\section{Two-branch states, and why many branches have no critical distance} \label{sec:twobranch} \subsection{The published distances as special cases} With two branches per body each space of patterns is a single dipole, and the canonical correlation is the cosine between the two dipoles. For $S_A=\{a_1,a_2\}$, $S_B=\{b_1,b_2\}$, Eq.~\eqref{eq:rhomax} is \begin{equation} s=\frac{|f(a_1b_1)+f(a_2b_2)-f(a_1b_2)-f(a_2b_1)|}{2\sqrt{D(L_A)D(L_B)}},\qquad D(L)=f_0-f(L), \label{eq:twobranch} \end{equation} with $L_A=|a_1-a_2|$, $L_B=|b_1-b_2|$ and $f(xy)=f(|x-y|)$ (point masses). The cosine depends on how the dipoles are placed, so a critical distance belongs to a geometry and not to the model. Four limiting families have closed forms (Table~\ref{tab:twobranch}, Fig.~\ref{fig:twobranch}): superpositions of length $L\to0$ along the line joining the bodies (collinear); superpositions perpendicular to that line (transversal), for $L\to0$ and for $L\to\infty$; and a vanishing superposition of $A$ midway between two branches of $B$, each at distance $d$ (straddle). At their critical distances the collinear and straddle limits ($L\to0$) and the transversal limit $L\to\infty$ are the suprema of $s$ over $L$ in their families, approached and not attained; $s$ is not monotone in $L$ for the collinear and straddle families. In the transversal family $s$ increases with $L$, so the $L\to0$ value is an infimum: below $1.547\,\sigma$ every transversal pair is entangled, between $1.547\,\sigma$ and $2.211\,\sigma$ only those with $L$ above a $d$-dependent length ($L>2.12\,\sigma$ at $d=1.6\,\sigma$). Setting the limits equal to $\sth$ reproduces the two distances of~\cite{TrilloNavascues2025} and adds two. For every $C\geq1$ the straddle family has the largest critical distance of the four (Table~\ref{tab:Cdep} gives the dependence on $C$). \begin{table}[h] \centering \caption{The four limiting two-branch families: the limit of the correlation $s$, with $\kappa_0=-f''(0)=1/(6\sqrt{\pi}\,\sigma^3)$ and $f(d)/f_0=\sqrt{\pi}\,\sigma\operatorname{erf}(d/2\sigma)/d$, and the critical distance at $C=1$, where the limit equals $\sth(1)$; $d$ is the closest approach.} \label{tab:twobranch} \begin{tabular}{llc} \toprule family & limit of $s$ & critical $d/\sigma$\\ \midrule collinear, $L\to0$~\cite{TrilloNavascues2025} & $|f''(d)|/\kappa_0$ & 0.850872\\ transversal, $L\to0$ (infimum over $L$) & $|f'(d)/d|/\kappa_0$ & 1.547134\\ transversal, $L\to\infty$~\cite{TrilloNavascues2025} & $f(d)/f_0$ & 2.210928\\ straddle & $\sqrt2|f'(d)|/\sqrt{\kappa_0(f_0-f(2d))}$ & 2.738073\\ \bottomrule \end{tabular} \end{table} \begin{figure}[t] \centering \includegraphics[width=0.64\textwidth]{fig-twobranch.pdf} \caption{Canonical correlation of the four limiting two-branch families against the separation, with the thresholds $\sth(1)$ and $\sth(2)$; dots mark the critical distances at $C=1$. In the shaded region ($d\geq2.75\,\sigma$ at slab separation) no two-branch state of any geometry is entangled at $C\geq1$ (Proposition~\ref{prop:ceilings}).} \label{fig:twobranch} \end{figure} Most designs give both masses the same superposition, translated; the design of~\cite{Bose2017} is one. For this parallel class the transversal limit is the supremum. \begin{theorem}[Parallel superpositions] \label{thm:parallel} Let $S_A=\{a,a+w\}$ and $S_B=\{a+r,a+r+w\}$ for arbitrary vectors $w$, $r$, and let $d$ be the closest approach. Then \begin{equation} s\leq\max\big(f(d)/f_0,\;c_*\big),\qquad c_*=\Lambda_+L_{1/2}^2/f_0\approx0.635, \label{eq:parallel} \end{equation} where $\Lambda_+=\max f''$ and $f(L_{1/2})=f_0/2$ (values in Table~\ref{tab:constants}). For every $C$ with $\sth(C)\geq c_*$, in particular every $C\geq1$, no parallel two-branch state with closest approach $d\geq d_*(C)$ is entangled, where $f(d_*)/f_0=\sth(C)$ ($d_*=2.21\,\sigma$ at $C=1$); for every $d0$ and every $C<\infty$ there are finite branch sets at slab separation $d$ with $\rmax>\sth$. For uniform coaxial discs of radius $a$ at gap $d$, each carrying a continuous uniform charge (or a point-branch lattice in the limit of spacing $\ll d$), each body carrying in addition a far copy of its disc, the far copies facing each other at gap $d$, \begin{equation} \rmax\geq\operatorname{erf}(d/2\sigma)\Big(1-\frac{3\pi d}{8a}\Big), \label{eq:discbound} \end{equation} so the model entangles such states once $a/d>(3\pi/8)/\big(1-\sth/\operatorname{erf}(d/2\sigma)\big)$, which is $4.02$ at $C=1$ and $d\gg\sigma$. Sparse lattices can fall below~\eqref{eq:discbound}. \end{theorem} The condition is on the extent of the coherent superposition in units of the gap, not on $d/\sigma$. The far copy is a second disc of branches, far from both near discs, on which the pattern has the opposite sign; the copy of $B$ is the copy of $A$ translated by $d$ along the normal, so the two copies face each other at the same gap. It makes the pattern neutral without changing the correlation, and it means that the coherent extent of the state is really the distance to the copy (Section~\ref{sec:extent} gives the sharp extent law, also for a single sheet). Since $\rmax=1$ for every pair of open supports (Remark~\ref{rem:ideal}), the absence of a critical distance is not by itself a physical prediction. What matters is how much entanglement the model can produce, and how fast.