%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% \section{Torsion groups that occur infinitely often}\label{sec:infinite} %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% In this section we prove \Cref{thm:infinite}. The groups listed there occur for infinitely many $\overline\Q$-isomorphism classes of elliptic curves over number fields of degree $10$ by the results of \Cref{sec:occur}, so we have to show that each of the other $16$ groups of \Cref{thm:main} occurs for only finitely many. For a curve $X$ over $\Q$ and $d\geq1$ we write $W_d(X)\subseteq\Pic^d(X)$ for the image of $X^{(d)}$ under the map $D\mapsto[D]$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:inf-finite} Let $X$ be a curve over $\Q$ with $J_X(\Q)$ finite, and let $d\geq1$ be such that $\gon_\Q X>d$. Then $X$ has only finitely many closed points of degree at most $d$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $e\leq d$ and suppose that $X$ has a closed point $D_0$ of degree $e$. By \Cref{lem:closed} a) the map $X^{(e)}(\Q)\to J_X(\Q)$, $D\mapsto[D-D_0]$, is injective, so $X^{(e)}(\Q)$ is finite. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:inf-j} Let $m\in\{1,2\}$ and $n\geq5$ with $m\mid n$, and suppose that for every $e\mid 10$ the curve $X_1(m,n)$ has only finitely many closed points of degree $e$. Then the elliptic curves $E$ over number fields $K$ of degree $10$ with $\tg mn\subseteq E(K)$ have only finitely many $j$-invariants. In particular, no group containing $\tg mn$ lies in $\Phi^\infty(10)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Such a curve $E$ gives a point $x\in Y_1(m,n)(K)$ with $j(x)=j(E)$ (see \Cref{subsec:trace}), and the closed point of $X_1(m,n)$ below $x$ has degree $[\Q(x):\Q]$, which divides $10$. \end{proof} \subsection{Rank \texorpdfstring{$0$}{0} and gonality}\label{subsec:inf-rank0} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:inf-rank0} Let $(m,n)$ be one of the pairs $$(1,N)\ \text{for}\ N\in\{29,31,35,38,39,40,42,45,50\},\qquad (2,28).$$ Then $X_1(m,n)$ has only finitely many closed points of degree at most $10$, and $\tg mn\notin\Phi^\infty(10)$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} The group $J_1(N)(\Q)$ is finite for these $N$ by \cite[Theorem 3.1(2)]{DEHMZ}, and $J_1(2,28)(\Q)$ is finite by \cite[Theorem 4.1]{DS}. By \cite[Theorem 4 and Table 1]{DvH} for $N\leq40$ and by \cite[Theorem D]{Varivoda26} for $N\in\{42,45,50\}$ we have $$ \begin{array}{c|ccccccccc} N & 29 & 31 & 35 & 38 & 39 & 40 & 42 & 45 & 50\\\hline \gon_\Q X_1(N) & 11 & 12 & 12 & 12 & 14 & 12 & 12 & 18 & 15 \end{array} $$ and $\gon_\Q X_1(2,28)\geq12$ by \cite[Table 1]{NV}. All these numbers are larger than $10$, so the result follows from \Cref{lem:inf-finite,lem:inf-j}. \end{proof} \subsection{The group \texorpdfstring{$\tg{2}{30}$}{Z/2Z x Z/30Z}}\label{subsec:inf-2x30} The Jacobian of $X_1(2,30)$, a curve of genus $25$, has finitely many rational points \cite[Theorem 4.1]{DS}, but the bound $\gon_\Q X_1(2,30)\geq10$ of \cite[Table 1]{NV} is not sufficient for \Cref{lem:inf-finite}. We use the model $X_H(60)$ of $X_1(2,30)$ with $H=\dm{-1,31}$ of \Cref{subsec:families}. The Galois orbits of the cusps over $\Q$ have degrees $1^{12},2^6,4^6$ (see \githubbare{phi_infinity/outputs/cusp_lattice_2_30.json}), so $X_1(2,30)$ has $12$ rational cusps. