\section{Introduction}\label{sec:introduction} The points of the octonionic projective plane $\mathbb OP^2$ are the trace-one idempotents of the Albert algebra $J=H_3(\mathbb O)$. Two points have an \emph{overlap} $\langle p,q\rangle=\operatorname{tr}(p\circ q)$, the inner product of Cohn, Kumar and Minton\cite{CKM16}, or $1-\rho^2$ for the chordal distance $\rho$ of $p$ and $q$. A \emph{code} is a finite set of points. By a linear programming bound, Lemma~2.7 of Cohn, Kumar and Minton, a code in which distinct points have overlap at most $1/3$ has at most $39$ points; a code attaining this number is a \emph{tight $39$-point code}. They record that Hoggar\cite{Hoggar84} conjectured that such a code exists, and in their Theorem~8.3 they constructed one\cite{CKM16}: thirteen triples of mutually orthogonal points, with overlap $1/3$ between points of different triples. They show that it is tight and universally optimal\cite{CK07}, that is, it minimizes potential energy for every completely monotonic function of squared chordal distance. Four unit complex numbers can be inserted into its defining formula\cite{CKM16}, giving a four-parameter family of tight codes that remains four-dimensional modulo the isometry group $F_4$ of $\mathbb OP^2$. Write $P(\xi)$ for the member with parameters $\xi\in(S^1)^4$; the code they constructed is $P(1)$, the \emph{original code}. They further conjectured, on numerical evidence, that near the original code the space of tight codes modulo $F_4$ is a twenty-four-dimensional manifold\cite[Conjecture~8.4]{CKM16}. Their procedure in Section~7.5 perturbs a solution, solves again, and looks for a gap in the singular values of the matrix of normalized displacement vectors. They describe the procedure as a heuristic, discuss its geometric and precision requirements, and state in Section~8.2 that they had not found a nonsingular equation system to which their Theorem~3.1 could be applied. This paper describes the local geometry of the space of tight $39$-point codes around this family. Outside a closed nowhere-dense set of \emph{resonant} parameters, the tight codes near $P(\xi)$, with their points labeled, are, modulo $F_4$, exactly the members of four ten-dimensional families, any two of which meet exactly in the four-parameter family (Theorem~\ref{thm:real}). The original code is resonant, and the methods of this paper do not determine the codes near it. But nonresonant members accumulate at it, and it follows that any neighborhood of it in the space of unlabeled tight $39$-point codes modulo $F_4$ that is a manifold has dimension ten (Theorem~\ref{thm:patches}, Corollary~\ref{cor:no24}). \subsection{Setting} The Albert algebra $J$ is the exceptional Euclidean, or formally real, Jordan algebra. It has dimension $27$ and a unit $e$ of trace three. Its product is $x\circ y=(xy+yx)/2$, and its trace form is $\langle x,y\rangle=\operatorname{tr}(x\circ y)$. The automorphism group of $J$ is $F_4$; it has dimension $52$ and preserves the trace form. Points are the primitive idempotents\cite{Baez02}. A \emph{Jordan frame} is a triple of points with sum $e$ and pairwise zero Jordan products. Two frames are \emph{mutually unbiased}, as for bases of $\mathbb C^d$, when all nine overlaps between their points equal $1/3$. The spaces studied are \begin{equation}\label{eq:moduli} \begin{gathered} \mathcal C=\{(p_k)\in J^{39}:p_k\text{ a point},\ \langle p_k,p_m\rangle\le1/3\ (k\ne m)\},\\ Y=\mathcal C/F_4,\qquad \mathcal M=Y/\mathfrak S_{39}, \end{gathered} \end{equation} where the symmetric group $\mathfrak S_{39}$ permutes the labels and the quotients carry their quotient topologies. The \emph{unlabeled space} $\mathcal M$ is the space of tight $39$-point codes modulo $F_4$ in the sense of Cohn, Kumar and Minton. Every element of $\mathcal C$ is a union of thirteen pairwise mutually unbiased Jordan frames in exactly one way, and the partition into frames is locally constant on $\mathcal C$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:frames}, Lemma~\ref{lem:partition}). Near a given code, $\mathcal C$ is therefore the real zero set $\mathcal Z$ of one polynomial map $F$ of degree two on $J^{39}$, the residual of the \emph{frame equations} \eqref{eq:frame-equations}. The family rests on four subalgebras of $J$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:subalgebras}). Let \emph{frame~$0$} be the frame of diagonal matrix units and $D$ its span. There are subalgebras $A_0,\ldots,A_3$, each a copy of $H_3(\mathbb C)$ containing $D$, that are otherwise orthogonal to