) for E in good) == \ Fraction(*thresholds[m-1]) exceptional.extend(bad) assert sum(counts) == 301 assert exceptional == [ (1,0,1,0), (1,1,0,1), (1,1,1,1), (1,1,1,2), (2,1,1,2), (2,2,0,2), (2,2,1,3), (2,2,2,4)] \end{lstlisting} For the extended comparison in Lemma~\ref{lem:quintic-remainder}, continue the same script with the following exhaustive integer check. \begin{lstlisting}[language=Python] expected_counts = [108, 136, 165, 202, 242, 290] expected_maxima = [15, 16, 18, 19, 21, 22] for m in range(11, 17): rows = list(diagonal_data(m)) assert len(rows) == expected_counts[m-11] assert max(E for typ, E in rows) == expected_maxima[m-11] if m == 15: assert [typ for typ, E in rows if E == 21] == [(3,3,3,6)] assert max(E for typ, E in rows if typ != (3,3,3,6)) == 20 \end{lstlisting} There are $301$ admissible types with $1\le m\le10$. The following table records their distribution. In its last column, the maximum is taken over the nonexceptional types of the indicated total exponent. Since $E$ is an upper bound for the exponent of $p$ in \eqref{eq:Ebound}, the number $(E+1)/m$ is the threshold supplied by that estimate for absolute summation over primes. \begin{center} \begin{tabular}{@{}rrrr@{}} \toprule $m$&Admissible types&Exceptional types&$\max (E+1)/m$\\ \midrule 1&1&0&$1$\\ 2&3&1&$1$\\ 3&6&1&$4/3$\\ 4&11&1&$5/4$\\ 5&17&1&$7/5$\\ 6&27&2&$4/3$\\ 7&35&0&$10/7$\\ 8&50&1&$11/8$\\ 9&64&0&$13/9$\\ 10&87&1&$7/5$\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{center} For coefficient checks in the second class of Lemma~\ref{lem:cyclicvaluation}, the following symmetry reduces the number of pairs that must be examined. Fix $m\ge1$ and put $A=\Z/p^m\Z$. If $\alpha\in A^\times$, the precomposition of the defining character with the automorphism $t\mapsto\alpha t$, followed by normalization at $t$, sends \[ (B,C,D)\longmapsto(\alpha B,\alpha^2 C,\alpha^3 D). \] It preserves multiplicative closure of the kernel and is transitive on the choices of $B$ with any fixed valuation $1\le r