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:2x30-small} Every closed point of $X_1(2,30)$ of degree at most $9$ is a cusp. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} A non-cuspidal closed point $x$ of degree $e$ gives an elliptic curve $E$ over the field $\Q(x)$ of degree $e$ with $\tg{2}{30}\subseteq E(\Q(x))$, so it suffices to show that for $e\leq9$ no group of $\Phi(e)$ contains $\tg{2}{30}$. By \Cref{lem:base} we have $\Phi(1)\subseteq\Phi(2)\subseteq\Phi(4)\subseteq\Phi(8)$ and $\Phi(3)\subseteq\Phi(6)$, so we only need to consider $5\leq e\leq9$. By \cite[Theorem 1.1]{N5} and \cite[Theorem 1.1]{N69}, the groups of these sets $\Phi(e)$ which contain $\tg22$ are among the groups $\tg{2}{2n}$ with $n\leq13$, $\tg{4}{4n}$ with $n\leq3$ and $\tg66$. None of them contains $\tg{2}{30}$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:2x30-units} If $X_1(2,30)$ has a function of degree $e\leq10$ over $\Q$, then it has a modular unit of degree $e$ over $\Q$, that is, a function of degree $e$ over $\Q$ whose divisor is supported on the cusps. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} Let $f$ be a function of degree $e\leq10$ over $\Q$, and let $c$ be a rational cusp. If $c$ is not a pole of $f$, we replace $f$ by $1/(f-f(c))$, which also has degree $e$. Then the polar divisor of $f$ is an effective $\Q$-rational divisor of degree $e$ which contains $c$, so removing $c$ from it leaves an effective $\Q$-rational divisor of degree $e-1\leq9$, which is supported on the cusps by \Cref{lem:2x30-small}. Hence all the poles of $f$ are cusps. At most $e\leq10$ of the $12$ rational cusps are poles of $f$, so there is a rational cusp $c'$ which is not a pole of $f$. The function $g=f-f(c')$ has the same poles as $f$, and its divisor of zeros contains $c'$, so by the same argument all the zeros of $g$ are cusps. Hence $g$ is a modular unit of degree $e$. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:2x30-classes} No two distinct effective $\Q$-rational cuspidal divisors of degree $10$ on $X_1(2,30)$ are linearly equivalent. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} As in the proof of \Cref{prop:families}, a $\Q$-rational cuspidal divisor of degree $0$ on $X_H(60)$ is principal if and only if it lies in the lattice of divisors of rational modular units, which we \gitlink{phi_infinity/work/cusp_degree10_2_30.py}{compute} with the function \texttt{rational\_modular\_unit\_lattice} of \texttt{mdsage} \cite{mdsage}. It follows that the group of classes of $\Q$-rational cuspidal divisors of degree $0$ is isomorphic to $(\torz2)^5\times\torz{24}\times(\torz{8160})^2$. Writing the effective $\Q$-rational cuspidal divisors of degree $10$ as non-negative combinations of the $24$ Galois orbits of cusps, we find $1287948$ of them, and we compute that their classes, relative to $10$ times a fixed rational cusp, are pairwise distinct. