DIHEDRAL TYPE on Z_N (E = {+-1}): all the relations commutative? N= 3: True N= 4: False N= 5: True N= 6: True N= 7: True N= 8: True N= 9: True N=10: True N=11: True N=12: True N=13: True N=14: True N=15: True N=16: True N=17: True N=18: True N=19: True N=20: True PRIME CASE, p < 200: number of pairs (p,k) where all the relations are commutative, compared with the bound p > (k-1)(k-2)+2 of Theorem 8.2 total 173, commutative 139, bound applies 97, violations of the bound: [] GENERAL CASE, N < 130, all the groups -1 in E generated by at most 3 elements, k = |E|, m = max gcd(a-1,N): all the relations must be commutative when N > mk(k-1)-2(k-2) (Theorem 8.2), and when N > 2(k-1)(km-1)+2 (Theorem 8.1) groups 512, commutative 371, Theorem 8.2 applies 183, Theorem 8.1 applies 158, violations: [] PRIME POWERS, E of order k | p-1: N= 9 k= 2: True N= 25 k= 2: True N= 25 k= 4: True N= 27 k= 2: True N= 49 k= 2: True N= 49 k= 6: True N=121 k= 2: True N=121 k=10: True N=125 k= 2: True N=125 k= 4: True N=169 k= 2: True N=169 k= 4: True N=169 k= 6: True N=169 k=12: True