{
  "date": "2026-11-11",
  "status": "exposition revision completed; compilation and rendered pages checked",
  "independent_audit": "review/independent-audit-2026-11-11.json",
  "independently_audited_pdf_sha256": "2635118a4d725bfe9b1667c4df6873fa1f13f692e8ea42be73e76939b3572724",
  "preceding_revision": "review/audit-response-2026-11-11.json",
  "preceding_pdf_sha256": "4b3e7d1cc7b4a842876f673647bde287f9f262060ec56ac27a43daa7473e163d",
  "current_pdf": "output/pdf/fifteen-beta-values.pdf",
  "current_pdf_sha256": "08f03f808651cbf65e7cb4b6caadc55230f7811de99744cbb06cf0b653f90851",
  "current_pages": 15,
  "changes": [
    {
      "location": "Introduction",
      "change": "Moved the integer contradiction before the denominator discussion and removed its later repetition."
    },
    {
      "location": "Section 4 opening",
      "change": "Stated the numerical decay target before the estimates and identified the prime contributions."
    },
    {
      "location": "Sections 4.1 and 4.2",
      "change": "Explained the factorial subtraction and moved the prime-number-theorem explanation of the integral weight ahead of its computation; defined the Chebyshev function."
    },
    {
      "location": "Section 5.3",
      "change": "Specified that the beta coefficient contribution vanishes modulo the prime."
    }
  ],
  "changed_source_files": [
    {
      "path": "paper/sections/01-introduction.tex",
      "preceding_sha256": "52176cf4af54cc5739e9166e82ec2ecc6cb379f14d2f1f690b0d274c7831a101",
      "current_sha256": "7d9247ef34f94c16f72a08a211308a43cc4b1a08760b5dfac4ec426656f2b86b"
    },
    {
      "path": "paper/sections/04-decay.tex",
      "preceding_sha256": "44612e75a369a4efe309c659124a5d545644ff50ef3744a3e055aa2f0a5fe6d8",
      "current_sha256": "b230831fd777022f686c40912d120f5e963427b75c1a0f8735a9e72c4b1e32f2"
    },
    {
      "path": "paper/sections/05-nonvanishing.tex",
      "preceding_sha256": "6ea9afde95ad9cb2163cfde9910587464b046442e63db76901da3a43b240435f",
      "current_sha256": "d10ececfed0df96afca037bad693f597e31455d3656f43d598612434c8e9bd6d"
    }
  ],
  "mathematical_scope": "No theorem, parameter, certificate or mathematical argument changed. Existing estimates and the contradiction were brought forward and explained; coefficient wording and notation were clarified.",
  "validation": {
    "compilation_record": "paper/build-record.json",
    "unresolved_references": false,
    "overfull_boxes": false,
    "underfull_warnings": [],
    "source_hashes_verified": 9,
    "audited_computational_files_unchanged": [
      "checks/certify_fifteen.py",
      "checks/certify_phase_polynomial.py",
      "checks/check-report.json",
      "checks/fifteen-arithmetic-midpoints.tsv",
      "checks/fifteen-arithmetic-second-check.json",
      "checks/fifteen-certificate.json",
      "checks/fifteen-seed-p10007.json",
      "checks/fifteen-seed-p10009.json",
      "checks/fifteen-seed-rows-p10007.json",
      "checks/fifteen-seed-rows-p10009.json",
      "checks/fifteen-seed-second-check.json",
      "checks/phase-polynomial-certificate.json",
      "checks/requirements-optional.txt",
      "checks/run_checks.py",
      "checks/seed_fifteen.py",
      "checks/verify_fifteen_arithmetic.cpp",
      "checks/verify_fifteen_seed.py"
    ],
    "decay_margin_decimal_check": "0.2327922916008203587415181781273514788674979845961711881898",
    "visual_review": "Rendered all 15 pages at 110 dpi. Inspected pages 1 through 14; page 15 is pixel-identical to the previously reviewed rendering. No clipping, overlap, missing glyphs or unresolved references observed.",
    "page_sha256": {
      "1": "deb4832c725364c04baaecc4aa25a9221cc71a23ec0e378edf9ff52d9c69fcd1",
      "2": "d8f55fdce1e7f09ba222d3450f37695ce5e46b40f143c4d449ac107165ea3a22",
      "3": "4dc508f8fa7f370d0db62d9860864fe2446fb47552d344f80eabd766b4eb8180",
      "4": "a7456e39eed64dc7d9d30c039f6687926449b28ba2bcff4d6fa0e546756d4cea",
      "5": "ee769c54abefe6d96d210b0d719ef5ba7d0ef589ad5591cde8138dd543dfb471",
      "6": "6b726f59e1e30bb02b7e5c68c3aff796f8c49aa8dcdc2900b7c25104c69a60b5",
      "7": "e68d900b9e21634eff3a4d01f124c968b3037a4d0811c8e1fcf5283bd8a3136f",
      "8": "59647b17915c7dc14cd8533f2d53e46b841524d9aa4b687e955774dff0b64067",
      "9": "594cea257daa1dd0583c8416b57084c786cbaca896c77cd111aa78e11ef2a984",
      "10": "ba824ed5e4ca0b6df97ffc97ad02e0d51e81b743ea1037a39b58ec65bae4975e",
      "11": "b654d8c73bb7a2c7ea6fef51bf904c5c36ffb036d10d6cb1acac950f2653bfb7",
      "12": "3047683ff07e20e1342d5429048e1c2736074d3bffbf86011aceb9c4cf508ddb",
      "13": "714890e33ca22cc2988a30c168f3a8b6efa2c45d62e5177a5c74ca95611ed8f6",
      "14": "db93bd65eb5d8859bc1e259d0727983610f23ae4af13fcd88d40228629367441",
      "15": "d697d9b0aea4aa23d5db983a3af81d267e9cc125a90e018052dc0b8ab035eead"
    }
  },
  "review_scope": "Internal verification of this exposition revision, not a new independent mathematical audit. The original audit and preceding revision records retain their original scope."
}