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:inf-2x30} We have $\gon_\Q X_1(2,30)>10$. Hence $X_1(2,30)$ has only finitely many closed points of degree at most $10$, and $\tg{2}{30}\notin\Phi^\infty(10)$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Suppose that $X_1(2,30)$ has a function of degree $e\leq10$ over $\Q$. By \Cref{lem:2x30-units} it then has a modular unit $g$ of degree $e$ over $\Q$. Write $\ddiv(g)=D_0-D_\infty$, where $D_0$ and $D_\infty$ are distinct effective $\Q$-rational cuspidal divisors of degree $e$, and let $c$ be a rational cusp. Then $D_0+(10-e)c$ and $D_\infty+(10-e)c$ are distinct and linearly equivalent, which contradicts \Cref{lem:2x30-classes}. As $J_1(2,30)(\Q)$ is finite \cite[Theorem 4.1]{DS}, the remaining claims follow from \Cref{lem:inf-finite,lem:inf-j}. \end{proof} \subsection{The group \texorpdfstring{$\torz{37}$}{Z/37Z}}\label{subsec:inf-37} The curve $X_1(37)$ has genus $40$ and $\gon_\Q X_1(37)=18$ \cite[Theorem 4 and Table 1]{DvH}, but $J_1(37)(\Q)$ is infinite, so \Cref{lem:inf-finite} does not apply. We follow the proof of \cite[Proposition 5.7]{NV}, where Najman and Varivoda showed that $X_1(37)$ has only finitely many points of degree $9$. We will use the following consequence of Faltings' theorem (see also \cite[Theorem 2.4]{NV}). \begin{lemma}\label{lem:inf-faltings} Let $X$ be a curve over $\Q$ and let $d\geq1$ be such that $\gon_\Q X>d$. If $X$ has infinitely many closed points of degree $d$, then there are an abelian subvariety $A\subseteq J_X$ defined over $\Q$ with $A(\Q)$ infinite and a point $y\in W_d(X)(\Q)$ such that $y+A\subseteq W_d(X)$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By \Cref{lem:closed} a), distinct effective $\Q$-rational divisors of degree $d$ on $X$ have distinct classes, so $W_d(X)(\Q)$ is infinite. Fix $y_0\in W_d(X)(\Q)$ and put $Z=W_d(X)-y_0\subseteq J_X$. By Faltings' theorem \cite{faltings94}, $Z(\Q)$ is a finite union of sets $z_i+B_i(\Q)$, where $z_i\in Z(\Q)$ and $B_i\subseteq J_X$ are abelian subvarieties with $z_i+B_i\subseteq Z$. One of the sets $B_i(\Q)$ is infinite. Let $A$ be the identity component of the Zariski closure of $B_i(\Q)$. It is an abelian subvariety of $B_i$ defined over $\Q$, and $A(\Q)$ has finite index in a group containing $B_i(\Q)$, so it is infinite. Hence $y=y_0+z_i$ has the required properties. \end{proof} Let $\pi:X_1(37)\to X_0^+(37)$ be the quotient map, of degree $36$, and identify the curve $X_0^+(37)$ with the elliptic curve $E:y^2+y=x^3-x$ (\lmfdbec{37}{a}{1}). We write $\pi^*E$ for the image of $\pi^*:\Pic^0(E)\to J_1(37)$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:37-factor} Every abelian subvariety $A\subseteq J_1(37)$ defined over $\Q$ with $A(\Q)$ infinite contains $\pi^*E$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} By \cite[proof of Proposition 5.7]{NV}, the only simple factor of $J_1(37)$ of positive rank, up to isogeny, is $\pi^*E$. As $A(\Q)$ is infinite, one of the simple factors of $A$ has positive rank, so $A$ contains an abelian subvariety $B$ isogenous to $E$. As $37$ is prime and there are no cusp forms of weight $2$ and level $1$, every simple factor of $J_1(37)$ occurs in it with multiplicity $1$ up to isogeny, so $B=\pi^*E$. \end{proof} Let $C=X_1(37)_{\F_2}$ and $\overline E=E_{\F_2}$. By \Cref{lem:goodred}, $\pi$ extends to the smooth models