one another: \[ J=D\oplus N_0\oplus N_1\oplus N_2\oplus N_3,\qquad A_i=D\oplus N_i. \] A point that has overlap $1/3$ with the points of frame~$0$ has component $e/3$ in $D$, so two such points in different subalgebras have overlap $1/3$. The code $P(\xi)$, written out in \eqref{eq:literal}, is frame~$0$ with three further frames in each subalgebra. These form with frame~$0$ a \emph{complex quartet}: a complete set of four mutually unbiased bases of $\mathbb C^3$ (Figure~\ref{fig:flower}). The parameters enter through diagonal conjugations within the subalgebras. \begin{conceptfigure} \centering \includegraphics{figures/fig1-frames.pdf} \captionof{figure}{Each disc is a Jordan frame. Frames $3i+1$, $3i+2$, $3i+3$ make up \emph{lobe}~$i$; with frame~$0$ they form complex quartet~$i$, which spans $A_i$.}\label{fig:flower} \end{conceptfigure} A parameter $\xi$ is \emph{nonresonant} if the linearized frame equations at $P(\xi)$ have a solution space of dimension $80$, the least that occurs on the family. By Proposition~\ref{prop:kernel} the resonant parameters are those at which one of twelve nonconstant monomials $\pm\xi_1^{a_1}\xi_2^{a_2}\xi_3^{a_3}\xi_4^{a_4}$, listed in Section~\ref{sec:families}, has cube one. The set $\mathcal N\subset(S^1)^4$ of nonresonant parameters is therefore open and dense. \subsection{Results} The local model is the \emph{germ} at the origin of \begin{equation}\label{eq:axes} \mathbb R^4\times\bigcup_{i=0}^3 W_i\ \subset\ \mathbb R^4\times\mathbb R^{24}, \qquad W_i=\mathbb R^6_i\subset\bigoplus_{j=0}^3\mathbb R^6_j=\mathbb R^{24}, \end{equation} four copies of $\mathbb R^{10}$ that meet pairwise in $\mathbb R^4\times\{0\}$ and whose \emph{transverse spaces} $W_i$ are linearly independent. \begin{theorem}[Local solutions at nonresonant parameters]\label{thm:real} \leannote{formal}{\leandecl{normal_form_exists}; the common part is in \leanref{Proofs/PairingA5Geometry.lean}{63}{native_A5_geometry}.}{Proofs/PairingR.lean}{57} Let $\mathcal Z$ be the real zero set of the frame equations. At every $\xi\in\mathcal N$, the germ of $\mathcal Z$ at $P(\xi)$ in a local slice transverse to the $F_4$-orbit is homeomorphic to the germ of \eqref{eq:axes} at the origin. Its four branches are the families $M_0,\ldots,M_3$ constructed in Sections~\ref{sec:families} and~\ref{sec:linear}, one for each complex quartet. Their common part is the slice image of the four-parameter family $\xi^{\prime}\mapsto P(\xi^{\prime})$ near $\xi$. \end{theorem} The proof gives more: near $P(\xi)$ the slice has analytic coordinates in which its intersection with $\mathcal Z$ is, near the origin, the product of \eqref{eq:axes} with the origin of $\mathbb R^{973}$ (Propositions~\ref{prop:simultaneous} and~\ref{prop:exhaustion}). The registered statement of Theorem~\ref{thm:real} gives such a chart as a homeomorphism only; the analytic chart of Proposition~\ref{prop:simultaneous}, in which the families are coordinate subspaces, is registered separately. In the family $M_i$ the twelve points of quartet~$i$ stay fixed, up to an $F_4$ motion, while the other nine frames move. So every labeled tight code near $P(\xi)$ contains, up to $F_4$, one of the four complex quartets of $P(\xi)$. The slice identifies its zero set with a neighborhood of $[P(\xi)]$ in $Y$ (Section~\ref{sec:quotient}), so the theorem describes all labeled tight codes modulo $F_4$ near $P(\xi)$. The orbit $F_4P(\xi)$ has dimension $52$, so the \emph{first-order deformations} (solutions of the linearized equations; infinitesimal flexes in rigidity theory) form modulo $F_4$ a space of dimension $80-52=28=4+4\cdot6$, the sum of the tangent spaces of the four families. The quadratic part of the equations obstructs all of them except those tangent to a single family (Figure~\ref{fig:book}). \begin{conceptfigure} \centering \includegraphics{figures/fig2-families.pdf} \captionof{figure}{The local model \eqref{eq:axes}: four ten-dimensional families meet along the four-parameter family, with independent transverse spaces.} \label{fig:book} \end{conceptfigure} In the next theorem the norms on $J^{39}$ and on the residuals are any fixed norms; they affect only the constants. \begin{theorem}[Distance bound]\label{thm:bound} \leannote{different}{Stated for $S_\xi$ of Section~\ref{sec:verification}, item~(1), in place of $\mathcal Z$: \leandecl{native_real_endpoint}; the equivalence is argued there.