over $\Z_{(2)}$, and we denote its reduction $C\to\overline E$ again by $\pi$. The group $\overline E(\F_2)$ has order $5$. Let $e_\infty\in\overline E(\F_2)$ be the reduction of the cusp of $X_0^+(37)$, which is the image of all the cusps of $X_1(37)$, and let $e_0\in\overline E(\F_2)$ be the point above $S=T=0$ on the plane model of $X_0^+(37)_{\F_2}$ with coordinates $S=j(\mathcal E)+j(\mathcal E/\dm P)$ and $T=j(\mathcal E)j(\mathcal E/\dm P)$ of \cite[proof of Proposition 5.7]{NV}, where $(\mathcal E,P)$ is the universal pair. Put $F_\infty=\pi^*e_\infty$, $F_0=\pi^*e_0$ and $\Delta=F_\infty-F_0$, a divisor of degree $0$ on $C$. As $e_0\neq e_\infty$, the class $[e_\infty-e_0]$ generates $\Pic^0(\overline E)\simeq\overline E(\F_2)$, where $\Pic^0(\overline E)$ is the group of classes of $\F_2$-rational divisors of degree $0$, so its image $[\Delta]=\pi^*[e_\infty-e_0]$ satisfies $5[\Delta]=0$. \begin{lemma}\label{lem:37-push} Let $D$ and $D'$ be effective $\F_2$-rational divisors of degree $10$ on $C$ with $D'\sim D+\Delta$. Then $D$ or $D'$ contains a closed point of degree larger than $1$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} No elliptic curve over $\F_2$ has a point of order $37$, as it has at most $5$ points, so every $\F_2$-rational point of $C$ is a cusp and is mapped to $e_\infty$ by $\pi$. If $D$ and $D'$ are supported on $\F_2$-rational points, it follows that $\pi_*D=\pi_*D'=10e_\infty$. On the other hand, $\pi_*D'\sim\pi_*D+\pi_*\pi^*(e_\infty-e_0)=\pi_*D+36(e_\infty-e_0)$, and $36[e_\infty-e_0]=[e_\infty-e_0]\neq0$ in $\Pic^0(\overline E)$, which has order $5$. This is a contradiction. \end{proof} \begin{lemma}\label{lem:37-comp} For every effective $\F_2$-rational divisor $D$ of degree $10$ on $C$ which contains a closed point of degree larger than $1$, there is a $k\in\{1,2,3,4\}$ with $\ell(D+k\Delta)=0$. \end{lemma} \begin{proof} We use the plane model of $X_1(37)$ and the map $\pi$ of \cite[proof of Proposition 5.7]{NV} (see \githubbare{phi_infinity/work/x1_37/driver_fast.m} and \githubbare{phi_infinity/work/x1_37/X1_37_X0plus_map_data.m}). We \gitlink{phi_infinity/work/x1_37/verify_model_places.m}{compute} that $C$ has genus $40$ and that the numbers of its closed points of degree $1,2,\dots,10$ are $$18,\ 0,\ 0,\ 0,\ 0,\ 21,\ 18,\ 0,\ 39,\ 99.$$ We compute $F_0$ and the fibre of $\pi$ over the point at infinity of the plane model of $X_0^+(37)_{\F_2}$, check that both have degree $36$, and check that the latter contains the $18$ points of degree $1$, which are cusps, so that it is $F_\infty$. Hence $D=P+R$, where $P$ is a closed point of degree $i\in\{6,7,9,10\}$ and $R$ is an effective divisor of degree $10-i$ supported on the $18$ points of degree $1$, and there are $21\binom{21}{4}+18\binom{20}{3}+39\cdot18+99=147006$ such divisors $D$. For each closed point $P$ of degree $i$ put $H=P+(10-i)\sum_{c\in C(\F_2)}c$. Every divisor $D=P+R$ satisfies $D\leq H$, and $H-D$ is supported on $C(\F_2)$, so $L(D+k\Delta)=L(H+k\Delta-(H-D))$ is the subspace of $L(H+k\Delta)$ cut out by vanishing conditions at the points of $C(\F_2)$. We compute a basis of $L(H+k\Delta)$ and the Laurent expansions of its elements at the points