}{Proofs/PairingR.lean}{23}% Let $\xi\in\mathcal N$. \begin{enumerate} \item[\textup{(a)}] There are an open neighborhood $U_\xi$ of the orbit $F_4P(\xi)$ in $J^{39}$ and a constant $C_\xi>0$ such that \begin{equation}\label{eq:main-bound} \begin{gathered} \mathcal Z\cap U_\xi=F_4(M_0\cup\cdots\cup M_3)\cap U_\xi,\\ \operatorname{dist}(y,\mathcal Z)^2\le C_\xi\|F(y)\|\qquad(y\in U_\xi). \end{gathered} \end{equation} \item[\textup{(b)}] The exponent cannot be improved: for no $\alpha>1/2$ does a bound $\operatorname{dist}(y,\mathcal Z)\le C\|F(y)\|^\alpha$ hold on a neighborhood of $P(\xi)$ in $J^{39}$. \end{enumerate} \end{theorem} Part~(b) holds because the linearization at $P(\xi)$ of any $C^2$ equations with zero set $\mathcal Z$ near $P(\xi)$ has solutions outside the \emph{tangent cone} of $\mathcal Z$, the cone of limits of secant directions, and this excludes every exponent above $1/2$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:cone-sharp}). Even on configurations whose thirteen triples are Jordan frames, no exponent above $1/2$ is possible (Section~\ref{sec:quantitative}; proved in the text, not formalized). Write $c_0=[P(1)]$ for the class of the original code in $\mathcal M$. \begin{theorem}[Open patches near the original code]\label{thm:patches} Every \leannote{formal}{\leandecl{originalCode_has_ten_patches}, compiled but not a registered target.}{Proofs/NativeOriginalCodeNoManifold24.lean}{30}open neighborhood $\Omega$ of $c_0$ in $\mathcal M$ contains a nonempty open subset $V$ of $\mathcal M$ homeomorphic to a nonempty open subset of $\mathbb R^{10}$. \end{theorem} The patch $V$ need not contain $c_0$. A ten-dimensional family can lie inside a manifold of larger dimension (Figure~\ref{fig:patch}(a)); a nonempty open set homeomorphic to an open subset of $\mathbb R^{10}$ cannot, by invariance of dimension. \begin{corollary}[Manifold neighborhoods]\label{cor:no24} \leannote{narrower}{Only $n=24$: \leandecl{Option2StatementCode.originalCode_no_open24_chart}, \leanref{Proofs/PairingCodeNoManifold.lean}{22}{originalCode_no_charted24_neighborhood}.}{Proofs/PairingCodeNoManifold.lean}{10}% If a neighborhood of $c_0$ in $\mathcal M$ is homeomorphic to an open subset of $\mathbb R^n$, then $n=10$. In particular the original code has no twenty-four-dimensional manifold neighborhood in $\mathcal M$. \end{corollary} The last assertion is contrary to the neighborhood statement of Conjecture~8.4 of Cohn, Kumar and Minton\cite{CKM16}. The nonresonant local model also illustrates a limitation of displacement-based dimension estimates at a singularity: limiting displacement directions from different branches can together span a space of dimension larger than that of any individual branch. In the local slice for labeled codes modulo $F_4$, the four ten-dimensional branch tangent spaces span $28$ dimensions. This observation is not offered as the reason their procedure gave $24$: the original code is resonant, and its germ is not determined here. \begin{conceptfigure} \centering \includegraphics{figures/fig5-patch.pdf} \captionof{figure}{(a) A family inside a manifold of larger dimension is not open in it. (b) Every neighborhood $\Omega$ of $c_0$ in $\mathcal M$ contains a ten-dimensional patch open in $\mathcal M$ (heavy segments). Dots mark nonresonant members. The stippled shape at the original code is not determined. Schematic.}\label{fig:patch} \end{conceptfigure} \subsection{What is open} By \eqref{eq:fullkernel} the linearized equations at the original code have a solution space of dimension $92$, that is $40$ modulo $F_4$. The four families can account for at most $28$ of these dimensions, whereas the argument of Section~\ref{sec:exhaustion} starts from coordinates in which they account for every first-order deformation. Along $\xi(t)=(e^{it},e^{-it},1,e^{-it})$, with $t\in\mathbb R/2\pi\mathbb Z$, the dimension is also $92$, except at the three values of $t$ with $e^{3it}=-1$, where it is $104$. So the resonance at the original code is not isolated in the family. The following questions are open. \begin{enumerate} \item[(a)] The germ of $\mathcal M$ at $c_0$, and at the other resonant members of the family. In particular the local dimension at $c_0$ is not determined: solution sets of dimension greater than ten passing through resonant members, away from the nonresonant ones, are not excluded. \item[(b)] The finite group in the germ of $\mathcal M$ at a nonresonant member. That germ is the model \eqref{eq:axes} modulo an action of the group $\operatorname{Aut}(P(\xi))$ of automorphisms of $J$ that permute the code (Remark~\ref{rem:aut}); neither the group nor its action is determined here. \item[(c)] Whether the constants $C_\xi$ stay bounded as $\xi$ approaches a resonant parameter (Section~\ref{sec:quantitative}). \item[(d)] Tight $39$-point codes away from the family. This paper does not show that every tight $39$-point code lies in one of the families described here. \end{enumerate} \subsection{Method and verification} Theorem~\ref{thm:real}, Theorem~\ref{thm:bound} in an equivalent form, and Corollary~\ref{cor:no24} for $n=24$ are formalized in Lean~4 and registered (Section~\ref{sec:verification}). Gray notes in the margin name the Lean declarations and link to them. Their lead phrase says how the Lean statement relates to the printed one: formalized, by the same route or a different one, narrower in Lean, or in a different form. Some notes only name the declaration. The printed proof relies on two machine computations, both part of the formal development. The properties of the stresses \textup{(}linear functionals on the residuals that annihilate the linearized equations\textup{)} of Proposition~\ref{prop:finite} are finite polynomial identities over $\mathbb Q(i,\sqrt3)$ with Laurent dependence on the parameters (Appendix~\ref{app:quadrics}), checked exactly. The quartic identity \eqref{eq:quartic} is checked by direct expansion. Section~\ref{sec:verification} says which further checks were made outside the formal development. Section~\ref{sec:outline} outlines the proof. \subsection{Related work}\label{sec:related} A good faith effort was made, using AI systems, to search for prior work; this subsection describes the sources found and how each relates to the results here. Finite sets of points of $\mathbb OP^2$ have also been studied as designs, where \emph{tight} has another meaning: a tight $t$-design attains the lower bound for the number of points of a $t$-design. A tight $39$-point code is a projective $2$-design, but not a tight one in this sense. Nasmith\cite{Nasmith22} gives a common octonionic construction of the two strictly projective tight $5$-designs, the $98{,}280$ lines of the Leech lattice in $\mathbb RP^{23}$ and $819$ points of $\mathbb OP^2$; his thesis extends the construction through octonion orders and integral Albert algebras\cite{Nasmith23thesis}. H\"ohn reconstructs the traceless Albert product from the third moment of a projective $3$-design and extends angle-preserving bijections between such designs to $F_4$ automorphisms; see Lemmas~5.2--5.3 and equation~(53) of his paper\cite{Hoehn26Design}. This gives geometric uniqueness of the tight $819$-point $5$-design, his Theorem~5.6. His companion paper\cite{Hoehn26Albert} returns to this reconstruction in Remark~7.3 of Section~7.2, on Hoggar's assertion of geometric uniqueness. These configurations differ from the tight $39$-point codes, and none of these results is used in the deformation or residual-distance arguments here. For spherical codes, Cohn, Jiao, Kumar and Torquato remark that there seems to be no simple method to turn an infinitesimal unjamming into an actual one\cite{CJKT11}; here, at a nonresonant parameter, the first-order deformations modulo $F_4$ form a space of dimension $28$, but each family through $P(\xi)$ has dimension ten. For complex Hadamard matrices the first-order count is the defect of Tadej and \.Zyczkowski, which by their Theorem~4.7 is an upper bound for the dimension of a smooth family\cite{TZ08}. Barros e S\'a and Bengtsson found perturbative evidence for two $13$-dimensional families of Hadamard matrices of order $12$ crossing along a nine-dimensional one, with defect $17=13+13-9$, on pp.~4 and 24--26 of their paper\cite{BSB13}. Theorem~\ref{thm:real} describes a crossing of the same kind and proves that nothing else passes through the point. In rigidity theory, Connelly's second-order rigidity asks for an equilibrium stress for each nontrivial first-order flex, and the prestress stability of Connelly and Whiteley (their Proposition~3.4.2 and Theorem~4.4.1) for one stress serving them all\cite{CW96}. Lemma~\ref{lem:stress} asks for one stress field for each limiting direction along a family, in a situation those results do not cover: several exact families that cross. For analytic equations some bound $\operatorname{dist}\le C\|F\|^\alpha$ is automatic by \L{}ojasiewicz's inequality\cite{Lojasiewicz59}. The theory of $2$-regular maps\cite{AAA91} gives the exponent $1/2$ under a surjectivity condition in every critical direction (Theorem~4 of Izmailov and Solodov)\cite{IS01}, which makes the solution set a manifold away from the base point and so cannot hold where the zero set is locally \eqref{eq:axes}.