of $C(\F_2)$, so that $\ell(D+k\Delta)$ is the dimension of the kernel of a matrix over $\F_2$. In this way we \gitlink{additions/phi_infinity/X1_37_all_places/cover_degree10_all.m}{find}, for each of the $147006$ divisors $D$, a $k\in\{1,2,3,4\}$ with $\ell(D+k\Delta)=0$. For one divisor $D$ for every $P$, we also compute $\ell(D+\Delta)$ directly, with the same result. \end{proof} \begin{proposition}\label{prop:inf-37} The curve $X_1(37)$ has only finitely many closed points of degree $10$, and $\torz{37}\notin\Phi^\infty(10)$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} Suppose that $X_1(37)$ has infinitely many closed points of degree $10$. As $\gon_\Q X_1(37)=18>10$, by \Cref{lem:inf-faltings,lem:37-factor} there is a $y\in W_{10}(X_1(37))(\Q)$ with $y+\pi^*E\subseteq W_{10}(X_1(37))$. Let $a\in E(\Q)$. Then $y+\pi^*[a-O]$ is a rational point of $W_{10}(X_1(37))$, and as $X_1(37)$ has a rational cusp, it is the class of an effective $\Q$-rational divisor $D_a$ of degree $10$. Reduction of divisors from $X_1(37)$ to $C$, through their closures in the smooth model over $\Z_{(2)}$, preserves effectivity and linear equivalence and commutes with $\pi^*$ (compare \cite[Lemma 2.5]{NV}). Hence the reduction $\overline D_a$ of $D_a$ is an effective $\F_2$-rational divisor in the class $\overline y+\pi^*[\overline a-\overline O]$. The group $E(\Q)$ is generated by the point $(0,0)$ \cite{lmfdb}, whose reduction is not $\overline O$, so the reduction map $E(\Q)\to\overline E(\F_2)$ is surjective. Hence for every $k\in\{0,\dots,4\}$ there is an effective $\F_2$-rational divisor $D_k$ of degree $10$ on $C$ with $D_k\sim D_0+k\Delta$. By \Cref{lem:37-push}, $D_0$ or $D_1$ contains a closed point of degree larger than $1$. As $5[\Delta]=0$, every class $[D_0+k\Delta]$ is the class of one of $D_0,\dots,D_4$, so $\ell(D_0+k\Delta)\geq1$ and $\ell(D_1+k\Delta)\geq1$ for all $k$, which contradicts \Cref{lem:37-comp}. Hence $X_1(37)$ has only finitely many closed points of degree $10$. Its closed points of degree $1$, $2$ and $5$ are cusps, as $\torz{37}$ does not lie in $\Phi(1)$, $\Phi(2)$ and $\Phi(5)$ (\Cref{subsec:base}), so the second claim follows from \Cref{lem:inf-j}. \end{proof} \begin{proof}[Proof of \Cref{thm:infinite}] By \Cref{lem:base}, applied to infinitely many elliptic curves with pairwise distinct $j$-invariants, we have $\Phi^\infty(e)\subseteq\Phi^\infty(10)$ for every $e\mid10$. We have $\Phi^\infty(1)=\Phi(1)$ and $\Phi^\infty(2)=\Phi(2)$ (see \cite[Section 1]{DS}), and $\Phi^\infty(5)$ consists of the groups $\torz n$ with $1\leq n\leq25$, $n\neq23$, and $\tg{2}{2n}$ with $1\leq n\leq8$ \cite[Theorem 1.1]{DS}. With the lists of $\Phi(1)$ and $\Phi(2)$ in \Cref{subsec:base}, these are $35$ of the groups of \Cref{thm:infinite}, and the other $18$ lie in $\Phi^\infty(10)$ by \Cref{prop:families}. The remaining $16$ groups of \Cref{thm:main} do not lie in $\Phi^\infty(10)$ by \Cref{thm:sporadic} for $\tg{2}{26}$, $\tg{3}{15}$, $\tg{3}{18}$ and $\tg{6}{12}$, by \Cref{prop:inf-rank0} for $\torz n$ with $n\in\{29,31,35,38,39,40,42,45,50\}$ and for $\tg{2}{28}$, and by \Cref{prop:inf-2x30,prop:inf-37} for $\tg{2}{30}$ and $\torz{37}$. \end{proof}